Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Congenital Talipes (Clubfoot)
Congenital Talipes (Clubfoot)
Congenital Talipes (Clubfoot)
EQUINOVARUS
DR. SAMPATH MARASINGHE
REGISTRAR
SJGH
CONTENTS
1. Introduction
2. Anatomy
3. History
4. Epidemiology
5. Etiology
6. Clinical evaluation
7. Assessment of the severity
8. Management options
INTRODUCTION
Clubfoot is not an embryonic malformation.
Developmental deformation of the foot
Characterized by rotational subluxation of the talocalcaneonavicular
joint complex with
Talus in plantar flexion and
Subtalar complex in medial rotation and inversion
ANATOMY
• In the clubfoot, the ligaments of the
posterior and medial aspect of the
ankle and tarsal joints are very thick
and taut, thereby severely restraining
the foot in equinus and the navicular
and calcaneus in adduction and
inversion.
• Deltoid, tibionavicular ligament, and the
tibialis posterior tendon to be very thick
and to merge with the short plantar
calcaneonavicular ligament.
• A photomicrograph of the
tibionavicular ligament shows the
collagen fibers to be wavy and
densely packed. The cells are very
abundant, and many have spherical
nuclei.
• Excessive collagen synthesis in the
ligaments, tendons, and muscles may
persist until the child is 3 or 4 years of
age and might be a cause of relapses.
• Under the microscope, the bundles of collagen fibers display a wavy
appearance known as crimp.
• This crimp allows the ligaments to be stretched.
• Gentle stretching of the ligaments in the infant causes no harm.
• The crimp reappears a few days later, allowing for further stretching.
• That is why manual correction of the deformity is feasible.
KINEMATICS
• The clubfoot deformity occurs mostly in the tarsus.
• The tarsal bones, which are mostly made of cartilage, are in the most
extreme positions of flexion, adduction, and inversion at birth.
• The talus is in severe plantar flexion, its neck is medially and plantarly
deflected, and its head is wedge-shaped.
• The navicular is severely medially displaced, close to the medial
malleolus, and articulates with the medial surface of the head of the
talus.
• The calcaneus is adducted and inverted under the talus.
• The navicular is medially displaced and
articulates only with the medial aspect
of the head of the talus.
• The cuneiforms are seen to the right of
the navicular, and the cuboid is
underneath it.
• The calcaneocuboid joint is directed
posteromedially.
• The anterior two-thirds of the calcaneus
is seen underneath the talus.
• The tendons of the tibialis anterior,
extensor hallucis longus, and extensor
digitorum longus are medially displaced.
• In the clubfoot, the anterior portion of the calcaneus lies beneath the
head of the talus. This position causes varus and equinus deformity of the
heel.
• Attempts to push the calcaneus into eversion without abducting it will
press the calcaneus against the talus and will not correct the heel varus.
• Lateral displacement (abduction) of the calcaneus to its normal
relationship with the talus will correct the heel varus deformity of the
clubfoot.
• Correction of clubfoot is accomplished by abducting the foot in
supination while counterpressure is applied over the lateral aspect of
the head of the talus to prevent rotation of the talus in the ankle.
• A well-molded plaster cast maintains the foot in an improved
position.
• The ligaments should never be stretched beyond their natural amount
of give.
• After 5 days, the ligaments can be stretched again to further improve
the degree of correction of the deformity.
• The bones and joints remodel with each cast
change because of the inherent properties of
young connective tissue, cartilage, and bone,
which respond to the changes in the direction
of mechanical stimuli.
• This has been beautifully demonstrated by
Pirani, comparing the clinical and magnetic
resonance imaging appearance before, during,
and at the end of cast treatment
• The tendo Achillis, unlike the tarsal ligaments that are stretchable, is
made of non-stretchable, thick, tight collagen bundles with few cells.
• Before applying the last plaster cast, the tendo Achillis may have to be
percutaneously sectioned to achieve complete correction of the
equinus.
• The last cast is left in place for 3 weeks while the severed heel-cord
tendon regenerates in the proper length with minimal scarring.
• At that point, the tarsal joints have remodeled in the corrected
positions.
HISTORY
• Talipes - Talus (astragalus) and pes (foot)
• Literally means to walk on the ankles
• first depicted from archeological studies in ancient Egyptian tombs on
mummies by Smith and Warren reporting clubfoot on the Egyptian
Pharaon Siptah (XII century B.C.).
• This mummy and other drawings from an Egyptian temple indicate
that the deformity known as clubfoot has been recognized for
centuries and that it was possible to reach adulthood without
correction of the deformity.
Drawings of the deformity of Hephaestus’ feet over an Etruscan vase stored at The Kunsthistorisches Museum of
Vienna
• The first research and written description of clubfoot was performed
by Hippocrates from Kos in 400 B.C.
• Clubfoot was considered as curable by Hippocrates for the majority of
cases by manipulative correction remarkably similar to current non-
operative methods.
• He described methods for repeated manipulations of the involved
foot, followed by the application of strong bandages to maintain
correction.
• He explained that treatment should begin as early as possible before
the deformity of the bones is well established
• Ambroise Pare (1510–
1590), almost 2000 years
after Hippocrates,
described essentially the
same technique for the
treatment of varus and
valgus forms of clubfeet.
• He also used some
ingenious slippers and
boots to help maintain the
correction
• The first physician to
approach the
treatment of clubfoot
with attention to their
social as well as their
medical needs in an
institutional setting
was Jean-Andre Venel
(1740–1791)
• The first description of the
pathological anatomy of
clubfeet was given by
Antonio S. Scarpa (1752–
1832).
• he described his methods
of treatment, which relied
on gentle manipulation
and the use of braces
incorporating steel springs
Dr. Ignacio Vives Ponseti (1914- 2009)
• Dr. Ignacio Vives Ponseti was born in Ciutadella de Menorca, Spain, on
June 3, 1914, and died in Iowa City, Iowa on October 18, 2009, at the
age of 95.
• His legacy is the development of a primarily nonoperative method of
clubfoot treatment, which involves serial casting, heel cord tenotomy,
and brace wear.
• This method has become the gold standard of clubfoot treatment and
has benefited tens of thousands patients worldwide.
• It could be easily concluded that Ponseti's paper on clubfoot
management (1963) is one of the few manuscripts in orthopaedic
literature which has changed the practice as we know it now.
EPIDIMIOLOGY
• Demographics
• Most common musculoskeletal birth defect
• Overall incidence 1:1,000, though some populations 1:250
• Highest prevalence in Hawaiians and Maoris
• Male:female ratio approximately 2:1
• Anatomic location
• Half of cases are bilateral
• In 80%, clubfoot is an isolated deformity
AETIOLOGY
• Polygenic inheritance for sensitivity to unknown environmental
factors.
• The inheritance pattern has not been established nor a single gene
identified.
• It has been suggested that these genes activate an arrest in the
normal development of the limb bud at five weeks’ gestation.
• Certain modulating environmental factors (e.g., maternal smoking,
alcohol consumption) have been suggested as a contributing factor, as
has intravenous drug use by the mother during pregnancy.
• Incidence was 17 times higher than in the normal population for f irst-degree
relatives and 6 times higher in second-degree relatives.
• Risk of a second child having clubfoot was 1:35 (to unaffected parents).
ETIOLOGICAL
FACTORE
EXTRINSIC
INTRINSIC
(INTRAUTERINE
(GENETIC)
)
EXTRINSIC FACTORS
• Cardy et al. found a significant association of clubfoot between paternal smoking family history
during pregnancy
• Hackshaw et al. in a meta-analysis of 172 articles published from 1959 to 2010, confirmed a
significant association of smoking with clubfoot
• Nguyen et al. found . A strong association of clubfoot incidence was found with breech presentation
and younger maternal age
• Werler et al. investigated the effect of maternal consumption of cigarette smoking, alcohol, and
coffee from 2007 to 2011 with 646 patients and 2,037 controls
• Cigarette smoking is positively associated with increased incidence of clubfoot
• Alcohol and coffee - the risk increased only with a higher level of intake
• Use of antiviral drugs was the most common evidence in isolated clubfoot
• A greater risk was observed for metronidazole
• Slightly higher risks were observed for antinausea treatments - promethazine and ondesetron
EXTRINSIC FACTORS
• Nutritional deficiency
• Karakurt et al. studied the relationship between the plasma total homocysteine level in
blood samples of mothers of children with clubfoot
• Congenital idiopathic clubfoot showed a significant association with a high plasma total homocysteine
level
• Maternal diseases – obesity and / or diabetes
• Amniocentesis and uterine factors
• Farrell et al. analyzed adverse effect of amniocentesis in the etiology of clubfoot in a review
of the largest study by the Canadian Early and Mid-Trimester Amniocentesis Trial group
(CEMAT)
• They were divided into two groups of 2,187 women each: group 1 was the early amniocentesis (EA) group
and group 2 was the midterm amniocentesis (MA) group
• There were 29 (1.3%) cases of clubfoot in 2,172 pregnancies in group 1 but only two (0.1%) in the 2,162
pregnancies of group 2, that is, 10 times more in EA than MA
INTRINSIC FACTORS
• Intrinsic factors
• Neuromuscular or syndromic/dysmorphic etiology
• Arthrogryposis
• Diastrophic dysplasia
• Streeter dysplasia (constriction band syndrome)
• Freeman-Sheldon syndrome
• Möbius syndrome
• Genetic factors
• Limb and muscle morphogenesis - HOXA,HOXD & IGFBP3
• Development of the lower extremity - CAND2 & WNT7a
• Hind limb specific genes - TBX4
• Alvarado et al. screened cases of familial isolated clubfoot to find any genetic etiology and found that
microduplication of chromosome 17q23.1q23.2 is a common cause and provides strong evidence linking it to
clubfoot etiology
• Congenital constriction bands
TYPICAL DEFORMITIES OF THE
CLUBFOOT
1. Cavus
2. Adductus Forefoot
deformities
3. Forefoot supination
4. Hindfoot varus Hindfoot
deformities
5. Equinous
6. Foot is smaller than the normal foot
7. Calf is smaller
PATHOLOGY
• Seven well-established theories of pathology
• Chromosomal theory
• Embryonic theory
• Otogenic theory
• Fetal theory
• Neurogenic theory
• Myogenic theory
• Vascular theory
PATHOLOGY
• Arrest in embryonic development
• The foot in a 6- 8-week-old fetus has many characteristics of a congenital
clubfoot,
• Equinus
• Supination
• Forefoot adduction
• Medial deviation of the talar neck
• The fetal foot becomes normal at 12 to 14 weeks 1 - 111
• Bohm proposed that an arrest in fetal development at this stage was
responsible for the clinical deformities noted at birth 1 – 15
• The characteristic dysmorphic talar head and the medial dislocation of the
navicular have never been observed at any stage of normal fetal development.
PATHOLOGY
• Retractive fibrotic response
• Zimny et.al. identified myofibroblastic retractile tissue in the medial ligaments 1-201
• Ippolito and Ponseti identified an increase in collagen fibers and fibroblastic cells in the
ligaments and tendons of a clubfoot.1 – 94
• Transforming growth factor-β and platelet-derived growth factor are expressed at higher
levels in these contracted tissues.1 -119
• Growth factor blockade with neutralizing antibodies is reported to have the potential to
lessen the severity of the contractures and ultimately positively influence the outcome of
clubfoot treatment.
• The association of clubfeet with syndromes of inherent ligamentous laxity (Down, Larsen)
confounds the hypothesis that fibrotic retractile tissue is a primary etiology
• Recent report using light and transmission electron microscopy failed to reveal any
myofibroblast-like cells in the capsule, fascia, ligaments, or tendon sheaths of nine clubfoot
specimens
PATHOLOGY
• Localized neuromyogenic imbalance
• Imbalance between types I and type II muscle fibers
• Atrophy of type I fibers, has been found in both peroneal and triceps surae
• A recent study on the histologic and histochemical analysis of 431 muscle
specimens in idiopathic clubfeet reported
• 86% showed no evidence of a pathologic diagnosis with normal fiber-type ratios and no
type I fiber grouping indicative of neuromuscular pathology
• Only four specimens (0.9%) showed type I fiber predominance
• 12.8% revealed muscle fiber atrophy 1 – 80
Evaluation of the severity
• Goldner and Fitch
• Carroll
• Pirani
• Dimeglio
• Others
Pirani score
• General Principle of Scoring
• 6 clinical signs of a clubfoot are compared to a normal foot.
• 3 signs evaluate the hind foot contracture.
• 3 signs evaluate the mid foot contracture.
• Each sign is scored with:
• 0 = no abnormality 0.5 = moderate abnormality 1 = severe abnormality
• Higher score indicates a more severe deformity.
• Scoring should be done each visit during treatment.
• Benefits
• Shows the severity of the clubfoot.
• Encourages intensive examination in the beginning.
• Helps to monitor treatment progress.
• Shows, when tenotomy of the Achilles tendon is indicated.
• Tells, when the correction is finished, and the bracing should start.
• Help for research (comparison of results, extraction of subgroups, etc.)
Pirani score
• Hind Foot Contracture Score : 0 - 3
• Posterior Crease
• Empty Heel
• Rigid Equinus
• Mid Foot Contracture Score : 0 - 3
• Medial Crease
• Lateral part of the Head of the Talus
• Curvature of Lateral Border of foot
Hind Foot Contracture Score
• Posterior Crease
• Empty heel
• Easily palpable
• Palpable – deep
• Not palpable
1.0
0.5
Hind Foot Contracture Score
• Rigid equinus
Mid Foot Contracture Score
• Lateral part of the Head of the
Talus (palpability)
• None – 0
• Partial – 0.5
• Full - 1
Mid Foot Contracture Score
• Medial Crease
Mid Foot Contracture Score
• Curvature of Lateral Border of
foot
How to remember easily in the exam
• Two points you look for
• Posterior crease
• Medial crease
• Two points you feel for
• Empty heel
• Lateral head of talus
• Two points you measure for
• Equinus
• Curved lateral border
Dimeglio
Dimeglio
Dimeglio
Dimeglio
Dimeglio
Dimeglio
CLUBFOOT ASSESSMENT
• Screening Encourage all healthcare workers to screen all newborns and infants for
foot deformities and other problems.
• Infants with problems can be referred for care at a clubfoot clinic.
• Confirming The diagnosis suggested during screening is made by someone with
experience with musculoskeletal problems who can establish the diagnosis.
• The essential features of a clubfoot include
• cavus,
• varus,
• adductus
• equinus
• During this evaluation, other conditions such as metatarsus adductus
and the presence of some underlying syndrome can be ruled out.
• The clubfoot is classified into categories.
• This classification is made to establish the prognosis and to plan
management.
POSITIONAL
DELAYED TREATED
TYPICAL
RECURRENT
TYPICAL
CLUBFOOT
ALTERNATIVELY
TREATED TYPICAL
RIGID OR RESISTANT
ATYPICAL
SYNDROMIC
ATYPICAL TERATOLOGIC
NEUROGENIC
AQUIRED
PONSETI CAST CORRECTION
• The setup for casting includes calming the child
with a bottle or breast feeding.
• When possible, have a trained assistant.
• The treatment setup is important.
• The assistant holds the foot while the
manipulator performs the correction
• Start as soon after birth as possible. Make the
infant and family comfortable.
• Allow the infant to feed during the
manipulation and casting processes.
Exactly locate the head of the talus
Stiff forefoot and hindfoot deformity + History of previous soft tissue releases
Gradual correction
through soft tissue Age >10 years Changes of joint degeneration
distraction in (subarticular sclerosis with joint space
external fixation loss)
+
Gradual correction Age >12 years
through V-type
osteotomy across
calcaneum and
midfoot with Triple arthrodesis
distraction in OR
external fixation Gradual correction through V-type osteotomy
across calcaneum and midfoot with distraction
in external fixation
SUMMARY
• Clubfoot, also known as congenital talipes equinovarus, is a
common idiopathic deformity of the foot that presents in
neonates.
• Diagnosis is made clinically with a resting equinovarus
deformity of the foot.
• Treatment is usually ponseti method casting.
• Supplemental surgical procedures such as tendoachilles
lengthening and tibialis anterior transfer may be required during
treatment to correct residual deformity.
REFERENCES
• https://www.orthobullets.com/pediatrics/4062/clubfoot-congenital-t
alipes-equinovarus
• Clubfoot:Ponseti Management.Third Edition
• Campbells operative orthopedics. 14th edition
• Ponseti IV, Smoley EN. Congenital clubfoot: the results of treatment. J
Bone Joint Surg Am 45(2):2261¬–2270.
• Pirani S, Zeznik L, Hodges D. Magnetic resonance imaging study of the
congenital clubfoot treated with the Ponseti method. J Pediatr Orthop
21(6):719–726.