Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Assisted Reproductive Technologies (Arts) : By: Randolph Camolista, R.N. and Maria Consolacion Poral, R.N
Assisted Reproductive Technologies (Arts) : By: Randolph Camolista, R.N. and Maria Consolacion Poral, R.N
TECHNOLOGIES (ARTS)
Cytoplasmic transfer
Egg donors
Gestational carrier
Embryo splitting
OTHERS (DOES NOT NECESSARILY
INVOLVE IVF):
Surrogacy
Reproductive surgery
Cryopreservation
RISKS:
Genetic Disorders
Preterm Birth
ISSUES ON:
1. Conception, Pregnancy and Marriage
Valid Marriage (2 central considerations):
1.
1. The unitive and the procreative dimensions of the marital
act must remain intact and;
2.
2. Each couple is called to responsible parenthood
IVF is the converse of contraception: which allows the
unitive dimension to happen without the procreative;
IVF allows the procreative without the unitive.
Human procreation is a natural act and a vital act.
2. Permitted Assistance to Human Procreation
Ethical medical advancement in itself is a positive
expression of the inspiration of the Holy Spirit upon
the medical and scientific community.
What is allowed is assisted reproduction?
Informed Choice
- it requires full disclosure and fair representation of all potential medical,
social and emotional outcomes and risks.
Research
- remains incomplete with regards to efficacy, long-term safety and
psychosocial implications of most ARTs, but these concerns are being
addressed.
- key factors that motivate research: the desire to overcome infertility, to be
helpful, to achieve professional advancement and to acquire financial gain.
Gender Issues
- significantly influenced by societal assumptions about men and women.
Embryo status
- Vatican considers embryos to be persons from conception and rejects IVF because it
separates sex and reproduction.
Access
- difficulty in ensuring access to medically necessary and appropriate treatment while
avoiding inappropriate overuse at both micro (individual patient) and macro (health
policy) levels.
Commercializing Reproduction
- Markets in human gametes, embryos and pregnancy raise widespread ethical
alarm.
CATHOLICS POINT OF VIEW:
Catholicism
- The Roman Catholic opposes all kinds of ART
because, as with contraception, it separates the
procreation purpose of the marriage act from its unitive
purpose.
- According to Pope Benedict XVI “it replaces love
between a husband and wife.”
- in Catholicism, and embryo is viewed as an individual
that must be treated as a person.
- IVF is disregarded because it might cause embryo
disposal
CONCLUSION: