Obli Con MTG 12

You might also like

Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 14

EXTINGUISHMENT OF

OBLIGATIONS (Art. 1231)


Meeting 12

APRIL 7, 2020 TUESDAY


1. Payment/ performance (Art 1232)
a. Requisites
i. Who can pay

•  General Rule
• Exceptions:
o   Third person who is an interested party; effects
(Art 1302[3])
o   Third person who is not an interested party and without
the consent of the debtor, without the knowledge/ against
the will of the debtor (Art 1236[2], Art 1237, 1236 [1])
• In an obligation to give (Art 1239, 1427)

ii. To whom payment can be made


• General Rule (Art 1240)
• In case of active solidarity (Art 1214)
• Exceptions:
o   Incapacitated person (Art 1241, par 1)
o   Third person (Art 1241, par 2)
Sps. Dela Cruz v. Concepcion
GR 172825, Oct 11 2012
o   When proof of benefit not required
(Art 1241, par 3; Art 1242)
iii. What is to be paid (Identity)

• General Rule
• Specific cases:
o   To give a specific thing (Art 1244)
o   To give a generic thing (Art 1246)
o   To pay money (Art 1249, 1250; RA 529, RA 4100,
RA 8183)
St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance v.
Macondray
GR L-27796, 70 SCRA 122 (1976)
Papa v. A.V. Valencia
GR 105188, 284 SCRA 643 (1998)
Philippine Airlines v. CA
GR 49188, 181 SCRA 557 (1990)
•   Payment of Interest (Art. 1956)
Lim, et al. v. Development Bank of
the Philippines
GR 177050, July 1 2013
Sps. Andal v. PNB
GR 194201, Nov 23 2013
iv. How payment is to be made

• General Rule – Integrity (Art 1233)


o   Partial payment is not allowed; exceptions (Art 1248)
• Substantial performance in good faith (Art 1234)
• Estoppel (Art 1235)
• Presumptions in payment of interests and
installments (Art 1176)
v. When is payment to be made

• General Rule (1169)


• No demand, no delay; Exceptions

You might also like