Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BI CCM Unit I
BI CCM Unit I
• Interpersonal • Decisional
– Figurehead – Entrepreneur
– Leader – Disturbance Handler
– Liaison – Resource Allocation
• Informational – Negotiator
– Monitor
– Disseminator
– Spokesperson
Productivity
• DSS • EIP
• Management Science • ERM
• Business Analytics • ERP
• Data Mining • CRM
• Data Warehouse • SCM
• Business Intelligence • KMS
• OLAP • KMP
• CASE tools • ES
• GSS • ANN
• EIS • Intelligent Agents
• E-commerce DSS
Decision Support Frameworks
Type of Control
Type of Control
Environment
System Types
• Closed system
– Independent
– Takes no inputs
– Delivers no outputs to the environment
– Black Box
• Open system
– Accepts inputs
– Delivers outputs to environment
Models Used for DSS
• Iconic
– Small physical replication of system
• Analog
– Behavioral representation of system
– May not look like system
• Quantitative (mathematical)
– Demonstrates relationships between systems
Phases of Decision-Making
• Simon’s original three phases:
– Intelligence
– Design
– Choice
• He added fourth phase later:
– Implementation
• Book adds fifth stage:
– Monitoring
Decision-Making Intelligence Phase
• Scan the environment
• Analyze organizational goals
• Collect data
• Identify problem
• Categorize problem
– Programmed and non-programmed
– Decomposed into smaller parts
• Assess ownership and responsibility for problem
resolution
Decision-Making Design Phase
• Develop alternative courses of action
• Analyze potential solutions
• Create model
• Test for feasibility
• Validate results
• Select a principle of choice
– Establish objectives
– Incorporate into models
– Risk assessment and acceptance
– Criteria and constraints
Decision-Making Choice Phase
• Principle of choice
– Describes acceptability of a solution approach
• Normative Models
– Optimization
• Effect of each alternative
– Rationalization
• More of good things, less of bad things
• Courses of action are known quantity
• Options ranked from best to worse
– Suboptimization
• Decisions made in separate parts of organization without
consideration of whole
Descriptive Models
• Describe how things are believed to be
• Typically, mathematically based
• Applies single set of alternatives
• Examples:
– Simulations
– What-if scenarios
– Cognitive map
– Narratives
Developing Alternatives
• Generation of alternatives
– May be automatic or manual
– May be legion, leading to information overload
– Scenarios
– Evaluate with heuristics
– Outcome measured by goal attainment
Problems
• Satisficing is the willingness to settle for less
than ideal.
– Form of suboptimization
• Bounded rationality
– Limited human capacity
– Limited by individual differences and biases
• Too many choices
Decision-Making Choice Phase
• Decision making with commitment to act
• Determine courses of action
– Analytical techniques
– Algorithms
– Heuristics
– Blind searches
• Analyze for robustness
Decision-Making Implementation
Phase
• Putting solution to work
• Vague boundaries which include:
– Dealing with resistance to change
– User training
– Upper management support
Source: Based on Sprague, R.H., Jr., “A Framework for the Development of DSS.” MIS Quarterly, Dec. 1980, Fig. 5, p. 13.
Decision Support Systems
• Intelligence Phase
– Automatic
• Data Mining
– Expert systems, CRM, neural networks
– Manual
• OLAP
• KMS
– Reporting
• Routine and ad hoc
Decision Support Systems
• Design Phase
– Financial and forecasting models
– Generation of alternatives by expert system
– Relationship identification through OLAP and data
mining
– Recognition through KMS
– Business process models from CRM, RMS, ERP,
and SCM
Decision Support Systems
• Choice Phase
– Identification of best alternative
– Identification of good enough alternative
– What-if analysis
– Goal-seeking analysis
– May use KMS, GSS, CRM, ERP, and SCM systems
Decision Support Systems
• Implementation Phase
– Improved communications
– Collaboration
– Training
– Supported by KMS, expert systems, GSS
Decision-Making In Humans
• Temperament
– Hippocrates’ personality types
– Myers-Briggs’ Type Indicator
– Kiersey and Bates’ Types and Motivations
– Birkman’s True Colours
• Gender
Decision-Making In Humans
• Cognitive styles
– What is perceived?
– How is it organized?
– Subjective
• Decision styles
– How do people think?
– How do they react?
– Heuristic, analytical, autocratic, democratic,
consultative
Groupwork
• Groupwork
– Collaboration and communication
• Members can be located in different places and work at
different times
• Information may be located external to the project
• Allows for rapid solutions
• May exhibit normal team problems of synergy or conflict
• Often Internet based
• Groupware tools support groupwork
• Work called computer-supported cooperative work
• Collaborative computing
Communication Support
• No collaboration without communication
• Internet supplies fast, reliable, inexpensive
support
• Groups need not only communication, but
information and knowledge
Time/Place Communication Framework
• Effectiveness of
collaborative
group depends on
– Time
• synchronous or
asynchronous
transmission of
information
– Place
• location of
participants
Groupware
• Software providing collaborative support to groups
• Different time/place applications
• Most use Internet technologies
• Most offer one or more capabilities
– Electronic brainstorming
• Free flow of ideas and comments
– Electronic conferencing or videoconferencing
– Group scheduling and calendars
– Conflict resolution
– Model building
– Electronic document sharing
– Voting services
• Electronic meeting services also available
• Enterprise-wide systems expensive in cost and human resources
Popular Groupware
• Lotus Notes/Domino
• Microsoft Netmeeting
• Groove Workspace
• GroupSystems MeetingRoom and OnLine
• WebEx
Benefits and Problems
• Benefits of groupwork
– Process gains
• Nominal group technique
• Delphi method
– Technology applied as GSS
• Hardware and software combined to enhance groupwork
• Collaborative computing
• Problems in groupwork
– Process losses
– inefficient
GSS
• Common group activities with computer assistance
– Information retrieval
– Information sharing
• Parallelism
• Anonymity
– Information use
• Support participants
– Improve productivity and effectiveness of meetings
• More efficient decision-making
• Increase effectiveness of decisions
GSS Technology Deployment
• Special purpose decision room
– Electronic meeting rooms
– Software operates across LAN
– Allowed for face-to-face meetings
– Trained facilitator coordinates meeting
– Group leader structures meeting with facilitator
• Multiple use facility
– General purpose computer lab
– Effective way to lower costs
– Trained facilitator coordinates meeting
– Group leader structures meeting with facilitator
• Web-based groupware with clients
– Anytime/anyplace meetings with deadlines established
– Software bought or leased
– No facility costs
– Flexible
GSS Meeting Process
• Group leader meets with facilitator to plan meeting structure.
• Participants meet on computers.
• Group leader or facilitator poses question.
• Participants brainstorm by entering comments into computer.
• Facilitator employs idea organization software to sort comments into
common themes.
• Results are displayed.
• Facilitator or group leader leads discussion.
• Themes are prioritized.
• Highest priority topics are either sent through the process again for
further discussion or a vote is taken.
GSS Meeting Process
• Standard Process
– Exploratory idea generation
– Idea organization tool
– Prioritization
– New idea generation
– Selection of final idea
• Success based upon effectiveness, reduction
in costs, better decisions, increased
productivity
GSS and Distance Education
• Classroom collaborative computing advantages
– Brainstorming, chat, discussion boards
– Distribution of information, lectures
• Publishes to course site
• Videoconferenced
• Consistent materials
– Textbooks can be bound or electronic
– E-mails and listservs
• One-on-one interaction
– Allows for global classrooms
– Anytime/anyplace with fixed deadlines
• Flexible time frame
• Doesn’t interfere with work shift
– Low delivery costs with large audiences
GSS and Distance Education, continued
• Disadvantages:
– Fewer social interactions
– Communication problems
– Students must be self-starters and highly disciplined
– Classes require major technical and administrative support
– Technical infrastructure must be reliable
– Courses may need to be redesigned for online
– Special training
• Corporate training online:
– Allows anytime/anyplace training
– Lowers costs
– Decreases time away from jobs
– Shortens learning process
– Delivered via Intranet, intranets, extranets, audio and video conferencing
Creativity Support System
• Creativity
– Fundamental human trait
– Level of achievement
– Can be learned
• Organizations recognize value in innovation
• Stimulated by electronic brainstorming software
– Free flow idea generation
• Creative computer programs
– Smartbots function as facilitators
– Identify analogies in letter patterns
– Draw art
– Write poems
• Computer programs stimulate human productivity
Experts
• Experts
– Have special knowledge, judgment, and experience
– Can apply these to solve problems
• Higher performance level than average person
• Relative
• Faster solutions
• Recognize patterns
• Expertise
– Task specific knowledge of experts
• Acquired from reading, training, practice
Expert Systems Features
• Expertise
– Capable of making expert level decisions
• Symbolic reasoning
– Knowledge represented symbolically
– Reasoning mechanism symbolic
• Deep knowledge
– Knowledge base contains complex knowledge
• Self-knowledge
– Able to examine own reasoning
– Explain why conclusion reached
Applications of Expert Systems
• DENDRAL project
– Applied knowledge or rule-based reasoning commands
– Deduced likely molecular structure of compounds
• MYCIN
– Rule-based system for diagnosing bacterial infections
• XCON
– Rule-based system to determine optimal systems configuration
• Credit analysis
– Ruled-based systems for commercial lenders
• Pension fund adviser
– Knowledge-based system analyzing impact of regulation and
conformance requirements on fund status
Applications
• Finance
– Insurance evaluation, credit analysis, tax planning, financial planning and
reporting, performance evaluation
• Data processing
– Systems planning, equipment maintenance, vendor evaluation, network
management
• Marketing
– Customer-relationship management, market analysis, product planning
• Human resources
– HR planning, performance evaluation, scheduling, pension management, legal
advising
• Manufacturing
– Production planning, quality management, product design, plant site
selection, equipment maintenance and repair
Environments
• Consultation (runtime)
• Development
Major Components of Expert Systems
• Major components
– Knowledge base
• Facts
• Special heuristics to direct use of knowledge
– Inference engine
• Brain
• Control structure
• Rule interpreter
– User interface
• Language processor
Additional Components of Expert Systems
• Additional components
– Knowledge acquisition subsystem
• Accumulates, transfers, and transforms expertise to computer
– Workplace
• Blackboard
• Area of working memory
• Decisions
– Plan, agenda, solution
– Justifier
• Explanation subsystem
– Traces responsibility for conclusions
– Knowledge refinement system
• Analyzes knowledge and use for learning and improvements
Knowledge Presentation
• Production rules
– IF-THEN rules combine with conditions to produce
conclusions
– Easy to understand
– New rules easily added
– Uncertainty
• Semantic networks
• Logic statements
Inference Engine
• Forward chaining
– Looks for the IF part of rule first
– Selects path based upon meeting all of the IF
requirements
• Backward chaining
– Starts from conclusion and hypothesizes that it is true
– Identifies IF conditions and tests their veracity
– If they are all true, it accepts conclusion
– If they fail, then discards conclusion
General Problems Suitable for Expert
Systems
• Interpretation systems
– Surveillance, image analysis, signal interpretation
• Prediction systems
– Weather forecasting, traffic predictions, demographics
• Diagnostic systems
– Medical, mechanical, electronic, software diagnosis
• Design systems
– Circuit layouts, building design, plant layout
• Planning systems
– Project management, routing, communications, financial plans
General Problems Suitable for Expert
Systems
• Monitoring systems
– Air traffic control, fiscal management tasks
• Debugging systems
– Mechanical and software
• Repair systems
– Incorporate debugging, planning, and execution capabilities
• Instruction systems
– Identify weaknesses in knowledge and appropriate remedies
• Control systems
– Life support, artificial environment
Benefits of Expert Systems
• Increased outputs
• Increased productivity
• Decreased decision-making time
• Increased process and product quality
• Reduced downtime
• Capture of scarce expertise
• Flexibility
• Ease of complex equipment operation
• Elimination of expensive monitoring equipment
• Operation in hazardous environments
• Access to knowledge and help desks
Benefits of Expert Systems
• Ability to work with incomplete, imprecise, uncertain data
• Provides training
• Enhanced problem solving and decision-making
• Rapid feedback
• Facilitate communications
• Reliable decision quality
• Ability to solve complex problems
• Ease of knowledge transfer to remote locations
• Provides intelligent capabilities to other information systems
Limitations
• Knowledge not always readily available
• Difficult to extract expertise from humans
– Approaches vary
– Natural cognitive limitations
– Vocabulary limited
– Wrong recommendations
• Lack of end-user trust
• Knowledge subject to biases
• Systems may not be able to arrive at conclusions
Success Factors
• Management champion
• User involvement
• Training
• Expertise from cooperative experts
• Qualitative, not quantitative, problem
• User-friendly interface
• Expert’s level of knowledge must be high
Types of Expert Systems
• Rule-based Systems
– Knowledge represented by series of rules
• Frame-based Systems
– Knowledge represented by frames
• Hybrid Systems
– Several approaches are combined, usually rules and frames
• Model-based Systems
– Models simulate structure and functions of systems
• Off-the-shelf Systems
– Ready made packages for general use
• Custom-made Systems
– Meet specific need
• Real-time Systems
– Strict limits set on system response times