The document summarizes weaknesses in performance monitoring before and after a distribution franchisee agreement. Before the agreement, there was no investment in infrastructure, poor quality supply with frequent interruptions, illegal lines supplied by private agents, difficulty getting official connections leading to theft and bribery. After the agreement, there were issues with compatibility of IT systems to analyze franchisee data, no third party audits were conducted despite requests, and customers still perceived high bills and distrusted meter accuracy.
Original Description:
PERFORMANCE MONITORING CHALLENGES INFRONT OF PUBLIC SECTOR
The document summarizes weaknesses in performance monitoring before and after a distribution franchisee agreement. Before the agreement, there was no investment in infrastructure, poor quality supply with frequent interruptions, illegal lines supplied by private agents, difficulty getting official connections leading to theft and bribery. After the agreement, there were issues with compatibility of IT systems to analyze franchisee data, no third party audits were conducted despite requests, and customers still perceived high bills and distrusted meter accuracy.
The document summarizes weaknesses in performance monitoring before and after a distribution franchisee agreement. Before the agreement, there was no investment in infrastructure, poor quality supply with frequent interruptions, illegal lines supplied by private agents, difficulty getting official connections leading to theft and bribery. After the agreement, there were issues with compatibility of IT systems to analyze franchisee data, no third party audits were conducted despite requests, and customers still perceived high bills and distrusted meter accuracy.
• No investment in distribution network improvement while load increased • Poor quality of supply, frequent intteruptions • Fixed tariff illegal lines such as Tarapur line, Padga line,etc supplied by private agents • Feeder changer switch used in households to switch between official and non-official lines • 110 V bulbs to counter the problem of low voltages • Getting the load increased or getting official connection was very difficult leading to the thefts and illegal connections • Metering and billing efficiency was low • Paying bribes to agents to get the transformed and other faults repaired • Lack of consistency in efforts for a long period • Lack of political support WEAKNESS IN PERFORMANCE MONITORING • AFTER DISTRIBUTION FRANCHISEE AGREEMENT • Incompatibility of IT systems of MSEDCL to analyse the data provided by TPAL. • The average billing rate has a direct effect on the revenue of MSEDCL, hence TPAL requested for third party annual audit. But, even after two years of DFA, no audit was done • The consumers perception of high bills and fast running meters showed that even TPAL was unable to win customer confidence • From the survey, it seems that the cost of good quality supply was unable to poor customers of bhiwandi