Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 74

Systems Engineering

Chad Fish
chad.fish@sdl.usu.edu
435-797-0469

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
1
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004
-1

Presentation Overview

Key System Requirements


System Design
System Operation
Technical Resources and Error Budgets
Post-PDR System Changes
Technical Risks
Technical Coordination
Summary
Supplementary Material
Error Budget Models
Level 3 Requirements Compendium

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
2
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004
-2

Key System Requirements

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
3
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004
-3

Science Objectives

SOFIE will support AIM mission in study of PMCs and the environment in which they
form. SOFIE will use differential solar occultation to measure:
Five gaseous species (H2O, CO2, O3, CH4, NO)
Temperature
Particle extinction at 10 wavelengths

SOFIE Channel Overview

Channel

Target Absorber

O3

particles

H2O

CO2

particles

CH4

CO2

NO

Center (m)
Strong band
Weak band

0.290
0.328

0.862
1.031

2.60
2.45

2.77
2.94

3.06
3.19

3.37
3.51

4.25
4.63

5.32
4.98

Each SOFIE channel uses two detectors to make three measurements:


Strong band absorption
Weak band absorption
Difference signal (weak band strong band = V)
Remove interference and reduce noise!

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
4
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004
-4

System Requirements
IDENTIFIER

SHORT DESCRIPTION

REQUIREMENT
(General Operational)

SOF 289

Mission Lifetime

Function 25 months following a 1 month on-orbit


commissioning.

SOF 288

Nominal Operability

Operate 95% of the time over any 5 consecutive days


during the primary science observation season.

SOF 279

Autonomous
Operations

SOFIE shall be capable of autonomous operations for at


least 96 hours.

SOF 172

Mission Ops

SOFIE shall make 2 solar occultation measurements per


orbit, one at sunrise and one at sunset.

SOF 175

Time Stamp

The SOFIE science data time stamp shall be accurate to


within 2.5 msec relative to successive data samples
during occultation measurements.

SOF 179

Spatial Resolution

The SOFIE science data products shall have 3.0 km or


less spatial resolution in elevation.

SOF 308

Sampling Rate

The SOFIE science data channel sample rates shall be


20 Hz during an occultation measurement.

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
5
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004
-5

System Requirements (cont)


IDENTIFIER

SHORT DESCRIPTION

REQUIREMENT
(Observational Views)

SOF 180

Instantaneous Science
FOV

The SOFIE instantaneous science FOV shall be 6 arc


minutes horizontal and 1.8 arc minutes vertical (defined
as along the axis between Nadir and Zenith).

SOF 295

Glint FOV

The SOFIE glint FOV shall be 24 deg horizontal and 32


deg vertical.

SOF 178

FOR

The SOFIE steering mirror shall provide a field of regard


of 2 elevation and 2 azimuth.
(Pointing)

SOF 300

Pointing Ability

SOFIE shall point the center of its FOV to 1 arcminute


at a fixed distance relative to the solar top edge
centerpoint and maintain this position during occultation
measurement.
The pointing position will be considered "maintained" if a
10 Hz filtering (0.1 sec running mean) of the true pointing
position varies <15 arc seconds (1 sigma) in elevation
and <1.0 arcmin (1 sigma) in azimuth.

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
6
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004
-6

System Requirements (Cont)


Table 2. SOFIE spectral band specifications and channel S/N requirements.

SOF 174 :
Measurement Bands
SOF 183 :
Radiometric SNR

Band

Center
(m)

Band Limits, m

Band Limits, cm-1

S/N*

O3 strong

0.290

0.2857 - 0.2941

34000 - 35000

1.0104

O3 weak

0.328

0.3226 0.3333

30000 - 31000

1.0104

particle
strong

0.862

0.8475 0.8772

11400 - 11800

1.0106

particle weak

1.03

1.0101 1.0526

9500 - 9900

1.0106

H2O weak

2.45

2.427 2.475

4040 - 4120

2.5104

H2O strong

2.60

2.577 2.632

3800 - 3880

2.5104

CO2 strong

2.77

2.740 2.794

3580 - 3650

3.0105

CO2 weak

2.94

2.907 2.967

3370 - 3440

3.0105

particle
strong

3.06

3.030 3.091

3235 - 3300

1.0105

particle weak

3.19

3.160 3.226

3100 - 3165

1.0105

CH4 strong

3.37

3.333 3.401

2940 - 3000

4.0105

CH4 weak

3.51

3.472 3.546

2820 - 2880

4.0105

CO2 strong

4.25

4.255 4.444

2250 - 2350

4.0105

CO2 weak

4.63

4.630 4.740

2110 - 2160

4.0105

NO weak

4.98

4.951 5.051

1980 - 2020

3.0105

NO strong

5.32

5.263 5.376

1860 - 1900

3.0105

*The effective noise bandwidth is 2 Hz.


-1
Band limits are given in different units (cm
= 10000/m)
but are Chad
otherwise
Systems
Engineering,
Fishidentical.

SOFIE PDR October 22, 2003

GATS

SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

-7

System Requirements (cont)


IDENTIFIER

SHORT
DESCRIPTION

REQUIREMENT
(Solar Tracking and Maneuvering)

SOF 181

Altitude Range

SOFIE shall be able to track the top edge centerpoint


of the sun from an apparent altitude of 315 km down to
the hard edge of the Earth during an occultation
measurement.

SOF 176

Scanning

SOFIE shall provide the capability to vertically scan


across the disk of the sun four (4) times after the
sunrise occultation measurement and four (4) times
prior to the sunset occultation measurement.

SOF 304

Balancing

SOFIE shall provide the capability to balance the V


signal (i.e. set V to zero) using a gain setting (GA) to
within 1000 counts.

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
8
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004
-8

System Design

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
9
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004
-9

Environmental Orbital Considerations


Orbit

- 600-650 km geocentric
- Polar sun-synchronous
- 2 year operational lifetime

Thermal Predictions

- Electronics Survival = -25 to +55 C


- Electronics Operation = 0 to +50 C
- Instrument Survival = -45 to +20 C
- Instrument Operation = -40 to +20 C

Radiation

TID = 10 kRAD
SEE = 37 MeV

Atomic Oxygen

Strongly dependent on altitude (600 km significantly less than 450 km).


Using MgF2 protective coating on our steering mirror and
primary/secondary Cassegrain telescope mirrors.

Cleanliness

Internal mirrors allowed to degrade (EOL, 26 months) to Level 500. This


includes effects of micro-meteroids.

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
10 - 10
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Design Description

Instrument Unit
Purpose:
Perform science signal detection & FOV pointing and stabilization control
Contains:
Opto-mechanics
Mirrors, filters, beam splitters, field-stop, chopper
[1.8 x 6 Inst FOV; 32 x 24 Glint FOV]
Detector assemblies (includes TECs and PreAmps)
Steering mirror [4 x 4 FOR]
Sun sensor electronics and software [2 x 2 FOV]

Electronics Unit
Purpose:
Perform system command and control, communication, signal conditioning,
and power conditioning
Contains:
Command and data handling electronics and system software
Position and stabilization control electronics and software
Communication, signal conditioning, and mechanisms control electronics
and software
Thermal sensor, TEC thermal control, and housekeeping electronics
Power conditioning electronics

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
11 - 11
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

System Block Diagram

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
12 - 12
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Spacecraft Configuration

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
13 - 13
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Instrument Unit
Radiator
Pin pullers
Aperture cover
Steering mirror
Alignment cubes

N2 Purge

Witness Mirrors (x4)


Circular connector
interfaces

SC Isolator Feet (eff 14 wedge)

GATS

Dynamic Envelope: 16.2 x 26.3 x 29.5 inches


Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
14 - 14
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

SOFIE Instrument Unit (cont)

POINTING AND
STABILIZATION CONTROL
Sun Sensor

SIGNAL DETECTION
Channel Separation Module

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
15 - 15
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

SOFIE Electronics Unit


Electronics PCBs

Top Connectors
and Cabling

SC Radiator Panel

Power Conditioning

Dynamic Envelope: 16.2 x 26.3 x 29.5 inches

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
16 - 16
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

System Operation

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
17 - 17
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Modes of Operation
Survival

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
18 - 18
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Modes of Operation (cont)


Mode

Measurements

Commands

Code
Updates

Survival
Heaters

Comments

Science

- Occultation
- Housekeeping
- System status

1. Real time
processed
1. Timed not
processed

Processed

ON

Standby

- Housekeeping
- System status

Real and
timed
processed

Processed

ON

Safe

- Housekeeping
- System status

Real and
timed
processed

Processed

ON

SOFIE software
can transition into
this mode without
a ground
command but
cannot transition
out without a
ground command

Survival

NA

NA

NA

ON

System power OFF

GATS

Peak data rate and


power mode

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
19 - 19
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Science Mode

Orbital Characteristics

1. 600-650 km altitude
2. Polar sun-synchronous
3. SOFIE instrument pointed by SC to within 1
(3 sigma) of the solar vector during an occultation

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
20 - 20
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Science Mode (cont)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
21 - 21
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Science Mode (cont)


States

General Operations

INIT

Prepare system for occultation measurements


Synchronize electronics and software
Initialize timing and balance commands
Initialize tracking profiles

AQR
(15 seconds)

Search and acquire sun on FPA


Find sun within FOR (if not found abort and return system error)
Position sun center at center of FPA
Begin fine tracking (arcsecond resolution) of sun
Position IFOV at desired offset from sun center
Can overlap with DATA state

DATA
(~ 150 seconds)

Perform science channel measurements!


Maintain IFOV locked at desired offsets from sun center while
following table driven profile (solar tracking)
Fixed position
Solar scanning (including azimuthal offsets)
Perform balance (set V offsets) function
Save CO2 and balance data for post occultation analysis
Can overlap with AQR state

Maximum science measurement duration (AQR, DATA) = 155 seconds

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
22 - 22
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Science Mode (cont)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
23 - 23
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Conceptual Science Mode Operational Profile

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
24 - 24
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Solar Acquisition and Tracking

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
25 - 25
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Solar Scanning and Maneuvering


Vertical Scanning

FOV

Azimuthal Offsetting
(bore sighting)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
26 - 26
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Science Data Products


2

1. Occultation
(20 Hz)

-Solar edge locations (X,Y)


-Solar vertical edge and center

images
-Steering mirror command and
position (X,Y)
-All channel sets (Strong, Weak,
V)
-Time stamps (SC and relative)

1
2. Diagnostic
(Limited)

-Solar images
-FPA frame images

1
El
Az

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
27 - 27
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Commissioning Phase

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
28 - 28
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

System Technical Resources


&
Error Budgets

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
29 - 29
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Technical Resources
RESOURCE

CURRENT BEST ESTIMATE

REQ ID

Mass

36.4 kg

SOF 194

Envelope

Controlled by MICD

SOF 195

Average Power

74.1 W
[56 W Electronics Unit, 18 W Instrument Unit]

SOF 205

Peak Power

107.6 W

SOF 206

Pinpuller Peak Power

32.2 W for < 0.5 sec,


(130 mW Pre and Post Fire)

SC ICD

Survival Heater
Average Power

15.2 W

SOF 272

Survival Heater
Peak Power

62.8 W

SOF 272

Daily Data Volume

168 Mbits/day

SOF 243

Resource margin and reserve managed by mission

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
30 - 30
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Mass Budget

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
31 - 31
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Power Budget

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
32 - 32
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Orbital Power Profile

In eclipse

84

82

80

78

SOFIE

76

74

72

70

68
0

20

40

60

GATS

80

100

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
33 - 33
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Resource Tracking

GATS

Resource

CDR/PDR Ratio

Mass

36.4 / 34.6 = 1.05

Power

74.1 / 83.5 = 0.89

Data

168 / 73.6 = 2.28

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
34 - 34
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Error Budgets
BUDGET

REQUIREMENT

EXPECTED PERFORMANCE

Radiometric

WC Band 15 (NOWEAK)
SNR = 3.0 x 105

SNR = 9.33 x 105 (Margin = 3.11)

Pointing

15 Arcseconds (1 Sigma)
over 0.5 seconds

<1 Arcsecond (0.5 Arcseconds)

Static
Alignment

0.5 to SC

3 Arcminutes CBE
Will be calibrated out on orbit!

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
35 - 35
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Post-PDR System Changes

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
36 - 36
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Changes since PDR

SMA Caging
Mechanism
Removed

Wedge
Removed
Radiator
Reshaped
Cable Ports
Relocated

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
37 - 37
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Changes since PDR (cont)


Repositioned
in SC and
Radiator
Removed
Electronics
Power
Conditioning
Redesigned

Detector
Packages
now
Non-hermetic

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
38 - 38
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

System Technical Risks

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
39 - 39
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Technical Risks
RISK ID = SOFIE_RISK_4
SOFIE depends upon an active pointing system to provide the required sun
pointing accuracy and precision. The active pointing and control system
algorithm may be unable to provide the required sun pointing accuracy and
precision and the science capability would be degraded.
CRITICALITY
Green
MITIGATION
Extensive prototype and protoflight testing will be conducted.

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
40 - 40
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

System Technical Coordination

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
41 - 41
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Technical Coordination SDL Design Processes

Engineering Design and Development


System Design
QP0401
Software Design
QP0406
Document Control and Configuration Management
Document Control
QP0501
Software Configuration Management
QP0403, SOFIE Software Configuration Management Plan
SDL to maintain up-down information flow
Waivers, Problem Failure Reports (PFR)
QP1301

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
42 - 42
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Technical Coordination Internal Peer Review

Review follows Breadboard/Prototype design phase


Includes SDL members both internal and external to SOFIE
System and component level

Following review, design placed in configuration control

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
43 - 43
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Technical Coordination SDL Design Processes (cont)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
44 - 44
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Documentation Status
Document

Status

SOFIE Level 3 Requirements

Mission Approved

SOFIE Specifications Document

Released

SOFIE Flight Software Development Plan

Released

SOFIE Flight Software Specifications

Released

SOFIE Program Management Plan

Released

SOFIE Product Assurance Plan

Released

SOFIE Safety Plan

Released

SOFIE Contamination Control Plan

Baseline Released

SOFIE EEE and Materials Parts Lists

Controlled. Initial lists submitted to Mission November 2003

SOFIE Risk Management Database

Controlled

SOFIE Calibration Plan

Baseline Released

SOFIE Integration and Test Plan

Baseline Released

SOFIE Software Design Document and Test Plan

Baselines Released

SOFIE Electrical/Software ICD

Baseline Released

Subcontractor SOWs and ICDs

Released

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
45 - 45
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

SE Summary

Designs are mature and provide margin on system requirements


Technical resources are being managed and tracked
Error budgets are being managed

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
46 - 46
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Supplementary Material

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
47 - 47
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Radiometric System Requirements


Table 2. SOFIE spectral band specifications and channel S/N requirements.

SOF 174 :
Measurement Bands
SOF 183 :
Radiometric SNR

Band

Center
(m)

Band Limits, m

Band Limits, cm-1

S/N*

O3 strong

0.290

0.2857 - 0.2941

34000 - 35000

1.0104

O3 weak

0.328

0.3226 0.3333

30000 - 31000

1.0104

particle
strong

0.862

0.8475 0.8772

11400 - 11800

1.0106

particle weak

1.03

1.0101 1.0526

9500 - 9900

1.0106

H2O weak

2.45

2.427 2.475

4040 - 4120

2.5104

H2O strong

2.60

2.577 2.632

3800 - 3880

2.5104

CO2 strong

2.77

2.740 2.794

3580 - 3650

3.0105

CO2 weak

2.94

2.907 2.967

3370 - 3440

3.0105

particle
strong

3.06

3.030 3.091

3235 - 3300

1.0105

particle weak

3.19

3.160 3.226

3100 - 3165

1.0105

CH4 strong

3.37

3.333 3.401

2940 - 3000

4.0105

CH4 weak

3.51

3.472 3.546

2820 - 2880

4.0105

CO2 strong

4.25

4.255 4.444

2250 - 2350

4.0105

CO2 weak

4.63

4.630 4.740

2110 - 2160

4.0105

NO weak

4.98

4.951 5.051

1980 - 2020

3.0105

NO strong

5.32

5.263 5.376

1860 - 1900

3.0105

*The effective noise bandwidth is 2 Hz.


-1
Band limits are given in different units (cm
= 10000/m)
but are Chad
otherwise
Systems
Engineering,
Fishidentical.

SOFIE PDR October 22, 2003

GATS

SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

48 - 48

Radiometric Model Error Budget

Optical Input Path

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
49 - 49
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Radiometric Model Error Budget (cont)

Optical Math Model Transfer Function

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
50 - 50
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Radiometric Model Error Budget (cont)

Electronics Path

Effective Sync Rect Q = 500

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
51 - 51
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Radiometric Model Error Budget (cont)


Band /
Detector Type
1 / PV
2 / PV
3 / PV
4 / PV
5 / PC
6 / PC
7 / PC
8 / PC
9 / PC
10 / PC
11 / PC
12 / PC
13 / PC
14 / PC
15 / PC
16 / PC

SNR
3.14 Hz bw
5.81E+06
7.19E+06
8.38E+06
8.38E+06
3.59E+06
3.54E+06
6.79E+06
6.94E+06
2.65E+06
2.68E+06
2.98E+06
4.87E+06
5.39E+06
3.11E+06
9.33E+05
1.48E+06

GATS

Required
SNR
1.00E+04
1.00E+04
1.00E+06
1.00E+06
2.50E+04
2.50E+04
3.00E+05
3.00E+05
1.00E+05
1.00E+05
4.00E+05
4.00E+05
4.00E+05
4.00E+05
3.00E+05
3.00E+05

Margin
581.40
719.42
8.38
8.38
143.53
141.58
22.64
23.14
26.48
26.77
7.44
12.17
13.47
7.77
3.11
4.92

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
52 - 52
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Pointing Model Error Budget

IDENTIFIER

SHORT DESCRIPTION

REQUIREMENT
(Pointing)

SOF 300

Pointing Ability

SOFIE shall point the center of its FOV to 1 arcminute


at a fixed distance relative to the solar top edge
centerpoint and maintain this position during occultation
measurement.
The pointing position will be considered "maintained" if a
10 Hz filtering (0.1 sec running mean) of the true pointing
position varies <15 arc seconds (1 sigma) in elevation
and <1.0 arcmin (1 sigma) in azimuth.

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
53 - 53
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Pointing Model Error Budget (cont)

2D derived by hand, includes 1 mode in mirror and 1 mode in structure (4 plant states)
Integrates OSCs latest S/C model (from AIM Bus CDR) and SSGs latest SMA model

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
54 - 54
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Pointing Model Error Budget (cont)

25
20
15

S/C Motion (arcsec)

10
5
0
-5
-10
-15
-20
-25

10

GATS

15

20

25
Time (sec)

30

35

40

45

50

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
55 - 55
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Pointing Model Error Budget (cont)

Description

Two-D simple model


with 4 states

Jitter in Sun
Elevation
Position
(arcsec, 1)

Jitter in Sun
Azimuth
Position
(arcsec, 1)

S/C Reaction
Torque in Elev.
Plane (N-m, 1)

0.499

N/A

0.0001

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
56 - 56
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Alignment Knowledge Error Budget SOFIE FOV to ROS

Spacecraft Pointing Knowledge Requirements


SOF231

The SOFIE optical axis shall be aligned to the spacecraft optical axis with an accuracy of 0.25 prior to launch.
This alignment will be maintained to within 0.5 on orbit.

From
MRD SYS837

SOF292

The SOFIE reference axis alignment to the observatory reference axis shall be known to better than +/-10 arcsec.

From
MRD SYS753

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
57 - 57
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Alignment Knowledge Error Budget Slow Thermal Dynamic


Simulation of Hot Case Conditions

Assumptions

Hot case thermal loads considered


Restrained temperatures:

CSM Assembly 37 F to 48 F
Radiator Interface 24.5 F
Aft Optics Deck 30 F to 37 F
Fore Optics Deck 25 F to 32 F
Bottom Deck 32 F to 35 F
Sun Sensor 39 F to 43 F
Mid Optics 39 F
M1 and Hub 34 F
M2 and Mount 52 F
Isolator interface at S/C 86 F

Only conduction heat transfer


considered
Steady-state temperature predicted
Displacements from 70 F
Displacements relative to Field Stop

GATS

Node

Displacement (in)

Rotation (Degrees)

Mirror

81101

M2/SS1

-1.5E-3

-2.7E-3

-1.2E-3

-8.1E-5

-2.8E-5

-9.7E-6

106497

Chop

-3.8E-4

4.0E-5

1.7E-6

-4.0E-6

-1.2E-6

-1.5E-5

106510

M3

1.7E-5

3.8E-4

-1.4E-4

-2.4E-6

-1.2E-5

7.0E-6

106520

Field
Stop

107175

SS2

-3.0E-5

-1.1E-3

-1.1E-3

-8.1E-5

-3.2E-5

8.9E-6

116912

SS4

-2.4E-4

7.5E-4

1.9E-6

-7.8E-5

-3.9E-5

1.8E-5

116922

SS3

-1.1E-3

2.1E-3

1.7E-4

-1.2E-4

-4.3E-5

3.2E-5

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
58 - 58
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Alignment Knowledge Error Budget Slow Thermal Dynamic


Simulation of Cold Case Conditions

Assumptions

Hot case thermal loads considered


Restrained temperatures:

CSM Assembly -27 F


Radiator Interface -35 F
Aft Optics Deck -26 F
Fore Optics Deck -31 F
Bottom Deck -30 F
Sun Sensor -27 F
Mid Optics -25 F
M1 and Hub -28 F
M2 and Mount -26 F
Isolator interface at S/C -4 F

Only conduction heat transfer


considered
Steady-state temperature predicted
Displacements from 70 F
Displacement relative to Field Stop

GATS

Node

Displacement (in)

Rotation (Degrees)

Mirror

81101

M2/SS1

-1.1E-3

-1.4E-3

-2.5E-4

-1.4E-5

-1.5E-5

1.0E-5

106497

Chop

-2.7E-4

2.7E-5

-1.8E-6

7.2E-6

-2.1E-7

-1.3E-5

106510

M3

4.5E-5

2.3E-4

-7.3E-5

-1.6E-5

-8.6E-6

-1.1E-6

106520

Field
Stop

107175

SS2

-2.1E-4

-9.3E-4

-2.7E-4

-1.2E-5

-1.8E-5

1.8E-6

116912

SS4

-1.6E-4

5.4E-4

1.6E-5

-1.2E-5

-4.1E-6

-2.5E-6

116922

SS3

-7.9E-4

1.4E-3

2.0E-4

-2.1E-5

-4.3E-5

5.2E-7

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
59 - 59
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Alignment Knowledge Error Budget Slow Thermal Dynamic


Simulation of SOFIE to SC Deflections
Node in center of Aperture Cover (SOFIE FEM coordinate system)
Hot Case:

Cold Case:

Tx:
Ty:
Tz:
Rx:
Ry:
Rz:
Tx:
Ty:
Tz:
Rx:
Ry:
Rz:

GATS

3.03e-4 in
-6.05e-3 in
-8.46e-3 in
-2.14e-4 degrees
5.39e-5 degrees
-4.41e-5 degrees
6.00e-4 in
-1.82e-2 in
-1.99e-2 in
-6.77e-4 degrees
6.92e-5 degrees
-3.87e-5 degrees

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
60 - 60
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Pointing Budget SOFIE to SC Accuracy


SOFIE Science
FOV Boresight to
Sun Center
(SYS755)
Required 60

RSS
SOFIE Science
FOV Boresight to
ROS Error

SOFIE ROS to S/C


Deck I/F Plane
Error

CBE 0.4

(SOF231)
Required 30

SOFIE ROS to S/C


Deck I/F Plane
Static Error

SOFIE ROS to S/C


Deck I/F Plane Slow
Dynamic Error

SOFIE ROS to S/C


Deck I/F Plane
Launch Shift

CBE 1

CBE 2

CBE 2

S/C Deck I/F Plane


to MRC Error
(SYS837)

MRC Pointing
Accuracy
(SYS844)

Required 2

Required 17

ACS Accuracy
(BUS272)

Ephemeris Error
(SYS844)

Required 5

Required 36

RSS = 3 Arcminutes (3 Sigma)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
61 - 61
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

GFOV Clearance
9.53in.
Scienc
e FOV

Glint FOV

0.69in.

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
62 - 62
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 & 4 Requirements Compendium

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
63 - 63
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

AIM Science Objectives Traceability to SOFIE


Science Question
1. Morphology

2. GW Affects

3. Dynamics

4. H-chemistry

5. Nucleation

Geophysical Parameters Required to Answer Science Question


PMC
Morphology,
Particle Sizes

PMC
Morphology

SOFIE
Observation

PMC
Morphology

PMC
Morphology

PMC
Morphology

Cloud
Extinction

Temperature
Profile

T,CO2
Profiles,
Circulation

Temperature
Profile

Temperature
Profile

CO2
Absorption

H2O Profile

H2O Profile,

H2O Profile

H2O Profile

H2O
Absorption

Circulation
O3 Profile

O3 Absorption

CH4 Profile,

CH4 Profile,

Circulation

Circulation

CH4
Absorption
NO Profile

GATS

NO Absorption

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
64 - 64
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 Requirements Management

Requirements will be utilized as the main method for defining the functionality,
performance, design constraints, and interfaces for the AIM program

Requirements will be used throughout all phases of the program to guide design,
development, integration, and test

Requirements tracking and compliance assurance will be an integral part of peer,


design, integration, and test reviews to insure that the system development is
proceeding in accordance with the systems engineering and management process

After initial completion, the requirements and interfaces will baselined and change
tracking will occur:
Access control will allow those teams and individuals with responsibility for
portions of the requirements to propose changes to those requirements.
The system engineering team will work with the necessary engineers and
management personnel to access the impact of requirements changes on the
remainder of the system.

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
65 - 65
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 Requirements Management (cont)


Documents
U Science

DOORS
Science
Rqmts

H Rqmts Doc
Mission
U Rqmts Doc
Verification
& Validation
Plan

U
H

Level 1

H : HU
S: SDL
U: UAF
A: All

Level 2

Mission/System L
Rqmts
U

Responsibility:
L: LASP
NS: NASA
O: Orbital
G: GATS

Level 3
Ground
System
Rqmts L

IPI
Rqmts

Bus
Rqmts

CIPS
Rqmts

SOFIE
Rqmts

CDE
Rqmts

Software
Development
Plan
L
LV ICD

I/F
Definitions A

L
RF ICD
L

Ground
System Spec

IPI
Spec

Bus
Spec

ICD
O

CDE
Spec

SOFIE
Spec

CIPS
Spec
L

AIM Requirements Traceability & Specification Tree (from AIM SEMP)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
66 - 66
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 Requirements Management (cont)


Science U
Rqmts
H

CDE
Rqmts

Responsibility:
L: LASP
NS: NASA
O: Orbital
G: GATS
H : HU
S: SDL
U: UAF
A: All

System L
Rqmts
U

Mission L
Rqmts
U

Bus
Rqmts

SOFIE
Rqmts S

IPI
Rqmts L

CIPS
Rqmts L

Black Box Requirements

Input Interfaces:
Electrical
Thermal
Commands
Data
Attitude
Optical,
etc.

Functional Examples:
Mandatory (minimum) and required (goal) as necessary
Measurements to be made
Criteria for when to collect measurements
Pointing required for measurements
Operational sequences
Conditions/events to which system must respond
Operator and data processing considerations
Performance Examples:
Quality of measurements (accuracy, precision, stability)
Quantity and frequency of measurements
Input/Output data size & rates
Design Constraint Examples:
Mass, power, volume limitations
Environmental conditions (temp, radiation, cleanliness)
Capacity & throughput limitations
Technology limitations
GFE, COTS, etc.

Other
Sources

Ground
System
Rqmts L

General Requirement Guidelines:


-Define these types of requirements:
-Functional: What, How Many,
When, Where, etc.
-Performance: How Well, How Often,
Within How Long, etc.
-Design Constraints: Environmental
conditions/limits, Contract/mission
restrictions, standards, plans,
interaction w/ existing systems, etc.
-Interfaces: Inputs & outputs (at particular
requirement level) to other parts of
the system or external to system
-Consider allocated requirements: those
flowed-down from higher-level requirements
-Consider derived requirements: those
inferred from higher level or same level
requirements
-Insure requirements are:
-Understandable
-Unambiguous
-Comprehensive
-Complete
-Precise
-Verifiable
-Consistent
-Appropriate to level

Output Interfaces:
Electrical
Thermal
Commands
Data
etc.

AIM Requirements Development Approach and Guidelines (from AIM SEMP)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
67 - 67
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 & 4 Requirements Management (cont)

SOFIE Level 3 requirements derived from AIM Level 1 & 2 requirements


Level 3 requirements report (DOORS) created in accordance with WBS
Approved by AIM Mission systems engineer and Deputy SE

Level 3 requirements managed by SOFIE systems engineer


Level 3 requirements assigned to appropriate discipline leads

Level 4 requirements derived from Level 3 requirements by systems engineer and


discipline leads
Subcontractors requirements are also managed as Level 4

Level 3 and Level 4 requirements derivation includes source traceability and


verification process information
Serves as Verification Matrix

SOFIE Instrument Specifications and SOFIE Flight Software Specifications captured in


SDL/04-004 and SDL/04-003, respectively

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
68 - 68
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 Verification Matrix

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
69 - 69
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 Verification Matrix (cont.)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
70 - 70
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 Verification Matrix (cont.)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
71 - 71
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 Verification Matrix (cont.)

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
72 - 72
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 3 Requirements Database

Acrobat Document

GATS

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
73 - 73
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

Level 4 Requirements Database

Acrobat Document

GATS

Acrobat Document

Systems Engineering,
SOFIE Chad
PDR Fish
October 22, 2003
74 - 74
SOFIE CDR October 7-8, 2004

You might also like