Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CN - Session 4 and 5 Catalan Nationalism Up To Transition
CN - Session 4 and 5 Catalan Nationalism Up To Transition
Transition to Democracy
► IESBarcelona
► FALL 2007 PROGRAM
► Politics
► Society
► Economy
2
Political Integration of Catalonia
into Spain (partial)
► Last remnants of institutional autonomy removed
after Bourbon takeover and Nueva Planta decrees,
1716.
movements.
Industrial Revolution
Catalonia
► During the nineteenth century, Catalonia
moves away from traditional manufacturing
to modern industry.
► Slow and gradual until 1840, but after the
First Carlist War, growth became
spectacular.
► The Catalan textile industry was most
important.
► Early factory conditions are poor, migration
from countryside is socially traumatic.
4
Integration into a frail system
5
The beginning of nationalism
► Industrial revolution is on in Catalonia,
positive growth, poor conditions,
dependent on central government
assistance. State is only minimally
functional. What are your interests,
concerns at this time?
► Cultural revivalists
► Progressive federalists
► Anti-Bourbon traditionalists
► Industrial Bourgeoisie
7
The Renaixença
► Early 19th century romantic revivalist movement in
Catalan language and culture, akin to the Galician
Renaixensa or the Occitan Félibrige movements.
► But
how to ‘use’ the history moving forward
was the site of controversy…
11
Catalan bourgeoisie
► The most critical group in Catalonia -
They had bought into Spain as part of
an imperial project.
► Were not inherently Catalan
nationalists.
► Much of the Catalan middle class still
depended on trade with Cuba and the
Philippines, and on protectionist trade
measures.
12
Bourgeoisie interests
► The bourgeoisie in Catalonia was the
only one to have interests in industry
in Spain.
► Because of growth, there was a
growing contrast between industrial
Catalonia and Spain, which was more
agricultural.
► They pressed for protectionist
economic measures that would reduce
the competition of products from
13
Carlism in Catalonia
► Carlism was a social and political movement
that formed in support of Carlos María Isidro,
the brother of Fernando VII. Reaction by
traditional rural society against the secular,
centralist and modernizing efforts of liberal
and republican regimes.
► The movement drew all those nostalgic for
absolutism, as well as farmers and peasants
badly affected by liberal measures.
► The Catalan Carlists, of whom there were
many in the inland areas and in the
Pyrenees, defended a reactionary
traditionalism with return to local-self rule
under the king. 14
Carlism in Catalonia II
► There were three Carlist wars on Catalan
soil: the Seven Years' War of 1833-40, the
War of the Matiners (one of the warring
factions) of 1846-49 and the third Carlist
War (1872-76).
► In
Catalonia, Carlists were supported by the
Church, because they supported traditional
values, including staunch Catholicism
15
Catalan Federalism
► Federalism in Spain was a ‘Catalan project’ –
administration needed to be reformed and
decentralized. Wanted to ‘fix’ Spain
► Catalan bourgeoisie would regenerate Spain
from a politically resurgent Catalonia – they
would show Spain the way, imposing their
model on ‘backward’ Spain.
► They believed that federalism would
regenerate all the Spanish regions. But it
was REPUBLICAN and LAIQUE.
► Francesc Pi i Maragall – Las nacionalidades
(1877)
16
Catalanisme – Broad Church but
intellectual by nature
►3 main sources – all believed in autonomy
for Catalonia. What do you see as the
difference?
lead to modernisation.
Enric Prat de la Riba
► Leaderof the Lliga - Important figure in
Catalan nationalism - he went farther than
most. Declares Catalonia a nation as part of
a Spanish state but….
21
‘Bases de Manresa’
► In 1892, it was published by the Unió
Catalanista, and meant to create a big-tent
Catalan nationalist grouping. Headed by Prat
de la Riba, and included members of Lliga
and many others, they defined Catalonia in
truly nationalist terms.
► Prat de la Riba defines Spain as simply a
political entity, the state, while Catalonia was
the nation to which they were proud
members.
► They called for powers in taxation, coinage,
legislative and executive authority, civil,
penal and mercantile legislation, regional
army and police units, education, and the
return of the more traditional political 22
The Reaction from Madrid
► Closure of Newspapers
► Prevention of meeting
► Closing of clubs and societies
► These policies legitimized the
nationalists.
25
Political Catalanism I
► The loss of the Cuban and Philippine
colonial markets finally pushed the
Catalan industrial middle class into
political action.
► The economic effects consolidate
affection among workers for various
combinations of socialism, anarchism,
republicanism and federalism.
26
Two Basic Principles of
Catalanisme
► Rejection of a centralized Spanish
state, and the pushing for a
decentralized one. Convert other
regions and nationalities to their
decentralized caused.
► The hecho diferencial (fet diferencial).
The acceptance that Catalonia has
specific characteristics, different from
those of Spain - language, private law,
culture, common history, and general
cultural characteristics. 27
But they are different
‘nationalisms’
► The peasant nationalism –
consequence of modernization and
failure of Spanish state to adapt -
unable to establish universal
education, offer national symbols or
rituals.
► Textile magnate – reacting to loss of
empire, assisting Catalan business.
This Catalan nationalism still about
how to ‘fix’ Spain. 28
Magazine ‘Cu-cut!’ uses the
army as butt of a joke
29
Central Government’s Reaction:
The Law of Jurisdictions
► In1906 the Law of Jurisdictions was
passed, which stated that offenses
against the army or any national symbols
would be prosecuted in a military
tribunal.
34
► Itwas the first Spanish city to
industrialize, and thus the first to
experience the social upheaval that
had occurred earlier in other parts of
Europe.
38
Setmana Tragica (the Tragic
Week) 1909
► Barcelona revolts - the week of July 26 to
August 1, a largely spontaneous uprising
which lead to five days of shooting, looting,
murders, bombs and barricades.
► Hundreds of demonstrators were killed in
the streets while protesting against the
military service system and factory closures
► anarchists and radical republicans burned
21 churches and 40 convents (not
uncommon for anti-Catholic ideologues in
Spain for past 100 years)
39
Catalanisme arrives to the
Popular Classes
president.
Mancommunitat encourages
further Catalanisme -
noucentisme
► Pompeu Fabra – standardizes Catalan
(1913-1932)
► Institut d’Estudis Catalans (1907)
► Catalan National Library (1914)
► Increased focus on education
► But central government still
influential…
44
By way of comparison -
Bourbon’s Social Institutions
Regulating the Arts and Sciences:
45
Summary of late Restoration
Monarchy (1902-1923)
► Between 1902-23, 34 different
governments
► All attempts to reform corrupt system
fail
► High class tension over Morocco and
industrial relations
► In 1923, due to this instability, and
following longstanding tradition,
Miguel Primo de Rivera pushes another
pronunciamiento. Initially strongly 46
supported.
Primo Dictatorship 1923-30
► In
order to solve the ‘problem of the
nation’, the military Captain General of
Catalonia, Miguel Primo de Rivera
(1870-1930), proclaimed himself
dictator of Spain in 1923, with the
authorization of the king.
47
Primo Dictatorship 1923-30
► Establishes a Military Directory
(although two years later he becomes
a government of civil politicians) and
suspends the civil Constitution.
► The Dictatorship welcomed with
enthusiasm by almost everybody
(including the King, and the Lliga
Regionalista in CAT).
► It was also initially successful in
restoring public order.
48
Primo Dictatorship 1923-30
► Public work projects: railroads,
highways, marshes, ports and
reforestation, thus ending the jobs
crisis.
► Also the Banco de Crédito Industrial
and the Banco de Crédito Local were
established, stimulated the small
businesses and savings.
49
Primo Dictatorship 1923-30
► The system of collection of taxes
improves
► The national budget is balanced.
► Simultaneously, general Primo de
Rivera manages to pacify the north of
Morocco after two years military
(1925-1927).
50
Primo Dictatorship 1923-30
► BUT - All this is coming on top of a
culturally homogenizing, restrictive
and authoritarian government.
► Country needed reforms, but he relied
on Church and Military.
► Despite the advances of the
Dictatorship, the intellectuals, liberal
and the revolutionaries complained
the persistent suppression of
constitutional guarantees
51
Effects in Catalonia
► Catalan flag and language and banned
► Catalanist organizations dissolved,
meetings prohibited
► Centralization of Spanish curriculum
► Dissolves the Mancommunitat (1925)
► Changed street names
► Banned language’s use on shops
► Becomes a model for Franco later on…
52
Primo Dictatorship 1923-30
► The Great Depression of 1929
ended the prosperity of the Directory
(now public neither happy with social
reforms or economy)
► King Alfonso XIII, fearing the future of
the monarchy, rescinds his support of
the dictator and, subsequently, Primo
de Rivera is forced to resign his
position in 1930.
53
Pact of San Sebastian
► The Pact of San Sebastián (1930)
united the liberal politicians
(republican moderate) and to the
revolutionary extremists (socialist and
anarchists) to overthrow the Bourbon
monarchy and to exile King Alfonso
XIII.
54
Second Republic (1931-1936)
► In the elections of April of 1931,
although the monarchic parties obtained a
great majority in the rural countryside, the
coalition of republican and socialist parties
won in the cities and Catalonia.
► The new government declares a Spanish
Federal Republic (1931-1936)
► In order to avoid a civil war, the King leaves
the country on the April 14th 1931 for
France. The King dies later in Rome in 1941.
55
The Second Republic (1931-
9)
► Estado Integral - establishes a state
structure somewhere between unitary
and federal models
62
63
Catalonia during the Civil
War
► During the Civil War, the Government of the
Generalitat, which remained loyal to the
Republic, organised the citizens' defence.
When Franco's troops entered Barcelona,
Lluis Companys (President of the
Generalitat) went into exile in France.
► On 23 December 1938, Franco's army began
its final offensive against Catalonia. The
republican army withdrew to avoid a
disorderly retreat.
64
The End of the War
► Thousands of civilians made their way to the
French border. On 26 January 1939, Franco's
troops entered Barcelona. On 9 February,
Franco's troops reached Pertús (the border
town w/ France). On 1 April 1939, the war
came to an end.
67
Economic and Social
Repression
► The post-war years were characterized by
adversity - rationing, the black market, fuel
restrictions and industrial stagnation - that
arose from the regime's policy of self-
sufficiency and interventionism.
► Attempts were made to break up the
economic fabric of Catalonia, and Catalan
companies were discriminated against in the
supply of raw materials and energy.
► Borders closed economically - autarky
68
Repercussions II
► At home, the Francoist army of occupation
and the leaders of the "Nuevo Estado" (New
State) began to seek revenge. The
repression was extremely severe. All the
Catalan symbols were harshly suppressed
while a new set of fascistic imperial symbols
was imposed.
► Some 150,000 of the Catalans who
remained in Catalonia were imprisoned in
concentration camps; 4,000 of them were
shot. 69
Cultural Repression
72
Economy under Franco
► Important year 1959 – Franco shuffles
his cabinet, gets rid of the Falangists
and Carlists, and brings in Opus Dei
technocrats. Economy had been
faltering and might have threatened
the regime if he continued.
75
Growth and Catalonia
► Catalonia went through unprecedented
economic growth. The consolidation of
industrial diversification turned Catalan
industry into the principal provider of goods
for the Spanish market.
► This expansion took place without any type
of urban planning nor the slightest degree of
democratic control over the economy. Urban
chaos and the lack of a basic infrastructure
were common in the large cities and the
tourist areas on the coast. 76
Immigration in Catalonia
77
Catalan culture late Franco
period
► Modest revival of both language and culture
► Language restrictions eased
► Exiled intellectuals allowed to return
► Cultural gatherings allowed
► More sensitive subjects such as history
taught clandestinely
► Jordi Pujol – Catalan activist, ‘fer pais’.
► All of this is tightly controlled, and censored,
but not ‘erased’, as it had been in the first
years… 78
The Assembly of Catalonia
► The Assembly of Catalonia (Assamblea de
Catalunya) was set up on 7 November 1971 and, as
an anti-Franco platform, it led popular
demonstrations right through to the early years of
the democratic transition.
► Its program included liberty, amnesty, the Statute
of Self-government as the first step towards self-
determination, and co-ordination with the
democratic struggle taking place elsewhere in
Spain.
► The assembly was made up of political parties,
trade unions, professional associations, local and
district democratic assemblies, residents'
associations and a large number of intellectuals and
individuals with no particular affiliations.
79
Inclusive Catalan nationalism
► Twomost powerful political forces late-
Franco period
Communists (PSUC)
Catholic Nationalists (led by Jordi Pujol)