Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ethics 2
Ethics 2
Ethics 2
Chapter II:
Utilitarianism
Objectives
⚬Discuss the basic principles of utilitarian ethics;
⚬Distinguish between two utilitarian models: the quantitative
model of Jeremy Bentham and the qualitative model of John
Stuart Mill; and
⚬Apply utilitarianism in understanding and evaluating local
and international scenarios.
THE PRINCIPLE OF UTILITY
Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832)
• an advocate of economic freedom and women‘s rights
• Bentham believes that our actions are governed by two “sovereign master“
which he calls pleasure and pain
• the principle of utility refers to the motivation of our actions as guided by our
avoidance of pain and our desire for pleasure. On the other hand, the principle
also refers to pleasure as good if, and only if, they produce more happiness than
unhappiness.
• Bentham equates happiness with pleasure
John Stuart Mill (1806–1873)
• supports Benthams‘s theory of utility
• He reiterates moral good as happiness and, consequently, happiness as
pleasure. Mill clarifies that what makes people happy is intended pleasure and
what makes us unhappy is the privation of pleasure. The things that produce
happiness and pleasure are good; whereas, those that produce unhappiness and
pain are bad.
• Contrary to Bentham, Mill argues that quality is more preferable than quantity.
An excessive quantity of what is otherwise pleasurable might result in pain.
Whereas eating the right amount of food can be pleasurable, excessive eating
may not be.
• For Bentham and Mill, the pursuit for pleasure and the
avoidance of pain are not only important principles— they are
in fact the only principle in assessing an action’s morality.
• In determining the moral preferability of actions, Bentham
provides a framework for evaluating pleasure and pain
commonly called felicific calculus, a common currency
framework that calculates the pleasure that some actions can
produce.
The felicific calculus is an algorithm formulated or calculating the degree or amount of pleasure that a specific
action is likely to cause
To be included in this calculation are several variables (or vectors), which Bentham called
"circumstances". These are:
Intensity: How strong is the pleasure?
Duration: How long will the pleasure last?
Certainty or uncertainty: How likely or unlikely is it that the pleasure will occur?
Propinquity or remoteness: How soon will the pleasure occur?
Fecundity: The probability that the action will be followed by sensations of the same kind.
Purity: The probability that it will not be followed by sensations of the opposite kind.
Extent: How many people will be affected?
THE PRINCIPLE OF THE GREATEST
NUMBER
• Utilitarianism is not only about our individual pleasures, regardless of how high,
intellectual, or in other ways noble it is, but it is also about the pleasure of the
2.Rehabilitation. Punishment might make "bad people" into "better" ones. For the utilitarian, all that
"bad person" can mean is "person who's likely to cause unwanted things (like suffering)". So,
utilitarianism could recommend punishment that changes someone such that they are less likely to
cause bad things.
3. Security/Incapacitation. Perhaps there are people who are irredeemable causers of bad things. If so,
imprisoning them might maximize welfare by limiting their opportunities to cause harm and therefore
the benefit lies within protecting society.
JUSTICE AND MORAL RIGHTS
Justice- is the principle that people receive that which they deserve
-respect for rights directed toward society’s pursuit for the greatest
number.
Rights- are related to the interests that serve general happiness.
Ex. The right to due process, right to free speech or religion
-
SYMBOLS OF JUSTICEBalance Scales: These represent impartiality and the obligation of
the law (through its representatives) to weigh the evidence
presented to the court.