6 SOCRATIC QUESTIONS

6 (enam) Pertanyaan Socratic

1.Question for Clarification Pertanyaan untuk klarifikasi/kejelasan Why do you say that ? Mengapa anda mengatakan itu ? How does this relate to our discussion ? Bagaimana hub.nya dgn diskusi kita ? Are you going to include diffusion in your mole balance equation? Akankah anda memasukkan difusi didalam subtansi persamaan keseimbangan?

2. Question that probe assumption Pertanyaan yang membuktikan dugaan

What could we assume instead ? Apa yang dapat anda duga ? How can you verify or disapprove that assumption ? Bagaiamana anda bisa setuju atau menolak asumsi itu ? Why are neglecting radial diffusion and including only oxial diffusion ? Mengapa anda melupakan pusat difusi dan hanya memasukkan difusi yg sepihak ?

3.Question that probe reason and evidence

Pertanyaan yang membutuhkan alasan dan bukti

What would be an example ? Apa contohnya ? What is analogous to ? Analogi apa ? What do you think causes to happen? Apa menurut anda penyebabnya ? Why : ? Mengapa ? Do you think that difusion is responsible for the lower conversion ? Apa menurut anda difusi

itu berperan lebih rendah dari konversi ?

4. Question about viewpoints and perspectives

Pertanyaan tentang sudut pandang dan persepektif What would be an alternative ? Apa alternatifnya ? What is another way to look at ? Apa ada cara lain ? Would you explain why it is necessary or beneficial , and who benefits ? Apa bisa dijelaskan mengapa perlu & bermanfaat & siapa yg memanfaatkan ? Why is it the best ? Mengapa itu terbaik ? What are the strenghts and weaknesses of ? Apa keunggulan dan kelemahannya ? How are and similar ? Bagamana persamaannya? What is counterargument for ? Apa alasan mendasarnya? What all bends in the pipe, from an industrial practical standpoint, do you think diffusion will effect the conversion ? Menurut anda apakah difusi akan mempengaruhi konversi ?

5. Question that probe implication and consequences

Pertanyaan yg membuktikan penerapan dan konsekuensi

What generalization can you make ? Apa

kesimpulan umum yang bisa Anda buat

What are the consequences of that assumption?

Apa konskuensi-konsekuensi terhadap dugaan itu ?

Why are you implying ? Mengapa anda

mengungkapkannya?

How does affect? Bagaimana pengaruhnya ? How does ..tie in the with what we learned before ? Apa hub.nya dg yg pelajari sebelumya?

How would our results be effected if neglected diffusion ? Bagaimana hasil-hasil kita berpengaruh jika difusi dilupakan ?

6. Question about question Pertanyaan tentang pertanyaan

What was the point of this question ? Apa inti dari pertanyaan ini ? Why do you think I asked this question ? Mengapa Anda berfikir, saya menanyakan pertanyaan ini? What does mean ? Apa maksudnya How does apply to everyday life ? Bagaimana menerapkan dalam kehidupan sehari-hari Why do you think difussion is important ? Mengapa menurut Anda difusi penting ?