HAMILTON COUNTY JUDGES CASE

STUDY
GROUP 1
1203-AJAY SHARMA
1204-AMAN KUMAR
1205-ANAKSHEE NAYAK
1206-ANKIT ANAND
1207-ANKIT KUMAR
1208-ANURAG VERMA
 BASIS OF case study and RANKING -
Introduction-

This case study refers to the performance of the judges in the

different courts of Hamilton County. In this case study we
analyze three different courts such as Common pleas court,
Domestic relations court and Municipal court. The
performance of Judges is in each and every court is analyzed
using probability techniques.
 QUESTIONS -
Question 1:
The probability of cases being appealed and reversed in the three different courts.
Ans:-
Common Pleas Court= 0.040,0.004
Domestic Relations Court=0.003,0.000
Municipal Court= 0.004, 0.000

Question 2:
The probability of a case being appealed for each judge
Question 3:
The probability of a case being reversed for each judge.
Question 4:
The probability of reversal given an appeal for each judge.
Question 5:
Rank the judges within the court. State the criteria you used and provide a rationale for your
choice.
-The ranking of the judges within each court has been done based on the probability of
reversal given an appeal since that provides how accurately they were able to take
decisions(individual judges)
 Fr
ed

0.000
0.050
0.100
0.150
0.200
0.250

Ca
rto
lan
o
Th
o m
as
C ru
Pa s h
tri
ck
D in
k ela
ck
er
Tim
ot
hy
Ho
g an
Ro
be
rt
K ra
W ft
illi
am
M
at
he
W w
s
illi
am
M
or
ris
s ey

Probability of a case being reversed for each judge

No

Probability of reversal given an appeal for each judge

rb
er
tN
ad
el
Ar
th
ur
Ne
y,
Jr.
Ri
ch
ar
Common Pleas Court

d
Ni
eh
au
s
Th
o m
as
N ur
re
Jo
hn
O’
Co
nn
Ro or
b er
tR
ue
J. hl
Ho m
w an
ar
d
Su
nd
er
m
an
An n
n
M
ar
ie
Tr
a ce
Probability of a case being appealed for each judge

y
Ra
lp
h
W
in
k ler
 Domesti c Relati ons Court
0.250 0.006

0.005
0.200

0.004
0.150

0.003

0.100
0.002

0.050
0.001

0.000 0.000
Penelope Cunningham Patrick Dinkelacker Deborah Gaines Ronald Panioto

Probability of reversal given an appeal for each judge Probability of a case being appealed for each judge
Probability of a case being reversed for each judge
 Municipal Court
0.600 0.008

0.007
0.500
0.006
0.400
0.005

0.300 0.004

0.003
0.200
0.002
0.100
0.001

0.000 0.000
en n
ac
k is es y ai
r
ick an ey rs ry sh gl
y er te
r en rt le st
l l
Al
le l av in r ad H g n b e l l o a r n a k n s ke da e
A
yB D Ga G ra el
m Ho Ke
n
eb a M atti m Pa
i Ro we
i
ck .W
ike i ne th vid h r l a i d H h y k L u M a te k c k h to A
M d o Da ai
a
Ka De ni
s
ot ric ph am el
b M es ar Ja Sc S
oh
n
Na i m I s n m a t e l l i M e th M M r k vid J
T
slie De Ti sP Jo
s
W
i B er
t
M
a Da
e l b
Le m A
Ja

Probability of reversal given an appeal for each judge Probability of a case being appealed for each judge
Probability of a case being reversed for each judge
THANK YOU