Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ELT (Material Evaluation)
ELT (Material Evaluation)
Evaluation
Group 4 - Nguyen Nhat Le
Evaluation process
Needs Analysis
Matching
Action
Content
2. Mismatches
3.
1. Matches &
Conclusion
Action
1. Match
Audience: Institution:
• Type: General English • Course: published
• Intended audience: ESL coursebook with high “face
learners (children) validity”
• Design and layout: colorful,
engaging to children with • Book: published by
some spaces within page Cambridge Press
layout not feeling
overwhelmed
1. Match
Knowledge: Vocabulary Vocabulary
Grammar
Matching
Listening
Completing
tables
Vocabulary
Sequencing:
o Vocabulary learnt from previous lessons can be
repeated and have further practice in later sessions.
Lesson 1 Lesson 5
Vocabulary
Unit 1 Unit 2
With frequent exposure Help students
remember for a long time & build up vocabulary
Vocabulary
Roles of learners:
• undertake tasks as directed by the materials
Grammar
Exercise 4 (Review)
Grammar
Roles of teachers:
Roles of learners:
etc
Listening
Understand with little or no support most There are 2-3 stories or short articles (200
specific information and details in short, words long) related to the topic, provided with
Roles of teachers:
• Giving instructions and demonstrate activities/special vocabulary or
grammar if necessary
• Check students’ understanding and make sure they get the aims of the
exercise whether it is to read texts to match headings or to scan texts
to answer questions
Roles of students:
• Undertake the assigned tasks
• Follow instructions given by teachers or the books
Writing
Plan, write, edit and proof-read a short Students learn and practice writing from
simple connectives, grammatical structures into sentences, short paragraphs, letters. (via
and sentence patterns with a limited range of “Over to you”, “Use of English”, “Write”
mistakes. activities).
Writing
Roles of teachers:
• Giving instructions and demonstrate necessary activities/special
Phrases
vocabulary or grammar
• Discuss some ideas about the things they could write
• Provide steps taken for paragraphs or letter writing Sentences
• Monitor students’ progress and correct their mistakes
Roles of students:
• Undertake the assigned tasks
From reading samples
• Follow instructions given by teachers or the books To letter writing
Speaking
Deliver basic information about themselves, Speaking activities are involved many times
people, places and objects, and routine past through “talk about it”, “talk”, “over to you”
and present actions and events, using a short (2-3 speaking tasks/lesson) which spread
lesson
→ Learners get practice constantly with every new vocabulary of the topic
Constructivist
Individualized learning
1. Match
Attitude
The Course The Book
Individualized learning + Learner-centered
Participate willingly in written and spoken
approach
communication in familiar situations
respects & based on students’ knowledge &
Show a positive attitude toward the language experience.
Many opportunities for learners to discuss with
and language learning process
their friends and teachers (a large proportion of
this book is devoted for speaking)
2. Mismatch
Course aim:
- get high scores at school
- pass flyers test
Grammar Participation
- Book: The focus is exclusively on meaning and o Book: Most tasks in the book require
meaning-form relationship, metalinguistic learners to work individually
knowledge is presented but NOT in details simultaneously
- Course: To support the development of writing Adaptation: Task restructure
skills, grammatical structures are expected to be
detailed Flyer tests
o Book: No exact test formats are
provided
Adaptation:
- Extra exercises
- Test-taking strategies
Adaptation: Demonstration & Extra Practice
- Mock-tests
3. Conclusion
Pick the book as the core material
Minor adaptations need to be taken
Thanks!
Any questions ?
You can find us at
◉ phanhcao3011@gmail.com
◉ phamthehien2510@gmail.com
◉ viviannguyen9647@gmail.com
30
31