Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Human Events: Week of May 7, 2012
Human Events: Week of May 7, 2012
T h e N aT i o N a l C o N s e r vaT i v e W e e k ly | e s Ta b l i s h e d 1 9 4 4 Wa s h i N g T o N , d . C . | W e e k o f M ay 7, 2 0 1 2
Plan of Attack
EXCLUSIVE: GOP strategist Karl Rove says Romney can win in 2012, but he needs to absorb Obamas blows and counter decisively with how hell grow the economy and put America back to work. p. 16
Senators, pass the bipartisan Wyden-Snowe Wireless Tax Fairness Act (S. 543). Its a grand slam for wireless consumers, who already pay on average more than 16% of their monthly bill in taxes and fees, compared to 7% on other taxable goods and services. S. 543 is the perfect pitch to fix that. It would put a five-year freeze on new and discriminatory state and local wireless taxes and fees. The House has already put a man in scoring position by passing H.R. 1002. Nows the time for the Senate to drive home the winning run for wireless consumers.
Page Three
n This week
By Audrey Hudson
Congress returns to work after a weeklong recess and begins the arduous task of passing annual spending bills to fund all federal agencies in 2013. Meanwhile, the senate will focus on legislation to stop rate hikes on subsidized stafford loans for college students, which are scheduled to double on July 1 from 3.4 percent to 6.8 percent. The senate will also vote on the nominations of Jacqueline Nguyen to be circuit judge for the Ninth Circuit; Kristine gerhard Baker to be district judge for the Eastern District of Arkansas; and John Lee to be district judge for the Northern District of Illinois. Conferees from the House and senate will hold their first meeting Tuesday to begin hammering out the differences in the highway funding bill before the June deadline but the sticking point will certainly be language in the House version that bypasses the president to approve the Keystone XL pipeline project. The Hill reports that senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) has already made it very clear senate Democratic conferees will not agree to include that provision in the final measure. Personally, Im notIm not one of the confereesbut I think Keystone is a program that were not going, that I am not going to help in any way I can, Reid said. The president feels that way. I do, too. Whether the Keystone language makes it will likely come down to final negotiations between Reid and House speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio). Hearings of note scheduled this week include a House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee event titled A Review of solutions to Reform, Reorganize, or Retire the general services Administration (gsA). A science, space and Technology subcommittee hearing will also examine spending at the National byline
Jerry Ensminger holds a portrait of his daughter, Janey, in this May 9, 2007 photo in White Lake, N.C.
AP IMAgEs
erry Ensminger is one of more than 750,000 Marines and military family members who lived aboard Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune during a three-decade period in which serious contaminants, including chemical degreasers and organic solvents, seeped into the drinking water on base. Ensminger, a grizzled retired master sergeant, saw his 9-year-old daughter Janey die from Leukemia that he believed was caused by the contamination; others who lived on base were diagnosed with kidney cancer, non-Hodgkins lymphoma, and a host of other serious diseases. Over 70 men who lived or grew up on the base have been diagnosed with breast cancer so far. Ensminger and his advocates in Congress have proposed that the Department of Veterans Affairs provide survivors with medical care and hospice for their contaminationrelated illnesses, a plan that would cost an estimated $3.9 billion to fund. It seems a reasonable request, given these veterans and family members were unwittingly poisoned by government neglect; but in these days of budget uncertainty and looming fiscal cuts, perhaps a tough sell nonetheless. VA unilaterally spent its cash surplus Heres the thing: in a rare case of over allocation, VA officials found that cash in surplusthen they went ahead and unilaterally spent it on other things. Staff with the House Veterans Affairs Committee said the VA was required to submit a healthcare budget to Congress every year based on spending estimates for that year. In the spring, officials ran another model that shows the years spending rate to date and how much the department is likely to spend for the rest of the year. For Fiscal 2012, slower than estimated spending rates meant the VA was left with a $3 billion surplus for that year, committee staff said. For Fiscal 2013, it was $2 billion. (VA officials said the figures were $2.2 billion and $2 billion, respectively.) The problem here, committee officials said, was that they were not informed until early 2012, with the presidents FY 2013 budget proposal, about a surplus that had been discovered starting in 2011. And, by the time they were informed, the money had been reinvested into other VA projects, including activating new facilities, expanding mental health, and eliminating veteran homelessness, according to VA officials.
The command decision to reinvest the $5 billionrepresenting more than five percent of the departments annual healthcare budgetleft some lawmakers on the committee feeling snubbed. Rep. Bill Flores, a Republican freshman from Texas, said he wanted to work with the committee to organize a hearing on the issue to hold department heads accountable. It would have been better if they told us when they were [finding the overage] rather than after the moneys gone, he said. Committee chairman Jeff Miller (R-Fla.) penned a letter in February to VA Secretary Eric Shinseki asking him to consider allocating the overage funds to healthcare for Camp Lejeune veterans, rather than the programs the VA had specified. Earlier in April, Shinseki responded, saying it was premature to make the decision to give the group healthcare, as studies to determine the full extent and effects of the contamination were ongoing. The letter did not mention that the agency performing the studies, the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, had already stated that the water was clearly a hazard and the EPA had separately confirmed that two of the contaminants, Benzene and TCE, were known human carcinogens. The fact is that we were poisoned; the documents are there, Ensminger told Human Events. Its time to move. Its time to give these people their benefits. A couple weeks ago, Miller and three other lawmakers representing bipartisan leadership of the House and Senate Veterans Affairs Committees elevated the matter to President Barack Obama in a joint letter.VA has existing resources which could be reserved without derailing other initiatives; we will work the legislative process to complement what VA can do on its own authority, they said. Miller told Human Events via email that he has requested a full accounting of overestimated funds from the VA and made it a priority to ensure Congress and the VA work together in the future on these matters. Miller said he was also working to get those affected by Camp Lejeune water their needed medical care as quickly as possible, whether by opening up a VA priority, passing legislation now in Congress, or drafting a new resolution. These men and women have been waiting too long to be recognized by our government, and should not have to wait another day, he said.
Hope Hodge is a reporter covering national security & defense for Human Events. She can be reached at HHodge@EaglePub.Com
CaPITaL BrIeFS
and letting the House work its will. Though Democrats abandoned the practice when they controlled the House, Speaker Boehner has previously endorsed bringing appropriations bills to the floor under open rules. Thus, the Republican Study Committee argues that move is non-controversial and would be a significant step in curbing spending and bringing about transparency and accountability.
DeFeNSe
try over to Afghan control by 2014 and said the goal of defeating al Qaeda was within reach. Several GOP members of the House and Senate Armed Services committees said the visit was long overdue.
AP IMAgEs
HoUSe
DeFeNSe
eNViRoNMeNt
AP IMAgEs
Human Events
Frank C. Hanighen (1899-1964) James L. Wick (1897-1964)
huMan EVEnts gROuP VP, group Publisher Joseph Guerriero cOntEnt Editor-in-chief Emeritus Thomas S. Winter Editor Cathy Taylor Managing Editor Adam Tragone senior Reporter, Economy & budget David Harsanyi senior Reporter, Energy & Environment Audrey Hudson senior Reporter, Political Editor John Gizzi Reporter, Defense & national security Hope Hodge Reporter, technology & Freedom John Hayward legal affairs correspondent Ann Coulter Web editor Karl Selzer Editor-at-large Allan Ryskind Regular contributors Jim Edwards, Steven Greenhut, Ken Hanner, Mark LaRochelle, John Seiler huMan EVEnts Digital OPERatiOns www.humanEvents.com Steve Miller, Todd Herman, Todd Van Etten, Jayson Manship, Patrick Klinetobe, Chris Pascuzzo, Tony Cane
DEsign art Director Amanda Larsen graphic Designers Amber Colleran, Stephanie Patience, Henry Pereira, Lisa Pulaski, Jason Sunde aDVERtising senior account advertising Managers Melinda Beatty, Scott Fowler, Chris McIntyre, Cheri DeLand advertising Operations Manager Patrick Klinetobe Marketing Director Elizabeth Setterlin Marketing Manager Jenna Geiger advertising Marketing Manager Jake Berube advertising traffic Manager Linda Jenkins sales administrator Holly Berggren Distribution Jim Zerr Production Sean Munns
EaglE Publishing, inc. chairman Thomas L. Phillips President Jeffrey J. Carneal cFO/VP Operations Jon A. Heimerman Regnery Publishing Marjory G. Ross Eagle Financial Publications Roger Michalski Eagle Wellness Chris Broussard
all mail correspondence for human Events or Eagle Publishing should be addressed to One Massachusetts avenue nW, Washington, D.c. 20001. human Events cannot be responsible for the return of unsolicited manuscripts, either by email or postal mail. Opinions expressed in signed articles do not necessarily represent the views of human Events. Postmaster: send address changes to human Events, 1 Massachusetts ave., n.W., 6th Floor, Washington, D.c.
The Declaration of Independence begins: When in the course of Human Events In reporting the news, Human Events is objective; it aims for accurate presentation of all the facts. But it is not impartial. It looks at events through eye s that favor limited constitutional government, local self-government, private enterprise and individual freedom. These were the principles that inspired the founders. We believe that today the same principles will preserve freedom in America.
human Events (issn 0018-7194) is published weekly, except 2/27/12, 4/9/12, 6/4/12, 7/19/12, 8/6/12, 9/10/12, 11/26/12, 12/31/12 by human Events, 1 Massachusetts ave., n.W., Washington D.c. 20001. Periodicals postage paid at Washington,D.c. and additional mailing offices. single issue price $9.95. One year subscription, $129. copyright 2012 human Events.
to subscribe: 1 800-787-7557 customerservice@humanEventsOnline.com to advertise: 202 677-4462 To Contact Editorial 202 677-4518 202 216-0600 To Send a Letter, Op-eds ctaylor@EaglePub.com atragone@EaglePub.com
Because the Audit Bureau of Circulations audits the circulation of [name of publication], advertisers know that our audited information is accurate.
Because the Audit Bureau of Circulations audits the circulation of Human Events, advertisers know that our audited information is accurate.
Because the WERE PROuD TOAudit Bureau of Circulations audits the circulation of [name of publication], advertisers know BE A MEMBER information that our Of is accurate. audited AuDIT BuREAu Of CIRCuLATIONs
Because the Audit Bureau of Circulations audits the circulation of [name of publication], advertisers know that our audited information is accurate.
Because the Audit Bureau of Circulations audits the circulation of [name of publication], advertisers know that our audited information is accurate.
5
NewS, ViewS, opiNioNS FRoM wASHiNGtoN
Obama by environmentalists, who said the civil engineering professor from Southern Methodist University would be tough on polluters. Armendariz is also an author of a 2009 study by the Environmental Defense Fund, which blamed the drilling of Barnett Shale for causing more air pollution in the Dallas/Fort Worth area than cars and trucks. Armendarizs exit at the EPA will not slow down a slew of burdensome regulations the agency is producing under Obamas leadership, Inhofe said. His investigation of the agency will continue despite Armendarizs resignation.
xx
xx
new Gallup survey, over the past 15 years, Americans have altered their expected retirement form the age of 60 to the age of 67.
SpeNDiNG
wALkeR wAtcH
scott Walker
AP IMAgEs
The campaigns of Falk and Barrett both issued statements about Walkers finances, accusing the governor of spending more time raising funds rather than creating jobs, the Associated Press reported. Barrett, in a statement, accused Walker of putting an extreme, partisan agenda ahead of Wisconsins economy. Friends of Scott Walker Communications Director Ciara Matthews, however, responded that The City of Milwaukee, under Mayor Barretts failed policies, is an anchor weighing on Wisconsins ability to create jobs. Under Barrett, Milwaukees unemployment rate skyrocketed by 29 percent and the city stands as the ninth poorest in the nation. Falks campaign joined Barretts in accusing Walkerand New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, who has been recently campaigning for Walkerof extreme records. According to the Walker campaign, 96,292 (76 percent) of the 125,926 contributions since January have been donations of $50 or less. For more information or to find ways to participate, please visit www.ScottWalker.Org.
SociAL SecURity
10
De Fe N S e
Page
20 26
o p iN io N
War on Terror still threatens u.s., one year after the death of Osama bin Laden. By Hope Hodge
AcR o S S A M eRicA
21
Louisianas Bobby Jindal emerges as an education reform leader with new measures to transform schools. By William OBrien
Nebraska senate primary highlights tea party vs. establishment within gOP. Whoever wins May 15 likely will win senate seat in November.
24
opiNioN
30
Rep. Jim Mcgovern has proposed a constitutional amendment that would undercut free speech. By George Will
Rep. Buck McKeon accuses the president of doing nothing to stop automatic defense cuts. By Bob Maginnis
tHe xx D eB UNkeR
The xxx president says the Bush capital gains tax cut should be permitted to expire. Heres why it shouldnt. By Mark LaRochelle
CaPITaL BrIeFS
Frozen cows to be Removed by Handsaw; Fire and explosives Dont Meet Green Rules
Ranch hands will hike in to remove the six dead cows piece by piece.
By Audrey Hudson
andsaws will be used to cut up six frozen cows discovered in an abandoned Colorado mountain cabin as opposed to fire or explosives the Forest Service was considering to remove the carcasses before the spring thaw. Federal officials are being forced to adhere to strict environmental regulations to dispose of the cows, which they say needs to be taken care of be-
fore bears come out of hibernation and sniff out the corpses, which are in a popular hiking area near Aspen. Forest Service officials initially said that blowing up the cabin or burning it down would be the fastest and most efficient means of meeting environmental regulations, which forbid the use of motorized vehicles or machinery in designated wilderness areas. But a Forest Service official told the Aspen Daily News last week that fire
and explosives would have required environmental assessment work and thats not the fastest way to go. Several ranch hands will make the nearly nine-mile hike to the cabin near the Conundrum Hot Springs, carrying the hand saws to cut up 6,000 consolidated pounds of frozen cow, and then will disperse the remains to speed up decomposition. The cows were discovered in March by hikers and reported to the Forest
Service, however another hiker is now telling reporters in Colorado that he saw the cows alive but trapped in the cabin after a November snowstorm. That hiker said he sent photos of the live cows to the rangers in hopes the animalswould be rescued, but Forest Service officials say they never got the hiwkers email or photos.
Audrey Hudson is senior reporter covering Energy and Environment for Human Events. She can be reached at AHudson@EaglePub.Com
DaTeBook
WAshingTon FAIR ImmIgRAtIon mEdIA EvEnt, HERItAgE FoundAtIon HoldS A numbER oF lECtuRES And dISCuSSIonS, And bRAdlEy FoundAtIon PRIzES AwARdEd. TuesdAyWednesdAy:
Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) sixth annual Hold Their Feet to the Fire immigration media event, to highlight the burden, cost and harm of illegal immigration. Phoenix Park Hotel, North Capitol Street, N.W.
Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.) delivers the Heritage Foundation Annual Helms Lecture, on Why Conservatives Should Fund and Support a Strong National Defense. Heritage Foundation, 9 a.m.
Prizes awarded to former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, York University Law Professor Richard A. Epstein, Harvard University Professor Harvey Mansfield and Carnegie Mellon Professor Allan Meltzer for their promotion and advocacy in the fields of liberal democracy, democratic capitalism, and a vigorous defense of American institutions. subcommittee hearing on Supporting American Jobs and the Economy through Expanded Energy Production: Challenges and Opportunities of Unconventional Resources Technology. 2318 Rayburn House Office Building, 9:30 a.m.
Congress botH HouSE And SEnAtE REtuRn FRom ConStItuEnt woRk wEEk. SEnAtE IS ExPECtEd to tAkE uP tHE StoP tHE StudEnt loAn IntERESt RAtE HIkE ACt oF 2012. HouSE CommIttEE HEARIngS ARE notEd.
Security subcommittee hearing on Measuring Border Security: U.S. Border Patrols New Strategic Plan and the Path Forward. 311 Cannon House Office Building, 10 a.m.
Services subcommittee hearing on the impact the Dodd-Frank Act regulations are having on small banks lending and investment activities. 2128 Rayburn House Office Building, 2 p.m.
oF inTeresT dEmoCRAtIC PRImARy In RECAll EFFoRt AgAInSt wISConSIn gov. SCott wAlkER, CtIA wIRElESS tRAdE SHow And dHS SymPoSIum on tRAdE.
Party holds gubernatorial primary election ahead of the June 5 recall election against Republican Gov. Scott Walker.
TuesdAyThursdAy: CTIA Wireless, the largest and most comprehensive trade show in the wireless industry. Speakers to include former President Bill Clinton, Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski, Electronic Arts CEO John Riccitiello, Visa President John Partridge, Mozilla Corporation CEO Gary Kovacs and Spotify CEO and co-founder Daniel Ek. Ernest N. Morial Convention Center, New Orleans, La. ThursdAy: George Clooney hosts
ThursdAy: U.S. Customs and Border Protection 2012 West Coast Trade Symposium Harmonizing Trade for a Stronger Economy. Long Beach Convention and Entertainment Center, Long Beach, Calif.
CAmPAign TrAil tHREE StAtES votE In tHE goP PRESIdEntIAl PRImARy; obAmA RE-ElECtIon CAmPAIgnIng And FundRAISIng ContInuES, wItH RomnEy tRyIng to PICk uP momEntum.
and West Virginia hold Republican presidential primary elections. Voters in North Carolina will also be deciding on an amendment to the State Constitution on whether to define marriage as between one man and one woman.
a fundraiser for President Barack Obama to raise money for the Obama Victory Fund. Tickets are $40,000-per-person, with expected guests to include Barbra Streisand and DreamWorks Animation CEO Jeffrey Katzenberg.
sATurdAy: Former
Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney delivers the Commencement address at Liberty University in Lynchburg, Va. The Universitys Chancellor, Jerry Fallwell, Jr., is also expected to speak.
Treasury secretary Tim geithner testifies on June 22, 2010 before the Congressional Oversight Panel on TARP.
AP IMAgEs
Another report from Federal Reserve economists confirms that TARP encouraged high-risk behavior by insulating the risk-takers from the consequences of failure.
By David Harsanyi
id TARP save America from economic catastrophe? We hear a lot of counterfactual arguments and economic theories on the matter. Politicians, naturally, have definitive answers. The public, though, is left to focus on three questions that now matter: Was the money paid back? Did TARP turn a profit? Did the legislation stabilize the long-term health of the economy? A new report to congress by Christy Romero, the Special Inspector General for the Troubled Asset Relief Program, says no on all fronts. Though the report asserts that TARP played an active role in the recovery (some of you may surely wonder what recovery?), it ends the myth that taxpayers turned a profit or were paid back by borrowers. How could this be? It was only in March when Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner claimed that while the overriding objective of TARP was to break the back of the financial crisis and save jobs, the fact that our investment in banks has also delivered a significant profit for taxpayers is a welcome development. Similarly, after the first-round of bank re-payments, President Barack Obama maintained that the government has actually turned a profit. Americans may be astonished to
hear that our debt-ridden government has the capacity to turn a profita significant profit, evenon taxpayer-funded emergency investments. After all, if TARP is a win-win policy that generates revenue, why doesnt government pour hundreds of billions of dollars into failing companies and troubled banks every year? how government defines profit The White House asserts that it will create $179 billion in profit by the fiscal year 2015. How does government make a profit, exactly? Well, the Federal Reserve undergoes a couple of rounds of quantitative easing (QE1, QE2and maybe another sequel), buying Treasury bills and distressed mortgage-backed securitiesor, in laymens terms, it prints money. Then it takes the interest made off of that printed money and deems it profit. Even using this brand of inventive accounting, the report notes it is a widely held misconception that TARP is generating profit. The most recent cost estimate for TARP is a loss of $60 billion. Taxpayers are still owed $118.5 billion (including $14 billion written off or otherwise lost), the report calculates. Though its tricky to track $700 billion of emergency funding that was haphazardly dropped into the economy by a panic-stricken government, when accounting for the Fannie Mae and Fred-
die Mac bailout, the American taxpayer is probably owed somewhere in neighborhood of $237.7 billion, though some estimates are far higher. And it will be more. The Treasury Department says that a large part of the money lost via TARP is the result of the housing and car bailouts, which wernt paid back, either. When the next Fannie and Freddie rescue comesas a number of reports have indicated will be neededtaxpayers will be on the hook. And lets not forget that many of the banks, and auto companies, had conveniently paid back their government bailouts using other government funds. The report also makes the case that TARP may be perpetuating future financial misadventures and bailouts. The issue is moral hazardhow companies embrace undue risks knowing full well they wont be held accountable. Most of the banks that were too big to fail when TARP was implemented are now even bigger. The report to Congress points out that a recent working paper from Federal Reserve economists confirms that TARP encouraged high-risk behavior by insulating the risk-takers from the consequences of failure. Risk a key component of capitalism. Government-backed risk is no risk at all.
david Harsanyi is a senior reporter covering the Economy and budget for Human Events. He can be reached at dHarsanyi@EaglePub.Com
10
war on terror Still threatens, one year After bin Ladens Death
President Obama, along with members of the national security team, in the situation Room, May 1, 2011.
AP IMAgEs
While some gains have been made in the war in Afghanistan, the projected U.S. drawdown of troops threatens any permanent success. And global terrorism has proliferated in the wake of the death of the terrorist leader, former Bush official John Bolton said.
By Hope Hodge
year ago last week, a nation learned about a valiant SEAL team, a situation room, and a compound in Abbottabad that became the setting of a notorious terrorists last stand. On the anniversary of Osama bin Ladens death, are we looking back on a turning point in the global War on Terror? Not by a long shot, a senior official of the Bush administration told Human Events. Former United Nations ambassador John Bolton, now a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, said that the U.S. assassination of the mastermind behind the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks was rightly celebrated when it took place, but should not be seen as a death blow to al Qaeda, or to the Talibans grip on Afghanistan. I dont think on net you can see
that much difference. (Bin Laden) had been pushed into a point from sustained pressure over a number of years where he was less relevant than he had been before, Bolton said. His death doesnt materially change the equation, I dont think. By the numbers, the night raid that took down the Taliban leader and al Qaeda kingpin may have had some positive effect on the trajectory of the war in Afghanistan, at least in the short run. U.S. and NATO casualties and the number of U.S. wounded were all down in a year-over-year comparison during the 12 months following bin Ladens death. Reports released by the International Security Assistance Force show a decrease in enemy-initiated attacks on ISAF troops in Afghanistan for every month since May 2011, compared to the same month the
previous year. Force officials added that the reduction in enemy-initiated attacks, the first such trend since 2008, was the longest sustained yearover-year downward trajectory recorded since ISAF began in 2001. Other war statistics, possibly more telling, are far less encouraging. insider attacks up Attacks on coalition troops from insidersAfghan police and soldiershave grown steadily. This year, so far, there have already been 13 such attacks, 10 of them fatal, compared with 21 attacks in total for 2011 and 11 for 2010, according to AP reports. Experts said one explanation for the abundance of these friendly attacks may be a concern among Afghan citizens that, as the U.S. telegraphs its intention to draw down troop strength in Afghanistan in 2014, Afghans must
once again form alliances with Taliban leaders preparing to assume control once again. Its bad enough that we will surrender Afghanistan to the people who brutalized it for decades before we overthrew them, Center for Security Policy Director Frank Gaffney said. Far from cutting our losses, I believe this will be a catalyst for far more intensive jihadist activity. And outside of Afghanistan, al Qaeda presence has proliferated, even in the wake of bin Ladens death, in regions including Iraq, Yemen, and Africa, and the terrorist organizations new leader, Ayman Al-Zawahiri, remains on the loose in Pakistan. Al Qaeda attacks in Iraq have actually increased since bin Ladens assassination, according to reports. Al Qaeda is not a corporate organization, Bolton said. It doesnt have an organizational charter on the wall. Its a loosely networked organization and it has grown substantially. The consequences of the Arab Spring have served not to undercut the appeal of al Qaeda, but simply to enhance it. As America faces the fractured end of a decade-long war and the proliferation of terrorism across the globe, celebrating the anniversary of eliminating a figurehead has seemed inappropriate for many. Killing Osama bin Laden happened while (Obama) was president, not because he was president, Bolton said. The analogy that I use is Richard Nixon taking credit for Aldrin and Armstrong landing on the moon. A group of former Navy SEALs came forward last week to protest President Obamas use of the Special Forces raid as a political gambit in his re-election campaign. And a veteran who maintains the popular military blog This Aint Hell compared Obamas grandstanding on the anniversary of the raid to President George W. Bush hanging out a Mission Accomplished banner in 2003: unwarranted and without real significance. Of course, Im glad (bin Laden is) dead and I wish hed been killed sooner. Other than that, I really dont see the value of bringing it up in an election year, Jonn Lilyea said. I think the initial death of bin Laden was a morale booster, but I dont think these anniversaries serve any purpose, not for troop morale.
Hope Hodge is a reporter covering defense and national Security for Human Events. She can be reached at HHodge@EaglePub.Com
Days between the 2001 invasion of Afghanistan and elimination of Osama bin Laden
11
12
Mining permit Backlog Leaves U.S. Dependent on china for Rare Minerals
n rare earth
Rep. Mark Amodei says this bill would streamline the permitting process, and leverage resources, respect environment.
AP IMAgEs
leading-edge industries need these rare minerals for key components in iPods, hybrid cars and solar panels. But, government policies are stifling mining companies from developing local sources, thus increasing reliance on foreign suppliers.
By Audrey Hudson
trategic minerals that are essential components in green and high technology such as hybrid cars, iPods and solar panels are readily available in the U.S. but efforts to mine the elements are being stalled by bureaucrats for years, industry officials say. The United States is heavily reliant on foreign countries such as China for critical minerals that are the building blocks of our economy and imperative to renewable energy development, military technology and the manufacturing of nearly all of our electronic devices, said Rep. Doc Hastings (RWash.), chairman of the House Resources Committee. There are 15 such rare earth minerals worth more than $6 trillion, including terbium, yttrium and dysprosium that are found throughout the U.S. To increase access, Republican lawmakers are supporting legislation called the Strategic and Critical Minerals Production Act that they say tackles the highest hurdle of getting the needed permits to begin mining operations. Hall Quinn, president of the National Mining Association, said at a recent House hearing on the bill that it often takes 10 years to get a mining permit.
The length, complexity and uncertainty of the permitting process are the primary reasons investors give for not investing in U.S. minerals mining, Quinn said. Delaying permits for mining projects is not a new problem. What is new is the growing awareness of its implications for our nation, particularly in a highly competitive world economy in which the demand for minerals continues to grow, especially in fast growing economies led by China and India, Quinn said. Amodei bill introduced The bill authored by Rep. Mark Amodei (R-Nev.) would reverse a 30-year trend of increased reliance on foreign countries and fierce competition to gain access to the needed resources. In the 2012 ranking of countries for mining investment, the United States ranked last, tied with Papua New Guinea, in permitting delays, Amodei said. Decade-long permitting delays are standing in the way of high-paying jobs and revenue for local communities. This bill would streamline the permitting process to leverage our nations vast mineral resources while paying due respect to economic and environmental concerns, Amodei said. Lawmakers say the United States
is completely reliant on China, and in addition to the threats to national security of not being self-reliant in this area, the delays in approving mining permits also costs good-paying jobs that are instead being filled overseas. The risk of scarcity is expected to rise so significantly that it will lead to supply instability and potential disruptions in the next five years, says the National Mining Association. If that happens, price increases will not be far behind. The U.S. Geological Survey reported in 2010 that 13 million tons of known deposits of rare earth elements have been located in 14 states including Alaska, California, Florida and New York. However, China accounts for 96 percent of the worlds supply. The Toyota Prius uses more of the mineral than any other consumer product, including lanthanum and cerium in the battery, yttrium in the component sensors, dysprosium and terbium in the motor and generator and neodymium in the headlight glass. The new bill is just getting off the ground in the House and it is unclear how much member support it will garner.
Audrey Hudson is a senior reporter for Human Events covering Energy and Environment. She can be reached at AHudson@EaglePub.Com
Reports of the Johnstons Frankenias demise were greatly exaggerated when it was listed as an endangered species in 1984. later surveys of the Texasbased plant showed a population greater than 9,000,000.
13
Regnery Publishing
G r e at Co n s e rvat i v e B o o k s G r e at Co n s e rvat i v e au t h o r s
A vA i l A b l e M Ay 1 s t, 2 0 12
i n b o o k sto r e s e v e r y w h e r e , o n A m A z o n, A n d At r e g n e ry. c o m.
14
sen. John McCain and sen. Joseph Lieberman, shown here in a 2011 photo, are proposing alternate senate versions of CIsPA.
AP IMAgEs
This time around, big online companies favor a bill that would allow Internet service providers to voluntarily turn over data to the government upon threat of a security breach. But, opening the Internet to government could harm user privacy, create unforeseen mischief.
By John Hayward
he Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act (CISPA), which passed the House of Representatives last month on a 248-168 vote that featured both bipartisan support and opposition, now moves to the Senate, also conflicted about the measure. The White House has threatened to veto CISPA, saying the bill effectively treats domestic cyber-security as an intelligence activity, and thus significantly departs from longstanding efforts to treat the Internet and cyberspace as civilian spheres. Internet companies and banks favor the legislation, while many online user communities, libertarians, and civil rights organizations such as the ACLU are opposed. Some believe that amendments passed by the House address their concerns about the bill,
while others say those amendments made it worse. In the Senate, alternative proposals are being advanced by Sens. John McCain (R-Ariz.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.). Most of CISPAs strongest critics dont think the McCain or Lieberman bills are much of an improvement, however, over the House version. These divergent views rather neatly capture the nature of the electronic security debate. How can cyber-security not be an intelligence activity? But if we must treat it as such, how can we also guarantee online privacy? CISPA enables Internet service providers to forward certain confidential user information to government security agencies when a cyber-security threat has been identified. At the moment, various privacy laws prevent this kind of information sharing. Furthermore, CISPA shields the ISPs from legal
liability for violating customers privacy while combating national security threats in cyberspacean umbrella many found uncomfortably broad, even before some last-minute amendments broadened it even further. Privacy concerns Detractors call CISPA the Son of SOPA, a reference to the Stop Online Piracy Act. SOPA died in Congress after massive public outcry over the damage it would have done to online privacy, and to the free flow of Internet communications. They are differentCISPA addresses national security issues, rather than SOPAs focus of intellectual propertybut critics are raising similar privacy concerns. Proponents of CISPA say that effective online security, particularly against large-scale coordinated attacks by enemy governments or large hacker
groups, requires timely involvement by the intelligence communitywhich must have some way to gather the intel needed to track down electronic terrorists and defeat viral attacks. The debate is an extension of the long-running tension between security and privacy. The Internet intensifies the debate because of its enormous reach and speed. Some data CISPA makes more readily available to government agencies can already be obtained with a warrant, but the time required to obtain a warrant could hamstring efforts to deal with a rapidly evolving online threat, supporters say. On the other hand, no one can be blamed for feeling nervous about the prospect of Internet service providers handing private data over to the government. This would happen largely at the discretion of the ISPstheyre allowed to hand over data they believe pertains to a security threat, but they are not required to do so. CISPA was designed to override almost all other privacy laws, as well as the Terms of Service agreements consumers sign, causing opponents to fear it is fraught with unintended consequences. Like every large bill, CISPA picked up a raft of amendments during the final day of debate. One of them added the protection of children from pornography as a valid reason for the government to harvest personal data. This did nothing to reassure those who thought national security was already too broad of a mission. Children are often victimized by online predators, but that has nothing to do with cyber-security. The front door of CISPA was already disturbingly large, but now it has a huge back door, too. The CISPA debate has not occurred strictly along partisan lines, although the Republican caucus in the House strongly favors it. However, 28 Republicans voted against the bill, and Rep. Ron Paul (R-Tex.) abstained. The White Houses preferred alternative legislation in the Senate was authored by Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.) and Susan Collins (R-Me.). Fox News explains it would give the Department of Homeland Security authority to set new cyber-security standards. Thats not exactly reassuring to those who worry about the 18-wheel truck of government power barreling toward the intersection of privacy and security.
John Hayward is a reporter for Human Events covering technology and Freedom. He can be reached at JHayward@EaglePub.Com.
FBi cyber-security chief believes most major companies have already been breached
fBI cyber-security chief shawn Henry (left) described the dimensions of the cyber warfare threat to a House Homeland security subcommittee as follows: I believe most major companies have already been breached or will be breached, resulting in substantial losses in information, economic competitiveness and national security. Many are breached and have absolutely no knowledge that an adversary was or remains resident on their network, often times for weeks, months or even years.
AP IMAgEs
15
The Bradley Prizes will be presented on Thursday, June 7 at The Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington, DC.
The Bradley Prizes recognize outstanding achievements that are consistent with the Foundations mission statement. Founded in 1985, The Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation is devoted to strengthening American democratic capitalism and the institutions, principles and values that sustain and nurture it. Its programs support limited, competent government; a dynamic marketplace for economic, cultural activity; and a vigorous defense, at home and abroad, of American ideas and institutions. Learn more at www.bradleyfdn.org.
16 Cover Story
Plan of Att
Mitt Romneys
eXCLuSIve: goP strategist karl rove tells human events romney can win and outlines strategies and tactics, beginning with flipping five key states that went for President obama in 2008.
uman Events Reporter Hope Hodge spoke with Karl Rove, senior adviser and deputy chief of staff to former President George W. Bush, about presumptive GOP nominee Mitt Romney and key tenets of a winning strategy for the 2012 presidential campaign. She also captured his key points in an address last Tuesday to a Young Americas Foundation event at George Washington University in Washington, D.C. romneys prospects Karl Rove: Sure he can [win]. Will he? I dont know; thats what the election is all about. romneys biggest roadblocks I think the question is going to be
how strong and powerful is (Romneys) argument going to be for economic growth. How strong is his emphasis going to be on reform. If he comes across as a reform conservative whos focused on growing the economy and putting America back to work, then hes going to be in good shape. And weve seen in the last couple of weeks very strong strains of him. Talking about how we need to put America back to work, talking about how we need to reduce tax rates and simplify the code. Having him talk candidly about the problem with entitlements and endorsing things like premium support, those are all good signs.
issues in romneys favor The economy, the deficits, spending, entitlements. The [Patient Protection and] Affordable care act is a big issue. This is something that really matters to a lot of people, and him being able to go on the offense not only to say lets repeal it, but to say, heres what Im going to do [that] is going to be really useful. states romney needs to take Three, two, oneIndiana, Virginia, North Carolina. Three historically Republican states that went Democrat; Florida and Ohiotogether they have 49 electoral college votes. Swung into the Democratic column in 08, but were Republican in 04 and swung by a smaller margin. And if Republicans win
those five states, then all they need to win is one more stateNew Hampshire, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Iowa, Colorado, New Mexico, or Nevada. President obamas present position in the minds of the American people Were right at the end of a really ugly Republican presidential process; its not over yet. Today [Tuesday, April 30] in the Gallup, it is Obama 46, Romney 47. Shouldnt be that way. We have a popular incumbent. They like him; the American people like him. They dont agree with a lot that hes done as president, but he came into office with the best wishes of the American people and they like him. And hes personally popular.
Cover Story 17
tack
President Barack Obama faces a challenge winning some of the swing states he carried in 2008. Tossup states for the last three presidential elections:
13.91%
9.61%
Penn.
12.5%
Colo.
8.95%
9.54%
Ohio N.M.
10.32%
Va.
4.58% 15.13%
6.3% 0.32%
Fla. N.C.
2.8%
NOTE: Alaska and Hawaii are not to scale
Colorado
Kerry
2012 MCT
Source: Dave Leips Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections Graphic: Julie Sheer, Doug Stevens, Los Angeles Times
Republican strategists view 9 states that went to Bush in 2004 and Obama in 2008 as crucial to the GOP hopes in 2012.
Electoral votes in 2012 and previous presidential winners: 2004 Bush Kerry McCain 47% 48% 52% Florida 29 49 47 51 Ohio 18 44 49 North Carolina 15 56 46 46 54 Virginia 13 39 49 60 Indiana 11 47 45 52 Colorado 9 49 44 50 Iowa 6 48 43 51 Nevada 6 49 42 50 New Mexico 5 2008 Obama 51% 52 50 53 50 54 54 55 57
AP AP
Re and
Ele
SOUR
90
<AP> ROAD TO 270 061911: Graphic sho 2012 election and their number of electoral breakdown of presidential winners by state 96 mm x 70 BottoM LiNemm; with BC-US--Road To 270
This is the number of additional electoral votes Romney needs to win, assuming he carries all of McCains 2008 states.
18 Cover Story
The most likely states he can win are Florida (29 electoral votes), Ohio (18), North Carolina (15), Virginia (13), Indiana (11), Colorado (9), Iowa (6), and New Hampshire (4). Total: 105 additional electoral votes, 15 more than the 270 Romney needs.
Romney strategists believe they also have a good shot at Pennsylvania (20), Michigan (16) and Wisconsin (10). The Romney camp mentions several reasons, including the fact that George W. Bush lost these states narrowly in 2000 and 2004. But others note that such optimism flies in the face of recent history, since Republicans havent captured any of these states in the last five presidential elections.
Trailing Obama narrowly in the state, Romney is thinking seriously about making Rob Portman, the popular Ohio Republican senator, his vice presidential pick. The key reason: No Republican candidate has won the White House without winning the Buckeye state. Portman has a great public service resume, having served in the House, the Senate and in the White House under Presidents George H.W. Bush and George W. Bush. A budget and tax expert, he is also liked by social conservatives and the tea party people in his home state. Nor is he identified with the state statute that weakened collective bargaining rights for public unions. Though backed by conservatives, the law was overturned by voters in November, 62 percent to 38 percent.
Gov. Romney is deeply concerned about whether Hispanics will be inspired to go to the polls en masse and vote for Obama. He recently told an audience in Palm Beach, Fla., that if this group goes overwhelmingly for the president, this spells doom for us. A Washington Post poll shows that only 32 percent of Hispanics have a favorable view of Romney while 39 percent give him an unfavorable rating. Obama is seen in a positive light by 67 percent of Hispanics. Romneys Hispanic problem is why hes also thinking of putting Floridas Republican senator, Marco Rubio, on the ticket. Some believe Rubios dynamic personality, personal story and rising national profile could give Romney the lift he needs in the Hispanic community and beyond.
authority and prestige in office and if you use it effectively, it makes it relatively easy for a president to get re-elected. But President Obama has not used the power and prestige of the office to prepare for his re-election. Last yeardo you remember what the topics of the State of the Union were last year? Three of them. The most compelling and centered issues in Americas life as a nation: High speed rail, high speed Internet, and countless green jobs. The last one doesnt sound too good after Solyndra. The first two are just plain weird. I defy you to tell me what the theme of this years State of the Union was. You think what are the two biggest signature accomplishments of president Obama the stimulus bill, which got not one word in this years State of the Union address, and the Affordable Care Act,
which got 44 words and two sentences. Obama campaign strategy: Kill Romney. Were going to see this. Were going to see it every day of the campaign. And it is not going to work to President Obamas advantage unless and until Mitt Romney stops replying to it. They want to see where these attacks are going. Were going to have this constantly throughout the campaign. Third key strategic ingredient for Romney campaign: understand its not merely enough to set the record straight or to use the presidents own words and own statements and his own pledges and promises and statements to hold him accountable, but its also very important for the American people to get a sense of who Mitt Romney is and what it is that hell do. They want to know what hes going to do in office. They want to know that hes got an idea of what he wants to achieve.
Romneys going to be tested. Whats he all about? How authentic is he? Who is he? You dont have to agree with someone 100 percent of time to kind of cave and say, you know what, I trust him. Romney needs to lay out an agenda. And it needs to be what he believes. This is not just about Obama did or didnt deliver. Its not just about going toe to toe with Obama, as he throws a punch at me I can defend myself and push back. Its going to have to be what is it am I going to do if I get elected. And thats really tough for people to do. Thats conventional politics. The stuff of laying out a vision sometimes comes across to the media as prosaic. Thats strategic. A few useful tactics First of all, (the Romney camp) has to worry about money. I add it all up, Obama is likely to have $1.2 billion dollars. So Romney has to worry about
Karl Rove
money and close the gap. He cant be like McCain... Obama vs. McCain $850 million to $525 million. So Romney needs to narrow that gap. Romney also needs to be careful about his travel and what states he focuses on. One way to look at this is 12thats how much closer the electoral college is going to be in 2012 if Romney only wins the states that McCain carried. Because between 08 and 12 we reapportioned the electoral college. This is going to be one of the most interesting contests in recent memory.