Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AA Effectiveness - Faith Meets Science
AA Effectiveness - Faith Meets Science
Lee Ann Kaskutas, Dr.P.H. Alcohol Research Group, Emeryville, CA School of Public Health, UC Berkeley
East Bay Community Recovery Project
June 26, 2007 Oakland, California
Perspectives on AA Effectiveness
AA members: I know AA works and there is no need for research to prove that
Perspectives on AA Effectiveness
AA members: I know AA works and there is no need for research to prove that AA critics: AA is a cult that relies on God as mechanism of action
Perspectives on AA Effectiveness
AA members: I know AA works and there is no need for research to prove that AA critics: AA is a cult that relies on God as mechanism of action Cochrane Review: no experimental evidence of effectiveness
Perspectives on AA Effectiveness
AA members: I know AA works and there is no need for research to prove that AA critics: AA is a cult that relies on God as mechanism of action Cochrane Review: no experimental evidence of effectiveness Moos: first send people to AA, not treatment
% abstinent
at 1 yr. at 18 mos.
no AA
Ouimette et al., J Stud Alcohol 1998 Thurstin et al., Int J Addict 1987
% abstinent at 2 yrs
meetings
Moos & Moos, J Clin Psychol 2006 Also see Moos & Moos, JSAT 2004
AA meeting trajectories
250
# of AA meetings, pst yr
% abstinent
3 years
5 years
Kaskutas et al., ACER 2005
% abstinent
50 40 30 20 10 0 1 year
a
3 years
8 years
aMale
VA inpatients n = 3018
bPreviously
Ouimette et al., J Stud Alcohol 1998 b Timko et al., J Stud Alcohol 2000
5 4 3 2 1 0
formal tx only
NESARC; dependent n = 4422 Tx n=239
12-step only
12-step n=138 both n=829
12-step + tx
nothing n=3217
significant
Abstinence at 10 years
Inpatients n=158
AA involvement
mos. 1-6
12-step activities
mos. 1-3
Cocaine-dependent outpatients in 6-month treatment program n = 336 Weiss et al., Drug Alcohol Depen 2005
What about increasing what you do? Increasing attendance from one month to the next: no effect Increasing participation from one month to the next: affected drug use the next month
% abstinent at 2 yrs
Alcohol abusers + EAP referred n = 227: n=73 hospital; n=83 AA; n=71 choice
3-yr follow-up
p < .007 PMRG, J Stud Alcohol 1997 PMRG, ACER 1998
Motiv
Cog Beh
.4
.4
.3
.3
.2
.2
.1
.1
0.0
0.0
Intake
15 Month
Intake
15 Month
Outpatient*
Project MATCH *n = 952 Outpatients, **n = 774 Aftercare
Aftercare**
Tonigan et al., Tx Match Alcohol 2003
Motivation AA involvement
negative
Alcohol problems
Psychopathology
Solution
Drink refusal skills Emergency planning Choose alternative behavior
Theory
Cognitive Behavioral Social Learning
environmental cues
See others succeed Self-efficacy Better role models Address needs
Drink due to unmet needs/ psych. states Drink due to spiritual condition
Psychodynamic
mood
Spiritual awakening
Solution
Drugs
Theory
Genetic Neurobiology
Drugs
alternative
What you do Place to go instead of bar Talk about your problems What you hear Others had similar experiences Ways people coped instead of drinking
alternative
What you do Place to go instead of bar Talk about your problems What you hear Others had similar experiences Ways people coped instead of drinking What happens Your mood changes Dont drink a day at a time
alternative
Friendship Adds sober people supportive of your abstinence Role models of new behavior Helps learn how to have fun sober alternative
Friendship Adds sober people supportive of your abstinence Role models of new behavior Helps learn how to have fun sober alternative Sponsorship Someone to call emerg plan Someone to provide emotional support
need
Change how you treat others, or you will drink Personal inventory; amends
need
Change how you treat others, or you will drink Personal inventory; amends Key to sobriety is helping others Helping gets you to relinquish negative self focus
need
mood
Self-efficacy*
Coping skills**
*1Morgenstern et al., J Consult Clin Psych 1997 *2Kelly et al., J Stud Alcohol 2002 **1Timko et al., ACER 2005 **2 male VA inpatients 2Humphreys et al., Ann Behav Med 1999 ** n=2,337
*2
Abstinence
*Kaskutas et al., Addiction 2002 **Humphreys et al., Ann Behav Med 1999 Timko et al., ACER 2005 Bond et al., J Stud Alcohol 2003
Life meaning*
*White & Laudet, CPDD 2006 **Kelly et al., J Stud Alcohol 2002
Spiritual awakening
Day Hosp & Residential, managed care n = 537
Summary
Effectiveness
AA involvement is associated with abstinence
at 1 month, 6 months, 1 yr, 3 yrs, 5 yrs, and 10 yrs after treatment At 1 yr, 8 yrs, and 16 yrs after seek help
Summary (contd)
What matters most about AA?
Weekly attendance Increasing AA activities early on Having, being a sponsor Doing service Working the steps
Summary (contd)
What are some key mechanisms of action for AA?
Changing social networks Improving coping skills Having confidence you can resist a drink Having meaning in ones life
Getting People to AA
Systematic encouragement & community access vs. standard referral to AA*
100% of the encouragement group attended within the week and continued to attend over next 4 weeks None of the standard referral group attended
Getting People to AA
(continued)
AA attendance between recruitment and year after treatment was higher for TSF patients
81% of TSF outpatients, half of CBT & MET outpatients 95% of TSF aftercare patients, over 80% of the CBT & MET aftercare patients
Overall
More involved in AA/NA, had sponsor, did service
MATCH Research Group, JSA 1997 MATCH Research Group, ACER 1998 CSAT, Substance abuse treatment: Group Therapy 2005 4 Weiss, et al., Harvard Review of Psychiatry 2004
2 Project
1 Project
Goal of MAAEZ
To prepare clients to engage in the culture of AA/NA/CA
Making it easier to connect with AA members
Changing social networks is a mechanism of AAs effect on abstinence 5,6
et al, Addiction 2002 et al, JSA 2003 7 Riessman, Social Policy 1976 8 Zemore, Southern Medical Journal, 2007 9 Alcoholics Anonymous, 1939
6 Bond
5 Kaskutas
Structure of MAAEZ
6 sessions
Run by counselors experienced in running groups, who are in recovery and active in a 12-step program 90 minutes each
Manualized session outline
Indicates when to open it up for discussion Provides time guidelines for each point in the session
10-minute break 5 minute summary: what are the take-home messages? 5 minutes to assign homework
Action Reading from Big Book or Living Sober or Sponsorship Pamphlet
Intro session
First and Last session attended Programs must run an intro session every week
For newcomers and graduates
4 core sessions
Spirituality, sponsorship, principles not personalities, living sober
Attended in any order
Introduction
Counselor and client introduction Layout of MAAEZ intervention Graduate vignettes of their AA and MAAEZ experience Why go to AA? Were you going to AA when you relapsed? How do you pick a meeting?
Meeting directories are passed-out
Spirituality
Why is spirituality necessary for recovery? AA is spiritual, not religious program
Things to think about when you hear God as we understood Him
Spirituality in AA
Its about your behavior and taking responsibility for it
Act your way into good thinking Get outside yourself; do service
Homework
Talk to someone at a meeting who you dont know, who has more sobriety than you
Homework
Ask someone you dont know at meeting, for their phone # Telephone them (and talk to them) before next session
Sponsorship
What is a sponsor? Why get one? Who should you ask?
Youre not imposing
Conclusions
How can treatment increase AA engagement?
Encouraging attendance at 3 meetings per week Providing opportunities for patients to help one another Introducing the AA concepts of acceptance and surrender Demonstrating the benefits of the AA fellowship
Implications
Move beyond requiring meeting attendance
Prepare clients for dealing with the philosophy of AA and the people in AA
AA Acknowledgements
NIAAA grants
R01 AA 11279 (Kaskutas, PI) R21 AA 13066 (Kaskutas, PI) R01 AA 14688 (Kaskutas, PI) R01 AA 9750 (Weisner, PI) P50 AA 5595 (Greenfield, PI)
NIDA grant
R01 DA 12297 (Kaskutas, PI)
CSAT contract
#270-94-0001 (Kaskutas, PI)