Here are the key issues concerned with genetic screening described in the passage, along with how genetic counselling may help families:
Issues with genetic screening:
- Risk of miscarriage from invasive prenatal tests like amniocentesis and CVS
- Potential for false positive or false negative results, leading to unnecessary anxiety or missed diagnosis
- Encouraging termination of pregnancies if genetic disorders are detected
- Ethical concerns about selecting embryos without genetic disorders through PGD
How genetic counselling can help:
- Provide information about inheritance of genetic disorders to assess risk level
- Explain the purpose, risks and limitations of various screening and diagnostic tests
- Help families make informed decisions about pursuing testing or not
Here are the key issues concerned with genetic screening described in the passage, along with how genetic counselling may help families:
Issues with genetic screening:
- Risk of miscarriage from invasive prenatal tests like amniocentesis and CVS
- Potential for false positive or false negative results, leading to unnecessary anxiety or missed diagnosis
- Encouraging termination of pregnancies if genetic disorders are detected
- Ethical concerns about selecting embryos without genetic disorders through PGD
How genetic counselling can help:
- Provide information about inheritance of genetic disorders to assess risk level
- Explain the purpose, risks and limitations of various screening and diagnostic tests
- Help families make informed decisions about pursuing testing or not
Here are the key issues concerned with genetic screening described in the passage, along with how genetic counselling may help families:
Issues with genetic screening:
- Risk of miscarriage from invasive prenatal tests like amniocentesis and CVS
- Potential for false positive or false negative results, leading to unnecessary anxiety or missed diagnosis
- Encouraging termination of pregnancies if genetic disorders are detected
- Ethical concerns about selecting embryos without genetic disorders through PGD
How genetic counselling can help:
- Provide information about inheritance of genetic disorders to assess risk level
- Explain the purpose, risks and limitations of various screening and diagnostic tests
- Help families make informed decisions about pursuing testing or not
LO: To understand the use of genetic screening and
the issues related ALL: List the different types of screening MOST: Describe the implications of prenatal screening SOME: Evaluate the ethical and social issues related to screening KEYWORDS Genetic screening STARTER Prenatal screening 1. What is the difference between Amniocentesis genetic screening and prenatal Chronic villus sampling screening? EXT: How might a genetic screening be used for a family with a history of cystic fibrosis? “Genetic disorders should not be corrected using gene therapy. Some people are born weaker than others and consequently die....it’s called survival of the fittest.”
What do you think?
Methods of genetic screening Pre-natal tests: - These occur once the embryo is developing inside the uterus. - Fetal cells or tissue collected from mother - The main two methods are amniocentesis and chorionic villus sampling (CVS) https://www.youtube.com/watch? v=sxEf_ddmpZk Questions - When is it performed? - What sample is collected? Methods of genetic screening Chorionic villus sampling (CVS): - Involves taking a sample of cells/tissue from the placenta. - Testing happens between the 11th and 14th week of pregnancy. - There are two methods of doing this: - transabdominal CVS – a needle is inserted through the abdomen (this is the most common method used) - •transcervical CVS – a tube or forceps are inserted through the cervix (the neck of the womb) What are the advantages and disadvantages of this method? Use page 143 to answer
EXT: Categorise the disadvantages into social
and eithical issues Methods of genetic screening Risks of chorionic villus sampling (CVS): - Miscarriage (1-2% of cases) - Infection caused by taking the sample - Can encourage abortion if the tests come back positive for a particular genetic disease. - False positives and false negatives https://www.youtube.com/watch? v=bZcGpjyOXt0 Questions - When is it performed? - What sample is collected? Methods of genetic screening Amniocentesis: - Removal of amniotic fluid using needle and syringe - Testing occurs between the 15th and 18th week of pregnancy. - Epithelial and blood cells extracted from centrifuged fluid - Cells are cultured for 2-3 weeks and chromosomes are examined. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this method? Use page 143 to answer
EXT: Categorise the disadvantages into social
and ethical issues Methods of genetic screening Risks of amniocentesis: - Miscarriage (lower chance than CVS)- 1% - Bacterial infection - Puncture of the placenta - Positive results can encourage abortion at a later stage of pregnancy than CVS - False positives and false negatives Preimplantation genetic diagnosis Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis • Scientists use pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) to help people decide which genes and characteristics to pass on to their children. • Using the sperm and egg taken from a couple, scientists create embryos by in vitro fertilisation (IVF). • Scientists examine these two or three-day old embryos to find out which genes for disease or other features are present in each embryo. • The couple can then choose which embryo, usually the healthiest, to put into the mother to grow into a baby. • Scientists are able to select embryos that are free from life- threatening or mild genetic diseases. • They can also select male or female embryos. But what characteristics should people be allowed to choose for their children? • The most common reason to use PGD is to avoid having a baby with a genetic disease. • If a couple know that one of them has a genetic disease, or that they have a history of genetic disease in their family, they may not wish to pass the genes on to their child. • They use PGD to select an embryo without the disease genes before going ahead with the pregnancy. • PGD is often used to avoid having a baby with a genetic disease. • If a woman has tests that showed her fetus had a serious disease, then she and the baby's father might have to decide whether to terminate the pregnancy. • PGD avoids this unhappy situation. Exam questions Difficult decisions Your homework is to read page 144-145 and list the issues concerned with genetic screening and describe how genetic counselling may help families.