Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EE - 453 Power Quality and Harmonics: Harmonic Mitigation
EE - 453 Power Quality and Harmonics: Harmonic Mitigation
EE - 453 Power Quality and Harmonics: Harmonic Mitigation
Introduction
State of Art of Passive Power Filters
Classification of Passive Power Filters
Principle of Operation of Passive Power
Filters
Analysis and Design of Passive Power
Filters
Modeling, Simulation and Performance of
Passive Power Filters
Passive Power Filter principle block diagram
Power filter
INTRODUCTION
As non-linear loads, these solid-state converters draw
harmonics and reactive power components of current from
ac mains.
The injected harmonics currents, and reactive power burden,
cause low system efficiency and poor power-factor. They
also cause disturbance to other consumers, protection
devices, and interference in nearby communication
networks.
Traditionally power passive filters are used to reduce
harmonics and capacitors are generally employed to
improve the power factor of these ac loads.
Passive filters become very sensitive to the parallel resonance
between filter capacitors and source impedance (mainly inductive in
nature)
There are many such situations which need power passive filters
but varying configurations therefore, an exhaustive study of these
power passive filters is considered very much relevant.
CLASSIFICATION OF PASSIVE FILTERS
Passive filters can be classified based on topologies, connections
and the number of phases.
The topology can be tuned and damped to act as low pass and high
pass for shunt filters Or to act as low block and high block for
series filters.
Since the value of the capacitor also known the size of the filter,
is decided by the reactive power requirements of the loads and its
inductor value is decided by the tuned frequency.
Notch filter provide harmonics current and voltage reduction and
power factor correction because of capacitive reactive power at
fundamental frequency as this filter circuit behaves as capacitive
impedance at fundamental frequency.
Normally, these notch filters are used at more than one tuned
frequency and may have more than one series RLC circuit for
multiple harmonics
They are also know damped filters as they provide damping due
a resistor present in the circuit.
is
C3 C5 Ch
vs Nonlinear
AC L3 L5 Lh Rh Loads
Mains
PHSh
Series Filters
It may also have high block filter with parallel LC circuit and
resistance in series with the capacitor.
Active-Passive
Power Quality Improvement Using Power Filters
Hybrid Filters
Harmonic reduction
Reactive power compensation
Zs
is
C3 C5 Ch
vs Nonlinear
AC L3 L5 Lh Rh Loads
Mains
PHSh
Tuned Shunt Passive Filters for
Three-Phase Three-Wire
vsa Zsa
isa
Three-Phase
vsb Zsb
Three-Wire
Nonlinear
isb Loads
vsc Zsc
C5 C7 Ch C5 C7 Ch C5 C7 Ch
L5 L7 Lh Rh L5 L7 Lh Rh L5 L7 Lh Rh
Tuned Series Passive Filters for
Single-Phase Systems
Zs
C3 C5 Ch Rh
is L3 L5 Lh
AC vs PHSS
Nonlinear
Mains
Loads
Tuned Series Passive Filters for
Three-phase Three-Wire
vsa Zsa Ch Rh PF
C5 C7
SSa
isa L5 L7 Lh
vsb Zsb
C5 C7 Ch Rh PF Three-Phase
SSb Three-Wire
isb Nonlinear
L5 L7 Lh
Loads
vsc Zsc C5 C7 Ch R
h PFSSc
isc Lh
L5 L7
Tuned Series Passive Filters
For 3-ph 4-wire system
vsa Zsa Ch Rh PF
C3 C5
ssa
isa L3 L5 Lh a
vsb Zsb
C3 C5 Ch Rh PF Three-Phase
n ssb b Four-Wire
isb Nonlinear
L3 L5 Lh
Loads
vsc Zsc C3 C5 Ch R
h PFssc c
isc Lh
L3 L5
n
Passive Hybrid Filters
Zs PFss
is
AC vs Nonlinear
PFsh Loads
Mains
is
AC vs Nonlinear
PFsh Loads
Mains
is
vs Non linear
PFsh loads
is
vs PFsh2 Non linear
PFsh1
loads
Classification of filters
3. Location
4. Connection of circuit
5. Sharpness of tuning
6. The number of frequencies of their resonances
Location:
Filters can be located on both ac and dc sides of converters.
Filters on the ac side may be connected either on primary side or
tertiary winding. Filters never connected on the secondary that is
on the side of valves in the case of HVDC.
Connection of circuit
harmonics may be impeded in passing from (a) the converter to
the power network or line by a high series impedance (b) diverted
by a low shunt impedance (c) both
The series filter must carry full current of the main circuit and
must be insulated throughout for full voltage to ground
The shunt filter can be grounded at one end and carries only the
harmonic current for which it is tuned plus a fundamental current
much smaller than that of the main circuit.
Hence shunt filter is much cheaper than a series filter of equal
effectiveness.
Shunt filter supplies needed reactive power but series filter
consumes it
Sharpness of tuning:
2 kinds of filters are used
(a) Tuned filter which is sharply tuned to one or two of the lower
harmonic frequencies such as fifth and seventh
(b) Damped filter (low Q filter) which is shunt connected offers low
impedance over a broad band of frequencies for 7th and higher
harmonics. This is called high pass filter.
Damped filter
Tuned filter
Cost of filters
The total cost of the filters is (5-15)% of the total cost of the terminal
equipment in case of HVDC system.
The converter is a low impedance harmonic source on the dc side and high
impedance harmonic source on the ac side
The harmonic current Ihc is assumed to be known. It is divided into two paths as
shown in figure.
1. If the network impedance were nil to harmonics Zhn=0 and Ihn=Ihc. Shunt
filters would have no effect.
All the harmonics generated by the converter would enter the network.
Filtering appears to be perfect if we see with voltage and bad if we judge with
current. So this assumption is unrealistic.
If it is true, we have to prefer series filtering elements.
2. If the network has infinity impedance. All the harmonic current generated by
network pass through a filter . Filtering would be perfect if it is judged by
current, and could be good if it is judged by voltage.
3. Network and filter are in parallel resonance. The resulting impedance would
be a high resistance.Vh, Ihn, Ihf all would be high. Indeed the harmonic
network current and voltage would be increased by filter.
PRINCIPLE OF OPERATION OF PASSIVE
POWER FILTERS
For multiple harmonics, multiple tuned series RLC circuits are used to absorb these
harmonics currents
Sharpness of Tuning of Passive Filter
This is one of the important properties of the passive filters. It is
quantified in terms a quality factor of the inductor (Q) and known as
sharpness of tuning of the passive filter.
A passive shunt filter is considered to be tuned corresponding to a
frequency at which its inductive reactance is equal to its capacitive
reactance
Cost of Passive Filter
The cost of the passive filter is reasonable and sometimes it reaches
15% to 20% of the equipment for which it is used therefore the
design of passive filter has to consider the cost factor in to account
while designing these passive filters.
Moreover, it has some power losses, which also must be considered
in its design. The cost of the passive filter may also be partially
supplemented to reactive power supplied by it.
Limitations of Passive Filters
These passive filters are not adaptable to varying system conditions and
remain rigid once they are installed in a application. The size and tuned
frequency cannot be altered easily.
The change in operating conditions of the system may result in detuning of
the filter and it may cause increased distortion. Such a change may happen
undetected provided there is online detection or monitoring in the system.
The design of the passive filter is reasonably affected by source
impedance. For an effective filter design, its impedance must be less than
source impedance. It may cause in large size of the filter in stiff system
with low source impedance, which may result in overcompensation of
reactive power. This overcompensation may cause over voltage in
switching in and under voltage at switching out the passive filter.
These passive filters are designed with large number of elements and
loss/damage of some of the elements may change its resonant frequencies.
This may result an increased in distortion above the permissible limits.
In case large filters, the power losses may be substantial because of
resistive elements.
Limitations of Passive Filters
The parallel resonance due to interaction between source and filter can
cause amplification of some characteristic and non characteristic
harmonics. Such problems enforce the constraints on the designer in
selecting tuned frequency for avoiding such resonances.
The size of damped filter becomes large in handling the fundamental
and harmonic frequencies.
The environmental effects such as aging, deterioration, temperature
change detune the filters in random manner.
In some cases even a presence of small dc component and even
harmonics current may cause saturation of the reactors of the filter.
A special switching is required in switching in and switching out of
passive filters to avoid the switching transients.
The grounded neutral of star connected capacitor banks may cause
amplification of third harmonic currents in some cases.
Special protective and monitoring devices are required in passive
filters.
Cost of Passive Filter
The cost of the passive filter is reasonable and sometimes it reaches 15% to
20% of the equipment for which it is used therefore the design of passive filter
has to consider the cost factor in to account while designing these passive
filters.
Moreover, it has some power losses, which also must be considered in its
design. The cost of the passive filter may also be partially supplemented to
reactive power supplied by it.
A minimum cost filter has to consider the cost of losses along with capital
cost of the filter. Major part of the capital cost about 60% is the cost of the
power capacitors, therefore a reasonable cost reduction may be archived by
proper choice of its capacitors.
Tuned Passive Filters
Key filter design considerations include the
following:
a) Reactive power (kVAR) requirements
b) Harmonic limitations
c) Normal system conditions, including ambient
harmonics
d) Normal harmonic filter conditions
e) Contingency system conditions, including ambient
harmonics
f) Contingency harmonic filter conditions
Selection of Power Filters
Nature of load (voltage fed, convert fed or mixed)
Rating of load
• Harmonics Distortion
• IT product
Tuned Filters
Double tuned filters
• Filter Impedance
Illustrative Examples
Q.1 A three-phase three branch shunt passive filter ( tuned 5 th, 7th and high
pass) is employed to reduce the THD of supply current and to improve
the displacement factor to unity for a three-phase 415 V, 50 Hz fed 6-
pulse thyristor bridge converter drawing 100 A constant dc current at
30º firing angle of its thyristors. Calculate (a) fundamental active power
drawn by the load, (b) fundamental reactive power drawn by the load,
(c) values of filter elements, (d) THD of supply current, and (e) THD of
load voltage, (f) the voltage, current and VA rating of the passive filter.
Let the supply has 5% source impedance mainly inductive.
• Given that, supply voltage, Vs =415/√3=239.6 V rms,
frequency of supply f=50 Hz, with a source impedance of
5% mainly inductive feeding a nonlinear load of 415 V, 50
Hz three-phase thyristor bridge converter with constant
dc current of 100 A at 30º firing angle of its thyristors.
• In this system, the load current harmonics and reactive
power compensation is provided by a three-phase three
branch shunt passive filter (PF) (5th, 7th and high pass
damped filter) to reduce the THD of the supply current
and to improve the displacement factor close to unity.
• The ac load rms current, Iload=Idc√2/√3=81.65A.
• The fundamental rms input current of thyristor bridge
converter is as, I1T=(√6/π) Iload =0.7797*100=77.98 A.
• The fundamental active component of load current, Iload1a= I1T
cosα=77.98cos30º=67.52A.
• The fundamental active power of the load, P1=3Vs1 I1T cosθ1= 3Vs1
I1T cosα=3*239.6*67.52=48536.05 W.
• The fundamental reactive power of the load, Q1=3Vs1 I1T
sinθ1=3Vs1 I1T sinα
• =3*239.6*77.98*0.5=28026.01 VAR.
• The source impedance is as, Zs=jXs=j0.05*239.6/77.98=j0.1536 Ω.
• The voltage drop in the source impedance is as,
Vzs=j67.52*0.1536=j10.37 V.
• The fundamental voltage across the load, VL=√(Vs2-
Vzs2)=239.38≈239.4 V.
• The passive shunt filter has three branch shunt passive
filter (PF) (5th, 7th and high pass damped filter). The
reactive power of 28026.01 VAR required by three-
phase thyristor rectifier has to be provided by all nine
branches of the passive shunt filter. Considering that
all branches of the passive filter has equal capacitors,
therefore, the value of this capacitor is as,
• C=Q/(9VS2ω)= 28026.01/(9*239.62*314)=172.75 µF.
• C5= C7=CH= C=172.75 µF.
• Therefore, the value of an inductor for 5rd harmonic
tuned filter is as,
• L5=1/ (ω52C5)=2.35 mH.
• The resistance of the inductor of 5th harmonic tuned
filter is as,
• R5=X5/Q5=3.687/30=0.1229 Ω. (Considering Q5=30 as it
may be in the range of 10-100 depending upon the
design of the inductor)
• The 5rd harmonic current in the supply is as,
• Is5=IL5*ZPF5/(ZPF5+Zs5)= (I1T/5)R5/(R5+jXs5)=( 77.98/5)*
0.1229/√{0.12292+(5*0.1536)2}=2.4644 A.
• The 5rd harmonic voltage at PCC is as,
• Vs5= Is5*Zs5=2.4644*5*0.1536=1.893 V
• Therefore, the value of an inductor for 7rd harmonic
tuned filter is as,
• L7=1/ (ω72C7)=1.198 mH.
• The resistance of the inductor of 7th harmonic tuned
filter is as,
• R7=X7/Q7=2.634/30=0.08779 Ω. (Considering Q7=30
as it may be in the range of 10-100 depending upon
the design of the inductor)
• The 7rd harmonic current in the supply is as,
• Is7=IL7*ZPF7/(ZPF7+Zs7)= (Iload1/7)R7/(R7+jXs7)=( 77.98/7)*
0.08779/√{0.087792+(7*0.1536)2}=0.9066A.
• The 5rd harmonic voltage at PCC is as,
• Vs7= Is7*Zs7=0.9066*7*0.1536=0.975 V
• The value of an inductor for high pass damped
harmonic filter (tuned at 11h harmonic) is as,
• LH=1/ (ω112CH)=0.4852 mH.
• The resistance in parallel of an inductor of a
high pass damped harmonic tuned filter is as,
• RH=XH/QH=1.676/5=0.3352 Ω. (Considering
QH=5 as it may be in the range of 0.5-5
depending upon the attenuation required)
• All other harmonics load currents to flow in to
high pass damped harmonic filter is as,
• ILH=√[ Iload2- I1T2- I52-I72]= √[81.652-77.982-
(77.98/5)2-(77.98/7)2]= √218.51=14.78 A.
• IsH=ILH*ZPFH/(ZPFH+ZsH)= (ILH)RH/(RH+jXsH)=(14.78)*
0.3352 /√{0.33522+(11*0.1536)2}=2.877 A.
• The high pass harmonic voltage at PCC is as,
• VsH= IsH*ZsH=2.877*11*0.1536=4.86 V
• THDIs={√(Is52+Is72+ISH2)/Is1}=0.05769=5.769%.
• THDVs=[√{(Xs5Is52+(Xs7Is7)2+(XsHISH)2}/
Vs1]=0.022146=2.2146%.
• The current rating of the passive shunt filter is as,
• IPF==√[ Iload2- Iload1a2-Is52-Is72-IsH2]=45.7449A.
• The VA rating of the passive shunt filter is as,
• VAPF=3VPF*IPF=3*239.6*45.7449=32881.46 VA.
Q.2 A single-phase diode bridge rectifier is supplied from 230V, 50 Hz ac
mains The dc load resistance is R =50 Ohms and load inductance is
L=10mH. (a) Design a DC side LC (Inductive- Capacitive) filter so that
the ripple factor of the output voltage is less than 10%.
Solution: Given that, supply rms voltage, Vs = 230 V, frequency of supply f=50
Hz, R=50Ω, L=10mH, Ripple Factor, RF=10%.
In the filter equivalent circuit of the converter system, the diode bridge
generates harmonics in output voltage which flows through output filter
(LdcCdc) and the load. To reduce the ripple in the output voltage, major amount
of ripple (harmonics) must flow the filter capacitor. For this, the load
impedance for these harmonics must be very high. It means analytically as.
{R2+(nωL) 2}½>>1/(nωCdc).
Considering the case, that load impedance is ten times the filter impedance as.
{R2+(nωL) 2}½=10/(nωCdc)
The nth harmonic voltage appearing across the load is computed as.
Vdcn=[-1/( nωCdc)/{(nωLdc)- 1/(nωCdc)}]Vnh=[-1/{(nω)2LdcCdc-1] Vnh
Where Vnh is the harmonics present in the diode rectifier output.
The total ripple voltage caused by all harmonics is as.
Vac= (∑Vdcn2)½ for n=2,4,6,….
In this case, only dominant harmonic may be considered to limit the total
harmonics as all other are lower than the dominant one. Considering, the second
harmonic, which is dominant one. The rms value of it is as. V 2h=4Vsm/(3π√2). Its
mean voltage is as. Vdc=2Vsm/π.
For second harmonic, N=2, it results in as.
Vac=Vdc2=[-1/{(2ω)LdcCdc-1}}V2h
The value of the filter capacitor is computed as.
{R2+(2ωL) 2}½=10/(2ωCdc) or Cdc=10/[4π f{R2+(2ωL) 2}½]=317.85µF
The ripple factor RF is as.
RF=Vac/Vdc=V2h/[Vdc{(4π f)2LdcCdc-1}]=(√2)/[3{(4π f)2LdcCdc-1}]=0.1
It results in as.
(4π f)2LdcCdc-1=4.714 or Ldc=45.58mH.
Ldc idc
zs
is
R
vs vdc
Cdc L
zs L
is
vs C vdc Load
Solution: Given that, supply voltage, Vs =220 V rms, frequency of supply f=50 Hz, with a
source impedance of 10% mainly inductive feeding a nonlinear load of 220 V, 50 Hz
single-phase thyristor bridge converter with constant dc current of 25 A at 60º firing
angle of its thyristors.
In this system, load current harmonics and reactive power compensation is to be
provided by a single-phase three branch shunt passive filter (PF) (3rd, 5th and high pass
filter) to reduce the THD of supply current and to improve the displacement factor to
unity.
The ac load rms current, Iload=Idc=25A.
The fundamental rms input current of the thyristor bridge converter is as, I1T=(2√2/π) Iload
=0.9*25=22.5 A.
The fundamental active component of load current, Iload1a= Iload1
cosα=0.9Idccos60º=11.25A.
The fundamental active power of the load, P1=Vs1Iload1 cosθ1= Vs1 Iload1 cosα=Vs1
Iload1=220*11.25=2475 W.
The fundamental reactive power of the load, P1=Vs1Iload1 sinθ1= Vs1 Iload1 sin α
=220*15*0.5=4286.83 VAR.
The source impedance is as, Zs=jXs=j0.1*220/25=j0.88 Ω.
The voltage drop in the source impedance is as, Vzs= j11.25*0.88=j9.9V.
The fundamental voltage across the load, VL=√(Vs2-Vzs2)=219.78≈220V.
The passive shunt filter has branch shunt passive filter (PF) (3rd, 5th and high pass
damped filter). The reactive power of 4286.83 VAR required by single-phase
thyristor rectifier has to be provided by all three branches of the passive shunt filter.
Considering that all branches of the passive filter has equal capacitors, therefore,
the value of this capacitor is as,
C=Q/(3VS2ω)= 4286.83/(3*2202*314)= 94.02 µF.
C3=C5= CH= C=94.02 µF.
Therefore, the value of an inductor for 3rd harmonic tuned filter is as,
L3=1/ (ω32C3)=11.99 mH.
The resistance of the inductor of 3th harmonic tuned filter is as,
R3=X3/Q3=11.29/50=0.2258 Ω. (Considering Q3=50 as it may be in the range of 10-100
depending upon the design of the inductor)
The 3rd harmonic current in the supply is as,
Is3=IL3*ZPF3/(ZPF3+Zs3)=
(Iload1/3)R3/(R3+jXs3)=(22.50/3)*0.2258/√{0.22582+(3*0.88)2}=0.6391A.
The value of an inductor for high pass damped harmonic filter (tuned at 5h harmonic) is
as,
L5=1/ (ω52C5)=4.315 mH.
The resistance in parallel of an inductor of a 5th harmonic tuned filter is as,
R5=X5/Q5=6.775/50=0.1355 Ω. (Considering Q3=50 as it may be in the range of 10-100
depending upon the design of the inductor)
The 5rd harmonic current in the supply is as,
Is5=IL5*ZPF5/(ZPF5+Zs5)= (Iload1/5)R5/(R5+jXs5)=(22.50/5)* 0.1355/√{0.13552+(5*0.88)2}=0.1385
A.
The value of an inductor for high pass damped harmonic filter (tuned at 7h harmonic) is
as,
LH=1/ (ω72CH)=2.202 mH.
The resistance in parallel of an inductor of a high pass damped harmonic tuned filter is
as,
RH=XH/QH=4.8386/5=0.96772 Ω. (Considering QH=5 as it may be in the range of 0.5-5
All other harmonics load currents to flow in to high pass damped harmonic filter is as,
ILH=√[ Iload2- I1T2- I32-I52]= √[252-22.52-(22.5/3)2-(22.5/5)2]= √43.24=6.58 A.
IsH=ILH*ZPFH/(ZPFH+ZsH)= (ILH)RH/(RH+jXsH)=( 6.58)* 0.96772 /√{0.967722+(7*0.88)2}=1.021 A.
THDIs={√(Is32+Is52+ISH2)/Is1}=0.1077=10.77%.
THDVs=[√{(Xs3Is32+(Xs5Is5)2+(XsHISH)2}/Vs1]=0.026149=2.62%.
IPF=√[ Iload2- Iload1a2- Is32-Is52-IsH2]=22.29 A.
idc
zs
is
L3 Ch
L5
vs vdc Load
C3 C5 Lh Rh
Ldc
isa io
zs
isb
N Cdc
isc vdc
vs V
isa
zs
io
isc isb
vs
zs Load
N
zs vo
L19 Ca
Lh R h
AC Filters
C19
Cm
Fig. 12 pulse HVDC converter station with single phase tuned filter and C-type filter
and performance waveforms
Solution : Given that, an ac mains rms voltage, V s=275 kV, frequency of the supply f=50 Hz, a
12-pulse converter HVDC station is rated at 110 kV, 100 MW dc, operating at =15, connected
to a 275 kV, 50 Hz ac system via a converter transformer of reactance of 15%. A passive shunt
filter system (consisting of a C-type filter tuned at 12 th harmonic and a shunt tuned filter arm at
19th harmonic) is connected on the primary winding side rated at 50 MVAR total. Consider 90%
of this reactive power is to be provided by the C-type filter.
The base impedance is as,
ZB=VL2/P=(275*103)2/(100*106)=756.25 Ω.
Xs=0.15* ZB=0.15*756.25=113.475 Ω.
The C-type filter is a high-pass filter with the capacitor Ca connected in series with the reactor X.
Its capacitive reactance is to be equal to the inductive reactance of X at the fundamental
frequency. The series connection of Ca and X avoids the fundamental frequency current to flow
through R and it reduces power losses in the filter. The C-type filter may also be tuned to a low
frequency than a conventional high-pass filter and it may provide a harmonic attenuation at its
tuned frequency. As the C-type filter provides adequate attenuation at higher frequencies, by
addition of a single-tuned filter order of 19th harmonic may brought harmonic level within the
permissible limits. Here, a single tuned filter is tuned at hT =19 to reduce a sufficient amount of
the 23th and 25th harmonic currents without shifting the parallel resonance into lower
frequencies. The C-type filter also has low initial cost, the low losses, superior non-characteristic
harmonics and inter-harmonics damping, better damping of energizing transient, and higher
robustness against tuning uncertainties compared to conventional tuned and high-pass filter
system. The parameters of C-type filter can be obtained as follows.
From the reactive power supplied by the C-type filter, (Q), the value of CM, is
calculated as,
XCM=VL2/Q=(275*103)2/(0.9*50*106)=1680.55 Ω.
and CCM=1/(XCM*ω)=1/(1680.55*2*π*50)=1.894 µF.
L=X/ω= VL2/{Q*ω*(hT2-1)}= (275*103)2/{(0.9*50*106)*(2*π*50)*(122-
1)}=0.037408=37.41 mH.
X= ω*L=11.746 Ω.
Ca=1/(X*ω)= 1/(L*ω2)=271.1276 µF.
R=q*VL2/(Q*hT)= 2*(275*103)2/{(0.9*50*106)*12}=280.093 Ω. (Considering a quality
factor, q of order of 2).
A passive shunt single tuned filter is tuned at hT =19 and its design parameters
are as.
It is to provide only 10% of the total reactive power of 50 MVAR.
L19=VL2/{Q*ω*(hT2-1)}= (275*103)2/{(0.1*50*106)*(2*π*50)*(192-1)}=0.037408=133.73
mH.
C19= (hT2-1)*Q/{VL2*ω*hT2}=(192
1)*(0.1*50*106)/{(275*103)2*(2*π*50)*(192)}=0.2098698 µF.
The resistance of 19th order passive shunt tuned filter is as,
R19= hTωL/q=19*(2*π*50)*0.13378/50=15.964 Ω.
Thank You