Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LECTURE 1 - MARITIME LAW - Introduction To The English Legal System
LECTURE 1 - MARITIME LAW - Introduction To The English Legal System
Law made by judges of the Supreme Court. Legal principles are expressed in court cases. The
principles apply if there is no existing statutory principle on the same topic and they must not
conflict with the statutes or with the constitution. The key concept of this source is ‘judicial
precedent’ – meaning legally binding decision. The rule which is established is called ‘ratio
decidendi’.
The system of following previous decided cases is called ‘doctrine of binding precedent’. The
doctrine of precedent is at the heart of the common law system. The courts are bound by prior
decisions of superior courts. So the District Courts, for example, are bound by decisions of the
Supreme Court.
Note: There is possibility that a new legal principle introduced by a case will not be binding
(obiter dicta principle) if it was extracted from hypothetical facts.
Advantages: adherence to precedent helps achieve stability, which in turn gives predictability
to the law and affords a degree of security for individual rights, while at the same time allows
the system to be adaptable to changing circumstances.
Disadvantages: it is a time consuming and complicated system.
EXERCISE -30 minutes
STATE THE PRINCIPLES (RATIO DECIDENDI) which have been established by the
following cases:
1.Hadley v Baxendale
2.Re City Equitable Fire Insurance
3.Freeman and Lockyer
4.Salomon v salomon
5.Carlill v carbolic smoke ball
6.Donogue v Stevenson
7.Caparo v cape industries
8.Hendley byrne v heller
4. EU LAW
Following the accession of Cyprus to the EU, EU law is now a source of our law
National Statutes must comply and implement EU Law. The law of the EU, which
after accession of Cyprus to the EU, has become part of the law of the country and
inescapably has primary over all national law, including Constitution.
EU TREATIES: the most important is the Treaty of Rome which was the foundation
Treaty of European Commission (E.C) and every new member state undertake the
obligation to follow its principles the most important of which is the obligation to
comply with EU LAW. Other Treaties require member states to respect human
rights(HR) or participate in EU committees etc.
EU DIRECTIVES: A directive is a legislative act of the European Union which is not
self executing and which requires member states to achieve a particular result by
adopting the directive through a national statute. If the member state fails to pass
the required legislation, or if the national legislation does not adequately comply
with the requirements of the directive the European Commission can initiate legal
action against the member state in the European Court of Justice.
Continue…
The common law forms part of the legal system of Cyprus. Section 29 of the
courts of justice law (L.14/60), provides that the common law applies in
Cyprus, provided :
A) that there is no statutory provision governing the matter, and
B) that is consistent with the Constitution of Cyprus.
Therefore the common law acts as the ‘reserve law’ of Cyprus.
6. EQUITY
3. Family Courts: They deal with family disputes such as divorce, custody etc.
4. Industrial Disputes Court: Employment courts dealing with employment
claims.
5. Rent Control Court: Deals with rental agreements
6. Military Court: Deals with military claims
Doctrine of Necessity
As stated by Triantafyllides J. in the Attorney General of the Republic of
Cyprus v Mustafa Ibrahim and others, ‘ the legal doctrine of necessity in
public law is in reality the acceptance of necessity as a source of
authority for acting in a manner not regulated by law but requires, in
prevailing circumstances, by supreme public interest, for the salvation
of the state and its people’.
The Cyprus constitutions required that when legislating both the Turkish
and Grekk members of parliament should together form the quorum.
Under the new constitution, laws could now be validly passed with only
the Greek members participating and that they alone shall previously
form the quorum. In this new constitution, the State argued, that the
Greek members of Parliament would by themselves constitute a valid
quorum, thus excluding the requirement of Turkish participation. This is
a temporary measure, and shall continue so long as the necessitating
conditions persists.
Continue…
The doctrine operates when:
1. An imperative necessity arises because of the existence of exceptional
circumstances not provided for in the Constitution, for immediate
action to be taken to protect or preserve some vital functions of the
state
2. There must be no other course reasonably available
3. Any such action must be reasonably necessary in the interest of peace,
order, and good government, but it must not be more than is
necessary or legislate beyond that
4. It must not impair the just rights of citizens under the Constitution
5. The doctrine does not affect the Constitution. The Constitution
remains in force.
Which of the following is NOT a source
of Cyprus Law?
A. Common law
B. Statutes
C. EU Law
D. Sharia Law
Answer: D
The supreme court of Cyprus is the higher Court in
Cyprus with the Power to deal with the proceedings
for the issue of orders, for example mandamus.
TRUE
FALSE
ANSWER: TRUE
Since Cyprus joined EU, the EU law
prevails over the Constitution
TRUE
FALSE
ANSWER: TRUE
Which of the Following is not EU Law?
1. Regulations
2. Decisions
3. Treaties
4. Directives
5. Delegated legislation
Answer: 5.
Which of the following is correct as
characteristic of Cyprus Legal System ?
1. Only statutes create legal rules
2. Only statutes and the Constitution create legal rules
3. Case law is a primary source of law
4. Case law is not a source of law
Answer: 3.
The ECJ deals with disputes affecting
human rights?
True
False
Answer: False
the District Civil courts have jurisdiction to hear and determine
at first instance all civil actions, with the exception of matters
that fall within the jurisdiction of the rent control tribunal,
employment disputes and the family court
TRUE
FALSE
ANSWER: TRUE
A person who claims violation of his rights and
liberties protected is entitled to resort to: