Journal of the Geological Society A laminated hemipelagic facies from the Wenlock and Ludlow of the Welsh Basin

A. J. DIMBERLINE, A. BELL and N. H. WOODCOCK Journal of the Geological Society 1990; v. 147; p. 693-701 doi:10.1144/gsjgs.147.4.0693

Email alerting service Permission request Subscribe

click here to receive free email alerts when new articles cite this article click here to seek permission to re-use all or part of this article click here to subscribe to Journal of the Geological Society or the Lyell Collection

Notes

Downloaded by

Geological Society of America on 9 July 2010

1990 Geological Society of London

Journal of the Geological Society, London, Vol. 147, 1990, pp. 693-701, 6 figs. Printed in Northern Ireland

A laminated hemipelagic facies from the Wenlock and Ludlow of the Welsh Basin
A . J . D I M B E R L I N E , A . BELL & N . H . WOODCOCK Department of Earth Sciences, University of Cambridge, Downing Street, Cambridge CB2 3EQ, UK

Abstract: A hemipelagicfaciesfrom the Siluriansuccessionin Wales consists of finely laminated, dominantlysilt-gradesediment. It canbeinterbeddedwith sand- or mud-grade turbidites, or can occur as an independent facies. Its occurrence and character was controlled mainly by low bottom wateroxicity.Thepelagic fauna of the laminatedhemipelagitesupportsthis view. Many of the silt-grade particles have an aggregate structure and probably represent the faecal pellets of oceanic zooplankton. The fine laminationis thought to have formed by alternations of planktonic blooms and increased discharges of silt into the basin. By comparison with modern examples this alternation was likely to have been annual or seasonal.

The Silurian Welsh Basin

The Welsh Basin was a Cambrian to Early Devonian zone of relatively rapid subsidence on the Avalonian microcontinent (Fig. l ) , bordered to the northwest and southeast by shallow or emergent platforms. Recent reviews of its history are given by Woodcock (1984, 1990) and Kokelaar (1988). During most of Ordovician time, represented by rocks of the Gwynedd Supergroup, it was a volcanically active marginal basin, but most volcanism ceased in late Caradoc time. A basin-wide unconformity in the early Ashgill (Pusgillian) marks tectonic activity along the basin-bounding fault systems andtheonset of deposition of the Powys Supergroup (Ashgill through Lower Devonian). During this interval the basinwas in anon-volcanicactive margin or collision zone setting. The northern and central to southern parts of the Welsh Basin had differing histories during the time of Powys Supergroup accumulation. In Ashgill and Llandovery times, slowhemipelagic depositionin thenorth contrasted with repeatedandvoluminous influxes of turbiditycurrentsin mid-Wales. The majority of these sediments were deposited under oxic conditions, which encouraged burrowing and grazingorganisms andthedestruction of anyhemipelagic lamination. During earliest Wenlock time there was a marked decrease in the oxicity of the basin bottomwaters.This anoxic event can be traced throughout the basins bordering the Iapetus Ocean (Kemp 1985, 1990). The early Wenlock also saw increased subsidence and clastic supply in the northern Welsh Basin. A turbiditedepocentredeveloped, termed the Denbigh Trough (Cummins 1957), which remained a discrete sub-basin throughout Wenlock and Ludlow times, largely barred from thecontinuing mid-Wales depocentre, the Montgomery Trough (Fig. 1). Inversion of the Welsh Basin probablybeganduring Ludlow time and climaxed in the Acadian shortening late in the Early Devonian. The inversion was accompanied by a rapidtransitionfrommarine to non-marine facies in the basin and on its Bounding platforms. 693

Distribution of laminated hemipelagite

Palaeogeographical distribution
Laminated hemipelagite occurs over the whole area of the Welsh Basin where Wenlock and Ludlow rocks are preserved (Fig. 1; Cummins 1 9 5 9 ~ Warren et al. 1984). It ; laps some way onto the basin slopes but is not preserved on the platforms. Laminated hemipelagite in not restricted to those basinal area inundated by the contemporary sand turbidite systems. Two areas exemplify this relationship. On the southeast basin margin, northerly-directed Wenlock turbidity flows were confined laterally by a fault-controlled slope, whilst hemipelagic sediment was deposited on basin floor and slope alike (Dimberline & Woodcock1987). On the palaeohigh between the Montgomery Denbigh and Troughs, the Derwen Ridge of Cummins (1957), Wenlock turbidites are almost absent yet a continous laminated hemipelagite sequence was deposited. The distribution of Fig. 1 is compatible with turbidity flows hugging depositional lows and with vertical fallout forming laminatedhemipelagite indiscriminately on lows, slopes and highs throughout the basin.

Stratigraphical distribution
Laminated hemipelagite occurs in the basin in strata from the centrifugus Biozone(lowest Wenlock) to the incipiem Biozone (lower Ludlow) (Fig.2). However, the character of the resulting sediment is controlled stronglyby temporal fluctuations in the proportion of interbedded turbidites and in the bottom water oxicity. At the base of the Wenlock Series (centrifugus Biozone) laminatedhemipelagite is interbedded with turbiditesbut can form >50% of the sequence. Examples of this facies are the Benarth Formation Wales the in north and murchisoni Nant-y-Sgollen Shales in mid-Wales. In the through linnarsoni biozones, turbidites dominate the intrabasinal troughs, forming the Denbigh Grits Group. By contrast,laminatedhemipelagitedominatesthesequences

694

A . J . DIMBERLINE E T A,!,.

Fig. 1 Map of Wales showing outcrop . of Wenlock and Ludlow rocks, selected

palaeogeographical features and depthrelated fauna1 communities for midWenlock time (rigidus Biozone); modified after Hurstet al. (1978). Facies boundaries are conjectural away from outcrop control. LHP, laminated hemipelagic facies.

on the intervening Derwen Ridge palaeohigh, forming 100% of the sequence Llangollen. near The magnitude and frequency of the turbidites in the troughs decrease in the linnarsoni Biozone, so thatlaminatedhemipelagitemakes up about 60% of the sequence. This facies, typical of the NantglynFlags Group (ellesae to nilssoni biozones), has a distinctive striped or ribbon-bandedappearance due to interbedding of 5-40 mm laminatedhemipelagitepackets with 5-20 mm silt-mud turbidites. Turbidite deposition increasingly affected the Derwen Ridge during late Wenlock time and the basal Ludlow Glyndyfrdwy Group is very similar to the Nantglyn Flags Group. There are two intervalsin the NantglynFlags Group, within the ludemis and nassa biozones respectively,which preserve little laminated hemipelagite but contain a benthic infauna as well as epifauna. More oxic bottom waters allowed burrowers and grazers to destroy any lamination that formed. The two oxic episodes have been linked to a continental regression coincident with the development of the Wenlock Limestone the on Midland Platform (McKerrow 1979; Kemp 1990). Both may be a consequence of a drop in sea-level, allowing reef build-up on the shelf and the breakdown of stratification in the basin. Laminated hemipelagite is rarely preserved rocks in younger than those of nilssoni Biozone age. In north Wales this can be explained by the increasing volume of turbidites supplied to the Denbigh Trough. In mid-Wales the laminated hemipelagite deficiencymay have resulted from the breakdown of basin-water stratification, since inter-

bedded silt and fine sandbeds show structuresconsistent with astorm influence(Tyler & Woodcock1987). Storms would lead to mixing, to increase of bottom-water oxicity, matter onthe and in turn to the oxidation of organic sea-floor. Despitethis,somelaminatedhemipelagitehas been described from the storm-influenced Bailey Hill & Woodcock 1987), the Formation (Tyler Tyler 1987: Ludlow turbidites of Cummins (1959b). This laminated hemipelagite could have resulted from the re-establishment of water stratification and oxygen depletion of bottom waters between major storm events. Alternatively the storm mobilized sediments could have been deposited rapidly onto organic rich sedimentsthathadnot had time to oxidize, isolating the laminated hemipelagitethe from now oxygenated surface waters. The youngest laminated hemipelagite in north Wales is found in the Bont-UchelFormation of the Elwy Group (Warren et al. 1984), in the incipiens Biozone.

General description and interpretation Lithology, structure and sequence

The laminated hemipelagite consists of silt laminae alternating with organic carbon-rich laminae on a scale of three to four carbon-rich laminae per mm (Cummins 1959a; Warren et al. 1984). The lamination is discontinuous laterally on a 1-5 cmscale inlamination-normalsections (Fig. 3a). The silt laminae contain silt and clay aggregates

HEMIPELAGIC FACIES OF THE WELSH BASIN

695

Fig. 2. Representative stratigraphical columns for the Silurian of:2, Denbigh Trough; north flankof Berwyn High (Llangollen Syncline);4, 1, Montgomery Trough; 5, Midland Platform. DC, Denbigh Grits Group; GDG, Glandyfrdwy Group; LNF, Lower Nantglyn Flags Group; LS,

Ludlow shale; PG, Pen-y-Clog Group; UNF, Upper Nantglyn Flags Group; Wenlock Limestone; WS, Wenlock Shale; LHP, laminated WL hemipelagic facies. Sections parallel the cut to up to 2 mm in diameter. lamination show a distinctive mottled appearance (Fig. 3b) due the to presence of these aggregates. The detailed description and interpretation of the aggregates is covered in a later section. Interbedding of laminatedhemipelagite with turbidites in the SilurianWelshBasin hasbeen well describedand illustrated by Cave (1979) and Cave & Hains (1986). Logs through the Wenlock of mid-Wales (Fig. 4) show that the laminated hemipelagite always occurs above a structureless turbidite mudstone. It is always overlain by asharpor erosive contact with the basal silt or sand of a turbidite (Fig. 3f). It never grades up into finer-grained, wispy-laminated or gradedlungraded mud as would be expected if it was a traction current deposit associated with a turbidite (Stow & Bowen1980). Theserelationships confirm anon-turbidite origin for the laminated hemipelagite. Moreover, bentonite bands always occur bracketed by hemipelagite, as observed by Kemp (1985). The same logs (Fig. 4) show that sand-based turbidites of laminated tend to be underlain by thinner packets hemipelagite than do silt-mud turbidites. This suggests that the greater erosive capacity of the coarser turbidity currents removed a greater thickness of accumulated laminated hemipelagite. However, there are examples both of coarse sandstone turbidites underlain by hemipelagite and successive mud turbidites with no intervening hemipelagite, suggesting that the time-gap between turbidite eventsis also

an important factor, Whilst laminated hemipelagite occurs most commonly between silt-mud turbidites (Figs 3c and d) it also occurs independently of turbidites, for instance in the Llangollen area where there are over 50 m of uninterrupted laminated hemipelagite.

Fauna
The laminated hemipelagite is generally unbioturbated, indicating that oxygen levels beneathandjustabovethe sediment interfaces water were too low to support a burrowing infauna (Bromley & Ekdale 1984). At a few 597 and a localities (e.g. Nantglyn Quarries, SH 977 roadside quarry, SH 908 663) grazing trails can be seen on the surface of the hemipelagite. These grazing trails do not apparently disturb the lamination. Graptolites orthoconic and nautiloids are particularly common in the laminated hemipelagite and are often found aligned (Fig. 3e). The aligning currents have not disturbed the lamination. A diverse but sparse shelly fauna has been collected by Warren el al. (1984) from the laminated hemipelagite of theLower NantglynFlags Group of the Denbigh Moorsarea.Thisfauna consists of the bivalves Cardiola and Butovicella, pterineids, rare crinoids and ostracodes. The bivalves and ostracodes are found sporadically in ones ortwos and only rarely in clusters. Both valves of the bivalves andthe ostracodes are commonly found together.

6%

A . J . DIMBERLINE E T A L .

b
1

Fg 3. r.

(a) Thin sectionof laminated hemipelagic showing continuous organic laminae and silt aggregates (OL) (A). Castle Vale (SO 092 747). (b) Section of laminated hemipelagite parallel lamination, showing mottling to intersection with organic laminae and tabular aggregate to due (SO cap structures (arrowed). Llanbadarn Fynydd 098 775). (c) Laminated hemipelagite(H) with interbedded silt-mud turbidite (centre), Lens is 5 cm diameter. Locality as (a). laminated hemipelagite(H) with interbedded silt-mud turbidites. Pencil is mm diameter. Locality as (b). (a) 7 (e) Aligned graptoliteson bedding surface laminated hemipelagite. Bwlch Sarnau (SO 037 751). ( f ) Thin section of erosive based silt of y turbidite (T) overlying laminated hemipelagite(H). Locality as (a).

graptolites, the The orthocones crinoid and Scyphocrinites? are assumed to havebeenpelagicandto have settled through the water column after death (Warren et al. 1984). The crinoids are commonly found articulated. Because crinoids tend to disarticulate soon after death, such good preservation normally implies rapid burial. In the laminatedhemipelagiteit is more likely that the strongly reducing bottom waters slowed down decomposition.

The bivalves and ostracodes may have been pelagic (KM 1969), but it is more likely that they were epibenthic (McAlester in Berry & Boucot 1967). Their association with graptolites suggests that they were adapted to lowoxygen environments which excluded most other life forms but which best preservedgraptolites(Berry & Boucot 1967). Bivalves such as Cardiola may have part been of an exaerobic biofacies (Savrda & Bottjer 1987) present around

H E M IO EA C IG I C PF L A E S F

THE WELSH B A S I N

697

this boundary coincided with the sedimentlwater interface, excluding infauna but allowing the establishment of a of bivalves and grazing restricted exaerobic benthos organisms.

Possible modern analogue

An instructive modern analogue for the Wenlock laminated hemipelagite is the varved sediment in the Tertiary basins of the Californian Borderland (Hulsemann & Emery 1961; Isaacs 1984; Thornton 1984). In basinssuch as theSanta Barbara Basin (Thornton 1984) anoxic bottom water allows the preservation of laminites, together with turbidites and flood suspensate layers. The lamination is due to increased claylsilt discharge intothe basin in November to March alternating with plankton fallout during the rest of the year (Emery 1960). The lamina couplets prove to be annual by correlation with rainfall totals and tree rings (Soutar & Crill 1977).
l

100

U)
4-

2
3

U)

E
Q)

E c

Interpretation
The laminated hemipelagite is interpreted as interturbidite sediment that formedthe hemipelagic background deposit in the basin, following similar interpretations by Cummins (19596) and Cave (1979) in Wales and by Kemp (1985) in the Southern Uplands of Scotland. Hemipelagic deposition occurred primarilyslow by settling through the water column in the absence of marked traction or turbidity currents. (Fig. 6). A component of current-induced lateral advection of suspended sediment (Drake et al. 1978) is evidenced by aligned graptolites and orthocones (Fig. 3e). It is proposed that the silt laminae were formed bya combination of vertical fallout of aggregates produced inthe water column and the deposition of silt and clay grade sediment by extremely dilute density currents with very low velocities just sufficient to align graptolites. A bottom water nepheloid layer (Gorseline 1984; McCave 1984) is a possible mechanism. The source of the terrigenous sediment for the Wenlock hemipelagite could havebeen wave-resuspended shelf sediment, aeolian input, or river discharge. The latter source is suggested by the likely delta-fed origin of the Wenlock turbidite system (Dimberline 1987; Dimberline & Woodcock 1987). The carbon-rich laminae are thought to have originated by the vertical fallout from seasonal phytoplankton blooms. An alternative is that represent they sulphur-oxidizing bacterial mats (cf. Williams & Reimers 1983). Such mats form in dysaerobic sediments between the oxygenated zone and the underlying hydrogen sulphide zone. The laminated hemipelagite contains no direct evidence, such as phosphate cements, for a permanent sulphidicloxic interface ator below the sediment-water interface. However, other features associated with this interface, grazing trails and a limited epifauna, are seen occasionally. The current alignment of graptolites and orthocones without disruption of laminae is compatiblewith,though does require, not a bacterial mat binding the sediment surface. The sulphidic/oxic interface may have been usually just above the sediment surface, butat times was lowered to coincidewith it andthus allowing the development of a bacterial mat. Such mats may have contributed to the organic carbon in the hemipelagite, but are unlikely to have been the only source.

C
Q)

1
h "
l

50

1 ..,....._.

F
. . ...

parallel lamination cross lamination structureless sandstone

hemipelagite m turbidite

laminated

0mudstone

Fig. 4. Examples of logged sections including laminated hemipelagite (a) Packet of laminated hemipelagite/mud turbidites within sand turbidite sequence (Bwlch-y-Sarnau Quarry, SO 037 751). (b) Interbedded laminated hemipelagite, fine sand/silt-mud turbidites (Llanbadarn Fynydd, SO 098 775).

thedysaerobic/anaerobicboundary.Thisboundary would have shifted its vertical position through time due tochanges in primary productivity, level, sea the position of the pycnocline, or the rate of sedimentation. In a slope setting, therefore, onlya relatively thin zone of sediments would contain this interface. The widespreadoccurrence of laminatedhemipelagite indicates that the mid-Silurian floor to the Welsh Basin was generally below the dysaerobic/anaerobic boundary and therefore preserves a predominantly pelagic fauna. At times

698

A . J . DIMBERLINE E T A L

Fg 5. i.

(a) Thin sectionof laminated hemipelagite showing large silt aggregate (A). Castle Vale(SO 092 747). (b) Backscatter SEM image of laminated hemipelagite showing chlorite-rimmed aggregate containing clay-grade mica and chlorite. Locality as(c) Chondrites-bioturbated (a). (SO hemipelagite from centrifugzu Biozone, Howgill Fells 699 970). (a) Backscatter SEM image of laminated hemipelagite showing aggregate of clay-grade chlorite and illite-mica. Locality (a). as

I l

SILT INPUT

~,

Y
ANAEROBIC

aeolian

wave resuspended

siltlmud I* turbidites I

7 =Z -- z 5 - =-= . . .. -

- - = - L . __.

. .

0. . &..' .

- ..

=.c

Q.

; +LHP

aggregate

organic laminae from seasonal phytoplankton blooms siltlmudrnatrix silt/clay

Fig. 6. Cartoon illustratingthe origin of laminated hemipelagite and its relationship sand turbidites. to

HEMIPELAGICFACIESOFTHEWELSHBASIN

699

Periodicity
Direct analogy with the California Borderland suggests that the sub-millimetre lamination scale in the laminated hemipelagite is annual. This conclusion must be viewed with some caution. Assessment of the number of laminae in a known number of graptolite zones give periodicities of aboutfouryears in theLakeDistrict(Kemp 1985) and about ten years in northWales. The extent to which the deficit is due to erosionalremoval of laminae is unknown. IntheSantaBarbaraBasin,occasionalhomogeneous mud layers ( < l cm thick) record increased discharge from floods on land. The mean periodicity for the mud layers is 59 years, for and silt-mud turbidites it is 120 years (Thornton 1984). Similar thin ( < l cm) homogeneous mud layers in the Wenlock hemipelagite may also represent flood layers. Silt-mud turbidites in mid-Wales have comparable mean repeat times of75 years for sand-poor sections and 123 years for sand-rich (Dimberline sections 1987; Dimberline & Woodcock 1987). Warren et nl. (1984) obtained a mean repeat timeof 200 years for mud turbidites intercalated with laminatedhemipelagite in northWales, based on the number per graptolite biozone.

Aggregate structures
Description
Aggregate structures are composite grains up to 2 mm in diameter,occurringabundantly in the silt laminae of the laminatedhemipelagite (Cummins 1959~).Thereare two compositionaltypes,those with a high quartz-siltcontent (Figs 3a and 2a) and those entirely of clay size chlorite and illite (Figs 5b and Original c). pellet shape is hard to determine, bedding but parallel sections (Fig. 3b) show ellipsoidal to cylindrical shapes. In bedding normal sections (Figs2a and 3a) pellets are elongated in the plane of the lamination.

Possible modern anaIogues

Clay and silt gradeparticlesneed such small currentsto keep them in suspension that particle by particle deposition in a pelagic setting is virtually impossible (Pryor 1975). The vertical flux of sediment in the oceans is dominated by relatively large aggregated particles (McCave 1984). The aggregates are mainly faecal pellets ofpelagic organisms and mucus feedingsheets.Pellets have agreaterpreservation potential that the sheets. The importance of faecal pellets as a vehicle for transporting sediment to the seafloor has been recognized widely (e.g. Smayada 1971; McCave 1975; Roth et al. 1975; Dunbar & Berger 1981). The best modern analogues the for Welsh Wenlock aggregates occur in the California Borderland basins. In the Santa Barbara Basin vertical fallout of tunicate and crustacean pellets accounts for 50% of the sediment flux to the central basin floor and for 60-90% of trapped material (Dunbar & Berger 1981). The pellets are tabular, ellipsoidal and cyclindrical, butrarelyspherical.Theyrange up to 1 mm in diameter. The composition of the pellets reflects the composition of suspended suspension-feeding matter, organisms cleaning the water of edible indigestible and material alike. Most California Borderland pellets consists of clay minerals and quartz silt (Dunbar & Berger 1981). Other modem producers pellet are shallow water, benthic, filter-feeding organisms polychaete and worms. Benthic faecal pellets robust are and hydrodynamically equivalent to fine quartz sand (Pryor 1975). Some may have been transported the into Welsh Silurian basin from adjacentplatforms.Pioneeringpolychaetespelletizesediment with low dissolved oxygen contents(<0.1ml/l-l), leaving no worm tubes or disrupted lamination (Cuomo & Rhoads 1987). However, very low pore-water oxygen contents will not support a polychaete assemblage. Cuomo & Rhoads (1987) describe such a sediment with extremely fine lamination and abundant pyrite, similar to the Wenlock laminated hemipelagite, and suggest that its contained pellets could be polychaete pellets transported from more oxic sediments upslope or be from a zooplankton source.

Comparison with previous interpretations

Carey & Roy (1985) interpreted Silurian the laminated facies in the Jemtland Formation of northern Maine as part of a silt/clay turbidite. They concluded that the laminated shale occurs above non-laminated shale and below siltstone beds and recognized a complete Bouma (1962) sequence as: laminated siltstone, laminated and shale uniform shale. Theyinterpretedthelaminatedhemipelagite as the Piper (1978) E l division. Although recognized the they both aggregate structures and laminae the organic their mechanism fails to explain either feature. Neither does it accountfor the much higherorganiccontentand pelagic fauna of the laminated hemipelagite compared with associated lithologies of similar grainsize. Warren (1963 and Warren et al. 1984) envisaged a rather similar turbiditicoriginforlaminatedhemipelagite in the Wenlock of south Scotland. He explained its high organic and fauna1 content by the entrapping of pelagic organisms by driftingclouds of fine turbiditesediment.There still remains the difficulty of explaining a lamination defined by alternating organic-rich with silt/mud laminae in terms of traction processes in a density current. The slow uniform deposition mechanism of Cummins (1959a) also leaves the origin of the lamination unspecified. In summary, there are four main lines of evidence that thelaminatedfacies is hemipelagicbackgroundsediment and not turbiditic. (a) position Its between never but within individual turbidites, whether sand-, silt- or mud-based. (b) The ubiquity of sharp upper contacts to packets of laminatedhemipelagiteratherthanan upward gradation into finer-grained mud. (c) The abundant pelagic fauna in the laminated hemipelagite whichis very rare in theassociatedsilt-mud turbidites. The laminated facies is known to palaeontologists as graptolitic shale. (d) Bentonite bands always occur bracketed by hemipelagite.

Interpretation
It is concluded that the aggregate structures in the Welsh Silurian laminated hemipelagite are primarily the faecal pellets of pelagic organisms. Transported pellets of benthic organisms are a possible component. It is proposed that the clay pellets were produced by a different organismto the silt pellets, perhaps one unable to ingest silt-sized particles.

700

A . J . DIMBERLINE E T A L .

There is no literature on the faecal pellets produced by Silurian pelagic filter feeders. Modern arthropods are importantpelletproducersandcould also havebeen so during Wenlock and Ludlow times (S. Conway-Morris, pers. comm.). Organisms providing a food source filter for feeders could have included algae, dinoflagellates, zooflagellates, acritarchs, and chitinozoans.

(b) Marine snow does not contain tabular the and cylindrical shapes seen in many of the aggregates. (c) Marine snow could not promote observed the differentiation into silt and clay aggregates.

General relevance of laminated hemipelagite

The main conclusions accepted from previous work or derived from this study are: (a) The laminated hemipelagite of Wales was deposited during prolonged episodes of low bottom water oxygen content in Wenlock and Ludlow times: (b) laminated hemipelagite is hemipelagic a background facies, not deposited itself by turbidity currents although commonly interbedded with turbidites: (c) the fauna of the laminated hemipelagite is predominantly pelagic;a sparse; low-diversity benthic fauna represents an exaerobic epifauna; (d) the aggregate structures with the laminated hemipelagite are primarily the faecal pellets of pelagic organisms, with subordinatetransported pellets from benthic organisms; (e) the lamination within the laminated hemipelagite is approximately annual. These conclusions are of more than local relevance. A facies similar to the Welsh laminated hemipelagite is found in manySilurian sequencesthroughout the world (Kemp 1985,1990; R. B. Rickards pers. comm.). Good examples occur in basins now adjacent to the Welsh Basin: the Lake District (Rickards 1964, 1965: Llewellyn 1965), the Southern Uplands(Warren 1963; Kemp 1985) andIreland(Archer 1981). Its widespread development probably reflects sluggish circulation of the world's oceans and a global 'greenhouse' state (Leggett et al. 1981). However, it isclear thatthe spatial and temporal distribution of laminated hemipelagite has been controlled by local tectonic factors as well as by global oceanographic effects, particularly events that cause sand turbidite input to basins. The hypothesis of a near-annual lamination within the laminated hemipelagite has wide implications, allowing estimates of accumulation rates and turbidite repeat times throughout much of the Silurian. The spacing of organic laminae in the Wenlock laminated hemipelagite is one area in which there is general agreement. Cummins (1959a) found 3-4 organic carbon-rich laminae per millimetre; Kemp (1985) measured 3-3.5; and a figure of 3 has been determined in this study. The sedimentationrate of the hemipelagite is therefore approximately 0.33 mm a-', 33 cm ka-', 333 m Ma-'. Both this rate and the relative coarseness of the hemipelagite is consistentwith that of present day continental margin settings (Stow et al. 1985). Where the hemipelagite is interbedded with thin silt-mud turbidites, packets of laminated hemipelagite thin as as 0.5-1.5mmhave been traced laterally as much as 25 m, suggesting little or no erosion by the turbidity flows (e.g. Nantglyn Flags, Deeside Slab Quarry SJ 137 404). If erosion was minimal then the thickness of the laminated hemipelagite interbeds will be proportional to the time period between the turbidites, and it is possible to calculate accumulation rates for the turbidite-laminated hemipelagite interbeds. The potential of such quantitative studies is currently being explored using the sequences in North Wales.

Comparison with previous interpretations

A faecal pellet origin for the Welsh Silurian aggregates has been suggestedpreviouslyby Jones (1954) and Llewellyn (1965). Kemp (1985) rejected this origin on two accounts. (a)thepellets of benthicburrowers could nothave been transported throughout the Iapetus Ocean. This is not a seriousobjection in the Welsh Basin with its closely bordering platforms, in nor similar basins marginal to Iapetus. (b) Planktic organisms would not have produced faecal pellets as large as the aggregates seen. This objection is not supported by the from data the California Borderland basins (Dunbar & Berger 1981). Other proposed origins fortheaggregatestructuresin the WelshSilurian must be considered.They are not the result of bioturbating organisms (Jones 1954; Cummins 19590; Llewellyn 1965) for the following reasons. (a) The interface between the laminated hemipelagite and the underlying turbidite mud is always sharp and this mud is rarely bioturbated. (b)Discrete lensoid ortabular aggregategeometries dominate over cylindrical shapes that would be compatible with burrows as well as with a pelletal origin. (c) Undoubted bioturbation of laminated hemipelagite does not produce pellets, but rather destroys both the organic-rich laminae and the aggregate structures. Examples occur in the the ludensis and nussa biozones of the Denbigh Trough (Warren et al. 1984), the upper Llandovery of mid-Wales (Smith 1987,1988), and the basal Wenlock of the Howgill Fells (Fig. 5d). The aggregates could not have been produced entirelyby compaction around irregularly distributed carbonaceous flakes (Rickards 1964, 1965) because: (a) aggregates the are discrete structures are that occasionally bound and rimmed by organic matter (Figs 2a and 3a); (b) compaction could not have produced the observed segregation into silt and clay aggregates; (c) the uncompacted aggregates probably were not spherical, countering the argument thatcompaction was not sufficient to produce the presentlensoid shapes; (d) plastically deformed rip-up clasts of laminated hemipelagite showingwell developedaggregatestructures occur in turbidite sandstones. The aggregates are not thought to be the mucus feeding sheets of gelatinouszooplankton, so-called marine snow (Kemp 1985), because of the following. (a) Marine snow consists of large (0.5-1000mm) fragile aggregates and sheets of mucus (Gilmer 1972) which are unlikely to remain as discrete structures after deposition. They will break up and release their bound sediment at the water surface and during descent (I. N. McCave,pers. comm.). The Wenlockaggregates are clearly robust enough to have survived compaction.

BASIN WELSH OF HEMIPELAGIC THE FACIES ThisworkwasfundedbyNERCresearchstudentships(A. J. D. and A. B.) andaNERCresearchgrant(N. H. W.).Discussions with A. Kemp, N. McCave, B. Rickards, R. Smith, J. Tyler, and P. Warren are gratefully acknowledged. A constructive review by R. Cave substantially improved the paper.

701
Papers in Palaeontology. KOKELAAR, P. 1988. Tectonic controls of Ordovician arc andmarginal B. basinvolcanisminWales. JournaloftheGeological Society, London, 145, 759-776. Ei,J. 1%9. Genus Butovicella Kiiz 1965,in the Silurian of Bohemia (Bivalvia). Sbornik geologickych Ved. Rada, 10, 105-139. J. W. L. LEGGETT, K., MCKERROW, S . , COCKS, R. M. C RICKARDS, R. B. 1981. Periodicity in the early Palaeozoic marine realm. Journal of the GeologicalSociety, London, l38, 167-176. LLEWELLYN, G . 1%5. The graptolitic mudstones of the Howgill P. Fells. Geological Magazine, 102,277-278. M ~ A V E , N. 1975. Vertical I. flux of particles in the ocean. Deep Sea Research, 2 , 491-502. 2 - 1984. Erosion, transport and deposition of fine-grained marine sediments. In: STOW,D. A. V. & PIPER,D. J. W. (eds) Fine-grained sediments: deep-water processes and facies. Geological Society, London, Special Publication, 15, 35-69. MCKERROW, S. 1979. W. Ordovician Silurian and changes in sea level. Journal of the Geological Society, London, l36, 137-145. J. PIPER, D. W. 1978. Turbidite muds and silts on deep-sea fans and abyssal plains. In: STANLEY, J. KELLING, . (eds) Sedimentation in submarine D. G canyons, fans and trenches. Dowden, Hutchinson and Ross, Stroudsburg, Pa, 163-176. PRYOR, W.A.1975.Biogenic sedimentation and alteration of argillaceous Society of sediments in shallow marine environments. Geological America Bulletin, 86, 1244-1254. RICKARDS, B. 1964. The graptolitic mudstone and associated facies in the R. Silurian strata of the Howgill Fells. Geological Magazine, 101, 435-451. - 1965. The graptolitic mudstones of the Howgill Fells. Geological Magazine, 102,558-559. & BERGER,W. H. 1975. Coccolith Row, P. H. MULLIN,M. M. sedimentation by fecal pellets: laboratory experiments and field observations. The Geological Society of America Bulletin, 86, 1079-1084. D. J. 1987. The exaerobic zone, a new SAVDRA, E. & BOTHER, C. oxygen-deficient marine biofacies. Nature, 327, 54-56. SMAYADA,J. 1971. Normal andaccelerated sinking of phytoplankton in the T. 1 sea. Marine Geology, 1 , 105-122. SMITH, R. D. A. 1987. The griestoniensis Zone turbidite system, Welsh Basin. In: L E G G J. ,K. & ZUFFA, G . (eds) Marine Clastic Sedimentology: ~ C. Concepts and Case Studies. Graham and Trotman, London, 89-107. -1988. Sedimentological analysis of a turbidite basin: the late Llandovery (Silurian) Welsh Basin. PhD thesis, University of Cambridge. P. SOUTAR, & CRILL, A. 1977. Sedimentation and climatic patterns in the A. Santa Barbara Basin during the 19th and 20th centuries. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 88, 1161-1172. D. A. STOW, A. V. & BOWEN, J. 1980. A physical model for the transport and 7 sorting of fine-grained sediment by turbidity currents. Sedimentology, 2 , 31-46. -, HOWELL, G . & NELSON, C. 1985. Sedimentary, tectonic, and D. H. A. W. N. sea-level controls. In: BOUMA, H., NORMARK, R. & BARNES, E. (eds) Submarine fans and related depositional systems. Springer, New York, 15-23. S. Basin model for hemipelagic sedimentation in a THORNTON, E 1984. tectonicallyactive continental margin: Santa Barbara Basin, California Continental Borderland. In: STOW,D. A. V. & PIPER, D. J. W. (eds) Fine-grained sediments: deep-water processes and facies. Geological Society, London, Special Publication, 1 , 377-395. 5 J. TYLER, E. 1987. Clastic marine facies inthe Ludlow ofthecentralWelsh region. PhD thesis, University of Cambridge. - & WOODCOCK, H. 1987. Hill Formation: Ludlow Series N. Bailey turbidites in the Welsh Borderland reinterpreted as distal storm deposits. Geological Journal, 2 , 73-86. 2 WARREN, T. 1%3. The petrography, sedimentation and provenance of the P. of the Wenlock rocks near Hawick, Roxburghshire. Transactions Geological Society of Edniburg. 19, 225-255. , PRICE, D., NW, M. J. C . & SMITH,E. G . 1984. Geology of the Country around Rhyl and Denbigh. Memoir, British Geological Survey, sheets 95 and 97. Her Majestys Stationery Office. C. 1983. Role of bacterial mats in WILLIAMS, A. & REIMERS, L. oxygen-deficientmarinebasinsand coastal upwellingregimes:preliminary report. Geology, 11,267-269. WOODCOCK, 1984. N.H. Early Palaeozoic sedimentation andtectonics in 5 Wales. Proceedings of the Geologists Association, 9 , 323-335. -. 1990. Sequence stratigraphy of the Welsh Basin. Journalthe of Geological Society, London, 141, 537-547.

References
ARCHER B. 1981. The Lower Palaeozoic rocks of the northwestern part of J. the Devilsbit-Keeper Hill inlier and their implications for the postulated course of the Iapetus suture zone in Ireland. Journal of Earth Sciences, Royal Dublin Society, 4, 21-38. BERRY, B. N. & BOUCOT, J. 1967. Pelecypod-graptoliteassociations in W. A. Society of America, Bulletin R, the old world Silurian. Geological 1515-1522. of some flysch deposits. Elsevier BOUMA, A. H. 1962. Sedimentology Amsterdam. BROMLEY, G . & EKDALE, A. 1984. Chondrites: a trace fossil indicator R. A. 2, of anoxia in sediments. Science 2 4 872-874. CAREY, L. & ROY,D. C. 1985. Deposition of laminated shale: a field and D. experimental study. Geo-Marine Letters, 5, 3-9. Sedimentary environments of the basinal Llandovery of CAVE,R. 1979. A. C. B. mid-Wales. I N HARRIS, L. HOLLAND, H. & LEAKE E. (eds) Caledonides ofthe British Isles-reviewed. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 8, 517-526. -& HAINS, A. 1986. Geology of the country between Aberystwyth and B. Machynlleth. Memoir, British Geological Survey, Sheet, 13 Her 6 majestys Stationery Office. CUMMINS, A. 1957. The Denbigh Grits: WenlockgreywackesinWales. W. Geological Magazine, 9 , 433-451. 4 - 1959a. The Nantglyn Flags: mid Salopian basin facies in Wales. Liverpool and Manchester Geological Journal, 2, 159-167. -. 1959b. The Lower Ludlow Grits in Wales. Liverpool andManchester Geological Journal 2, 168-179. D. Biogenic sedimentary fabrics CUOMO, M. C. & RHOADS, C. 1987. associated with pioneering polychaete assemblages: modern and ancient. Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, SI, 537-543. DIMBERLINE, J. 1987. ThesedimentologyanddiagenesisoftheWenlock A. turbidite system Wales, UK PhD thesis, University of Cambridge. - & WOODCOCK, H. 1987. The southeast margin of the Wenlock N. turbidite system, mid-Wales. Geological Journal, 2 , 61-71. 2 DRAKE, E., D. HATCHER, G . & KELLER, . H. 1978. Suspended P. G particulate matter and mud deposition in Upper Hudson submarine D. G.(eds) Sedimentation in canyon. In: STANLEY, J. & KELLING, submarine canyons, fansandtrenches. Dowden, Hutchinson and Ross, Stroudsburg, Pa., 33-41. W. DUNBAR, B. & BERGER, H. 1981. Fecal pellet flux to modern bottom R. sediment of Santa Barbara Basin (California) based on sediment trapping. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 92, 212-218. 1960. Thesea off southern California: A modernhabitat for EMERY, 0. K. petroleum. Wiley, New York. GILMER, W. 1972. Free-floating mucus webs: R. a novel feeding adaptation for the open ocean. Science, 176, 1239-1240. sediment origins, GORSELINE, S. 1984. A review of fine-grained D. D. characteristics, transport and deposition. In: STOW, A. V. & PIPER, D. J .W. (eds) Fine-grained sediments: deep-water processes and facies. Geological Society, London, Special Publication. 1 , 17-34. 5 J. & K. 1961. Stratification inrecent sediments of HULSEMANN, EMERY, 0. Santa Barbara basin as controlled by organisms and water characteristics. Journal of Geology, 69, 279-290. J. N. W. Wenlock HURST, M,,HANCOCK, J. & MCKERROW, S . 1978. stratigraphy and palaeogeography of Wales and the Welsh Borderland. Proceedings of the Geologists Association, 89, 197-226. C ISAACS, . M. 1984.Hemipelagic deposits in a Miocene basin, California: D. toward a model of lithologic variation and sequence. In: STOW, A. V. & PIPER, J. W. (eds) Fine-grained sediments: deep-water processes D. and facies. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 15,481-97. 0. JONES, T. 1954. The use of graptolites in geological mapping. Liverpool and Manchester Geological Journal, 1 246-260. , KEMP, E. S. 1985. The later Silurian sedimentary and tectonic evolution of A. the Southern Uplandr accretionary terrain. PhD thesis, University of Edinburgh. -. 1990. Mid-Silurian pelagic and hemipelagic sedimentation. Special

Received 15 May 1989; revised typescript accepted 10 December 1989.