Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Trevali Mining - Raymond James
Trevali Mining - Raymond James
Recommendation
We are maintaining our Outperform rating and are raising our target price to C$2.15 from C$2.05. We are increasing our P/NAV target multiple to 0.75x (prev. 0.70x) based on a reduction in the funding risk for Trevali following this financing announcement. We continue to recommend investors buy the shares of Trevali as it transitions to an operating mining company from a developer. Trevalis objective is to commence production in 2012 at both of its polymetallic mine projects: Halfmile in New Brunswick, and Santander in Peru. Mining has commenced from the uppermost portion of Halfmile and ore is being stockpiled at Xstratas nearby Brunswick 12 mill for processing in late 1Q12. Trevali intends to commission Santander in mid-2012. We expect to see an appreciation in the trading multiple as the company makes this progression.
Analysis
We believe that this announcement is positive for Trevali as it removes the companys near-term financing gap. The funds will be used to advance the Santander mine, and provide working capital facilities for the Halfmile mine. In our view this is also a very favourable endorsement for Trevali from the largest player in the zinc industry (Glencore). The moderately dilutive impact of the share issuance to our net asset value (NAV) estimate (refer to Exhibit 5), is partially offset by the recent changes to our near- to medium-term precious metals prices (see the Industry Comment published by our Precious Metals team on February 22, 2012 entitled Precious Metals: Fourth Quarter Preview & Reviewing Our Price Deck). Our revised NAV/share is C$2.87 (prev. C$2.91).
Valuation
Trevalis shares are trading at a P/NAV of 0.56x. Our target price of C$2.15 is based on a 0.75x multiple applied to our NAV of C$2.87 (in-line with risk and liquidity-adjusted historic developer and producer multiples).
EPS 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q Mar Jun Sep Dec 2010A C$(0.01) C$(0.01) C$(0.01) C$(0.02) 2011E (0.01)A (0.04)A (0.01)A (0.01) 2011E (0.01)A (0.04)A (0.01)A (0.01) 2012E (0.01) 0.00 0.02 0.04 2012E (0.02) 0.00 0.02 0.04 Full Year C$(0.06) (0.06) (0.06) 0.05 0.05 Revenues (mln) NA NA NA 58 57 NAV
NA NA 2.91 2.87
Please read domestic and foreign disclosure/risk information beginning on page 6 and Analyst Certification on page 7.
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
The agreements that Trevali has negotiated with Glencore and Xstrata have enabled it to position itself for near-term production, with minimal capital expenditure, at both of its mine development projects. We expect Xstratas Brunswick mine to be depleted in 2013, at which time we also anticipate that Xstrata will close its Brunswick 12 concentrator, thus bringing an end to the toll-milling agreement for Halfmile. In our base case analysis we assume that the closure of the Brunswick 12 mill will necessitate Trevali constructing its own dedicated concentrator to process ore from the HalfmileStratmat deposits. We have assumed a capital cost estimate for this facility of $136 million. In our view, the combination of Glencores equity investment in Trevali (signifying the strong relationship that these two companies share), and Glencores pending merger with Xstrata, has the potential to reduce this capital expenditure burden. We can envision two possible scenarios through which Trevali could benefit from a Glencore and Xstrata merger: 1) Glencore could retrofit the Brunswick 12 mill to a smaller throughput capacity (from 10,000 tonnes/day to 4,000 tonnes/day) and extend the tollmilling agreement; or 2) Glencore could sell the Brunswick 12 mill to Trevali, and Trevali could then refurbish and customize the mill to meet its requirements. In Exhibit 1 we outline the impact that these scenarios could have on our NAV estimate.
Capital Cost NAV % Change from ($ mln) ($/share) Base Case 135.6 2.87 N/A 0.0 3.14 9% 100.0 3.01 5% 50.0 3.21 12%
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
Feb-12 Dec-11
Dec-11
Dec-11
Oct-11
Purchased a 43.66% equity interest in Umcebo Mining Ltd., a private South African coal mining business. Umcebo has three thermal coal mines in operation and a stand-alone wash plant, with annual production of 7.2 million tonnes. PolyMet Equity CopperIncreased its equity stake in PolyMet Mining Corp. (POM-TSX) to 24.1% from ~16.4% Mining Corp. Nickel via a private placement. Through oustanding convertible debentures, warrants, and common share purchase agreements, Glencore can increase its stake to 35.1%. PolyMet owns the NorthMet copper-nickel-precious metals ore body and the large Erie Plant processing facility in the Mesabi Range mining district in northeastern Minnesota. Ironbark Convertible Zinc, Other Entered into a US$50 million convertible funding facility with Ironbark Zinc Ltd. (IBGZinc Debt Base Metals AU) to help fund Ironbark's growth acquisition strategy. Glencore also entered into an agreement for up to 55% of the production of concentrates from Ironbark's Citronen project, one of the world's largest undeveloped zinc deposits in northern Greenland. Glencore had an existing 12% equity interest in the company. Minara Resources Acquisition Nickel Acquired the remaining 27% of Minara Resources that Glencore did not already own. Minara operates the Murrin Murrin nickel-cobalt project in Western Australia, one of the world's largest and lowest cost nickel mines.
Equity
Coal
Oct-11
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
The breakdown of the changes to our model with respect to their impact our NAV estimate is shown in Exhibit 5. Exhibit 5: Net Asset Value Change Breakdown
Previous NAV Equity Raise / Share Dilution Gold / Silver Price Changes New NAV
Source: Raymond James Ltd.
Company Citations Company Name Glencore International Plc PolyMet Mining Corp. Xstrata
Currency
Closing Price
RJ Rating NC NC NC
RJ Entity
Notes: Prices are as of the most recent close on the indicated exchange and may not be in US$. See Disclosure section for rating definitions. Stocks that do not trade on a U.S. national exchange may not be approved for sale in all U.S. states. NC=not covered.
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
Analyst Information
Analyst Compensation: Equity research analysts and associates at Raymond James are compensated on a salary and bonus system. Several factors enter into the compensation determination for an analyst, including i) research quality and overall productivity, including success in rating stocks on an absolute basis and relative to the local exchange composite Index and/or a sector index, ii) recognition from institutional investors, iii) support effectiveness to the institutional and retail sales forces and traders, iv) commissions generated in stocks under coverage that are attributable to the analysts efforts, v) net revenues of the overall Equity Capital Markets Group, and vi) compensation levels for analysts at competing investment dealers. Analyst Stock Holdings: Effective September 2002, Raymond James equity research analysts and associates or members of their households are forbidden from investing in securities of companies covered by them. Analysts and associates are
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
permitted to hold long positions in the securities of companies they cover which were in place prior to September 2002 but are only permitted to sell those positions five days after the rating has been lowered to Underperform. The views expressed in this report accurately reflect the personal views of the analyst(s) covering the subject securities. No part of said person's compensation was, is, or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific recommendations or views contained in this research report. In addition, said analyst has not received compensation from any subject company in the last 12 months.
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
Growth (G) Low to average risk equities with sound financials, more consistent earnings growth, possibly a small dividend, and the potential for long-term price appreciation. Aggressive Growth (AG) Medium or higher risk equities of companies in fast growing and competitive industries, with less predictable earnings and acceptable, but possibly more leveraged balance sheets. High Risk (HR) Companies with less predictable earnings (or losses), rapidly changing market dynamics, financial and competitive issues, higher price volatility (beta), and risk of principal. Venture Risk (VR) Companies with a short or unprofitable operating history, limited or less predictable revenues, very high risk associated with success, and a substantial risk of principal.
Rating Distributions
Coverage Universe Rating Distribution RJL Strong Buy and Outperform (Buy) Market Perform (Hold) Underperform (Sell) 72% 28% 1% RJA 56% 38% 6% RJ LatAm 38% 56% 7% Investment Banking Distribution RJL 41% 29% 0% RJA 13% 5% 4% RJ LatAm 15% 3% 0%
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
Update Date
Closing Price
M $2.35 O2 M $2.25 O2
M $1.95 O2
M $2.05 O2
$1.60 $1.40 $1.20 $1.00 $0.80 $0.60 $0.40 $0.20 $0.00 O ct-12-09 O ct-11-10 Feb-01-10 Feb-25-11 O ct-20-11 Feb-02-12 Mar-02-09 Mar-30-09 Mar-01-10 Mar-29-10 May-25-09 May-24-10 Mar-25-11 May-20-11 Nov-09-09 Dec-07-09 Nov-08-10 Dec-04-10 Nov-15-11 Dec-14-11 Feb-28-12 A pr-27-09 A pr-26-10 A ug-17-09 S ep-14-09 A ug-16-10 S ep-13-10 A pr-22-11 A ug-02-11 A ug-27-11 S ep-23-11 Ju n-22-09 Ja n-04-10 Ju n-21-10 Ja n-01-11 Ja n-28-11 Ju n-11-11 Ja n-06-12 Ju l-20-09 Ju l-19-10 Ju l-07-11
Analyst Recommendations & 12 Month SB1: Strong Buy MO2: MP3: Market Perform MU4: NR : Not Rated R:
D ate: February 29 2012 P rice C overage Suspended R ating C hange Target P rice and R ating C hange Target P rice C hange Split Adjustm ent
Valuation Methodology: Our target price is based on a multiple applied to our NAV/share, and takes into account the risk and liquidity-adjusted historic producer multiples.
Risk Factors
General Risk Factors: Following are some general risk factors that pertain to the projected target prices included on Raymond James research: (1) Industry fundamentals with respect to customer demand or product / service pricing could change and adversely impact expected revenues and earnings; (2) Issues relating to major competitors or market shares or new product expectations could change investor attitudes toward the sector or this stock; (3) Unforeseen developments with respect to the management, financial condition or accounting policies or practices could alter the prospective valuation. Risks - Trevali Mining Corporation Mining companies are subject to a range of risks, including, but not limited to: environmental risk, political risk, operational risk, financial risk, hedging risk, commodity price fluctuation risk, and currency risk. Any difference between our metal price forecasts and realized metal prices will likely have an impact on our earnings and valuation estimates for the mining companies in our research coverage universe. The operation of mines, and mills is complex and is exposed to a number of risks, most of which are beyond the companys control. These include: environmental compliance issues; personal accidents; metallurgical/other processing problems; unexpected rock formations; ground or slope failures; flooding or fires; earthquakes; rock bursts; equipment failures; consultant errors and, interruption due to inclement, weather conditions, road closures, and/or local protests. Other risks include, but are not limited to: uncertainties surrounding reclamation costs; aging equipment and facilities which could lead to increased costs; strikes; and, transportation disruptions. Additional Risk and Disclosure information, as well as more information on the Raymond James rating system and suitability categories, is available for Raymond James at rjcapitalmarkets.com/SearchForDisclosures_main.asp and for Raymond James Limited at www.raymondjames.ca/researchdisclosures.
International Disclosures
For clients in the United States: Investing in securities of issuers organized outside of the U.S., including ADRs, may entail certain risks. The securities of non-U.S. issuers may not be registered with, nor be subject to the reporting requirements of, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. There may be limited information available on such securities. Investors who have received this report may be prohibited in certain states or other jurisdictions from purchasing the securities mentioned in this report. Please ask your Financial Advisor for additional details.
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2
Rating 2 2 2 2 2
Raymond James Ltd. is not a U.S. broker-dealer and therefore is not governed by U.S. laws, rules or regulations applicable to U.S. broker-dealers. Consequently, the persons responsible for the content of this publication are not licensed in the U.S. as research analysts in accordance with applicable rules promulgated by the U.S. Self Regulatory Organizations. Any U.S. Institutional Investor wishing to effect trades in any security should contact Raymond James (USA) Ltd., a U.S. broker-dealer affiliate of Raymond James Ltd. For clients in the United Kingdom: For clients of Raymond James & Associates (RJA) and Raymond James Financial International, Ltd. (RJFI): This report is for distribution only to persons who fall within Articles 19 or Article 49(2) of the Financial Services and Markets Act (Financial Promotion) Order 2000 as investment professionals and may not be distributed to, or relied upon, by any other person. For clients of Raymond James Investment Services, Ltd.: This report is intended only for clients in receipt of Raymond James Investment Services, Ltd.s Terms of Business or others to whom it may be lawfully submitted. For purposes of the Financial Services Authority requirements, this research report is classified as objective with respect to conflict of interest management. RJA, Raymond James Financial International, Ltd., and Raymond James Investment Services, Ltd. are authorized and regulated in the U.K. by the Financial Services Authority. For institutional clients in the European Economic Area (EEA) outside of the United Kingdom: This document (and any attachments or exhibits hereto) is intended only for EEA institutional clients or others to whom it may lawfully be submitted. Proprietary Rights Notice: By accepting a copy of this report, you acknowledge and agree as follows: This report is provided to clients of Raymond James only for your personal, noncommercial use. Except as expressly authorized by Raymond James, you may not copy, reproduce, transmit, sell, display, distribute, publish, broadcast, circulate, modify, disseminate or commercially exploit the information contained in this report, in printed, electronic or any other form, in any manner, without the prior express written consent of Raymond James. You also agree not to use the information provided in this report for any unlawful purpose.
This is RJA client releasable research
This report and its contents are the property of Raymond James and are protected by applicable copyright, trade secret or other intellectual property laws (of the United States and other countries). United States law, 17 U.S.C. Sec.501 et seq, provides for civil and criminal penalties for copyright infringement. Additional information is available upon request. This document may not be reprinted without permission. RJL is a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund. 2012 Raymond James Ltd.
Raymond James Ltd. | 2200 925 West Georgia Street | Vancouver BC Canada V6C 3L2