Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aggression - Raine 1997
Aggression - Raine 1997
Aggression - Raine 1997
2or
Terminal Button
3
Somatosensory cortex
Primary Motor Cortex
Parietal Taste
2
Lobe
Temperature
Touch
Decision-making Frontal
Impulse control 1
Lobe Occipital
3
Lobe
Vision
Temporal
4 Speech Brain Stem
Sound
lobe
Limbic System – match-up
1. Generates the release of hormones
such as adrenaline, preparing us for
aggression Hypothalamus
2. Relays information from the senses Amygdala
(sight, sound, etc) to the relevant Thalamus
parts of the cortex
Hippocampus
3. Long-term memory formation
4. Anger, fear and anxiety/stress centre
Split Brain
Objectives
• To be able to describe the Raine et al (1997) study in terms of: Aim,
Procedure, Results, Conclusions
• To be able to evaluate the Raine et al (1997) study in terms of GRAVE
Prefrontal
Cortex
Amygdala
(pronounced
Ahh-Mig-Dala)
RAINE et al (1997) Brain abnormalities in murderers indicated by PET Ad d
th
at th is headin
e top g
12 box es
she et i n t o
e your
Divid
Draw pictures to represent each of these stages of the experiment
23 had a history of brain
Experimental group of 41 damage, 3 with a history of There was also a control
The murderers were 39
participants convicted of drug abuse, 6 suffered group of 41 ‘normal’ people
men and 2 women (mean
murder/manslaughter who from schizophrenia, 2 with who were matched for sex
age 34.3)
had pleaded ‘not guilty by epilepsy and 7 with other and age other ways e.g. 6
reasons of insanity’ emotional or learning had schizophrenia
disorders
Murderers, had an
They then did a
Murderers had lower Murderers had less activity imbalance of activity
‘continuous performance
glucose metabolism (i.e. in corpus callosum between the left and right
task’ for 32 minutes and
less activity) in the pre- (structure that joins the two hemispheres in the limbic
their brain function was
frontal cortex halves of the brain) system: eg, less activity on
measured using a PET
the left and more on the
scan
right in the amygdala.
The results could be used to help identify people at risk of commit
violent crimes so that they can be helped to control their aggression
•Replicability: The participants’ all had exactly 32 minutes in the PET brain scanner carrying out the
same Continuous Performance Task
•Applications: The results could be used to help identify people at risk of commit violent crimes so that
they can be helped to control their aggression
•Validity – Internal: Raine made sure none of the participants (NGRIs or Controls) was on medication;
the NGRIs had been kept medication-free for 2 weeks before the PET scan
•Validity – External: The participants’ brains were scanned whilst carrying out a Continuous
Performance Task (CPT) which had nothing to do with violence or the decision to be violent
•Ethics: The murderers may have felt pressured to take part in the study as part of their process of
pleading not guilty for reason of insanity
1. Discuss
2. Write (on your own)
3. Swap
4. Discuss whose is better
and why
Limbic System – match-up
1. Generates the release of hormones
such as adrenaline, preparing us for
aggression Hypothalamus
2. Relays information from the senses Amygdala
(sight, sound, etc) to the relevant Thalamus
parts of the cortex
Hippocampus
3. Long-term memory formation
4. Anger, fear and anxiety/stress centre
1 Axon Terminal
2or
Terminal Button
3
Somatosensory cortex
Primary Motor Cortex
Parietal Taste
2
Lobe
Temperature
Touch
Decision-making Frontal
Impulse control 1
Lobe Occipital
3
Lobe
Vision
Temporal
4 Speech Brain Stem
Sound
lobe