Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Topic 3 Bonds Volatility New Summer
Topic 3 Bonds Volatility New Summer
0
Outline
1
Bond Price / Yield Relationship
• A fundamental property of a bond is that its price changes in the
opposite direction from the change in the required yield.
• The reason is that the price of the bond is the present value of the
cash flows.
• If we graph the price-yield relationship for any option-free bond, we
will find that it has the “bowed” shape.
Market yield
Holding maturity constant, a rate decrease will raise prices a greater percent
than a corresponding increase in rates will lower prices
2
Bond Price in a Time Path
Assuming constant interest rates over time:
1. If the coupon is lower than the market interest rate the
bond price will be below par. The discount will however
decline as the bond moves towards maturity.
2. If the coupon is higher than the market interest rate the
bond price will be above par. The premium will however
decline as the bond moves towards maturity.
3. If the coupon is the same as the market interest rate the
bond price will be par and will stay so until maturity.
2
Price 3
1
Time
3
Bond Price Volatility – Question
Suppose you are reviewing a price sheet for bonds and see
the following prices. You observe what seems to be several
pricing errors. Without calculating the price of each bond,
indicate which bonds seem to be reported incorrectly, and
explain why. All bonds have a nominal value of 100.
Bond Price CPN (%) Yield (%)
A 90 6 9
B 96 9 8
C 110 8 6
D 105 0 5
E 107 7 9
F 100 6 6
4
Bond Price - Volatility
5
Bond Price Volatility – Coupon Size
The smaller the coupon then the larger the price volatility.
Bond Value - Different Coupon with Fixed Maturity
Bond Value
6
Bond Price Volatility – Maturity
The longer the maturity then the larger the price volatility.
$2,000.00
Years to Mat
1
2
Bond Prices
$1,500.00
3
5
10
$1,000.00
15
20
$500.00 25
30
$0.00
0.5% 1.0% 1.5% 2.0% 2.5% 3.0% 3.5% 4.0% 4.5% 5.0% 5.5% 6.0% 6.5% 7.0% 7.5% 8.0%
Market Interest Rate
7
Bond Price Volatility - Summary
• Bond prices are inversely related to bond yields.
Implication: When market rates fall, bond prices rise, and vice versa.
• Generally, for a given coupon rate, the longer is the time to maturity, the
greater is the percentage price change for a given shift in yields. (The
maturity effect)
Implication: Long-term bonds are riskier than short-term bonds for a given
shift in yields, but also have more potential for gain if rates fall.
• For a given maturity, the lower is the coupon rate, the greater is the
percentage price change for a given shift in yields. (The coupon effect)
Implication: Low-coupon bonds are riskier than high-coupon bonds given
the same maturity, but also have more potential for gain if rates fall.
• For a given coupon rate and maturity, the price increase from a given
reduction in yield will always exceed the price decrease from an equivalent
increase in yield. (The convexity effect)
8
Properties of Bond Price Volatility
1. Bond prices and market interest rates move in opposite
directions. i.e. an inverse, nonlinear relationship.
2. Small changes in the required yield produce relatively
symmetrical changes in the bond’s price. That is, bond
price increases and decreases that result from small
changes in the required yield are approximately equal.
3. Large changes in the required yield produce unequal
changes in the bond’s price. A large decrease in the yield
will produce a greater increase in the bond’s price when
compared to the decrease in price that results from an
increase in the required yield of the same magnitude.
9
Properties of Bond Price Volatility
10
Measuring Bond Price Volatility
11
Measures of Bond Price Volatility
Price Value of a Basis Point – PV01 (more in later topics)
- The price value of a basis point, also referred to as the dollar
value of an 01 (also known as DV01), is the change in the price
of the bond if the required yield changes by 1 basis point.
- Note that this measure of price volatility indicates dollar price
volatility as opposed to percentage price volatility (price change
as a percent of the initial price).
- Typically, the price value of a basis point is expressed as the
“absolute value” of the change in price.
- PV01 value is the same for an increase or a decrease of 1 basis
point in required yield except in opposite sign “+” or “-”.
- Because this measure of price volatility is in terms of dollar price
change, dividing the price value of a basis point by the initial
price gives the percentage price change for a 1-basis-point
change in yield.
12
Example – PV01 Calculation
• Initial Prices:
5 80 1000
PA = + = 924.18
t =1 (1 + .10)
t 5
(1 + .10)
20 50 1000
PB = + = 705.46
t =1 (1 + .08)
t
(1 + .08) 20
20 80 1000
PC = + = 1000.00
t =1 (1 + .08)
t
(1 + .08) 20
13
Example – PV01 Calculation
• Initial Prices:
5
80 1000
PA = (1 + .1001)
t
+ 5
= 923.825 PV01 = 0.355
t =1 (1 + .1001)
20
50 1000
PB =
t
t =1 (1 + .0801)
+
(1 + .0801) 20
= 704.694
PV01 = 0.766
20
80 1000
PC =
t
t =1 (1 + .0801)
+
(1 + .0801) 20
= 999.019
PV01 = 0.981
14
Bond Price Volatility Example
• Prices after yields increase by 50 bp:
5 80 1000
PA = + = 906.43
t =1 (1 + .105)
t
(1 + .105)5
20
50 1000
PB = (1 + .085) t
+ 20
= 668.78
t =1 (1 + .085)
20
80 1000
PC = (1 + .085) t
+
(1 + .085) 20
= 952.68
t =1
15
Bond Price Volatility Example
• Question: Where would Bond D, which has a coupon rate of 6% and
a maturity of 19 years, fit into this price sensitivity spectrum?
(Assume its initial yield is also 8%.)
19 60 1000
Initial: PD = + = 807.93
t =1 (1 + .08)
t
(1 + .08)19
19 60 1000
After: PD = + = 768.31
t =1 (1 + .085)
t
(1 + .085)19
16
Measures of Bond Price Volatility
Duration Concept by
• The Macaulay duration is one measure of the approximate change in
price for a small change in yield.
• It is the weighted maturity average of the payment dates, using the
present value of the relative cash payments as the weights.
17
Why is Duration Important?
18
Measuring Duration (Macaulay, Modified, Dollar)
Macaulay duration is a weighted average of the cash flows for the bond
PVCFt n
Wt ; D Mac Wt t where PVCFt CFt /(1 r) t
P t -1
n
PVCFt t
D Mac CFt = Cash Flow at period t (Coupon & Principal)
t 1 P P = Bond Price; t = period
Example: A bond has 2 years maturity pays a $6 coupon semi annually. The yield
curve is flat at an semi annual interest rate of 10%p.a.
6 6 6 106
P 1
2
3
4
(1.05) (1.05) (1.05) (1.05)
$5.71 $5.44 $5.18 $87.21 $103.54
4
PV(CFt) t 5.71x1 5.44x2 5.18x3 87.21x4
D Mac -
t 1 P 103.54 103.54 103.54 103.54
0.055 0.105 0.15 3.369 3.68 years (semi annual)
Annual DMac = Semi DMac /2 = -3.68/2 = -1.84 years 19
Example: Macaulay Duration Calculation
PVCFt
5 2 120 99.17 0.0922 0.1844
D Mac t 3 120 90.16 0.0838 0.2514
t 1 P
4 120 81.96 0.0762 0.3047
5 1120 695.43 0.6464 3.2321
$1075.82 1.0000 4.074 yrs
or:
(109.09) 99.17 90.16
DMAC x1 1,075.82 x2 1,075.82 x3
1,075.82
81.96 695.43
x 4 1,075.82 x5 4.0740
1,075.82
20
Macaulay Duration Calculation – A simplified Equation
n
PVCFt t (1 r) 1 r [n(c - r)]
D Mac can be simplified to D MAC
t 1 P r c [(1 r) n - 1] r
c = coupon; r = yield to maturity; N = no. of period
Example: Consider a 2-year coupon bond with a face and redemption value of
$100 and a coupon rate of 10% p.a. payable semiannually and a yield to maturity
of 12% p.a compounded semiannually. Find the Macaulay Duration.
c=5%; r=6%; N=4
21
Other Duration Formulas
1. Annuity cashflow:
DMac = ((1+r)/r) - N/((1+r)N -1)
2. Perpetuity cashflow:
DMac = (1+r)/r
DMod = (1/r)
22
Uses of Duration
1. Immunization strategies:
- If you equate the duration of an asset (bond) with
the duration of a liability, you will (subject to some
limitations) immunize your investment portfolio from
interest rate risk.
2. Used in predicting (or estimating) bond prices given a
change in interest rates (yields)
23
Duration Application - Estimating Price Changes
ΔP/P
D Mac ; ΔP/P - D Mac Δ(1 r)/(1 r)
Δ(1 r)/(1 r)
Δr
DP = Change in Bond Price ΔP -DMAC P
(1 r)
Duration is positively related to maturity and negatively related to coupon.
Changes on Bond price are also directly related to duration.
As a result the % Change in the Bonds Price Is Proportional to Its
Duration
24
Duration Application - Estimating Price Changes
Use of Duration to predict prices changes when yield changes
Example – % Change in Price (using Duration rule)
We have a 15 year bond with 8%p.a. annual coupon offering at
$84.63 to yield 10%. If Duration (DMac) = 8.45 years, we can infer what
is the impact on the bond price for a small changes on the yield.
So let yield increase to 10.10% change in yield is 0.1%
- ΔP/P
D Mac ΔP/P - D Mac Δ(r)/(1 r)
Δ(1 r)/(1 r)
(0.1%)
ΔP/P 8.45 0.00768
(1 10%)
ΔP/P - 0.768% % Change due to a change in yield of 0.1%
25
Macaulay’s Duration - Example
A 5 year bond paying a semi annual coupon of 10%p.a. with a price of
$1000 and a YTM of 10%p.a.
n
PVCFt t
D Mac
t 1 P
26
Macaulay’s Duration - Example
A 5 year bond paying a semi annual coupon of 10%p.a. with a price of
$1000 and a YTM of 10%p.a.
28
Properties of Duration - Maturity
Duration
(as a function of the bond maturity)
10
9
8
7
Duration
5
4
2
1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Maturity
29
Properties of Duration - Coupon
20
18
16
14
Duration
12
10
0
1% 3% 5% 7% 9% 11% 13% 15% 17% 19%
Coupon Rate
30
Properties of Duration - YTM
Duration
(as a function of the yield)
16
14
12
10
Duration
0
1% 3% 5% 7% 9% 11% 13% 15% 17% 19%
Yield
31
Modified Duration
32
Modified Duration
If a bond pays annual coupons (once per year) n = 1
Then Modified Duration, DMod :
D Mac ΔP/P
D Mod Remember : D Mac
1 r/1 Δ(1 r)/(1 r)
So Modified Duration (DMod) is the price duration of a bond that shows the
% change in the bond price resulting from a % change in the redemption
yield. To get the % change in bond price, the % change must be
multiplied by the original bond price.
33
Example - Modified Duration
10 year semi-annual bond, YTM 10%p.a., DMac is 4.055
This shows that for every 1% movement in interest rates, the bond is this
example would inversely move in price by 3.86%.
The modified duration (DMod) can be used to estimate the % bond price
change (DP/P) as interest rates change
ΔP
% ΔBond Price D Mod Δr
P
Example: If the annual interest rates increases from 10% to 10.2% (0.2%
increase) then we can estimate the bond price by usind Dmod.
-3.86*0.2 = -0.772%
34
Using Modified Duration to calculate PV01
• Consider a five-year, 12% annual coupon bond with a YTM of 10%
trading at 107.582:
- Macaulay D = 4.074
- Modified D = 3.704 [= 4.074 /(1+0.1)]
This means that an increase in yields of 1% or 100 bp will change the
bond’s price by approximately 3.704% in opposite direction
ΔP DMod Δr P
35
Dollar ($) Duration
• The Dollar duration ($D) is defined as the product of the
Modified Duration and the bond price (value). It gives the
variation in a bond's dollar value for a small variation in the
yield.
$ D D Mod x Bond Price D
ΔP/P
Mod
Δr
ΔP/P ΔP
$D- xP-
Dr Dr
36
Calculating Duration in a Bond Portfolio
The duration of a portfolio is simply the weighted average
duration of the bonds in the portfolios. Portfolio duration is
simply the weighted duration of all the bonds in the portfolio:
N
Portfolio Duration w j x Duration j
j1
37
Portfolio Duration
Consider the following portfolio of semiannual payment bonds.
Face Value Coupon Maturity Yield (s.a.) Market Value Annual Duration
$50 Million 8% 12 yrs 9.62% $44,306,787 7.652
$25 Million 11% 8 yrs 9.38% $27,243,887 5.633
$25 Million 9% 6 yrs 9.10% $24,886,343 4.761
$96,437,017
= 6.336
38
Portfolio Duration
Question : What is the duration of a portfolio consisting of 75%
of 1.5 year zero coupon bond and 25% of 30 year zero coupon
bond?
Answer :
The Duration (DMac) of the 1.5 year zero coupon bond is 1.5
and the Duration (DMac) of the 30 year zero coupon bond is 30.
Portfolio Duration (DMac) = (75% x 1.5) + (25% x 30) = 8.625
39
Portfolio Duration - Example
Portfolio
(Annual) Contribution to
Holdings Weight
Duration Portfolio Duration
Bond 1 0% 4.95 0
Bond 2 12.1% 3.44 0.42
Bond 3 44.9% 3.58 1.61
Bond 4 13.9% 5.04 0.7
Bond 5 1.7% 3.16 0.05
Bond 6 27.4% 6.35 1.74
Total 100% 4.52
40
Duration Conclusions
41
Problems with Duration
• It assumes a straight line relationship between the changes in bond
price given the change in yield to maturity…however, the actual
relationship is curvilinear…therefore, the greater the change in YTM,
the greater the error in predicted bond price using duration…as can be
seen…
Error from
Bond using duration Current bond
Price only price
Bond Price
Price estimate is good estimated by
$1,200 when yield change is duration
small
$1,100
Actual
$1,000 Bond Price
$900 D
Y
Yield to Maturity (%)
Y*
42
Problems with Duration
Duration is a conservatively biased estimate of actual price changes from
the perspective of the asset-holder.
Duration underestimates price increases when rates fall and
overestimates price reductions when rates rise.
The reason for the bias is the of the price-yield curve for a fixed
income instrument that contains no embedded put or call options. The bias
is greater, the greater is the change in yield. For small rate changes,
duration can be a very accurate predictor of the price change.
Price
Underestimate of Price Increase
When the Yield Falls
43
Convexity
The relationship between bond prices and market yields is CONVEX.
250.0
200.0
Bond Price ($)
150.0
Convex (to
the origin).
100.0
50.0
0.0
0% 5% 10% 15% 20%
Yield
Convexity means that as the YTM falls from 10% the rate of increase in
the bond price accelerates.
44
Convexity
•
45
Convexity
• Bond Convexity is a direct measure of the duration sensitivity of a bond
when its interest rate is changing. As bond yields go higher, price goes
lower. This relationship between price and yield has a convex structure
in nature. The term used to describe this relationship is also known as
convexity. 2
1 d (P)
Conv
P dr 2
• Mathematically, convexity is the rate of change of duration. The degree
to which the graph is curved shows how much a bond's yield changes
in response to a change in price. Convexity is such measure to
compare bonds.
n
Ct t(t 1)/(1 r) t 1 n
Ct t(t 1)
Conv
t 1 P(1 r) 2
P(1 r) 2
t 1 (1 r) t
46
Calculating a bond’s convexity
47
Calculating a bond’s convexity – another example
48
Dollar Convexity
• The Dollar Convexity ($Conv) is convexity multiplied by the
price (value). Dollar convexity is one source of error in
approximating the dollar price of a bond generated by
change in yield using dollar duration alone.
$ Conv Conv x Bond Price
49
Convexity
50
Price Estimation - Convexity and Duration
Estimating Price Change Using Duration and Convexity Measures
Using duration and convexity measures together gives a better
approximation of the actual price change for a large movement in the
required yield.
% DP (Change in Price) =
Price
Underestimate of Price Increase
When the Yield Falls % DP Change in Price due to Duration Adjustment term
51
Price Estimation - Convexity and Duration
Example
8%, 15 years bond with yield = 10%
DMac = 8.4495; P = 84.6275; Convexity = 94.36
If yield rises to 13% (from 10%)
% Change in Price due to Duration
ΔP/P - D Mac Δ(1 r)/(1 r)
[-8.4495/(1 0.1/2)] 0.03 - 24.1%
% Change in Price due to Convexity =
1/2 x Conv x (% Dr)2 =
1/2 x 94.36 x (0.03)2 = 4.25%
52
Convexity and Duration for Price Estimation
Exercise
Suppose 5%, 20 years bond with yield = 9%.
Duration (DMac) = 10.87; Convexity (Conv) = 170.22
If yield changes from 9% to 11% (2% or 200 basis point
increase).
Estimate the change in bond price?
% Change in Price =
% Change in Price due to Duration
+
% Change in Price due to Convexity
53
Convexity and Duration for Price Estimation
54
Convexity
Value of Convexity
• The two bonds have the same duration and are offering
the same yield; they have different convexities, however,
Bond B is more convex (bowed) than bond A.
55
Convexity
Coupon Time to Maturity YTM Duration
Bond A 15% 3 10% 3.154
Bond B 13.78% 3.89 10% 3.154
Two bonds have the same yield but one exhibits greater convexity,
changes in interest rates will affect each bond differently.
56
Observations:
• A bond with greater convexity is less affected by an
increase in interest rates than a bond with less convexity.
57
Convexity
Value of Convexity
• The market considers a bond’s convexity
• If investors expect that market yields will change by
very little, investors should not be willing to pay much
for convexity.
• If the market prices convexity high, investors with
expectations of low interest rate volatility will probably
want to “sell convexity.”
58
Properties of Convexity
59
Portfolio Convexity
60
Portfolio Convexity
61
Summary
Duration and convexity are measures of sensitivity of a bond
price to changes in yield.
Duration is the first derivative and convexity is the second
derivative
Convexity is the rate of change of duration with changes in
yield.
Convexity is ‘correction’ to duration
Both Duration and Convexity has the same relationship:
directly related to time to maturity,
inversely related to coupon size and
inversely related to YTM.
62
Summary
Used as a risk measure for interest rate sensitivity
Determine hedging of interest rate risk (immunization)
There are several different definitions of duration:
• Macaulay duration (DMac) and modified duration (DMod)
• Differ by factor of (1+yield)
Zero-coupon long-dated bonds have the highest duration.
63