Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Self From Various Perspectives
The Self From Various Perspectives
THE SELF
FROM VARIOUS
PERSPECTIVES
“
that since which can pass
the test of doubt; if
something is so clear and
lucid as not to be even
doubted, then that is the
only time when one
should actually buy a
Rene proposition.
Descartes
⊙the only thing
Rene
Descartes that one cannot
doubt is the
existence of the
self
“ ⊙Cogito ergo
sum,
⊙"I think
therefore, I
Rene am"
Descartes
⊙The self, then, is also a
combination of two
Rene distinct entities:
Descartes ○ the cogito - the thing
that thinks, which is
the mind
○ the extenza - the
extension of the mind,
which is the body
⊙But what then am I? A
“
thinking thing. It has been
said. But what is a thinking
thing? It is a thing that
doubts, understands,
affirms, denies, wills,
refuses; that imagines
also, and perceives.
Rene
Descartes
JO LO
H CK
N E
⊙ Self is comparable to an
empty space where
everyday experiences
contribute to the pile of
knowledge that is put forth
on that empty space.
Experience is an important
requirement.
⊙ personal identity is a matter
of psychological continuity.
⊙ posits an “empty” mind, a
John tabula rasa, which is shaped
Locke by experience, and
sensations and reflections
being the two sources of all
our ideas
⊙ - the individual person process
different perceptions from
various experiences
DAVID
HUME
⊙ believes that one can know
only what comes from the
senses and experiences
David ⊙ Experiences can be
Hume categorized into two:
○ impressions - products of our
direct experience with the
world
○ Ideas - copies of impressions
and are thus not as lively and
vivid as our impressions
⊙ “Bundles of temporary
impressions”
Examples:name,height,affiliation
s,skills,achievements and the like.
(temporary and non-persisiting)
David Hume
IMMANUE
L
K
A
NT
⊙Believes that there is
necessarily a mind
Immanuel that organizes the
Kant impressions that men
get from the external
world which he calls
APPARATUSES OF
THE MIND
⊙Along with the
apparatuses of the mind
Immanuel goes the "self"
Kant ⊙The self is not just what
gives one his personality;
in addition, it is also the
seat of knowledge
acquisition for all human
persons
The self is always transcendental.
FREU
D
⊙three layers of
Sigmund
Freud the self:
○Id
○Ego (“I”)
○superego
ID
- the primitive and instinctive
- consists of all the inherited
Sigmund components of personality present
Freud at birth, including Eros and
Thanatos
- impulsive (and unconscious)
- remains infantile in its function
throughout a persons life, as it is
not in touch with the external
world
- it operates on the pleasure
EGO
⊙ It is the decision-making component
of personality
Sigmund ⊙ operates according to the reality
principle
Freud ⊙ concerned with devising a realistic
strategy to obtain pleasure.
⊙ has no concept of right or wrong;
⊙ uses unconscious defense
mechanisms to help ward off
unpleasant feelings (i.e., anxiety)
⊙ engages in secondary process
thinking and utilizes reality testing
SUPEREGO
- its function is to control the
Sigmund id's impulses and persuade
Freud the ego to turn to moralistic
goals rather than simply
realistic ones and to strive
for perfection
- it consists of two systems:
1.conscience
2.ego-ideal
⊙ We are certain about the
many wrong things that may
be brought about by our
actions, but we never
understand why there is
something somewhere inside
us that makes many of us do
what we know is wrong.
GILBERT
RYLE
⊙the "self" is not an
Gilbert entity one can locate
and analyze but simply
Ryle
the convenient name
that people use to
refer to all the
behaviors that people
make
⊙ The thinking I will never be
found because it is just a
“ghost in the machine”
⊙ The mind is never separate
from the body.
⊙ The physical actions or
behaviors are dispositions of
the self.
⊙ The mind is a disposition of
the self.
CHURCHLA
D
PA
UL
⊙ Paul and Patricia
Churchland promoted
the position called
“eliminative materialism”
which bring forth
neuroscience into the
fore of understanding the
self.
⊙ tossed aside the concept of
dualism and the brain and
adhered to materialism - the
Paul belief that nothing but
Churchland matter exist
⊙ neurobiology
MERLEA
U PONTY
-
⊙the mind and body are
intertwined that they
Merleau- cannot be separated
Ponty from one another
⊙The living body,his
thoughts,emotions,and
experiences are all one.
He proposes treating perception as a
causal process.
⊙ It means that our perceptions are
caused by the intricate
experiences the self, and
processed intellectually while
distinguishing truthful perceptions
from illusory. Therefore the self is
taken as a phenomenon of the
world.
Group
quiz#1
IDENTIFY WHOSE
STATEMENT ARE THE
FOLLOWING. Write the
philosopher’s name on your
paper.
“
⊙1. Human rationality is the
primary condition in the
existence of the self.
“ ⊙2. Man’s end
goal is
happiness
“ ⊙ 3. There are three
layers of the self, the
id,ego, and super ego
“
⊙4. Claimed that we cannot
really rely on our senses
because our sense
perceptions can often
deceive us.
“
⊙ 5.The self is comparable to an
empty space – tabula rasa.
“ ⊙ 6.The self is not just what gives
one his personality; in
addition, it is also the seat of
knowledge acquisition for all
human persons.
“ ⊙ 7. The self is nothing else
but a bundle of
impressions.
“ ⊙ 8.The self is not an entity
one can locate and
analyze but simply the
convenient name that
people use to refer to all
behaviors that people
make.
“ ⊙ 9.Our behavior appears to
have its basic cause in
neural activity.
“ ⊙ 10.The living body, his
thoughts, emotions, and
experiences are all one.
“ ⊙ 11. There are three components
of the soul:
⊙ The rational soul ,the spirited
soul and the appetitive soul
“
⊙ 12.The self is always
transcendental
“ ⊙ 13.He harshly claimed that
there IS no Self.
“ .
⊙ 14.Experience is an
important requirement
to fill in the empty
space.
“ ⊙ “I KNOW THAT I DO NOT
KNOW”