Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 104

DSCE

DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING


IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

SAFETY INSTRUMENTATION
Module -5
Operation,Maintenance,Testing,Reporting and
Management of PSMP
Dr V S Krushnasamy
Associate Professor
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 1
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

Reports/Records
Protection System Maintenance
Program[PSMP]
Self Monitoring Capabilities and Limitations
Notifications of Protection Systems Failures

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 2


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

DESCRIBE THE WORKING OF VARIOUS TYPES OF


REPORTS REQUIRED FOR MAINTENANCE
MANAGEMENT:

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 3


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

REPORTS / RECORDS
TEST REPORT :
• Test report is a report which include output data of
function of instrument through which behavior of
instrument can be judge, with known inputs.
• It provides working range of instrument.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 4


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 INSPECTION REPORT
• Inspection report is a report which prepared by
visual verification of physical condition of any
instrument as per their name-plate of data sheet
provide from instrument manufecturer
• As per this type of report we can maintain the
condition of any instrument as it would receive
from factory.
• -As per this report we can have necessary steps
to maintain our instruments and relevant assets
in good condition in different atmosphere like we
can provide protection against different season or
in Hazardous area.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology
5
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
Following type of Inspection Report can be prepared :
 Inspection reports of Impulse lines & Fittings
 Inspection report of JB, cable glands, cable & cable trays.
 Inspection report of cable route including cable tray / duct
conditions.
 Inspection report of external chamber level instrument.
 Inspection report of cooling system / radiation shields of
Nucleonic detectors.
 Inspection report on visual check of thermowells, flanges and
conduits & Skin T/C.
 Inspection report of sealing element for special design temperature
element.
 Inspection report on visual check of final control elements
[Valves] and accessories.
 Inspection report of instrument air header & air tubing for leakage
and corrosion.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 6
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
EQUIPMENT RECORD
Equipment records are grouped under four classifications:
 maintenance work performed,
 maintenance cost,
 inventory, and files.
 Equipment records are useful when procuring new
items/equipment to determine operating performance
trends, troubleshooting breakdowns, making
replacement or modification decisions, investigating
incidents, identifying areas of concern, performing
reliability and maintainability studies, and conducting
life cycle cost and design studies.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 7
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

WORK REQUEST
A document that instructs the maintenance
department that work is required.
It identifies the equipment number, a unique
job number, the work requested, any
approvals required, and the priority of the
work.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 8


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 WORK ORDER
 A document that instructs the maintenance person in
what is to be done.
 It identifies crafts, if appropriate, materials, special
tools, critical times, and provides other necessary
information to accomplish the job.
 The format for the work order must be agreed upon
at the beginning of the computerization process.
 It is the key to definition of the job, planning,
scheduling, and control of the work, plus developing
histories for future analysis.
 Although no database is preloaded, one is rapidly
generated.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 9
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

WORK PLAN
The asking of why, what, who, where, when,
and how the maintenance group will respond
to a work request. It provides logical answers to
these questions.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 10


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

JOB SEQUENCE
 Frequently called scheduling. It recognizes
priorities and resource availability and can
be done at several levels.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 11


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

CONTROL REPORTS
An after-the-fact record, or accounting, or what
has been done and some form of measurement.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 12


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 SAFETY INSTRUMENT BIN CARD :
 Bin Card is also called as Cardex, Tag Card etc. The
detailed information about the materials is contained
in the Bin Card.
 Normally Bin Card Consists of the information like
Qty Received, Qty Issued, Minimum Stock Level,
Maximum Stock Level, Recorder Level, Re-Order
Quantity, Closing Stock, Opening Stock etc.
 Bin card is a record of receipt and issue of materials
Quantity of store received is entered with receipt
column and the quantity of store issued is recorded in
the issue column of Bin Card. Balance of quantity of
stores is ensured after every receipt or issue column
of Bin Card.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 13
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 Bin Card also assists to store-keeper for control of
stock. For each item of stores minimum- level, and
ordering level are shown in the part of the Bin-
Card.

 A Bin-Card is also known as BIN TAG or STOCK-


CARD and is usually hung-up or placed in shelf,
rack or bin where the material has been kept. Bin-
cards can also be in the form of loose sheets which
can be maintained in a ledger kept in the stores.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 14
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 15
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
SAFETY INSTRUMENT LOG BOOK
 Safety Instrument Log Book provide following information in
which daily maintenance related technical data including
solved safety related problems filled by technical person:
 Description of the instrument, critical accessories and software;
 Manufacturer's name, Type identification and Serial number;
 Installation qualification (IQ) and operational qualification
(OQ) records obtained from the installer or manufacturer; and
other related material such as instrument service and repair,
warranty information, service contract conditions and
specifications, and equipment manufacturer representative’s
names and telephone numbers.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 16


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

Log book also useful to provide information


to technical Engineer / Technician about an
problem of Instrument/ Safety Instrument,
where in more than one numbers of engineer
worked.
It is easy to carry-out the work / execution of
maintenance task for different
engineer/technician who work in changeable
shift duty.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 17
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 18


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 SAFETY INSTRUMENT MAINTENANCE INDENT
BOOK: (PHYSICAL, HUMAN RESOURCE)
 Indent book is bunch of Indent slip which is
Order for GOODS/ ASSETS/
INSTRUMENT-PARTS (placed often
through a local or foreign agent of a foreign
supplier) under specified conditions of sale,
the acceptance of which by the supplier (or
the agent) constitutes a contract of sale.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 19
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 20


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 21


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 SAFETY INSTRUMENT COMPLAINT
BOOK
 Complaint book is a bunch of slip of complaint
form which shows a reason for dissatisfaction
of any Instrument/ Service of Instrument/
Function of Instrument/ Malfunction of
Instrument.
 Complaint book is necessary to identify about
nature of problem in instrument so that
performance of instrument can be improve by
eliminating such a problems from instruments
and its function. Dept of Instrumentation Technology
4/25/2019 22
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 23


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
Define the terms context to Protection System Maintenance Progra
VERIFICATION :
 A means of determining that the Protection System or component
is functioning correctly and is fit for service.
MONITORING :
 Observation of the correctness of routine in-service operation of
the Protection System or component.
TESTING :
 Application of signals to a Protection System or component
removed from service, to observe functional performance or
output behavior.
PHYSICAL INSPECTION :
 To detect visible signs of component failure, reduced performance
and degradation.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 24


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
CALIBRATION :
 Adjustment of the operating threshold or measurement
accuracy of a Protection System measuring element to
meet manufacturer’s specifications or an application
accuracy requirement.
UPKEEP :
 Routine activities necessary to assure that the component
remains in good working order and implementation of
any manufacturer’s hardware and software service
advisories which are relevant to the application of the
device.
RESTORATION :
 The actions to restore proper operation of
malfunctioning components, too.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 25
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 26


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
LIST TYPES OF PROTECTION SYSTEM
MAINTENANCE PROGRAM [PSMP - 5.2.1 TO
5.2.7] :
MONITORING BY ANALYSIS OF FAULT RECORDS,
PERFORMANCE-BASEDMAINTENANCE PROCESS,
MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE VERIFICATION INTERVALS,
TIME BASED VERSUS CONDITION BASED
MAINTENANCE,
CONDITION BASED MAINTENANCE [CBM]
PROGRAMS,
TIME BASED MAINTENANCE [TBM] PROGRAMS,
OVERLAPPING THE VERIFICATION OF SEGMENTS
OF THE PROTECTION SYSTEM.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 27
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
DESCRIBE THE WORKING OF VARIOUS
TYPES OF PSMP 5.2.1 TO 5.2.7 MAINTENANCE
MANAGEMENT:
 An ongoing program by which Protection
System components are kept in working order and
proper operation of malfunctioning
components is restored.
 The protective relay system maintenance and
testing includes the entire protective relay system
consisting of relay inputs, relay sources, the
protective relays, the relay outputs, associated
communication equipment, and control
circuitry.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 28
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
Typical maintenance of a protective relay system include the
following maintenance task :
 Verify all relay inputs — voltages, currents, pilot signals, and
control signals.
 Verify individual relay performance, timing, settings, and
accuracy.
 Verify all relay outputs — trips, close signal, transfer trip or pilot
signals, breaker failure initiate, alarms, etc., for all setting groups
if applicable.
 Perform a functional trip test of the circuit breaker.
 Perform a functional test of all auxiliary relays, including lock-
out relays.
 Perform load or in-service tests.
 Perform end-to-end testing where relay scheme is dependent
upon quantities- from the
4/25/2019
other end, such as a line differential. 29
Dept of Instrumentation Technology
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
MONITORING BY ANALYSIS OF FAULT
RECORDS:
 Fault record processing systems gather the data and they
search for evidence of component failures or setting
problems hidden behind an operation whose overall
outcome seems to be correct.
 A typical Fault record will verify particular parts of
certain Protection Systems in the vicinity of the Fault.
 For a given Protection System installation, it may or may
not be possible to gather, within a reasonable amount of
time, a collection of internal and external Fault records
that completely verify the Protection System.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 30


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

MONITORING BY ANALYSIS OF
FAULT RECORDS:
Machine fault can be defined as any change in a
machinery part or component which makes it
unable to perform its function satisfactorily .
or
It can be defined as the termination of
availability of an item to perform its intended
function.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 31
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

 Maintenance can be defined as the total


activities carried out in order to restore or
renew an item to working condition, if fault
is there.
 Maintenance is also defined as combination
of action carried out to return an item to or
restore it to an acceptable condition.
 The classification of maintenance according to
timings of action for maintenance is shown in
Table 1.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 32
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 33


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 34


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 35


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 36


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 37


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 38


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 39


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 40


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 41


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 42


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 Fault records may verify that the particular
relays that tripped are able to trip via the
control circuit path that was specifically
used to clear that fault.
 A relay or DFR record may indicate correct
operation of the protection communications
channel.
 Furthermore, other nearby protection systems
may verify that they restrain from tripping
for a fault just outside their respective zones
of protection.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 43
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 44


4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 45
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 46
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 47
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 48


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 49


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 50


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
Performance-Based Maintenance
 A performance-based maintenance process may
justify longer maintenance intervals, or require
shorter intervals.
 In order to use a performance-based maintenance
process, the documented maintenance program
must include records of repairs, adjustments,
and corrections to covered protection systems.
 The system owner must regularly analyze these
records of corrective actions to develop a
ranking of causes.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 51
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
• Recurrent problems are to be highlighted,
and remedial action plans are to be
documented to mitigate or eliminate
recurrent problems.
• A performance-based maintenance program
requires auditing processes like those
included in widely used industrial quality
systems (such as ISO 9001-2000, Quality
management systems — Requirements; or
applicable parts of the NIST Baldridge
National Quality Program).
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 52
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

The audits periodically evaluate:


 The completeness of the documented
maintenance process.
 Organizational knowledge of and adherence
to the process.
 Performance metrics and documentation of
results.
 Remediation of issues.
 Demonstration of continuous improvement.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 53
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 PBM method looks at individual relay system
performance for each fault that it is exposed to
and determines appropriate maintenance
requirements based on actual relay
performance.
 PBM method can be used to extend the intervals
between time-based testing. It is based on a
determination that the relay system performed
satisfactorily for a recent event.
 Performance-based testing is most appropriate
for transmission or distribution lines that
experience periodic
4/25/2019
fault operations.
Dept of Instrumentation Technology 54
MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE
VERIFICATION INTERVALS
 The maximum allowable testing intervals and
maintenance activities show how CBM (Condition
based Maintenance) with newer device types can
reduce the need for many of the tests and site visits
that older Protection System components require.
 Periodic maintenance testing is performed to ensure
that the protection and control system is operating
correctly after a time period of field installation.
 These tests may be used to ensure that individual
components are still operating within acceptable
performance parameters ‐ this type of test is needed
for components susceptible to degraded or changing
characteristics due to aging and wear.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 55
Unmonitored:
Applies to electromechanical and analog solid
state protection systems.
 The telecommunications equipment (Category 5
of Table) used with these legacy systems
frequently includes partial or full monitoring
capabilities, allowing longer testing intervals for
that category of equipment 5 years
Partially Monitored
 Applies to microprocessor relays and associated
protection system components whose self-
monitoring alarms are transmitted to a location
where action can be taken for alarmed failures.(7
Years)

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 56


Thoroughly Monitored
 Applies to microprocessor relays and associated
protection system components that meet partial
monitoring requirements, plus additional monitoring of
alarms and performance measurement values.

 With these additional monitoring actions, the bulk


of the protection system elements that are likely to
fail are monitored continuously or frequently, so that
maximum allowable verification intervals may be
significantly extended.
 Even these additional monitoring steps do not assure
that every possible failure is detected, so infrequent
periodic verification is still required.(10 Years)

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 57


Fully Monitored
 Applies to microprocessor relays and associated
protection system components in which every
element or function required for correct operation
of the protection system is monitored continuously or
verified, including verification of the means by which
failure alarms or indicators are transmitted to a
central location for immediate action.
 Full monitoring includes all elements of thorough
monitoring.
 For fully-monitored systems or segments,
documentation is required that shows how every
possible failure, including a failure in the
verification or monitoring system or alarming
channel, is detected. ( Continuous Monitoring and
Verification)
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 58
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

Condition-Based Maintenance (CbM)


 Condition-based maintenance (CbM) refers
to a collection of activities, inspections, tests
and procedures that are performed in
response to the failure or destabilization of
equipment, a machine or a material.
 It focuses on responding to the root causes of
machine or material failure, and dealing
with those issues after problems occur.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 59
 Condition-based maintenance is performed only when a
need arises, typically in response to a deviation from the
normal operation of a machine or piece of equipment.
 CbM is based on using real-time data trends to optimize
maintenance resources. Via continuous monitoring, a
computerized system observes the equipment's health, and
action is taken only when necessary.
 It is dependent on the collection of historical data for the
component in question. Present conditions of the equipment
or material are then continuously compared to a historical
baseline. This baseline is used as a point of reference for
system upsets.
 Challenges of CbM include its high cost, interruptions with
production output when performed in a large processing
facility and the need for specialized personnel to perform
recovery
4/25/2019 tasks. Dept of Instrumentation Technology 60
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

 CBM is a maintenance program that


recommends maintenance actions (decisions)
based on the information collected through
condition monitoring process.
• In CBM, the lifetime (age) of the
equipmentis monitored through its
operating condition, which can be measured
based on various monitoring parameters, such
as vibration,temperature, lubricating oil,
contaminants, and noise levels
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 61
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 The motivation of CBM is that 99 per cent of
equipment failures are preceded by certain signs,
conditions, or indications that a failure is going to
occur .
 Therefore, CBM is needed for better equipment
health management, lower life cycle cost,
catastrophic failure avoidance etc.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 62


4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 63
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 64
 The heart of CBM is the condition monitoring (CM)
process, where signals are continuously monitored
using certain types of sensor or other appropriate
indicators. Thus, maintenance activities (e.g., repairs
or replacements) are performed only ‘when needed’
or just before failure .
 In general, the main goal of CBM is to perform a
real-time assessment of equipment conditions in
order to make maintenance decisions,
consequently reducing unnecessary maintenance
and related costs. Fig. 5 presents two important
processes of CBM.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 65
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 66
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 67
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 Time-based maintenance, also known as
periodic-based maintenance is a traditional
maintenance technique.
 In TBM, maintenance decisions (e.g., preventive
repair times/intervals) are determined based on
failure time analyses. In other words, the aging
(expected lifetime), T, of some equipment is
estimated based on failure time data or used-
based data .
 TBM assumes that the failure behavior
(characteristic) of the equipment is predictable.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 68
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 69


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

• Failure rate trends can be divided into three


phases: burn-in,useful life, and wear-out.
• The TBM technique assumes that equipment
experience decreasing failure rates early in
their life cycle (burn-in), followed by a near
constant failure rate (useful life). At the end
of their life cycles (wear-out), equipment
experience increasing failure rates.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 70


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

 The first process of TBM starts with failure


data analysis/modeling.The basic purpose of
this process is to statistically investigate the
failure characteristics of the equipment
based on the set of failure time data
gathered.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 71


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 72


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 73


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

OVERLAPPING THE VERIFICATION OF


SEGMENTS OF THE PROTECTION
SYSTEM:
 Every protection system element be periodically verified.
One approach is to test the entire protection scheme as a
unit, from voltage and current sources to breaker tripping.
 For practical ongoing verification, segments of the
protection system may be tested or monitored individually.
The boundaries of the verified segments must overlap to
insure that there are no gaps in the verification.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 74


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
To be technically valid, maintenance
programs should be supported by
documentation showing how the verified
protection system segments overlap so that
no segment is left unverified.
Figure shown below gives an example of how
the overlapping of monitoring and tests
might be accomplished in a carrier blocking
pilot line protection system; it demonstrates
monitoring gaps that must be covered by
testing.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 75
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 76


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 77


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 Figure shows protection for a critical
transmission line by carrier blocking
directional comparison pilot relaying.
 The goal is to verify the ability of the entire two-
terminal pilot protection scheme to protect for
line faults, and to avoid over-tripping for faults
external to the transmission line zone of
protection bounded by the current transformer
locations.
 verification takes advantage of the self-
monitoring features of microprocessor
multifunction line relays at each end of the
line.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 78
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 For each of the line relays themselves, the example
assumes that the user has the following
arrangements in place:
 The relay has a data communications port that can
be accessed from remote locations.
 The relay has internal self-monitoring programs
and functions that report failures of internal
electronics, via communications messages or
alarm contacts to SCADA.
 The relays report loss of dc power, and the relays
themselves or external monitors report the state of
the dc battery supply.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 79
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 The CT and PT inputs to the relays are used for continuous
calculation of metered values of volts, amperes, plus Watts
and VARs on the line. These metered values are reported by
data communications.
 For maintenance, the user selects to compare these readings
to those of other relays, meters, or DFRs.
 The other readings may be from redundant relaying or
measurement systems or they may be derived from values
in other protection zones.
 Comparison with other such readings to within required
relaying accuracy verifies instrument transformers, wiring,
and analog signal input processing of the relays.
 One effective way to do this is to utilize the relay metered
values directly in SCADA, where they can be compared with
other references or state estimator values.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 80
 Breaker status indication from auxiliary contacts is verified
in the same way as in (2). Status indications must be
consistent with the flow or absence of current.
 Continuity of the breaker trip circuit from dc bus through
the trip coil is monitored by the relay and reported via
communications.
 Correct operation of the on-off carrier channel is also
critical to security of the protection system, so each carrier
set has a connected or integrated automatic checkback
test unit.
 The automatic checkback test runs several times a day.
Newer carrier sets with integrated checkback testing
check for received signal level and report abnormal
channel attenuation or noise, even if the problem is not
severe
4/25/2019 enough to completely disable
Dept of Instrumentation Technology the channel. 81
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

All of the methodologies expressed within this


report may be combined by an entity, as
appropriate, to establish and operate a
maintenance program.
 For example, a protection system may be
divided into four or more overlapping
segments with a different maintenance
methodology for each segment:

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 82


COMPARE RULES OF PSMP – 5.2.1 TO 5.2.7 :
 Condition Based Maintenance :continuously or frequently
reported results from non-disruptive self monitoring of
components demonstrate operational status as those
components remain in service.
 Time Based Maintenance: externally prescribed maximum
maintenance or testing intervals are applied for components or
groups of components.
 Performance Based Maintenance: extend TBM test time
intervals by analyzing records showing low failure rates of
particular equipment families receiving TBM-demonstrated
reliability.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 83


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

Overlapping the verification of Segments of


the protection system
 It describes segments of the protection system, and
overlapping considerations for full verification of
the protection system by segments.
 Segments refer to pieces of the protection system,
which can range from a single device to a panel to an
entire substation.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 84


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 Monitoring by analysis of Fault Records:
describes how relay operating records can serve
as a basis for verification, reducing the
frequency of manual testing.
 Self Monitoring Capabilities and Limitations
describes how a cooperative effort of relay
manufacturers and protection system users can
improve the coverage of self- monitoring
functions, leading to full monitoring of for the
bulk of the protection system, and eventual
elimination of manual
4/25/2019
verification or testing. 85
Dept of Instrumentation Technology
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 86


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 87


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 88


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 89


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 90


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 91


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 92


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 93


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 94


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 95


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

Self Monitoring Capabilities and Limitations


of System Components
 The processors can check themselves, peripheral
circuits, and some connected substation inputs and
outputs such as trip coil continuity.
 Most relay users are aware that these relays have self
monitoring, but are not focusing on exactly what
parts are actually monitored.
 As explained further below, every element critical to
the protection system must be monitored, or else
verified periodically.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 96
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 Microprocessor relay proponents have cited the
self‐monitoring capabilities of these products for
nearly 20 years.
 Theoretically, any element that is monitored
does not need a periodic manual test.
 A problem today is that the community of
manufacturers and users has not created clear
documentation of exactly what is and is not
monitored.
 Some unmonitored but critical elements are
buried in installed systems that are described as
self‐monitoring.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 97
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

To utilize the extended time intervals allowed


by monitoring, the user must document that
the monitoring attributes of the device match
the minimum requirements listed in the Table 1.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 98


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

Until users are able to document how all


parts of a system which are required for the
protective functions are monitored or
verified (with help from manufacturers), they
must continue with the unmonitored,
partially monitored, or thoroughly
monitored intervals established in Table 1.

4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 99


DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 Going forward, manufacturers and users can
develop mappings of the monitoring within
relays, and monitoring coverage by the relay of
user circuits connected to the relay terminals.
 To enable the use of the most extensive
monitoring (and never again have a hands‐on
maintenance requirement), the manufacturers of
the microprocessor‐based self‐monitoring
components in the Protection System should
publish for the user a document or map
thatshows:
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 100
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation

How all internal elements of the product are


monitored for any failure that could impact
Protection System performance.
 Which connected circuits are monitored by
checks implemented within the product;
how to connect and set the product to assure
monitoring of these connected circuits; and
what circuits or potential problems are not
monitored.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 101
With this information in hand, the user can document
full monitoring for some or all segments by:
1.Presenting or referencing the product manufacturer
documents.
2. Explaining in a system design document the
mapping of how every component and circuit that is
critical to protection is monitored by the
microprocessor product(s) or by other design features.
3. Extending the monitoring to include the alarm
transmission facilities through which failures are
reported to remote centers for immediate action, so
that failures of monitoring or alarming systems also lead
to alarms and action.
4. Documenting the plans for verification of any
unmonitored elements according to the requirements of
Table 1.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 102
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
 Notify the protection system failures as Report and
Action
 When a failure occurs in a Protection System or
Automatic Reclosing, power system security may be
compromised, and notification of the failure must be
conducted in accordance with relevant NERC
standard(s).
 Knowledge of the failure may impact the system
operator’s decisions on acceptable Loading conditions.
 This formal reporting of the failure and repair status
to the system operator by the Protection System or
Automatic Reclosing owner also encourages the
system owner to execute repairs as rapidly as
possible.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 103
DSCE
DEPT OF ELECTRONICS and INSTRUMENTATION ENGINEERING
IEEI821 Safety Instrumentation
In some cases, a microprocessor relay or
carrier set can be replaced in hours;
wiring termination failures may be repaired
in a similar time frame.
On the other hand, a component in an
electromechanical or early‐generation
electronic relay may be difficult to find and
may hold up repair for weeks.
In some situations, the owner may have to
resort to a temporary protection panel, or
complete panel replacement.
4/25/2019 Dept of Instrumentation Technology 104

You might also like