Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) : Dr.D.Saravanan.,Md.,Dph., GDMCH
Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) : Dr.D.Saravanan.,Md.,Dph., GDMCH
TRIAL (RCT)
DR.D.SARAVANAN.,MD.,DPH.,
GDMCH
1
METHOD OF KNOWLEDGE IS
EXPERIMENT
-- WILLIAM BLAKE
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
• 2. EXPERIMENTAL/INTERVENTION STUDIES
..Observing and comparing the outcome of the experiment in both the groups.
• This contrasts sharply with observational studies (descriptive, case control, cohort
studies), where the epidemiologist takes no action but only observes the natural
course of events or outcome.
AIMS
• TO PROVIDE “SCIENTIFIC PROOF” OF ETIOLOGICAL OR RISK FACTORS WHICH
MAY PERMIT THE MODIFICATION OR CONTROL OF THOSE DISEASES.
WHICH
• FOR NEW PROGRAMMES OR NEW THERAPIES, THE RCT IS THE NO.1 METHOD FOR
EVALUATION.
DESIGN OF RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL
Select suitable population (reference or target)
Experimental
Control
Assessment
1. DRAWING UP A PROTOCOL
• STRICT PROTOCOL
• AIMS , OBJECTIVES & SAMPLE SIZE
• QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED
• CRITERIA OF SELECTION: STUDY & CONTROL GROUPS
• INTERVENTION TO BE APPLIED
• STANDARDIZATION OF WORKING PROCEDURES
• SCHEDULES
STRICTLY FOLLOWED THROUGH OUT THE STUDY
PRELIMINARY TEST RUNS
• SOMETIMES IT IS USEFUL TO HAVE A SHORT TEST RUN OF THE PROTOCOL TO SEE WHETHER IT
CONTAINS FLAWS.
• IT IS IMPORTANT THAT THE FINAL VERSION OF THE PROTOCOL SHOULD BE AGREED UPON
• Randomization is done only after the participant has entered the study and it can
be done by using table of random numbers.
1. RANDOM ASSIGNMENT:
FLIP A COIN
• “HEADS”—T X A
• “TAILS”—T X B
• Subjects are divided into ‘blocks’ and randomization is carried out in each
blocks.
• Ex; for two treatments and a block size of four, two of every four consecutive
patients would receive the experimental therapy and the other two would
receive control therapy.
• It may be important to ensure that the treatment and control groups are balanced
on important prognostic factors that can influence the study outcome
(e.g., gender, ethnicity, age, socioeconomic status).
• Before doing the trial, the investigator decides which strata are important and
how many stratification variables can be considered given the proposed sample
size.
a) POSITIVE RESULTS:
B) NEGATIVE RESULTS:
Subject variation
Observer bias
Evaluation Bias
BASED ON RANDOMIZATION:
1. RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS:
WHERE RANDOMIZATION IS USED FOR ALLOCATION OF PRODUCTS AND / OR SUBJECTS.
one group exposed to specific treatment and the other group not exposed.
• Patients remain in the study group or the control group –during the investigation.
2. Factorial Design:
• More efficient than a parallel design if there is an interest in studying more
than one intervention at a time.
• With this type of study design, each patient serves as his own control.
• As before, the patients are randomly assigned to a study group and control
group. The study group receives –treatment, control group receives some
alternate form of active treatment or placebo.
. The two groups are observed over time. Then the patients in each group are
taken off their medication or placebo to allow for the elimination of the
medication from the body and for the possibility of any "carry over" effect.
1. CLINICAL TRIALS
2. PREVENTIVE TRIALS
3. RISK FACTOR TRIALS
4. CESSATION EXPERIMENT
5. TRIAL OF ETIOLOGICAL AGENTS
6. EVALUATION OF HEALTH SERVICES
7. COMMUNITY INTERVENTION TRIALS
1. CLINICAL TRIALS
Traditionally, clinical trials of new therapies or devices pass through the following phases:
1.Phase I clinical trial – trial on a small group(10-30) of health individuals to know the
safety, efficacy and side effects of vaccine. (8-12 months)
2. Phase II clinical trial– trial on large group (50 -500) to know not only safety but also
refining the dose schedule, in multiple centers.(18-24 months)
phase II b (step study or test of concept trial) – enables the researcher to decide whether
is it worth testing in large.
3. Phase III clinical trial – trial in thousands of volunteers not only safety and dose ,
4. Phase IV clinical trial – continuous ongoing process to know long term effects.
2. PREVENTIVE TRIALS
• E.G.:
• In these types of studies, the major difference from the RCT is that the
randomization is done on communities rather than individuals.
ETHICAL ISSUES IN CLINICAL TRIALS
CLINICAL TRIALS SHOULD FOLLOW 3 PRINCIPLES:
• RESPECT FOR RIGHTS: INCLUDING THE FREE CHOICE OF THE SUBJECT AND
PROTECTION FOR THOSE DIMINISHED AUTONOMY.
Jadad AR, et al. Assessing the quality of reports on randomized clinical trials: Is blinding necessary?
Controlled Clin Trials1996;17:1-12. URL: http://www.bmjpg.com/rct/chapter4.html
CONCLUSIONS
a) PROTOCOL
b) INTERVENTION
c) RANDOMIZATION
d) NONE OF THE ABOVE
2. IN A DOUBLE BLIND CLINICAL DRUG TRIAL?
a) PHASE 1
b) PHASE 2
c) PHASE 3
d) PHASE 4
5.TYPE OF RCT, IN WHICH BOTH GROUPS (EXPERIMENT &
REFERENCE ) ACT AS EXPOSED GROUP AS WELL AS NON EXPOSED
GROUP?
a) UNCONTROLLED TRIAL
b) CONCURRENT PARALLEL TRIAL
c) CROSS OVER TRIAL
d) NATURAL EXPERIMENT
PREVIOUS YEAR UNIVERSITY EXAM QUESTIONS
1. DEFINE EPIDEMIOLOGY ?