Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ADV. Cost24 March
ADV. Cost24 March
&
Management Control Systems
ACFN 622
Teklu K.(Ph.D)
March,2016
Course Description:
• Total ……………………………………………………
100%
Text books:
Horngren, Datan, Rajan, 2012, Cost
Accounting: a managerial emphasis, 14th
edition Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as
Pearson Prentice Hall
Blocher, Stout and Cokins, 2010,Cost
Management: a strategic emphasis, 5thedition
The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. New York, NY,
•
Advanced Cost
&
Management Control Systems
ACFN 622
Teklu K.(Ph.D)
March,2016
Contents
1.General Introduction
9
Introduction
Essence
Cost accounting a branch of accounting
that measures and reports financial and
non financial information related to the
cost of acquiring or utilizing resources in
an organization.
Cost concepts and classifications
Cost: is a resource sacrificed or forgone to achieve a
specific objective. A cost is usually measured as the
monetary amount that must be paid to acquire goods and
services.
A Cost object: is anything for which a separate
measurement of costs is desired. Example; product,
department, customer, geographical area, process etc.
Cost pool: A cost pool is a grouping of individual cost
items possessing identical nature. Cost pools can range
from broad, such as all costs within a manufacturing
plant, to narrow, such as the costs of operating machine.
Cost accumulation: is the collection of costs in
some organized way by means of an accounting
system, i.e., by some natural or self descriptive
classification.
Eg. material cost, labor cost, fuel, Advertisement
cost etc.
Cost assignment: is a general term that includes:
Tracing accumulated costs: For direct costs
Allocating accumulated costs: For indirect costs
Cost Classification
Costs are classified into different categories on the basis
of different reasons:
Based on their traceability to a particular cost object
a. Direct Costs: costs that have a relationship with the
cost object and can be traced to that cost object in an
economically feasible (cost effective) way.
Example:
i. The cost of bottle is a direct cost to Pepsi-Cola because
the cost of it can be easily traced to or identified with
the drink.
ii. Cost of paper is a direct cost for a sport magazines
because it can be conveniently traced to a magazine.
b. Indirect Costs: costs that have a relationship
with the cost object but cannot be traced to
that cost object in an economically feasible
way.
22
Three underlying sub processes of MCS
Management control process has three
underlying sub processes
Target setting ( budgeting), also known
as attention directing
Performance measurement
Reward and compensation
23
Strategic planning and budgeting
24
The nature of strategic planning
Strategic planning include:
–Thinking about the future
–Deciding on the future direction
of the entity
–Leading to formal statement of
plans about the future
–Plan how to get there
25
Strategy formulation and strategic planning
Strategy formulation involves :
– an overall drawing of road map
– Defining strategic direction
Planning
Develop long-term strategy
And short term plans
control
Reevaluate objectives, goals strategy and plans
29
Budget setting process
Important issues to be settled before
detailed budget setting.
• Corporate objectives : major, growth and
profitability, broken down into products
• Corporate profit planning: summary plan
• Nature of market- buyers’ or sellers’
• Principal budget factor: identify key factor,
limiting factor, critical factor, or governing
factor
30
Cont’d
• Sales forecasting: (starting point, factors
to consider, demand analysis, general
business conditions, production capacity,
sales mix analysis
• Spending for the future (spending on
items that affect the future, but no
contribution for the current
sales/revenue (non expense items)
31
Budgeting under uncertainty
• Scenario analysis- Optimistic /pessimistic
• Sensitivity analysis – what if technique
• Probability analysis- how big the chance?
• limiting factor analysis-(multi constraints
32
The master budget: interrelationship of
functional budget components
37
Cont’d
• Qualitative method
– Opinion from experts
– Brain-storming
– Delphi techniques
– Scenario building
• field survey data etc
38
Example
• The following is actual revenue of Addis Ababa
City administration during the last five years.
What will be forecasted revenue at higher case
and lower case scenario based on the
philosophy of trend analysis.
Year Revenue Growth Rate
2008 31,000,000 29
39
Exercise
• Tax and none tax revenue of Akaki kality
Sub city in 2004 E.C was 20,000,000.
During the subsequent four years,
revenue were growing at 100,000 plus 20
% of the preceding year. What will be
revenue of 2009 E.C assuming higher
case, lower case and average growth rate
principles of trend method?
40
Components of master budget
• Sales budget
• Selling and distribution expense
• Advertising
• Production budget
• Plant utilisation budget
• Repairs and maintenance
• Personnel
• Purchase budget
41
Cont’d
• Purchase budget depends on
– Production budget
– Capital expenditure budget
– R & D budget
– Policy of subcontracting
– Stock levels (inventory policy)
– Availability of finance
– Storage space and source of supply
42
Framework for performance
measurement system
• Purpose of measurement:
– tool to help managers control the results of their
organizations,
– Helps organizations to gain insight into, and make
judgments about the effectiveness and efficiency of
their programs, process and people.
• Choice of the right metrics important
• Prioritize indicators
• Choose appropriate measurement methods
– Achieve understanding and acceptance
43
Types of metrics
• Hard vs soft (Both have their strength and weakness)
– Hard
• Pure facts that are possible to measure ( input,
production, net profit etc)
– Objective reference
– Accurately known
– Hierarchical
– Soft
• Measure the intangible (customer satisfaction,
brand loyalty, employee satisfaction, etc
– Observer bias
– Surrogate indicator
– Multi variable situations
44
Performance cont’d
• Financial Vs Non financial
– Integration of the two is important to achieve best
results
– financial metrics example
• Budget vs actual variance analysis
• Product and product group (cost, contribution
margin)
• Profitability, Cash flow analysis, ROI, EPS
• Customer profitability, ets
– Non financial metrics example
• Inventory turnover, labor efficiency, capacity
utilization, defect ratio, lead time, market share
analysis, market penetration, new product sales
45
Cont’d
• Financial performance targets ( for control)
a. Model based vs historical vs negotiated targets
. Model based
» Deterministic casual relationship
between output and inputs (engineered
targets)
• Historical targets
» Derived from past
• Negotiated
» Mutual agreement between superior and
subordinate
46
Requirements for PMS
• Establishing and updating performance
measures
• Establishing accountability for
performance
• Gathering and analyzing performance
data
• Reporting and using performance
information
47
Cont’d
b. Internally vs externally derived targets
• Target costing derived from selling prices
• Benchmarking ( study of best practice and
implement process and system to enhance
performance)
(internal bench mark, external bench mark)
C. Fixed vs flexible targets
– (changing and non changing)
48
Single Vs. multiple performance indicator
• Drawback of single indicator
– Single indicator may apply to a given situation but
not to all.
– Single indicator such as profitability may apply well
to macro situations but not to micro situations
– single indicator ignores underlying process
– It also fails to link with strategic plans
– It is also able to only measure one aspect of business
performance
• The G.E measurement project
• Balanced scorecard 49
Cont’d
• The G.E measurement project
– Divided into three projects
• those designed to measure overall
performance of department as an
economic entity
• Those designed to measure performance of
functional organizations such as finance,
marketing, production human resource, etc
• Those designed to measure performance of
the departments’ management
50
Continued
– Core principles:
– 1. Measures designed to provide factual knowledge to
support judgments in performance appraisals
2. Measures designed to provide information regarding
short term objectives and long term goals
3. Minimum number of indicators used at each level
The following key success factors were selected for each
department:
a. Short term profitability (ROI, profit contribution/NI to
sales ratio, and residual income /net income minus
capital charge/)
b.Market share (degree of attaining market leadership)
51
Cont’d
c. Productivity ( department productivity =value
added /(labor inputs + capital inputs)
d. Product leadership (long run goal, company
originated product, research and development
effort that led to product development,
comparative analysis of competitors and
company positions)
e. Personnel development (demand for human
resources by type and supply of talented
personnel, effectiveness of training programs etc)
f. Employee attitude , (measured by turnover, rate of
absenteeism, tardiness, punctuality etc)
52
Cont’d
g. Public responsibility [good corporate
citizenship, well being of all stakeholders,
including employees, vendors (suppliers),
customers environment, community at large]
h. Balance between short term and long range
objectives (the measures mentioned are
combinations of short term profitability and
growth and long term goals)
53
The Balanced Scorecard as measure of
performance
• Traditional performance report focus on cost
control
• In modern business companies compete in terms
of product quality, terms of delivery, reliability,
after sales services, customer satisfaction etc
• These variables are not captured in traditional
measures
• Traditional measure do not include information
needed for planning since they are based on
historical facts/records/accounts
54
Cont’d
• BSC was developed to link financial and
nonfinancial measures of performance and to
identify key performance measures (Kaplan
and Norton,1992)
• BSC is a set of financial and non financial
measure related to company’s critical success
factors
• It provides information to management to
assist in strategic policy formulation
• As a tool, helps to assess over all performance
55
Cont’d
• The general objective of the BSC is to provide
comprehensive framework for translating a
firm’s strategic objectives into coherent set of
performance measures
• There are four perspectives from which
company performance is to be measured in
the BSC
• companies need to articulate objectives for
each of the for perspectives
• Performance measures are then set for each
goal
56
Major components of BSC
• Customer perspective / how do customers
see us/
• Internal perspective/ what must we excel
at/
• Innovation and learning perspective/
ability to continue to improve and create
value/
• Financial perspective / how do we look to
our share holders/
57
Reward/ incentive and compensations
‘One of the primary principles of effective
management is that rewards should be the
third thing you work on, measurement
should come second, and both reward and
measurements should be subordinated to
performance definition; i.e. clear
unambiguous articulation of what needs to
be done’ ( Kerr, 2004, Quoted in Merchant and van der Stede 2007 p. 393 )
58
Examples of positive and negative rewards
• Positive rewards
– Autonomy
– Power
– Oppurtunity to participate in important decision process
– Salary increases
– Bonuses
– Stock options
– Restricted stock
– Praise
– Recognitions
– Promotions
– Titles
– Job assignment
– Office assignment
– Reserved parking place
– Country club membership
– Job security
– Merchandise prizes
– Vacation trips
– Participation in executive development programs
– Time off 59
Cont’d
• Negative rewards
– Interference in job from superiors
– Loss of job
– Zero salary increase
– Assignment to un important tasks
– Chastisement (public or private)
– No promotion
– Demotion
– Public humiliation
60
Purpose of incentives
• Performance-dependent rewards or incentives,
provide the drive for alignment of employees’
natural self-interests with organization’s
objectives.
• They provide three types of management
control benefits
– Information : inform the employees or remind them
of the importance of result areas (cost control,
quality customer handling, asset management etc) –
effort directing purpose
61
Cont’d
– Motivational : effort inducing,
employees need rewards/ incentive to
exert extra effort to accomplish tasks
– Personnel related to improve
employment, (salary plus incentive
package, or low salary plus incentive-
performance dependent pay, variable
pay etc)
62
Environment of MCS
application of MCS in :
• service organizations
– eg Financial institutions, airlines, transport
services
• No for profit organizations
• or government entities
• Projects/ long term construction projects …
• Multinational firms
63