Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IEC61850 P1results
IEC61850 P1results
IEC61850 P1results
IEC 61850
INTEROPERABILITY BETWEEN
ABB, ALSTOM and SIEMENS
IOP11/2002 2
IEC
61850 IEC 61850 Interoperability in two phases
INTEROPERABILITY
Tests
Specification level Typical functions of a
substation automation
Phase1 Phase 2 system
Test P2b
Test P2a
Test P1
Kickoff
IOP11/2002 4
IEC
61850 What is GOOSE?
INTEROPERABILITY
Tests
EXAMPLE: GOOSE
Receiver
Device Y
GOOSE
Ethernet
GOOSE message
Sender
Device X
GOOSE
Receiver
Device Z
IOP11/2002 6
IEC
61850 Test configuration of phase 1
INTEROPERABILITY
Tests
GOOSE messages
GOOSE „Y does
Injection test device Receiver not react“
Device Y
GOOSE
Sender
Fault Device X
Simulation
Ethernet
GOOSE
Receiver „CB* off“
Device Z
„Z starts its
disturbance
* CB = Circuit Breaker
recording“
IOP11/2002 9
IEC
61850 Negative tests
INTEROPERABILITY GOOSE message with commands for CB tripping and
Tests
disturbance recorder starting
Configuration: sender Y --> receiver Z not configured
Injection test device
GOOSE
Fault
Sender
simulation
Device Y
GOOSE
Sender
Device X Ethernet
GOOSE
Receiver „no reaction“
Device Z
IOP11/2002 10
IEC
61850 Positive tests
INTEROPERABILITY
Tests GOOSE message with commands for CB tripping and
disturbance recorder starting
Configuration: sender Y --> receiver Z
Injection test device
GOOSE
Sender Fault
Device Y simulation
GOOSE
Sender
Device X
Ethernet
GOOSE
„CB off“
Receiver
Device Z
IOP11/2002 11
IEC
61850 Performance tests: Background traffic
INTEROPERABILITY
Tests
KEMA UniCA-
IEC61850 GOOSE Simulator Produced 10, 50,150, 300 GOOSE
messages within 50ms
Heavy busload
measured time
Fault CB off
IOP11/2002 12
IEC
61850 Performance tests: Device load
INTEROPERABILITY
Tests
KEMA UniCA-
IEC61850 GOOSE Simulator Produced 10, 50,150, 300 GOOSE
messages within 50ms
Heavy busload
Heavy device load
measured time
Fault CB off
IOP11/2002 13
IEC
61850 Phase 1: Performance tests
INTEROPERABILITY
Tests
Software
implementation
Optimised
Average
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Transmission time [ms]
Number of tests
Positive tests 9
Correct message transmission between
configured senders and receivers
IOP11/2002 15
IEC
61850 Test results
INTEROPERABILITY
Tests
40
(implementation)
(standard)
accepted
dismissed
Total tests
IOP11/2002 18