Khit Maung Vol 1 No 2

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 66

+ , , ,

/
0 0







, 4 +,



5 6

, + ,
,

,







+



+
,
: + ,

+


+

+
,

:


+
+
,


+ ,






+
+
,



+



,



+


+







+

; :


0 ; :
+ ,
+








+ ,

0 0






,

,




,




+


,



+
,





, Enlightenment 6
,



,




+

+






,
,



,




+


:




:








0 6








0



0

0 I
+


I ++




0 / 6

0
+ ,
,







0 0






I




+ 00 + ,
+



M ()
The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized
community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others.



0




b


c d

+ , +




0





,





+ ,










www.khitmaung.com

,

0

- editors@khitmaung.com

/

+



,
,

RACISM +

10

10

0

+

12

14

18

18

19

6 (
(
)

19

22


(Ethnocentrism)

22

,



M

25

Stereotype
Stereotype 6d

28

30

44

+


+

44

48

55

+
v


;+

55

58

58

60


: ;

60

64

65

65







/ 0


M

6 ;



, M





;


(

)





+


???
.. ??? (

)




() +



d
0I
5

0
!!!
=0

;

0 M



0








:






0
0
0






0

0




Problem child 0
; 6 0
: 0
0
0
I ()
0
0





0
0
5: 0
5: 0



0

+
5:





+
(
)
0
u u 0



6

M




+ +


:+

: :

:+

M

( )



0


0 ''


::


6




I

,


( )

M M




M

6

+4



+0






M





0 0 0




,



+









I
x


//

+

,

,

; /

, ;, 0 ,



,
,




/



5:
M






c






0





,
56




0

++


(. +. )



,
,
Ja Maran



, + Basch


+




7


6 I








5d



d
0





(nation)


(nation-state)
t


+

Deterritorialization











(nation-state)

+
Deterritorialization



(nation-state)




(Appadurai)




+

6



(
..)




,


+


: :




5





+ ,





(ethical)


, +
, (minority)

(
)
+


,

/
,
(immigration)



(capital)




50 decolonization
6




, (lowland civilization)

6 (upland
societies) :+
6 d



0 6
,


+
6
0


+

/ James Scott


,
,



+ 0



(nation)

6

+
+


Karin Dean

/ La Raw Maran

Dean ,
(geography and legitimacy) +

Dean












(



6 ,)

, (ethnicity)


,
(



(state

nationalism)







+0


0










-





+
( )






0


0






0



state-nationalism

+)

homeland




homeland territories








+



Anurachal Pradesh

(KIA)






,
,





,


, ,
Cohen


0 :
+



(KIA)

,


,
,

nation






0

(nation-state)



,
c 0


+
+



,

0



Karin
Dean

states. Basel, Switzerland : Gordon and


Breach.
Cohen, Robin. (1997) Global diasporas :An
Introduction. London : UCL Press.
Dean, Karin - (2005) "Spaces, and territorialities on
the Sino-Burmese boundary: China.


(Kachin political culture)
LaRaw Maran ,


,
+









,





, 6
,
+



/

(conflict
engagement)

++

(enduring engagement) /





++







6



6


LaRaw
Maran











+








0
6
;







, (institutions inside
Kachin social system)


+
La Raw Maran



,

+

Appadurai, Arjun (1996). Modernity At Large:
Cultural Dimensions of Globalization.
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Basch,
Linda
G
et.al
(1994)
Nations
unbound :transnational projects, postcolonial
predicaments, and deterritorialized nation9

Racism +

Racism
..
..

+
0
0

racism ,
, 6

+


+

+
v


0



racism



I
racism
monkey chant
0 racism
,






..


racism














,
zero tolerance 6
0





, + 0

..




0





, 0 0


racism






+


,

0 +





:



+

racism + +

+



https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=racism&hl
=en&prmd=imvnsub&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=u
niv&sa=X&ei=wP_kT72OoTw8QPPueyiCg&sqi=2&ved=0CIMBELAE&bi
w=1600&bih=771
http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio1/advice/factfile_az
/racism
http://www.goal.com/en/news/9/england/2012/
06/22/3193281/liverpool-monkey-gesture-fanfound-guilty-of-racism-offence
http://www.unitedhumanrights.org/genocide/g
enocide_in_rwanda.htm
http://www.un.org/en/events/racialdiscriminati
onday/
http://www.theholocaustexplained.org/?gclid=
CN2ih8SA47ACFdKBfAod-CwM1g




+











International Institute for
Strategic Studies (IISS) 6 0





- /

think tank
10



:
:
IISS

,
,


IISS


0
, 6 0







+
0




Charity



+



I
- :
v


Manama Dialogue





d


: Liang Guanglie



:







:


d


, +




,



,
;

0 IISS
,



: d

:


: d









+ -












;






+



:


6,







: Leon Panetta

,


, 0





,


; 0 :


6
d

00

Anti-access








area denial






,



,


A2/AD

v :

v

6


















+ A2/AD


0
0
,

,


++

Joint


Operational

, 0

, +
,

Access Concept

(JOAC)
0

v

v

, 0+

v
AirSea Battle
Leon Panetta +
JOAC

v


-


0

:



:
v

- d

Cam Ranh Bay



, 0

, +
:

,

0
I





v









+
+

0

6 0 ,

0


,

0

0






6
0
counter
,

insurgency campaigns 6


Gold Cobra 6







,




+



I
:



:



+



anti



access/area denial (A2/AD)






:


11


Ref:
Military strategy: The China syndrome
Military diplomacy: Not so warm and fuzzy,
The Economist, June 9th-15th 2012

0 5


d

0 Chinese are coming







0 5d

+ +
+
++





+


0

+ d




0 + ,






0




0






:

:


+




comprehensive defence
review critical region
66 ,


+ +




0,
,


0
12

+
0 +


:




0

0
pacific power

:



0 rebalancing
,
bb





bb

00
+


,


d





,
I +


:



0



+

0 +




rotational deployment


++ 0



0


: +

,





,


0





,



,
c









0
c







+

I
I





, 0


0


0


:

M



, 0
,
0




,
d




+0 d

)



0 +




6

6 +


+ :


:






6



:










:








+ ++



, 0

0





6

,





+
++

) treaty allies

,


:

(
:, ,





d
13



5
6








0

0

,


,

0

,





:



:
:
0














0







+

t


::


;


, 0




+0















I


,





+

() +

http://www.whitehouse.gov/the


press-office/2012/01/05/remarks-president-defensestrategic-review
14

()

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o318z54rHTU

,

http://www.defense.gov/news/newsarticle.aspx?id=
116591
,


()


v



+


+


+



0
;


+0





,:

M
+

0

d


0


0 +0




0 ::








/ :

0
0



+








+


0 0



0
/
0


/




0

/





++




+


6



6



15


/


, 0
/

:06
b


/


+
6


6

/
:


,



+









+

I +



:
b





4

0
+0




,

,


4
,
: 0





+











4





0






0


0 +



0

I

+0 I





0 6

+ 0

+
,



: 0



:

,

+



0

c




+
I

4

,

:
0





I




0
+

0 ,


, +




v

v
I


16

0 +

:
M+
v


+
c


00



v

0

v
c
v




c


v




c +

+
v



0 +,

v
+

+
+


0



,








:


6

+ :

0
:







0



/ +

,



M

:
0

:


+ :



6


0









0




/





0

0 :




:


;

c ,
0


c

0



17

/ 0


0

+
+

v
c +






0

+



++

/






c




v


v
c



c

c


v v, 0





v +




/




/

+


:


0 6








0 +0

/


+


+



:
0











+:





:
6 :
:
+










18




:
b










d

++ +


0
d 6







:








: +







:




+












6

+

+
+












d







,





:

0

+
+








:



6







+ ,6


, 6
,





+

+


:




;+

;


6 :
:





+


+






5




+
+:




+0 u
:

6 ()
0



,


+
,
+,




,
+





,

0


0
,

,


, +




0


,



+ (+




, ) +

,

,






b +


,
,
6









u 6
+

,
u6

,
u

u
6


+

19


u







0
:


,

+ +
0


6



6

: ()




+



u
+
5
+



u
+

u


,


:0

,
0

t
u

,









u



+0



:
u




,
u




20

0




,





0

0
u

,





, d
v

+


0


d

v



u
u +





+


+
(


u) +









0


+






+
+





:

(


+ , (), 6 0





u






+



6 0
6


,
6


, ) 6

+




+




+



6
u


+
u

t

+

,



+












u







;

(a colony of souls)




+



+
+

;


0

+
+

;
+


6



+





+

,
+


b :6



+

,

,
0+



()
6

6
6




+
6




()

+

(



)
,




()

+ (idealist)


,
6+ u 0

+
+0

u +


+



() u

b;



21




(

)
6









+
0
0




+



u

:
0



u




0






+ ,

(

) 6


,



,



;
0




d v



+

+








,
0 (
)


:








+


0

:

;


: :

0

6




22





0


: +












+
:
t :
,



;

+
+ +

+


d
6

:




,

0
6
,




() u
,


(Ethnocentrism)
0

,

0

v
Ethno
(

,
)
Centric ( )

,




/



,
+

+
/
:

- :


4
M


M

6



,



+

+
/ ,

5


,
,
( )




6 0

+

6
,






6 ,

,

+










0






23








+
,




M 0








60


:







6


t : (NAS)





(Oxytocin Hormone)




4









,

6 (
)


,


,
,
(Favouritism) 6





- v

Barbarian (+)

0 ,

, 0


d

Barbars

t
0





66
,

6
(Eskimo)



t 0






,
+


6
6





60


6



,





0
+




, +

Hatred) 6




-
,


+


+
(Personal









Space)




d




,

,




(Patriotism)




,

;

( )

,

+


+
( )














+

,







6+ ()
(Personal Space)





0
,

+





0


5




0

,


,



60 ()









6
( )


0

6

;
,

, ( )


,






+ / (Ethnic Conflicts)


0


,

(Culture

() :
Clashes)
(Racial


+




24


()
,






()




0 +




+


:







() +




() +
























: (Racial Supremacism)

: ()

0



,
/


:






;, 0







(Peaceful Co-Existence)

+ 4

(Self-Determination)


()



;
0
,






,
,


25






,
,

,



:









:

:
, 6

0 () 5
0





,

+


Ref:
Collected Psychology articles (in Burmese) by
Dr. Myint Lwin (Psyco), 2004.
De Dreu, Carsten K. W., "Oxytocin promotes
human ethnocentrism," Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, Jan. 10, 2011.
Kaplan, Lawrence, "Inuit or Eskimo: Which
names to use?". Alaska Native Language Center,
University of Alaska Fairbanks, 2002.
Justin Marozzi, The Way of Herodotus:
Travels with the Man who Invented History, 2010,
pages 311315.

,



M

d

, 0


;
00




,
6 ,

,
6

M,

Newsweek


+

5

5



,
6

+
,

5
, ;

+,

Newsweek




,
+,




+

Women will rule the world
+ 5





/



,





,
0




,

feminized

,

(stereotypes)


5


,
,



Stereotype
GDP


,

t

( )


0






,

,
M


+
,

, ;

: , 6
0 ,
0





GDP

:


,

x
,


: ( )

;



,

+
:


,

Millenium Development Goal

5
, ;



5:



;,
0

6





+

26


6

;

, M

M



,



+
+

( )

, ,









; , +




0
+



,
,




(






)
:

I


M

M (
)




0
(
)







;
M (
)

+

,
+





+

6
+
6


27





t
+


0

,
I 0






6

,


t


0


M

: :







:

0
;, 56


,


, 0
,

Ref: I think women are really going to


shake up the workplace over the next 15 years,
says Koehn. This is just the beginning of a
tsunami of changeand its far bigger than any
single organization. Or any single nation. If weve
just come through a mancession, then the
recovery, it seems, will be feminized. Women will
rule the world, Newsweek, 2010



;
http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2010/07/
06/women-will-rule-the-world.html
Closing the gap, The Economist, 2011


Stereotype
6d

()


++




.....



stereotype
+




+

+


:


b

()
Stereotype



Stereotype
+

...















...






5 :


28

()



stereotype
Facebook
+
Mark Zuckerberg
Facebook 0

+


b
()




66


;

( )




,





0
+
- -

0






0



6+



6



00

v

+ v

...



Racists
+ 0

6


+
[



]

+ +






:6

+



:6
0
...

...




5:

;
;

6

5: 6 56



:6

56


5
: M


:6

5
: M




5
:

M


0



56



/
+




++
00

0



+


0



/


c +

: + ,

/ 0 0





0




/
+



/
/
0


/
,

,




/


+
()

6 +0
0

b


5









()

+
+

NGO

+
0


:6

29


+ d







0 6d







6d : ;



..6d





+
6







6
d
6 6



()


+



+

:




Gay
Gay +



c
+


b
0


+

0 Gay
Gay rights

0
...





+

30


,

()



0




Debate

Comment
Comment

,

+

6 +


. . .







. .

(
)
0

,



(Nation State)




0


+

, + v




0
,






b
,
0



0



5




; 5


+
5
6




0 M


:


0


00 +

5 6

0



, ;





0
, ;, ,






+
0



,




b





M









b
;




, ;


6

()

M

31

+






,
;
M




M













0







b

d


I





:




0



0
+

























M
,


M
0

M

0
M


M
d




;
;
+



0

+

:


5


0
: 56



:











.






0
5




+ 0







0

+

0
,



0

+






+




,



+

+
b




,








6




+



b

:




+

+


+0
+

d

+








d
M


;





;

0











0




M 0


0











+








,



;
,


0 ,





32








+0










+








0












;
0




( )




+ 0





,

; ;+


+0







,
d




,


0






0

6

M

6


6




(Unitary Stystem)





:


v

;






/




33


0, 0
, 6


0






:












d
+ 0


d
+








d
d



:+ d




:





d


+


0
0
,


:










+



+
u





+

:




I 6

; +

+
v




















+ :


:

+

,
,


,







,








: ,




+ 0 , ;

; ;


0 , ;
34


0 ,


+

I













+






,




, 0
, 6


(Federal
(Federal System)


d
0






+





0




+ +




+


+





v /
6
()
:
() (




)
()


,


0 (


)


I


()







:





;











;
+







:

()





d+ +

0






+







()



+


,






I



,






d


+




d

d

35

d

d






d



d

( )







+



;

d




+


+







,

,


,



+



5


:

+
5




+







I

,





5
:
0 0


:
5










5


:





0 :


d ;


+

+
6





+










+ +,





d

d
d

36


b
:
M






b
:

:

+ M






;
()


+


+
;


:






+
;










0
;





,+





66


66
6

M













(Regions)



( ) (states)








(State)
66


+


+

6


: 66










66

37



:






5






66



:








;


:+

0



:



v


,


+
()




: () :





, 66

x:

b6







,






+


0
,

b

,

38




,

;

;



:

I




:

: d





:

,

x


4

:
:






0









:

: :

: d



4

4
:






:

b



: :
:






:

:



+

:



:

()



x
4

0




:

:


+
:
:


x:()





, 0



;



:
d

, 6







6
:
:






b


+

0








;

:
39

0
+

0





( )

;
0

,
:+



+
:






,


+d

6



I


0 b
6 +d







:
(v) (
)

:, +






:

5






x

; x


0


+ +





x


+








0

:





()

:

()
()
+

x0


x +


+
:


,






( )

,



0
: ;





I 6




:




() ()
40

; ( )
0
:





;
+0


:



,

;

6
+









0
,



+

: ,
6




0










,


;





,
+
:


I




b
+ +, ,






( )









0

+

,
6




6




0


()
5




:

+



5


:








+

0,










0









+

+



0
0



()

( )



() () ()
:


66 () ( )

:()





41

()
()( )


:()d
:

() () ( )


: ():

() () ( )
:
():


x


()



+ .0



M
()
:







;0






6






+


,

M

() x


x0




: +
M ()
:
+


0








M




0

0






+ +

0

+



0

+


+

0




0


+
0
+

+
0


0


: ;


, +

42




6


+

6








;








;





()





: :
:

0

:
()


()

()



;



c




+

0

()

c


+ I



I
+




+
+



()






+ +

:





,
+





:
,

0




,

+


,


M

+


;
+

() +



,

d ,


0
+ +

0 M




43



++



;





+ b




0







0



()


()


+
0


( )+



()





()

5

50

+



0






(


) 0 :



()

+ 0
:

5

0 0 0

0
: (


)










6








6


; 0



M ( )0

0



0





Ref: 5



(
+)
World Constitutions: A Comparative
Study (Vishnoo Bhagwah & Vidya Bhushan)


Local Government












M
M



0
M

M
M

M


M


0
M


t
+



+
(

) -
0




6/





6


0


I



, ;,



0








)

6 +



+
,

+




44




0 , 6 0



+

0





,

+,
+0




6

,







6

+
, d


,

00


0


,
,

/

, +


+
+0


+ 6,



+ 0

+

:
;+


:

6


/
:




,

,








+


45



+





+
, +


(Terrell
Carver)

(Jerry Cohen) M
( Jon
Pike) (Rajeev Sehgal)

+











+


;



6


(Benedetto Croce)
6

0
0


0
0


0



0

0 6
c

?



+











d


;















+





0,
:
v


: (

) 00
+



6 +






/


+



: , 0



:+
+


,





(















,
, :




:
0



0



,



5

46

::
0


;
+





:,

:




,
00




+0

,
M


,




d

,


,


,
, 0



,




,

,
,
t

, 6




, ,




( )



+: +




(+






+ )



0 +



+

:+

0
,




(




0

) 0




6
0 : d


,




+


6


6


;,







: 6


+
+

0 +

+
0

0


,







+


+

d
( )

;









,

47


0
,
6
+
,



: 6



0

,



6



0
,
:


;


,
,





0
,
00
0

+
5


:

, + 6





, +


0




0
0









+
0

;+


,
0


;
;
,

,


00

+


0

,

,




0

0
0







0
,


:


+

+






(

)

, 6


+


0

,











0



+

I


+




0

,






/

+


+

+
+
48

,

,



+

;+







,


, ,




;
,







;









, :



,+


+


;
+


0 +
+
;





;
+ +



: +



:
,


,

+
,
:
+
, 6
+
, ;




+



;

49

,
+


0
+

+ ;+
+

:


,





,


,
, 0

,









;





b


(Alexis
de
Tocqueville)
( )








+

:







(Crane Brinton)


,
,


,

,





( Eric R. Wolf)
0







0


;
,
6










()
,
+

:+
0




6



,








0

, 0 ,







0

,



, ; +







+


0 ,
6
0




, +



,

, +






6










+
0








(Samuel P.
Huntington)





,

t

;





0



0
:
50








,
;


00




,


/ 0



0

:

:;:

:

:


0

+







+
0


0
;





+
0

:+ 6 0 0
;

,

; ,

,






+
;





0



;





, 6
0
;

+/
+
,
0

0


I










6
6
,




0 ,+

+



0








c

+


...



,
51

+;

0







,
0


d
,


x




M+




,
6,

t



x


+


(James Billington)


6
,





0
0 ;





;




0


;
6
,












6




, 0
6 ,
0












,


+








( )
6
6

+
+









0 I

: 0 ;
0


+







,


6

+


+



/


,
+


+




,


0
6

,
/








6,








(The
Anatomy
of
Revolution)



52

d+
+

,

,

,





,
+


++



+





,






(Thermidor)6

+
, 0



+


,



+

53








,



;



;








0


0




v


0



, +
( )
v


( )

0



0
,

0

d

:+
0
;


0 0
,
+




0
;





,


+
0
;

0
; :



+ 0




0


d

; ,






:: +


+





, ;
,


+

::





,+
;



,
0











++
, 6
+
0
;





0
+











;



0

+



0
+


,

,
54




,

+
+






0




+



4






0





+






,
,
:



, +







+
0


:










, 6


;

,



0
+



0


6

: 6

,


+ +






dd 0

;,

0:



:




+ ,
6
,
,
;




0
+
, 0
,

/

, :




5




55

+
+ (0
;)


,








+0

00





,


;


0


;


Ref: Chapter 17 Political Violence (Political
Science: an introduction 11th Edition Michael
G. Roskin, Robert L.Cord, James A. Medeiros,
Walter S. Jones)

u
+

v


;+


+ : 6


:

M


0

: M M

: ,







++






I





6

5 :
+ M








56



:


M



: 0 :








,







0


+
+




+


++


0
+ M

56





+:





6


:
6

M 6
M
:

:
:




: 0

+


+ :

:
57

c




I 0

0




:


0
:
0



,


+


0
0 6







+0

+
+

I+


M


0
d
M 0
M
M

0
+




0 d M

0




+6

:



0



0
M

M 0

58


6
0


b 0









0

0












;

0 d


+ d




6 +
d











+ 0

+ d


0

+ 0 b
d

M



0


+


I+
+




6

6
,




0



+
0 M



0 d


+
M
M


5

M 5


5

M


+
M d

I+
6




+



I + 00
,:
d


M

I
+



M



I

I M
M

b







0 M



+
/ /


b


M

+

+

59

+ 0


0 ;
0




M
0 M
+


M d



0 6

,
0


6




6


+:

0
M

+


6 ;


M

-

;
-





M


M


M M


,
0







6

d







M
:



0






+ d +





d

I ,


M
+

I
M

M




0
M

+

I
6






d M





+

/
M

M d 0




d I


+





:

M




M M










0





M I+

I

+
d


6

6
M





:
M




60

0
+0



bb



0
Geeta Jensen A
Good
Country

http://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/issues/200
3/05/jensen.htm



:
;


(


:
Prisoner
of
the
State


:


0

: 0

+ 0


:
+

+

+ 0


,

6
, +
+









0

+ :




; : +






+


;

0 Prisoner of the State







,
Bao Pu
Renee
Chaing Adi Ignatius
0





0



)
()
,
,0







(
) M ( )
:














;




+

0
M

() :
u

M

0 0 (

61

-
0

+
)





,
,:
d

+


()


0()

+





,
,

0

+
,
,
0

,








,+
+ +


,
,
0 0
0


: ( )
0 + M
0

:



+



6+



0 0
+



+ + +
:

,
,
+
,






:
+




: 0


0 ()






+





:





d


I
0
+
+ ,

,



+


6
0
+

+

0
x
;


,



,



,

0



+
6
()()








0

;
b

+
+ 0









,
0

6
0




:
(


)



M



,
,

+


,



+





0


)
M +



,
,

(Anti-Bourgeois Liberalization Campaign)
c



:+ 0 +
( )



0


M+


62


M
, ; :


0 M
()




00
,
,
,


6

0


(



, +



0


M



0 0
0 ,




0)
, ;


0



,



, 0










,
+ +



c


( )



M + (:)
6 0
0



6




+ 0







M

() 0
63


0()



M



()

M

()


00 M



+

()



0


6 0
6

M

0

M


;

0



:
+0

M
(6
0
)


I 0


0 6

0
M

+






+0




6

0



M




6
0

..


v


++ Geoff Wade







0
+
0
;



0
;


6








,
,


+




0




(0
;) 0 0
6


bb



0
;


:
(

v
M )


0
,

0
;

, 0



0

+ 0 0





0
,
6



+d ,










+,

0



0


+
+ 0




0



64






: ,
,

,
,


+

,
,



+
,
,






0


+ 0

0
,

0 ,
+

+




+



4

6


6 0
,

;





:

South
East Asian Treaty Organization (SEATO)



6







0



+

0
+

0 +














0





/


+ +


6

Ruth McVey
,
,


,



,
,
0
,




,

0

0
+
+

revisionist
theory


:

0 +





+
+

+
0 +0 +





, + +


0 +0
+
South East Asian
Studies


Geoff Wade, The beginnings of a Cold
War in Southeast Asia: British and
Australian perceptions, pp. 543-565
McVey (Ruth McVey, The Calcutta
Conference and the South-East Asia
uprisings (Ithaca, New York: Cornell
Univeristy, 1958) in The origins of the
Southeast Asian Cold War by Karl
Hack and Geoff Wade, pp. 441-448

+





:

George Fujii, Tuong Vu and Wasana


Wongsurawat (eds.) (2009) Dynamics of the Cold
War in Asia: Ideology, Identity, and Culture. New
York: Palgrave MacMillan
http://www.hnet.org/~diplo/roundtables/PDF/Roundtable-XII7.pdf

0 :
:

+

65


+ :


0 +



+

:
0




+

:

:

0
u








+


/ /



+


:




+: :










+

66

You might also like