Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Current Trends & Cases in Finance: Microfinance
Current Trends & Cases in Finance: Microfinance
Cases in Finance
Chapter 1 : Microfinance
Prof : Manav Agarwal
9823962733
Manava_iom@bkc.met.edu
Microfinance: Definition
“Microfinance is an economic development tool whose
objective is to assist the poor to work their way out of
poverty. It covers a range of services which include, in
addition to the provision of credit, many other services
such as savings, insurance, money transfers,
counselling, etc.” – Reserve Bank of India
600 MFI initiatives have a cumulative outreach of 1.25 crore poor households
NABARD’s bank linkage program has cumulatively reached a total of 9.4 lakh SHGs
with about 1.4 crore households.
Why Microfinance Can Change the Way the World Works
GRWOTH PERFORMANCE OF MICROFINANCE
PROBLEMS FACED BY MICROFINANCE
JLG members to engage in similar type of economic activities either in farm and non
farm sector.
Disadvantages:
Fewer services.
Cooperative Model
A cooperative is an autonomous association
of persons united voluntarily to meet their
common economic ,social and cultural
needs and aspirations through a jointly –
owned and democratically –controlled
enterprise.
Some cooperatives include member –
financing and savings activities in their
mandate.
Non-governmental Organization
Model
• The term non-governmental Features
organization was first used in •Function on no profit basis
1945.
•Non political character
• A non-governmental
•Clearly defined objectives
organization is a citizen-based
•Voluntary character
association that operates
independently of government. •Wide operational area
• There are specialized lenders called apex MFIs that provide both
loans and capacity building support to MFIs .
• This Institution lend to the concept of JLG
MFIs for offering microfinance
are as follows
• High Transaction cost
• Absence of collaterals
Chit Funds Act, 1982 In 1982, the Ministry of Finance enacted the Chit Funds Act to regulate the sector. Under the Act,
the central government can choose to notify the Act in different states on different dates; if the Act is notified in a state,
then the state act would Be repealed. States are responsible for notifying rules and have the power to exempt
certain chit funds from the provisions of the Act. States may appoint a Registrar who would be responsible for
regulation, inspection and dispute settlement in the sector. Any grievances over decisions made by the Registrar
can be subject to appeals directed to the state government. Chit fund managers are required to deposit the entire value
of the chit fund (can be done in 50% cash and 50% bank guarantee) with the Registrar for the duration of the chit cycle.
What is the role of RBI and
SEBI?
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the regulator for banks and other non banking financial companies
(NBFCs) but does not regulate the chit fund business. While chit funds accept deposits, the term
‘deposit’ as defined under the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 does not include subscriptions to chits.
However the RBI can provide guidance to state governments on regulatory aspects like creating rules or
exempting certain chit funds.
As the regulator of the securities market, SEBI regulates collective investment schemes. But
the SEBI Act, 1992 specifically excludes chit funds from their definition of collective investment
schemes. In the case with Sarada Group, the SEBI investigation discovered that Sarada were, in effect,
operating a collective investment scheme without SEBI’s approval.
Current Scenario
These are challenging times for chit fund operators. A scam involving the Saradha
group allegedly conning customers under the guise of a chit fund, has raised serious
questions for the industry.
The scam also sparked responses from both the centre and states: the Finance
Ministry, Ministry of Corporate Affairs and SEBI all promised to act and the West Bengal
Assembly passed The West Bengal Protection of Interest of Depositors in Financial
Establishments Bill, 2013, with Odisha and Haryana considering similar legislation.
With a reported around 10,000 chit funds in the country handling over Rs 30,000
crore annually, chit fund proponents maintain that these funds are an important
financial tool.
Saradha chit fund scam: All you want to know
HIGHLIGHTS
•The Saradha Group financial scandal is a major
financial scam and alleged political scandal caused
by the collapse of a Ponzi scheme run by Saradha
Group in , a consortium of over 200 private
companies that were believed to be running
collective investment schemes popularly but
incorrectly referred to as chit funds. Here is a look at
the details of the scam.
The group collected around $4–6 billion from over 1.7 million
depositors before it collapsed in April 2013.
In the aftermath of the scandal, the state government of West
Bengal, where the Saradha Group and most of its investors
were based, instituted an inquiry commission to investigate the
collapse.
The central government through the Income Tax Department
and Enforcement Directorate launched a multi-agency probe to
investigate the Saradha scam and similar Ponzi schemes.
In May 2014, the Supreme Court of India observed inter-state
ramifications of the scheme, possible international money
laundering, serious regulatory failures and alleged political
The CBI arrested a third TC politician,
nexus, and, hence, transferred all investigations into the Madan Mitra, in connection with the
scam, prompting opposition parties in the
Saradha scam and other Ponzi schemes to the Central Bureau state to demand the CM’s resignation.
of Investigation (CBI).
Many prominent personalities were arrested for their involvement in the scam including two
Members of Parliament (MP) - Kunal Ghosh and Srinjoy Bose, former West Bengal director general of
Police Rajat Majumdar, a top football club official Debabrata Sarkar, sports and transport minister in
the Mamata Banerjee cabinet– Madan Mitra.
In February 2014, Sudipta Sen was sentenced to three years in jail for failing to deposit with the
provident fund authorities INR 0.03 million that his firm owed to its employees.
Soon after the scam was unearthed, the West Bengal government set up a four-member judicial
enquiry headed by Shyamal Kumar Sen, retired Chief Justice of the Allahabad High Court. The
commission was named Justice Shyamal Sen Commission of Enquiry.
The commission completed its enquiry in mid-August 2013. As many as 1.73 million depositors filed a
complaint with the commission. In its recommendations, the state government was urged to sell off
the assets of the Sardha Group.
The chief minister also set up a Rs 500 crore package to safeguard the interest of small-time investors.
To raise the money for the package, Mamata introduced a 10% additional tax on tobacco products.
Within days of the collapse of the scheme, the
Assam government unanimously passed the Assam
Protection of Interests of Depositors (in Financial
Establishments) (Amendment) Bill (2013) to enhance
the protections available to depositors and to curb
fraudulent financial schemes.
As many as 6,000 investors in Odisha filed a
complaint against the Sardha Group, mainly from
areas adjoining West Bengal. The state government
launched an investigation by the Crime Branch of
the state police.
A month after the collapse of the scheme, the
Tripura government handed over the documents of
the case to CBI.
SKS Microfinance 53
Grameen Bank
• Grameen Bank (GB) was initiated as a challenge to the conventional banking which
had no place for the poor
• Began as the Grameen Bank Project in 1976; which was established as a Bank in
1983
• Promotes Credit as a Human Right
• Grameen Bank gives collateral-free loans. Provides loans and financial services
without any legally enforceable contact
• Preference for giving loans to women
• Provides services at the door-step of the poor
• Owned by the poor borrowers
Grameen Bank – Contd.
SKS Microfinance 55
Professor Yunus and Ms. Taslima Begum with
Nobel Peace Prize, 2006
(efforts in Economic & Social Development)
SKS Microfinance 56
Case Overview
• Microfinance is an effective tool that can help reduce poverty and spread economic opportunity
by giving poor people access to financial services, such as credit and insurance. SKS distributes
small loans that begin at Rs. 2,000 to Rs. 12,000 (about $44-$260) to poor women so they can start
and expand simple businesses and increase their incomes.
• SKS uses the group lending model
• Borrowers undergo financial literacy training and must pass a test before they are allowed to take
out loans.
• Weekly meetings with borrowers follow a highly disciplined approach.
• Re-payment rates on our collateral-free loans are more than 99% because of this systematic
process.
Organization
Founder and CEO of SKS Microfinance
PhD from University of Chicago, BA from Tufts University
Management Consultant with Mckinsey prior to SKS
Vikram Akula
COO of SKS Microfinance
Head- Alternate Channel ING Vysya Life Insurance2004 – 2006 (2
years)
AVP 1992 – 1995 (3 years)
Esanda FinANZ, a subsidiary of ANZ Grindlays Bank plc
Prior to this he worked with American Express and Standard Chartered
M R Rao Bank
SKS Microfinance 58
Snapshot of SKS Microfinance
3 C’s
Lack of capital
Capacity constraints
High cost of delivering microloans
individual women, utilizing five member groups where groups serve as the ultimate guarantor for each
member.
– Village selection
– Projection meeting
– Group Formation
– Centre Meetings
MFI Operating Income
Operating Income = Interest rates higher as compared to the
Income generated through interests from banks
loan products • Labor intensive business
- Salaries - Benefits - Other Costs • Weekly loan officer visits
- Provisions
• Extensive traveling
• Low ticket size
• Poor Infrastructure
Higher interest rates of around 23.6% to How did SKS reduce cost?
28.1%
Reduced manual processing errors
and confusion from
variance in process by
installing Portfolio
But this customer segment would not get
loans from bank and even if they got it the Tracker
cost of commute to & fro was high The system captured all the data
and tracked delivery
SKS was nicknamed “Starbucks of Indiaof loans
SKS Microfinance 61
Client
• Typical customer – Rural, poor woman, Market Sizing
earning less than $1-$2 a day
– Estimated market size Rs
• Potential market size for this profile – 150
M households
4.5 Trillion
• Estimated Credit Demand – Rs 30K – Even if probabilities are
• Occupations they were typically involved in
taken into account market
– Production, blanket weaving, candle making,
size is Rs 200 Billion
flour grinding etc – Current penetration is less
than 6%
SKS Microfinance 62
The Structure
• Conducted meetings in the day time
• Recruited new clients in the night
• Served 330 clients each
SKS Microfinance 64
Malegam Recommendation
Qualifying asset’ shall mean a loan, which satisfies the following criteria:
•Loan disbursed by an NBFC-MFI to a borrower with a rural household annual income not exceeding Rs.
60,000 or urban and semi-urban household income not exceeding Rs. 1,20,000.
•Loan amount does not exceed Rs. 35,000 in the first cycle and Rs. 50,000 in subsequent cycles.
•Tenure of the loan not to be less than 24 months for loan amount in excess of Rs. 15,000 with
prepayment without penalty.
•Loan to be extended without collateral.
•Aggregate amount of loans, given for income generation, is not less than 75 % of the total loans given by
the MFIs.
•Loan is repayable on weekly, fortnightly or monthly instalments at the choice of the borrower.
SKS Microfinance 65
Why does SKS require Capital?
• Growing number of borrowers and branches and to finance its ambitious expansion plans
• SKS depended on interest from loans given for operating income. So, not possible to give loans
to new borrowers from this income
• Not allowed to take deposits from general public
• Increased demand from commercial bank, therefore wanted to achieve first mover advantage
• Maintenance of capital adequacy ratio of 9%
• Very high debt equity ratio would increase distress costs and was very risky. So, could not
depend very much on debt and needed equity
SKS Microfinance 66
SKS Microfinance: The company that got too big
Silver Lining
• Completed a Rs 230 Crore QIP at
share price of Rs 75.4 Deutsche
Sec buys 9.15% stake
• Will help in restarting lending
Challenges
Changed Customer Perception
Regulatory environment not
favorable
Dark Times
• Andhra Pradesh Microfinance (Regulation of Moneylending) Act 2010
• Suresh Gurumani – Quit after the IPO
• Vikram Akula – Was shown the exit door
SKS Microfinance employees embezzle Rs 15.8 cr
• Auditors of the company have reported that Initiatives taken by SKS to prevent this
there was cash embezzlement by the employees Indemnity bond from every field staff Personal
to the tune of Rs 2.5 crores and loans given to guarantee of a third person Every Bank transaction
non-existent borrowers was Rs 13.3 crores requires two associates Fidelity Insurance Strong box
• Employee fraud is an inherent risk in the business controlled by two keys
SKS Microfinance soars on hopes RBI will ease bad loan norms
• Provisioning Norms for bad-loans to be relaxed In 2011 RBI mandated that MFI’s make 100% provisioning
• Asset Classification guidelines have been pushed for loans overdue for a period of more than 180 days
MFI based out of AP are facing tough times
SKS Microfinance 68
Top 5 Current Players and Leaders in MFI Industry
SKS Microfinance Ltd (SKSMPL) {HQ – Secunderabad (AP); Loan Outstd. 18227 mn}
Spandana Sphoorty Financial Ltd (SSFL) {HQ – Hyderabad (AP); Loan Outstd. 18227 mn}
Share Microfin Limited (SML) {HQ – Hyderabad (AP); Loan Outstd. 8568 mn}
Asmitha Microfin Ltd (AML) {HQ – Hyderabad (AP); Loan Outstd. 4944 mn}
SKS Microfinance 69
Value chain finance refers to:
financial products and services
in order to increase returns on investment, growth and competitiveness of that value chain.
Source image: KIT – Value Chain Finance – adapted by FSAS
Reasons for existence of the Missing Middle & Challenges in Rural
Micro Finance
-No collateral
Warehouse Receipt
Systems & Leasing
Examples of Specific Adapted VCF
Coop as inter-
mediate for MFI
lending to individual
farmers
ROLE OF MICRO FINANCE IN
RURAL DEVELOPMENT
FEATURE
S
PREFER WOMEN CUSTOMERS OVER MEN
MECHANISMS
MICROFINANCE INSTI
TUTIONS(MFIs)
(NGO,ASSOCIATION &
BANKS)
IRRIGATION, TRANSPORTATION,
MEDIUM TERM DEPOSIT LIVESTOCK, EDUCATION, etc.