Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Public Administration Theories
Public Administration Theories
Public Administration Theories
Theories
By
Suvicha Pouaree, Ph.D.
Original Paradigm
(1887 – 1950)
Original Paradigm (1887 – 1950)
• Separation of administration from politics
• Woodrow Wilson: “The Study of Administration”
(1887)
• The science of administration is the latest fruit of that
study of the science of politics
• Developed countries should have good government,
strong executive branch, efficient and rational
bureaucratic system, good administration => “it is
getting harder to run a constitution than to frame
one”.
Original Paradigm (1887 – 1950)
• Principles of management
– Division of labor
– Authority (formal authority and personal
authority): “wherever authority is exercised,
responsibilities arise”
– Discipline deriving from good leaders, clear
agreements between management and labor
regarding rules, and the judicious use of sanctions
(penalties)
Original Paradigm (1887 – 1950)
– Unity of command: “For any action whatsoever an
employee should receive orders from one superior
only
– Unity of direction: “one head and one plan for a
group of activities having the same objectives
– Subordination of individual interests to general
interest
– Remuneration (fair rewarding)
– Centralization depends on situation
Original Paradigm (1887 – 1950)
– Scalar chain: “the chain of superiors ranging from
the ultimate authority to the lowest ranks”
– Order to ensure a place for everything and
everything in its place
– Equity results from kindliness and justice and
provides a principle for employee relations
– Stability of tenure of personnel: “To provide for
orderly personnel planning and provision to
replace human resources”
Original Paradigm (1887 – 1950)
– Initiative as a principle exhorted individuals to
display zeal and energy in all efforts
– Esprit de corps—stressing on building harmony
and unity within firm
Original Paradigm (1887 – 1950)
• Structure of authority
– Span of control: an appropriateness of numbers of
subordinates
– Unity of command: controlling and coordinating
by one chief only, not by committee
– Principle of homogeneity: bring all expertise to
work together for technical efficiency
Original Paradigm (1887 – 1950)
• Organizing executives: “The work of chief
executive is POSDCORB”
– Planning
– Organizing
– Staffing
– Directing
– Coordinating
– Reporting
– Budgeting
Original Paradigm (1887 – 1950)
• Administration is politics
• Informal bureaucratic system
• Human relation theories
• Administrative science
Administration is Politics
Administration is Politics
• James W. Fesler:
– Some public organizations are likely to be
independent from the executive branch domination
because they gain supports from interest groups.
• Don K. Price:
– Bureaucrats are obligated not only to implement
policies but also to make policies. They are able to
express their ideas to support or against any
policies.
Administration is Politics
• Paul Henson Appleby
• Public administration is actually about politics because
it is a part of political process.
• PA is about governing. PA studies should not focus on
how to create the most efficient administration, but the
policy-making and the power of political groups.
• The belief on the separation of administration from
politics was made because those academics too much
followed the US constitution particularly on the
“Separation of Power”. That made a misunderstanding
that the civil service system must be neutral.
Administration is Politics
• Power to make policy actually belongs to
every branches.
• In reality, there is no separation of power.
• What make public administration different
from private management is the political
involvement. The decision-making of
executive branch and public administrators is
the government’s action on behalf of the
people.
Administration is Politics
• Theory Y
– Management side is obligated to prepare
organizational components
– Natural characteristics of human is not lazy but
his/her experience within an organization makes
him/her become lazy person
– Human is responsible person and like to be
developed, so that the management side needs not
to motivate them on these matters.
Human Relation Theories
– Management side should focus on how to make
workers maximum use of their potential, setting
working condition to cope with workers’ personal
demands, and making workers’ personal demands
to become organizational objective
Human Relation Theories
• Chris Argryis: “Personality and Organization”
(1957)
• Human with a good mental health must be
maturation: from lazy to enthusiastic person; from
dependent to independent person; from simply to
complex behavior; from unstable to stable person;
from today’s expectation to long terms expectation;
from subordinate to boss behavior; and from
uncontrollable to self-controllable person
Human Relation Theories
• The bureaucratic organization structure is an obstacle
to the human development because it makes the
workers to only follow the bosses’ demands
• In the long terms—under the bureaucratic
organization structure—bosses will have less
enthusiastic because of inefficient organization
• The ways to solve the problem are to push for
maturation of workers, to reduce controlling system,
and to encourage democracy in the organization.
Administrative Science
Administrative Science