N

O
I
S
I
EC RP
D O
C

G
N
I
K
A
M

AT

T
A
C
A

THE ISSUE
Objective : Choose the BEST Supplier!

Quantitati
Qualitative
ve
Efficiency

Turn Ratio

Power Factor

Cost

Losses

SUPPLIERS

Ideal

Dolphi
n

Boss

Freedo
m

SCALE OF PAIR-WISE COMPARISON

1
3
5
7
9

Equal Importance
Moderate
Importance
Strong Importance
Very Strong
Importance
Extreme Importance

THE DECISION
PAIR-WISE COMPARISONS OF CRITERIA, ONE AGAINST THE
OTHER

CRITERIA

EFFICIENCY

POWER
FACTOR

LOSSES

TURN RATIO

EFFICIENCY

3/1

1/5

7/1

POWER
FACTOR

1/3

3/1

5/1

LOSSES

5/1

1/3

7/1

TURN RATIO

7/1

1/5

1/7

THE DECISION
PAIR-WISE COMPARISONS OF TRANSFORMER BRANDS/MODELS
IN TERMS OF EFFICIENCY AS CRITERION

EFFICIENCY

DOLPHIN

BOSS

FREEDOM

IDEAL

DOLPHIN

1/3

5/1

1/9

BOSS

3/1

5/1

1/7

FREEDOM

1/5

1/5

1/7

IDEAL

9/1

7/1

7/1

THE DECISION
PAIR-WISE COMPARISONS OF TRANSFORMER BRANDS/MODELS
IN TERMS OF POWER FACTOR AS CRITERION

POWER
FACTOR

DOLPHIN

BOSS

FREEDOM

IDEAL

DOLPHIN

3/1

9/1

1/1

BOSS

1/3

5/1

3/1

FREEDOM

1/9

1/5

1/7

IDEAL

1/1

1/3

7/1

THE DECISION
PAIR-WISE COMPARISONS OF TRANSFORMER BRANDS/MODELS
IN TERMS OF LOSSES AS CRITERION

LOSSES

DOLPHIN

BOSS

FREEDOM

IDEAL

DOLPHIN

5/1

9/1

1/7

BOSS

1/5

3/1

5/1

FREEDOM

1/9

1/3

1/5

IDEAL

7/1

1/5

5/1

QUANTITATIVE DATA
TURN RATIO AND COST FOR DIFFERENT TRANSFORMER
BRANDS/MODELS

BRANDS

TURN RATIO

COST (Rs./Unit)

DOLPHIN

0.93

516

BOSS

0.82

496

FREEDOM

0.87

486

IDEAL

0.97

507

EXPERT CHOICE - GOAL

Dilakukan penyesuaian agar mendapatkan Inconsistency
dibawah 10% (0.1)

Nominal yang disesuaikan

EXPERT CHOICE - EFFICIENCY

Dilakukan penyesuaian agar mendapatkan Inconsistency
dibawah 10% (0.1)

Ideal > Boss > Dolphin > Freedom

Nominal yang disesuaikan

EXPERT CHOICE POWER FACTOR

Dilakukan penyesuaian agar mendapatkan Inconsistency
dibawah 10% (0.1)

Dolphin > Ideal > Boss > Freedom

EXPERT CHOICE - LOSSES

Dilakukan penyesuaian agar mendapatkan Inconsistency
dibawah 10% (0.1)

Ideal > Dolphin > Boss > Freedom

Nominal yang disesuaikan

EXPERT CHOICE TURN RATIO

Kuantitatif : melakukan penyesuaian nominal berdasarkan
range nominal turn ratio yang diberikan dari data, dan
disesuaikan agar mendapatkan inconsistency dibawah 10%
(0.1)

Boss > Freedom > Dolphin > Ideal

EXPERT CHOICE - COST

Kuantitatif : melakukan penyesuaian nominal berdasarkan
range nominal cost yang diberikan dari data, dan
disesuaikan agar mendapatkan inconsistency dibawah 10%
(0.1)

Freedom > Boss > Ideal > Dolphin

RESULT
The BEST transformer brand/model choice for VR500 is :
FREEDOM

FREEDOM
BRAND