Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Switzerland Finance: Media Touchpoints in The Consumer Path To Purchase
Switzerland Finance: Media Touchpoints in The Consumer Path To Purchase
Finance
Media Touchpoints in the Consumer Path to Purchase
• Methodology
• Purchase Behaviour
• Research Behaviour
• Online Banking Behaviour
• Management Summary
2
Methodology
VDD Finance Switzerland
• Target group: Internet users in Switzerland, 18 years and older
• Sample: N=1,000 Internet users
• Methodology:
– Online Questionnaire
– Representative weighting by age, gender, education, income, frequency of
online access, frequency of online purchase, usage of YouTube
• Period of analysis:
– Fieldwork: from July 28th – August 11th, 2011
– Final report: September 1st, 2011
• Research company: TNS Infratest
3
Relevant finance products for Switzerland
4
Purchase Behaviour
5
Category knowledge – insurance products
Swiss internet users are well informed about insurances – the vast
majority is at least familiar with the basic idea of the analyzed products
Category knowledge – insurance products
All respondents
I’m absolutely familiar I’m aware of the basic I just know this product by name but I have never heard
with this product idea of this product I’m not really sure what it’s about of this product
Q8: How would you rate your personal knowledge about each of the following financial products?
Base (weighted): All respondents n=1,000
6
Category knowledge – finance products
I’m absolutely familiar I’m aware of the basic I just know this product by name but I have never heard
with this product idea of this product I’m not really sure what it’s about of this product
Q8: How would you rate your personal knowledge about each of the following financial products?
Base (weighted): All respondents n=1,000
Source: TNS Infratest
7
Ownership of finance products
Swiss Onliners are well equipped with finance products (Ø 8 products
owned) - private accounts and health insurances are most popular
Ownership of finance products
All respondents
Swiss onliners own on average 8 financial products - Ø 5 insurances and Ø 3 other finance products
8
Purchase of financial products – past 24 months
9
Place of last purchase: insurance products
Q9: Please think now about the last time you purchased each of the following products. How did you actually make your purchase?
Base (weighted): All respondents who purchased at least one product in the past 24 months: Health insurance n=144, Travel insurance n=90, Legal
protection n=53, Car insurance n=127, Private liability n=79, Home insurance n=136
10
Place of last purchase: other finance products
11
Provider vs. Broker: insurance products
1% 1%
18% 11% 12% 15% 1% 5%
27%
17%
33%
29%
59% 62%
73% 71%
80% 84%
12
Provider vs. Broker: finance products
67%
82% 78% 90% 88% 87%
13
Drivers for buying online
Convenience related aspects (gain of time, buying anywhere at any time)
are the main driver for buying finance products on the internet
Motivation for purchasing finance products online
Respondents who purchased online in the past 24 months
It is fast and it is a gain of time 71% Convenience
71%
It is available 24 hours and 7 days a week Convenience
Q11: You’ve stated that you purchased the following products online via the internet: (…) What are from your perspective reasons for buying these products
on the internet? Base (weighted): All respondents who purchased at least one product online in the past 24 months: n=206; answer categories "Other", “Don’t
know” not shown
14
Barriers for buying online
On the internet I don’t have a dedicated contact person 52% Personal advice
I’m used to purchasing directly at the branch of a bank/ insurance 34% Convenience
13%
I’ve got security concerns Convenience
13%
Product descriptions are too complicated and complex Assortment/ Clarity
13%
High range of products - more complicated to find the right one Assortment/ Clarity
13%
Not possible to buy specific financial products via the internet Assortment/ Clarity
11%
Special offers/ promotions in the branch of a bank / insurance Prices/ Payment
11%
Better offline terms and conditions than online Prices/ Payment
5%
Usability on site is too complex Assortment/ Clarity
2%
Lower prices than online Prices/ Payment
Q12: [...] What are from your perspective reasons for buying these products offline and not buying them via the internet?
Base (weighted): All respondents who purchased at least one product offline in the past 24 months: n=399; answer categories "Other", “Don’t know” not
shown
15
Wrap up Purchase Behaviour
1 Swiss Onliners are well equipped with finance products (Ø 8 products owned) -
private accounts and health insurances are most popular.
Offline contracting is still the prevailing purchase method in the finance vertical:
3 insurances are usually subscribed for with insurance consultants whereas other
finance products are rather bought directly at a branch of the financial provider.
5 order to push online sales finance providers could focus on those products that
require comparably low information and advisory. For these products the internet as
a purchase channel can benefit from strong convenience advantages.
16
Research Behaviour
17
Research funnel: online vs. offline search
The internet is particularly strong for supporting the initial and intensive
research phase – however, offline sources predominantly used
Research for finance products
Respondents who purchased in the past 24 months
First awareness Initial research Intensive research Final decision
Insurances
Insurance of Home, Life, Health, 20% 48% 30% 9%
Car, Travel, Accident, Legal 71% 64% 73% 74%
protection, Private liability
online touchpoints used in the respective stage of the research funnel
offline touchpoints used in the respective stage of the research funnel
Q15: How or where did you first hear about them? Q16: And how did you start informing yourself about each of the following products? Q17: And how did you
collect intensive and deeper information about each of the following products? Q18: And how did you come to your final decision to buy the product?
Base: Respondents who applied for/purchased in the categories and used online or offline touchpoints in the research process
Source: TNS Infratest
18
Online research funnel: Savings and investments
Provider websites are the dominant source for online research on
savings / investments – search particularly strong for intial and intense
research
First awareness* Initial research Intense research Final decision*
Q15: How or where did you first hear about them? Q16: And how did you start informing yourself about each of the following products? Q17: And how did you
collect intensive and deeper information about each of the following products? Q18: And how did you come to your final decision to buy the product?
Base: Respondents who purchased/informed on products of savings/investments and used online touchpoints in the research process on products of
savings/investments: First awareness n=61, Initial research n=119; Intense research n=73; Final decision n=54
Source: TNS Infratest
19
Offline research funnel: Savings and investments
Personal consultancy from financial providers is the most popular offline
research source in the path to purchase on savings / investments
Billboard 1% 5% 3% 0%
TV program/ TV advert 1% 5% 5% 2%
20
Online research funnel: Money lending
Search engines create awareness and support initial research - provider
and comparison sites dominant for intense research and decision support
Newsletter 3% 5% 7% 1%
Q15: How or where did you first hear about them? Q16: And how did you start informing yourself about each of the following products? Q17: And how did you
collect intensive and deeper information about each of the following products? Q18: And how did you come to your final decision to buy the product?
Base: Respondents who purchased/informed on money lending products and used online touchpoints in the research process on money lending products:
First awareness n=30, Initial research n=72; Intense research n=45; Final decision n=14
21
Offline research funnel: Money lending
Professional consultancy from financial providers is by far the most
important offline information source about money lending products
TV program/ TV advert 1% 2% 1% 1%
Billboard 1% 0% 2% 0%
Q15: How or where did you first hear about them? Q16: And how did you start informing yourself about each of the following products? Q17: And how did you
collect intensive and deeper information about each of the following products? Q18: And how did you come to your final decision to buy the product?
Base: Respondents who purchased/informed on money lending products and used offline touchpoints in the research process on money lending products:
First awareness n=107, Initial research n=96; Intense research n=110; Final decision n=112
Source: TNS Infratest
22
Online research funnel: Insurances
Comparison sites are the most frequently used information sources in the
online research process on insurances followed by provider sites
Newsletter 10% 7% 4% 8%
Q15: How or where did you first hear about them? Q16: And how did you start informing yourself about each of the following products? Q17: And how did you
collect intensive and deeper information about each of the following products? Q18: And how did you come to your final decision to buy the product?
Base: Respondents who purchased/informed on insurances and used online touchpoints in the research process on insurances: First awareness n=132,
Initial research n=167; Intense research n=117; Final decision n=88
23
Offline research funnel: Insurances
WOM either professional with (independent) consultants or personal
with friends is the dominant offline research source on insurances
First awareness Initial research Intense research Final decision
Poster / leaflet 8% 6% 6% 4%
Billboard 1% 6% 2% 0%
Newspaper/ magazine 9% 5% 4% 5%
TV program/ TV advert 7% 4% 1% 1%
Q15: How or where did you first hear about them? Q16: And how did you start informing yourself about each of the following products? Q17: And how did you
collect intensive and deeper information about each of the following products? Q18: And how did you come to your final decision to buy the product?
Base: Respondents who purchased/informed on insurance and used offline touchpoints in the research process on insurance: First awareness n=200, Initial
research n=227; Intense research n=183; Final decision n=210
24
Finance provider sites
vs. price comparison sites
Provider sites are strong for providing in-depth and up-to-date
information about the whole product portfolio – trust contributes as well
Advantages of finance provider sites over price comparison sites
Users of websites of financial institutes
Comprehensive and in-depth information –
comparison sites only list key features 16% 47% 30% 8%4%
Comparison sites do not list all available providers – 13% 48% 29% 5% 4%
therefore direct browsing is necessary
Contain the whole product portfolio of a provider – 17% 43% 31% 3%2%
comparison sites only cover specific products
25
Finance provider sites
vs. price comparison sites
Gaining a comparative perspective about the whole market is the main
advantage of comparison sites – recommendations relevant as well
Advantages of price comparison sites over finance provider sites
Users of comparison sites
Compare products from different providers fast and easily 44% 40% 12% 8%1%
Q29: You’ve stated that you used product or price comparison sites (e.g. comparis) for informing yourself about financial products. (…) Please evaluate each of the following
statements on a scale from 1 – strongly agree to 5 –strongly disagree.
Base (weighted): All who used comparison sites n=150
Source: TNS Infratest
26
Research online –
purchase…? Insurance products
ROPO effect varies per insurance product: comparably strong for home
insurances and private liabilities
55%
Health insurance 68% 42%
54% 45%
Car insurance
55%
52% 56%
Travel insurance 39%
40% 36%
Legal protection 55%
37% 19%
Home insurance 77%
37%
Private liability 31% 63%
Online Offline
Q15: How or where did you first hear about them? Q16: And how did you start informing yourself about each of the following products? Q17: And how did you
collect intensive and deeper information about each of the following products? Q18: And how did you come to your final decision to buy the product? / Q9:
How did you actually made your purchase? Base (weighted): Purchaser per category: Health insurance n=144, Travel insurance n=90, Car insurance n=127,
Home insurance n=136, Private liability n=79, Legal protection n=53
Source: TNS Infratest
27
Research online –
purchase…? Finance products
Strong ROPO effects visible for mortgages, private accounts and funds
whereas share purchasers who research online preferably buy online
43%
Savings account 60% 57%
59% 1%
Mortgage
* 96%
55% 42%
Personal loan 51%
72%
Shares 50%
28%
47% 14%
Private account 86%
25%
Funds 40% 75%
Online Offline
Q15: How or where did you first hear about them? Q16: And how did you start informing yourself about each of the following products? Q17: And how did you collect intensive
and deeper information about each of the following products? Q18: And how did you come to your final decision to buy the product? / Q9: How did you actually made your
purchase? Base (weighted): Purchaser per category: Saving account n=115, mortgage n=111, personal loan n=53, shares n=135, private account n=97, funds n=75
28
Information trigger
Apart from direct type-in at the browser start page search engines are the
leading navigator tool to relevant online information sources
How did you find the websites you used
for searching product information?
Online researcher
Typing in the website address directly in the browser 50%
E-mail or newsletter 7%
Q20: You mentioned that you used online information sources while searching for product information. How did you find the websites you have used in the
internet? Base (weighted): All who used online information sources n=312; answer categories “Don’t know” not shown
29
Length of Research Process: Insurance products
Rather short research process for private liabilities and car insurances -
comparably long research for legal protection and health insurances
How long did you inform yourself…?
Purchaser of the past 24 months
Q19: How long did you inform yourself before you decided to make the purchase? Purchaser per category: Health insurance n=144, Home insurance n=136,
Private liability n=79, Car insurance n=127, Travel insurance n=90, Legal protection n=53
30
Length of Research Process: Finance products
Obviously rather complicated products with high consultancy needs e.
g. mortgages and personal loans show a comparably long research
path
How long did you inform yourself…?
Purchaser of the past 24 months
Q19: How long did you inform yourself before you decided to make the purchase? Purchaser per category: Private account n=97, Savings account n=115,
Personal loan n=53, Shares n=135, Mortgage n=111, Funds n=75
31
Advertising recall - overview
Q21: Did you recently see or notice any advertising for the following products?
Base (weighted): All respondents n=1,000
32
Advertising contact – insurance products
Radio 5% 1% 2% 2% 2% 2%
Q21: Did you recently see or notice any advertising for the following products?
Base (weighted): All respondents n=1,000
33
Advertising contact – finance products
TV 15% 12% 8% 3% 6% 3%
Radio 2% 2% 1% 2% 1% 1%
Q21: Did you recently see or notice any advertising for the following products?
Base (weighted): All respondents n=1,000
34
Wrap up Research Behaviour
1 Online research prior to purchase is relevant for all analyzed products - however,
offline research is still predominant in the finance vertical.
Among the online information sources finance provider websites are predominantly
3 used for savings & investments and for money lending products whereas for
insurances comparison sites play a major role in the online research process.
4 Search top navigator tool for finance research: 4 out of 10 online researchers start
on search in order to navigate to relevant research sources.
Online is a strong and important channel for creating ad contacts in the finance
5 vertical – for insurances its reach is on a level of print advertising, for other finance
products the ad contact shares are comparable to TV advertising.
35
Online Banking Behaviour
Information frequency – Online vs. Offline
In comparison with visits at the bank the internet is clearly more regularly
considered for collecting information about financial products
How often do you inform yourself about financial products …?
All respondents
Online Offline
via the internet visit at the branch
of a bank
Monthly 22% 5%
39% inform
themselves online
About once every 3 months 9% at least once 6%
every 6 months
About once every 6 months 8% 8%
51% visit the
branch of their
About once a year 13% 22% bank only once a
year or less
Less frequently 19% 29%
3% 3%
Don’t know
Q22: How often do you inform yourself about financial products (e.g. information about product descriptions, interest rates, terms and
conditions…)?
Base (weighted): All respondents n=1,000
37
Transaction frequency – Online vs. Offline
1% Online 9% 6%
About once every 3 months total:
79%
About once every 6 months 1% 8% 3%
Don’t know 3% 4% 3%
Q23: And how often do you process banking transactions (e. g. checking your account balance, transferring money, paying bills, …)?
Base (weighted): All respondents n=1,000
Source: TNS Infratest
38
Financial activities online
Processing transactions (paying bills, transferring money) and checking
accounts are the most popular activities among Swiss online bankers
Financial activities online
Yes, I use online Users of online banking
banking. (79%)
Online banking activities
Made bill payments 85%
Q25: Which of the following actions did you do online within the last 6 months?
Base (weighted): Users of online banking n=795; answer categories "Other", “Don’t know/ Don’t remember”, “No answer” not shown
Source: TNS Infratest
39
Drivers for online banking
Convenience related aspects and time efficiencies are the main drivers
for online banking
Why do you use online banking?
Users of online banking
Yes, I am using online I can process banking transactions at any time 78%
banking.
I have a permanent access / up-to-date overview 71%
27%
It’s safe
41
Channels for online banking
The first choice access for online banking is the stationary internet at
home – however, already noticeable shares for mobile devices
For online banking I use…
Users of online banking
87 % 5%
14 % 5%
Q24: You’ve stated that you at least sometimes use the internet in order to process banking transactions (e. g. checking your account balance, transferring
money, paying bills, …). Which of the following devices do you use for online banking?
Base (weighted): Users of online banking n=795; answer categories “Don’t know/No answer” not shown
42
Wrap up Online Banking Behaviour
2 Paying bills, transferring money, and keeping an eye on account balance and
account transactions are the most popular online banking activities.
3 The vast majority of the online bankers access their online banking system via
stationary internet – noticeable mobile share indicates future growth potential.
43
Management Summary
Management Summary
2 The internet is a popular channel for processing banking transactions with 8 out of
10 Swiss Onliners using online banking.
In this respect advisory from consultants at financial providers is the key information
4 source along the path to purchase. Among the online sources finance provider
websites and comparison sites are most frequently considered.
5 Search engines are a top navigator tool for finance research on the internet: 4 out of
10 online researchers start on search in order to navigate to relevant sources.
45