Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 106

In Search of Excellence

7-QC Tools
What is a Process

Input Output
Process
Raw Material Finished or
Intermediate
A Value adding Product
Transformation

Opportunities to
Measure

All work is accomplished by a process


2 In Search of Excellence
Improvement
Bad
Sporadic
Chronic

Breakthrough

Good

 Change from current level of performance to a superior


level and staying there
3 In Search of Excellence
Understanding Variation

Variation

Assignable Chance
(Special Cause) (Random Cause)
 Sporadic  Random
 Very Few  Large in number
 Large contribution  Small contribution
 Easy to identify  Difficult to identify and
and eliminate eliminate
4 In Search of Excellence
Product Process Mapping
Product CTQs
Process flow diagram Process
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
CTQs
CTQ

CTQ

CTQ

CTQ

CTQ High
CTQ correlation
CTQ

CTQ

CTQ

CTQ

CTQ

CTQ

CTQ

5 In Search of Excellence
What is a problem?

Problem is an unsatisfied
performance in product/ service.

6 In Search of Excellence
A problem could be
• nonconformance
• scrap
• chronic rework
• recurring accepted on deviation poor yield
• customer complaint
• machine breakdown
• low process capability
• loosing customers
• reducing market share
• late delivery, etc.

7 In Search of Excellence
Known approaches for problem solving

Traditional method: requires no


factual analysis or observations
Symptom Remedy

Scientific and methodical.


Symptom Root Cause Remedy

8 In Search of Excellence
Steps of Problem Solving

1. Definition - Identify and defining the problem


2. Observation/Measure - Investigating the features of the
problem
3. Analysis - Finding the root causes
4. Actions - Establishing and implementing
countermeasures
5. Check - Ensuring the effectiveness of the
remedies & countermeasures
- Results v/s Plan
6. Standardization - Holding the gains
7. Conclusion - Reviewing the problem solving
approach and identifying next problem
9 In Search of Excellence
7-QC Tools

Check sheet
Pareto Diagram
Stratification
Cause and Effect Diagram
Scatter diagram
Histogram
Graphs & Charts

10 In Search of Excellence
Check Sheet

11 In Search of Excellence
What is check sheet?

A convenient and compact


format to facilitate data gathering
& to quantify the current status
or magnitude of the problem

12 In Search of Excellence
Data Collection

What is Data ?
Data is a numerical expression of an activity

Quantitative Qualitative
• Measurable • Subjective assessment
 e.g. :Length, e.g. :Score in a
Temperature beauty contest
• Countable
 e.g. :Number of
defects
13 In Search of Excellence
Population, Sample and Data

Random Measurement
Population Data
Sample
(Lot) Sampling / Observation

Action

Objectives of Data Collection


• To know and quantify the status
• To monitor the process
• To decide acceptance or rejection
• To analyse and decide the course of action
14 In Search of Excellence
How to collect data?

Define the purpose


 Decide the type of analysis
 Define the period of data collection
 Is the the required data already available ?

15 In Search of Excellence
For Proper Data Collection

 Proper sampling procedure


 Proper choice of instruments
 Calibration of instruments used
 Availability of standards for sensory
characteristics
 Adequate lighting and other
test/ inspection facilities.

16 In Search of Excellence
Purpose of Check Sheet

 Simplify of data gathering


 Provide preliminary summarisation
 Provide a basis for statistical analysis
 Problem monitoring
 Direction of trouble shooting

17 In Search of Excellence
Areas of application

Production: Measurements on process parameters,


No. of defects in products,
Location of defect.

Raw Material: No of defects,location of defects,


Measurement on Quality Characteristics.

Maintenance: Maintenance time, down time,


Machine wise break-down,
Causes of break down.

18 In Search of Excellence
Type of check
sheets
Purpose of Checking Type of Check Sheet
Determine defect details Defective item check sheet

Determine occurrence of defects Defect factor check sheet


by day, week, operator, machine etc

Determine where defects occur Defect location check sheet

Determine dispersion of dimensions, Process distribution check


hardness, weight etc. sheet

Inspect machines or equipment or Inspection and validation


check the operating procedure check sheet

19 In Search of Excellence
Production Process Distribution Check sheet

Diameter of Component X
Department : Operator :
Specification : Dates : to
Measurement Frequency of occurrence
(cms) 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Total
0.95 l 1
0.96 lll 3
0.97 llll ll 7
0.98 llll llll llll ll 17
0.99 llll llll lll l llll llll 25
1.00 llll llll llll llll llll llll llll llll l 42
1.01 llll llll llll llll llll l 26
1.02 llll llll llll lll 18
1.03 llll l 6
1.04 llll 4
1.05 llll 1

20 In Search of Excellence
Location Check
sheet

Hood Paint Defects


Name: ____
Date: ____
Model: ____ DD D
S

XXX
B X
X = Dirt
D = Dent
S = Scratch
No. inspected: _____ B = Bubble

21 In Search of Excellence
In Search of Excellence

PARETO DIAGRAM
A tool to select vital few and few trivial
many.

80-20 Rule

23 In Search of Excellence
Pareto chart by
effect

To find out what the major problem is Viz.


Quality: Defects, Faults , Failures, Complaints,
Repairs, Returned items etc.
Cost: Amount of loss, Expenses
Delivery: Stock, Shortages, Delay in delivery,
Default in payment.
Safety: Accidents, Breakdowns, mistakes.

24 In Search of Excellence
Pareto chart by Cause

To find out what the major problem is Viz.


 Operator Shift, Group,
Experience, Skill.
 Machine Machines,
Equipment,
Tools
 Raw material Manufacturer, lot
 Operational method Conditions, Order,
Method

25 In Search of Excellence
Uses of Pareto diagram

Find out the most important item/defect.


Ratio of each item to the whole.
Degree of improvement after remedial action in
some limited area.
Improvement in each item/defect compared before
and after correction.

26 In Search of Excellence
How to prepare a Pareto diagram

Decide which item to be studied.

Stratify the problem according to sources (by defects,


by supplier etc.) and tabulate the corresponding data.

Arrange the stratified items in descending order of value


and draw a bar diagram.

Draw a curve showing the cumulative % above the bar


chart starting from the greatest value.

27 In Search of Excellence
Pareto Analysis for inspection of product ABC

100%
90%
80%
Percentage Defects

70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
g
sh

er
s

k
s

ns
in
he
le

ac
rn
ni

ck

ai
bb

Fi

co
tc

Cr
Pa

St
Bu

ra
h

k
ug

ed
Sc

ea
Ro

ag

W
m

Defects
Da

28 In Search of Excellence
In Search of Excellence

STRATIFICATION
The method of grouping data by common points or characteristics
to understand similarities and characteristics of data is called
stratification.

30 In Search of Excellence
Such classification helps in obtaining vital
information by distinguishing and comparing
data in different class or strata.

It also identifies the key strata to concentrate on

31 In Search of Excellence
The stratification may be based on machines, operators, shifts or
any other source of variation.

32 In Search of Excellence
The purpose of stratification is to ascertain the difference
between different categories and to analyse the reasons
behind abnormal distribution.

33 In Search of Excellence
IDENTIFY STRATIFICATION CRITERIA FOR COLLECTING
DATA ON HOUSE KEEPING DEFECTS:
RESULT: # OF DEFECTS PER AUDIT

STRATIFICATION CRITERIA:

• TYPE OF DEFECTS
• LOCATION
• DATE & TIME
• AUDITED BY
• PEOPLE IN THE LOCATION
34 • INFRASTRUCTURES AVAILABLE
In Search of Excellence
TYPE OF STRATIFICATION CRITERIA:

• IDENTITY: e.g. product name, reference no. …


• MACHANICAL:
• OPERATIONAL:
• TECHNICAL:
• ENVIRONMENTAL
• MEASUREMENT:
• BEHAVIOURAL/SKILL RELATED
• TIME RELATED:
• ROLE, RESPONSIBILITY & AUTHORITY RELATED:
35 In Search of Excellence
Areas of application

Raw material
Rejection % in supplier wise and batch wise.

Production
Stratification as per Machine, Shift, operator
etc. of rejections.

Engineering and design


Stratification of drawing errors draftsman wise.

36 In Search of Excellence
USE OF STRATIFICATION:

REVIEW ADEQUACY OF PRESENTLY USED DATA


COLLECTION MODE LIKE REGISTER, LOGBOOK etc.

INTRODUCING NEW DATA COLLECTION MODE

COLLECTION OF DATA FOR ANY SPECIFIC


PURPOSE

BEFORE CHECKSHEET

37 In Search of Excellence
In Search of Excellence

BRAIN STORMING
Basic Rules for Brainstorming

Defer evaluation

Fantasize freely

Generate quantity

Build on ideas

39 In Search of Excellence
Generate Quantity

Generate as many ideas as possible.

A pearl diver will be more successful in finding


pearls, when he brings up 200 oysters than when
he surfaces only 15-20 oysters.

40 In Search of Excellence
In Search of Excellence

Cause & Effect Diagram

(Optional)
Tree Diagram
&
Affinity Diagram
In Search of Excellence

Organizing
Potential Causes
Looking for Relationships
Graphic displays can help you structure possible causes in order to find
relationships that will shed new light on your problem.

Means

Cause & Effect Diagram Tree Diagram


Means/Objective
Means

Means/Objective
Means
Means/Objective
Means
Objective

Means
Means/Objective
Means

Affinity Diagram Means/Objective


Means
Means/Objective
Means

43 In Search of Excellence
Cause-and-Effect Diagram

Cause-and-effect
diagrams graphically Men Machine
display potential
causes of a problem.
The layout shows
cause-and-effect
Problem
relationships
between the
potential causes.

Material Method

44 In Search of Excellence
Cause-and-Effect Diagram Features
Potential causes
at lower level Narrowly defined
would contribute problem forms
to cause at next Storm Power Bulb head of the fish;
Old
level up causes listed on
Burned
Power Outage Out Replace the diagram
Bulb should potentially
Power Plant Broken contribute to this
Failure
Is Current problem
Circuit Breaker On? Loose
Is Bill
No House Paid?
Arrows Current
Missing
indicate the
direction of Unpaid Bill Wall Switch Lamp
potential Turned Off Assembly error
Doesn’t
cause-and- Turn On
effect Not Plugged In Switch
Broken

Chewed
by Dog Switch
Causes Missing One “spine” leads
Cord Cut into head (problem
grouped by
relationship statement).
to each Vandal No Contact Contributing
other causes are
Corroded arranged on
smaller and
Plug/Cord Lamp smaller “bones.”
High humidity

45 In Search of Excellence
Width variation Narrowly defined
Slot dim variation problem forms
Warpage
Wrong placement ofof the fish;
head
Material Lgth variation Operator terminal incauses
slot listed on
Unskilled
Base dim. the diagram
Base material operator Interchange of terminal in slots
should potentially
variation
Thickness variation
not ok contribute to this
Hardness negligence
Width of Base problem
Width dim. variation Dust in locator
less Wrong placement of
Terminal dim. Flash in slot fatigue
base in fixture locator
variation
Lgth dim. variation
Uneven leg of Blinker
thickness base base
Punch & locator crack
misalignment
Worn-out punch
Wrong sequence Pressure
of operation variation
Oversize
d Locator
Stopper Play of base in
not Unequal locator slot
working Punch level
Height of Offset of terminal
Method Stopper Machine CL and Punch CL
less/more

46 In Search of Excellence
Why Use Cause-and-Effect Diagrams

 To stimulate thinking
during a brainstorm
of potential causes
 To understand
relationships between
potential causes
 To track which
potential causes
have been investigated,
and which proved to contribute
significantly to the problem

47 In Search of Excellence
When to Use Cause-and-Effect
Diagrams

Use a Cause-and-Effect Diagram:

When there is so large a number of potential causes


that it is difficult to focus the analysis.

When there is a lack of clarity about the relationship


between different potential causes.

48 In Search of Excellence
Effective Use of Cause-and-Effect
Diagrams

 Have a narrowly defined problem to start with.


 This should come from your work in Measure.
 Capture cause-and-effect relationships between units and sub-units.

Bulb

Burned out
Loose
Lamp does not burn
 Causes on the diagram must be verified with data
to confirm that they are real causes.

49 In Search of Excellence
How to Create a Cause-and-Effect
Diagram

1. Review the Focused Problem Statement

2. Identify Possible Causes

3. Sort Possible Causes into Reasonable Clusters

4. Choose a Cluster and label a main Bone

5. Develop and Arrange Bones for that Cluster

6. Develop Other Main Bones

50 In Search of Excellence
Avoid Common Mistakes

 Do not use this tool as an alternative form of outlining

Lamp
Cord
Switch Plug
Lamp does
not burn

 Do not use the tool to list potential solutions

People

Increase
headcount
Offer premium
Cycle time too
Long

51 In Search of Excellence
“The Five Whys” and Mile-Deep Thinking

Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Problem Etc.
A B C D E F G H I J K L M

Local focus
“Ask the question on causes
‘Why’ five times”
Why?
1. Why did X happen? Wider focus
Because of W. on causes

2. Why did W happen? Why?


Because of V. Wider focus
on causes

3. Why did V happen? Why?


Because of U. Wider focus
on causes

4. Why did U happen? Why?


Because of T. Wider focus
on causes

5. Why did T Why?


happen? Wider focus
Because of S. on causes
52 In Search of Excellence
The “Might Cause” Check

 Helps to confirm the items listed are potential causes


 Helps to check relationships between items
Might Cause Check

<smallest bone>

might cause
<next largest bone>

which might cause


<next largest bone>

which might cause


<main bone>

which might cause


<head (problem statement)>
53 In Search of Excellence
Might Cause Example

Might Cause Check

High humidity
<smallest bone>

Corrosion
might cause
<next largest bone>

which might cause


<next largest bone>

No contact
which might cause
<main bone>

Lamp does not turn on


which might cause
<head (problem statement)>

54 In Search of Excellence
Cause and Effect Diagram for high
petrol consumption
Procedure Driver Vehicle

Spark plugs
Impatience Heavy Contacts
Poor Bad Life
Craze
anticipation attitude
Body Technical
Wrong Poor details
skill Shape
Always gears Fuel mix
late Lack of Inexperience High H.P Carburetor
awareness Wrong
Riding on culture Engine
clutch
Cylinders High Petrol
Spurious Consumption
Crossings Spares Impurities
Restrictions Traffic Incorrect
One way
No turn Tyres Inferior Octane no.
Frequent Petrol
Faulty
Circuitous stops Negligence
Speed Breakers pressure Additives
Road
Ignorance
Potholes Irregular Incorrect viscosity
Low pressure
Poor servicing
Clogged
condition Oil
False filters
Steep economy Not changed
Low level
Road Maintenance Materials

55 In Search of Excellence
Tree Diagram Definition

Another way to find structure in potential causes is to use a


tree diagram, which is a tool used to arrange related ideas in
sequence from broad and general to narrow and specific.

56 In Search of Excellence
Causal Tree Diagram Features
Levels of Whys are reflected
As you move out to the right Order Entry
RAW UNPLANNED USAGE
MATERIAL REJECTED @ LAB NO C OF A
SHORTAGE LONG APPROVAL TIME PRIORITIES NOT KNOWN
27%
PARTIAL SHIPMENTS ARRIVES IN BATCHES
LATE DELIVERIES
LATE ORDERING R.M. SHORTAGE

LONG MFG. TIME WAIT @ FILLING


GRINDER AVAILABILITY
ORDERS W/O
PROBLEMS INVENTORY ACCURACY WRONG QUANTITY
35% WRONG LOCATION

NOT SURE WE'LL GET AN ORDER

FORMULA NOT ON FILE ORDER BEFORE OR WITH APPROVAL


NEW FORMULA
CODE NOT
DISCONTINUED R.M. ORDERS ARRIVE IN BATCHES
ON FILE NEW CONTAINER SIZE
25% PURGED FORMULA
ORDER ENTRY
SWITCH FROM PURCH.
CYCLE TIME
TO PRODUCT
IS TOO LONG
Most specific
DIDN'T KNOW DATA
WAS NEEDED
Lines connect causes appear to
related series of the far right
Problem
causes
appears at far
left with the FORMULA ON FILE BUT NOT APPROVED

potential NOTIFICATION OF NEXT BATCH


causes PROBLEM W/PREVIOUS BATCH
branching ORDERS WITH USE ALTERNATE R.M.
ALTERNATE FORMULA
out to the PROBLEMS
65%
FORMULA ON
USE SALVAGE MAT'L
LEFT OVERS
“LOCK HOLD”
right. 1% CHANGE BATCH SIZE R.G.

57 In Search of Excellence
Affinity Diagrams

Affinity diagrams were Main Cause A


introduced in Module 1.3
as a tool for Cause 1 Cause 2 Main Cause C

understanding customer
needs.
The sketch shown here
depicts how an affinity
diagram can also be used
to help understand the Main Cause B
relationships between
Cause 4 Cause 5
potential causes.

Cause 6

58 In Search of Excellence
In Search of Excellence

HISTOGRAM
Histogram is a graph that displays the
distribution of data

60 In Search of Excellence
Histogram is characterised by three
constituents

• A center ( mean)
• A width (spread)
• An over all shape

61 In Search of Excellence
How to make a Histogram

Select a sample of size N.


Record the measurements.
Determine the range.
Decide the number of classes.
Determine the boundary or class limits.
Prepare frequency distribution.
Construct histogram.

62 In Search of Excellence
Data on Metal Block thickness (in mm)
3.56 3.46 3.48 3.50 3.42 3.43 3.52 3.49 3.44 3.50
3.48 3.56 3.50 3.52 3.47 3.48 3.46 3.50 3.56 3.38
3.41 3.37 3.47 3.49 3.45 3.44 3.50 3.49 3.46 3.46
3.55 3.52 3.44 3.50 3.45 3.44 3.48 3.46 3.52 3.46
3.48 3.48 3.32 3.40 3.52 3.34 3.46 3.43 3.30 3.46
3.59 3.63 3.59 3.47 3.38 3.52 3.45 3.48 3.31 3.46
3.40 3.54 3.46 3.51 3.48 3.50 3.68 3.60 3.46 3.52
3.48 3.50 3.56 3.50 3.52 3.46 3.48 3.46 3.52 3.56
3.52 3.48 3.46 3.45 3.46 3.54 3.54 3.48 3.49 3.41
3.41 3.45 3.34 3.44 3.47 3.47 3.41 3.38 3.54 3.47

63 In Search of Excellence
Frequency Table
Class Class Mid -value Frequen
no. Boundaries cy
1 3.275 – 3.325 3.30 3
2 3.325 – 3.375 3.35 3
3 3.375 – 3.425 3.40 9
4 3.425 – 3.475 3.45 33
5 3.475 – 3.525 3.50 37
6 3.525 – 3.575 3.55 10
7 3.575 – 3.625 3.60 3
8 3.625 – 3.675 3.65 1
9 3.675 – 3.725 3.70 1

64 In Search of Excellence
Histogram for Metal Block Thickness

45

40 37
35 33
30
Frequency

25

20

15

10 9 10
5 3 3 3
1 1
0
3.3 3.35 3.4 3.45 3.5 3.55 3.6 3.65 3.7

Thickness (in mm)

65 In Search of Excellence
Histogram for Bearing Thickness
45
41
40

35
31
29
30
Frequency

25 22
20 18 17

15 12
9
10
5
5 3

0
5.24 5.28 5.32 5.36 5.4 5.44 5.48 5.52 5.56 5.6

Thickness (in mm)


66 In Search of Excellence
Applications of
Histograms

Shape and Smoothness


Comparison to Specification limits
Comparison to Sources of Variability
Outlier Detection
Before and After Comparison

67 In Search of Excellence
Comparison of Histogram with Specification Limits

68 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms

69 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms
Bell shaped

Symmetrical shape with a peak in


middle representing a normal
histogram

70 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms

Double peaked

Two normal distributions with two


peaks in middle indicating more
than one distribution at work

71 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms

Plateau

More than one distribution at work

72 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms

Comb

Alternative peaks showing


possible errors in data
collection and analysis

73 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms

Skewed

An asymmetrical shape - positively


or negatively skewed - usually
reflecting limits in the specification
on one side

74 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms

Truncated

Usually being a part of a normal


distribution with part of it having
been removed.

75 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms

Isolated peak

Two normal distributions


suggesting two processes taking
place at the same time.

76 In Search of Excellence
Types of Histograms
Edged peaked

A normal distribution curve with a


large peak at one end indicating
errors in data recording.

77 In Search of Excellence
In Search of Excellence

SCATTER DIAGRAM
If two types of data, x and y,
are related in that x
increases or decreases
with y, a correlation exists
between them.

79 In Search of Excellence
A scatter diagram is a
chart that expresses the
relationship between two
such data types.

80 In Search of Excellence
Some examples of
relationship

• Cutting speed and tool life


• Moisture content and thread elongation
• Breakdown and equipment age
• Temperature and lipstick hardness
• Striking pressure and electrical current
• Temperature and percent foam in soft
drinks

81 In Search of Excellence
Scatter diagram on Automotive Speed vs.
Mileage

40

35
Mileage (km/Lit)

30

25

20

15
25 35 45 55 65 75

Speed (km/h)

82 In Search of Excellence
A scatter diagram depicts the
relationship as a pattern that
can be directly read.

83 In Search of Excellence
Different Scatter diagram
Patterns

84 In Search of Excellence
If y increases with x, then x
and y are positively
correlated.

85 In Search of Excellence
If y decreases as x increases,
then the two types of data are
negatively correlated.

86 In Search of Excellence
If no significant relationship
is apparent between x and y,
then the two data types are
not correlated.

87 In Search of Excellence
How to make a Scatter
diagram

• Collect 30 to 50 pairs of quantitative data (x and


y).

• Choosing units that express the range of the x


and y values, draw an x scale along the
horizontal axis and a y scale along the vertical
axis.

• Plot the data pairs (x, y) as points on a scatter


diagram.

88 In Search of Excellence
Data on Conveyor Speed and Severed Length

Sl. No. Conveyor Severed Sl. No. Conveyor Severed


Speed Length Speed Length
(cm/sec) (mm) (cm/sec) (mm)
1 8.1 1046 16 6.7 1024
2 7.7 1030 17 8.2 1034
3 7.4 1039 18 8.1 1036
4 5.8 1027 19 6.6 1023
5 7.6 1028 20 6.5 1011
6 6.8 1025 21 8.5 1030
7 7.9 1035 22 7.4 1014
8 6.3 1015 23 7.2 1030
9 7.0 1038 24 5.6 1016
10 8.0 1036 25 6.3 1020
11 8.0 1026 26 8.0 1040
12 8.0 1041 27 5.5 1013
13 7.2 1029 28 6.9 1025
14 6.0 1010 29 7.0 1020
15 6.3 1020 30 7.5 1022
89 In Search of Excellence
Scatter Diagram on Conveyor Speed vs. Severed
Length

1050
Severed Length (mm)

1045
1040
1035
1030
1025
1020
1015
1010
1005
1000
5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 8 8.5 9

Conveyor Speed (cm/sec)

90 In Search of Excellence
Uses of Scatter Diagram

If an increase in y depends on increase in x, then, if x is


controlled y will be naturally controlled.

If x is increased, y will increase somewhat. Then y seems


to have causes other than x.

91 In Search of Excellence
In Search of Excellence

GRAPHS and CHARTS


Graphs and charts are pictorial
representation of the data, making it easy to
spot trends, ratios and comparisons among
different groups of data.

93 In Search of Excellence
The more common types of graphs and
charts are Line graphs, Bar charts and Pie
charts.

94 In Search of Excellence
Purpose of Graphs and Charts

To present the numerical data in an easy-


to-plot visual form.

95 In Search of Excellence
Purpose of Graphs and Charts

Line graphs are used to depict change or


variation over time.

96 In Search of Excellence
Purpose of Graphs and Charts

Bar charts are used for comparing


quantities between persons, regions, time
intervals etc.

97 In Search of Excellence
Purpose of Graphs and Charts

Pie charts are used to show percentages


or proportions of different components
of a specific item.

98 In Search of Excellence
Procedure for making Graphs and Charts

Select the type of chart or graph most suitable for the


type of data.
Decide the units and scale of items to be shown on X-
axis and Y-axis
Fill the information on the graph sheet.
Join the required points to complete lines or bars.
Colour or shade the lines or bars to distinguish between
different groups or classes.
Provide appropriate title.

99 In Search of Excellence
% Defectives for different Weeks for product XYZ

7.5
7
6.5
% Defectives

6
5.5
5
4.5
4
3.5
3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Week Number

100 In Search of Excellence


Average Production in different months

90
80
80 75 76
70 68
Avg. Production (Tons)

70
60
60

50

40

30

20

10

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun

Month

101 In Search of Excellence


Horizontal Bar Graph
Personnel Performance

Poor 15

Average 40

Very Good 30

Excellent 15

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Percentage

102 In Search of Excellence


Comparison of Machines A & B
for weekly Rejection

25

21
20 20
% Rejection

20

15 15
15 14
13 13
11 11 11
10 10
10 8
6
5
4
5 3 3
2

0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Week Number

103 In Search of Excellence


Comparison of Machines A & B
for Units Produced

900

800
Units Produced

700

600 422
257
358
500
336 281 317 299
400 244
300 221
275
200 435
375 348
285 321 307 294
263
100 201
133
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Week Number

104 In Search of Excellence


Pie Chart for
Customer returned watches
A - Glass Broken
B - Stop F G
C - Matt. Trouble E 3% 5%
D - Defective Dial 4%
D
E - Regulation 6%
F - Stem Loose
G - Others A
C
12% 43%

B
27%

105 In Search of Excellence


STRATIFICATION CHECKSHEET PARETO DIAGRAM

CHECKSHEET FOR
DEFECT TALLY
   TYPE
DEFECTS
MARKS

A ///// /// // WHAT ARE OUR


   B //// ///// //// PRIORITY AREAS?
C /// /
TOTAL A B C D OTHERS
WHAT DATA? HOW EASILY USL
TO COOLECT DATA?

HISTOGRAM HOW DO THE DA


TA VARY?

MAN M/C E
CAUSE & EFFECT
F
DIAGRAM F WHAT ARE
E THE CAUSES?
C
MATL. METHOD
T

SCATTER DIAGRAM WHAT IS THE APPARENT


RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
CAUSE (X) & EFFECT(Y)?
X

GRAPHS & CHARTS HOW DOES IT


VARY OVER TIME?

TIME 
106 In Search of Excellence

You might also like