Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transcultural Nursing
Transcultural Nursing
NURSING
Guide to Heritage Assessment and
⊹ Week 1 -2
“ Review of relevant theories:
Transcultural Nursing Theory
Interpersonal Relations Theory
Cultural Conflicts
2
Contents
⊹Preface
⊹Cultural conflicts
⊹CulturalCare Considerations
•Heritage Assessment
•Cultural Phenomena Affecting HEALTH
•CulturalCare Etiquette
•HEALTH Traditions Assessment Model
•HEALTH Traditions Assessment Guidelines
•Community HEALTH Traditions Assessment Guidelines
⊹CulturalCare Guide
⊹CulturalCare Conclusions
⊹Selected CulturalCare Terms
3
PR E FA
CE
4
There are countless conflicts that occur in the health-care delivery arenas predicated on
cultural misunderstandings. Albeit, many of these misunderstandings are related to universal
situations, such as:
- verbal and nonverbal language misunderstandings
- the conventions for courtesy
- sequencing of interactions
- phasing of interactions
- Objectivity
There are, however, countless cultural misunderstandings unique to the delivery of health
care; hence the necessity to provide Cultural Care.
5
Cultural Care
⊹ professional health care that is culturally
sensitive, culturally appropriate, and
culturally competent - is essential as we
enter the new millennium, and this
demands that providers must be able to to
assess and interpret the given patient's
health beliefs and practices.
6
CulturalCare alters the perspective of health-care delivery as it enables the provider to
undertand, from a cultural perspective, the manifestations of the patient's HEALTH-CARE
beliefs and practices.
9
Cultural
1
Conflicts
The following scenarios are composite situations that may be
encountered in a variety of clinical settings. In order to
prevent stereotyping, the heritage of the patient involved in
the situation is not given here. Rather, the situations are
presented in a generic fashion. The tools for assessment and
process are then presented with a subsequent section on
scenario is revisited and the possible “Cultural Care
Conclusions” are presented. They serve to demonstrate how a
given situation may, in fact, occur among people from many
different ethnocultural backgrounds.
11
1. A person who is bleeding refuses surgery when they are
forced to remove what appears to be a piece of jewelry.
2. A person is admitted to the emergency room with welts and
large red circles on their back.
3. A person who is being interviewed refuses to answer
questions directly or to look the provider in the eye.
4. An adult immunization clinic is held in a public building
and the turnout for the program is minimal.
5. A new mother does not want to hold or see her baby
following the delivery.
6. A person on a liquid diet refuses to eat the gelatin.
12
7. A young patient refuses a blood transfusion and is supported
by the family.
8. A patient is given a supply of antibiotics in the emergency
room to treat a respiratory infection and leaves the medication
behind.
9. A person is acurately ill and does not respond to the questions
being asked.
10. A person who is terminally ill is found to have a card hidden
under the pillow.
11. The family of a person who died refuses to lave the room.
12. A patient who is 24-hours post-chest surgery does not
request pain medication.
13
Culturalcare
consideratio
2
ns
CULTURALCARE
CONSIDERATIONS
This section of the guide contains practical
guides: Heritage Assessment, CulturalCare
Phenomena Affecting HEALTH,
CulturalCare Etiquette, HEALTH
Traditions Assessment Model, and
HEALTH Traditions Assessment
Guidelines for the community.
15
HERITAGE ASSESSMENT TOOL
This set of questions can be used to investigate a given patient's or your own
ethnic, cultural, and religious heritage. it can help you to perform a heritage
assessment to determine how deeply a given person identifies with a particular
tradition. It is most useful in setting the stage for understanding a person's
identification with a traditional heritage. The one exception to positive answers is
the question about family name change. This questions may be answered
negatively.
16
CULTURALCARE
PHENOMENA AFFECTIVE
HEALTHC E
Giger and Davidhizar* have identified six cultural phenomena
that vary among cultural groups. These are:
⊹ Environmental ⊹ Biological ⊹ Social
control variations organization
17
Week 3-TOPICS:
Cultural Variations
Cultural Competence
Culturally diverse nursing care
Cultural heritage
Areas/races/places of Variations
Environmental control
The ability of members of a particular cultural group to
plan activities that control nature or direct environmental
factors. Included are the complex systems of tradional
health and illness beliefs, the practice of folk medicine,
and the use tradional healers. These play an extremely
important role in the way patients respond to health-
related experiences, including the ways in which they
define health and illness and seek and use health-care
resources and social supports.
19
“ ⊹ Cultural Variations call
nurses to be
CULTURALLY
COMPETENT
20
⊹ CULTURALLY COMPETENT
1. Gaining understanding of your cultural
“ heritage.
2. Considering how media influences
society’s impressions of cultural groups
3. Developing a general baseline knowledge
relative to specific cultural groups
4. Be vigilant and aware
21
⊹ CULTURALLY DIVERSE NURSING
CARE
23
⊹ Cultural Heritage
24
BIOLOGICAL
VARIATIONS
People from one cultural group differ
biologically (physically and genetically) from
members of other cultural groups:
b) Skin color
d) Susceptibility to disease
e) Nutritional variations
25
Social organization
The family unit, (nuclear, single-
parent, or extended family) and the
social group organizations (religious
or ethnic) with which patients and
families may identify.
26
COMMUNICATION
Communication differences are presented
in many ways, including language
differences, verbal and nonverbal
behaviors, and silence.
27
Space or proxemics
Personal space and territoriality involves
people’s behaviors and attitudes toward space
around themselves and are influenced by
culture. The following terms indicate different
types of space and relate to acceptable
behaviors within these zones.
a) Intimate zone: extends up to 1 ½ feet.
b) Personal distance: extends from 1 ½ to 4
feet.
c) Social distance: extends from 4 to 12 feet.
d) Public distance: extends 12 feet or more.
28
TIME ORIENTATION
The viewing of the time in the present, past, or future varies among different cultural
groups.
a) Future-oriented: People are concerned with long-range goals and with health-care
measures taken in the present to prevent the occurrence of illness in the future.
b) Present-oriented: People are oriented to the present than the future and may be late
for appointments because they are less concerned about planning ahead of time.
29
PHENOMENA AFFECTIVE
HEALTHC E
American European
African Asian/Pacific
Indians Hispanic (White)
(Black) Islander
Aleuts, and Americans Origin
Americans Americans
Eskimos Americans
30
PHENOMENA AFFECTIVE
HEALTHC E
Asian/Pacific American European
African (Black) Hispanic
Islander Indians Aleuts, (White) Origin
Americans Americans
Americans and Eskimos Americans
Traditional health Traditional health Traditional health Traditional health Primary reliance
and illness and illness and illness and illness on “modern,
beliefs may beliefs may beliefs may beliefs may Western”
continue to be continue to be continue to be continue to be healthcare
observe by observe by observe by observe by delivery system
ENVIRONMENT “traditional ” “traditional ” “traditional ” “traditional ” Remaining
-AL CONTROL people people people people traditional health
Natural and Folk medicine and illness
magicoreligious tradition beliefs and
folk medicine Traditional practices may be
tradition healers: observed
Traditional curandero, Some remaining
healer: medicine espirista, traditional folk
man or woman partera, señora medicine
Homeopathic
medicine
resurgent
31
PHENOMENA AFFECTIVE
HEALTHC E
American European
African Asian/Pacific
Indians Hispanic (White)
(Black) Islander
Aleuts, and Americans Origin
Americans Americans
Eskimos Americans
32
PHENOMENA AFFECTIVE
HEALTHC
American European
African Asian/Pacific
Indians Hispanic (White)
(Black) Islander
Aleuts, and Americans Origin
Americans Americans
Eskimos Americans
34
PHENOMENA AFFECTIVE
HEALTHC E
American European
African Asian/Pacific
Indians Hispanic (White)
(Black) Islander
Aleuts, and Americans Origin
Americans Americans
Eskimos Americans
Space Close Noncontact Space very Tactile Noncontact
personal people important and relationships: people: aloof,
space has no touch, distant
boundaries handshakes, Southern
embrace countries:
Values closer contact
physical and touch
presence
35
RE
ETIQUETTE
There are countless ways in which the
etiquette essential to a satisfactory
provider-patient encounter is breached.
This table presents an overview of
selected situations wherein etiquette
can be modified to the needs of a
patient.
CULTURAL PHENOMENA AFFECT
ING ETIQUETTE.docx
36
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
People who identify with a traditional ethnocultural heritage may tend to define HEALTH
and illness in a holistic way, and have health beliefs and practices that differ from those of
the Western, or modern, health-care delivery system.
Imagine holistic HEALTH as a three-dimensional phenomenon that encompasses the
following: body (the physical self), mind (feelings, attitudes, and behavior), and spirit (the I
am who I am).
HEALTH, in the traditional sense, is the state of balance within the body, mind, and
spirit, and with the family, community, and the forces of the natural world.
Illness is the opposite.
Many traditional HEALTH beliefs and practices exist today among people who know
and live by the traditions of their given ethnocultural heritage.
37
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
HEALTH, in this traditional context, has three dimensions each of which has three aspects,
making a total of nine interrelated facets.
1. Maintaining HEALTH
a) Physical- are there special clothes one must wear; food one must eat, not eat, or
combinations to avoid; exercises one must do?
b) Mental- are there special sources of entertainment; games or other ways of concentrating;
traditional “rules of behavior”?
38
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
2. Protecting HEALTH
a) Physical- are there special foods that must be eaten after
certain life events, such as childbirth; dietary taboos that
must be adhered to; symbolic clothes that must be worn?
39
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
3. Restoring HEALTH
a) Physical- are there special folk remedies; liniments; procedures, such as cupping,
acupuncture, and moxibustion?
b) Mental- are there special healers, such as curanderos, available; rituals; folk medicines?
41
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
PHYSICAL MENTAL SPIRITUAL
Maintain • Are there special • What do your do for • Do you practice you
clothes you must wear activities, such as religions and attend
HEALTH at certain times of the reading, sports, church or other
day, week, year? games? communal activities?
• Are there special • Do you have • Do you pray or
foods you must eat at hobbies? meditate?
certain times? • Do you visit family • Do you observe
• Do you have any often? religious customs?
dietary restrictions? • Do you visit friends • Do you belong to
• Are there any foods often? fraternal
that you cannot eat? organizations?
42
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
PHYSICAL MENTAL SPIRITUAL
Protect • Are there foods that • Are there people or • Do you observe
you cannot eat situations that you religious customs?
HEALTH together? have been taught to • Do you wear any
• Are there special avoid? amulets or hang them
foods that your must • Do you take in your home?
eat? extraordinary • Do you have any
• Are there any types of precautions under practices, such as
clothing that you are certain always opening the
not allowed to wear? circumstances? window when you
• Do you take time for sleep?
yourself? • Do you have any other
practices to protect
yourself from “harm”?
43
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
PHYSICAL MENTAL SPIRITUAL
44
COMMUNITY HEALTH
TRADITIONS ASSESSMENT
GUIDELINES
HEALTH traditions come alive the moment one leaves institutional confines and goes into the
community. An in-depth community assessment of an ethnoreligious community alerts your to
the vast resources that exist within traditional communities and that may be tapped.
The following outline serves as a community assessment guide:
Demographic Data
⊹ Total population size of entire city or town
⊹ Breakdown by areas – residential concentrations
⊹ Breakdown by ages
⊹ Other breakdowns: Educations, occupations, income and nations of origin of
residents of the location and the target neighborhood
45
TRADITIONS ASSESSMENT
GUIDELINES
Traditional HEALTH Beliefs: Definition of HEALTH; Definition of illness;
Overall HEALTH status
Causes of Illness: Poor eating habits; wrong food combinations; viruses, bacteria,
and other organisms; punishment from God; the eye evil; hexes, spells or envy;
witchcraft; environmental changes; exposure to drafts; over- or underwork; grief
and loss
46
TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT
GUIDELINES
- Methods of Maintaining HEALTH
- Methods of Protecting HEALTH
- Methods of Restoring HEALTH – Home Remedies
- Visits and Use of M.D. or Other Health-Care Resources
- HealthCare Resources, Such as Neighborhood health Centers
- Anyone Else Within Community Who Looks After People, Such As
Traditional Healers
- Child-Bearing Beliefs and Practices
- Child-Rearing Beliefs and Practices
- Rituals and Beliefs Surrounding Death and Dying
47
TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT
GUIDELINES
Walk through the community and observe the traditional grocery
stores, pharmacies, markets, jewelry stores, beauty parlors,
morticians, and churches. If possible, visit several places, purchase
remedies, eat in a restaurant, and observe services in a church.
48
ASSESSMENT GUIDE FOR COMMUNAL
METHODS AND RESOURCES FRO MAINTAING,
PROTECTING, AND RESTORING HEALTH
PHYSICAL MENTAL SPIRITUAL
Maintain • Where are people • What are examples • Are these resources
HEALTH able to purchase of culture-specific to meet the patient’s
special clothing? books, games, and identified spiritual
• Where are specific other activities for needs?
foods purchased? this given patient? • How are the people
• What types of health • Where are books, and places
education are a part games, and other accessed?
of the person’s forms of culture-
culture and who specific materials
teaches this obtained?
information? • What are culture-
• Where is the specific rules for
information this patient, such
obtained? as conversation,
eye contact?
49
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
PHYSICAL MENTAL SPIRITUAL
Protect • Where are special • Who within the • Who teaches the
HEALTH clothes obtained? patient’s family spiritual practices?
• What are some and community • Where can the
examples of teaches the patient purchase
symbolic clothing a cultural rules? special amulets and
person may obtain? • Are there rules other symbolic
about avoiding objects?
people or places? • Are they costly?
• Are there special • Are they readily
activities that available?
must be
observed?
50
HEALTH TRADITIONS
ASSESSMENT MODEL
PHYSICAL MENTAL SPIRITUAL
Restore • Where are various • Who are the • Are the traditional
remedies purchased? traditional people healers in the
HEALTH • Are people able to within the community?
grow herbs and other community that the • Who are they and how
remedies in their own person may seek are they accessed?
homes? care and advice
• Where are other from?
traditional services • Are there culture-
obtained? specific activities,
• Who are the such as story telling
traditional healers that may be
within the patient available to the
community and where patient?
do they practice? • Where are the
ingredients for
special “teas”
purchased?
51
Selected
SELECTED HEALTH TRAD
health ITIONS.docx
traditions
52
Culturalcare
3
guide
The following guidelines will help you understand your patients better and allow you to
provide the needed help.
Preparing
⊹ Understand your own cultural values and biases.
⊹ Acquire basic knowledge of cultural values, HEALTH beliefs and practices for the
patient groups you serve.
⊹ Be respectful of, interested in, and understanding of other
cultures without being judgmental.
54
Enhancing Communication
⊹ Determine the patient’s level of fluency in English and arrange for an
interpreter, if needed.
⊹ Ask how the patient prefers to be addressed.
⊹ Allow the patient to choose seating for comfortable personal space and eye
contact.
⊹ Avoid body language that may be offensive or misunderstood.
⊹ Speak directly to the patient, whether an interpreter is present or not.
⊹ Choose a speech rate and style that promotes understanding and
demonstrates respect for the patient.
⊹ Avoid slang, technical jargon, and complex sentences.
⊹ Use open-ended questions or questions phrased in several ways to obtain
information.
⊹ Determine the patient’s reading ability before using written materials in the
teaching process. If patient cannot read English, translate materials.
55
Promoting Positive Change
• Build on cultural practices, reinforcing those that
are positive, and promoting change only in those
that are harmful.
• Check for patient understanding and acceptance
of recommendations.
• Remember: Not all seeds of knowledge fall into
a fertile environment to produce change. Of
those that do some will take years to germinate.
Be patient and provide care in a culturally
appropriate environment to promote health
behavior.
56
Culturalcare
CONCLUSI
3
ONS
Each of the cases presented in the beginning of
this guide book can be understood if viewed through a
lens of CulturalCare. Initially, the patient in each scene
must be assessed with the Heritage Assessment tool.
Once the given patient’s ethnocultural history is
learned and the degree to which this person identifies
with the given tradition detected, emphasis must be
placed on discovering the role given heritage plays in
the situation. Each situation has specifi reasons for
occurring within a cultural context. The text, Cultural
Diversity in Health and Illness, 5th ed., provides a
much deeper theoretical background relevant to each
of the situation. A summary is presented here:
⊹ A person who is bleeding refuses surgery when they are forced to remove what appears
to be a piece of jewelry.
This person may be from an ethnocultural tradition where amulets are worn and the
removal. Of the amulet may precede certain health death. The amulet is believed to
protect the person from external evils and thee person may be reluctant to remove it
for this reason. The person may be from an African, Hispanic, Asian, or European
heritage.
⊹ A person admitted to the emergency room with welts and large red circles on their back.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition where coining or cupping are
used to treat many maladies, especially respiratory infections. These traditional
practices include people from Asian and Eastern heritage.
59
⊹ A person who is being interviewed refuses to answer questions directly or to look the
provider in the eye.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition that places taboo on
interviews where the recording of answers Is taboo and/or eye contact with strangers
is prohibited. The heritages may include, but are not limited to, American Indian,
African American, and Moslem.
⊹ An adult immunization clinic is held in a public building and the turnout for the program
is minimal.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition wherein it is believed that
immunization is not necessary for adult, especially the elderly. Many believe that
since they were not immunized as children, it is necessary now. Others believe that
seit, amulets, and other practices serve to protect their HEALTH. This phenomena
may be observed among people from all heritages.
60
⊹ A new mother does not want to hold or see her baby following the delivery.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition where she has been socialized
to believe that the baby must not be bonded with until it is a certain age, as it is
vulnerable to outside evil forces. Many rituals of a religious or ethnocultural nature
must be observed until the baby is seen to be free from a state of taboo and then
bonding is permissible. This may be observed among people from Middle Eastern
countries. Also, it may be observed that the mother, or grandmother, may place a red
ribbon on the baby.
⊹ A person on a liquid diet refuses to eat the gelatin.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition that prohibits the eating of pig
and/or animal products and gelatin is made from pig bones, unless specified as
“kosher”. Jews and Muslims who follow the kosher diet may reject this food.
61
⊹ A young patient refuses a blood transfusion and is supported by the family.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition that prohibits the use of blood. This
is especially seen when caring for Jehovah’s Witnesses, but other religions also prohibit
the use of blood.
⊹ A patient is given a supply of antibiotics in the emergency room to treat a respiratory infection
and leaves the medication behind.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition that rejects the use of Western
medications. The person may elect to use traditional medications and seek the services of
a traditional herbalist. This is observed among Hispanics and Asian Americans.
⊹ A person is acutely ill and does not respond to the questions being asked.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition that views the answering of direct
questions to be taboo. The given person may prefer to answer questions that are asked
indirectly and where metaphors are used as statements. This practice is found among
American Indians 62
⊹ A person who is terminally ill is found to have a card hidden under the pillow.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition that views the answering of direct
questions to be taboo. The given person may prefer to answer questions that are asked
indirectly and where metaphors are used as statements. This practice is found among
American Indians.
⊹ The family of a person who died refuses to leave the room.
The family of the recently decreased person may come from an ethnocultural tradition that
believes that the soul of the person must be protected and the body must be ritually cared
for by members of the family and/or religious community.
⊹ A patient who is 24-hours post-chest surgery does not request pain medication.
The person may come from an ethnocultural tradition that believe in “saving face” and
that to complain of pain is taboo. This belief is particularly common among Chinese
people.
63
Needless to say, even with these brief scenarios and
explanations there is the danger of stereotyping.
However, the situations are real – they occurred within
the scope of my own practice and experiences. When
situations such as these occur, the most important
aspect of care is to have the “cultural” antenna sharp
and to question the patient, the family, and/or
community people to determine the ethos of the
patient’s cultural beliefs and practices. In this way, a
proper way can be found to avoid harming the patient
and holding respect for the patient’s cultural traditions.
64
Selected
Culturalcare
3
terms
CulturalCare – A concept that describes professional health care that is
culturally sensitive, culturally appropriate, and culturally competent.
Culturally appropriate – implies that the health-care provider applies the
underlying background knowledge that must be possessed to provide a given
patient with the best possible health care
Culturally competent – implies that within the delivered care the health-care
provider understands and attends to the total context of the patient’s situations
including awareness of immigration, stress factors, and cultural differences.
Culturally sensitive – implies that the health-care providers possess some basic
knowledge of and constructive attitudes towards the diverse cultural groups found
in the setting in which they are practicing.
Emerging Majority – people of color-Black; Asian or Pacific Islander; American
Indian, Eskimo, or Aleut; and Hispanic origin, who are expected to comprise a
majority of the American population by the year 2020.
HEALTH – the balance of the person, both within one’s being–physical, mental,
and spiritual–and one in the outside environment–natural, familial, and
communal, and metaphysical. 66
HEALTH maintenance – the traditional beliefs and practices,
such as daily health-related activities, diet, exercise, rest, and
clothing, used to maintain HEALTH.
HEALTH protection – the traditional beliefs and practices
about what should be done on special occasions or on an
ongoing basis for HEALTH protection, such as food taboos
and wearing amulets.
HEALTH restoration – the traditional beliefs and practices
concerning the activities, such as the use of folk remedies and
healers, that must be used to restore HEALTH.
67
Sample Grid for Cultural Health Assessment
Physical Mental Spiritual
Maintain
HEALTH
Protect
HEALTH
Restore
HEALTH
68
Thank you for
listening! 69