The document discusses the division of powers between the federal and provincial governments in Canada related to transportation law under the Constitution Act of 1867. It outlines that legislative authority over transportation is divided between the two levels of government, with the federal government having jurisdiction over inter-provincial transportation while intra-provincial transportation falls under provincial jurisdiction. The document then examines this division of powers as it applies specifically to transportation by road, rail, water, and air.
The document discusses the division of powers between the federal and provincial governments in Canada related to transportation law under the Constitution Act of 1867. It outlines that legislative authority over transportation is divided between the two levels of government, with the federal government having jurisdiction over inter-provincial transportation while intra-provincial transportation falls under provincial jurisdiction. The document then examines this division of powers as it applies specifically to transportation by road, rail, water, and air.
The document discusses the division of powers between the federal and provincial governments in Canada related to transportation law under the Constitution Act of 1867. It outlines that legislative authority over transportation is divided between the two levels of government, with the federal government having jurisdiction over inter-provincial transportation while intra-provincial transportation falls under provincial jurisdiction. The document then examines this division of powers as it applies specifically to transportation by road, rail, water, and air.
Legislative authority to make laws dealing with transportation is
divided between the federal and provincial government under the Constitution Act, 1867 (formerly known as the British North America Act)
Law is held to be “ultra vires” (beyond the powers) if a level of
government passes a law that it has no constitutional authority to pass
Section 91 – federal jurisdiction
Section 92 – provincial jurisdiction
z Federal Powers
Preamble of section 91 – residual power for “Peace, order and
good government” for any area not assigned to provincial government
Section 91(10) – navigation and shipping
z Provincial Powers
Section 92(10) – laws respecting certain transportation entities
Intra-provincial shipping, railways and other transportation is
provincial jurisdiction
Therefore, anything not listed is governed by federal powers
Federal jurisdiction over inter-provincial (including international)
shipping, railways, and other means of transportation
NOTE: section 92(10)(c) – federal government can declare its own
jurisdiction in certain matters
Work versus undertaking
z Transportation by Road
Winner case – constitutional authority over road transport
Canadian constitutional law avoids divided jurisdiction over a transportation
enterprise
Where a transportation enterprise has a continuous and regular inter-
provincial aspect, its whole operation will come under federal jurisdiction
Undertaking – Winner’s bus line business was one “undertaking” – it was a
unified entity
Introduction of the Motor Vehicle Transport Act, 1954
Section 7/8 – delegation of federal licensing power to provincial officials
z Transportation by Rail
Local railways within a province come within provincial
jurisdiction
Inter-provincial railways come under federal jurisdiction
Physical and operational connection
NOTE: section 92(10)(c) – some intra-provincial railways have
been brought under federal powers through this declaratory power z Transportation by Water
Federal government has general jurisdiction over inter-provincial
and international ship lines
No federal jurisdiction over intra-provincial ship lines as
undertakings BUT
Section 91(10) Authority over navigation and shipping
Exclusive jurisdiction to the federal government over purely navigational and shipping aspects of water transportation Harbours, maritime and admiralty law Liability for accidents at sea and liability for loss of cargo z Transportation by Air
Exclusive Federal jurisdiction over aeronautics
Re: Aerial Navigation – peace, order and good government
Treaty making power – federal power – section 132 of the
Constitution Act, 1867
Both navigational and economic aspects of air transport is
federal z Discussion Forum
Is the case of Regina v. Toronto Magistrates consistent with the
Law School Survival Guide (Volume I of II) - Outlines and Case Summaries for Torts, Civil Procedure, Property, Contracts & Sales: Law School Survival Guides