Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project Management: Week 3 Project Management: Week 3
Project Management: Week 3 Project Management: Week 3
Project Management:
Management: Week
Week 33
1–1
Week
Week 33 Agenda:
Agenda: PERT
PERT
7–2
Unit
Unit 22 Managing
Managing various
various Aspects
Aspects of
of
Projects
Projects
7–3
Project Scheduling “Mind Map”
Work
Packages
Charter Network
Diagram/PD
M/CPM
PERT/Mont
Project
Strategy Scope WBS e Carlo
Scheduling
Critical
Chain
Project
Lifecycle
Resources
Leveling
Project Project Optimizatio
Selection Estimating n/Crashing
Monitoring
&
Controlling-
EVM
6–5
Network
Network Information
Information
TABLE 6.2
6–6
Activity-on-Node
Activity-on-Node Network
Network
FIGURE 6.5
6–7
Activity-on-Node
Activity-on-Node Network
Network Forward
Forward Pass
Pass
FIGURE 6.6
6–8
Forward
Forward Pass
Pass Computation
Computation
• Add activity times along each path in the
network (ES + Duration = EF).
• Carry the early finish (EF) to the next activity
where it becomes its early start (ES) unless…
• The next succeeding activity is a merge activity,
in which case the largest EF of all preceding
activities is selected.
6–9
Activity-on-Node
Activity-on-Node Network
Network Backward
Backward Pass
Pass
FIGURE 6.7
6–10
Backward
Backward Pass
Pass Computation
Computation
• Subtract activity times along each path in the
network (LF - Duration = LS).
• Carry the late start (LS) to the next activity
where it becomes its late finish (LF) unless
• The next succeeding activity is a burst activity, in
which case the smallest LF of all preceding
activities is selected.
6–11
Determining
Determining Free
Free Slack
Slack (or
(or Float)
Float)
• Free Slack (or Float)
– Is the amount of time an activity can be delayed after
the start of a longer parallel activity or activities.
– Is how long an activity can exceed its early finish date
without affecting early start dates of any successor(s).
– Allows flexibility in scheduling scarce resources.
• Sensitivity
– The likelihood the original critical path(s) will change
once the project is initiated.
– The critical path is the network path(s) that has (have)
the least slack in common.
6–12
Activity-on-Node
Activity-on-Node Network
Network with
with Slack
Slack
FIGURE 6.8
6–13
Free
Free Slack
Slack Example
Example
FIGURE 6.9
6–14
PERT,
PERT, Schedule
Schedule Risk
Risk and
and Uncertainty
Uncertainty
Schedule risks!
7–15
Why
Why PERT?
PERT?
7–17
Activity
Activity and
and Project
Project Frequency
Frequency Distributions
Distributions
FIGURE A7.1
7–18
Uh-oh…PERT
Uh-oh…PERT uses
uses stats….
stats….
7–19
First,
First, let’s
let’s look
look at
at the
the normal
normal curve
curve
7–20
This is normal?
Importance of
Normal Distribution
1. Describes many random processes or
continuous phenomena
2. Basis for classical statistical inference
Normal Distribution
f(x )
How wide?
How thin?
Mean
Median
Mode
Central tendency
μ
Effect of Varying
Parameters ( & )
f(X)
B
A C
X
Measuring:
• Time duration of class: Hours
• Distance from here to there: Miles/Kilometers
• How far from the center of a normal curve?
Probability is the
area under
curve!
f( x )
x
c d
The normal curve and probability
Heard of “Six Sigma?”
6
So what? Why should PMs care about this?
7–31
7–32
Normal
Normal Curve
Curve Rules
Rules of
of Thumb
Thumb
7–34
Class
Class Time
Time Estimate
Estimate (Minutes)
(Minutes)
• 3 hrs, 20 mins = 210 mins
– Let’s assume previous class finish times
Probability of finishing at 210 minutes?
Class Times Probability of finishing at 195 minutes?
Class 1 210 95% probability finishing time?
Class 2 205
Class 3 207
Class 4 212
Class 5 205
Class 6 200
Class 7 220
Mean 208.43
SD 6.40
7–35
Let’s
Let’s estimate
estimate project
project task
task durations
durations
Hmmm..how
long is it
gonna take??
7–36
Activity
Activity Time
Time Calculations
Calculations
(7.1)
7–37
Activity
Activity Time
Time Calculations
Calculations (cont’d)
(cont’d)
The variability in the activity time estimates is approximated by the following
equations:
(7.2)
(7.3)
Note the standard deviation of the activity is squared in this equation; this
is also called variance. This sum includes only activities on the critical
path(s) or path being reviewed.
7–38
Probability
Probability of
of Completing
Completing the
the Project
Project
(7.4)
7–39
Activity
Activity Times
Times and
and Variances
Variances
TABLE A7.1
7–40
Hypothetical
Hypothetical Network
Network (cont’d)
(cont’d)
7–41
Activity
Activity Times
Times and
and Variances
Variances
TABLE A7.1
7–42
Possible
Possible Project
Project Duration
Duration
Probability project is completed before Probability project is completed
scheduled time (TS) of 67 units by the 60th unit time period (TS)
FIGURE A7.3
7–43
ZZ Values
Values and
and Probabilities
Probabilities
TABLE A7.2
7–44
Finding Z Values
for Known Probabilities
What is Z, given Standardized Normal
P(Z) = .1217? Probability Table (Portion)
=0 ?
.31 Z 0.2 .0793 .0832 .0871
= 5 8.1
? X = 0 .31 Z
X Z 5 . 3 1 1 0 8 . 1
Shaded areas exaggerated
Key
Key Takeaways:
Takeaways:
7–47
Case
Case Study
Study Example
Example
7–48
Assume that you are a project manager within a company that
installs upgrades and maintains computers and networks. Your
company has won a bid to complete a project consisting of
upgrading a network of desktop computers in a call center. The
upgrades consist of updating the operating system and call center
application of each of the computers, performing memory upgrades
to those desktops that require it, and converting from a wired to a
wireless LAN network.
7–49
Tasks
Tasks
7–50
Identifier Task Description Predecessor
3 PC upgrade plan 1
6 Order software 3
7–52
Identifier Task Description Predecessor BC WC ML
3 PC upgrade plan 1 5 10 7
equipment
6 Order software 3 2 5 3
cards
10 Author training 6 10 20 15
materials/guide
12 System cutover 11 1 1 1
7–53
Identifier Task Description Predecessor WAE
10 Author training 6
15
materials/guide
12 System cutover 11 1
7–54
7–55
Identifier Task Description Predecessor BC WC ML ((WC-
BC)/6)^2
equipment
6 Order software 3 2 5 3
cards
10 Author training 6 10 20 15
materials/guide
12 System cutover 11 1 1 1 1
7–56
Project
Project Standard
Standard Deviation
Deviation
7–57
What
What does
does this
this mean?
mean?
7–58
The
The “Recipe”
“Recipe”
7–59
The
The “Recipe”
“Recipe” (cont.)
(cont.)
-1/(project SD)
-3/(project SD)
-5/(project SD)
7–60
What
What ifif you
you don’t
don’t have
have aa convection
convection
oven?
oven? ….or
….or aa ZZ table
table in
in your
your wallet?
wallet?
Ballpark the probability using the “Rules of Thumb” for the normal curve
(think 68-95-99).
7–61
What
What ifif you
you don’t
don’t have
have aa convection
convection
oven?
oven? ….or
….or aa ZZ table
table in
in your
your wallet?
wallet?
What about adding 1.5 SD using the Rules of thumb? In this case,
we add to 50%, not subtract, as follows:
7–62
Normal
Normal Curve
Curve Rules
Rules of
of Thumb
Thumb
– Therefore…it’s a project!
What’s next? Getting Started
• Formal authorization…the charter
• Identify who is involved, who is interested in the
outcome, who might be willing to help …..the
stakeholders
• Determine exactly WHAT needs to be done….the
SCOPE
• First boil it down…the scope statement
• Then, expand….the WBS
The charter…
Budget
Finance Building
Payments specifications
Furniture
Infrastructure Transition Plan
Office Relocation
Communication Layout
Utilities
Planners Existing Location
Close out plan
Coordinators Relocation
Management
Packing
Packers Personnel
Movers
…a hierarchical and
categorical structured
outline of the project
deliverables…
The Task List (high level)…
1-10
15-5
4-10 5-20 6-10
Say…I’m going to
need you to reduce
your schedule by ten
days…that would be Oh no!
great…thanks….
How to respond?
• Ask for a project brainstorming meeting with
sponsoring executives
• Present high level schedule for office relocation
• Ask for consensus of “Best-Case”, “Worst-Case”
and “Optimistic” durations for each element of
schedule.
• Show probability of achieving estimated
schedule, AND
• MOST importantly—show probability of
achieving the requested schedule reduction.
Where
Where are
are we
we now?
now?
Course Contents:
Unit 2 Managing various Aspects of Projects2.1Project Time Management: WBS –Work breakdown structure, Gantt
Chart, Arrow on Arrow diagram, PERT/CPM
2.2 Project Cost Management –Introduction to RFP, Invitation to Bid, Tender process, Technical and Commercial Bids.
2.3 Project Quality Management
2.4 Project Risk Management
2.5 Project Completion and Handover –Methods of Project Closure
5. Self-Learning Module In this Module, students will search on internet PMI and PMBOK, to understand process
(methodology -Input/Tools and Techniques and Output)
Project
Project Risk
Risk Management
Management
11–79
Just
Just what
what is
is risk?
risk?
11–80
What
What is
is the
the opposite
opposite of
of RISK?
RISK?
CERTAINTY!
11–81
Risk
Risk Requires
Requires Management
Management
11–82
Risk
Risk and
and Project
Project Management
Management
11–83
11–84
The
The alternative
alternative to
to proactive
proactive
management
management is is reactive
reactive
management,
management, alsoalso called
called crisis
crisis
management.
management. ThisThis requires
requires
significantly
significantly more
more resources
resources
and
and takes
takes longer
longer for
for problems
problems
to
to surface.
surface.
Background
Background to
to risk
risk and
and uncertainty
uncertainty..
Risk
Risk as
as aa concept
concept
Dangerous sports.
Gambling.
Investments.
Entering a relationship.
Getting married.
Definition
Definition of
of risk
risk
• Risk is a measure of the probability and consequence of
not achieving a specific project goal.
• Risk depends on both the likelihood of occurrence
(probability) and the consequences of occurrence
(impact).
• Questions to be asked:
Do the returns justify the risk?
What is the extent of the loss if things go wrong?
Risk is concerned with the ‘known’ (conditions of
certainty), ‘known unknowns’ (conditions of risk) and
‘unknown unknowns’ (conditions of uncertainty).
Example:
Example: Investing
Investing In
In Tesla
Tesla
11–89
The
The Basic
Basic Risk
Risk Types
Types
•Risk origin and impact categories
11–91
External
External Risks
Risks
• External risks: may be calculable but not controllable
• Time-dependent risk: insurance policy expiration
• Competitor risk: new company, product
• Customer demand risk
• Exposure risk: gearing, borrowing; oil producers to oil
prices
• Shareholder risk: (loss of confidence makes it difficult to
raise capital)
• Political risk: home and neighbouring countries, fiscal
policy, UK/Euro
• Legislative risk: change existing statutes, introduce new
one, (e.g. green)
11–92
Internal
Internal Risks
Risks
11–93
Internal
Internal Risks
Risks
11–94
Sensitivity
Sensitivity to
to Risks
Risks
Firm sensitivity is function of:
•Severity of exposure to occurrence of events
•Likelihood of events
•Ability to handle events
Questions for risk taker:
•What are possible outcomes?
•Are outcomes related?
•How sensitive are strategies, earnings to occurrence?
•Is achievement of critical objectives affected?
•How capable are we of responding?
•How much potential reward is required to accept risks?
•If we accept to we have sufficient capital to absorb unforeseen
losses?
11–95
Key
Key variables
variables and
and risk
risk..
• Risk is the distribution of possible outcomes in a firms
performance over a given time horizon due to changes
in key underlying variables.
• The greater the dispersion of probable outcomes, the
higher the firm’s level of exposure to uncertain returns.
• These uncertain returns can have either positive or
negative values.
• Therefore both positive and negative changes in key
variables must be viewed as sources of risk.
Distribution
Distribution of
of Outcomes
Outcomes
11–97
Is
Is risk
risk aa good
good thing?
thing?
• Because of the potential for positive outcomes, risk
is a good thing.
• Risk is necessary in order to have an opportunity to
add value.
• Risk breeds innovation.
• Risk is a necessary by product of the creation of
new value in the market place.
•Risk mapping
•Risk profiling
•Risk footprinting.
Mice,
Mice, Rabbits,
Rabbits, Lions,
Lions, Sharks
Sharks (oh
(oh my!)
my!)
11–105
Types
Types of
of risk
risk
Risk
Risk seeker
neutral
Money at stake
General
General risk
risk response
response matrix
matrix..
Pragmatic
Which one
Synthesizer are you?
Risk Modifier
taking
Planner
Dreamer
Repeater
Low
High
Building contractor Architect
Accountant
Low Doctor
2 1 day …
days well..uhm....
3 Hmmm..
days
Compiling the executive
estimates…. Task 8 Task 14
BC ML WC BC ML WC
# # # # # #
7 10 12 25 30 35 25 30 35 # # # # # # 3 5 7 3 5 7 3 5 7 3 5 7
7 10 12 15 20 25 8 10 13 # # #
100-(50+(95/2))= <2.5%!
What you now get to say….
According to your
We will certainly own estimates, we
do our best to have only a 2.5%
reduce the chance of
schedule 10 days… achieving this….
Hmmmm…. however…
1. PERT can help you get agreement on the schedule you need to
be successful by using the very estimates of the management
team pushing you for a reduced schedule.
2. The probability of achieving a schedule built using weighted
averages of estimates is only 50%!
3. Schedule reductions from the 50% estimate drop the probability
rapidly (how rapidly depends upon the project SD!)
4. What you really need is a 95% probability schedule. This requires Yay!
adding at least (ballpark) 1.5 SDs worth of duration to your
project schedule.
5. The statistics are easy, and may be done on a white board—right
in front of those executives!
Monte
Monte Carlo
Carlo Analysis
Analysis
http://quantmleap.com/blog/2010/07/project-risk-management-and-the-application-of-monte-
carlo-simulation/
7–126
7–127
7–128
6-129
Risk Identification
• Brainstorming
• Checklists
• Prompt List-SWOT the PEST Project administration
Technical
• RBS—Risk Breakdown Client
• Stakeholder
Scenario planning/what if analysis Schedule
Risk Assessment
• Probability/Impact-qualitative (quantitative IF: historical data)
• FMEA-P/I/Ability to detect flaws
• Decision Tree
• Monte Carlo/PERT
Risk Response (“MART”)
• Mitigate—taking-action (reduce P, reduce I), Mitigation plan=Positive risk = Exploit
• Avoid—Don’t do it!
• Retain
• Transfer—Insurance and contracts
6-130
Risk Monitoring and Control
• Risk Register (Log: Risk, description, owner, mitigation plan)
Ranking: P/I or P/I/Ability to detect
• Which? (Lions or Hi P/Hi I or both)
Change control (Integrated change control)
• Risk response-mitigation plan
• Scope risk
Lessons learned
• Captured throughout project
• Reviewed at end of project
• Converted into OPA—Organizational Process Assets
• EEF-Enterprise Environmental Factors
6-131
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc.
Publishing as Prentice Hall 6-132
7–133
Risk
Risk Management
Management Process
Process
• Risk
– Uncertain or chance events that planning can not
overcome or control.
• Risk Management
– A proactive attempt to recognize and manage internal
events and external threats that affect the likelihood of
a project’s success.
• What can go wrong (risk event).
• How to minimize the risk event’s impact (consequences).
• What can be done before an event occurs (anticipation).
• What to do when an event occurs (contingency plans).
7–134
The
The Risk
Risk Event
Event Graph
Graph
FIGURE 7.1
7–135
Risk
Risk Management’s
Management’s Benefits
Benefits
• A proactive rather than reactive approach.
• Reduces surprises and negative consequences.
• Prepares the project manager to take advantage
of appropriate risks.
• Provides better control over the future.
• Improves chances of reaching project performance
objectives within budget and on time.
7–136
The
TheRisk
Risk
Management
Management
Process
Process
FIGURE 7.2
7–137
Managing
Managing Risk
Risk
• Step 1: Risk Identification
– Generate a list of possible risks through brainstorming,
problem identification and risk profiling.
• Macro risks first, then specific events
• Step 2: Risk Assessment
– Scenario analysis for event probability and impact
– Risk assessment matrix
– Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA)
– Probability analysis
• Decision trees, NPV, and PERT
– Semiquantitative scenario analysis
7–138
The
TheRisk
RiskBreakdown
BreakdownStructure
Structure(RBS)
(RBS)
FIGURE 7.3
7–139
Risk Breakdown Structure
Level 0 Level 1 Level 2 Level
3 </TBL_COLHD>
Project Risk Management Corporate Organizational stability
Financial stability
Stakeholders History and culture
Financial stability
Requirements
definitions and scope
External Cultural Cultural issues
Political, legal,
regulatory issues
Interest groups, lobbyist
issues
Economic Labor market
Labor conditions
Copyright © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc.
Financial markets
Publishing as Prentice Hall 6-140
Internal and External Risks
Internal risks
• Internal risks can be controlled by project managers and
stakeholders.
• They originate from all phases of a project.
• Examples of internal risks are not meeting time, cost,
scope, performance and value of a project due to
technological difficulties.
• Internal risks occur due to failure in customer
relationships. These may be due to failure in key
success factors of a project.
External risks
• These risks are from sources outside the project.
• Project managers or stakeholders have little or no
control over these risks.
• Physical risks encompass damage by fire, flood, or other
catastrophe, computer virus that infects the
development environment or operational system, and a
team member who steals confidential project material
and makes it available to competitors.
FIGURE 7.4
7–144
Defined
DefinedConditions
Conditionsfor
forImpact
Impact Scales
Scales of
ofaaRisk
Riskon
onMajor
Major
Project
Project Objectives
Objectives(Examples
(Examplesforfornegative
negativeimpacts
impactsonly)
only)
FIGURE 7.5
7–145
PFMEA
7–147
PFMEA
FIGURE 7.7
7–153
Managing
Managing Risk
Risk (cont’d)
(cont’d)
• Step 3: Risk Response Development
– Mitigating Risk
• Reducing the likelihood an adverse event will occur.
• Reducing impact of adverse event.
– Avoiding Risk
• Changing the project plan to eliminate the risk or condition.
– Transferring Risk
• Paying a premium to pass the risk to another party.
• Requiring Build-Own-Operate-Transfer (BOOT) provisions.
– Retaining Risk
• Making a conscious decision to accept the risk.
7–154
Contingency
Contingency Planning
Planning
• Contingency Plan
– An alternative plan that will be used if a possible
foreseen risk event actually occurs.
– A plan of actions that will reduce or mitigate the
negative impact (consequences) of a risk event.
7–155
Risk
Risk and
and Contingency
Contingency Planning
Planning
• Technical Risks
– Backup strategies if chosen technology fails.
– Assessing whether technical uncertainties
can be resolved.
• Schedule Risks
– Use of slack increases the risk of a late project finish.
– Imposed duration dates (absolute project finish date)
– Compression of project schedules due to a shortened
project duration date.
7–156
Risk
Risk Response
Response Matrix
Matrix
FIGURE 7.8
7–157
Risk Identification
7–166
Opportunity
Opportunity Management
Management Tactics
Tactics
• Exploit
– Seeking to eliminate the uncertainty associated with an
opportunity to ensure that it definitely happens.
• Share
– Allocating some or all of the ownership of an opportunity to
another party who is best able to capture the opportunity for the
benefit of the project.
• Enhance
– Taking action to increase the probability and/or the positive
impact of an opportunity.
• Accept
– Being willing to take advantage of an opportunity if it occurs, but
not taking action to pursue it.
7–167
Contingency
Contingency Funding
Funding and
and Time
Time Buffers
Buffers
• Contingency Funds
– Funds to cover project risks—identified and unknown.
• Size of funds reflects overall risk of a project
– Budget reserves
• Are linked to the identified risks of specific work packages.
– Management reserves
• Are large funds to be used to cover major unforeseen risks
(e.g., change in project scope) of the total project.
• Time Buffers
– Amounts of time used to compensate for unplanned
delays in the project schedule.
• Severe risk, merge, noncritical, and scarce resource activities
7–168
Contingency
Contingency Fund
Fund Estimate
Estimate ($000s)
($000s)
TABLE 7.1
7–169
Risk mitigation techniques: Scope
7–179
Change
Change Management
Management Control
Control
• Sources of Change
– Project scope changes
– Implementation of contingency plans
– Improvement changes
7–180
Change
Change Control
Control System
System Process
Process
1. Identify proposed changes.
2. List expected effects of proposed changes
on schedule and budget.
3. Review, evaluate, and approve or disapprove
of changes formally.
4. Negotiate and resolve conflicts of change,
condition, and cost.
5. Communicate changes to parties affected.
6. Assign responsibility for implementing change.
7. Adjust master schedule and budget.
8. Track all changes that are to be implemented
7–181
The
TheChange
ChangeControl
Control
Process
Process
FIGURE 7.9
7–182
Benefits
Benefits of
of aa Change
Change Control
Control System
System
1. Inconsequential changes are discouraged
by the formal process.
2. Costs of changes are maintained in a log.
3. Integrity of the WBS and performance measures
is maintained.
4. Allocation and use of budget and management
reserve funds are tracked.
5. Responsibility for implementation is clarified.
6. Effect of changes is visible to all parties involved.
7. Implementation of change is monitored.
8. Scope changes will be quickly reflected in baseline
and performance measures.
7–183
Sample
SampleChange
Change
Request
Request Form
Form
FIGURE 7.10
7–184
Change
Change
Request
RequestLog
Log
FIGURE 7.11
7–185
Summary
7–189