Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 20

So Paulo Business School

The Role of Trust in Appropriation of Value Created in Buyer-Supplier Relationships


MARTINS, Guilherme S. BRITO, Luiz A. MIGUEL, Priscila L. S.
FGV-EAESP - Brazil

So Paulo Business School

Buyer-supplier relationships
Vertical collaborative relationships: achieving sustainable competitive advantage
SCM: Chen & Paulraj, 2004; Terpend, Tyler, Krause, & Handfield, 2008 (reviews); Strategy: Lazzarini, Miller, & Zenger, 2008; Mayer & Salomon, 2006; Mesquita & Brush, 2008.

Relational rents (Dyer & Singh, 1998).

So Paulo Business School

Trust
Facilitator mechanism:
Its minimize transactions costs, lowers levels of conflict, and increases information sharing and cooperation (McEvily, Perrone, & Zaheer, 2003).
Effective coordination of both tasks as well as incentives (Gulati, Lawrence, & Puranam, 2005; Mesquita &
Brush, 2008).

So Paulo Business School

How much value is created?


The problem of firm-level studies.
Total Value created by a firm $ Opportunity Cost Captured by supplier Cost Price Willingness to pay Captured by custumer

Captured by firm

Source: Brandenburger e Stuart Jr. (1996)

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


Value captured by buyer
$

Opportunity Cost

Cost

Price

Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Value captured by supplier

Total value created by relationship

So Paulo Business School

Trust: creating and sharing value


Trust has been found to positively effect on buyer supplier relations.
(for reviews, see McEvily and Tortoriello, 2011; Zaheer and Harris, 2006)

Is Trust Without Measure a Good Measure of Trust?

So Paulo Business School

Trust: multidimensional concept


Competence-based trust:
being confident to other partys ability to perform as expected.

Goodwill-based trust:
a perception that the other party will behave in a trustworthy (non-opportunist) manner.

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Competencebased trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Competencebased trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Competencebased trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Competencebased trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Goodwill-based trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Goodwill-based trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Goodwill-based trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Goodwill-based trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Excess of Goodwill-based trust

So Paulo Business School

Value created by buyer-supplier relationship


$
Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willigness to pay

Buyer

$ Opportunity Cost Cost Price Willingness to pay

Supplier

Total value created by relationship

Excess of Goodwill-based trust

So Paulo Business School

Goodwill-based trust
45 40 35 30

Value

25 20 15 10 5 0 0 2 4 6 8 10

Trust

So Paulo Business School

Methodological remarks
Survey or Experiment?
Real world vs. variables control?

So Paulo Business School

Thank you!
Guilherme S. Martins
mr.gsmartins@gmail.com

You might also like