Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Photocatalysis Challenges and Potentials
Photocatalysis Challenges and Potentials
Prof. B. Viswanathan
Department of chemistry
Indian Institute of Technology -Madras
catalyst
Photocatalysis reaction assisted by photons
2
WHY SEMICONDUCTOR ?
Metals
CB
No band gap
Only reduction or oxidation CB
H+/H2
Depends on the band CB
position
VB E
H2O/O2 VB
SC
Insulators
VB
High band gap Metals Insulators
3
Concepts –Why semiconductors are chosen as
photo-catalysts?
For conventional redox reactions, one is interested in either
reduction or oxidation of a substrate.
4
Water splitting - carry out both the redox reactions simultaneously
- reduction of hydrogen ions (2H+ + 2e- → H2) as well as (2OH-
+ 2h+ → H2O + 1/2O2 ) oxygen evolution from the hydroxyl ions.
Since in the case of metals the top of the valence band (measure
of the oxidizing power) and bottom of the conduction band
(measure of the reducing power) are almost identical they cannot
be expected to promote a pair redox reactions separated by a
potential of nearly 1.23 V.
where the top of the valence band and bottom of the conduction
band are separated at least by 1.23V in addition to the condition
that the potential corresponding to the bottom of the conduction
band has to be more negative with respect to be more negative
with respect to while the potential of the top of the valence band
has to be more positive to the oxidation potential of the reaction
2OH- + 2h+ → H2O + ½ O2.
5
This situation is obtainable with semiconductors as
well as in insulators.
6
Criterion one has to use for the selection of the
semiconductor materials and also how one can fine
tune the material thus chosen for the water
splitting reaction.
7
Ionic solids as the ionicity of the M-O bond increases, the top
of the valence band (mainly contributed by the p- orbitals of
oxide ions) becomes less and less positive (since the binding
energy of the p orbitals will be decreased due to negative
charge on the oxide ions) and the bottom of the conduction band
will be stabilized to higher binding energy values due to the
positive charge on the metal ions which is not favourable for the
hydrogen reduction reaction.
More ionic the M-O bond of the semiconductor is, the less
suitable the material is for the photo-catalytic splitting of
water. The bond polarity can be estimated from the
expression
( A B )2
Percentage ionic character (%) =
(1 e 4
) 100
8
The percentage ionic character of the M-O bond
for some of the semiconductors
Semiconductor M-O Percentage ionic
character
TiO2 Ti-O 59.5
SrTiO3 Ti-O-Sr 68.5
Fe2O3 Fe-O 47.3
Zn-O 55.5
ZnO
W-O 57.5
WO3
Cd-S 17.6
CdS Cd-S 16.5
CdSe La-O-Rh 53.0
LaRhO3 La-O-Ru 53.5
LaRuO3 Pb-O 26.5
PbO Zn-Te 5.0
ZnTe Zn-As 6.8
ZnAs Zn-Se 18.4
ZnSe Zn-S 19.5
ZnS Ga-P 3.5
GaP Cu-Se 10.0
CuSe Ba-O-Ti 70.8
BaTiO3 Mo-S 4.3
MoS2 Fe-O-Ti 53.5
K-O-Ti 72.7
FeTiO3
Mn-O-Ti 59.0
KTaO3 Sn-O 42.2
MnTiO3 Bi-O 39.6
SnO2
9
The oxide semiconductors though - suitable for the
photo-catalytic water splitting reaction in terms of
the band gap value which is greater than the water
decomposition potential of 1.23 V.
10
The photo-catalytic semiconductors are often
used with addition of metals or with other hole
trapping agents so that the life time of the
excitons created can be increased.
11
•Hence we need stoichiometrically both oxidation
and reduction for the water splitting and this
reaction will not be achieved by one of the
trapping agents namely that is used for electrons
or holes.
12
Normally the semiconductors used in photo-catalytic
processes are substituted in the cationic positions so as
to alter the band gap value.
13
In addition the dissolution potential of the
substituted systems may be more favourbale than
the water oxidation reaction and hence this will be
the preferred path way.
14
Very low value of the ionic character also is not
suitable since these semiconductors do not have
the necessary band gap value of 1.23 V. - the
search for utilizing lower end of the visible region
is not possible for direct water splitting reaction.
15
Therefore it is deduced that the systems which
has ionic bond character of about 20-30% with
suitable positions of the valence and conduction
band edges may be appropriate for the water
splitting reaction.
16
There are some other aspects of photo-
catalysts on which some remarks may be
appropriate.
17
PROCESSES ON THE PHOTO-EXCITED SEMICONDUCTOR
SURFACE AND BULK
Photodecomposition of water
19
HYDROGEN PRODUCTION
There are various methods and technologies that have
been developed and a few of them have already been
practiced. These technologies can be broadly classified
as:
Thermo-chemical routes for hydrogen production
20
Photo electrolysis of Water-Holy Grail of
Electrochemistry
21
CHALLENGES IN PHOTODECOMPOSITION OF WATER
2H + + 2e- H2 0.00V
O2 + 4e- + 4H+ 2H2O 1.229V
22
PHOTO-ELECTROCHEMICAL CELL FOR THE
PHOTO CLEAVAGE OF WATER
23
TYPES OF SEMICONDUCTORS BASED ON WATER
ELECTOLYSIS – CHOICE OF MATERIALS
NH
OR Type – Oxidation & Reduction E
H+/H2 0.00
R Type – Reduction
eV
O Type – Oxidation
H2O/O2 1.23
X type - None
the UV region.
24
Conditions for photo electrolysis of water
For the direct photo electrochemical decomposition of
water to occur, several key criteria have to be met with.
These can be stated at the first level as follows:
25
What modifications?
various conceptual principles have been incorporated into
typical TiO2 system so as to make this system responsive
to longer wavelength radiations. These efforts can be
classified as follows:
Dye sensitization
Surface modification of the semiconductor to improve the
stability
Multi layer systems (coupled semiconductors)
Doping of wide band gap semiconductors like TiO2 by
nitrogen, carbon and Sulphur
New semiconductors with metal 3d valence band instead of
Oxide 2p contribution
Sensitization by doping.
All these attempts can be understood in terms of some
kind sensitization and hence the route of charge transfer
has been extended and hence the efficiency could not be
increased considerably. In spite of these options being
elucidated, success appears to be eluding the researchers.
26
Conditions to be satisfied?
The band edges of the electrode must overlap with the
acceptor and donor states of water decomposition
reaction, thus necessitating that the electrodes should
at least have a band gap of 1.23 V, the reversible
thermodynamic decomposition potential of water. This
situation necessarily means that appropriate
semiconductors alone are acceptable as electrode
materials for water
27
ENGINEERING THE SEMICONDUCTOR
ELECTRONIC STRUCTURES
28
Positions of bands of semiconductors relative to the
standard potentials of several redox couples
29
THE AVAILABLE OPPORTUNITIES
Identifying and designing new semiconductor materials
with considerable conversion efficiency and stability
30
ADVANTAGES OF SEMICONDUCTOR NANOPARTICLES
high surface area
morphology
31
The opportunities
32
Opportunities evolved
Deposition techniques have been considerably perfected
and hence can be exploited in various other applications
like in thin film technology especially for various devices
and sensory applications.
The knowledge of the defect chemistry has been
considerably improved and developed.
Optical collectors, mirrors and all optical analysis
capability have increased which can be exploited in many
other future optical devices.
The understanding of the electronic structure of
materials has been advanced and this has helped to our
background in materials chemistry.
Many electrodes have been developed, which can be a
useful for all other kinds of electrochemical devices.
33
Limited success – Why?
The main reasons for this limited success in all these directions
are due to:
The electronic structure of the semiconductor controls the
reaction and engineering these electronic structures without
deterioration of the stability of the resulting system appears to
be a difficult proposition.
The most obvious thermodynamic barriers to the reaction and
the thermodynamic balances that can be achieved in these
processes give little scope for remarkable improvements in the
efficiency of the systems as they have been conceived and
operated. Totally new formulations which can still satisfy the
existing thermodynamic barriers have to be devised.
The charge transfer processes at the interface, even though a
well studied subject in electrochemistry has to be understood
more explicitly, in terms of interfacial energetics as well as
kinetics. Till such an explicit knowledge is available, designing
systems will have to be based on trial and error rather than
based on sound logical scientific reasoning.
34
Nanocrystalline (mainly oxides like TiO2, ZnO, SnO and Nb2O5 or
chalcogenides like CdSe) mesoscopic semiconductor materials with
high internal surface area If a dye were to be adsorbed as a
monolayer, enough can be retained on a given area of the
electrode so as to absorb the entire incident light.
35
Another aspect of thee nano crystalline state is
the alteration of the band gap to larger values as
compared to the bulk material which may facilitate
both the oxidation/reduction reactions that cannot
normally proceed on bulk semiconductors.
36
This increase is due to better light harvesting
capacity of the dye sensitized nano crystalline
material but also due to mesoscpic film texture
favouring photo-generation and collection of
charge carriers .
37
The second option is to promote water splitting in the visible range
using Tandem ells. In this a thin film of a nanocrystalline WO3 or
Fe2O3 may serve as top electrode absorbing blue part of the solar
spectrum. The positive holes generated oxidize water to oxygen
4h+ + 2H2O --- O2 + 4 H+
The electrons in the conduction band are fed to the second photo
system consisting of the dye sensitized nano crystalline TiO2 and
since this is placed below the top layer it absorbs the green or
red part of the solar spectrum that is transmitted through the
top electrode. The photo voltage generated in the second photo
system favours hydrogen generation by the reaction
4H+ + 4e- --- 2H2
38
Dye sensitized solid hetero-junctions and extremely
thin absorber solar cells have also been designed
with light absorber and charge transport material
being selected independently so as to optimize solar
energy harvesting and high photovoltaic output.
However, the conversion efficiencies of these
configurations have not been remarkably high.
39
New Opportunities
40
New Opportunities
41
New opportunities (Contd)
Recently a combinatorial electrochemical synthesis and
characterization route has been considered for
developing tungsten based mixed metal oxides and this
has thrown open yet another opportunity to quickly
screen and evaluate the performances of a variety of
systems and to evolve suitable composition-function
relationships which can be used to predict appropriate
compositions for the desired manifestations of the
functions.
It has been shown that each of these concepts, though
has its own merits and innovations, has not yielded the
desired levels of efficiency. The main reason for this
failure appears to be that it is still not yet possible to
modulate the electronic structure of the semiconductor
in the required directions as well as control the electron
transfer process in the desired direction.
42
PREPARATION OF CdS NANOPARTICLES
1 g of Zeolite (HY, H, HZSM-5)
Cd / Zeolite
CdS / Zeolite
CdS Nanoparticles
43
XRD PATTERN OF CdS
45
UV –VISIBLE SPECTRA OF CdS SAMPLES
CdS – Y 2.27
CdS - 2.21
47
AMOUNT OF HYDROGEN EVOLVED BY CdS
PHOTOCATALYST
48
TEM IMAGE OF CdS NANOPARTICLES
Surface Rate of hydrogen CdS-Z
Particle Size
Catalyst area production
(nm)
(m2/g) ( moles /h)
CdS - Y 8.8 36 102
CdS - Z 6 46 68
CdS - 11 26 67
CdS - Bulk 23 14 45
CdS-Z CdS-
100 nm 100 nm
49
SCANNING ELECTRON MICROGRAPHS
CdS-Z CdS-Y
50
PHOTOCATALYSIS ON Pt/TiO2 INTERFACE
Vacuum level
Electrons are transferred
to metal surface
Reduction of H+ ions Aq. Sol Pt TiO2 Aq. Sol
takes place at the metal
surface pH = 7 C.B
H+/H2
The holes move into pH=0
EF
the other side of
semiconductor
The oxidation takes
place at the V.B
semiconductor surface
Conduction Band
e-(M) <-- M+e-e- e- e- e- e- e- e- e- e- e- e- e-
Valence Band
h+ h+ h+ h+ h+ h+ h+ h+ h+ h+
52
PHOTOCATALYTIC
HYDROGEN EVOLUTION
OVER METAL LOADED
CdS NANOPARTICLES
53
HYDROGEN PRODUCTION ACTIVITY OF METAL
LOADED CdS PREPARED FROM H-ZSM-5
Pt
Pd
1000
Pt, Pd & Rh show higher Rh
Au
activity
Cu
100
High reduction potential.
Ag
Hydrogen over voltage
Ni
is less for Pt, Pd & Rh
10
Fe
Ru
3%
55
EFFECT OF SUPPORT ON THE CdS PHOTOCATLYTIC
ACTIVITY
2, 5,10 and 20 wt % CdS on support - by dry impregnation method
56
Pb2+/ ZnS
Absorption at 530nm (calcinations at 623-673K)
Formation of extra energy levels between the band gap by Pb
6s orbital
Low activity at 873K is due to PbS formation on the surface
(Zinc blende to wurtzite)
Eg
(a) 573 K, (b) 623 K, (c) 673 K, (d) 773 K, and (e) 873K Band structure of ZnS doped with Pb.
250 ml of 1 mM
Cd(NO3)2
Rate of addition
20 ml / h
Ultrasonic waves
= 20 kHz
58
N2 ADSORPTION - DESORPTION ISOTHERM
The specific surface area and pore volume are 94 m2/g and
0.157 cm3/g respectively
The adsorption - desorption isotherm – Type IV (mesoporous nature)
59
X- RAY DIFFRACTION PATTERN
XRD pattern of as-prepared CdS -U shows the presence of cubic
phase
The observed “d” values are 1.75, 2.04 and 3.32 Å corresponding
to the (3 1 1) (2 2 0) and (1 1 1) planes respectively - cubic
100 nm
61
PHOTOCATALYTIC HYDROGEN PRODUCTION
62
LIMITED SUCCESS – WHY?
63
THE OTHER OPPORTUNITIES EVOLVED
64
Thank you all for
your kind attention