Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Flevy Strat Devdep
Flevy Strat Devdep
Flevy Strat Devdep
A successful business requires both a well developed strategy and the ability to execute on that
strategy. Strategy without execution is merely theory. Many companies develop robust strategies,
but fail at operationalizing their strategies into implementable steps. This document introduces 12
powerful business frameworks for Strategy Development and Strategy Execution.
2 5 8 11
Porter’s Five Organizational
SWOT Analysis Product Lifecycle
Forces Hurdles
3 6 9 12
BCG Growth-Share
PEST Analysis Consumer Adoption Curve Hoshin Kanri
Matrix
Overview 5
Summary
44
Appendix
50
Overview
Summary
Appendix
A successful business requires both a well developed strategy and the ability to execute on that strategy.
Strategy without execution is merely theory. Many companies develop robust strategies, but fail at operationalizing
their strategies into implementable steps.
This document covers frameworks that deal with both sides—Strategy Development and Strategy Execution.
In this presentation, we will discuss 12 business frameworks. For each framework, we will provide an overview,
explain its proper usage, and highlight the analyses involved.
This document will also provide references to more detailed documentation, guides, and methodologies if you would
like more information.
The following business frameworks will be discussed:
• Consolidation-Endgame Curve • Strategy Framework Canvas • Consumer Adoption Curve
• Porter’s Five Forces • SWOT Analysis • Balanced Scorecard
• BCG Growth-Share Matrix • PEST Analysis • Organizational Hurdles
• Marketing Mix (4/7 P’s) • Product Lifecycle • Hoshin Kanri
Each framework is geared towards a specific type of analysis—pick and choose the best
frameworks to use for your particular business problem.
Overview
Summary
Appendix
2 5 8
Porter’s Five Forces SWOT Analysis Product Lifecycle
3 6 9
BCG Growth-Share Matrix PEST Analysis Consumer Adoption Curve
These first 6 frameworks focus more on Industry and These 3 frameworks are more Product
Competitive Analysis—they are more externally focused. focused—and rely on more internal
strategies.
A well developed strategy should use at least 5 of the above analyses covering both
external and internal perspectives.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Overview Adoption Curve
• The Consolidation-Endgame Curve framework (also known as Consolidation Curve or Endgame Curve) is not a well
known framework, but is one that offers incredibly insights into market dynamics and competitive strategies.
• This type of framework is called a Maturity Model. Maturity Models gauge the “maturity” of an organization in a number of
disciplines or functions. They help pinpoint the specific areas of improvement in order to reach the next level of maturity.
The Consolidation-Endgame Curve assesses the growth maturity of the industry.
• This framework was developed by the management consulting firm AT Kearney after they performed a study on 25,000
firms, representing 98% of the global market cap. The firm realizes that all industries go through the same 4-stage
lifecycle—Opening, Scale, Focus, Balance & Alliance.
• Across all industries, the same characteristics are exhibited at each stage of the Curve.
• By appropriately identifying our stage and understanding the defining traits and behavior of our stage, we can better
understand and predict market and competitive behavior and trends. Every major strategic and operational move should
be evaluated with regard to the industry’s stage in the Consolidation Curve.
• On a more subtle note, the industry stage also governs what type of management and leadership works best for the
company. In other words, the management team in the Scale phase may not possess the right skills to run the company
at the Balance & Alliance stage.
This framework not only helps us define a more informed corporate strategy, but also helps
define our organizational structure and the proper management team.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
4 Stages of Consolidation Adoption Curve
DESCRIPTION The industries operating in In the Scale stage, major In the Focus stage, In the final stage,
the Opening stage include players begin to emerge successful players consolidation rates reach
newly deregulated and size begins to matter continue to aggressively 90%, so a few players
industries, startups, and —these players take the outgrow competition dominate each industry at
spin-off industries lead in consolidation These companies focus— this point
New industry catalysts can Niche players begin to feel meaning they extend their Large companies form
include new technology, pressure core business and alliances with each other,
new regulation, new ideas, eliminate secondary as growth is challenging at
Concentration rates can
and new consumer needs be as high as 45% in business units this stage
There is little to no market some industries The supply and value Companies often look for
concentration at this point chains begin to be new Opening-stage
streamlined industries to expand into
COMBINED
SHARE OF TOP 41% 42% 50% 70%
3 PLAYERS
In the final stage, industry titans dominate the landscape, controlling 70% of the market—any
number of businesses can occupy the remaining 30%.
Source: Winning the Merger Endgame, 2002
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Consolidation-Endgame Curve Diagram Adoption Curve
Combined
Share of
Top 3
Players Maximum
Combined market
share of top 3 players
50%
Minimum
Time
0%
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
More Information Adoption Curve
RELATED DOCUMENTS/FRAMEWORKS
• Guide to Business Strategy Design - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/complete-guide-to-business-strategy-design-375
• Growth Strategy Toolkit - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/growth-strategy-208
• Five Stages of Business Growth - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/five-stages-of-business-growth-249
• Additional Maturity Models - https://flevy.com/business-toolkit/maturity-model
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Overview Adoption Curve
• Developed by Michael Porter, recognized as the father of modern business strategy, Porter’s Five Forces is one
of the most well known classic strategy frameworks.
• Porter’s Five Forces is a framework used for industry analysis and understand the various dynamics amongst industry
players and external “forces.”
• It is based on the theory that competition in any industry is dependent on 5 basic forces— Potential Entrants, Internal
Rivalry, Suppliers, Buyers, and Substitutes (or Complements). The collective strength of these forces determines the
ultimate profit potential and allocation in the industry.
• Using this framework, we can determine how attractive/desirable it is to compete in any industry, as well as what the
overarching strategy should be to compete successfully in the industry—success is determined by the ability to develop a
sustainable competitive advantage.
• It can also be used to assess which industry trends may pose as opportunities or threats.
Several important economic and technical characteristics of an industry are critical to the
strengths of each competitive force.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
5 Forces Explained and Framework Diagram Adoption Curve
A supplier group is powerful when: Intense rivalry results from: A buyer group is powerful when:
It is dominated by a few companies and is more Numerous or equally balanced competitors It is concentrated or purchases large volumes relative
concentrated than the industry it sells to. to seller sales.
Slow industry growth
The products represent a significant fraction of the
There are no substitute products. High fixed or storage costs buyers’ costs or purchases.
The industry is not an important customer. Lack of differentiation or switching costs The products are standard or undifferentiated.
Its products are important to the industry. Capacity augmented in large increments It faces few switching costs.
Products are differentiated or suppliers have built Diverse competitors It earns low profits.
up switching costs. It poses a credible threat of backward integration.
High strategic stakes The bought product is unimportant.
It poses a credible threat of forward integration. High exit barriers It has full information.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
More Information Adoption Curve
RELATED DOCUMENTS/FRAMEWORKS
• Growth Strategy Toolkit - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/growth-strategy-208
• Strategy Framework Canvas - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/blue-ocean-strategy-the-peaceful-strategy-114
• Industry Analysis - http://flevy.com/browse/business-document/industry-analysis-773
• Porter’s Value Chain - https://flevy.com/browse/flevypro/strategy-classics-porters-value-chain-4058
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Overview Adoption Curve
• The BCG Growth-Share Matrix (also called Product Portfolio and Boston Matrix) is a classic competitive positioning
strategy framework developed by the management consulting firm Boston Consulting Group (BCG).
The growth-share matrix displays graphically in a 2-by-2 matrix one of two scenarios:
The position of each business of a company’s portfolio; or
Compares the position of various players in one industry.
The two axes of the matrix are 1) market/industry growth and 2) relative market share (RMS). We then plot our products
onto the matrix and quadrant associated with the product drives its strategy. The quadrants are defined as follows:
Star – high RMS, high market growth;
Cash cow – High RMS, low market growth;
Dog – Low RMS, low market growth; and
Question mark – Low RMS, high market growth.
The key premise to this framework is that products located in each of the quadrants will be in fundamentally different cash
flow positions and should be managed differently.
This framework is used to assess trends in the evolution of a company’s portfolio of business (when matrix is drawn for
both the current year and past years). It can also be used to understand the competitive position of each business,
possible cash requirements, and focus attention on key issues.
This framework helps the us allocate resources and is can be used as an analytical tool in
brand marketing, product management, strategic management, or portfolio analysis.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
4 Quadrants Explained Adoption Curve
Cash cows are units with high market share in a slow-growing industry. These units typically generate
cash in excess of the amount of cash needed to maintain the business. They are regarded as staid
Cash Cow and boring, in a "mature" market, and every corporation would be thrilled to own as many as
possible. They are to be "milked" continuously with as little investment as possible, since such
investment would be wasted in an industry with low growth.
Dogs, or more charitably called pets, are units with low market share in a mature, slow-growing
industry. These units typically "break even", generating barely enough cash to maintain the
business's market share. Though owning a break-even unit provides the social benefit of providing
Dog jobs and possible synergies that assist other business units, from an accounting point of view such a
unit is worthless, not generating cash for the company. They depress a profitable company's return
on assets ratio, used by many investors to judge how well a company is being managed. Dogs, it is
thought, should be sold off.
Question marks (also known as problem child) are growing rapidly and thus consume large amounts
?
of cash, but because they have low market shares they do not generate much cash. The result is a
Question large net cash consumption. A question mark has the potential to gain market share and become a
Mark star, and eventually a cash cow when the market growth slows. If the question mark does not
succeed in becoming the market leader, then after perhaps years of cash consumption it will
degenerate into a dog when the market growth declines. Question marks must be analyzed carefully
in order to determine whether they are worth the investment required to grow market share.
Stars are units with a high market share in a fast-growing industry. The hope is that stars become the
next cash cows. Sustaining the business unit's market leadership may require extra cash, but this is
Star worthwhile if that's what it takes for the unit to remain a leader. When growth slows, stars become
cash cows if they have been able to maintain their category leadership, or they move from brief
stardom to dogdom.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
BCG Matrix Framework Diagram Adoption Curve
Y%
Star Question Mark
?
Industry
Growth
Z 0
Relative
Market Share
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
More Information Adoption Curve
RELATED DOCUMENTS/FRAMEWORKS
• Market Analysis - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/market-analysis-215
• Product Lifecycle - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/product-lifecycle-227
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Overview Adoption Curve
• By now, you can tell there are numerous Strategy frameworks available. As there are so many tools available, it can be
difficult to determine what the right approach is for our organization.
• The Strategy Framework Canvas (SFC) is a unifying choice framework that guides us in selecting the appropriate
strategy for the circumstances at hand and execute it effectively. This model is particularly useful for large
organizations that are now stretched across a more diverse and faster-changing range of business situations.
• SFC identifies 5 distinct archetypal approaches to strategy:
1. Classic (e.g. Porter’s Five Forces, BCG Growth-Share Matrix)
2. Adaptive (e.g. First Mover Advantage, Dynamic Capabilities)
3. Visionary (e.g. Blue Ocean Strategy, Innovator’s Dilemma)
4. Leader (e.g. S-Curve, Ecosystem Strategy)
5. Renewal (e.g. Transformation/turnaround strategies)
• Once we determine the Strategy approach to take, the next step is to adopt a Strategy framework most befitting our
organization. Key considerations include our Corporate Culture, Organizational Design, Leadership Style,
Competitive Positioning, and Core Competencies, to name a few.
Consumer
Five Strategy Environments BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Adoption Curve
Business environments differ along 3 distinct dimensions: Predictability (can we forecast it?), Malleability (can
we shape it—either alone or in collaboration with other organizations?), and Harshness (can we survive it?).
Using these dimensions, we can create a matrix that reveals the 5 distinct environments:
RENEWAL
My resources are Be Viable
severely constrained
ADAPTIVE LEADER
Be the
I can’t predict it and I Be Fast I can’t predict it, but I
orchestrator
can’t change it can change it
CLASSIC VISIONARY
I can predict it, Be Big I can predict it and I Be First
but I can’t change it can change it
Consumer
SFC Application BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Adoption Curve
The Strategy Framework Canvas provides management with a new tool for describing and selecting the
appropriate approach to strategy in a particular part of the organization. In fact, it can actually be applied on 3
levels of our organization:
This framework also provides a logical process to connect strategizing and execution
for each Strategy approach.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
More Information Adoption Curve
RELATED DOCUMENTS/FRAMEWORKS
• Strategy Chessboard - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/strategy-chessboard-3125
• Complete Guide to Business Strategy Design -
https://flevy.com/browse/busines-document/complete-guide-to-business-strategy-design-375
• Strategy Development Methodology - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/strategy-development-methodology-264
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Overview Adoption Curve
• The SWOT Analysis (also called SWOT Matrix) is one of the earliest strategy frameworks. It was developed in the
1960s at Harvard Business School by Learned, Christensen, Andrews, and Guth.
• The name is an acronym for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats.
• This framework provides basic directions for structuring strategic analysis.
• The underlying theory is that assessment of competitive position should combine both an external and an internal
analysis. The internal factors are Weaknesses and Strengths, whereas the external factors are Opportunities and
Threats.
• We can conduct SWOT analyses for our own organization in addition to our competitors, so that we gain added insight
into our company’s competitive position.
• The output of this analysis is often displayed in the form of a 2x2 matrix.
• SWOT Analysis is often conducted in conjunction with PEST Analysis.
Many market research firms routinely publish SWOT analyses for public companies.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Overview Adoption Curve
• PEST Analysis is a framework evaluating macro-environmental factors used in the environmental scanning
component of strategic management. The PEST analysis framework has become increasingly popular and relevant as
the first decade of the 21st century have given rise to green business and environmental concerns from the public.
• PEST is an acronym for Political, Economic, Social, and Technological, which are the macro-environmental factors to
analysis in this analysis.
• This analysis is often performed in conjunction with other popular frameworks, as a means of enhancing the
understanding and output of these other frameworks. Specifically, it is often used to help explain the analysis in the
following frameworks:
• Porter’s Five Forces;
• SWOT Analysis;
• Value Chain Analysis; and
• Industry financials.
• PEST Analysis is often performed in a 3-phase process: data collection, industry trend analysis, and trend quantification.
PEST Analysis been sometimes been extended to include Legal and Environmental, forming
the name PESTLE Analysis.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Overview Adoption Curve
• The 4 P’s of marketing, often just called Marketing Mix, is perhaps the commonly used corporate marketing framework.
The marketing mix refers to the 4 levers to adjust when determining the essence of product’s marketing strategy.
• The 4 P’s refer to Price, Product, Promotion, and Placement.
• This framework has been extended to 7 P’s, to also include Physical Evidence, People, and Process.
• The definitions for the additional 3 P’s should not be confused with the People-Process-Technology framework, which is
more operationally-focused (vs. consumer-focused).
In most cases, Price and Product are the more important factors and are determined
first—as these are more closely tied to our competitive advantage.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Definitions of the P’s Adoption Curve
1 A product is seen as an item that satisfies what a consumer needs or wants. It is a tangible good or an
intangible service. Intangible products are service based like the tourism industry, the hotel industry and the
Product financial industry. Tangible products are those that have an independent physical existence.
Typical examples of mass-produced, tangible objects are the motor car and the disposable razor. A less
obvious but ubiquitous mass-produced service is a computer operating system. Every product is subject to a
life-cycle including a growth phase followed by a maturity phase and finally an eventual period of decline as
sales falls.
Marketers must do careful research on how long the life cycle of the product they are marketing is likely to be
and focus their attention on different challenges that arise as the product moves through each stage. The
marketer must also consider the product mix. Marketers can expand the current product mix by increasing a
certain product line’s depth or by increasing the number of product lines. Marketers should consider how to
position the product, how to exploit the brand, how to exploit the company’s resources and how to configure
the product mix so that each product complements the other.
The marketer must also consider product development strategies.
The amount a customer pays for the product. The price is very important as it determines the company’s
2
profit and hence, survival. Adjusting the price has a profound impact on the marketing strategy, and depending
on the price elasticity of the product, often it will affect the demand and sales as well. The marketer should set
Price
a price that complements the other elements of the marketing mix.
When setting a price, the marketer must be aware of the customer perceived value for the product. Three
basic pricing strategies are: market skimming pricing, market penetration pricing and neutral pricing. The
‘reference value’ (where the consumer refers to the prices of competing products) and the ‘differential value’
(the consumer’s view of this product’s attributes versus the attributes of other products) must be taken into
account.
Flevy.com (http://flevy.com) – Marketplace for premium business documents
27
Download the latest version of this primer for free at: http://flevy.com/strategy-frameworks / Question? Email us: support@flevy.com 27
Consolidation- Strategy
Marketing Mix
Endgame Curve Canvas
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Definitions of the P’s Adoption Curve
3 All of the methods of communication that a marketer may use to provide information to different
parties about the product. Promotion comprises elements such as: advertising, public relations, personal
Promotion selling and sales promotion.
Advertising covers any communication that is paid for, from cinema commercials, radio and Internet
advertisements through print media and billboards. Public relations is where the communication is not directly
paid for and includes press releases, sponsorship deals, exhibitions, conferences, seminars or trade fairs and
events. Word-of-mouth is any apparently informal communication about the product by ordinary individuals,
satisfied customers or people specifically engaged to create word of mouth momentum. Sales staff often plays
an important role in word of mouth and public relations.
Refers to providing the product at a place which is convenient for consumers to access. Various
4
strategies such as intensive distribution, selective distribution, exclusive distribution and franchising can be
Placement used by the marketer to complement the other aspects of the marketing mix.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Definitions of the P’s Adoption Curve
5
Physical Elements within the store — the store front, the uniforms employees wear, signboards, etc.
Evidence
6
The employees of the organization with whom customers come into contact.
People
7 The processes and systems within the organization that affects its marketing process.
Process
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
More Information Adoption Curve
PRICING STRATEGY
• Pricing Strategy Framework - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/pricing-strategy-226
• Pricing Strategy Workshop - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/pricing-strategy-workshop-764
• Value-based Pricing Strategy - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/value-based-pricing-strategy-1096
PRODUCT STRATEGY
• Product Lifecycle - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/product-lifecycle-227
• Rogers’ Five Factors - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/rogers-five-factors-169
• Psychology of Product Adoption - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/psychology-of-product-adoption-203
The Flevy author DemandMetric specializes in Corporate Marketing tools built in Excel:
https://flevy.com/author/demandmetric
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Overview Adoption Curve
• Product Lifecycle analysis is a tool to predict how sales will develop based on the age of the product category.
Marketers and strategists can use this analysis to predict sales growth, associated customer and competitor behaviors,
and, in turn, devise the appropriate product marketing strategy.
• The Product Lifecycle itself it divided into 4 stages of development: Introduction, Growth, Maturity (and Saturation),
and Decline (and Termination).
• The length of each period varies tremendously. Some products have very short cycles, whereas others can take decades
or even centuries to go through the cycle. The lifecycle can be mapped against the consumer adoption curve, where the
peak of the curve generally occurs in the maturity stage of the Product Lifecycle.
• The Product Lifecycle is typically mapped against the Consumer Adoption Curve to draw out key marketing and
competitive insights. By understanding what stage of the Consumer Adoption Curve we’re at, we can gain invaluable
insights into who our target customer are, as well as their defining attributes.
• The Consumer Adoption Curve is defined by 5 sequential stages: Innovators, Early Adopters, Early Majority, Late
Majority, and Laggards. Typically, there is a “chasm” between the Early Adopters and Early Majority.
• Product Lifecycle Analysis also provides a framework to understand the competitive environment. It makes an underlying
assumption that sales and profitability follow a predictable pattern for all industries and all products within those
industries.
Be aware that as a product moves through its lifecycle, the likelihood of customers
switching to a substitute product increases.
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
Product Lifecycle Mapped on Consumer Adoption Curve Adoption Curve
It is useful to map all products within an industry or product category against the Adoption
Curve—to visualize dynamics among products (e.g. substitution, complements).
Consumer
BCG Matrix PEST Analysis
More Information Adoption Curve
RELATED DOCUMENTS/FRAMEWORKS
• Product Innovation Management - https://flevy.com/browse/flevypro/product-innovation-management-3263
• Kano Customer Satisfaction Model - https://flevy.com/browse/flevypro/kano-customer-satisfaction-model-2425
• Product Strategy: Smart Customization - https://flevy.com/browse/flevypro/product-strategy-smart-customization-3779
Learn more about Product Lifecycle and Consumer Adoption Curve analyses here:
https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/product-lifecycle-227
Overview
Summary
Appendix
1 2 3
Organizations spend 90-95% of their time and resources on execution—despite this, most
organizations fail at the execution of their strategies.
The BSC framework is flexible in that it allows for the strategy itself to evolve in response to
changes in the company’s competitive, market, and technological environments.
3 Business Planning
• Setting targets
• Aligning strategic initiatives
• Allocating resources
• Establishing milestones
RELATED DOCUMENTS/FRAMEWORKS
• BSC Deployment Process - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/opex-balanced-scorecard-training-module-567
• BSC Overview & Examples - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/introduction-to-balanced-scorecard-723
• Supercharge Strategy Execution - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/supercharge-strategy-execution-1870
• Strategy Map - https://flevy.com/browse/flevypro/strategy-map-2488
1 2 3 4
Cognitive Resource Motivational Political
Hurdle Hurdle Hurdle Hurdle
RELATED DOCUMENTS/FRAMEWORKS
• Strategic Management Office (SMO) Primer: https://flevy.com/browse/flevypro/smo-series-strategic-management-office-primer-3393
• Formulating a Breakthrough Strategy - https://flevy.com/browse/business-document/formulating-a-breakthrough-strategy-598
• Managing Strategy through Execution - https://flevy.com/browse/flevypro/10-principles-of-managing-strategy-through-execution-2975
Learn more Organizational Hurdles and other Strategy Execution frameworks here:
http://flevy.com/browse/business-document/guide-to-business-strategy-execution-873
Hoshin Kanri strives to get every employee pulling in the same direction at the same time.
Overview
Summary
Appendix
In this document, we provided high level overviews of 12 different frameworks related to Strategy Development and
Strategy Execution. These are the same tools and analyses performed by top tier consulting firms, although only a
small sample of the wide array of frameworks and tools available. You can find countless more frameworks available at
Flevy (http://flevy.com).
Using and applying these frameworks is an art. Depending on your specific business situation, the usage and
applications of these frameworks will change significantly.
To learn more about any of these topics, we advise you take a look at the recommended documents referenced
throughout this presentation. We have also included additional recommended documents in the following slides.
2 5 8 11
Porter’s Five Organizational
SWOT Analysis Product Lifecycle
Forces Hurdles
3 6 9 12
BCG Growth-Share
PEST Analysis Consumer Adoption Curve Hoshin Kanri
Matrix
Looking for more business frameworks? Check out our 10 must-have frameworks:
http://flevy.com/business-frameworks
Overview
Summary
Appendix
Earn passive income on Flevy by selling your old business documents— register here:
http://flevy.com/register