Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GBE KPO 2 001 00 Lean Basics 1
GBE KPO 2 001 00 Lean Basics 1
GBE KPO 2 001 00 Lean Basics 1
Expectations
Open Discussion Learn from each other In Lean, the learning never stops It is a Continuous Process Discussion topics If we had to advise Paul Michaels how to roll out lean to all of Mars, Inc what would we say? 1 Expectation (Session)
The idea is to discuss everything here, if not we can park it & come back later
Lean Thinking
Its a people issue. Thats why its so hard. Getting people to change to do things differently than they have done them is really, really hard.
Art
If a company is really maniacal about Lean it takes two to three years to go from kindergarten to first grade. Thats how tough it is.
Mark
Lean requires experienced managers and Execs to change what they Know and have done for many years! Lean Thinking requires Courage! Lean Thinking is about removing safety nets and exposing problems Lean Thinking is about making problems Ugly so they can be resolved Sometimes it is not good enough to improve a process - you have to change it Completely Lean Thinking is an understanding that lean is about Cultural change NOT a quick Fix Lean Thinking is about asking WHY? and Challenging what we have defined as the NORM Lean Thinking requires us to view our own Discipline to process in the same way as we view Quality of Product or Service- LEAD BY EXAMPLE Lean Thinking is an Understanding that $ savings are Consequential, not a Driver. Lean Thinking Is about Teaching everyone we interact with, what Lean Thinking is. LEAN THINKING STARTS WITH THE MANAGEMENT, US!!!!!
+ Innovation
Innovative Production
LEAN
Source: Womack and Jones: The Machine that Changed the World
Improvement Level
kaizen
Standardization
Before improvements have an opportunity to degrade, the team is on to the next improvement.
Time
Our competitors achieve average results, with brilliant people working on broken processes. At Toyota, we achieve brilliant results, with average people working on brilliant processes
Taiichi Ohno, Toyota
Kaizen
Consider how computer storage media has continuously improved over 30 years
Value
Correctly Specify Value of Product/Service with Customer in mind
Flow
Make the Product and Value Flow Smoothly
Pull Perfection
Wastes Elimination as an Ongoing Process towards Perfection Produce only to the Pull of Customer Demand
Mars : Suppliers
Mars : Customer
See the Whole Process from Start to Finish See the Whole Process from Start to Finish
Lean
Is a business system involving all employees which constantly pursues the elimination of waste and variation in all business processes.
Supplier
MFG
Customer
Quality
Customer satisfaction
Q may influence C: Positive, because if sales rise then fixed overheads are reduced. C must not influence Q: Costs can for instance be influenced by purchasing in cheap raw materials
Quality
Q may influence S: Good process and component quality makes it easier to deliver punctually. S may influence Q: Good process quality cuts throughput times. These are the result of lower WIP which pressures the process to solve quality problems.
Costs
S may influence C: Punctual delivery is achieved (penalties for late delivery can be avoided). C must not influence S: Larger packaging containers can be a means of reducing costs, but this is not in accordance with the JITVision, since their throughput time is
Service
Price Price
ofi Pr os t C t
Price
Pr of it Co st
Price
Defining Value
Value Added Activity
Something customers are willing to pay for - AND changes the form, fit, or function of materials or information - AND Is being done right the first time.
Non -Value Added Activity
All other actions and unwanted features are by definitionWASTE adding no value to the customer.simply raise costs in our business!
Before After
Time
Value Added Work Non Value Added Work
Understanding & Eliminating Waste Observe that 2 Things are ALWAYS Happening. . . Things that should be done Things that should not be done
Before After
WORK WASTE
Time
Value Added Work Non Value Added Work
ItEither Adds Value or Does Not ItEither Adds Value or Does Not
7.70 hrs
Waste
Work which does not increase the value of the product (e.g. rework due to wrongly assembled parts or operator waiting-time while machine is running.)
Value added
Work that directly increases the value of the product (e.g. assembly of parts)
Waste
Objective
The objective is to maximize the value added part by eliminating waste and incidental work
Non value added, but necessary work (e.g. small movements to reach for material for assembly, quality-checks)
WASTE IS WORK THAT ADDS COST BUT DOES NOT ADD VALUE
Waste Exists In Every ProcessEliminate It! Waste Exists In Every ProcessEliminate It!
Waste #1 Defects
1 4
Defects
Over Production
Inventory
Motion
Processing Transactions
Transportation
Waiting
Reworking Defects Is WastefulSending Them to Customers is Outrageous Reworking Defects Is WastefulSending Them to Customers is Outrageous
Waste #2 Over-Production
Defects 2 4
Over Production
Inventory
Motion
Processing Transactions
Transportation
Waiting
Do Not Produce What the Customer Does Not Need Do Not Produce What the Customer Does Not Need
Waste #3 Inventory
Defects
Over Production 3 4
Inventory
Processing Transactions
Inventory levels
High spoilage Unplanned stoppages Slow running
Transportation
Waiting
Waste Asks For More Waste Waste Asks For More Waste
Waste #4 Motion
???
Defects
Over Production
sitting
searching
turning around
w alking
Inventory
Motion Motion
Processing Transactions
clim g bin
choosin g
lying dow n
After
Transportation
Waiting
Treat Operators as SurgeonsEverything Within Reach Treat Operators as SurgeonsEverything Within Reach
Over Production
Inventory
Motion
5 4
Creates Delay Increased Opportunity for More Defects Doesnt Add Value By Definition
Transportation
Waiting
Match Physical Movement With Systemic Match Physical Movement With Systemic TransactionStrive for 1:1 Ratio TransactionStrive for 1:1 Ratio
Waste #6 Transportation
Defects
Over Production
Weld
End Finish
Weld
End Finish
Inventory
Motion
Processing Transactions
6 4 Motion Transportation
Waiting
Machines Next to Each OtherTransport Time Minimized Machines Next to Each OtherTransport Time Minimized
Waste #7 Waiting
Defects
Over Production
Inventory
Motion
Processing Transactions
Transportation
7 4
Waiting Motion
When Inventory Waits Your Customer Waits When Inventory Waits Your Customer Waits
Lean: Identify the Waste & Eliminate It! Lean: Identify the Waste & Eliminate It!
Inventory
Motion
Searching for files / handling paperwork Gathering information Extra key strokes Handoffs
Waiting
Over-Processing
Repeated manual entry of data Use of inappropriate software Use of outdated forms
Waiting for Faxes System to come up Customer response A handed-off file to come back
Over-Production
Unused Creativity
More information than customer needs Wasted ideas from the Creating reports no one reads team Making extra copies
Zero Defect
Isolated Processes
What is impact of Throughput time, Quality, Reliability, Stocks, Responsiveness, Flexiblity, Freshness, ROTA, Utilisation, FIFO, Changeover time, Age ?
Coupling of Processes
Batch production Flow production
What is impact of Quality, Reliability, Stocks, Responsiveness, Flexiblity, Freshness, ROTA, Utilisation, FIFO, Changeover time ?
Value Chain
Levels of Mapping
Forms the Blueprint for a Lean Implementation Plan Forms the Blueprint for a Lean Implementation Plan
How do we Start?
Identify the Value Stream for every major product family / program Concept to launch - Order to delivery
Map the current state - Identify all the actions that dont create value (VA/NVA/VE) Develop and map concepts for the future state as a management team & communicate your vision to your team. Develop metrics & determine goals How will Success be measured? Develop actions and drive toward future state
Current State Current State Drawing Drawing Future State Future State Drawing Drawing Implementation Implementation Plan Plan
3G
Genchi Genbutsu Gemba
Guidelines for Mapping Start at the customer and work backwards Walk the actual flows Dont Map the Organization but the flow through it Dont be too detailed this is an overview Use pencil not power pointquick and crude
Pretend you are the Part And follow the path part flows Pretend you are the Part And follow the path part flows
Mars India
Customer
BAX
On Demand
Daily Schedule
LEVEL 5
KITTING
CONVERSION
BOTTOM Yield=99.%
TOP Yield=98.6%
MIDDLE** Yield=73.2%
BACK-END Yield=78.6%
Traffic Intersection
Kitting Racks
Kits
1 h** 6h
1 h*** 6h 4h
0.24 h 2h 0.2 h
Mars India
CISCO
On Demand
Batch
Set Ups
LEVEL 5
Batch
Batch
BACK-END Yield=78.6%
Yield=99.%
Kitting Racks
Batch
Kits
Batch
0.24 h 0.25 h 2h 0.2 h 2.7 h 0.5 h
1 h** 6h
1 h*** 6h 4h
Clearly Identifies Opportunities to Drive Sustainable Change Clearly Identifies Opportunities to Drive Sustainable Change
Detailed info.
Push system
Key: Material flow Information
Pull system
Push
Long throughput times requires long term planning leads to uncertain forecasts Long term planning little trust in the planning figures build-up of buffer stocks Buffer stocks are incorporated into store planning Changes to the production plan lead to overproduction and incorrect products in market Machine stoppages etc. call for fire fighting measures
Synchronous production
Isolated Processes
What is impact of Throughput time, Quality, Reliability, Stocks, Responsiveness, Flexiblity, Freshness, ROTA, Utilisation, FIFO, Changeover time, Age ?
Coupling of Processes
Batch production Flow production
What is impact of Quality, Reliability, Stocks, Responsiveness, Flexiblity, Freshness, ROTA, Utilisation, FIFO, Changeover time ?
Pull System
How to maintain a Pull System on decoupled processes?
Raw materials
The first aim is Couple all processes, then Pull becomes integrated and Throughput times and Stocks remain low. However, when there is spacial separation of processes, how can we can create Pull?
Setting up of supermarkets
No overview of stocks
Overview of stocks
Supermarket Features
Fixed locations, Quantity, Visualization and the Fill-up principle are characteristics of a supermarket
The supermarket controls the previous process according to the principle Whats gone must be replenished.
Raw material
Process
Supermarket
Container Benefits:
The arrival of an empty container immediately sets off the production of a new part required for that specific container.
KANBAN Cycle
The four stages in a KANBAN cycle represent the information and material flows at production level
2. The KANBAN card is brought to the preceding process. 1. The following process places the KANBAN card in a KANBAN box when removing the first part from the container.
3. The full container is taken from the preceding processs supermarket along with the KANBAN card.
4. The container is transported to the following process together with the KANBAN card.
Information
1. When taking out the first part from the parts container, the KANBAN is removed and placed in a KANBAN mail box. The KANBANs are collected and sorted according to supplier.
3. At the suppliers, the KANBANs are attached to the containers with finished goods.
4. The products together with KANBAN are delivered to the customer according to the delivery cycle.
Not able to control material and information flows, due to the complex and overriding production system
Annual planning
The pull system differs in that the Planning* is done directly at shop floor level to ensure a direct information and material flow between the processes
Annual planning
*
replenishmen t
Workshop / Gemba
Workshop / Gemba
Push System
Pull System
TAKT TIME
Determine Build Strategy
= Customer Forecast
Available time
TAKT TIME is just Mathematics, but is Fundamental to Lean AVAILABLE TIME: Total amount of TIME allocated for production DEMAND: qty of scheduled parts for a given time frame each shift has ~ 6.5 hrs available - this is a constant! 6.5 hrs is used to account for lunches, breaks, etc... EXAMPLE Available Time = 60 min/hr x 6.5 hrs/shift x 2 shifts/day x 5 days/wk = 3900 min/wk Your customer demand is 90 pcs per week
TAKT Time =
= 43 min/pc
Fluctuations in Demand
Starting situation: Sales volume fluctuates due to: Seasonality Advertising Promotions Competitors Activities exchange rate fluctuations ... Demand behaviour
Volume
Upper Limit
Effects on the business: - Need to lower or increase the normal factory capacity
planned amount
Lower Limit
Sales
N D Months
2 3 Week
Time
Actual load
Overloading
Underloading
(B)
Demanded load
M A
M J
O N D
Months
MARKET-SYNCHRONISED PRODUCTION
The vision of the complete synchronization of demand and production volume cannot be implemented in practice
Ideal case/vision synchronization
Volume (units)
Synchronization: Production volume is identical with the sales volume and adjusts quickly to market demand. In practice, this adjustment is often not possible. Reasons for this are for example: - inflexible work time models - sluggish information flow - time-consuming material procurement - insufficient employee qualifications - lack of planning instruments - capacities must be geared to max. values danger of over-capacity - ...
Production
Demand
Lower AFL*
N D Months
(A) + Overload
Cycle-time method
Underload
(B)
Demand
lower AFL*
N D Months
N D Months
Features: Capacity problems Capacity utilization problems Quality problems High costs
Features: Constant personnel numbers Purchase volumes can be planned and machines run at full capacity Standardized processes
Demand
Lower AFL*
Cycle time
Work content
4 3 2 1 Processing cycle 3
1 Processing cycle 4
PLANNING CRITERIA
In any change to the customer cycle, important points need to be observed
Parameters Employees
Logistics
Monuments, space requirement, fire safety zones, machine running times, tools, workplaces
Production process
Zero Defects
The direct coupling of processes in Flow production principle is not sufficient to represent a just-in-time-production correctly
80 %
80 %
80 %
80 %
80 %
80 %
80 %
80 %
Total availability = ? 80 %
Total availability = ? 41 %
Perfect Quality
There are several tools available to increase process quality
Perfect Quality
TPM
Poka Yoke, 5S
Zero-defect program
Process stability
Fault prevention
Jidoka
Andon Boards
Fault correction
5 Whys?
Quality
Service
The Four Pillars
Value
Continuous Improvement
Pull System
Takt Time
Zero Defect
Identify steps in the whole value stream to highlight waste Create a continuous flow of activities along the value stream
Strive for perfection by continually creating value and removing successive layers of waste
LEAN MANUFACTURING
-Continuous Improvement is a journey & not a destination. It is not the big that eats the small. It is the fast that beats the slow