Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lesson 3: Being Sensitive To Others
Lesson 3: Being Sensitive To Others
Lesson 3: Being Sensitive To Others
LESSON 3
BEING SENSITIVE
TO OTHERS
“WE CANNOT BE MORE
SENSITIVE TO PLEASURE
WITHOUT BEING MORE
SENSITIVE TO PAIN.”
– ALAN WATTS
Y
O
U
R
TASK 1: PICTURES TALK
I
N LOOK AT THE PHOTOS BELOW.
I
T WHAT DO THEY REVEAL ABOUT
I
A
L
MEN, WOMEN, AND CHILDREN?
T WRITE YOUR ANSWERS IN YOUR
A
S
K
NOTEBOOK.
S
1. WITH YOUR PARTNER, DESCRIBE EACH
PICTURE. WHAT DO THEY REVEAL ABOUT
MEN AND WOMEN?
2. SHOULD WOMEN ALWAYS BE PICTURED AS
DOING HOUSEHOLD CHORES AND MEN AS
WARRIORS? WHY?
TASK 2: MIND YOUR WORD
FIND OUT THE MESSAGE
CONVEYED BY THE COMIC STRIP
AND BE READY TO SHARE YOUR
IDEAS IN CLASS.
1. DISCUSSION POINTS: 1. WHAT IS THE
CHARACTER IN THE COMIC STRIP
PREJUDICED/BIASED FOR? AGAINST?
2. WHAT COULD BE THE REASON FOR THE
PREJUDICE/BIAS?
3. IS IT RIGHT TO HAVE PREJUDICES OR BIASES?
4. CAN YOU THINK OF WORDS THAT YOU COULD ASSOCIATE
WITH PREJUDICE/BIAS? WRITE THEM IN THE WORD WEB
BELOW.
TASK 3: WATCH THAT LABEL
A. HERE’S A VIDEO FEATURING A FILIPINA
ACTRESS WHO CLAIMS THAT IT’S NOT
RIGHT TO PUT A LABEL ON ANYONE.
WATCH IT AND FIND OUT THE LABEL
ATTACHED TO HER. ATTACHED TO HER.
WWW.YOUTUBE.COM/WATCH?V=XYSVCK
FQ8E
1. WHAT IS THE “LABEL” ATTACHED TO THE WOMAN IN THE VIDEO?
2. DO YOU AGREE WITH WHAT THE WOMAN SAID? WHY?
3. WHEN YOU PUT A “LABEL” ON SOMEONE, ARE YOU ALSO BEING
BIASED? EXPLAIN.
4. WHAT ADVICE WOULD YOU GIVE TO THE WOMAN IN THE VIDEO?
5. WHAT COMMENTS DO YOU HEAR FROM OTHER PEOPLE ABOUT
WOMEN IN THE SAME SITUATION AS THE ACTRESS? HOW SHOULD
YOU REACT TO THEM?
B. HAVE YOU HEARD AND SEEN EXAMPLES OF BIAS AROUND YOU? FILL OUT THE
TABLE BELOW FOR MORE EXAMPLES OF BIAS AND PREJUDICE YOU HAVE
EXPERIENCED AROUND YOU. WORK ON IT WITH YOUR PARTNER. IN THE
SECOND COLUMN, WRITE EXAMPLES OF ADVERTISEMENTS AND IN THE LAST
COLUMN, WRITE THE BIAS FOUND IN EACH EXAMPLE.
C. CAN BIASES BE AVOIDED? HOW?
______________________________________
______________________________________
______________________________________
_______________________
TASK 4: BIAS DETECTIVES
SOURCE:
HTTP://WWW.SADKER.ORG/CURRICUL
ARBIAS.HTML ACCORDING TO A
GROUP OF RESEARCHERS THERE ARE
SEVEN FORMS OF BIAS IN
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS.THEY ARE
AS FOLLOWS:
1. INVISIBILITY: WHAT YOU DON’T SEE MAKES A LASTING
IMPRESSION
THE MOST FUNDAMENTAL AND OLDEST FORM OF BIAS IN
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IS THE COMPLETE OR RELATIVE
EXCLUSION OF A GROUP. WITH AN ATTEMPT FOR INCLUSION
AFTER 1960, MANY OF TODAY’S TEXTBOOKS ARE IMPROVED, BUT
FAR FROM PERFECT. WOMEN, THOSE WITH DISABILITIES, GAYS,
AND HOMOSEXUALS CONTINUE TO BE MISSING FROM MANY
OF TODAY’S TEXTS.
2. STEREOTYPING: SHORTCUTS TO BIGOTRY
PERHAPS THE MOST FAMILIAR FORM OF BIAS IS THE
STEREOTYPE, WHICH ASSIGNS A RIGID SET OF
CHARACTERISTICS TO ALL MEMBERS OF A GROUP, AT THE COST
OF INDIVIDUAL ATTRIBUTES AND DIFFERENCES. WHILE
STEREOTYPES CAN BE POSITIVE, THEY ARE MORE OFTEN
NEGATIVE. SOME TYPICAL STEREOTYPES INCLUDE: MEN
PORTRAYED AS ASSERTIVE AND SUCCESSFUL IN THEIR JOBS, BUT
RARELY DISCUSSED AS HUSBANDS OR FATHERS. WOMEN AS
CAREGIVERS.
3. IMBALANCE AND SELECTIVITY: A TALE HALF TOLD
CURRICULUM MAY PERPETUATE BIAS BY PRESENTING ONLY ONE
INTERPRETATION OF AN ISSUE, SITUATION, OR GROUP OF PEOPLE. SUCH
ACCOUNTS SIMPLIFY AND DISTORT COMPLEX ISSUES BY OMITTING
DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES. A TEXT REPORTS THAT WOMEN WERE “GIVEN”
THE VOTE, BUT DOES NOT DISCUSS THE WORK, SACRIFICES, AND EVEN
PHYSICAL ABUSE SUFFERED BY THE LEADERS OF THE SUFFRAGE
MOVEMENT THAT “WON” THE VOTE. LITERATURE IS DRAWN PRIMARILY
FROM WESTERN, MALE AUTHORS. MATH AND SCIENCE COURSES
TYPICALLY REFERENCE EUROPEAN DISCOVERIES AND FORMULAS.
4. UNREALITY: ROSE COLORED GLASSES
MANY RESEARCHERS HAVE NOTED THE TENDENCY
OF INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS TO GLOSS OVER
UNPLEASANT FACTS AND EVENTS IN OUR HISTORY.
ANOTHER EXAMPLE IS THE NOTION THAT
TECHNOLOGY WILL RESOLVE PERSISTENT SOCIAL
PROBLEMS.
5. FRAGMENTATION AND ISOLATION: THE PARTS ARE LESS THAN THE
WHOLE
FRAGMENTATION EMERGES WHEN A GROUP IS PHYSICALLY OR
VISUALLY ISOLATED IN THE TEXT. OFTEN, RACIAL AND ETHNIC
GROUP MEMBERS ARE DEPICTED AS INTERACTING ONLY WITH
PERSONS LIKE THEMSELVES, ISOLATED FROM OTHER CULTURAL
COMMUNITIES. WHILE THIS FORM OF BIAS MAY BE LESS DAMAGING
THAN OMISSION OR STEREOTYPES, FRAGMENTATION AND
ISOLATION PRESENT NON-DOMINANT GROUPS AS PERIPHERAL
MEMBERS OF SOCIETY.
6.LINGUISTIC BIAS: WORDS COUNT
LANGUAGE CAN BE A POWERFUL CONVEYOR OF BIAS,
IN BOTH BLATANT AND SUBTLE FORMS. LINGUISTIC BIAS
CAN IMPACT RACE/ETHNICITY, GENDER, ACCENTS, AGE,
(DIS)ABILITY, AND SEXUAL ORIENTATION. SUCH WORDS AS
FOREFATHERS, MANKIND, AND BUSINESSMAN SERVE TO
DENY THE CONTRIBUTIONS (EVEN THE EXISTENCE) OF
FEMALES.
7. COSMETIC BIAS: “SHINY” COVERS
THE RELATIVELY NEW COSMETIC BIAS SUGGESTS THAT A TEXT IS BIAS
FREE, BUT BEYOND THE ATTRACTIVE COVERS, PHOTOS, OR POSTERS, BIAS
PERSISTS. AN EXAMPLE IS A SCIENCE TEXTBOOK THAT FEATURES A
GLOSSY PULLOUT OF FEMALE SCIENTISTS BUT INCLUDES PRECIOUS
LITTLE NARRATIVE OF THE SCIENTIFIC CONTRIBUTIONS OF WOMEN.
PRETEND THAT YOU ARE A GROUP OF DETECTIVES. USING THE SEVEN
FORMS OF BIAS DISCUSSED HERE, REVIEW YOUR SCHOOL’S ENGLISH
REFERENCE BOOKS/TEXTBOOKS AND IDENTIFY IF IT HAS ANY OF THOSE
FORMS OF BIASES. WRITE THE TITLE OF THE BOOK AND PUT A CHECK
MARK ON THE FORM OF BIAS YOU HAVE DISCOVERED IN THE BOOK(S).
THIS TIME, SUGGEST
WAYS ON HOW TO
AVOID THESE BIASES IN
YOUR ENGLISH
TEXTBOOK.
____________________
____________________
____________________
____________________
____________________
____________________
______
Y TASK 5: LOVE IS EVERYWHERE
O
U
A. BEING SENSITIVE TO OTHERS IS ONE
WAY OF SHOWING LOVE AND CONCERN.
R WHOSE LOVE STORY DO YOU CONSIDER
SPECIAL AND WORTH EMULATING? HERE
T ARE PHOTOS FROM SOME ROMANTIC
E FILMS. MATCH THE DESCRIPTION OF THE
X CHARACTERS IN THE MOVIE TO THE
T PHOTOS.
DANIELLE, THE ONLY DAUGHTER OF A
DECEASED FRENCH NOBLEMAN, IS
MADE A SERVANT BY HER
STEPMOTHER. SHE ALSO HAS TWO
STEPSISTERS, ONE QUITE KIND BUT
THE OTHER ONE REALLY TERRIBLE.
STILL, DANIELLE GROWS UP TO BE A
HAPPY AND STRONG-WILLED YOUNG
LADY, AND ONE DAY HER PATH
CROSSES THAT OF HANDSOME PRINCE
HENRY, WHO HAS FALLEN IN LOVE
WITH HER. DESPITE SOME TROUBLES,
DANIELLE AND THE PRINCE END UP
TOGETHER WITH THE HELP OF THE
NICE LEONARDO DA VINCI.
REBELLIOUS HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT
LANDON CARTER IS THREATENED WITH
EXPULSION UNLESS HE PERFORMS IN
THE DRAMA CLUB’S SPRING MUSICAL.
AT THIS FUNCTION, HE IS FORCED TO
INTERACT WITH QUIET JAMIE SULLIVAN
WHO HAS HELPED HIM WITH HIS LINES.
DURING THE PLAY, JAMIE SURPRISES
LANDON AND THE ENTIRE AUDIENCE
WITH HER BEAUTY AND VOICE. WHILE
THEIR FRIENDSHIP AND ADMIRATION
FOR EACH OTHER GROWS DEEPER,
JAMIE’S CANCER GETS WORSE.
IN 1912 SOUTHAMPTON, 17-YEAR-
OLD FIRSTCLASS PASSENGER ROSE
DEWITT BUKATER WHO IS
ENGAGED TO BE MARRIED AGAINST
HER WILL PLANS TO JUMP OFF THE
SHIP. JACK DAWSON, A PENNILESS
ARTIST, CONVINCES HER NOT TO.
THIS INCIDENT STARTED THEIR
FRIENDSHIP WHICH LATER ON
DEVELOPS INTO A ROMANTIC LOVE
AFFAIR.
B. CAN YOU NAME OTHER MOVIES THAT SPEAK OF GREAT LOVE?
GIRLS, IN THE FUTURE WHEN A MAN COURTS YOU, HOW WOULD
YOU WANT HIM TO DO IT?
BOYS, HOW DO YOU PLAN TO WIN THE HEART OF YOUR LADYLOVE
SOMEDAY? • LIST DOWN WHAT YOU DREAM OF IN A COURTSHIP.
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
• READ ABOUT THE COURTSHIP DURING THE MIDDLE-AGES.
COMPARE IT WITH YOUR “IDEAL” COURTSHIP.
CHIVALRY AND ROMANTIC IDEALS (MIDDLE AGES, 1100-1500)
THE KNIGHTS AND TROUBADOURS (TRAVELING POETS AND
MUSICIANS) OF MEDIEVAL TIMES OPENED DOORS, PULLED OUT CHAIRS,
AND LET THEIR LADYLOVES ORDER FIRST. THESE MEN KNEW THEIR
LADIES WANTS AND DESIRES, IT ALWAYS CAME FIRST AND FOREMOST IN
LOVE; WINNING LADIES’ HEARTS WAS THEIR ULTIMATE GOAL. WEALTHY
KNIGHTS WON WOMEN’S HANDS THROUGH BRAVE DEEDS, WHILE THE
POETS WON THEM OVER THROUGH THEIR USE OF WORDS AND SONGS.
THESE IDEAS WERE INSPIRED BY “COURTLY LOVE,” WHICH WAS A HIGHLY
IDEALIZED AND EXTRAVAGANT FORBIDDEN AFFAIR (MOSTLY AMONG
THE NOBLE CLASS) WHOSE CORE BELIEFS WERE THE SUPERIORITY OF THE
LADY, THE INSTABILITY OF DESIRE, AND THE ENNOBLING POWER OF
LOVE.
• WHEN ONE IS IN LOVE, ONE HAS THE TENDENCY TO BE BIASED.
NAME AN INCIDENT WHEN YOU DID SOMETHING IN THE NAME OF
LOVE.
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
• HERE ARE POEMS FROM PETRARCH’S CANZONIERE. READ ENJOY
THE RHYME AND RHYTHM, AND DISCOVER THE MESSAGE OF EACH
POEM.
• BEFORE YOU START READING, THINK ABOUT THIS: HOW WOULD
YOU DESCRIBE SOMEONE YOU ARE PASSIONATELY IN LOVE WITH?
LAURA
Translated by Morris Bishop
SHE USED TO LET HER GOLDEN HAIR FLY FREE WHAT WONDER THAT THE FLAME BURNED
FOR THE WIND TO TOY AND TANGLE AND FURIOUSLY?
MOLEST; SHE DID NOT WALK IN ANY MORTAL WAY,
HER EYES WERE BRIGHTER THAN THE BUT WITH ANGELIC PROGRESS; WHEN SHE
RADIANT WEST. SPOKE,
(SELDOM THEY SHINE SO NOW.) I USED TO SEE UNEARTHLY VOICES SANG IN UNISON.
PITY LOOK OUT OF THOSE DEEP EYES ON ME. SHE SEEMED DIVINE AMONG THE DREARY
(“IT WAS FALSE PITY,” YOU WOULD NOW FOLK
PROTEST) OF EARTH.YOU SAY SHE IS NOT SO TODAY?
I HAD LOVE’S TINDER HEAPED WITHIN MY WELL, THOUGH THE BOW’S UNBENT, THE
BREAST; WOUND BLEEDS ON.
THE WHITE DOE TRANSLATED
BY ANNA MARIA ARMI
A PURE-WHITE DOE IN AN EMERALD GLADE AROUND HER LOVELY NECK “DO NOT
APPEARED TO ME, WITH TWO ANTLERS OF TOUCH ME,”
GOLD,
WAS WRITTEN WITH TOPAZ AND
BETWEEN TWO STREAMS, UNDER A LAUREL’S DIAMOND STONE,
SHADE,
“MY CAESAR’S WILL HAS BEEN TO MAKE ME
AT SUNRISE, IN THE SEASON’S BITTER COLD.
FREE.”
HER SIGHT WAS SO SUAVELY MERCILESS
ALREADY TOWARD NOON HAD CLIMBED
THAT I LEFT WORK TO FOLLOW HER AT LEISURE, THE SUN,
LIKE THE MISER WHO LOOKING FOR HIS MY WEARY EYES WERE NOT SATED TO SEE,
TREASURE
WHEN I FELL IN THE STREAM AND SHE WAS
SWEETENS WITH THAT DELIGHT HIS
BITTERNESS. GONE.
THE WHITE DOE TRANSLATED
BY ANNA MARIA ARMI
A PURE-WHITE DOE IN AN EMERALD GLADE AROUND HER LOVELY NECK “DO NOT
APPEARED TO ME, WITH TWO ANTLERS OF TOUCH ME,”
GOLD,
WAS WRITTEN WITH TOPAZ AND
BETWEEN TWO STREAMS, UNDER A LAUREL’S DIAMOND STONE,
SHADE,
“MY CAESAR’S WILL HAS BEEN TO MAKE ME
AT SUNRISE, IN THE SEASON’S BITTER COLD.
FREE.”
HER SIGHT WAS SO SUAVELY MERCILESS
ALREADY TOWARD NOON HAD CLIMBED
THAT I LEFT WORK TO FOLLOW HER AT LEISURE, THE SUN,
LIKE THE MISER WHO LOOKING FOR HIS MY WEARY EYES WERE NOT SATED TO SEE,
TREASURE
WHEN I FELL IN THE STREAM AND SHE WAS
SWEETENS WITH THAT DELIGHT HIS
BITTERNESS. GONE.
SPRING TRANSLATED
BY MORRIS BISHOP
ZEPHYR RETURNS, AND SCATTERS EVERYWHERE BUT TO ME ONLY HEAVY SIGHS RETURN
NEW FLOWERS AND GRASS, AND COMPANY FOR HER WHO CARRIED IN HER LITTLE
DOES BRING, HAND
PROCNE AND PHILOMEL, IN SWEET DESPAIR, MY HEART’S KEY TO HER HEAVENLY
SOJOURN,
AND ALL THE TENDER COLORS OF THE SPRING.
THE BIRDS SING LOUD ABOVE THE
NEVER WERE FIELDS SO GLAD, NOR SKIES SO FLOWERING LAND;
FAIR,
LADIES ARE GRACIOUS NOW – WHERE
AND JOVE EXULTS IN VENUS PROSPERING. DESERTS BURN
LOVE IS IN ALL THE WATER, EARTH AND AIR, THE BEASTS STILL PROWL ON THE
UNGREENING SAND.
AND LOVE POSSESSES EVERY LIVING THING.
TASK 6:THINK ABOUT THE POEMS