Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Year 11 - A Christmas Carol HT1
Year 11 - A Christmas Carol HT1
Year 11 - A Christmas Carol HT1
Responsibility Dickens felt that every individual had a responsibility for those around him or her.
o Fred describes Christmas as a time when men and women ‘think of people below them as if they really were fellow-passengers to the grave, and not another race of creatures bound on
other journeys’.
o Marley’s Ghost succinctly conveys the message of the novella when he cries, ‘Mankind was my business’. This change of focus jolts us, as well as Scrooge, because we learn that the
proper ‘business’ of life is not about seeking financial reward but having concern for others.
o Scrooge learns to take responsibility for the poor, and in doing so redeems himself ‘as good a man, as the good old city knew’.
o Scrooge shows us the difference a wealthy individual can make, but Dickens also shows us that Fezziwig’s small contribution, ‘The happiness he gives, is quite as great as if it cost a
fortune’, can make a significance difference to an individual’s life.
Poverty The Cratchits are regarded as Dickens’ face of the poor in this novella:
o They are living on the edge as Bob Cratchit can only just afford to keep his family fed and sheltered. Tiny Tim’s poor health emphasises the harsh realities and consequences of living in
such poverty.
o Mrs Cratchit’s ribbons may be a luxury but they are also a symbol of her desperation to make her dress look new and respectable. She is ‘brave in ribbons’.
o The Cratchits are grateful for their Christmas meal, although we have to wonder if this is because they don’t have enough throughout the rest of the year ‘nobody said or thought it was
at all a small pudding for a large family. It would have been flat heresy to do so. Any Cratchit would have blushed to hint at such a thing’.
Dickens also shows us glimpses of poverty even deeper than that of the Cratchits:
o The charity collectors emphasise the desperation of the poor, they reveal that ‘Many thousands are in want of common necessaries’. Many of the poor ‘would rather die’ than go to the
Union Workhouses or the Treadmill.
o Dickens places Old Joe’ shop in a part of the city which ‘reeked with crime, with filth, and misery’. With this scene, he shows the corrupting nature of poverty as these thieves enjoy
showing what they have stolen to sell.
o Scrooge is appalled by the appearance of the children, Ignorance and Want. The children personify the dangerous consequences of allowing poverty to continue.
Scrooge’s refusal to give to charity highlights the selfishness of the higher classes and the injustice of wealth distribution in Victorian society.
Education Dickens emphasises the value of education through his presentation of the two children, Ignorance and Want:
o They are horrific in their appearance ‘Yellow, meagre, ragged, scowling, wolfish’.
o They serve to illustrate Dickens’ belief in the power of and need for education. We are told to ‘beware’ ignorance for he is ‘Doom’. This not only refers to the uncivilised and inadequate
lives the children will have as adults, but it also warns readers about the blind ignorance of the rich who do not take any responsibility for the children. The negligence of the higher
classes only contributed to the suffering of the poor.
o Dickens does not shy away from presenting the most graphic effects of ignorance and deprivation – he makes us think about the role of education in the fight against poverty. His chilling,
emotive language shows us how seriously he takes this issue.
The Supernatural A Christmas Carol is set in an ordinary location with ordinary characters. Having a convincing setting means that readers are more likely to accept an event as supernatural.
It also makes the supernatural seem even stranger by contrasting it with normal events.
o The narrator works hard to convince us that Scrooge’s partner, Marley, is dead. There can be no other explanation for his reappearance than that it is his ghost haunting
Scrooge.
o This theme does not just refer to Ghosts – Dickens also makes use of the supernatural to manipulate time and allow Scrooge to travel to his past, present and future and
back again.
o The use of supernatural characters and events creates a unique and interesting story. Being the first writer to associate Christmas with ghost stories enabled Dickens to
give his readers a new experience. The gothic characteristics also help to structure the story: each ghost teaches Scrooge an important and valuable lesson.
Family Dickens balances Scrooge’s isolation with vibrant vignettes that show us the positive benefits of a close and loving family life:
o The lonely young Scrooge is rescued by his sister and returns home.
o As an apprentice, Scrooge is part of Fezziwig’s Christmas party, along with countless locals. Through the description of the party, Dickens emphasises the impact small
actions can have.
o The Christmas celebrations of the Cratchits and Fred’s family show the benefits of sharing laughter and optimism. Despite their poverty, the Cratchit family are shown as
the model happy family.
o Bob’s ‘sudden declension in… high spirits’ when he thinks Martha can’t come home for Christmas shows us the need for families to be together at key times.
o The closeness the Cratchit family have supports them in dealing with the foreshadowed death of Tiny Tim in stave four.
o The transformed Scrooge revels in being part of his own and the Cratchit family.
Christmas The story of Scrooge takes place on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day and uses the ideas of generosity and compassion that we associate with Christmas to highlight the
transformation of the main character. We see Scrooge change from a miserly man, contrasting with the spirit of Christmas, to someone who is full of joy.
o The theme of the novella is clear from the title - A Christmas Carol - which refers to the traditional carols that are sung at Christmas time. The novella has an unusual
layout, using five staves rather than chapters. Each stave has a specific purpose, this enables Dickens to guide his readers through Scrooge’s transformation. We can clearly
understand how each Ghost affects Scrooge and how each lesson contributes to his final, joyful redemption. By reflecting the shape of a typical carol, Dickens can present
his moral tale of transformation whilst also emphasisng the delight and generosity of the season.
o As it does during the festive season, music has a significant presence in the novella. Music is central to a lot of the celebrations (from Fezziwig’s party to the men in the
solitary lighthouse) in the story and often provokes a powerful emotional response. Music symbolises the joy and unity of the season – something Scrooge eventually
learns to accept and appreciate. In addition, the “merry” sound of the bells in Stave 5 reflects Scrooge’s change and reinforces Christian values as Scrooge goes to church.
Scrooge’s nephew, Fed, embodies the spirit of Christmas; he celebrates the season wholeheartedly and appreciates how it brings the classes together. Fred reminds the reader
of the importance of compassion and forgiveness, he refuses to give up on his uncle and welcomes him with open arms at the end of the novella.