Monopoly and Imperfect Competition

 Monopoly and Imperfect Competition
1
Monopoly
 A monopoly firm is the only seller of a good or service with
no close substitutes
 Market in which the monopoly firm operates is called a monopoly
market
 Key concept is notion of substitutability (input production)
 Definition of monopoly firm or market may seem precise
 But in real world, definition is not always so clear-cut
 Because we all have different tastes and characteristics, we
can have different opinions about what is, and what is not, a
“close” substitute
 As a result, we can have different ideas about how broadly or how
narrowly we should define a market when trying to decide if it is a
monopoly
Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 2

Why Monopolies Exist
 Existence of a monopoly means that
something is causing other firms to stay out
of the market
 Rather than enter and compete with firm already
there
 What barrier prevents additional firms from
entering the market?
 Several possible answers
• Economies of scale
• Legal barriers
• Network externalities
Economies of Scale
 If economies of scale persist to the point where a
single firm is producing for entire market, the
market is a natural monopoly
 Market in which, due to economies of scale, one firm can
operate at lower average cost than can two or more firms
 Unless government intervenes, only one seller
would survive—market would naturally become a
monopoly
 Small local monopolies are often natural
monopolies
 Because they continue to enjoy economies of scale up to
point at which they are serving entire market

Figure 1: A Natural Monopoly
Dollars
15 A
B
12
LRATC
5 C
DMarket
300 350 Pieces of Clothing

per Week

Legal Barriers
 Sometimes public interest is best
served by having a single seller in a
market
 Many monopolies arise because of
legal barriers including
 Protection of intellectual property
 Government franchise

Protection of Intellectual Property
 The words you are reading right now are an example of intellectual
property, which includes literary, artistic and musical works, and
scientific inventions
 In dealing with intellectual property government strikes a compromise
 Allows creators of intellectual property to enjoy a monopoly and earn
economic profit, but only for a limited period of time
 Once time is up, other sellers are allowed to enter the market, and it is
hoped that competition among them will bring down prices
 Most important kinds of legal protection for intellectual property are
 Patents
• Temporary grant of monopoly rights over a new product or scientific discovery
 Copyrights
• Grant of exclusive rights to sell a literary, musical, or artistic work
 Copyrights and patents are often sold to another person or firm, but this
does not change monopoly status of the market, since there is still just
one seller

Government Franchise
 Large firms we usually think of as monopolies have
their monopoly status guaranteed through
government franchise
 Grant of exclusive rights over a product
 Barrier to entry is
 Any other firm that enters the market will be prosecuted
 Governments usually grant franchises when they
think market is a natural monopoly

Network Externalities
 Exist when an increase in network’s membership
increases its value to current and potential
members
 When network externalities are present, joining a
large network is more beneficial than joining a small
network
 Even if product in larger network is somewhat inferior to
product in smaller one
 In addition to advantages of joining a larger
network
 Advantage in not leaving it once you’ve joined
• Avoiding switching costs

Network Externalities
 All of this clearly applies to the market for computer
operating systems
 When you buy a computer already loaded with Microsoft Windows,
you benefit
• By having a large number of people with whom you can easily share
documents
• Huge number of computers everywhere you can easily operate
 You gain access to many more software programs, like Microsoft
Word, Excel, or Outlook, since many more programs are designed
for Windows than for the few alternatives
 You can save time by just calling knowledgeable friends or
coworkers
• Rather than attempting to contact technical support

Monopoly Goals And Constraints
 Goal of a monopoly—like that of any firm—is to
earn highest profit possible
 However, a monopolist faces constraints
 Constraint on monopoly’s cost
• For any level of output it might produce, total cost is determined
by
 Technology of production
 Price it must pay for its inputs
 Demand constraint
• Monopolist’s demand curve tells us maximum price monopolist
can charge to sell any given quantity of output
• And for any level of output it might produce, maximum price it
can charge is determined by market demand curve for its product

Monopoly Price or Output Decision
 Noncompetitive firms—such as monopolies—do not make
two separate decisions about price and quantity, but rather
one decision
 Once firm determines its output level, it has also determined its price
 When any firm—including a monopoly—faces a downward
sloping demand curve, marginal revenue is less than price
of output
 Therefore, marginal revenue curve will lie below demand curve
 Monopoly will produce at an output level where marginal
revenue is positive

Figure 2: Demand and Marginal
Revenue
Monthly $60
Price per
Subscriber 50 A
B
48
C
38
30
20 F
G
18
Demand
5,000 15,000 20,000 30,000

6,000 MR 21,000
Number of Subscribers

The Profit-Maximizing Output Level
 To maximize profit, the firm should produce
level of output where MC = MR and
 MC curve crosses MR curve from below
 For a monopoly, price and output are not
independent decisions
 But different ways of expressing the same
decision

Figure 3: Monopoly Price and Output
Determination
Monthly $60 MC
Price per
Subscriber
40 E
10,000 30,000
MR
Number of Subscribers
Profit And Loss
 A monopoly earns a profit whenever P > ATC
 Its total profit at best output level equals area of a
rectangle
• Height equal to distance between P and ATC
• Width equal to level of output
 A monopoly suffers a loss whenever P < ATC
 Its total loss at best output level equals area of a
rectangle
• Height equal to distance between ATC and P
• Width equal to level of output

Figure 4: Monopoly Profit and Loss
(a) (b)
Dollars Dollars ATC
MC ATC MC AVC
$50
E E
$40 40
32 Total Loss
Total
Profit
D D
10,000 Number of 10,000 Number of
MR Subscribers MR Subscribers

The Shut-Down Decision
 What if a monopoly suffers a loss in short-
run?
 Any firm should shut down if P < AVC at output
level where MR = MC
 If monopoly suddenly finds that P < AVC,
government will usually not allow it to shut
down,
 Instead use tax revenue to make up for firm’s
losses

Monopoly in the Long-Run
 In the short run, a monopoly may earn an economic
profit or suffer an economic loss
 But what about the long run?
 Important insights of previous chapter—perfectly
competitive firms cannot earn a profit in long-run
equilibrium
 However, monopolies may earn economic profit in
long-run
 A privately owned monopoly suffering an economic
loss in long-run will exit the industry
 Should not find privately owned monopolies suffering
economic losses in long-run

Comparing Monopoly to Perfect
Competition
 In perfect competition, economic profit is relentlessly
reduced to zero by entry of other firms
 In monopoly, economic profit can continue indefinitely
 But monopoly differs from perfect competition in another
way
 Can expect a monopoly market to have a higher price and lower
output than an otherwise similar perfectly competitive market
 By raising price and restricting output, new monopoly earns
economic profit
 Consumers lose in two ways
 Pay more for output they buy
 Due to higher prices they buy less output

Figure 5(a/b): Comparing Monopoly
and Perfect Competition
(a) Competitive Market (b) Competitive Firm
Price Dollars
per per 2. and each firm produces
Unit Unit 1,000 units, where P = MC.
S
MC ATC
E
$10 3. When monopoly $10 d
takes over, the old
market supply
curve . . .
D
Quantity of Quantity of
100,000 1,000
Output Output
1. In this competitive
market of 100 firms,
equilibrium price is $10
Figure 5(c): Comparing Monopoly and
Perfect Competition
(c) Monopoly
Price
per
Unit S = MC
F 4. becomes the monopoly's MC curve.

$15
E 5. The monopoly produces where MR = MC,
10
6. with a higher price and lower market

output than under perfect competition.
MR D
Quantity of
100,000 Output
60,000

Comparing Monopoly to Perfect
Competition
 Changeover from perfect competition to monopoly benefits
owners of monopoly and harms consumers of the product
 Important proviso concerning this result
• In comparing monopoly and perfect competition, price is higher and
output is lower under monopoly if all else is equal
 General conclusion
 Monopolization of a competitive industry leads to two opposing
effects
• For any given technology of production, monopolization leads to higher
prices and lower output
• Changes in technology of production made possible under monopoly
may lead to lower prices and higher output
 Ultimate effect on price and quantity depends on relative strengths of
two effects

The Decline of Monopoly?
 Past century was not kind to monopolies
 Today, monopolies face a different threat
 Relentless advance of technology & WTO
 The world of monopolies is changing rapidly
 But monopolies i nmany forms will be with us for
some time

Monopolistic Competition
 Imperfect competition refers to market structures between perfect
competition and monopoly
 In imperfectly competitive markets, there is more than one seller, but still too
few to create a perfectly competitive market
 In addition, imperfectly competitive markets often violate other conditions of
perfect competition, such as the requirement of a standardized product or
free entry and exit
 Monopolistic competition is a market sturcture with three fundamental
characteristics
 1. Many buyers and sellers
 2. Sellers offer a differentiated product
 3. Sellers can easily enter into or exit from the market
 Because it produces a differentiated product, a monopolistic competitor
faces a downward-sloping demand curve
 When it raises its price a modest amount, quantity demanded will decline
(but not all the way to zero)

Monopolistic Competition in the Short-
Run
 Individual monopolistic competitor behaves
very much like a monopoly
 Key difference is this
 While a monopoly is the only seller in its market,
a monopolistic competitor is one of many sellers
 When a monopolistic competitor raises its price,
its customers have one additional option
• Can buy similar good from some other firm

Figure 6: A Monopolistically
Competitive Firm in the Short Run
Dollars 1. Kafka services 250 homes
per month, where MC and
MR intersect . . .
A MC
$70 ATC
2. and charges
$70 per home.
d1
30
MR1 3. ATC at 250 units is less
4. Kafka's monthly than price, so profit per
profit–$10,000–is unit is positive.
the area of the
shaded rectangle.
250 Homes Serviced per Month

Monopolistic Competition in the Long-
Run
 Under monopolistic competition—in which there are no
barriers to entry and exit—the firm will not enjoy its profit for
long
 Entry will continue to occur, and demand curve will continue to shift
leftward
 Under monopolistic competition, firms can earn positive or
negative economic profit in short-run
 But in long-run, free entry and exit will ensure that each firm earns
zero economic profit just as under perfect competition
 In real world, monopolistic competitors often earn economic
profit or loss in the short-run
 But—given enough time—profits attract new entrants, and losses
result in an industry shakeout
• Until firms are earning zero economic profit

Figure 7: A Monopolistically
Competitive Firm in the Long Run
Dollars In the long run, profit attracts
entry, which shifts the firm's
demand curve leftward.
MC
ATC
E Entry continues until P = ATC

$40
at the best output level, and
The typical firm economic profit is zero. d1
produces where
its new MR MR1
crosses MC. MR2 d2
100 250 Homes Serviced

per Month

Nonprice Competition
 If monopolistic competitor wants to increase its output it can
cut its price
 Move along its demand curve
 Any action a firm takes to increase demand for its output—
other than cutting its price—is called nonprice competition
 Examples include better service, product guarantees, free home
delivery, more attractive packaging
 Nonprice competition is another reason why monopolistic
competitors earn zero economic profit in long-run
 All this nonprice competition is costly
 Must pay for advertising, for product guarantees, for better staff
training
 Costs must be included in each firm’s ATC curve, shifting it upward
 None of this changes conclusion that monopolistic
competitors will earn zero economic profit in long-run

Oligopoly
 When just a few large firms dominate a market
 So that actions of each one have an important impact on
the others
 Would be foolish for any one firm to ignore its
competitors’ reactions
 In such a market, each firm recognizes its strategic
interdependence with others
 An oligopoly is a market dominated by a small
number of strategically interdependent firms

Economies of Scale: Natural
Oligopolies
 When minimum efficient scale (MES) for a typical
firm is a relatively large percentage of market
 A large firm—supplying a large share of the market—will
have lower cost per unit than a small firm
• Since small firms can’t compete, only a few large firms survive
 Market becomes an oligopoly
• Tends to happen on its own unless there is government
intervention
 Such a market is often called a natural oligopoly—analogous to
natural monopoly

Reputation as a Barrier
 A new entrant may suffer just from being new
 Established oligopolists are likely to have favorable
reputations
 In some cases, where potential profits are great,
investors may decide it is worth the risk and accept
initial losses in order to enter industry
 In other industries, the initial losses may be too
great and probability of success too low for
investors to risk their money starting a new firm

Strategic Barriers
 Oligopoly firms often pursue strategies designed to
keep out potential competitors
 Maintain excess production capacity as a signal to a
potential entrant that they could easily saturate market
and leave new entrant with little or no revenue
 Make special deals with distributors to receive best shelf
space in retail stores
 Make long-term arrangements with customers to ensure
that their products are not displaced quickly by those of a
new entrant
 Spend large amounts on advertising to make it difficult for
a new entrant to differentiate its product

Legal Barriers
 Patents and copyrights—which can be
responsible for monopoly—can also create
oligopolies
 Like monopolies, oligopolies are not shy
about lobbying government to preserve their
market domination
 Government barriers can operate against
domestic entrants, too

Oligopoly Behavior
 Oligopoly presents the greatest challenge to
economists
 Essence of oligopoly is strategic interdependence
 Wherein each firm anticipates actions of its rivals when
making decisions
 In order to understand and predict behavior in
oligopoly markets
 Economists have had to modify the tools used to analyze
other market structures and to develop entirely new tools
as well
 One approach—game theory—has yielded rich
insights into oligopoly behavior

The Game Theory Approach
 Game theory
 An approach to modeling strategic interaction of
oligopolists in terms of moves and countermoves
 In all games—except those of pure chance, such
as roulette—a player’s strategy must take account
of the strategies followed by other players
 Game theory analyzes oligopoly decisions as if
they were games by
 Looking at the rules players must follow
 Payoffs they are trying to achieve
 Strategies they can use to achieve them

Simple Oligopoly Games
 Duopoly
 Oligopoly market with only two sellers
 Assume that Gus and Filip must make their
decisions independently
 Without knowing in advance what the other will do
 No matter what Filip does, Gus’s best move is to
charge a low price—his dominant strategy
 A similar analysis from Filip’s point of view, would tell us
that his dominant strategy is the same: a low price
 Equilibrium price in market is the low price

Fig. 4: A Duopoly Game
Gus’s Actions
Confess Don’t Confess
Gus’s profit Gus’s profit
= $25,000 = –$10,000
Confess Filip’s Filip’s
Profit = Profit =
$25,000 $75,000
Filip’s Actions
Gus’s profit Gus’s profit
= $75,000 = $50,000
Don’t Confess Filip’s Filip’s

Profit = Profit =
$–10,000 $50,000

Oligopoly Games in the Real World
 Will typically be more than two strategies
from which to choose
 Will usually be more than two players
 In some games, one or more players may
not have a dominant strategy
 When one player has a dominant strategy, we
can still predict the game’s outcome
• Whether the other has a dominant strategy or not

Cooperative Behavior in Oligopoly
 In real world, oligopolists will usually get
more than one chance to choose their prices
 The equilibrium in a game with repeated
plays may be very different from equilibrium
in a game played only once
 Often, firms will evolve some form of cooperation
in the long run

Explicit Collusion
 Simplest form of cooperation is explicit collusion
 Managers meet face-to-face to decide how to set prices
 Most extreme form of explicit collusion is creation of a cartel
 Group of firms that tries to maximize total profits of the group as a
whole
 If explicit collusion to raise prices is such a good thing for
oligopolists, why don’t they all do it?
 Usually illegal
 Penalties, if the oligopolists are caught, can be severe
 But oligopolists can collude in other, implicit ways

Tacit Collusion
 Any time firms cooperate without an explicit
agreement, they are engaging in tacit collusion
 Tit for tat
 A game-theoretic strategy of doing to another player this
period what he has done to you in previous period
 However, gentle reminder of tit-for-tat is not always
effective in maintaining tacit collusion
 Oligopolist will sometimes go further
• Attempting to punish a firm that threatens to destroy tacit
cooperation

Tacit Collusion
 Another form of tacit collusion is price leadership
 One firm—the price leader—sets its price and other
sellers copy that price
 With price leadership, there is no formal agreement
 Rather the decisions come about because firms realize—
without formal discussion—that system benefits all of
them
 Decisions include
• Choice of leader
• Criteria it uses to set its price
• Willingness of other firms to follow

The Limits to Collusion
 Oligopoly power—even with collusion—has
its limits
 Even colluding firms are constrained by market
demand curve
 Collusion—even when it is tacit—may be illegal
 Collusion is limited by powerful incentives to
cheat on any agreement

The Future of Oligopoly
 Some people think U.S. and other Western
economies are moving toward oligopoly as
dominant market structure
 In 1932, two economists—Adolf Berle and Gardiner
Means—noted trend toward big business
• Predicted the 200 largest U.S. firms would control nation’s entire
economy by 1970
 Unless something were done to stop it
 Prediction has not come true
 Today, there are hundreds and thousands of ongoing
businesses in United States

Antitrust Legislation and Enforcement
 Antitrust enforcement has focused on three types of actions
 Preventing collusive agreements among firms
• Such as price-fixing agreements
 Breaking up or limiting activities of large firms—oligopolists and
monopolists—whose market dominance harms consumers
 Preventing mergers that would lead to harmful market domination
 Managers of other firms considering anticompetitive moves
have to think long and hard about consequences of acts that
might violate antitrust laws
 While thrust of these policies is to preserve competition
 Type of competition preserved—and zeal with which policies are
applied—can shift

The Globalization of Markets
 By enlarging markets from national ones to global ones,
international trade can increase the number of firms in a
market
 Decreasing market dominance by a few, and increasing competition
 Although oligopolists often try to prevent it, they face
increasingly stiff competition from foreign producers
 Entry of U.S. producers has helped to increase competition
in foreign markets for movies, television shows, clothing,
household cleaning products, and prepared foods
 While consumers in each nation may have access to more
firms, these may be larger and more powerful firms
 Creating greater likelihood of strategic interaction and danger of
collusion
Technological Change
 Technological change works to increase competition by
creating new substitute goods
 Can reduce barriers to entry in much the same way that
globalization does
 By increasing size of market
 Technology—the internet—has enabled residents in many
smaller towns to choose among a dozen or more online
sellers of the same merchandize
 Trend can also be seen as encouraging oligopoly
 Result could be strategic interaction, or collusion, among large
national players
 Finally, some technologies actually increase MES of typical
firm
 Thereby encouraging formation of oligopolies

Figure 9(a): Advertising in Monopolistic
Competition
1.Before advertising, long-run 2. In the short run, the first firms to
economic profit is zero. advertise earn economic profit.
Dollars 3. But in the long run, imitation

B and entry bring economic
$120
C profit back to zero.
100
ATCads
ATCno ads
A
60
4. Advertising dads
can lead to a
higher price dall advertise
in the long dno ads
run, as in this
panel . . . 1,000 6,000 Bottles of Perfume
2,000 per Month

Figure 9(a): Advertising in Monopolistic
Competition
Dollars dall advertise 5. or to a lower price

B in the long run, as
$120
in this panel.
A
60 C ATCads
50 ATCno ads
dno ads dads
1,000 6,000 Bottles of Perfume

2,000 per Month
Using the Theory: Advertising in
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
 Perfect competitors never advertise and
monopolies advertise relatively little
 But advertising is almost always found under
monopolistic competition and very often in oligopoly
 Why?
 All monopolistic competitors, and many oligopolists,
produce differentiated products
 Since other firms will take advantage of opportunity
to advertise, any firm that doesn’t advertise will be
lost in shuffle

Using the Theory: Advertising and Market
Equilibrium Under Monopolistic Competition
 A monopolistic competitor advertises for two reasons
 To shift its demand curve rightward (greater quantity demanded at
each price)
 To make demand for its output less elastic
• So it can raise price and suffer a smaller decrease in quantity demanded
 Can summarize impact of advertising as illustrated in panel
(a)
 Since each firm must pay costs of advertising, and more competitors
have entered the market, Narcissus and its competitors are each
earning normal economic profit—just as they were originally
 Advertising has raised the price from $60 to $100 in long-
run
 But this is not the only possible result

Using the Theory: Advertising and Market
Equilibrium Under Monopolistic Competition
 Because you and I and everyone else is buying
more perfume
 Each producer can operate closer to capacity output, with
lower costs per unit
 In long-run, entry will force each firm to pass cost savings
on to us
 Analysis suggests the following conclusion
 Under monopolistic competition, advertising may
increase size of market, so that more units are sold
• But in long-run, each firm earns zero economic profit, just as it
would if no firm were advertising
• Price to consumer, however, may either rise or fall

Advertising and Collusion in Oligopoly
 Oligopolists have a strong incentive to engage in tacit
collusion
 But in some cases can use a simple game theory model to show that
collusion is almost certainly taking place
 Take airline industry as an example
 In theory, any airline should be able to claim superior safety
 Yet no airline has ever run an advertisement with information about
its security policies or attacked those of a competitor
• Airlines are playing against each other repeatedly and reach the kind of
cooperative equilibrium we discussed earlier

Figure 10: An Advertising Game
American's Actions
Run Safety Ads Don't Run Ads
American American
earns low earns very
profit low profit
Run Safety Ads
United United
earns low earns high
profit profit
United's Actions American American
earns high earns
profit medium
Don't Run Ads United
profit
United earns
earns very medium
low profit profit

The Four Market Structures: A
Postscript
 Different market structures
 Perfect competition
 Monopoly
 Monopolistic competition
 Oligopoly
 Market structure models help us organize
and understand apparent chaos of real-world
markets

Monopoly and Imperfect Competition

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

You might also like

Monopoly and Imperfect Competition

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Monopoly and Imperfect Competition

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

 Monopoly and Imperfect Competition

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 2

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 4

300 350 Pieces of Clothing

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 5

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 6

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 7

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 8

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 9

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 10

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 11

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 12

5,000 15,000 20,000 30,000

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 13

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 14

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 16

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 17

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 18

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 19

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 20

F 4. becomes the monopoly's MC curve.

6. with a higher price and lower market

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 22

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 23

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 24

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 25

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 26

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 27

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 28

E Entry continues until P = ATC

100 250 Homes Serviced

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 29

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 30

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 31

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 32

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 33

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 34

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 35

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 36

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 37

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 38

Don’t Confess Filip’s Filip’s

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 39

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 40

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 41

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 42

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 43

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 44

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 45

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 46

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 47

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 49

Dollars 3. But in the long run, imitation

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 50

Dollars dall advertise 5. or to a lower price

dno ads dads

1,000 6,000 Bottles of Perfume

Lieberman & Hall; Introduction to Economics, 2005 52