ADB PPT New

Uttar Pradesh Power Distribution
Rehabilitation Project
Funded by ADB
1
Table of Contents
S.No Title Page No
1 Feeder Segregation Work 5
2 Summary of Agriculture Load 6
3 District Wise Proposed Work 7
4 Important Dates of tenders 9
5 Financial & Technical Parameters 11
6 T No: 77 (G B Nagar Zone) 12
(a) Summary of feeders and project Cost 13
(b) Comparsion of L1 Bidder wrt to other Bidders 14
(c) L1 price bid comparison with DPR & L2 Bidder 15
(d) Activity Wise Cost Breakup 16
(e) Reasonalibility of Rate 17-18
(f) Comparsion of L1 Bidder wrt to DPR/Respo/Market rate 19-26
(g) Activity wise comparison of L1 bidder (supply to supply/incidental to incidental/istallation to installation) 27
(h) Comparison of supply rate of L1 bidder wrt. Stock issue rate 20-21, 19-20, 18-19 28
7 T No: 78 (Ghaziabad Zone) 29
8 T No: 79 (Bulandshahr Zone) 46
9 T No: 80 (Meerut Zone) 63
2
S.No Title Page No
10 T No: 81 (Saharanpur Zone) 80
11 T No: 82 (Moradabad Zone) 97
12 Comparsion of all tenders at a Glance 114
(a) Comparison of L1 Bidder with original DPR & New DPR 115-116
(b) Comparison of L1 Bidder with other Bidders 117-119
(c) ADB Tender zone wise cost detail with and without GST 120
(d) Cost of L1 Bidder in all tenders with and without GST 121
(e) Comparison of lowest package value with M/s L&T quoted/calculated package value 122-123
(f) Activitywise L1 bidder cost to cost comparison with estimated rate of DPR 124
(g) Activitywise breakup of L1 bidder 125
(h) Activity Wise Comparsion of L1 Bidder of T-No 77 & 80 126
(i) Activity Wise Comparsion of L1 Bidder of T-No 77 & 82 127
(j) Comparision of Supply rates of L1 Bidders 128-130
(k) Terms and Conditions 131-132
(l) Abnormally Low Bids 133-134
3
Total Feeders Considered
for
Separation under ADB
4
Feeder Segregation Work in PVVNL, Meerut
Work carried out in DDUGJY (New) Work Proposed in ADB Project
Total Mix Total Mix feeders Total New 11 KV Existing Mix New 11 KV
S.No Zone Name of District Feeders in taken for Feeder Total Domestic
Total Feeders Total Ag Feeders Feeders Feeders Total DPR
PVVNL segregation constructed Feeders after
after segregation after segregation proposed for proposed for Cost (In Cr.)
under DDUGJY under DDUGJY segregation
segregation construction
new new
1 2 3 4 5 6 7=5+6 8 9=7-8 10=4-5 11 12
1 G.B.Nagar G.B.Nagar 45 4 4 8 4 4 41 20 45.78
2 Ghaziabad Ghaziabad 94 57 46 103 40 63 37 21 44.52
3 Meerut 240 167 102 269 167 102 73 43 85.06
4 Meerut Baghpat 146 127 67 194 126 68 19 10 21.35
Total 386 294 169 463 293 170 92 53 106.41
5 Bulandshahr 305 96 57 153 96 57 209 117 252.88
6 Bulandshahr Hapur 120 92 55 147 90 57 28 18 37.52
Total 425 188 112 300 186 114 237 135 290.4
7 Moradabad 109 54 35 89 52 37 55 33 90.75
8 Amroha 137 104 71 175 104 71 33 17 37.51
9 Bijnor 188 104 58 162 104 58 84 46 100.51
Moradabad
10 Sambhal 67 30 27 57 30 27 37 21 45.86
11 Rampur 75 35 37 72 35 37 40 23 54.24
Total 576 327 228 555 325 230 249 140 328.87
12 Saharanpur 260 131 75 206 131 75 129 67 147.28
13 Muzaffarnagar 177 129 88 217 126 91 48 32 67.64
Saharanpur
14 Shamli 83 55 42 97 55 42 28 16 33.6
Total 520 315 205 520 312 208 205 115 248.52
Total DISCOM 2046 1185 764 1949 1160 789 861 484 1064.5 5
Pashchimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited, Meerut
Summary for district wise agricultural load after proposed Feeder Segregation under ADB Loan
Shifted Load on Balance load on
No. of feeders Present Load on existing PTW to be on Ag
No. of Proposed New Proposed Domestic Agricultural Feeders
S.No. Name of District No of Substation considered for Feeders Feeder
Domestic feeders Feeders
Segregation (MVA) (Nos)
(MVA) (MVA)
1 Meerut 33 73 43 123.1 37.9 85.2 14162

2 Baghpat 7 19 10 31.2 10.4 20.7 3439
Meerut Zone 40 92 53 154.2 48.3 105.9 17601
3 Ghaziabad 13 37 21 62.5 19.9 42.6 7135
Ghaziabad Zone 13 37 21 62.5 19.9 42.6 7135
4 GB Nagar 11 41 20 87.1 27.1 59.9 9973
G.B.Nagar Zone 11 41 20 87.1 27.1 59.9 9973
5 Hapur 14 28 18 52.1 16.7 35.4 5879
6 Bulandshahr 62 209 117 355.1 113.4 241.8 39611
Bulandshahr Zone 76 237 135 407.2 130.0 277.1 45490
7 Moradabad 18 55 33 104.3 33.6 70.7 11734
8 JP Nagar 9 33 17 86.3 25.5 60.8 10094
9 Bijnor 33 84 46 186.0 59.2 126.8 21393
10 Sambhal 13 37 21 93.3 28.3 65.0 10782
11 Rampur 11 40 23 102.9 31.7 71.2 11816
Moradabad Zone 84 249 140 572.8 178.3 394.5 65819
12 Saharanpur 41 129 67 240.1 80.9 159.2 26447
13 Muzaffarnagar 21 48 32 126.0 40.5 85.5 14192
14 Shamli 13 28 16 67.9 21.0 47.0 7796
Saharanpur Zone 75 205 115 434.0 142.3 291.7 48435
Total 299 861 484 1717.9 545.95 1171.9 194453
6
Summary for district wise proposed work for Feeder Segregation under ADB Project
Detail of Addl.
11 KV line LT Line
DT Required
No. of feeders No. of Proposed Rabbit
No of Shifted
S.No. Name of District considered for New Domestic PTW to be Proposed Conductor 3X95+1X7 No. of
Substation Present Load on Load on 3X50+1X35+1
Segregation feeders on Ag Feeder 11 KV VCB 0+1X16 Additional DT
existing Feeder Proposed X16 AB Cable
Feeder length (Nos.) Length AB Cable required
(Amp) Feeder (Km)
(Nos) (Ckt. Km) (Ckt. (Km) (Nos.)
(Amp)
Kms)
1 Meerut 33 73 43 6461 1987 14162 535 43 40 21 24 534
2 Baghpat 7 19 10 1635 548 3439 130 10 10 6 6 130
Meerut Zone 40 92 53 8096 2535 17601 665 53 50 26 29 664
3 Ghaziabad 13 37 21 3282 1044 7135 265 21 20 10 10 295
Ghaziabad Zone 13 37 21 3282 1044 7135 265 21 20 10 10 295
4 GB Nagar 11 41 20 4570 1424 9973 283 20 20 11 10 300
G.B.Nagar Zone 11 41 20 4570 1424 9973 283 20 20 11 10 300
5 Hapur 14 28 18 2732 874 5879 210 18 19 9 9 265
6 Bulandshahr 62 209 117 18640 5951 39611 1591 117 119 58 59 1672
Bulandshahr Zone 76 237 135 21372 6825 45490 1801 135 138 67 68 1937
7 Moradabad 18 55 33 5475 1766 11734 431 33 407 17 17 492
8 JP Nagar 9 33 17 4530 1137 10094 227 17 17 9 9 254
9 Bijnor 33 84 46 9765 3107 21393 620 46 47 23 23 683
10 Sambhal 13 37 21 4895 1485 10782 276 21 20 10 10 294
11 Rampur 11 40 23 5250 1663 11816 303 23 23 12 11 326
Moradabad Zone 84 249 140 29915 9158 65819 1857 140 514 71 70 2049
12 Saharanpur 41 129 67 12602 4244 26447 888 67 68 34 34 992
13 Muzaffarnagar 21 48 32 6615 2126 14192 421 32 33 16 16 448
14 Shamli 13 28 16 3565 1100 7796 175 16 16 8 8 231
Saharanpur Zone 75 205 115 22782 7470 48435 1484 115 118 57 59 1671
Total 299 861 484 90017 28456 194453 6354 484 859 242 245 6916
7
Important Dates
for
Processing of Tenders
8
Important Dates for processing of Tenders
NIT Issued :-07.02.2019 Clarification on points raised by the bidder uploaded on e-tender portal :-17.08.2019
Bid documents uploaded on e-Tender portal :- 31.05.2019 Bid extension date (Techno commercial) :-
12.03.2019,22.04.2019,10.06.2019,15.07.2019,21.08.2019,12.09.2019,16.09.2019
Pre-Bid meeting held :-12.06.2019 Last Date of Bid submission :-16.09.2019
Internal
Evaluation Meeting with Meeting with TBER
Technical Bid Committee
Sent to Revised
ADB for TBER Price Bid
FBER
FBER Sent to Approval
Tender No. TBER
opening date submit ADB at UPPCL ADB at PVVNL Approval (All to ADB sent Approved by opening ADB for
Six Tenders) ADB Approval received
ADB
from
report
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
PVVNL-MT/MM/ADB/77/18-19 16.09.2019 24.10.2019 10/11.12.2019 27.12.2019 13.02.2020 05.05.2020 28.05.2020 16.10.2020 29.06.2020
PVVNL-MT/MM/ADB/78/18-19 16.09.2019 24.10.2019 10/11.12.2019 27.12.2019 13.02.2020 05.05.2020 28.05.2020 10.06.2020 29.06.2020
PVVNL-MT/MM/ADB/79/18-19 16.09.2019 24.10.2019 10/11.12.2019 27.12.2019 13.02.2020 10.06.2020 16.07.2020 20.07.2020 04.08.2020 Awaited
PVVNL-MT/MM/ADB/80/18-19 16.09.2019 24.10.2019 10/11.12.2019 27.12.2019 13.02.2020 10.06.2020 06.08.2020 10.08.2020 14.08.2020 19.08.2020
PVVNL-MT/MM/ADB/81/18-19 16.09.2019 24.10.2019 10/11.12.2019 27.12.2019 13.02.2020 10.06.2020 14.08.2020 17.08.2020 26.08.2020 31.08.2020
PVVNL-MT/MM/ADB/82/18-19 16.09.2019 24.10.2019 10/11.12.2019 27.12.2019 13.02.2020 17.06.2020 15.07.2020 20.07.2020 04.08.2020 Awaited
9
Required Financial & Technical Parameters
10
Required Financial & Technical Parameters
Required
77 (GB Nagar 78 (Ghaziabad 79 80 81 82
Financial/Technical
Zone) Zone) (Bulandshahr Zone) (Meerut Zone) (Saharanpur Zone) (Moradabad Zone)
Parameters
Estimate Cost Rs. 45.76 Cr. Rs. 44.50 Cr. Rs. 290.25 Cr. Rs. 106.32 Cr. Rs. 248.38 Cr. Rs. 328.71 Cr.
MAAT
Rs. 61.01 Cr. Rs. 59.33 Cr. Rs. 387.00 Cr. Rs. 141.76 Cr. Rs. 331.16 Cr. Rs. 438.28 Cr.
(133% of est. cost.)
Financial Resource
Rs. 7.63 Cr. Rs. 7.42 Cr. Rs. 48.38 Cr. Rs. 17.72 Cr. Rs. 41.40 Cr. Rs. 54.79 Cr.
(16.66% of est. cost.)
Rs. 45.76 Cr. (100% Rs. 44.50 Cr. Rs. 145.13 Cr. Rs. 106.32 Cr. Rs. 124.19 Cr. Rs. 164.36 Cr.
Exp.-1 Single contract Value
of est. cost) Cr. (100% of est. cost) Cr. (50% of est. cost) Cr. (100% of est. cost) Cr. (50% of est. cost) Cr. (50% of est. cost)
Exp.-2 Total no. of Transformer 210 nos. (70% of 207 nos. (70% of 969 nos. (50% of tender 465 nos. (70% of 836 nos. (50% of 1025 nos. (50% of
installed. tender Qty) tender Qty) Qty) tender Qty) tender Qty) tender Qty)
Exp.-2 Total Line Construction 227 km. 213 km. 1037.35 km. 539 km. 859 km. 1255 km.
installed. (70% of tender Qty) (70% of tender Qty) (50% of tender Qty) (70% of tender Qty) (50% of tender Qty) (50% of tender Qty)
11
Agriculture Feeder Segregation Work
in
G.B.Nagar Zone
(Tender No- PVVNL-MM/MT/ADB/77/18-19)
12
Summary of Feeders & Project Cost ( G.B.Nagar)
Total DPR Cost Total DPR Cost
Shifted load on
Present Load Balance Load PTW to be on Including GST excluding GST
No. of Feeder No. of Proposed proposed
on existing on Agriculture Agriculture (As per stock (As per stock
Zone No. of Substation considered for New Domestic domestic
feeders feeders feeder issue rate 2018- issue rate 2018-
segregation Feeders. feeders
(MVA) (MVA) (No) 19) 19)
(MVA)
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
GB Nagar 11 41 20 87.10 27.10 60.00 9973 45.78 38.78
Techno Evaluated Package

Quoted Package Value
Sl.No Bidder Name commercial Bid Rank Value (Excluding Bid Rank
(Excluding GST) (Rs.)
qualified GST) (Rs.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1 M/s Sterling And Wilson Private Limited. Yes 273133287.21 L1 266133869.61 L1
2 M/s Jakson Limited. Yes 283742325.80 L2 283742325.80 L2
3 M/s S.J.Transformers. Yes 343524623.43 L3 324720098.40 L3
4 M/s Tata Projects Limited. Yes 356177848.40 L4 349116748.40 L4
M/s Feedback Energy Distribution
5 Yes 393243456.20 L5 384845796.20 L5
Company Ltd.
6 M/s Raj Shyama Constructions Pvt. Ltd. Yes 675537232.51 L6 668432279.70 L6
Price bid not opened(firm has installed only 49 nos. transformers against required 210 nos.
7 M/s Raj Corporation Ltd., Mainpuri No transformers which were in successful operation for more than one year at the time of bid
opening)
8 M/s V.M. Infra projects No Price bid not opened (Tender cost &EMD not deposited)
13
Comparison of lowest Package Value w.r.t. package value quoted by other participating bidders
Tender No. 77 (Gautam Buddha Nagar Zone)
% Difference in lowest bidder

Sl.No Bidder Name Bid Rank Evaluated Package Value (Excluding GST) (Rs.) package value w.r.t. other
bidders
1 2 3 4 5
1 M/s Sterling And Wilson Private Limited. L1 266133869.61 —
2 M/s Jakson Limited. L2 283742325.80 -6.21
3 M/s S.J.Transformers. L3 324720098.40 -18.04
4 M/s Tata Projects Limited. L4 349116748.40 -23.77
M/s Feedback Energy Distribution

5 L5 384845796.20 -30.85
Company Ltd.
6 M/s Raj Shyama Constructions Pvt. Ltd. L6 668432279.70 -60.19
From the above tables it may be observed that quoted value of L-1 bidder is quite competitive in comparison to
quoted value of other participating bidders.
14
L-1 Price Bid Comparison with DPR
Estimated Value as per
Estimated Value as per DPR
L-1 Package value DPR (ex GST) without
(ex GST) Inc. 3% Conti., 1.5%
Name of the firm (Excluding GST) % Variation 3% Conti., 1.5% T&P, % Variation
T&P, 21% turnkey
(Rs. Cr.) 21% turnkey
(Rs. Cr.)
(Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6
38.78 30.73
M/s Sterling& (-)31.37% (-)13.42%
(Stock issue rate 18-19) (Stock issue rate 18-19)
Wilson Pvt. Ltd., 26.61
West Mumbai 38.41 30.44
(-)30.72% (-)12.58%
Price Bid Comparison L-1 bidder with L-2 bidder
Package Estimated Value as Estimated Value as per

value per DPR (ex GST) DPR (ex GST) without %
Bid %
Name of the firm (Excluding Inc. 3% Conti., 1.5% 3% Conti., 1.5% T&P, Variatio
Rank Variation
GST) T&P, 21% turnkey 21% turnkey n
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
M/s Sterling& Wilson Pvt.
L-1 26.61 (-)31.37% (-)13.42%
Ltd., West Mumbai 38.78 30.73
M/s Jakson Limited. L-2 28.37 (-)26.84% (-)7.68%
Rs. 1.76 Cr.
Variation between L-1 & L-2
6.61%
15
Item-wise break-up of costs Evaluated vs. Estimated for lowest bidder – [T-77] NOIDA ZONE
Variation Per
Sl. Evaluated Cost
Evaluated per Estimated Unit From
Item Description UoM Quantity
unit rate per unit rate Estimates
No. Supply Incidental Installation Total %age
1 100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer S/S Nos 120 28908180 616916.4 1701418.8 31226515.2 260221 329209 -20.96 
2 63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer Nos 120 21611170.8 465074.4 1701418.8 23777664 198147 288018 -31.20 
3 25KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer S/S Nos 60 7981287 170666.4 810199.2 8962152.6 149369 239442 -37.62 
4 11 KV Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with rabbit conductor km 271 97701378.92 1655033.63 29844553.64 129200966.2 476756 501846 -5.00 
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with AB Cable (3*120

5 km 6 5690918.46 80,284.67 688668.06 6459871.19 1076645 845780 27.30 
sq mm)
11 KV New UG Line with 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE cable
6 km 6 17091375.9 3695448 7072006.5 27858830.4 4643138 6744793 -31.16 
double circuit
11 KV line at Railway Crossing with 3x185 sq. mm. XLPE
7 Nos 2 1016284.88 2248389.84 308551.64 3573226.36 1786613 2016577 -11.40 
cable double circuit 150 m
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation Nos 20 10350481 67,448.20 805477.2 11223406.4 561170 561471 -0.05 
3 phase 4 wire LT Line ACSR Rabbit conductor on 8.5 mtr

9 km 20 5330888.85 89,827.68 1458357.4 6879073.93 343954 334325 2.88 
PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm) on 8.5 mtr
10 km 11 5445803.89 78,803.75 1540322.52 7064930.16 642266 653302 -1.69 
PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) on 8.5 mtr

11 km 10 3613259.24 51,932.50 1400293.2 5065484.94 506548 486116 4.20 
PCC Pole
12 Extension of substation control room building Nos 6 0 0 4841748.24 4841748.24 806958 570905 41.35 
Total (Rs.) 204741028.9 9219825.47 52173015.2 266133869.6
16
Reasonability of Rate (G.B.Nagar-77)
1. Cost of DPR is Rs. 38.78 Cr. (excluding GST but including 3% contingency, 1.5% T&P, & 21% turnkey
charges).
L-1 Package Value is Rs. 26.61 Cr.
L-1 Package Value is (–)31.38 % Lower w.r.t. Cost of DPR.

2. Loading of 3%, 1.5% & 21% has been done in the DPR as per the provisions made in RESSPO cost
schedules for the purpose of capitalization. Hence to find actual difference from the DPR cost, comparison
of cost of work (excluding 3% contingency, 1.5% T&P, & 21% turnkey charges in the DPR cost) has been
done which is bifurcated in supply and erection + F&I as under :-
DPR Amount L-1 Bidder % Variation w.r.t.

Sl.No. Type of Cost
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.) DPR
1 Cost of supply of items whose SIR available 13.50 14.74 9.19
2 Cost of supply of items whose Respo Rate available 5.45 3.96 (-)27.34
3 Cost of supply of items which are taken as per Market Rate 2.51 1.77 (-)29.48
Total Cost of Supply of items 21.46 20.47 (-)4.61
F & I + Erection + other incidental Charges 8.93 5.66 (-)36.61
Cost of Civil Work (Control Room Extension) 0.34 0.48 41.17
Total Cost of Project 30.73 26.61 (-)13.41
17
3. L-1 Package Value is (–) 13.41% lower than the DPR cost (excluding 3%,1.5% & 21%).
4. Package value of L-1 Bidder M/s Sterling & Wilson Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai seems to be reasonable in view of following reasons :-
(i) The package has attracted as many as 8 bidders; of whom 6 were found to be technically responsive. The price discovery has thus
happened through a highly competitive bidding process.
(ii) 5 out of the 6 bidders have quoted below PVVNLs estimate.
(iii) M/s L & T would be L-1 Bidder in the Tender and their package value would be -13.15% lower in comparison to package value of
sterling & Wilson.
(iv) The L-2 ( M/s Jackson) Bidder have also quoted rates which are very close to the L-1 Bidder’s rate (26.61 Cr./ 28.37 Cr.).
(v) Following new provisions have been made in the tender clauses by ADB:-
(a) Interest free mobilization advance to be given to the TKC;
(b) Interest is to be paid in case of delay of payment to TKCs beyond 45 days.
18
Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited,Meerut
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t DPR/Resspo/ Market Rate 2018-19 (T. NO 77)
Quoted Supply
Stock Rate by L1 Bidder Total Cost of Supply
Sl. DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder
Item Issue Unit Quantity M/s Sterling Items % diff erence
No.
Item Wilson. (T. no. 77)
Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 8.5 Mtr. Long PCC Pole SI No. 8013 2977.48 2721.00 23858547.24 21803373.00 9.43
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs. Long SI No. 542 4678.90 4671.00 2535963.80 2531682.00 0.17
3 Stone Pad (300x300x75 mm) RES No. 8717 85.07 140.00 741555.19 1220380.00 -39.24
4 ACSR Rabbit Conductor SI Km. 919.4 42240.52 39669.00 38835934.09 36471678.60 6.48
5 11 KV Composite Polymer Pin Insulator with Nut and washers SI No. 19821 200.39 196.00 3971930.19 3884916.00 2.24
6 11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45KN c/w Disc fittings SI No. 6504 164.61 264.00 1070623.44 1717056.00 -37.65
7 11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type 70 KN c/w Disc fittings SI No. 963 214.70 552.00 206756.10 531576.00 -61.11
8 Aluminium jointing sleeves No. 893 81.65 170.00 72913.45 151810.00 -51.97
9 PG Clamps for ACSR Rabbit/Weasel RES No. 8190 40.83 257.00 334397.70 2104830.00 -84.11
Stay Set ( Galvanised) with 50x8 mm stay clamp, stay
insulator, anchor plate (200x200x6), nut bolts, turn
buckles,1.8 m long 16 mm dia. Solid GS Stay Rod, & 7/3.15 2027.00 12090871.52 17353147.00 -30.32
10 RES No. 8561 1412.32
mm dia. GI stranded wire complete as per technical
specification, approved drawings, schedules and scope of
work.
MS earthing rod of 20x2500 mm. With accessories and 6 838.00 4585496.40 6713218.00 -31.69
11 RES No. 8011 572.40
SWG earthing wire for pole earthing
12 11 kV SMC Danger board with clamp with N&B RES No. 7203 190.52 461.00 1372315.56 3320583.00 -58.67
13 SMC Number Plate with clamp, bolts & nuts No. 670 190.52 121.00 127648.40 81070.00 57.45
14 G.I Barbed wire RES Kg 7645 83.20 162.00 636064.00 1238490.00 -48.64
15 Aluminium binding wire-6 SWG RES Kg 2871 316.26 247.00 907982.46 709137.00 28.04
Guarding angle 75x75x6 mm,1600 mm long with holding 609.00 1112255.20 660765.00 68.33
16 No. 1085 1025.12
clamp, N&B etc. (16 Nos / km of guarding)
G.I. Wire No. 6 SWG (330 Kg / km of guarding - along the 60.73 1709821.08 1358773.02 25.84
17 SI Kg 22374 76.42
span - )
G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG (110 Kg / km of guarding - across the 60.26 569940.36 449419.08 26.82
18 SI Kg 7458 76.42
span )
19 Turn Buckle (8 nos / km of guarding) No. 542 163.30 66.00 88508.60 35772.00 147.42
20 Eye Bolt (8 nos / km of guarding) No. 1627 68.04 48.00 110701.08 78096.00 41.75
21 GI Binding Wire 16 SWG (1 Kg / km of guarding) Kg 68 76.42 92.50 5196.56 6290.00 -17.38
22 Single support 13 Mtr. STP (SP-72) SI No. 54 22830.80 20798.00 1232863.20 1123092.00 9.77
23 11KV ' V' type Cross arm 100x50x6 mm, M.S. Channel SI No. 596 1179.38 535.00 702910.48 318860.00 120.44
24 X-Arm holding Clamp (Back Clamp) with bolts & nuts RES No. 7100 137.12 304.00 973552.00 2158400.00 -54.89
25 GI. guarding Angle Iron 75x75x6 mm 3010 mm long No. 54 1812.64 2134.00 97882.56 115236.00 -15.06
26 `F' Bracket RES No. 6829 307.94 265.00 2102922.26 1809685.00 16.20
27 Turn buckle No. 270 163.30 66.00 44091.00 17820.00 147.42
28 G.I. Wire 6 SWG along the span (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 1134 76.42 60.73 86660.28 68867.82 25.84
29 G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG across the span (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 756 76.42 60.26 57773.52 45556.56 26.82
30 G.I. Wire No. 16 SWG for binding Kg. 81 76.42 92.50 6190.02 7492.50 -17.38
Armour rod with ferrules for ACSR Dog/Raccoon Helical 253.00 33153.30 20493.00 61.78
31 Set 81 409.30
Performed
32 Red Oxide paint RES Ltrs 324 128.29 160.00 41565.96 51840.00 -19.82
33 Aluminium Paint RES Ltrs 162 283.58 319.00 45939.96 51678.00 -11.10
34 11KV `V' type Cross arm 65x65x6 mm, M.S. Angle SI No. 4607 1304.86 535.00 6011490.02 2464745.00 143.90
Top channel 100x50 mm 2240 mm (7.9 kg/M) with clamp, 823.00 1857281.28 908592.00 104.41
35 No. 1104 1682.32
nuts & bolts.
19
Quoted Supply
No.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
36 GI Channel 100x50x6 - 1300 mm No. 271 980.83 478.00 265804.93 129538.00 105.19
GI Angle Iron 65x65x6 mm,2700 mm long bracing with 2735.00 1865542.32 2964740.00 -37.08
37 No. 1084 1720.98
4 clamp
38 È' Bracket RES No. 1686 136.43 421.00 230020.98 709806.00 -67.59
11 KV 3x120 sq. mm AB Cable (with bare messenger 654000.00 4657500.54 4120200.00 13.04
39 SI Km. 6.3 739285.80
wire)
40 HT S uspension Clamp No. 150 217.73 450.00 32659.50 67500.00 -51.62
41 Channel 125x65x6mm (500 mm long) with back clamp No. 150 625.55 500.00 93832.50 75000.00 25.11
42 Bracing angle 65x65x6,450 mm No. 150 213.66 250.00 32049.00 37500.00 -14.54
43 Pole Clamps Pair 1140 228.62 155.00 260626.80 176700.00 47.50
Heat S hrinkable 1 ph. termination kit outdoor for 11 kV 1100.00 136331.28 79200.00 72.14
44 No. 72 1893.49
3x120 S q. mm. AB cable
45 Mid S pan Jointing S leeves (120 sq. mm) No. 24 285.78 140.90 6858.72 3381.60 102.82
46 S traight through jointing kit (all size) No. 6 5904.42 5500.00 35426.52 33000.00 7.35
47 Alluminium jointing sleeves No. 6 81.65 170.00 489.90 1020.00 -51.97
48 GI Nut and Bolts (all S izes for HT ABC line) Kg. 60 122.79 76.00 7367.40 4560.00 61.57
11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Insulated cable, 3x185 sq. 891.00 15475500.00 13365000.00 15.79
49 SI Mtr. 15000 1031.70
mm
Heat S hrinkable jointing / termination kits outdoor for 7680.00 356573.44 1136640.00 -68.63
50 No. 148 2409.28
11 kV 3x185 S q. mm. XLPE Cable
51 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 384 1858.50 800.00 713664.00 307200.00 132.31
HDPE pipe 160 mm Dia. for Cable Laying at Road 3449.00 1023155.20 4690640.00 -78.19
52 Mtr. 1360 752.32
Crossing, etc (for laying by HDD Method)
53 Cable Route Marker No. 64 478.75 1050.00 30640.00 67200.00 -54.40
54 S .T. P. IS 410 S P-55 11 Mtr. long. SI No. 108 15268.94 15049.00 1649045.52 1625292.00 1.46
Top channel 125x65 mm 2240 mm (10.7 kg/M) with 823.00 790120.42 274882.00 187.44
55 RES No. 334 2365.63
clamp, nuts & bolts.
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type 70 KN c/w Disc 552.00 21899.40 56304.00 -61.11
56 SI No. 102 214.70
fittings
57 P. G. Clamp for Dog/Raccoon RES No. 204 108.87 257.00 22209.48 52428.00 -57.64
58 GI Channel 125x65x2028 mm long No. 74 2072.40 1300.00 153357.60 96200.00 59.42
59 Holding clamps for channel with N&B RES Set 1336 401.45 259.00 536337.20 346024.00 55.00
60 11 kV Lightning Arrestor No. 1062 526.90 3960.00 559567.80 4205520.00 -86.69
61 GI S trip 25x3 mm for earthing Mtr. 6540 84.37 150.00 551779.80 981000.00 -43.75
11 KV Outgoing VCB indoor type with CTR 400/200/5A
62 350 MVA (Compatible with existing VCB at 33/11 KV SI No. 20 337582.85 296127.00 6751657.00 5922540.00 14.00
S ub-station )
Rearrangement for connecting New 11 KV
63 S witchgear with existing 11 KV S witchgears (Adopter No. 20 47261.60 40000.00 945232.00 800000.00 18.15
Panel)
Heat S hrinkable jointing kit suitable for 11 KV 19326.00 40991.60 386520.00 -89.39
64 No. 20 2049.58
XLPE 3x185 sq. mm cable size (indoor)
11KV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45 KN with 264.00 158025.60 253440.00 -37.65
65 SI No. 960 164.61
fittings
Holding clamps for top channel & Fuse set etc. with 259.00 951901.20 549080.00 73.36
66 RES No. 2120 449.01
bolts & nuts
67 11 KV TPMO RES No. 320 6804.21 18292.00 2177347.20 5853440.00 -62.80
68 11 kV Fuse S et RES No. 320 3266.02 7028.00 1045126.40 2248960.00 -53.53
MS earthing rod of 20x2500 mm. With accessories and 838.00 34344.00 50280.00 -31.69
69 RES No. 60 572.40
6 S WG earthing wire for pole earthing
70 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 60 438.05 396.00 26283.00 23760.00 10.62
20
Quoted Supply
No.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
71 LT Clamp with N & B for PCC Pole with Neutral RES No. 1600 120.43 304.00 192688.00 486400.00 -60.38
72 LT S hakle Insulator 100x115 mm RES No. 1600 38.65 36.00 61840.00 57600.00 7.36
73 Bolts and nuts for shackle insulators RES Kg. 600 122.79 196.00 73674.00 117600.00 -37.35
74 Loop Guard complete, 3-Phase RES No. 800 13.75 46.00 11000.00 36800.00 -70.11
75 Earth wire clamp Kg. 120 133.74 336.00 16048.80 40320.00 -60.20
76 Dead End (Insulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 420 285.78 399.30 120027.60 167706.00 -28.43
77 S uspension (Insulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 420 272.17 266.20 114311.40 111804.00 2.24
95/50 sq. mm - 70/35 sq. mm PG Clamp (For
78 line to line to line jumpering & energizing DB No. 630 108.87 133.10 68588.10 83853.00 -18.20
neutral)
LT Insulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50 sq. mm -
79 50-35 sq. mm size for energizing distribution No. 1890 89.82 199.65 169759.80 377338.50 -55.01
kiosk/box
LT Insulation Piercing connectors (16 sq. mm -16 sq. 121.00 56586.60 76230.00 -25.77
80 No. 630 89.82
mm) suitable for street light connection
81 Mid span jointing sleeves (95 sq. mm) No. 44 285.78 121.00 12574.32 5324.00 136.18
LT S MC distribution boxes 3 phase on the LT Poles
82 including all clamps & material required for mounting No. 420 1156.72 2420.00 485822.40 1016400.00 -52.20
connections & sealing
83 Insulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 sq. mm SI Km. 11.6 264680.92 250194.00 3070298.67 2902250.40 5.79
84 On/Off swith for street light connections No. 420 1367.85 605.00 574497.00 254100.00 126.09
1x35 mm2 XLPE/PVC insulated AL. cable for 67.00 184128.00 281400.00 -34.57
85 Mtr. 4200 43.84
energising the distribution boxes/kiosks.
2x16 mm2 XLPE/PVC insulated Al. cable for energising 40.00 0.00 0.00 101.58
86 Mtr. 0 80.63
the street light
88 Insulated ABC of 3x50+1x35+1x16 sq. mm SI Km. 10.5 138448.48 138727.00 1453709.04 1456633.50 -0.20
11/0.44 kV 100 KVA Tr ansformer (Four S tar Rating, 136710.00 17718154.80 16405200.00 8.00
89 SI No. 120 147651.29
Level-II)
90 GI Channel 100x50x6, 2028 mm (for Dropper Fuse set) No. 900 1530.09 748.00 1377081.00 673200.00 104.56
GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp for 1778.00 1150086.00 1066800.00 7.81
91 No. 600 1916.81
T/F base
92 GI Channel 125x65x6, 1300 mm (Te e-off) No. 300 1328.46 478.00 398538.00 143400.00 177.92
93 Clamp with nuts & bolts for 1300 mm long MS Channel RES No. 300 200.72 259.00 60216.00 77700.00 -22.50
S MC Distribution box having 200 A, 4 Pole ,MCCB for 3 14641.00 3600786.00 1756920.00 104.95
94 RES No. 120 30006.55
ph, 100 KVA Tr ansformer
Chemical Pipe Earthing (80 mm dia, 3 m long Pipe) as 3500.00 1940262.00 2100000.00 -7.61
95 No. 600 3233.77
per specification
96 LT PVC 3.5 x150/70 sqmm Cable RES Mtr. 2400 545.65 409.00 1309560.00 981600.00 33.41
97 ACS R Weasel conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 7500 25.49 23.98 191175.00 179850.00 6.30
98 Al. crimping lugs 150 sq.mm. No. 1920 27.36 75.00 52531.20 144000.00 -63.52
Extra for Al. tape , binding wire, jointing sleeves, PG 250.00 205176.00 75000.00 173.57
100 ls 300 683.92
clamps etc.
11/0.44 kV 63 KVA Tr ansformer (Four S tar Rating, 104596.00 11610698.40 12551520.00 -7.50
101 SI No. 120 96755.82
Level-II)
S MC Distribution box having 150 A, 4 Pole ,MCCB for 3 14641.00 3099452.40 1756920.00 76.41
102 RES No. 120 25828.77
103 LT PVC 3.5 x70/35 sqmm Cable RES Mtr. 3600 241.61 409.00 869796.00 1472400.00 -40.93
11/0.44 kV 25 KVA Tr ansformer (Four S tar Rating, 56780.00 3776334.60 3406800.00 10.85
105 SI No. 60 62938.91
Level-II)
S MC Distribution box having 70 A, 4 Pole ,MCCB for 3 14641.00 700561.20 878460.00 -20.25
106 RES No. 60 11676.02
TOTA L 204690232.04 214557584.58
TOTA L (Cr.) 20.47 21.46
21
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t Resspo Rate 2018-19 (T. NO 77)
Quoted Supply
Stock Rate by L1 Bidder
Sl. DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder Cost of Supply Items
Item Issue Unit Quantity M/s Sterling % diff erence
No.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
2 PG Clamps for ACSR Rabbit/Weasel RES No. 8190 40.83 257.00 334397.70 2104830.00 -84.11
Stay Set ( Galvanised) with 50x8 mm stay
clamp, stay insulator, anchor plate (200x200x6),
nut bolts, turn buckles,1.8 m long 16 mm dia.
3 Solid GS Stay Rod, & 7/3.15 mm dia. GI RES No. 8561 1412.32 2027.00 12090871.52 17353147.00 -30.32
stranded wire complete as per technical
specification, approved drawings, schedules and
scope of work.
MS earthing rod of 20x2500 mm. With
4 accessories and 6 SWG earthing wire for pole RES No. 8011 572.40 838.00 4585496.40 6713218.00 -31.69
earthing
X-Arm holding Clamp (Back Clamp) with bolts & 304.00 973552.00 2158400.00 -54.89
8 RES No. 7100 137.12
nuts
9 `F' Bracket RES No. 6829 307.94 265.00 2102922.26 1809685.00 16.20
12 È' Bracket RES No. 1686 136.43 421.00 230020.98 709806.00 -67.59
Top channel 125x65 mm 2240 mm (10.7 kg/M) 823.00 790120.42 274882.00 187.44
13 RES No. 334 2365.63
with clamp, nuts & bolts.
14 P. G. Clamp for Dog/Raccoon RES No. 204 108.87 257.00 22209.48 52428.00 -57.64
15 Holding clamps for channel with N&B RES Set 1336 401.45 259.00 536337.20 346024.00 55.00
Holding clamps for top channel & Fuse set etc. 259.00 951901.20 549080.00 73.36
16 RES No. 2120 449.01
with bolts & nuts
17 11 KV TPMO RES No. 320 6804.21 18292.00 2177347.20 5853440.00 -62.80
18 11 kV Fuse Set RES No. 320 3266.02 7028.00 1045126.40 2248960.00 -53.53
19 accessories and 6 SWG earthing wire for pole RES No. 60 572.40 838.00 34344.00 50280.00 -31.69
earthing
21 LT Shakle Insulator 100x115 mm RES No. 1600 38.65 36.00 61840.00 57600.00 7.36
23 Loop Guard complete, 3-Phase RES No. 800 13.75 46.00 11000.00 36800.00 -70.11
Clamp with nuts & bolts for 1300 mm long MS 259.00 60216.00 77700.00 -22.50
24 RES No. 300 200.72
Channel
SMC Distribution box having 200 A, 4 Pole 14641.00 3600786.00 1756920.00 104.95
25 RES No. 120 30006.55
,MCCB for 3 ph, 100 KVA Tr ansformer
26 LT PVC 3.5 x150/70 sqmm Cable RES Mtr. 2400 545.65 409.00 1309560.00 981600.00 33.41
SMC Distribution box having 150 A, 4 Pole 14641.00 3099452.40 1756920.00 76.41
27 RES No. 120 25828.77
,MCCB for 3 ph, 63 KVA Tr ansformer
SMC Distribution box having 70 A, 4 Pole ,MCCB 14641.00 700561.20 878460.00 -20.25
29 RES No. 60 11676.02
for 3 ph, 25 KVA Tr ansformer
39599643.49 54438688.00
TOTA L
TOTA L (Cr.) 3.96 5.44
22
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t Stock Issue Rate 2018-19 (T. NO 77)
Quoted Supply
Item Issue Unit Quantity M/s Sterling % diff erence
No.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs. Long SI No. 542 4678.90 4671.00 2535963.80 2531682.00 0.17
11 KV Composite Polymer Pin Insulator with Nut 196.00 3971930.19 3884916.00 2.24
4 SI No. 19821 200.39
and washers
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45KN 264.00 1070623.44 1717056.00 -37.65
5 SI No. 6504 164.61
c/w Disc fittings
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type 70 KN 552.00 206756.10 531576.00 -61.11
6 SI No. 963 214.70
c/w Disc fittings
G.I. Wire No. 6 SWG (330 Kg / km of guarding - 60.73 1709821.08 1358773.02 25.84
7 SI Kg 22374 76.42
along the span - )
G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG (110 Kg / km of guarding - 60.26 569940.36 449419.08 26.82
8 SI Kg 7458 76.42
across the span )
11KV ' V' type Cross arm 100x50x6 mm, M.S. 535.00 702910.48 318860.00 120.44
10 SI No. 596 1179.38
Channel
G.I. Wire 6 SWG along the span (For 50 Mtr. 60.73 86660.28 68867.82 25.84
11 SI Kg. 1134 76.42
line)
G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG across the span (For 50 60.26 57773.52 45556.56 26.82
12 SI Kg. 756 76.42
Mtr. line)
11KV `V' type Cross arm 65x65x6 mm, M.S. 535.00 6011490.02 2464745.00 143.90
13 SI No. 4607 1304.86
Angle
11 KV 3x120 sq. mm AB Cable (with bare 654000.00 4657500.54 4120200.00 13.04
14 SI Km. 6.3 739285.80
messenger wire)
11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Insulated cable, 891.00 15475500.00 13365000.00 15.79
15 SI Mtr. 15000 1031.70
3x185 sq. mm
16 S.T. P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. SI No. 108 15268.94 15049.00 1649045.52 1625292.00 1.46
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type 70 KN 552.00 21899.40 56304.00 -61.11
17 SI No. 102 214.70
c/w Disc fittings
11 KV Outgoing VCB indoor type with CTR
18 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with existing SI No. 20 337582.85 296127.00 6751657.00 5922540.00 14.00
VCB at 33/11 KV Sub-station )
11KV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45 KN 264.00 158025.60 253440.00 -37.65
19 SI No. 960 164.61
with fittings
20 Insulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 sq. mm SI Km. 11.6 264680.92 250194.00 3070298.67 2902250.40 5.79
11/0.44 kV 100 KVA Transformer (Four Star 136710.00 17718154.80 16405200.00 8.00
22 SI No. 120 147651.29
Rating, Level-II)
23 ACSR Weasel conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 7500 25.49 23.98 191175.00 179850.00 6.30
11/0.44 kV 63 KVA Transformer (Four Star 104596.00 11610698.40 12551520.00 -7.50
24 SI No. 120 96755.82
Rating, Level-II)
11/0.44 kV 25 KVA Transformer (Four Star 56780.00 3776334.60 3406800.00 10.85
25 SI No. 60 62938.91
Rating, Level-II)
TOTA L 147385212.37 135014624.98
TOTA L (Cr.) 14.74 13.50 23
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t Market Rate 2018-19 (T. NO 77)
Quoted Supply
Item Issue Unit Quantity M/s Sterling % difference
No.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Guarding angle 75x75x6 mm,1600 mm long with 609.00 1112255.20 660765.00 68.33
3 No. 1085 1025.12
holding clamp, N&B etc. (16 Nos / km of guarding)
8 Turn buckle No. 270 163.30 66.00 44091.00 17820.00 147.42
Armour rod with ferrules for ACSR Dog/Raccoon Helical 253.00 33153.30 20493.00 61.78
10 Set 81 409.30
Performed
Top channel 100x50 mm 2240 mm (7.9 kg/M) with 823.00 1857281.28 908592.00 104.41
11 No. 1104 1682.32
clamp, nuts & bolts.
GI Angle Iron 65x65x6 mm,2700 mm long bracing with 2735.00 1865542.32 2964740.00 -37.08
13 No. 1084 1720.98
4 clamp
14 HT Suspension Clamp No. 150 217.73 450.00 32659.50 67500.00 -51.62
17 Pole Clamps Pair 1140 228.62 155.00 260626.80 176700.00 47.50
Heat Shrinkable 1 ph. termination kit outdoor for 11 kV 1100.00 136331.28 79200.00 72.14
18 No. 72 1893.49
3x120 Sq. mm. AB cable
19 Mid Span Jointing Sleeves (120 sq. mm) No. 24 285.78 140.90 6858.72 3381.60 102.82
20 Straight through jointing kit (all size) No. 6 5904.42 5500.00 35426.52 33000.00 7.35
22 GI Nut and Bolts (all Sizes for HT ABC line) Kg. 60 122.79 76.00 7367.40 4560.00 61.57
Heat Shrinkable jointing / termination kits outdoor for 7680.00 356573.44 1136640.00 -68.63
23 No. 148 2409.28
11 kV 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE Cable
24 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 384 1858.50 800.00 713664.00 307200.00 132.31
HDPE pipe 160 mm Dia. for Cable Laying at Road 3449.00 1023155.20 4690640.00 -78.19
25 Mtr. 1360 752.32
Crossing, etc (for laying by HDD Method)
27 GI Channel 125x65x2028 mm long No. 74 2072.40 1300.00 153357.60 96200.00 59.42 24
Quoted Supply Rate by L1
Bidder M/s Sterling DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder Total DPR Cost Resspo Rate
Stock Issue Wilson. (T. no. 77)
Sl. No. Item Unit Quantity % difference
Item
29 GI Strip 25x3 mm for earthing Mtr. 6540 84.37 150.00 551779.80 981000.00 -43.75
Rearrangement for connecting New 11 KV Switchgear with 40000.00 945232.00 800000.00 18.15
30 No. 20 47261.60
existing 11 KV Switchgears (Adopter Panel)
Heat Shrinkable jointing kit suitable for 11 KV XLPE 3x185 19326.00 40991.60 386520.00 -89.39
31 No. 20 2049.58
sq. mm cable size (indoor)
32 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 60 438.05 396.00 26283.00 23760.00 10.62
33 Earth wire clamp Kg. 120 133.74 336.00 16048.80 40320.00 -60.20
35 Suspension (Insulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 420 272.17 266.20 114311.40 111804.00 2.24
95/50 sq. mm - 70/35 sq. mm PG Clamp (For line to 133.10 68588.10 83853.00 -18.20
36 No. 630 108.87
line to line jumpering & energizing DB neutral)
LT Insulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50 sq. mm -50-35 199.65 169759.80 377338.50 -55.01
37 No. 1890 89.82
sq. mm size for energizing distribution kiosk/box
LT Insulation Piercing connectors (16 sq. mm -16 sq. mm) 121.00 56586.60 76230.00 -25.77
38 No. 630 89.82
suitable for street light connection
LT SMC distribution boxes 3 phase on the LT Poles including all 2420.00 485822.40 1016400.00 -52.20
40 No. 420 1156.72
clamps & material required for mounting connections & sealing
1x35 mm2 XLPE/PVC insulated AL. cable for energising the 67.00 184128.00 281400.00 -34.57
42 Mtr. 4200 43.84
distribution boxes/kiosks.
2x16 mm2 XLPE/PVC insulated Al. cable for energising the street 40.00 0.00 0.00 101.58
43 Mtr. 0 80.63
light
46 GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp for T/F base No. 600 1916.81 1778.00 1150086.00 1066800.00 7.81
47 GI Channel 125x65x6, 1300 mm (Tee-off) No. 300 1328.46 478.00 398538.00 143400.00 177.92
Chemical Pipe Earthing (80 mm dia, 3 m long Pipe) as per 3500.00 1940262.00 2100000.00 -7.61
48 No. 600 3233.77
specification
51 Extra for Al. tape , binding wire, jointing sleeves, PG clamps etc. ls 300 683.92 250.00 205176.00 75000.00 173.57
TOTAL 17705376.18 25104271.60 25
TOTAL (Cr.) 1.77 2.51
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t PVVNL tender rate (T. No 77)
Quoted Supply Rate
by L1 Bidder M/s PVVNL Tender Total Cost L1 Cost of Supply
%
Sl. No. Item Unit Quantity Sterling Wilson. (T. Rate Bidder Items
difference
no. 77)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
1 8.5 Mtr. Long PCC Pole No. 8013 2977.48 1967.50 23858547.24 15765577.50 51.33
2 ACSR Rabbit Conductor Km. 919.4 42240.52 28625.00 38835934.09 26317825.00 47.57
11 KV Composite Polymer Pin Insulator 178.47 3971930.19 3537544.58 12.28
3 No. 19821 200.39
with Nut and washers
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C 141.30 1070623.44 918993.15 16.50
4 No. 6504 164.61
type 45KN c/w Disc fittings
G.I. Wire No. 6 SWG (330 Kg / km of 56.00 1709821.08 1252944.00 36.46
5 Kg 22374 76.42
guarding - along the span - )
G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG (110 Kg / km of 56.00 569940.36 417648.00 36.46
6 Kg 7458 76.42
guarding - across the span )
7 Single support 13 Mtr. STP (SP-72) No. 54 22830.80 18480.00 1232863.20 997920.00 23.54
11KV `V' type Cross arm 65x65x6 665.00 6011490.02 3063655.00 96.22
8 No. 4607 1304.86
mm, M.S. Angle
11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Insulated 775.42 15475500.00 11631355.93 33.05
9 mtr 15000 1031.70
cable, 3x185 sq. mm
10 S.T. P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. No. 108 15268.94 13390.00 1649045.52 1446120.00 14.03
11 KV Outgoing VCB indoor type with
CTR 400/200/5A 350 MVA 255000.00 6751657.00 5100000.00 32.39
11 No. 20 337582.85
(Compatible with existing VCB at
33/11 KV Sub-station )
Insulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 235655.93 3070298.67 2733608.81 12.32
12 Km. 11.6 264680.92
sq. mm
Insulated ABC of 3x50+1x35+1x16 127425.42 1453709.04 1337966.95 8.65
13 Km. 10.5 138448.48
sq. mm
11/0.44 kV 100 KVA Transformer 94745.76 17718154.80 11369491.53 55.84
14 No. 120 147651.29
(Four Star Rating, Level-II)
15 ACSR Weasel conductor for jumpering mtr 7500 25.49 18.76 191175.00 140720.34 35.85
11/0.44 kV 63 KVA Transformer (Four 89055.00 11610698.40 10686600.00 8.65
16 No. 120 96755.82
Star Rating, Level-II)
11/0.44 kV 25 KVA Transformer (Four 47649.00 3776334.60 2858940.00 32.09
17 No. 60 62938.91
TOTAL 138957722.65 99576910.79
TOTA L (Cr.) 13.90 9.96 26
Activity Wise Comparison of L1 Bidder rate (Supply to Supply/Incidental to Incidental/Insatallation to
T-77 (G.B. Nagar)
Installation)
Exclusive of 26.175% Loading (3% contigencies, 1.5% T&P, 21% Turnkey Factor)
Supply Rate Incidental Rate Installation Rate Total Rate
Sl.
Item Qty UoM As per L-1 % As per L-1 % As per L-1 % As per L-1
No. As per DPR As per DPR As per DPR As per DPR % Variation
Bidder Variation Bidder Variation Bidder Variation Bidder
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
1 Distribution 120 Nos 240902 272599 -11.63 5141 18684 -72.48 14178 37927 -62.62 260221 329209 -20.96
Transformer S/S
63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
Transformer
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV
Transformer S/S
11 KV Line on 8.5 m
4 PCC pole with rabbit 271 km 360522 354051 1.83 6107 21578 -71.70 110128 126217 -12.75 476756 501846 -5.00
conductor
11 KV New Line on
8.5 m PCC pole with
5 6 km 948486 742354 27.77 13381 51965 -74.25 114778 51462 123.04 1076645 845780 27.30
AB Cable (3*120 sq
mm)
11 KV New UG Line
with 3x185 Sq. mm.
6 6 km 2848563 3202235 -11.04 615908 779522 -20.99 1178668 2763037 -57.34 4643138 6744793 -31.16
XLPE cable double
circuit
11 KV line at Railway
Crossing with 3x185
7 2 Nos 508142 721650 -29.59 1124195 1160139 -3.10 154276 134789 14.46 1786613 2016577 -11.40
sq. mm. XLPE cable
double circuit 150 m
New 11 KV Feeder at
8 20 Nos 517524 510386 1.40 3372 17215 -80.41 40274 33870 18.91 561170 561471 -0.05
substation
3 phase 4 wire LT Line
ACSR Rabbit
9 20 km 266544 276182 -3.49 4491 17490 -74.32 72918 40652 79.37 343954 334325 2.88
conductor on 8.5 mtr
PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable
(3*95+1*70+1*16 sq
10 11 km 495073 548821 -9.79 7164 38373 -81.33 140029 66108 111.82 642266 653302 -1.69
mm) on 8.5 mtr PCC
Pole
LT Line ABC Cable
(3*50+1*35+1*16 sq
11 10 km 361326 400782 -9.84 5193 28055 -81.49 140029 57279 144.47 506548 486116 4.20
mm) on 8.5 mtr PCC
Pole
Extension of s/s
12 Control Room 6 Nos 0 0 0 0 806958 570905 41.35 806958 570905 41.35
Building
Note : 1 DPR Rate is Ex. 18% GST and Exclusive of 26.175% Loading (3% contigencies, 1.5% T&P, 21% Turnkey Factor)
2 L-1 Bidder Rate is Ex. 18% GST
27
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t Stock Issue Rate (Tender No- 77)
Quoted Supply Rate
As per DPR As per DPR As per DPR
Stock by L1 Bidder M/s
(Stock issue rate % (Stock issue rate (Stock issue %
Sl. No. Item Issue Unit Quantity Sterling Wilson. (T. % difference
20-21) difference 19-20) rate 18-19) difference
Item no. 77)
1 8.5 Mtr. Long PCC Pole SI No. 8013 2977.48 2509.00 18.67 2578.00 15.50 2721.00 9.43
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs. Long SI No. 542 4678.90 4522.94 3.45 4504.00 3.88 4671.00 0.17
3 ACSR Rabbit Conductor SI Km. 919.4 42240.52 37758.00 11.87 38984.00 8.35 39669.00 6.48
11 KV Composite Polymer Pin Insulator
4 with Nut and washers
SI No. 19821 200.39 182.00 10.10 190.00 5.47 384.00 -47.82
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type
5 45KN c/w Disc fittings
SI No. 6504 164.61 254.00 -35.19 251.00 -34.42 287.00 -42.64
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type
6 70 KN c/w Disc fittings
SI No. 963 214.70 872.78 -75.40 704.00 -69.50 552.00 -61.11
G.I. Wire No. 6 SWG (330 Kg / km of
7 guarding - along the span - )
SI Kg 22374 76.42 63.40 20.53 73.59 3.85 54.8 39.45
8 guarding - across the span )
SI Kg 7458 76.42 66.78 14.44 73.66 3.75 54.8 39.45
9 Single support 13 Mtr. STP (SP-72) SI No. 54 22830.80 21786.00 4.80 24641.00 -7.35 20190 13.08
11KV ' V' type Cross arm 100x50x6 mm,
10 M.S. Channel
SI No. 596 1179.38 625.00 88.70 618.00 90.84 744 58.52
11KV `V' type Cross arm 65x65x6 mm, M.S.
11 Angle
SI No. 4607 1304.86 624.93 108.80 618.00 111.14 744 75.38
11 KV 3x120 sq. mm AB Cable (with bare
12 messenger wire)
SI Km. 6.3 739285.80 742000.00 -0.37 774000.00 -4.49 548000 34.91
11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Insulated cable,
13 3x185 sq. mm
SI Mtr. 15000 1031.70 992.00 4.00 980.00 5.28 725 42.30
14 S.T.P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. SI No. 108 15268.94 15019.04 1.66 17858.00 -14.50 15049 1.46
CTR 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible
15 with existing VCB at 33/11 KV Sub-station
SI No. 20 337582.85 340737.98 -0.93 290357.00 16.26 353384 -4.47
)
Insulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 sq.
16 mm
SI Km. 11.6 264680.92 256513.00 3.18 258683.00 2.32 224969 17.65
17 mm
SI Km. 10.5 138448.48 143597.00 -3.59 147192.00 -5.94 127687 8.43
11/0.44 kV 100 KVA Transformer (Four
18 Star Rating, Level-II)
SI No. 120 147651.29 133150.00 10.89 145906.00 1.20 136710 8.00
19 ACSR Weasel conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 7500 25.49 22.90 11.31 24.82 2.70 28.38 -10.18
11/0.44 kV 63 KVA Transformer (Four Star
20 Rating, Level-II)
SI No. 120 96755.82 107144.09 -9.70 105626.00 -8.40 104596 -7.50
SI No. 60 62938.91 57181.95 10.07 58718.00 7.19 56780 10.85
28
in
Ghaziabad Zone
29
Summary of Feeders & Project Cost ( Ghaziabad Zone)
Shifted load
No. of Present Load Balance Load PTW to be on Including GST excluding GST
No. of Feeder on proposed
No. of Proposed New on existing on Agriculture Agriculture (As per stock (As per stock
Zone considered for domestic
Substation Domestic feeders feeders feeder issue rate 2018- issue rate 2018-
segregation feeders
Feeders. (MVA) (MVA) (No) 19) 19)
(MVA)
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Ghaziabad
13 37 21 62.50 19.90 42.60 7135 43.49 37.71
Zone

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1 M/s Sterling & Wilson Private Limited. Yes 267695120.06 L1 260711362.25 L1
2 M/s Mayasheel Construction. Yes 277525823.00 L2 277525823.00 L2
3 M/s Jakson Limited. Yes 288399135.20 L3 288399135.20 L3
4 M/s Gupta Power Infrastructure Limited. Yes 305250229.63 L4 297384416.60 L4
5 M/s RP Infrapower Private Limited. Yes 310308996.05 L5 307167826.10 L5
6 M/s Fabrico India Pvt. Ltd. Yes 330557849.00 L6 323621658.00 L6
7 M/s Vikran Engineering and Exim Pvt. Ltd. Yes 333111452.00 L7 325654376.80 L7
8 M/s Tata Projects Limited. Yes 349107544.50 L8 342121993.50 L8
M/s Feedback Energy Distribution Company
9 Yes 378655745.20 L9 370348554.20 L9
Ltd.
10 M/s V.M. Infra projects No Price bid not opened (Tender cost &EMD not deposited)
30
Tender No. 78 (Ghaziabad Zone)
bidders
1 2 3 4 5
—
1 M/s Sterling & Wilson Private Limited. L1 260711362.25
2 M/s Mayasheel Construction. L2 277525823.00 -6.06

4 M/s Gupta Power Infrastructure Limited. L4 297384416.60 -12.33
5 M/s RP Infrapower Private Limited. L5 307167826.10 -15.12
6 M/s Fabrico India Pvt. Ltd. L6 323621658.00 -19.44
7 M/s Vikran Engineering and Exim Pvt. Ltd. L7 325654376.80 -19.94
31
T&P, 21% turnkey
(Rs. Cr.)
(Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6
37.71 29.88
M/s Sterling& Wilson (-)30.87 (-)12.97
Pvt. Ltd., West 26.07
Mumbai 37.43 29.66
(-)30.34 (-)12.10

Bid value per DPR (ex GST) DPR (ex GST) without %
%
Name of the firm Ran (Excluding Inc. 3% Conti., 1.5% 3% Conti., 1.5% T&P, Variatio
Variation
k GST) T&P, 21% turnkey 21% turnkey n
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
M/s Sterling& Wilson Pvt. Ltd.,
L-1 26.07 (-)30.97 (-)12.97
West Mumbai 37.71 29.88
M/s Mayasheel Construction. L-2 27.75 (-)26.41 (-)7.13
Rs. 1.68 Cr.
6.44%
32
Item-wise break-up of costs Evaluated vs. Estimated for lowest bidder – [T-78] GHAZIABAD ZONE
Variation Per
Sl. Evaluated Cost
Evaluated per Estimated per Unit From
unit rate unit rate Estimates
1 100 KVA 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer S/S Nos 118 28512078.04 606634.46 1678001.3 30796713.8 260989 329209 -20.72 
2 63 KVA 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer Nos 111 20050610.43 430193.82 1578458.85 22059263.1 198732 288018 -31.00 
3 25KVA 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer S/S Nos 66 8805883.68 187733.04 893851.2 9887467.92 149810 239442 -37.43 
4 11 KV Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with rabbit conductor km 250 90441275.28 1777236.04 27612862.25 119831373.6 479325 501846 -4.49 
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with AB Cable

5 km 9 8599008.02 120971.67 1036053.99 9756033.68 1084004 845780 28.17 
(3*120 sq mm)
11 KV New UG Line with 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE cable

6 km 6 17142777.6 3695448 7092891.3 27931116.9 4655186 6744793 -30.98 
double circuit
11 KV line at Railway Crossing with 3x185 sq. mm.
7 Nos 3 1529031.3 3372584.76 464195.34 5365811.4 1788604 2016577 -11.30 
XLPE cable double circuit 150 m
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation Nos 21 10900295.49 69,811.98 848240.4 11818347.87 562778 561471 0.23 
3 phase 4 wire LT Line ACSR Rabbit conductor on 8.5

9 km 20 5346890.7 89,827.68 1462664.8 6899383.18 344969 334325 3.18 
mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm) on 8.5
10 km 10 4953483.29 71,462.50 1404429.4 6429375.19 642938 653302 -1.59 
mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) on 8.5
11 km 10 3624072.31 51,932.50 1404429.4 5080434.21 508043 486116 4.51 
mtr PCC Pole
12 Extension of substation control room building Nos 6 4856041.44 4856041.44 809340 570905 41.76 
Total 199905406.1 10473836.45 50332119.67 260711362.3
33
Reasonability of Rate (Ghaziabad-78)
charges).
schedules for the purpose of capitalization. Hence to find actual difference from the DPR cost, comparison
of cost of work to work (excluding 3% contingency, 1.5% T&P, & 21% turnkey charges in the DPR cost) has
been done which is bifurcated in supply and erection + F&I as under :-

Sl.No. Type of Cost
1 Cost of supply of items whose SIR available 13.18 14.45 (+)9.64
Total Cost of Supply of items Rs. Cr. 20.87 19.99 (-)4.22
F & I + Erection + other incidental Charges Rs. Cr. 8.68 5.59 (-)35.59
Cost of Civil work 0.34 0.49 (+)44.11
Total Cost of Project Rs. Cr. 29.89 26.07 (-)12.78
34
3. Package value of L-1 Bidder M/s Sterling & Wilson Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai seems to be reasonable in view of following reasons :-
(i) The package has attracted as many as 10 bidders; of whom 9 were found to be technically responsive. The price discovery has thus
happened through a highly competitive bidding process.
(ii) All the bidders have quoted below PVVNL estimate.
(iii) M/s L & T would be L-1 Bidder in the Tender and their package value would be -13.27% lower in comparison to package value of sterling & Wilson .
(iv) The L-2 (M/s Mayasheel) & L-3 ( M/s Jakson) Bidder have also quoted rates which are very close to the L-1 Bidder’s rate (26.07 Cr.
/27.75 Cr./ 28.84 Cr.)
(b) Interest is to be paid in case of delay of payment to TKCs beyond 45 days .
35
Quoted Supply
Stock Rate by L1 Bidder Total Cost L1 Total Cost of
Sl. DPR Rate
Item Issue Unit Quantity M/s Sterling Bidder Supply Items % diff erence
No.
Item Wilson.(T. no. 78)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs . Long SI No. 500 4692.71 4671.00 2346355.00 2335500.00 0.46
11 KV Compos ite Polymer Pin Ins ulator with Nut and
5 SI No. 18348 200.98 196.00 3687581.04 3596208.00 2.54
was hers
11 kV Polymer Dis c Ins ulator T&C type 45KN c/w
6 SI No. 6000 165.09 264.00 990540.00 1584000.00 -37.47
Dis c fittings
11 kV Polymer Dis c Ins ulator B&S type 70 KN c/w
7 SI No. 975 215.34 552.00 209956.50 538200.00 -60.99
Dis c fittings
8 Aluminium jointing s leeves No. 830 81.90 170.00 67977.00 141100.00 -51.82
9 PG Clamps for ACSR Rabbit/W eas el RES No. 7563 40.95 257.00 309704.85 1943691.00 -84.07
Stay Set ( Galvanis ed) with 50x8 mm s tay clamp, s tay
ins ulator, anchor plate (200x200x6), nut bolts , turn
buckles ,1.8 m long 16 mm dia. Solid GS Stay Rod, &
10 RES No. 8045 1416.58 2027.00 11396386.10 16307215.00 -30.11
7/3.15 mm dia. GI s tranded wire complete as per
technical s pecification, approved drawings ,
s chedules and s cope of work.
MS earthing rod of 20x2500 mm. W ith acces s ories
11 and 6 SW G earthing wire for pole earthing
RES No. 7543 574.12 838.00 4330587.16 6321034.00 -31.49
15 Aluminium binding wire-6 SW G RES Kg 2662 317.21 247.00 844413.02 657514.00 28.43
Guarding angle 75x75x6 mm,1600 mm long with
16 holding clamp, N&B etc. (16 Nos / km of guarding)
No. 1000 1028.21 609.00 1028210.00 609000.00 68.84
G.I. W ire No. 6 SW G (330 Kg / km of guarding -

17 SI Kg 20625 76.65 60.73 1580906.25 1252556.25 26.21
along the s pan - )
G.I. W ire No. 8 SW G (110 Kg / km of guarding -
18 SI Kg 6875 76.65 60.26 526968.75 414287.50 27.20
acros s the s pan )
21 GI Binding W ire 16 SW G (1 Kg / km of guarding) Kg 63 76.65 92.50 4828.95 5827.50 -17.14
22 Single s upport 13 Mtr. STP (SP-72) SI No. 50 22900.56 20798.00 1145028.00 1039900.00 10.11
11KV ' V' type Cros s arm 100x50x6 mm, M.S.
23 SI No. 550 1182.97 535.00 650633.50 294250.00 121.12
Channel
X-Arm holding Clamp (Back Clamp) with bolts &
24 RES No. 6550 137.53 304.00 900821.50 1991200.00 -54.76
nuts
26 `F' Bracket RES No. 6300 308.87 265.00 1945881.00 1669500.00 16.55
27 Turn buckle No. 250 163.79 66.00 40947.50 16500.00 148.17
28 G.I. W ire 6 SW G along the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 1050 76.65 60.73 80482.50 63766.50 26.21
G.I. W ire No. 8 SW G acros s the s pan (For 50 Mtr.
29 SI Kg. 700 76.65 60.26 53655.00 42182.00 27.20
line)
30 G.I. W ire No. 16 SW G for binding Kg. 75 76.65 92.50 5748.75 6937.50 -17.14
Armour rod with ferrules for ACSR Dog/Raccoon
31 No. 75 410.55 253.00 30791.25 18975.00 62.27
Helical Performed
32 Red Oxide paint RES ltr 328 128.67 160.00 42203.76 52480.00 -19.58
33 Aluminium Paint RES ltr 164 284.42 319.00 46644.88 52316.00 -10.84
34 11KV `V' type Cros s arm 65x65x6 mm, M.S. Angle SI No. 4250 1308.82 535.00 5562485.00 2273750.00 144.64
Top channel 100x50 mm 2240 mm (7.9 kg/M) with
35 No. 1021 1687.43 823.00 1722866.03 840283.00 105.03
clamp, nuts & bolts .
36
Quoted Supply
Sl. DPR Rate
Item Issue Unit Quantity M/s Sterling Bidder Supply items % diff erence
No.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
GI Angle Iron 65x65x6 mm,2700 mm long bracing with
37 No. 1000 1726.21 2735.00 1726210.00 2735000.00 -36.88
4 clamp
38 È' Bracket RES No. 1563 136.85 421.00 213896.55 658023.00 -67.49
11 KV 3x120 s q. mm AB Cable (with bare mes s enger
39 SI Km. 9.5 741500.38 654000.00 7044253.61 6213000.00 13.38
wire)
40 HT Sus pens ion Clamp No. 225 218.39 450.00 49137.75 101250.00 -51.47
43 Pole Clamps Set 1250 229.31 155.00 286637.50 193750.00 47.94
Heat Shrinkable 1 ph. termination kit outdoor for 11
44 No. 108 1899.16 1100.00 205109.28 118800.00 72.65
kV 3x120 Sq. mm. AB cable
45 Mid Span Jointing Sleeves (120 s q. mm) No. 36 286.64 140.90 10319.04 5072.40 103.44
46 Straight through jointing kit (all s ize) No. 9 5922.11 5500.00 53298.99 49500.00 7.67
47 Alluminium jointing s leeves No. 9 81.90 170.00 737.10 1530.00 -51.82
11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Ins ulated cable, 3x185 s q.
49 SI mtr 15360 1034.79 891.00 15894374.40 13685760.00 16.14
mm
Heat Shrinkable jointing / termination kits outdoor
50 No. 153 2416.49 7680.00 369722.97 1175040.00 -68.54
for 11 kV 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE Cable
51 G.I. Pipe 6" dia mtr 396 1864.18 800.00 738215.28 316800.00 133.02
HDPE pipe 160 mm Dia. for Cable Laying at Road
52 mtr 1440 754.62 3449.00 1086652.80 4966560.00 -78.12
Cros s ing, etc (for laying by HDD Method)
54 S.T.P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. SI No. 114 15316.38 15049.00 1746067.32 1715586.00 1.78
55 RES No. 331 2372.82 823.00 785403.42 272413.00 188.31
56 SI No. 108 215.34 552.00 23256.72 59616.00 -60.99
Dis c fittings
57 P.G. Clamp for Dog/Raccoon RES No. 216 109.20 257.00 23587.20 55512.00 -57.51
59 Holding clamps for channel with N&B RES No. 1324 402.66 259.00 533121.84 342916.00 55.47
60 11 kV Lightning Arres tor No. 1056 528.45 3960.00 558043.20 4181760.00 -86.66
61 GI Strip 25x3 mm for earthing mtr 6470 84.63 150.00 547556.10 970500.00 -43.58
62 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with exis ting VCB SI No. 21 338579.42 296127.00 7110167.82 6218667.00 14.34
at 33/11 KV Sub-s tation )
63 Switchgear with exis ting 11 KV Switchgears No. 21 47401.12 40000.00 995423.52 840000.00 18.50
(Adopter Panel)
Heat Shrinkable jointing kit s uitable for 11 KV
64 No. 21 2055.72 19326.00 43170.12 405846.00 -89.36
XLPE 3x185 s q. mm cable s ize (indoor)
11KV Polymer Dis c Ins ulator T&C type 45 KN with
65 SI No. 948 165.09 264.00 156505.32 250272.00 -37.47
fittings
Holding clamps for top channel & Fus e s et etc. with
66 RES No. 2112 450.37 259.00 951181.44 547008.00 73.89
bolts & nuts
67 11 KV TPMO RES No. 316 6824.74 18292.00 2156617.84 5780272.00 -62.69
68 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 316 3275.87 7028.00 1035174.92 2220848.00 -53.39
69 RES No. 63 574.12 838.00 36169.56 52794.00 -31.49
and 6 SW G earthing wire for pole earthing
70 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia mtr 63 439.39 396.00 27681.57 24948.00 10.96
37
Quoted Supply
Sl. DPR Rate
Item Issue Unit Quantity M/s Sterling Bidder Supply items % diff erence
No.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
72 LT Shakle Ins ulator 100x115 mm RES No. 1600 38.76 36.00 62016.00 57600.00 7.67
73 Bolts and nuts for s hackle ins ulators RES kg 600 123.16 196.00 73896.00 117600.00 -37.16
74 Loop Guard complete, 3-Phas e RES No. 800 13.79 46.00 11032.00 36800.00 -70.02
75 Earth wire clamp No. 120 134.15 336.00 16098.00 40320.00 -60.07
76 Dead End (Ins ulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 400 286.64 399.30 114656.00 159720.00 -28.21
77 Sus pens ion (Ins ulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 400 272.99 266.20 109196.00 106480.00 2.55
95/50 s q. mm - 70/35 s q. mm PG Clamp (For line
78 to line to line jumpering & energizing DB neutral)
No. 600 109.20 133.10 65520.00 79860.00 -17.96
LT Ins ulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50 s q.

79 mm -50-35 s q. mm s ize for energizing dis tribution No. 1800 90.09 199.65 162162.00 359370.00 -54.88
kios k/box
LT Ins ulation Piercing connectors (16 s q. mm -16 s q.
80 No. 600 90.09 121.00 54054.00 72600.00 -25.55
mm) s uitable for s treet light connection
81 Mid s pan jointing s leeves (95 s q. mm) No. 40 286.64 121.00 11465.60 4840.00 136.89
LT SMC dis tribution boxes 3 phas e on the LT Poles
82 including all clamps & material required for No. 400 1160.21 2420.00 464084.00 968000.00 -52.06
mounting connections & s ealing
83 Ins ulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 s q. mm SI Km. 10.5 265473.78 250194.00 2787474.69 2627037.00 6.11
84 On/Off s with for s treet light connections No. 400 1372.03 605.00 548812.00 242000.00 126.78
1x35 mm2 XLPE/PVC ins ulated AL. cable for
85 mtr 4000 43.97 67.00 175880.00 268000.00 -34.37
energis ing the dis tribution boxes /kios ks .
2x16 mm2 XLPE/PVC ins ulated Al. cable for
86 mtr 0 80.87 40.00 0.00 0.00 102.18
energis ing the s treet light
87 Mid s pan jointing s leeves (50 s q. mm) No. 40 286.64 121.00 11465.60 4840.00 136.89
88 Ins ulated ABC of 3x50+1x35+1x16 s q. mm SI No. 10.5 138863.21 138727.00 1458063.71 1456633.50 0.10
11/0.44 kV 100 KVA Trans former (Four Star Rating,
89 SI No. 118 148096.77 136710.00 17475418.86 16131780.00 8.33
Level-II)
90 GI Channel 100x50x6, 2028 mm (for Dropper Fus e s et) No. 885 1534.74 748.00 1358244.90 661980.00 105.18
GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp for
91 No. 590 1922.63 1778.00 1134351.70 1049020.00 8.13
T/F bas e
Clamp with nuts & bolts for 1300 mm long MS
93 RES No. 295 201.33 259.00 59392.35 76405.00 -22.27
Channel
SMC Dis tribution box having 200 A, 4 Pole ,MCCB
94 RES No. 118 30097.09 14641.00 3551456.62 1727638.00 105.57
for 3 ph, 100 KVA Trans former
Chemical Pipe Earthing (80 mm dia, 3 m long Pipe) as
95 No. 590 3243.52 3500.00 1913676.80 2065000.00 -7.33
per s pecification
96 LT PVC 3.5 x150/70 s qmm Cable RES mtr 2360 547.28 409.00 1291580.80 965240.00 33.81
97 ACSR W eas el conductor for jumpering SI mtr 7375 25.57 23.98 188578.75 176852.50 6.63
98 Al. crimping lugs 150 s q.mm. No. 1888 27.44 75.00 51806.72 141600.00 -63.41
Extra for Al. tape , binding wire, jointing s leeves , PG
100 ls 295 686.02 250.00 202375.90 73750.00 174.41
clamps etc.
101 SI No. 111 97047.75 104596.00 10772300.25 11610156.00 -7.22
Level-II)
102 RES No. 111 25906.70 14641.00 2875643.70 1625151.00 76.95
103 LT PVC 3.5 x70/35 s qmm Cable RES mtr 3540 242.33 409.00 857848.20 1447860.00 -40.75
105 SI No. 66 63128.81 56780.00 4166501.46 3747480.00 11.18
Level-II)
106 RES No. 66 11711.25 14641.00 772942.50 966306.00 -20.01
TOTAL 199856884.14 208704775.25
38
TOTAL (Cr.) 19.99 20.87
Quoted Supply
Stock Rate by L1 Bidder Total Cost L1
Sl. Quantity DPR Rate Cost of Supply
Item Issue Unit M/s Sterling Bidder % diff erence
No. Items
Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
buckles ,1.8 m long 16 mm dia. Solid GS Stay Rod, &
3 7/3.15 mm dia. GI s tranded wire complete as per
RES No. 8045 1416.58 2027.00 11396386.10 16307215.00 -30.11
technical s pecification, approved drawings ,
RES No. 7543 574.12 838.00 4330587.16 6321034.00 -31.49
8 nuts
RES No. 6550 137.53 304.00 900821.50 1991200.00 -54.76
9 `F' Bracket RES No. 6300 308.87 265.00 1945881.00 1669500.00 16.55
10 Red Oxide paint RES ltr 328 128.67 160.00 42203.76 52480.00 -19.58
11 Aluminium Paint RES ltr 164 284.42 319.00 46644.88 52316.00 -10.84
12 È' Bracket RES No. 1563 136.85 421.00 213896.55 658023.00 -67.49
13 clamp, nuts & bolts .
RES No. 331 2372.82 823.00 785403.42 272413.00 188.31
15 Holding clamps for channel with N&B RES No. 1324 402.66 259.00 533121.84 342916.00 55.47
16 bolts & nuts
RES No. 2112 450.37 259.00 951181.44 547008.00 73.89
17 11 KV TPMO RES No. 316 6824.74 18292.00 2156617.84 5780272.00 -62.69
18 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 316 3275.87 7028.00 1035174.92 2220848.00 -53.39
RES No. 63 574.12 838.00 36169.56 52794.00 -31.49
21 LT Shakle Ins ulator 100x115 mm RES No. 1600 38.76 36.00 62016.00 57600.00 7.67
22 Bolts and nuts for s hackle ins ulators RES kg 600 123.16 196.00 73896.00 117600.00 -37.16
23 Loop Guard complete, 3-Phas e RES No. 800 13.79 46.00 11032.00 36800.00 -70.02
24 Channel
RES No. 295 201.33 259.00 59392.35 76405.00 -22.27
25 for 3 ph, 100 KVA Trans former
RES No. 118 30097.09 14641.00 3551456.62 1727638.00 105.57
26 LT PVC 3.5 x150/70 s qmm Cable RES mtr 2360 547.28 409.00 1291580.80 965240.00 33.81
RES No. 111 25906.70 14641.00 2875643.70 1625151.00 76.95
28 LT PVC 3.5 x70/35 s qmm Cable RES mtr 3540 242.33 409.00 857848.20 1447860.00 -40.75
RES No. 66 11711.25 14641.00 772942.50 966306.00 -20.01
TOTAL 37872122.16 51813165.00
TOTAL (Cr.) 3.79 5.18
39
Quoted Supply
Item Issue Unit M/s Sterling Bidder % diff erence
No. Items
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
4 was hers
SI No. 18348 200.98 196.00 3687581.04 3596208.00 2.54
5 Dis c fittings
SI No. 6000 165.09 264.00 990540.00 1584000.00 -37.47
6 Dis c fittings
SI No. 975 215.34 552.00 209956.50 538200.00 -60.99
G.I. Wire No. 6 SWG (330 Kg / km of guarding -
7 along the s pan - )
SI Kg 20625 76.65 60.73 1580906.25 1252556.25 26.21
8 acros s the s pan )
SI Kg 6875 76.65 60.26 526968.75 414287.50 27.20
10 Channel
SI No. 550 1182.97 535.00 650633.50 294250.00 121.12
11 G.I. Wire 6 SWG along the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 1050 76.65 60.73 80482.50 63766.50 26.21
G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG acros s the s pan (For 50 Mtr.
12 line)
SI Kg. 700 76.65 60.26 53655.00 42182.00 27.20
14 wire)
SI Km. 9.5 741500.38 654000.00 7044253.61 6213000.00 13.38
15 mm
SI mtr 15360 1034.79 891.00 15894374.40 13685760.00 16.14
17 Dis c fittings
SI No. 108 215.34 552.00 23256.72 59616.00 -60.99
18 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with exis ting VCB SI No. 21 338579.42 296127.00 7110167.82 6218667.00 14.34
at 33/11 KV Sub-s tation )
19 fittings
SI No. 948 165.09 264.00 156505.32 250272.00 -37.47
21 Ins ulated ABC of 3x50+1x35+1x16 s q. mm SI No. 10.5 138863.21 138727.00 1458063.71 1456633.50 0.10
22 Level-II)
SI No. 118 148096.77 136710.00 17475418.86 16131780.00 8.33
23 ACSR Weas el conductor for jumpering SI mtr 7375 25.57 23.98 188578.75 176852.50 6.63
24 Level-II)
SI No. 111 97047.75 104596.00 10772300.25 11610156.00 -7.22
25 Level-II)
SI No. 66 63128.81 56780.00 4166501.46 3747480.00 11.18
TOTAL 144490239.98 131844667.85
14.45 13.18
TOTAL (Cr.)
40
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t Stock Issue Rate 2019-20 cost schedule 18-19 (T. No 78)
Quoted Supply
Item Issue Unit M/s Sterling Bidder % difference
No. Items

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Guarding angle 75x75x6 mm,1600 mm long with
3 holding clamp, N&B etc. (16 Nos / km of guarding)
No. 1000 1028.21 609.00 1028210.00 609000.00 68.84
8 Turn buckle No. 250 163.79 66.00 40947.50 16500.00 148.17
Armour rod with ferrules for ACSR Dog/Raccoon
10 No. 75 410.55 253.00 30791.25 18975.00 62.27
Helical Performed
11 No. 1021 1687.43 823.00 1722866.03 840283.00 105.03
GI Angle Iron 65x65x6 mm,2700 mm long bracing with
13 No. 1000 1726.21 2735.00 1726210.00 2735000.00 -36.88
4 clamp
17 Pole Clamps Set 1250 229.31 155.00 286637.50 193750.00 47.94
Heat Shrinkable 1 ph. termination kit outdoor for 11
18 No. 108 1899.16 1100.00 205109.28 118800.00 72.65
kV 3x120 Sq. mm. AB cable
19 Mid Span Jointing Sleeves (120 sq. mm) No. 36 286.64 140.90 10319.04 5072.40 103.44
20 Straight through jointing kit (all size) No. 9 5922.11 5500.00 53298.99 49500.00 7.67
Heat Shrinkable jointing / termination kits outdoor
23 No. 153 2416.49 7680.00 369722.97 1175040.00 -68.54
for 11 kV 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE Cable
24 G.I. Pipe 6" dia mtr 396 1864.18 800.00 738215.28 316800.00 133.02
HDPE pipe 160 mm Dia. for Cable Laying at Road
25 mtr 1440 754.62 3449.00 1086652.80 4966560.00 -78.12
Cros sing, etc (for laying by HDD Method)
41
Quoted Supply
Item Issue Unit M/s Sterling Bidder % difference
No. Items

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
29 GI Strip 25x3 mm for earthing mtr 6470 84.63 150.00 547556.10 970500.00 -43.58
30 Switchgear with existing 11 KV Switchgears No. 21 47401.12 40000.00 995423.52 840000.00 18.50
(Adopter Panel)
Heat Shrinkable jointing kit suitable for 11 19326.00 43170.12 405846.00 -89.36
31 No. 21 2055.72
KV XLPE 3x185 sq. mm cable size (indoor)
32 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia mtr 63 439.39 396.00 27681.57 24948.00 10.96
33 Earth wire clamp No. 120 134.15 336.00 16098.00 40320.00 -60.07
35 Suspension (Insulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 400 272.99 266.20 109196.00 106480.00 2.55
95/50 sq. mm - 70/35 sq. mm PG Clamp
36 (For line to line to line jumpering & No. 600 109.20 133.10 65520.00 79860.00 -17.96
energizing DB neutral)
LT Insulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50 sq.
37 mm -50-35 sq. mm size for energizing No. 1800 90.09 199.65 162162.00 359370.00 -54.88
distribution kiosk/box
LT Insulation Piercing connectors (16 sq. mm -16 121.00 54054.00 72600.00 -25.55
38 No. 600 90.09
sq. mm) suitable for street light connection
LT SMC distribution boxes 3 phase on the LT
40 Poles including all clamps & material required No. 400 1160.21 2420.00 464084.00 968000.00 -52.06
for mounting connections & sealing
42 mtr 4000 43.97
2x16 mm2 XLPE/PVC insulated Al. cable for 40.00 0.00 0.00 102.18
43 mtr 0 80.87
energising the street light
GI Channel 100x50x6, 2028 mm (for Dropper 748.00 1358244.90 661980.00 105.18
45 No. 885 1534.74
Fuse set)
GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp 1778.00 1134351.70 1049020.00 8.13
46 No. 590 1922.63
for T/F base
Chemical Pipe Earthing (80 mm dia, 3 m long 3500.00 1913676.80 2065000.00 -7.33
48 No. 590 3243.52
Pipe) as per specification
Extra for Al. tape , binding wire, jointing sleeves, 250.00 202375.90 73750.00 174.41
51 ls 295 686.02
PG clamps etc.
TOTAL 17494522.00 25046942.40
TOTA L (Cr.) 1.75 2.50
42
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t PVVNL tender rate (T. No- 78)
Quoted Supply Rate
by L1 Bidder M/s PVVNL Tender Total Cost L1 Cost of
Sl. No. Item Unit Quantity Sterling Wilson.(T. Rate Bidder Supply Items % difference
no. 78)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
11 KV Composite Polymer Pin Insulator with Nut
3 and washers
No. 18348 200.98 178.47 3687581.04 3274651.53 12.61
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45KN
4 c/w Disc fittings
No. 6000 165.09 141.30 990540.00 847779.66 16.84
5 along the span - )
Kg 20625 76.65 56.00 1580906.25 1155000.00 36.88
6 across the span )
Kg 6875 76.65 56.00 526968.75 385000.00 36.88
8 11KV `V' type Cross arm 65x65x6 mm, M.S. Angle No. 4250 1308.82 665.00 5562485.00 2826250.00 96.82
11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Insulated cable, 3x185
9 sq. mm
mtr 15360 1034.79 775.42 15894374.40 11910508.47 33.45
10 S.T.P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. No. 114 15316.38 13390.00 1746067.32 1526460.00 14.39
11 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with existing No. 21 338579.42 255000.00 7110167.82 5355000.00 32.78
12 Insulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 sq. mm Km. 10.5 265473.78 235655.93 2787474.69 2474387.29 12.65
No. 118 148096.77 94745.76 17475418.86 11180000.00 56.31
No. 111 97047.75 89055.00 10772300.25 9885105.00 8.98
No. 66 63128.81 47649 4166501.46 3144834.00 32.49
TOTAL 133925141.83 95735280.40
TOTAL (Cr.) 13.39 9.57
43
T-78 (Ghaziabad)
Installation)
Exclusive of 26.175% Loading (3% contigencies, 1.5% T&P, 21% Turnkey
Sl.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
100 KVA, 11/0.433
1 KV Dis tribution 118 Nos 241628 272599 -11.36 5141 18684 -72.48 14220 37927 -62.51 260989 329209 -20.72
Trans forme r S/S
63 KVA, 11/0.433
Trans forme r
25KVA, 11/0.433
Trans forme r S/S
11 KV Line on 8.5
4 m PCC pole with 250 km 361765 354202 2.14 7109 21588 -67.07 110451 126217 -12.49 479325 502008 -4.52
rabbit conductor
11 KV Ne w Line on
8.5 m PCC pole
5 9 km 955445 745398 28.18 13441 52178 -74.24 115117 51462 123.69 9756034 849038 1049.07
with AB Cable
(3*120 s q mm)
11 KV Ne w UG
Line with 3x185 Sq.
6 6 km 2857130 3202235 -10.78 615908 779522 -20.99 1182149 2763037 -57.22 4655186 6744793 -30.98
mm. XLPE cable
double circuit
11 KV line at
Railway Cros s ing
7 with 3x185 s q. mm. 3 Nos 509677 721650 -29.37 1124195 1160139 -3.10 154732 134789 14.80 1788604 2016577 -11.30
XLPE cable double
circuit 150 m
Ne w 11 KV Fe e de r
8 21 Nos 519062 510386 1.70 3324 17215 -80.69 40392 33870 19.26 562778 561471 0.23
at s ubs tation
3 phas e 4 wire LT
Line ACSR Rabbit
9 20 km 267345 276182 -3.20 4491 17490 -74.32 73133 40652 79.90 344969 334325 3.18
conductor on 8.5
mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable
(3*95+1*70+1*16
10 10 km 495348 547524 -9.53 7146 38282 -81.33 140443 66108 112.44 642938 651914 -1.38
s q mm) on 8.5 mtr
PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

(3*50+1*35+1*16
11 10 km 362407 400782 -9.57 5193 28055 -81.49 140443 57279 145.19 508043 486116 4.51
s q mm) on 8.5 mtr
PCC Pole
Exte ns ion of s /s
12 Control Room 6 Nos 0 0 0 0 0 #DIV/0! 809340 570905 41.76 809340 570905 41.76
Building
2 L-1 Bidder rateis Ex. 18% GST
44
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder Sterling Wilson w.r.t Stock Issue Rate (Tender No- 78)
Quoted Supply
Stock Rate by L1 Bidder As per DPR (Stock As per DPR (Stock As per DPR (Stock
% % %
Sl. No. Item Issue Unit Quantity M/s Sterling issue rate 20-21) issue rate 19-20) issue rate 18-19)
difference difference difference
3 ACSR Rabbit Conductor SI Km. 855.4 42367.96 37758.00 12.21 38984.00 8.68 39669.00 6.80
11 KV Composite Polymer Pin Insulator with
4 SI No. 18348 200.98 182.00 10.43 190.00 5.78 384.00 -47.66
Nut and washers
5 SI No. 6000 165.09 254.00 -35.00 251.00 -34.23 287.00 -42.48
45KN c/w Disc fittings
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type 70
6 SI No. 975 215.34 872.78 -75.33 704.00 -69.41 552.00 -60.99
KN c/w Disc fittings
7 SI Kg 20625 76.65 63.40 20.90 73.59 4.16 54.8 39.87
8 SI Kg 6875 76.65 66.78 14.79 73.66 4.06 54.8 39.87
11KV ' V' type Cross arm 100x50x6 mm, M.S.
10 SI No. 550 1182.97 625.00 89.28 618.00 91.42 744 59.00
Channel
11 SI No. 4250 1308.82 624.93 109.44 618.00 111.78 744 75.92
Angle
12 SI Km. 9.5 741500.38 742000.00 -0.07 774000.00 -4.20 548000 35.31
messenger wire)
13 SI mtr 15360 1034.79 992.00 4.31 980.00 5.59 725 42.73
3x185 sq. mm
15 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with SI No. 21 338579.42 340737.98 -0.63 290357.00 16.61 353384 -4.19
existing VCB at 33/11 KV Sub-station )
11KV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45
16 SI No. 948 165.09 254.00 -35.00 190.00 -13.11 287.00 -42.48
KN with fittings
17 Insulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 sq. mm SI Km. 10.5 265473.78 256513.00 3.49 258683.00 2.63 224969 18.00
18 Insulated ABC of 3x50+1x35+1x16 sq. mm SI No. 10.5 138863.21 143597.00 -3.30 147192.00 -5.66 127687 8.75
19 SI No. 118 148096.77 133150.00 11.23 145906.00 1.50 136710 8.33
Rating, Level-II)
20 ACSR Weasel conductor for jumpering SI mtr 7375 25.57 22.90 11.66 24.82 3.02 28.38 -9.90
21 SI No. 66 63128.81 57181.95 10.40 58718.00 7.51 56780 11.18
Rating, Level-II)
45
in
Bulandshahr Zone
46
Summary of Feeders & Project Cost ( Bulandshahr Zone)
Shifted load on
No. of on existing on Agriculture Agriculture (As per stock (As per stock
Zone considered for New Domestic domestic
Substation feeders feeders feeder issue rate 2018- issue rate 2018-
(MVA) (MVA) (No) 19) 19)
(MVA)
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Bulandshahr
76 237 135 407.20 130.00 277.20 45490 290.25 245.97
Zone

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1 NCC LIMITED Yes 1459443637.04 L1 1418093893 L1
2 LARSEN AND TOUBRO LIMITED Yes 1484815215.73 L2 1467476968 L2
3 M/s. Ashoka Buildcon Ltd Yes 1668600984.45 L3 1674742331 L3
4 TATA Projects Limited Yes 1784001631.00 L4 1738325146 L4
5 VINDHYA TELELINKS LIMITED Yes 1841604673.68 L5 1786571737 L5
6 Montecarlo Limited Yes 2208916488.90 L6 2138611017 L6
7 Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd. Yes 2725815547.60 L7 2686425458 L7
8 V.M. Infra projects No Tender cost &EMD not deposited
Debarred for 3 Years vide MVVNL OM no. 3082 dated 31.12.18 and circulated vide UPPCL letter no. 529
9 East India Udyog Ltd. Ghaziabad No
dated 09.04.2020
10 Vishwanath Projects Ltd. Hyderabad No firm has MAAT Rs. 281.63 Cr. against required Value Rs. 387.00 Cr.
47
Tender No. 79 (Bulandshahr Zone)
bidders
1 2 3 4 5
1 NCC LIMITED L1 1418093893 —
2 LARSEN AND TOUBRO LIMITED L2 1467476968 -3.37
3 Ashoka Buildcon Ltd L3 1674742331 -15.32

4 TATA Projects Limited L4 1738325146 -18.42
5 VINDHYA TELELINKS LIMITED L5 1786571737 -20.62
6 Montecarlo Limited L6 2138611017 -33.69
7 Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd. L7 2686425458 -47.21
48
T&P, 21% turnkey
(Rs. Cr.)
(Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6
245.96 194.93
(As per original DPR Stock issue (-)42.34 (As per original DPR Stock (-)27.25
rate 18-19) issue rate 18-19)
M/s NCC Limited,
141.80 192.75
Hyderabad 243.21
(Revised DPR prepared on the
(Revised DPR prepared on the basis (-)41.69 (-)26.43
basis of Stock issue rate 19-
of Stock issue rate 19-20)
20)

Bid %
Rank Variation
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
M/s NCC, Limited, Hyderabad L-1 141.81 (-)42.34 (-)27.25
245.96 194.93
M/s L&T Ltd. Mumbai L-2 146.74 (-)40.34 (-)24.72
Rs. 4.93 Cr.
3.47%
49
Table 9: Item-wise break-up of costs Evaluated vs. Estimated for lowest bidder – P23 [T-79]
Sl. Evaluated Cost %age of Evaluated per Estimated per Variation From
No. Supply Incidental Installation Total Bid unit rate unit rate %age Estimates
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution
1 km 752 13,12,07,756.80 13,25,475.20 1,80,03,902.72 150537134.7 10.60% 200182.36 329209 -39.19 
Transformer S/S
2 km 745 10,92,36,898.95 11,03,561.05 1,64,51,998.90 126792458.9 8.90% 170191.22 288018 -40.91 
Transformer
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution
3 km 440 4,57,26,027.60 4,61,969.20 89,85,037.60 55173034.4 3.90% 125393.26 239442 -47.63 
Transformer S/S
11 KV Line on 8.5 m PCC pole w ith rabbit
4 Nos 1,730 48,02,32,569.24 65,78,324.26 20,74,95,142.97 694306036.5 49.00% 401332.9691 501846 -20.03 
conductor
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole w ith
5 Nos 36 2,98,23,754.79 3,01,236.44 37,22,873.40 33847864.63 2.40% 940218.4619 845780 11.17 
AB Cable (3*120 sq mm)
11 KV New UG Line w ith 3x185 Sq. mm.
6 Nos 35 7,92,08,568.25 2,04,63,380.00 3,94,00,903.50 139072851.8 9.80% 3973510.05 6744793 -41.09 
XLPE cable double circuit
11 KV line at Railw ay Crossing w ith
7 3x185 sq. mm. XLPE cable double circuit Nos 10 52,07,270.38 1,45,13,295.68 21,03,167.56 21823733.62 1.50% 2182373.362 2016577 8.22 
150 m
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation Nos 135 5,55,43,024.35 5,61,078.90 93,69,418.50 65473521.75 4.60% 484989.05 561471 -13.62 
3 phase 4 w ire LT Line ACSR Rabbit
9 Nos 138 2,78,21,377.39 2,81,025.24 1,00,78,356.66 38180759.3 2.70% 276672.1688 334325 -17.24 
conductor on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq
10 Nos 67 2,74,72,036.70 2,77,516.42 77,93,190.09 35542743.21 2.50% 530488.7046 653302 -18.80 
mm) on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole
11 Nos 68 1,95,60,775.82 1,97,605.52 77,53,849.60 27512230.94 1.90% 404591.6315 486116 -16.77 
Extension of substation control room
12 Nos 38 2,98,31,523.80 29831523.8 2.10% 785040.1 570905 37.51 
building
Total 1,01,10,40,060.27 4,60,64,467.92 36,09,89,365.30 1,41,80,93,893.49
50
Reasonability of Rate (Bulandshahr-79)
1. Cost of DPR is Rs. 245.96 Cr. (excluding GST but including 3% contingency, 1.5% T&P, & 21%
turnkey charges).
L-1 Package Value is (–)42.34% Lower w.r.t. Cost of DPR.
schedules for the purpose of capitalization. Hence to find actual difference from the DPR cost,
comparison of cost of work (excluding 3% contingency, 1.5% T&P, & 21% turnkey charges in the DPR
cost) has been done which is bifurcated in supply and erection + F&I as under :-

Sl.No. Type of Cost
1 Cost of supply of items whose SIR available 85.74 75.01 (-)12.51
Cost of Civil Work (Control Room Extension) 2.17 2.98 (+)37.32
51
3. Package value of L-1 Bidder M/s NCC Limited., Hyderabad seems to be reasonable in view of following
reasons:-
(i) The package has attracted as many as 10 bidders; of whom 7 were found to be technically responsive. The
price discovery has thus happened through a highly competitive bidding process.
(ii) Six out of seven bidders have quoted below PVVNL estimate.
(iii)The L-2 Bidder (L&T) have also quoted rates which are very close to the L-1 Bidder’s rate (141.81 Cr. (NCC)
/146.74 Cr. (L&T))
(iv)Following new provisions have been made in the tender clauses by ADB:-
(v) L-1 bidder M/s NCC Limited., Hyderabad are already executing Saubhagya Project of approx. Rs. 500 Cr. in
PVVNL and will therefore have the benefit of very low setup cost
52
Quoted Supply Rate
Stock Total Cost of
Sl. by L1 Bidder M/s DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder
Item Issue Unit Quantity Supply Items % diff erence
No. NCC (T. no. 79)
Item
1 8.5 Mtr. Long PCC Pole SI No. 51374 2493.73 2721.00 128112885.02 139788654.00 -8.35
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs . Long SI No. 3460 4631.22 4671.00 16024021.20 16161660.00 -0.85
4 ACSR Rabbit Conductor SI Km. 5914.6 30874.79 39669.00 182612032.93 234626267.40 -22.17
5 was hers
SI No. 126624 147.25 196.00 18645384.00 24818304.00 -24.87
11 kV Polymer Dis c Ins ulator T&C type 45KN c/w Dis c
6 fittings
SI No. 41520 239.87 264.00 9959402.40 10961280.00 -9.14
11 kV Polymer Dis c Ins ulator B&S type 70 KN c/w Dis c
7 fittings
SI No. 6090 591.37 552.00 3601443.30 3361680.00 7.13
9 PG Clamps for ACSR Rabbit/Weas el RES No. 52305 47.50 257.00 2484487.50 13442385.00 -81.52
buckles ,1.8 m long 16 mm dia. Solid GS Stay Rod, & 7/3.15
10 mm dia. GI s tranded wire complete as per technical
RES No. 54739 1092.49 2027.00 59801810.11 110955953.00 -46.10
s pecification, approved drawings , s chedules and s cope of
work.
MS earthing rod of 20x2500 mm. With acces s ories and 6
11 SWG earthing wire for pole earthing
RES No. 51151 418.00 838.00 21381118.00 42864538.00 -50.12
13 SMC Number Plate with clamp, bolts & nuts No. 4277 118.75 121.00 507893.75 517517.00 -1.86
Guarding angle 75x75x6 mm,1600 mm long with holding
16 clamp, N&B etc. (16 Nos / km of guarding)
No. 6920 832.19 609.00 5758754.80 4214280.00 36.65
G.I. Wire No. 6 SWG (330 Kg / km of guarding - along the
17 s pan - )
SI Kg 142725 58.19 60.73 8305167.75 8667689.25 -4.18
G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG (110 Kg / km of guarding - acros s the
18 s pan )
SI Kg 47575 58.19 60.26 2768389.25 2866869.50 -3.44
23 11KV ' V' type Cros s arm 100x50x6 mm, M.S. Channel SI No. 3806 770.01 535.00 2930658.06 2036210.00 43.93
26 `F' Bracket RES No. 43596 157.37 265.00 6860702.52 11552940.00 -40.62
27 Turn buckle No. 1730 162.69 66.00 281453.70 114180.00 146.50
28 G.I. Wire 6 SWG along the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 7266 58.19 60.73 422808.54 441264.18 -4.18
29 G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG acros s the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 4844 58.19 60.26 281872.36 291899.44 -3.44
Armour rod with ferrules for ACSR Dog/Raccoon Helical
31 Performed
Set 519 356.25 253.00 184893.75 131307.00 40.81
Top channel 100x50 mm 2240 mm (7.9 kg/M) with clamp,
35 No. 7055 1445.47 823.00 10197790.85 5806265.00 75.63
nuts & bolts .
53
Quoted Supply Rate
Stock Total Cost of
Item Issue Unit Quantity Supply Items % diff erence
No. NCC (T. no. 79)
Item
GI Angle Iron 65x65x6 mm,2700 mm long bracing with 4
37 clamp
No. 6920 1797.91 2735.00 12441537.20 18926200.00 -34.26
38 È' Bracket RES No. 10785 151.33 421.00 1632094.05 4540485.00 -64.05
39 11 KV 3x120 s q. mm AB Cable (with bare mes s enger wire) SI Km. 37.8 651933.06 654000.00 24643069.67 24721200.00 -0.32
41 Channel 125x65x6mm (500 mm long) with back clamp No. 900 443.74 500.00 399366.00 450000.00 -11.25
43 Pole Clamps Pair 1800 201.35 155.00 362430.00 279000.00 29.90
Pole Clamps Pair 5400 134.52 156.00 726408.00 842400.00 -13.77
Heat Shrinkable 1 ph. termination kit outdoor for 11 kV
44 3x120 Sq. mm. AB cable
No. 432 1365.62 1100.00 589947.84 475200.00 24.15
45 Mid Span Jointing Sleeves (120 s q. mm) No. 144 118.75 140.90 17100.00 20289.60 -15.72
46 Straight through jointing kit (all s ize) No. 36 894.18 5500.00 32190.48 198000.00 -83.74
49 11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Ins ulated cable, 3x185 s q. mm SI Mtr. 89000 831.24 891.00 73980360.00 79299000.00 -6.71
Heat Shrinkable jointing / termination kits outdoor for 11 kV
50 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE Cable
No. 887 1484.36 7680.00 1316627.32 6812160.00 -80.67
51 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 2256 1306.24 800.00 2946877.44 1804800.00 63.28
HDPE pipe 160 mm Dia. for Cable Laying at Road Cros s ing,
52 etc (for laying by HDD Method)
Mtr. 8040 475.00 3449.00 3819000.00 27729960.00 -86.23
54 S.T.P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. SI No. 672 14249.90 15049.00 9575932.80 10112928.00 -5.31
55 nuts & bolts .
RES No. 2138 1705.30 823.00 3645931.40 1759574.00 107.21
56 fittings
SI No. 603 591.37 552.00 356596.11 332856.00 7.13
59 Holding clamps for channel with N&B RES Set 8324 134.52 259.00 1119744.48 2155916.00 -48.06
11 KV Outgoing VCB indoor type with CTR 400/200/5A 350
62 MVA (Compatible with exis ting VCB at 33/11 KV Sub- SI No. 135 255310.76 296127.00 34466952.60 39977145.00 -13.78
s tation )
Rearrangement for connecting New 11 KV Switchgear
63 with exis ting 11 KV Switchgears (Adopter Panel)
No. 135 47499.68 40000.00 6412456.80 5400000.00 18.75
Heat Shrinkable jointing kit s uitable for 11 KV XLPE
64 3x185 s q. mm cable s ize (indoor)
No. 135 1163.74 19326.00 157104.90 2609010.00 -93.98
65 11KV Polymer Dis c Ins ulator T&C type 45 KN with fittings SI No. 6216 239.87 264.00 1491031.92 1641024.00 -9.14
Holding clamps for top channel & Fus e s et etc. with bolts
66 & nuts
RES No. 14080 134.52 259.00 1894041.60 3646720.00 -48.06
67 11 KV TPMO RES No. 2072 7124.95 18292.00 14762896.40 37901024.00 -61.05
68 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 2072 2849.98 7028.00 5905158.56 14562016.00 -59.45
RES No. 405 418.00 838.00 169290.00 339390.00 -50.12
70 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 405 321.61 396.00 130252.05 160380.00 -18.79
54
Quoted Supply Rate
Stock Total DPR Cost
Item Issue Unit Quantity Resspo Rate % diff erence
No. NCC (T. no. 79)
Item
72 LT Shakle Ins ulator 100x115 mm RES No. 11040 14.25 36.00 157320.00 397440.00 -60.42
73 Bolts and nuts for s hackle ins ulators RES Kg. 4140 89.06 196.00 368708.40 811440.00 -54.56
74 Loop Guard complete, 3-Phas e RES No. 5520 59.37 46.00 327722.40 253920.00 29.07
75 Earth wire clamp Kg. 828 478.56 336.00 396247.68 278208.00 42.43
77 Sus pens ion (Ins ulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 2700 130.62 266.20 352674.00 718740.00 -50.93
95/50 s q. mm - 70/35 s q. mm PG Clamp (For line to
78 No. 4050 47.50 133.10 192375.00 539055.00 -64.31
LT Ins ulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50 s q. mm -50-
79 No. 12150 118.75 199.65 1442812.50 2425747.50 -40.52
35 s q. mm s ize for energizing dis tribution kios k/box
LT Ins ulation Piercing connectors (16 s q. mm -16 s q. mm)
80 No. 4050 53.44 121.00 216432.00 490050.00 -55.83
s uitable for s treet light connection
81 Mid s pan jointing s leeves (95 s q. mm) No. 268 47.50 121.00 12730.00 32428.00 -60.74
connections & s ealing
83 Ins ulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 s q. mm SI Km. 70.4 239873.37 250194.00 16887085.25 17613657.60 -4.13
84 On/Off s with for s treet light connections No. 2700 486.87 605.00 1314549.00 1633500.00 -19.53
1x35 mm2 XLPE/PVC ins ulated AL. cable for energis ing
85 Mtr. 27000 35.62 67.00 961740.00 1809000.00 -46.84
the dis tribution boxes /kios ks .
2x16 mm2 XLPE/PVC ins ulated Al. cable for energis ing the
86 Mtr. 4050 36.81 40.00 149080.50 162000.00 -7.97
s treet light
89 11/0.44 kV 100 KVA Trans former (Four Star Rating, Level-II) SI No. 752 117561.70 136710.00 88406398.40 102805920.00 -14.01
91 GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp for T/F bas e No. 3874 1018.82 1778.00 3946908.68 6887972.00 -42.70
SMC Dis tribution box having 200 A, 4 Pole ,MCCB for 3 ph,
94 RES No. 752 9998.68 14641.00 7519007.36 11010032.00 -31.71
100 KVA Trans former
Chemical Pipe Earthing (80 mm dia, 3 m long Pipe) as per
95 No. 3874 2137.49 3500.00 8280636.26 13559000.00 -38.93
s pecification
96 LT PVC 3.5 x150/70 s qmm Cable RES Mtr. 15040 415.62 409.00 6250924.80 6151360.00 1.62
97 ACSR W eas el conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 48425 20.31 23.98 983511.75 1161231.50 -15.30
Extra for Al. tape , binding wire, jointing s leeves , PG clamps
100 ls 1937 653.12 250.00 1265093.44 484250.00 161.25
etc.
102 RES No. 745 7243.70 14641.00 5396556.50 10907545.00 -50.52
63 KVA Trans former
106 RES No. 440 4645.47 14641.00 2044006.80 6442040.00 -68.27
25 KVA Trans former
TOTAL 1011040060.27 1365427837.77
TOTAL (Cr.) 101.10 136.54
55
Quoted Supply
Stock Cost of Supply
Sl. Quantity Rate by L1 Bidder DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder
Item Issue Unit Items % difference
No. M/s NCC (T. no. 79)
Item
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs. Long SI No. 3460 4631.22 4671.00 16024021.20 16161660.00 -0.85
11 KV Composite Polymer Pin Insulator with Nut 196.00 18645384.00 24818304.00 -24.87
4 SI No. 126624 147.25
and washers
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45KN c/w 264.00 9959402.40 10961280.00 -9.14
5 SI No. 41520 239.87
Disc fittings
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type 70 KN c/w 552.00 3601443.30 3361680.00 7.13
6 SI No. 6090 591.37
Disc fittings
G.I. Wire No. 6 SWG (330 Kg / km of guarding - 60.73 8305167.75 8667689.25 -4.18
7 SI Kg 142725 58.19
along the span - )
G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG (110 Kg / km of guarding - 60.26 2768389.25 2866869.50 -3.44
8 SI Kg 47575 58.19
across the span )
11KV ' V' type Cross arm 100x50x6 mm, M.S. 535.00 2930658.06 2036210.00 43.93
10 SI No. 3806 770.01
Channel
11 G.I. Wire 6 SWG along the span (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 7266 58.19 60.73 422808.54 441264.18 -4.18
G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG across the span (For 50 Mtr. 60.26 281872.36 291899.44 -3.44
12 SI Kg. 4844 58.19
line)
11KV `V' type Cross arm 65x65x6 mm, M.S. 535.00 16626061.20 15734350.00 5.67
13 SI No. 29410 565.32
Angle
11 KV 3x120 sq. mm AB Cable (with bare 654000.00 24643069.67 24721200.00 -0.32
14 SI Km. 37.8 651933.06
messenger wire)
11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Insulated cable, 3x185 891.00 73980360.00 79299000.00 -6.71
15 SI Mtr. 89000 831.24
sq. mm
16 S.T. P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. SI No. 672 14249.90 15049.00 9575932.80 10112928.00 -5.31
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type 70 KN c/w 552.00 356596.11 332856.00 7.13
17 SI No. 603 591.37
Disc fittings
18 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with existing SI No. 135 255310.76 296127.00 34466952.60 39977145.00 -13.78
11KV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45 KN with 264.00 1491031.92 1641024.00 -9.14
19 SI No. 6216 239.87
fittings
22 SI No. 752 117561.70
Rating, Level-II)
23 ACSR Weasel conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 48425 20.31 23.98 983511.75 1161231.50 -15.30
24 SI No. 745 92624.37
Rating, Level-II)
25 SI No. 440 52249.64
Rating, Level-II)
TOTAL 750111346.42 857429525.67
TOTA L (Cr.) 75.01 85.74 56
Quoted Supply
Sl. Quantity Rate by L1 Bidder DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder
Item Issue Unit Items % difference
Item
RES No. 54739 1092.49 2027.00 59801810.11 110955953.00 -46.10
work.
MS earthing rod of 20x2500 mm. With acces s ories and
4 6 SWG earthing wire for pole earthing
RES No. 51151 418.00 838.00 21381118.00 42864538.00 -50.12
9 `F' Bracket RES No. 43596 157.37 265.00 6860702.52 11552940.00 -40.62
12 È' Bracket RES No. 10785 151.33 421.00 1632094.05 4540485.00 -64.05
13 nuts & bolts .
RES No. 2138 1705.30 823.00 3645931.40 1759574.00 107.21
16 & nuts
RES No. 14080 134.52 259.00 1894041.60 3646720.00 -48.06
17 11 KV TPMO RES No. 2072 7124.95 18292.00 14762896.40 37901024.00 -61.05
18 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 2072 2849.98 7028.00 5905158.56 14562016.00 -59.45
RES No. 405 418.00 838.00 169290.00 339390.00 -50.12
SMC Dis tribution box having 200 A, 4 Pole ,MCCB for 3
25 ph, 100 KVA Trans former
RES No. 752 9998.68 14641.00 7519007.36 11010032.00 -31.71
RES No. 745 7243.70 14641.00 5396556.50 10907545.00 -50.52
RES No. 440 4645.47 14641.00 2044006.80 6442040.00 -68.27
TOTAL 176384129.55 349455568.00
TOTAL (Cr.) 17.64 34.95
57
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder NCC w.r.t Stock Issue Rate 2019-20 cost schedule 18-19 (T. No 79)
Stock Quoted Supply DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder Cost of Supply
Sl.
Item Issue Unit Quantity % difference
No. Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)
Item
Guarding angle 75x75x6 mm,1600 mm long
3 with holding clamp, N&B etc. (16 Nos / km of No. 6920 832.19 609.00 5758754.80 4214280.00 36.65
guarding)
GI Binding Wire 16 SWG (1 Kg / km of
6 Kg 433 65.31 92.50 28279.23 40052.50 -29.39
guarding)
GI. guarding Angle Iron 75x75x6 mm 3010
7 No. 346 1447.02 2134.00 500668.92 738364.00 -32.19
mm long
8 Turn buckle No. 1730 162.69 66.00 281453.70 114180.00 146.50
Armour rod with ferrules for ACSR
10 Set 519 356.25 253.00 184893.75 131307.00 40.81
Dog/Raccoon Helical Performed
Top channel 100x50 mm 2240 mm (7.9 kg/M)
11 No. 7055 1445.47 823.00 10197790.85 5806265.00 75.63
with clamp, nuts & bolts.
GI Angle Iron 65x65x6 mm,2700 mm long
13 No. 6920 1797.91 2735.00 12441537.20 18926200.00 -34.26
bracing with 4 clamp
Channel 125x65x6mm (500 mm long) with back
15 No. 900 443.74 500.00 399366.00 450000.00 -11.25
clamp
17 Pole Clamps Pair 1800 201.35 155.00 362430.00 279000.00 29.90
Pole Clamps Pair 5400 134.52 156.00 726408.00 842400.00 -13.77
Heat Shrinkable 1 ph. termination kit outdoor
18 No. 432 1365.62 1100.00 589947.84 475200.00 24.15
for 11 kV 3x120 Sq. mm. AB cable
19 Mid Span Jointing Sleeves (120 sq. mm) No. 144 118.75 140.90 17100.00 20289.60 -15.72
20 Straight through jointing kit (all size) No. 36 894.18 5500.00 32190.48 198000.00 -83.74
Heat Shrinkable jointing / termination kits
23 No. 887 1484.36 7680.00 1316627.32 6812160.00 -80.67
outdoor for 11 kV 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE Cable
24 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 2256 1306.24 800.00 2946877.44 1804800.00 63.28
HDPE pipe 160 mm Dia. for Cable Laying at
25 Road Crossing, etc (for laying by HDD Mtr. 8040 475.00 3449.00 3819000.00 27729960.00 -86.23
Method)
Quoted Supply
Sl. Rate by L1 Bidder DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder
Item Issue Unit Quantity Items % diff erence
Item
30 Switchgear with exis ting 11 KV Switchgears No. 135 47499.68 40000.00 6412456.80 5400000.00 18.75
(Adopter Panel)
Heat Shrinkable jointing kit s uitable for 11
31 No. 135 1163.74 19326.00 157104.90 2609010.00 -93.98
KV XLPE 3x185 s q. mm cable s ize (indoor)
32 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 405 321.61 396.00 130252.05 160380.00 -18.79
95/50 s q. mm - 70/35 s q. mm PG Clamp
36 (For line to line to line jumpering & No. 4050 47.50 133.10 192375.00 539055.00 -64.31
energizing DB neutral)
LT Ins ulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50
37 s q. mm -50-35 s q. mm s ize for energizing No. 12150 118.75 199.65 1442812.50 2425747.50 -40.52
dis tribution kios k/box
LT Ins ulation Piercing connectors (16 s q. mm -
38 16 s q. mm) s uitable for s treet light connection
No. 4050 53.44 121.00 216432.00 490050.00 -55.83
LT SMC dis tribution boxes 3 phas e on the LT
40 Poles including all clamps & material required No. 2700 819.37 2420.00 2212299.00 6534000.00 -66.14
for mounting connections & s ealing
1x35 mm2 XLPE/PVC ins ulated AL. cable for
42 Mtr. 27000 35.62 67.00 961740.00 1809000.00 -46.84
energis ing the dis tribution boxes /kios ks .
2x16 mm2 XLPE/PVC ins ulated Al. cable for
43 Mtr. 4050 36.81 40.00 149080.50 162000.00 -7.97
energis ing the s treet light
GI Channel 100x50x6, 2028 mm (for Dropper
45 No. 5811 1027.35 748.00 5969930.85 4346628.00 37.35
Fus e s et)
GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp
46 No. 3874 1018.82 1778.00 3946908.68 6887972.00 -42.70
for T/F bas e
Chemical Pipe Earthing (80 mm dia, 3 m long
48 No. 3874 2137.49 3500.00 8280636.26 13559000.00 -38.93
Pipe) as per s pecification
Extra for Al. tape , binding wire, jointing
51 ls 1937 653.12 250.00 1265093.44 484250.00 161.25
s leeves , PG clamps etc.
TOTAL 84544584.30 158542744.10
TOTAL (Cr.) 8.45 15.85 59
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder NCC w.r.t PVVNL tender rate (T. No- 79)
Quoted Supply Rate

PVVNL Total Cost L1 Cost of Supply
by L1 Bidder M/s %
Sl. No. Item Unit Quantity Tender Rate Bidder Items
NCC.(T. no. 79) difference

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
3 No. 126624 147.25 178.47 18645384.00 22599164.75 -17.50
Nut and washers
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator T&C type 45KN
4 No. 41520 239.87 141.30 9959402.40 5866635.25 69.76
c/w Disc fittings
5 Kg 142725 58.19 56.00 8305167.75 7992600.00 3.91
along the span - )
6 Kg 47575 58.19 56.00 2768389.25 2664200.00 3.91
across the span )
8 No. 29410 565.32 665.00 16626061.20 19557650.00 -14.99
Angle
9 mtr 89000 831.24 775.42 73980360.00 69012711.86 7.20
3x185 sq. mm
11 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with No. 135 255310.76 255000.00 34466952.60 34425000.00 0.12
13 Insulated ABC of 3x50+1x35+1x16 sq. mm Km. 71.4 123499.16 127425.42 8817840.02 9098175.25 -3.08
14 No. 752 117561.70 94745.76 88406398.40 71248813.56 24.08
Rating, Level-II)
16 No. 745 92624.37 89055.00 69005155.65 66345975.00 4.01
Rating, Level-II)
17 No. 440 52249.64 47649 22989841.60 20965560.00 9.66
Rating, Level-II)
TOTAL 700359845.27 633051177.63
TOTAL (Cr.) 70.04 63.31
60
Activity wise comparison of L-1 Bidder Rate (Supply to Supply/Incidental to incidental/Installation to installation) T-79 (Bulandshahr)
Sl. No. Item Qty UoM As per L-1 As per L-1
As per DPR % Variation As per DPR % Variation As per L-1 Bidder As per DPR % Variation As per L-1 Bidder As per DPR % Variation
Bidder Bidder
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
1
Distribution Transformer S/S
752 Nos 174478 272599 -35.99 1763 18684 -90.57 23941 37927 -36.87 200182 329209 -39.19
63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
2
Distribution Transformer
745 Nos 146627 250445 -41.45 1481 13556 -89.07 22083 24017 -8.05 170191 288018 -40.91
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV
3
440 Nos 103923 193809 -46.38 1050 13567 -92.26 20421 32067 -36.32 125393 239442 -47.63
11 KV Line on 8.5 m PCC pole

4
with rabbit conductor
1730 km 277591 354051 -21.60 3802 21578 -82.38 119939 126217 -4.97 401333 501846 -20.03
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC

5 pole with AB Cable (3*120 sq 36 km 828438 742354 11.60 8368 51965 -83.90 103413 51462 100.95 940218 845780 11.17
mm)
11 KV New UG Line with 3x185

6 Sq. mm. XLPE cable double 35 km 2263102 3202235 -29.33 584668 779522 -25.00 1125740 2763037 -59.26 3973510 6744793 -41.09
circuit
11 KV line at Railway Crossing

7 with 3x185 sq. mm. XLPE cable 10 Nos 520727 721650 -27.84 1451330 1160139 25.10 210317 134789 56.03 2182373 2016577 8.22
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation 135 Nos 411430 510386 -19.39 4156 17215 -75.86 69403 33870 104.91 484989 561471 -13.62
3 phase 4 wire LT Line ACSR

9 Rabbit conductor on 8.5 mtr 138 km 201604 276182 -27.00 2036 17490 -88.36 73032 40652 79.65 276672 334325 -17.24
PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

10 (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm) on 67 km 410030 548821 -25.29 4142 38373 -89.21 116316 66108 75.95 530489 653302 -18.80
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

11 (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) on 68 km 287658 400782 -28.23 2906 28055 -89.64 114027 57279 99.07 404592 486116 -16.77
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
Extension of s/s Control Room

12
Building
38 Nos 0 0 0 0 785040 570905 37.51 785040 570905 37.51
61
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder NCC w.r.t Stock Issue Rate (Tender No- 79)
Quoted Supply Rate by As per DPR
Stock As per DPR (Stock As per DPR (Stock
L1 Bidder M/s NCC. (T. % (Stock issue rate %
Sl. No. Item Issue Unit Quantity issue rate 20-21) % difference issue rate 19-20)
no. 70) difference 18-19) difference
Item
1 8.5 Mtr. Long PCC Pole SI No. 51374 2493.73 2509.00 -0.61 2578.00 -3.27 2721.00 -8.35
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs. Long SI No. 3460 4631.22 4522.94 2.39 4504.00 2.82 4671.00 -0.85
3 ACSR Rabbit Conductor SI Km. 5914.6 30874.79 37758.00 -18.23 38984.00 -20.80 39669.00 -22.17
4 SI No. 126624 147.25 182.00 -19.09 190.00 -22.50 384.00 -61.65
Nut and washers
5 SI No. 41520 239.87 254.00 -5.56 251.00 -4.43 287.00 -16.42
11 kV Polymer Disc Insulator B&S type 70
6 SI No. 6090 591.37 872.78 -32.24 704.00 -16.00 552.00 7.13
KN c/w Disc fittings
7 SI Kg 142725 58.19 63.40 -8.22 73.59 -20.93 54.8 6.19
8 SI Kg 47575 58.19 66.78 -12.86 73.66 -21.00 54.8 6.19
11KV ' V' type Cross arm 100x50x6 mm, M.S.
10 SI No. 3806 770.01 625.00 23.20 618.00 24.60 744 3.50
Channel
11 SI No. 29410 565.32 624.93 -9.54 618.00 -8.52 744 -24.02
Angle
12 SI Km. 37.8 651933.06 742000.00 -12.14 774000.00 -15.77 548000 18.97
messenger wire)
13 SI Mtr. 89000 831.24 992.00 -16.21 980.00 -15.18 725 14.65
3x185 sq. mm
14 S.T.P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. SI No. 672 14249.90 15019.04 -5.12 17858.00 -20.20 15049 -5.31
15 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with SI No. 135 255310.76 340737.98 -25.07 290357.00 -12.07 353384 -27.75
16 Insulated ABC of 3x95+1x70+1x16 sq. mm SI Km. 70.4 239873.37 256513.00 -6.49 258683.00 -7.27 224969 6.63
17 Insulated ABC of 3x50+1x35+1x16 sq. mm SI Km. 71.4 123499.16 143597.00 -14.00 147192.00 -16.10 127687 -3.28
18 SI No. 752 117561.70 133150.00 -11.71 145906.00 -19.43 136710 -14.01
Rating, Level-II)
19 ACSR Weasel conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 48425 20.31 22.90 -11.31 24.82 -18.17 28.38 -28.44
20 SI No. 745 92624.37 107144.09 -13.55 105626.00 -12.31 104596 -11.45
Rating, Level-II)
21 SI No. 440 52249.64 57181.95 -8.63 58718.00 -11.02 56780 -7.98
Rating, Level-II)
62
in
Meerut Zone
63
Summary of Feeders & Project Cost ( Meerut Zone)
Shifted load on
on existing on Agriculture Agriculture (As per stock (As per stock
Zone No. of Substation considered for New Domestic domestic
feeders feeders feeder issue rate 2018- issue rate 2018-
(MVA) (MVA) (No) 19) 19)
(MVA)
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Meerut Zone 40 92 53 154.2 48.30 105.90 17601 106.32 90.10

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1 NCC LIMITED Yes 594856629.55 L1 579075478 L1
2 M/s. Ashoka Buildcon Ltd Yes 619000226.88 L2 619000226.9 L2
3 TATA Projects Limited Yes 660939494.90 L3 645173951.9 L3
4 VIKRAN Engineering and Exim Pvt Ltd Yes 775537170.00 L4 758709556.4 L4
5 Transrail Lighting Limited Yes 818575467.22 L5 774331292.8 L5
6 VIBHOR VAIBHAV INFRA PRIVATE LIMITED Yes 860111555.19 L6 844419678.9 L6
7 Vishwanath Projects Limited Yes 958607271.58 L7 937720849.5 L7
8 Ircon International Limited Yes 1006126102.22 L8 971861581.4 L8
9 Raj Shyama Constructions Pvt. Ltd. Yes 1575980699.17 L9 1560069456 L9
Debarred for 3 Years vide MVVNL OM no. 3082 dated 31.12.18 and circulated vide UPPCL letter no. 529 dated
10 East India Udyog Limited, Ghaziabad No
09.04.2020
11 Jakson Limited, New Delhi No Executed One single project of Rs. 78.81 Cr. during last 5 years against required value Rs. 106.32 Cr.
12 Kanti Prasad Mittal and JSP Project Pvt Ltd., (JV) No Constructed 521 km. line against required 539 km.
13 VM Infraprojects Pvt. Ltd. No Did not deposit tender Cost & EMD
14 Offshore Infrastructure Limited, Mumbai No

Pavani Controls and Panels Limited & K. Bhupal Firm refused to extend bid validity upto 20.08.2020 as requested by PVVNL.
15 No
Engineers & Contractors Pvt Ltd (JV)
64
Tender No. 80 (Meerut Zone)
bidders
1 2 3 4 5
1 NCC LIMITED L1 579075478 —
2 Ashoka Buildcon Ltd L2 619000226.9 -6.45
3 TATA Projects Limited L3 645173951.9 -10.25

4 VIKRAN Engineering and Exim Pvt Ltd L4 758709556.4 -23.68
5 Transrail Lighting Limited L5 774331292.8 -25.22
6 VIBHOR VAIBHAV INFRA PRIVATE LIMITED L6 844419678.9 -31.42

7 Vishwanath Projects Limited L7 937720849.5 -38.25
8 Ircon International Limited L8 971861581.4 -40.42
9 Raj Shyama Constructions Pvt. Ltd. L9 1560069456 -62.88
65
T&P, 21% turnkey
(Rs. Cr.)
(Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6
90.10 71.41
M/s NCC Limited,
57.90 70.94
Hyderabad 89.51
(Revised DPR prepared on the
(Revised DPR prepared on the basis (-)35.31 (-)18.38
basis of Stock issue rate 19-
of Stock issue rate 19-20)
20)

Bid %
Rank Variation
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
90.10 71.41
M/s Ashoka Buildcon L-2 61.90 (-)31.29 (-)13.32
Rs. 4 Cr.
6.90%
66
Sl. Evaluated Cost Estimated Variation

%age of Evaluated per
Item Description UoM Quantity per unit
Bid unit rate From
No. Supply Incidental Installation Total rate %age
Estimate
1 km 267 5,16,15,935.37 5,21,418.96 70,41,804.60 5,91,79,158.93 10.20% 221645 329209 -32.67 
Transformer S/S
2 km 253 4,11,02,124.47 4,15,218.54 61,51,702.59 4,76,69,045.60 8.20% 188415 288018 -34.58 
Transformer
3 km 144 1,65,80,733.12 1,67,509.44 32,36,083.20 1,99,84,325.76 3.50% 138780 239442 -42.04 
Transformer S/S
4 Nos 639 19,65,56,614.38 26,23,000.65 8,40,63,971.02 28,32,43,586.05 48.90% 443261 501846 -11.67 
conductor
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole w ith
5 Nos 13 1,19,68,694.72 1,20,896.55 14,78,089.60 1,35,67,680.87 2.30% 1043668 845780 23.40 
AB Cable (3*120 sq mm)
6 Nos 13 3,25,97,204.25 76,32,595.10 1,61,98,081.90 5,64,27,881.25 9.70% 4340606 6744793 -35.65 
11 KV line at Railw ay Crossing w ith
7 Nos 4 22,19,061.40 55,84,212.80 8,93,681.40 86,96,955.60 1.50% 2174239 2016577 7.82 
3x185 sq. mm. XLPE cable double circuit
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation Nos 53 2,41,60,335.14 2,44,039.03 40,64,268.96 2,84,68,643.13 4.90% 537144 561471 -4.33 
9 Nos 50 1,11,68,213.54 1,12,812.24 40,08,376.50 1,52,89,402.28 2.60% 305788 334325 -8.54 
10 Nos 26 1,18,06,777.57 1,19,274.73 33,17,962.96 1,52,44,015.25 2.60% 586308 653302 -10.25 
11 Nos 29 93,18,132.42 93,447.62 36,27,253.88 1,30,38,833.92 2.30% 449615 486116 -7.51 
12 Nos 21 1,82,65,949.31 1,82,65,949.31 3.20% 869807 570905 52.36 
building
Total 40,90,93,826.38 1,76,34,425.65 15,23,47,225.92 57,90,75,477.95
67
Reasonability of Rate(Meerut Zone-80)
charges).

Sl.No. Type of Cost
68
3. Package value of L-1 Bidder M/s NCC Limited., Hyderabad seems to be reasonable in view of following reasons:-
(i) The package has attracted as many as 15 bidders; of whom 9 were found to be technically responsive for opening their
price bid. The price discovery has thus happened through a highly competitive bidding process.
(ii) Six out of nine bidders have quoted below PVVNL estimate.
(iii)The L-2 (M/s Ashoka Buildcon) Bidder have also quoted rates which are very close to the L-1 Bidder’s rate (57.90
Cr./61.90 Cr.)
(iv)Had M/s L&T Ltd. (L-2 bidder of T-79) participated in T-80, considering the quoted rate of items of L&T of T-79
(BSR Zone) in T-80, the package value of L&T in T-80 has been worked out as Rs. 54.51 Cr. In that case M/s L&T
would have emerged as lowest bidder in T-80 and package value of M/s NCC Ltd. shall be (+)6.21% w.r.t. M/s L&T
calculated package value.
(vi) L-1 bidder M/s NCC Limited., Hyderabad are already executing Saubhagya Project of approx. Rs. 500 Cr. in PVVNL
and will therefore have the benefit of very low setup cost 69
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder NCC w.r.t DPR/Resspo/ Market Rate 2018-19 (T. NO 80)
Quoted Supply
Total Cost of Supply
Item Item Unit Quantity Items % diff erence
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
4 ACSR Rabbit Conductor SI Km. 2181 34208.59 39669.00 74608934.79 86518089.00 -13.76
5 was hers
SI No. 46626 163.15 196.00 7607031.90 9138696.00 -16.76
6 fittings
SI No. 15336 265.77 264.00 4075848.72 4048704.00 0.67
7 fittings
SI No. 2242 655.23 552.00 1469025.66 1237584.00 18.70
RES No. 20100 1210.46 2027.00 24330246.00 40742700.00 -40.28
work.
MS earthing rod of 20x2500 mm. W ith acces s ories and 6
11 SW G earthing wire for pole earthing
RES No. 18831 463.13 838.00 8721201.03 15780378.00 -44.73
No. 2557 922.05 609.00 2357681.85 1557213.00 51.40
G.I. W ire No. 6 SW G (330 Kg / km of guarding - along the
17 s pan - )
SI Kg 52734 64.47 60.73 3399760.98 3202535.82 6.16
G.I. W ire No. 8 SW G (110 Kg / km of guarding - acros s the
18 s pan )
SI Kg 17578 64.47 60.26 1133253.66 1059250.28 6.99
26 `F' Bracket RES No. 16103 174.37 265.00 2807880.11 4267295.00 -34.20
27 Turn buckle No. 640 180.25 66.00 115360.00 42240.00 173.11
28 G.I. W ire 6 SW G along the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 2688 64.47 60.73 173295.36 163242.24 6.16
29 G.I. W ire No. 8 SW G acros s the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 1792 64.47 60.26 115530.24 107985.92 6.99
31 Performed
Set 192 394.71 253.00 75784.32 48576.00 56.01
35 nuts & bolts .
No. 2609 1601.55 823.00 4178443.95 2147207.00 94.60
70
Quoted Supply
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
37 clamp
No. 2556 1992.04 2735.00 5091654.24 6990660.00 -27.16
38 È' Bracket RES No. 3993 167.67 421.00 669506.31 1681053.00 -60.17
39 11 KV 3x120 s q. mm AB Cable (with bare mes s enger wire) SI Km. 13.7 722327.44 654000.00 9895885.93 8959800.00 10.45
43 Pole Clamps Pair 650 223.09 155.00 145008.50 100750.00 43.93
Pole Clamps Pair 2200 149.04 156.00 327888.00 343200.00 -4.46
No. 156 1513.07 1100.00 236038.92 171600.00 37.55
49 11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Ins ulated cable, 3x185 s q. mm SI Mtr. 33280 921.00 891.00 30650880.00 29652480.00 3.37
No. 333 1644.64 7680.00 547665.12 2557440.00 -78.59
51 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 840 1447.29 800.00 1215723.60 672000.00 80.91
Mtr. 3000 526.29 3449.00 1578870.00 10347000.00 -84.74
55 nuts & bolts .
RES No. 739 1889.43 823.00 1396288.77 608197.00 129.58
56 fittings
SI No. 225 655.23 552.00 147426.75 124200.00 18.70
s tation )
No. 53 52628.59 40000.00 2789315.27 2120000.00 31.57
No. 53 1289.40 19326.00 68338.20 1024278.00 -93.33
65 11KV Polymer Dis c Ins ulator T&C type 45 KN with fittings SI No. 2151 265.77 264.00 571671.27 567864.00 0.67
66 & nuts
RES No. 4788 149.04 259.00 713603.52 1240092.00 -42.46
67 11 KV TPMO RES No. 717 7894.29 18292.00 5660205.93 13115364.00 -56.84
68 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 717 3157.72 7028.00 2264085.24 5039076.00 -55.07
RES No. 159 463.13 838.00 73637.67 133242.00 -44.73
70 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 159 356.34 396.00 56658.06 62964.00 -10.02
71
Quoted Supply
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
78 line to line jumpering & energizing DB neutral)
No. 1650 52.63 133.10 86839.50 219615.00 -60.46
79 35 s q. mm s ize for energizing dis tribution kios k/box
No. 4950 131.57 199.65 651271.50 988267.50 -34.10
80 s uitable for s treet light connection
No. 1650 59.21 121.00 97696.50 199650.00 -51.07
85 the dis tribution boxes /kios ks .
Mtr. 11000 39.47 67.00 434170.00 737000.00 -41.09
86 s treet light
Mtr. 1650 40.79 40.00 67303.50 66000.00 1.98
88 Ins ulated ABC of 3x50+1x35+1x16 s q. mm SI Km. 31 136834.34 138727.00 4241864.54 4300537.00 -1.36
94 100 KVA Trans former
RES No. 267 11078.32 14641.00 2957911.44 3909147.00 -24.33
95 s pecification
No. 1328 2368.29 3500.00 3145089.12 4648000.00 -32.33
97 ACSR Weas el conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 16600 22.50 23.98 373500.00 398068.00 -6.17
100 etc.
ls 664 723.64 250.00 480496.96 166000.00 189.46
RES No. 253 8025.86 14641.00 2030542.58 3704173.00 -45.18
105 11/0.44 kV 25 KVA Trans former (Four Star Rating, Level-II) SI No. 144 57891.45 56780.00 8336368.80 8176320.00 1.96
RES No. 144 5147.08 14641.00 741179.52 2108304.00 -64.84
TOTAL 409093826.38 498110742.76
TOTAL (Cr.) 40.909 49.81
72
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder NCC w.r.t Resspo Rate 2018-19 (T. NO 80)
Quoted Supply
Sl. Rate by L1 Bidder DPR Rate Total Cost L1 Bidder Cost of Supply Items
Item Item Unit Quantity % diff erence
No. M/s NCC. (T. no. 80)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Stay Set ( Galvanis ed) with 50x8 mm s tay clamp,
s tay ins ulator, anchor plate (200x200x6), nut bolts ,
turn buckles ,1.8 m long 16 mm dia. Solid GS Stay
3 RES No. 19959 1210.46 2027.00 24159571.14 40456893.00 -40.28
Rod, & 7/3.15 mm dia. GI s tranded wire complete as
per technical s pecification, approved drawings ,
4 acces s ories and 6 SWG earthing wire for pole RES No. 18831 463.13 838.00 8721201.03 15780378.00 -44.73
earthing
8 RES No. 16742 161.54 304.00 2704502.68 5089568.00 -46.86
nuts
9 `F' Bracket RES No. 16103 174.37 265.00 2807880.11 4267295.00 -34.20
12 È' Bracket RES No. 3993 167.67 421.00 669506.31 1681053.00 -60.17
13 RES No. 739 1889.43 823.00 1396288.77 608197.00 129.58
16 RES No. 4788 149.04 259.00 713603.52 1240092.00 -42.46
bolts & nuts
17 11 KV TPMO RES No. 717 7894.29 18292.00 5660205.93 13115364.00 -56.84
18 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 717 3157.72 7028.00 2264085.24 5039076.00 -55.07
MS earthing rod of 20x2500 mm. With acces s ories
19 RES No. 159 463.13 838.00 73637.67 133242.00 -44.73
and 6 SWG earthing wire for pole earthing
24 RES No. 664 149.04 259.00 98962.56 171976.00 -42.46
Channel
25 RES No. 267 11078.32 14641.00 2957911.44 3909147.00 -24.33
27 RES No. 253 8025.86 14641.00 2030542.58 3704173.00 -45.18
29 RES No. 144 5147.08 14641.00 741179.52 2108304.00 -64.84
TOTAL 70250311.94 125867715.00
TOTAL (Cr.) 7.03 12.59
73
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder NCC w.r.t Stock Issue Rate 2018-19 (T. NO 80)
Quoted Supply
Stock
Item
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
3 ACSR Rabbit Conductor SI Km. 2181 34208.59 39669.00 74608934.79 86518089.00 -13.76
11 KV Compos ite Polymer Pin Ins ulator with Nut
4 and was hers
SI No. 46626 163.15 196.00 7607031.90 9138696.00 -16.76
5 Dis c fittings
SI No. 15336 265.77 264.00 4075848.72 4048704.00 0.67
6 Dis c fittings
SI No. 2242 655.23 552.00 1469025.66 1237584.00 18.70
SI Kg 52734 64.47 60.73 3399760.98 3202535.82 6.16
SI Kg 17578 64.47 60.26 1133253.66 1059250.28 6.99
10 Channel
SI No. 1406 853.15 535.00 1199528.90 752210.00 59.47
11 G.I. Wire 6 SWG along the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 2688 64.47 60.73 173295.36 163242.24 6.16
12 line)
SI Kg. 1792 64.47 60.26 115530.24 107985.92 6.99
14 wire)
SI Km. 13.7 722327.44 654000.00 9895885.93 8959800.00 10.45
15 mm
SI Mtr. 33280 921.00 891.00 30650880.00 29652480.00 3.37
17 Dis c fittings
SI No. 225 655.23 552.00 147426.75 124200.00 18.70
18 400/200/5A 350 MVA (Compatible with exis ting SI No. 53 282878.69 296127.00 14992570.57 15694731.00 -4.47
VCB at 33/11 KV Sub-s tation )
19 fittings
SI No. 2151 265.77 264.00 571671.27 567864.00 0.67
22 Level-II)
SI No. 267 130255.77 136710.00 34778290.59 36501570.00 -4.72
24 Level-II)
SI No. 253 102625.76 104596.00 25964317.28 26462788.00 -1.88
25 Level-II)
SI No. 144 57891.45 56780.00 8336368.80 8176320.00 1.96
TOTAL 304259670.97 313891882.46
TOTAL (Cr.) 30.43 31.39
74
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder NCC w.r.t Market Rate 2018-19 (T. NO 80)
Quoted Supply
Item Unit Quantity % difference
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
No. 2557 922.05 609.00 2357681.85 1557213.00 51.40
8 Turn buckle No. 640 180.25 66.00 115360.00 42240.00 173.11
10 Performed
Set 192 394.71 253.00 75784.32 48576.00 56.01
11 nuts & bolts.
No. 2609 1601.55 823.00 4178443.95 2147207.00 94.60
13 clamp
No. 2556 1992.04 2735.00 5091654.24 6990660.00 -27.16
17 Pole Clamps Pair 650 223.09 155.00 145008.50 100750.00 43.93
Pole Clamps Pair 2200 149.04 156.00 327888.00 343200.00 -4.46
No. 156 1513.07 1100.00 236038.92 171600.00 37.55
No. 333 1644.64 7680.00 547665.12 2557440.00 -78.59
24 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 840 1447.29 800.00 1215723.60 672000.00 80.91
HDPE pipe 160 mm Dia. for Cable Laying at Road Crossing,
Mtr. 3000 526.29 3449.00 1578870.00 10347000.00 -84.74
Quoted Supply
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
30 No. 53 52628.59 40000.00 2789315.27 2120000.00 31.57
with existing 11 KV Switchgears (Adopter Panel)
Heat Shrinkable jointing kit suitable for 11 KV XLPE
31 No. 53 1289.40 19326.00 68338.20 1024278.00 -93.33
3x185 sq. mm cable size (indoor)
32 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 159 356.34 396.00 56658.06 62964.00 -10.02
35 Suspension (Insulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 1100 144.73 266.20 159203.00 292820.00 -45.63
95/50 sq. mm - 70/35 sq. mm PG Clamp (For line to
36 No. 1650 52.63 133.10 86839.50 219615.00 -60.46
LT Insulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50 sq. mm -50-
37 No. 4950 131.57 199.65 651271.50 988267.50 -34.10
35 sq. mm size for energizing distribution kiosk/box
LT Insulation Piercing connectors (16 sq. mm -16 sq. mm)
38 No. 1650 59.21 121.00 97696.50 199650.00 -51.07
39 Mid span jointing sleeves (95 sq. mm) No. 104 52.63 121.00 5473.52 12584.00 -56.50
LT SMC distribution boxes 3 phase on the LT Poles
41 On/Off swith for street light connections No. 1100 539.44 605.00 593384.00 665500.00 -10.84
1x35 mm2 XLPE/PVC insulated AL. cable for energising
42 Mtr. 11000 39.47 67.00 434170.00 737000.00 -41.09
the distribution boxes/kiosks.
2x16 mm2 XLPE/PVC insulated Al. cable for energising the
43 Mtr. 1650 40.79 40.00 67303.50 66000.00 1.98
street light
46 GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp for T/F base No. 1328 1128.83 1778.00 1499086.24 2361184.00 -36.51
48 No. 1328 2368.29 3500.00 3145089.12 4648000.00 -32.33
specification
Extra for Al. tape , binding wire, jointing sleeves, PG clamps
51 ls 664 723.64 250.00 480496.96 166000.00 189.46
etc.
TOTAL 34413168.61 58065338.30
TOTAL (Cr.) 3.44 5.81
76
Comparison of Supply Rates by L-1 Bidder NCC w.r.t PVVNL tender rate (T. No 80)
Quoted Supply Rate
PVVNL Tender Total Cost L1 Cost of Supply
by L1 Bidder M/s %
Sl. No. Item Unit Quantity Rate Bidder Items
NCC. (T. no. 80) difference
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
2 ACSR Rabbit Conductor Km. 2181 34208.59 28625.00 74608934.79 62431125.00 19.51
3 No. 46626 163.15 178.47 7607031.90 8321555.59 -8.59
4 No. 15336 265.77 141.30 4075848.72 2166924.81 88.09
5 Kg 52734 64.47 56.00 3399760.98 2953104.00 15.13
6 Kg 17578 64.47 56.00 1133253.66 984368.00 15.13
11KV `V' type Cross arm 65x65x6 mm,
8 No. 10863 626.36 665.00 6804148.68 7223895.00 -5.81
M.S. Angle
11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Insulated
9 mtr 33280 921.00 775.42 30650880.00 25806101.69 18.77
cable, 3x185 sq. mm
11 No. 53 282878.69 255000.00 14992570.57 13515000.00 10.93
with existing VCB at 33/11 KV Sub-
station )
12 Km. 27.3 265774.39 235655.93 7255640.85 6433406.95 12.78
mm
13 Km. 31 136834.34 127425.42 4241864.54 3950188.14 7.38
mm
14 No. 267 130255.77 94745.76 34778290.59 25297118.64 37.48
16 No. 253 102625.76 89055.00 25964317.28 22530915.00 15.24
17 No. 144 57891.45 47649.00 8336368.80 6861456.00 21.50
TOTAL 284129518.24 231962399.85
TOTAL (Cr.) 28.41 23.20
77
T-80 (Meerut)
Installation)
Sl.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
100 KVA, 11/0.433
Trans forme r S/S
63 KVA, 11/0.433
2 KV Dis tribution 253 Nos 162459 250445 -35.13 1641 13556 -87.89 24315 24017 1.24 188415 288018 -34.58
Trans forme r
25KVA, 11/0.433
Trans forme r S/S
11 KV Line on 8.5
4 m PCC pole with 639 km 307600 354051 -13.12 4105 21578 -80.98 131556 126217 4.23 443261 501846 -11.67
rabbit conductor
11 KV Ne w Line on
8.5 m PCC pole
5 13 km 920669 742354 24.02 9300 51965 -82.10 113699 51462 120.94 1043668 845780 23.40
with AB Cable
(3*120 s q mm)
11 KV Ne w UG
Line with 3x185 Sq.
6 13 km 2507477 3202235 -21.70 587123 779522 -24.68 1246006 2763037 -54.90 4340606 6744793 -35.65
mm. XLPE cable
double circuit
11 KV line at
Railway Cros s ing
7 with 3x185 s q. mm. 4 Nos 554765 721650 -23.13 1396053 1160139 20.34 223420 134789 65.76 2174239 2016577 7.82
XLPE cable double
circuit 150 m
Ne w 11 KV Fe e de r
8 53 Nos 455855 510386 -10.68 4605 17215 -73.25 76684 33870 126.41 537144 561471 -4.33
at s ubs tation
3 phas e 4 wire LT
Line ACSR Rabbit
9 50 km 223364 276182 -19.12 2256 17490 -87.10 80168 40652 97.20 305788 334325 -8.54
conductor on 8.5
mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable
(3*95+1*70+1*16
10 26 km 454107 548821 -17.26 4587 38373 -88.05 127614 66108 93.04 586308 653302 -10.25
s q mm) on 8.5 mtr
PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

(3*50+1*35+1*16
11 29 km 321315 400782 -19.83 3222 28055 -88.51 125078 57279 118.37 449615 486116 -7.51
s q mm) on 8.5 mtr
PCC Pole
Exte ns ion of s /s
12 Control Room 21 Nos 0 0 #DIV/0! 0 0 #DIV/0! 869807 570905 52.36 869807 570905 52.36
Building
78
Quoted Supply Rate As per DPR As per DPR
Stock As per DPR (Stock
by L1 Bidder M/s (Stock issue rate (Stock issue rate
Sl. No. Item Issue Unit Quantity % difference % difference issue rate 18-19) % difference
NCC. (T. no. 80) 20-21) 19-20)
Item
4 SI No. 19821 163.15 182.00 -10.36 190.00 -14.13 384.00 -57.51
5 SI No. 6504 265.77 254.00 4.64 251.00 5.88 287.00 -7.40
6 SI No. 963 655.23 872.78 -24.93 704.00 -6.93 552.00 18.70
70 KN c/w Disc fittings
7 SI Kg 22374 64.47 63.40 1.69 73.59 -12.39 54.8 17.65
8 SI Kg 7458 64.47 66.78 -3.45 73.66 -12.48 54.8 17.65
9 Single support 13 Mtr. STP (SP-72) SI No. 54 26314.30 21786.00 20.79 24641.00 6.79 20190 30.33
10 SI No. 596 853.15 625.00 36.50 618.00 38.05 744 14.67
M.S. Channel
11 SI No. 4607 626.36 624.93 0.23 618.00 1.35 744 -15.81
Angle
12 SI Km. 6.3 722327.44 742000.00 -2.65 774000.00 -6.68 548000 31.81
messenger wire)
13 SI Mtr. 15000 921.00 992.00 -7.16 980.00 -6.02 725 27.03
3x185 sq. mm
15 SI No. 20 282878.69 340737.98 -16.98 290357.00 -2.58 353384 -19.95
with existing VCB at 33/11 KV Sub-station
)
16 SI Km. 11.6 265774.39 256513.00 3.61 258683.00 2.74 224969 18.14
mm
17 SI Km. 10.5 136834.34 143597.00 -4.71 147192.00 -7.04 127687 7.16
mm
18 SI No. 120 130255.77 133150.00 -2.17 145906.00 -10.73 136710 -4.72
20 SI No. 120 102625.76 107144.09 -4.22 105626.00 -2.84 104596 -1.88
Rating, Level-II)
21 SI No. 60 57891.45 57181.95 1.24 58718.00 -1.41 56780 1.96
Rating, Level-II)
79
in
Saharanpur Zone
80
Summary of Feeders & Project Cost ( Saharanpur Zone)
Shifted load
segregation feeders
(MVA)
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Saharanpur
Zone 75 205 115 434 142.30 291.70 48435 248.52 210.49

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1 M/s NCC LIMITED Yes 1236306833.54 L1 1196887261 L1
2 M/s LARSEN AND TOUBRO LIMITED Yes 1309584519.20 L2 1289746194 L2
3 M/s M/s. Ashoka Buildcon Ltd Yes 1431200492.98 L3 1431200493 L3
4 M/s TATA Projects Limited Yes 1608244396.90 L4 1568866052 L4
5 M/s Montecarlo Limited Yes 1762519973.56 L5 1705933098 L5
6 M/s Patel Engineering Ltd. Yes 2161977191.80 L6 2132356177 L6
7 M/s V.M. Infra projects No Tender cost & EMD not deposited
M/s East India Udyog Limited, Debarred for 3 Years vide MVVNL OM no. 3082 dated 31.12.18 and circulated vide UPPCL letter no.
8 No
Ghaziabad 529 dated 09.04.2020
81
Tender No. 81 (Saharanpur Zone)
bidders
1 2 3 4 5
1 NCC LIMITED L1 1196887261 —

6 Patel Engineering Ltd. L6 2132356177 -43.87
82
T&P, 21% turnkey
(Rs. Cr.)
(Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6
210.49 166.82
M/s NCC Limited,
119.68 165.05
Hyderabad 208.26
(Revised DPR prepared on
(Revised DPR prepared on the (-)42.53 (-)27.48
the basis of Stock issue rate
basis of Stock issue rate 19-20)
19-20)

Bid %
Rank Variation
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
210.49 166.82
M/s L&T Ltd., Mumbai L-2 128.97 (-)38.73 (-)22.69
Rs. 9.29 Cr.
7.76%
83
Table 9: Item-wise break-up of costs Evaluated vs. Estimated for lowest bidder–P25 [T-81]
Sl. Evaluated Cost Variation

Evaluated per Estimated
Item Description UoM Quantity %age of Bid
unit rate per unit rate From
Estimate
1 Nos 636 10,87,97,988.72 10,98,988.92 1,53,08,615.40 12,52,05,593.04 10.50% 196864 329209 -40.20 
Transformer S/S
2 Nos 595 8,55,36,587.15 8,64,017.35 1,32,37,768.25 9,96,38,372.75 8.30% 167459 288018 -41.86 
Transformer
3 Nos 440 4,48,31,705.60 4,52,852.40 90,71,999.20 5,43,56,557.20 4.50% 123538 239442 -48.41 
Transformer S/S
4 km 1,414 38,47,95,706.06 52,99,410.39 17,36,69,878.14 56,37,64,994.59 47.10% 398702 501846 -20.55 
conductor
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole w ith AB
5 km 36 2,92,40,466.08 2,95,358.38 37,73,939.40 3,33,09,763.87 2.80% 925271 845780 9.40 
Cable (3*120 sq mm)
6 km 34 7,54,41,129.50 1,98,63,036.30 3,76,98,520.00 13,30,02,685.80 11.10% 3911844 6744793 -42.00 
11 KV line at Railw ay Crossing w ith 3x185

7 Nos 11 43,20,002.28 1,22,79,584.90 17,67,036.04 1,83,66,623.22 1.50% 1669693 2016577 -17.20 
sq. mm. XLPE cable double circuit 150 m
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation Nos 115 4,63,89,122.05 4,68,559.45 79,20,821.65 5,47,78,503.15 4.60% 476335 561471 -15.16 
9 km 118 2,33,24,224.01 2,35,636.09 87,95,114.66 3,23,54,974.76 2.70% 274195 334325 -17.99 
10 km 57 2,29,16,470.41 2,31,461.20 67,81,572.15 2,99,29,503.76 2.50% 525079 653302 -19.63 
11 km 59 1,66,46,055.47 1,68,122.86 68,87,107.76 2,37,01,286.09 2.00% 401717 486116 -17.36 
12 Nos 37 2,84,78,402.72 2,84,78,402.72 2.40% 769687 570905 34.82 
building
Total 84,22,39,457.33 4,12,57,028.25 31,33,90,775.37 1,19,68,87,260.95 84
Reasonability of Rate (Saharanpur-81)
turnkey charges).
L-1 Package Value is (-)43.14% Lower w.r.t. Cost of DPR.

Sl.No. Type of Cost
85
reasons:-
(i) The package has attracted as many as 8 bidders; of whom 6 were found to be technically responsive for
opening their price bid. The price discovery has thus happened through a highly competitive bidding process.
(ii) Five out of six bidders have quoted below PVVNL estimate.
(iii) The L-2 Bidder (L&T) have also quoted rates which are very close to the L-1 Bidder’s rate (119.68 Cr.
(NCC)/128.97 Cr. (L&T))
PVVNL and will therefore have the benefit of very low setup cost
86
Quoted Supply
5 was hers
SI No. 103770 144.37 196.00 14981274.90 20338920.00 -26.34
6 fittings
SI No. 33936 235.18 264.00 7981068.48 8959104.00 -10.92
7 fittings
SI No. 5142 579.81 552.00 2981383.02 2838384.00 5.04
RES No. 45424 1071.13 2027.00 48655009.12 92074448.00 -47.16
work.
RES No. 42318 409.82 838.00 17342762.76 35462484.00 -51.10
No. 5656 815.92 609.00 4614843.52 3444504.00 33.98
G.I. W ire No. 6 SW G (330 Kg / km of guarding - along the
17 s pan - )
SI Kg 116655 57.05 60.73 6655167.75 7084458.15 -6.06
G.I. W ire No. 8 SW G (110 Kg / km of guarding - acros s the
18 s pan )
SI Kg 38885 57.05 60.26 2218389.25 2343210.10 -5.33
26 `F' Bracket RES No. 35632 154.30 265.00 5498017.60 9442480.00 -41.77
27 Turn buckle No. 1410 159.50 66.00 224895.00 93060.00 141.67
28 G.I. W ire 6 SW G along the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 5922 57.05 60.73 337850.10 359643.06 -6.06
29 G.I. W ire No. 8 SW G acros s the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 3948 57.05 60.26 225233.40 237906.48 -5.33
31 Performed
Set 423 349.28 253.00 147745.44 107019.00 38.06
35 No. 5771 1417.20 823.00 8178661.20 4749533.00 72.20
87
nuts & bolts .
Quoted Supply

37 No. 5656 1762.75 2735.00 9970114.00 15469160.00 -35.55
clamp
38 È' Bracket RES No. 8829 148.37 421.00 1309958.73 3717009.00 -64.76
43 Pole Clamps Pair 1800 197.41 155.00 355338.00 279000.00 27.36
Pole Clamps Pair 4640 131.89 156.00 611969.60 723840.00 -15.46
44 No. 432 1338.91 1100.00 578409.12 475200.00 21.72
50 No. 839 1455.33 7680.00 1221021.87 6443520.00 -81.05
3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE Cable
51 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 2172 1280.69 800.00 2781658.68 1737600.00 60.09
52 Mtr. 7680 465.71 3449.00 3576652.80 26488320.00 -86.50
etc (for laying by HDD Method)
55 RES No. 1863 1671.95 823.00 3114842.85 1533249.00 103.15
nuts & bolts .
56 SI No. 576 579.81 552.00 333970.56 317952.00 5.04
fittings
s tation )
63 No. 115 46570.69 40000.00 5355629.35 4600000.00 16.43
with exis ting 11 KV Switchgears (Adopter Panel)
64 No. 115 1140.98 19326.00 131212.70 2222490.00 -94.10
3x185 s q. mm cable s ize (indoor)
66 RES No. 12380 131.89 259.00 1632798.20 3206420.00 -49.08
& nuts
67 11 KV TPMO RES No. 1786 6985.60 18292.00 12476281.60 32669512.00 -61.81
68 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 1786 2794.24 7028.00 4990512.64 12552008.00 -60.24
69 RES No. 345 409.82 838.00 141387.90 289110.00 -51.10
70 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 345 315.32 396.00 108785.40 136620.00 -20.37
88
Quoted Supply

No. 3480 46.57 133.10 162063.60 463188.00 -65.01
79 35 s q. mm s ize for energizing dis tribution kios k/box
No. 10440 116.43 199.65 1215529.20 2084346.00 -41.68
80 s uitable for s treet light connection
No. 3480 52.39 121.00 182317.20 421080.00 -56.70
85 the dis tribution boxes /kios ks .
Mtr. 23200 34.93 67.00 810376.00 1554400.00 -47.87
86 s treet light
Mtr. 3480 36.09 40.00 125593.20 139200.00 -9.77
RES No. 636 9803.13 14641.00 6234790.68 9311676.00 -33.04
95 s pecification
No. 3342 2095.68 3500.00 7003762.56 11697000.00 -40.12
96 LT PVC 3.5 x150/70 s qmm Cable RES Mtr. 12720 407.49 409.00 5183272.80 5202480.00 -0.37
97 ACSR W eas el conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 41775 19.91 23.98 831740.25 1001764.50 -16.97
100 etc.
ls 1671 640.35 250.00 1070024.85 417750.00 156.14
RES No. 595 7102.03 14641.00 4225707.85 8711395.00 -51.49
RES No. 440 4554.61 14641.00 2004028.40 6442040.00 -68.89
TOTAL 842239457.33 1160252443.79
TOTAL (Cr.) 84.22 116.03
89
Quoted Supply
Total Cost PVVNL
Item Item Unit Quantity Tender rate % diff erence

3 Rod, & 7/3.15 mm dia. GI s tranded wire complete as
RES No. 45140 1071.13 2027.00 48350808.20 91498780.00 -47.16
earthing
8 nuts
RES No. 37046 142.94 304.00 5295355.24 11261984.00 -52.98
9 `F' Bracket RES No. 35632 154.30 265.00 5498017.60 9442480.00 -41.77
12 È' Bracket RES No. 8829 148.37 421.00 1309958.73 3717009.00 -64.76
RES No. 1863 1671.95 823.00 3114842.85 1533249.00 103.15
16 bolts & nuts
RES No. 12380 131.89 259.00 1632798.20 3206420.00 -49.08
17 11 KV TPMO RES No. 1786 6985.60 18292.00 12476281.60 32669512.00 -61.81
18 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 1786 2794.24 7028.00 4990512.64 12552008.00 -60.24
19 and 6 SWG earthing wire for pole earthing
RES No. 345 409.82 838.00 141387.90 289110.00 -51.10
24 Channel
RES No. 1671 131.89 259.00 220388.19 432789.00 -49.08
RES No. 636 9803.13 14641.00 6234790.68 9311676.00 -33.04
RES No. 595 7102.03 14641.00 4225707.85 8711395.00 -51.49
RES No. 440 4554.61 14641.00 2004028.40 6442040.00 -68.89
TOTAL 144623391.38 292135330.00
TOTAL (Cr.) 14.46 29.21
90
Quoted Supply
Stock
Item
4 and was hers
SI No. 103770 144.37 196.00 14981274.90 20338920.00 -26.34
5 Dis c fittings
SI No. 33936 235.18 264.00 7981068.48 8959104.00 -10.92
6 Dis c fittings
SI No. 5142 579.81 552.00 2981383.02 2838384.00 5.04
SI Kg 116655 57.05 60.73 6655167.75 7084458.15 -6.06
SI Kg 38885 57.05 60.26 2218389.25 2343210.10 -5.33
10 Channel
SI No. 3110 754.95 535.00 2347894.50 1663850.00 41.11
12 line)
SI Kg. 3948 57.05 60.26 225233.40 237906.48 -5.33
14 wire)
SI Km. 37.8 639182.78 654000.00 24161109.08 24721200.00 -2.27
15 mm
SI Mtr. 85000 814.99 891.00 69274150.00 75735000.00 -8.53
17 Dis c fittings
SI No. 576 579.81 552.00 333970.56 317952.00 5.04
19 fittings
SI No. 5358 235.18 264.00 1260094.44 1414512.00 -10.92
22 Level-II)
SI No. 636 115262.47 136710.00 73306930.92 86947560.00 -15.69
24 Level-II)
SI No. 595 90812.85 104596.00 54033645.75 62234620.00 -13.18
25 Level-II)
SI No. 440 51227.76 56780.00 22540214.40 24983200.00 -9.78
TOTAL 626297081.10 728525036.69
TOTA L (Cr.) 62.63 72.85
91
Quoted Supply
3 No. 5656 815.92 609.00 4614843.52 3444504.00 33.98
8 Turn buckle No. 1410 159.50 66.00 224895.00 93060.00 141.67
10 Set 423 349.28 253.00 147745.44 107019.00 38.06
Performed
11 No. 5771 1417.20 823.00 8178661.20 4749533.00 72.20
nuts & bolts.
13 No. 5656 1762.75 2735.00 9970114.00 15469160.00 -35.55
clamp
17 Pole Clamps Pair 1800 197.41 155.00 355338.00 279000.00 27.36
Pole Clamps Pair 4640 131.89 156.00 611969.60 723840.00 -15.46
18 No. 432 1338.91 1100.00 578409.12 475200.00 21.72
23 No. 839 1455.33 7680.00 1221021.87 6443520.00 -81.05
24 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 2172 1280.69 800.00 2781658.68 1737600.00 60.09
25 Mtr. 7680 465.71 3449.00 3576652.80 26488320.00 -86.50
92
Quoted Supply
30 with existing 11 KV Switchgears (Adopter Panel)
No. 115 46570.69 40000.00 5355629.35 4600000.00 16.43
31 3x185 sq. mm cable size (indoor)
No. 115 1140.98 19326.00 131212.70 2222490.00 -94.10
32 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 345 315.32 396.00 108785.40 136620.00 -20.37
No. 3480 46.57 133.10 162063.60 463188.00 -65.01
37 35 sq. mm size for energizing distribution kiosk/box
No. 10440 116.43 199.65 1215529.20 2084346.00 -41.68
38 suitable for street light connection
No. 3480 52.39 121.00 182317.20 421080.00 -56.70
42 the distribution boxes/kiosks.
Mtr. 23200 34.93 67.00 810376.00 1554400.00 -47.87
43 street light
Mtr. 3480 36.09 40.00 125593.20 139200.00 -9.77
48 specification
No. 3342 2095.68 3500.00 7003762.56 11697000.00 -40.12
51 etc.
ls 1671 640.35 250.00 1070024.85 417750.00 156.14
TOTAL 71014783.93 139016409.10
TOTAL (Cr.) 7.10 13.90 93
Quoted Supply Rate
PVVNL Tender Total Cost L1 Total Cost PVVNL
by L1 Bidder M/s %
Sl. No. Item Unit Quantity Rate Bidder Tender rate
No. 103770 144.37 178.47 14981274.90 18520306.78 -19.11
No. 33936 235.18 141.30 7981068.48 4795041.76 66.44
Kg 116655 57.05 56.00 6655167.75 6532680.00 1.88
Kg 38885 57.05 56.00 2218389.25 2177560.00 1.88
8 M.S. Angle
No. 24038 554.27 665.00 13323542.26 15985270.00 -16.65
9 cable, 3x185 sq. mm
mtr 85000 814.99 775.42 69274150.00 65911016.95 5.10
11 with existing VCB at 33/11 KV Sub-
No. 115 250317.48 255000.00 28786510.20 29325000.00 -1.84
station )
12 mm
Km. 59.9 235182.01 235655.93 14087402.40 14115790.34 -0.20
13 mm
Km. 62 121083.80 127425.42 7507195.60 7900376.27 -4.98
No. 636 115262.47 94745.76 73306930.92 60258305.08 21.65
No. 595 90812.85 89055.00 54033645.75 52987725.00 1.97
No. 440 51227.76 47649.00 22540214.40 20965560.00 7.51
TOTAL 581808616.08 536494734.47
TOTAL (Cr.) 58.18 53.65
94
Activity wise comparison of L-1 Bidder Rate (Supply to Supply/Incidental to incidental/Installation to installation) T-81 (Saharanpur)
Sl. No. Item Qty UoM As per L-1
As per DPR % Variation As per L-1 Bidder As per DPR % Variation As per L-1 Bidder As per DPR % Variation As per L-1 Bidder As per DPR % Variation
Bidder
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV

1
636 Nos 171066 272599 -37.25 1728 18684 -90.75 24070 37927 -36.53 196864 329209 -40.20
63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
2
595 Nos 143759 250445 -42.60 1452 13556 -89.29 22248 24017 -7.36 167459 288018 -41.86
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV
3
440 Nos 101890 193809 -47.43 1029 13567 -92.41 20618 32067 -35.70 123538 239442 -48.41

4
1414 km 272133 354051 -23.14 3748 21578 -82.63 122822 126217 -2.69 398702 501846 -20.55

mm)

circuit

7 with 3x185 sq. mm. XLPE cable 11 Nos 392727 721650 -45.58 1116326 1160139 -3.78 160640 134789 19.18 1669693 2016577 -17.20
New 11 KV Feeder at
8
substation
115 Nos 403384 510386 -20.96 4074 17215 -76.33 68877 33870 103.36 476335 561471 -15.16

PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

10 (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm) on 57 km 402043 548821 -26.74 4061 38373 -89.42 118975 66108 79.97 525079 653302 -19.63
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

11 (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) on 59 km 282137 400782 -29.60 2850 28055 -89.84 116731 57279 103.79 401717 486116 -17.36
8.5 mtr PCC Pole

12
Building
37 Nos 0 0 0 769687 570905 34.82 769687 570905 34.82
95
Quoted Supply Rate As per DPR As per DPR As per DPR
Stock
by L1 Bidder M/s (Stock issue rate % (Stock issue rate % (Stock issue %
Sl. No. Item Issue Unit Quantity
NCC (T. no. 81) 20-21) difference 19-20) difference rate 18-19) difference
Item
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs. Long SI No. 2828 4540.64 4522.94 0.39 4504.00 0.81 4671.00 -2.79
4 SI No. 103770 144.37 182.00 -20.68 190.00 -24.02 384.00 -62.40
5 SI No. 33936 235.18 254.00 -7.41 251.00 -6.30 287.00 -18.06
6 SI No. 5142 579.81 872.78 -33.57 704.00 -17.64 552.00 5.04
7 SI Kg 116655 57.05 63.40 -10.02 73.59 -22.48 54.8 4.11
8 SI Kg 38885 57.05 66.78 -14.57 73.66 -22.55 54.8 4.11
10 SI No. 3110 754.95 625.00 20.79 618.00 22.16 744 1.47
M.S. Channel
11 SI No. 24038 554.27 624.93 -11.31 618.00 -10.31 744 -25.50
M.S. Angle
12 SI Km. 37.8 639182.78 742000.00 -13.86 774000.00 -17.42 548000 16.64
messenger wire)
13 SI Mtr. 85000 814.99 992.00 -17.84 980.00 -16.84 725 12.41
cable, 3x185 sq. mm
15 SI No. 115 250317.48 340737.98 -26.54 290357.00 -13.79 353384 -29.17
station )
16 SI Km. 59.9 235182.01 256513.00 -8.32 258683.00 -9.08 224969 4.54
mm
17 SI Km. 62 121083.80 143597.00 -15.68 147192.00 -17.74 127687 -5.17
mm
18 SI No. 636 115262.47 133150.00 -13.43 145906.00 -21.00 136710 -15.69
20 SI No. 595 90812.85 107144.09 -15.24 105626.00 -14.02 104596 -13.18
21 SI No. 440 51227.76 57181.95 -10.41 58718.00 -12.76 56780 -9.78
96
in
Moradabad Zone
97
Summary of Feeders & Project Cost (Moradabad Zone)
Shifted load
segregation feeders
(MVA)
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Moradabad
84 249 140 572.80 178.30 394.50 65819 328.71 278.57
Zone

commercial Quoted Package Value
Sl.No Bidder Name Bid Rank Value (Excluding Bid Rank
qualified (Excluding GST) (Rs.)
GST) (Rs.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1 M/s NCC LIMITED Yes 1599279370.31 L1 1550945115.71 L1
2 M/s. Ashoka Buildcon Ltd Yes 1910500336.97 L2 1910500336.97 L2
3 M/s TATA Projects Limited Yes 2128717830.10 L3 2080434570.10 L3
4 M/s VINDHYA TELELINKS LIMITED Yes 2174310668.42 L4 2114522271.02 L4
5 M/s Montecarlo Limited Yes 2563466015.21 L5 2487485815.61 L5
6 M/s Patel Engineering Ltd. Yes 2807168075.04 L6 2770852959.84 L6
Tender cost & EMD not deposited
7 M/s V.M. Infra projects No
Firm has MAAT Rs. 424.71 Cr. against required Value Rs. 438.28.00 Cr. also debarred for 3 Years vide MVVNL
8 M/s East India Udyog Limited, Ghaziabad No
OM no. 3082 dated 31.12.18 and circulated vide UPPCL letter no. 529 dated 09.04.2020
9 M/s Bajaj Electrical Ltd., Mumbai No Firm refused to extend bid validity upto 30.06.2020 as requested by PVVNL
98
Tender No. 82 (Moradabad Zone)
bidders
1 2 3 4 5
1 NCC LIMITED L1 1550945115.71 —
4 VINDHYA TELELINKS LIMITED L4 2114522271.02 -26.65
5 Montecarlo Limited L5 2487485815.61 -37.65
6 Patel Engineering Ltd. L6 2770852959.84 -44.03
99
T&P, 21% turnkey
(Rs. Cr.)
(Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6
278.57 220.78
M/s NCC Limited,
155.09 218.8
Hyderabad 276.08
(Revised DPR prepared on
(Revised DPR prepared on the (-)43.82 (-)29.12
the basis of Stock issue rate
basis of Stock issue rate 19-20)
19-20)

Bid value per DPR (ex GST) DPR (ex GST) without %
%
Name of the firm Ran (Excluding Inc. 3% Conti., 1.5% 3% Conti., 1.5% T&P, Variatio
Variation
k GST) T&P, 21% turnkey 21% turnkey n
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
278.57 220.78
M/s Ashoka Buildcon L-2 191.05 (-)31.42 (-)13.46
Rs. 35.96 Cr.
23.18%
100
Sl. Evaluated Cost Variation
%age of Evaluated per Estimated
Item Description UoM Quantity From
No. Supply Incidental Installation Total Bid unit rate per unit rate %age
Estimates
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer
1 km 742 12,42,03,773.26 12,54,558.76 1,71,47,679.36 142606011.4 9.20% 192191.39 329209 -41.62 
S/S
2 63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer km 768 10,80,34,821.12 10,91,328.00 1,63,79,473.92 125505623 8.10% 163418.78 288018 -43.26 
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer

3 km 539 5,37,39,065.38 5,42,859.24 1,06,35,709.70 64917634.32 4.20% 120440.88 239442 -49.70 
S/S
4 Nos 1,762 46,92,48,559.70 64,97,674.63 20,49,28,095.89 680674330.2 43.90% 386307.7924 501846 -23.02 
conductor
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole w ith AB
5 Nos 49 3,90,60,603.33 3,94,535.48 49,18,318.49 44373457.29 2.90% 905580.761 845780 7.07 
Cable (3*120 sq mm)
11 KV New UG Line w ith 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE
6 Nos 45 9,77,02,524.00 2,62,68,318.00 4,86,54,216.00 172625058 11.10% 3836112.4 6744793 -43.12 
cable double circuit
11 KV line at Railw ay Crossing w ith 3x185 sq.
7 Nos 11 53,80,040.40 1,56,27,398.08 21,79,662.80 23187101.28 1.50% 2107918.298 2016577 4.53 
mm. XLPE cable double circuit 150 m
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation Nos 140 5,52,60,126.60 5,58,210.80 93,49,233.60 65167571 4.20% 465482.65 561471 -17.10 
3 phase 4 w ire LT Line ACSR Rabbit conductor

9 Nos 514 9,94,11,639.09 10,04,436.00 3,63,70,079.74 136786154.8 8.80% 266120.9238 334325 -20.40 
on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm) on
10 Nos 71 2,79,29,081.90 2,82,071.36 80,05,913.85 36217067.1 2.30% 510099.5366 653302 -21.92 
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) on
11 Nos 70 1,93,18,385.56 1,95,209.63 77,39,429.60 27253024.79 1.80% 389328.9256 486116 -19.91 
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
12 Extension of substation control room building Nos 42 3,16,32,082.44 31632082.44 2.00% 753144.82 570905 31.92 
Total 1,09,92,88,620.33 5,37,16,599.97 39,79,39,895.39 1,55,09,45,115.69
101
Reasonability of Rate (Moradabad-82)
turnkey charges).

Sl.No. Type of Cost
102
reasons:-
(i) The package has attracted as many as 9 bidders; of whom 6 were found to be technically responsive for
opening their price bid. The price discovery has thus happened through a highly competitive bidding process.
(ii) All the six bidders have quoted below PVVNL estimate.
(iii) Had M/s L&T Ltd. (L-2 bidder of T-79) participated in T-82, considering the quoted rate items by L&T in T-
79 (BSR Zone), the package value of L&T in T-82 has been worked out as Rs. 167.21 Cr. In that case package
value of L-1 bidder M/s NCC Ltd. shall be (-)7.21% w.r.t. M/s L&T calculated package value.

PVVNL and will therefore have the benefit of very low setup cost.
103
Quoted Supply
5 SI No. 129201 141.27 196.00 18252225.27 25323396.00 -27.92
was hers
6 SI No. 42288 230.13 264.00 9731737.44 11164032.00 -12.83
fittings
7 SI No. 6515 567.34 552.00 3696220.10 3596280.00 2.78
fittings
10 RES No. 58711 1048.27 2027.00 61544979.97 119007197.00 -48.28
mm dia. GI s tranded wire complete as per technical
work.
11 RES No. 54982 401.20 838.00 22058778.40 46074916.00 -52.12
16 No. 7048 798.38 609.00 5626982.24 4292232.00 31.10
17 SI Kg 145365 55.82 60.73 8114274.30 8828016.45 -8.08
s pan - )
18 SI Kg 48455 55.82 60.26 2704758.10 2919898.30 -7.37
s pan )
26 `F' Bracket RES No. 44402 150.98 265.00 6703813.96 11766530.00 -43.03
27 Turn buckle No. 1760 156.08 66.00 274700.80 116160.00 136.48
29 G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG acros s the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 4928 55.82 60.26 275080.96 296961.28 -7.37
31 Set 528 341.77 253.00 180454.56 133584.00 35.09
Performed
35 No. 7188 1386.74 823.00 9967887.12 5915724.00 68.50
nuts & bolts .
104
Quoted Supply
37 No. 7048 1724.86 2735.00 12156813.28 19276280.00 -36.93
clamp
38 È' Bracket RES No. 10992 145.18 421.00 1595818.56 4627632.00 -65.52
43 Pole Clamps Pair 2458 193.17 155.00 1564290.66 380990.00 24.63
Pole Clamps Pair 5640 129.05 156.00 727842.00 879840.00 -17.28
44 No. 590 1310.13 1100.00 772976.70 649000.00 19.10
50 No. 1096 1424.06 7680.00 1560769.76 8417280.00 -81.46
51 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 2868 1253.17 800.00 3594091.56 2294400.00 56.65
52 Mtr. 10120 455.70 3449.00 4611684.00 34903880.00 -86.79
55 RES No. 2302 1636.02 823.00 3766118.04 1894546.00 98.79
nuts & bolts .
56 SI No. 759 567.34 552.00 430611.06 418968.00 2.78
fittings
s tation )
63 No. 140 45569.82 40000.00 6379774.80 5600000.00 13.92
with exis ting 11 KV Switchgears (Adopter Panel)
64 No. 140 1116.46 19326.00 156304.40 2705640.00 -94.22
3x185 s q. mm cable s ize (indoor)
66 RES No. 15548 129.05 259.00 2006469.40 4026932.00 -50.17
& nuts
67 11 KV TPMO RES No. 2189 6835.47 18292.00 14962843.83 40041188.00 -62.63
68 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 2189 2734.19 7028.00 5985141.91 15384292.00 -61.10
69 RES No. 420 401.20 838.00 168504.00 351960.00 -52.12
70 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 420 308.55 396.00 129591.00 166320.00 -22.08
105
Quoted Supply
72 LT S hakle Insulator 100x115 mm RES No. 41120 13.67 36.00 562110.40 1480320.00 -62.03
74 Loop Guard complete, 3-Phase RES No. 20560 56.96 46.00 1171097.60 945760.00 23.83
77 S uspension (Insulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 2820 125.32 266.20 353402.40 750684.00 -52.92
95/50 sq. mm - 70/35 sq. mm PG Clamp (For
78 line to line to line jumpering & energizing DB No. 4230 45.57 133.10 192761.10 563013.00 -65.76
neutral)
LT Insulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50 sq. mm -
79 50-35 sq. mm size for energizing distribution No. 12690 113.92 199.65 1445644.80 2533558.50 -42.94
kiosk/box
LT Insulation Piercing connectors (16 sq. mm -16 sq. 121.00 216872.10 511830.00 -57.63
80 No. 4230 51.27
mm) suitable for street light connection
LT S MC distribution boxes 3 phase on the LT Poles
85 Mtr. 28200 34.18
2x16 mm2 XLPE/PVC insulated Al. cable for energising 40.00 149403.60 169200.00 -11.70
86 Mtr. 4230 35.32
the street light
89 SI No. 742 112785.30
Level-II)
GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp for 1778.00 4005508.14 7286244.00 -45.03
91 No. 4098 977.43
T/F base
92 GI Channel 125x65x6, 1300 mm (Te e-off) No. 2049 855.73 478.00 1753390.77 979422.00 79.02
94 RES No. 742 9592.45
Chemical Pipe Earthing (80 mm dia, 3 m long Pipe) as 3500.00 8403522.72 14343000.00 -41.41
95 No. 4098 2050.64
per specification
97 ACS R Weasel conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 51225 19.48 23.98 997863.00 1228375.50 -18.77
Extra for Al. tape , binding wire, jointing sleeves, PG 250.00 1283882.91 512250.00 150.64
100 ls 2049 626.59
clamps etc.
101 SI No. 768 88861.15
Level-II)
102 RES No. 768 6949.40
105 SI No. 539 50126.80
Level-II)
106 RES No. 539 4456.73
TOTAL 1099282314.36 1548543119.19
TOTA L (Cr.) 109.93 154.85
106
Quoted Supply
Item Item Unit Quantity % difference

3 Rod, & 7/3.15 mm dia. GI s tranded wire complete as
RES No. 58360 1048.27 2027.00 61177037.20 118295720.00 -48.28
earthing
8 nuts
RES No. 46164 139.87 304.00 6456958.68 14033856.00 -53.99
9 `F' Bracket RES No. 44402 150.98 265.00 6703813.96 11766530.00 -43.03
12 È' Bracket RES No. 10992 145.18 421.00 1595818.56 4627632.00 -65.52
RES No. 2302 1636.02 823.00 3766118.04 1894546.00 98.79
16 bolts & nuts
RES No. 15548 129.05 259.00 2006469.40 4026932.00 -50.17
17 11 KV TPMO RES No. 2189 6835.47 18292.00 14962843.83 40041188.00 -62.63
18 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 2189 2734.19 7028.00 5985141.91 15384292.00 -61.10
19 and 6 SWG earthing wire for pole earthing
RES No. 420 401.20 838.00 168504.00 351960.00 -52.12
24 Channel
RES No. 2049 129.05 259.00 264423.45 530691.00 -50.17
RES No. 742 9592.45 14641.00 7117597.90 10863622.00 -34.48
RES No. 768 6949.40 14641.00 5337139.20 11244288.00 -52.53
RES No. 539 4456.73 14641.00 2402177.47 7891499.00 -69.56
TOTAL 182805872.43 382606831.00
TOTAL (Cr.) 18.28 38.26
107
Quoted Supply
Stock
Item Issue Unit Quantity % diff erence
Item
4 SI No. 129201 141.27 196.00 18252225.27 25323396.00 -27.92
and was hers
5 SI No. 42288 230.13 264.00 9731737.44 11164032.00 -12.83
Dis c fittings
6 SI No. 6515 567.34 552.00 3696220.10 3596280.00 2.78
Dis c fittings
7 SI Kg 145365 55.82 60.73 8114274.30 8828016.45 -8.08
along the s pan - )
8 SI Kg 48455 55.82 60.26 2704758.10 2919898.30 -7.37
acros s the s pan )
10 SI No. 3876 738.72 535.00 2863278.72 2073660.00 38.08
Channel
12 SI Kg. 4928 55.82 60.26 275080.96 296961.28 -7.37
line)
14 SI Km. 51.6 625445.76 654000.00 32273001.22 33746400.00 -4.37
wire)
15 SI Mtr. 111600 797.47 891.00 88997652.00 99435600.00 -10.50
mm
17 SI No. 759 567.34 552.00 430611.06 418968.00 2.78
Dis c fittings
19 SI No. 6567 230.13 264.00 1511263.71 1733688.00 -12.83
fittings
22 SI No. 742 112785.30 136710.00 83686692.60 101438820.00 -17.50
Level-II)
24 SI No. 768 88861.15 104596.00 68245363.20 80329728.00 -15.04
Level-II)
25 SI No. 539 50126.80 56780.00 27018345.20 30604420.00 -11.72
Level-II)
TOTAL 828470434.09 989793719.89
TOTAL (Cr.) 82.85 98.98
108
Quoted Supply
3 No. 7048 798.38 609.00 5626982.24 4292232.00 31.10
8 Turn buckle No. 1760 156.08 66.00 274700.80 116160.00 136.48
10 Set 528 341.77 253.00 180454.56 133584.00 35.09
Performed
11 No. 7188 1386.74 823.00 9967887.12 5915724.00 68.50
nuts & bolts.
13 No. 7048 1724.86 2735.00 12156813.28 19276280.00 -36.93
clamp
17 Pole Clamps Pair 2458 193.17 155.00 474811.86 380990.00 24.63
Pole Clamps Pair 5640 129.05 156.00 727842.00 879840.00 -17.28
18 No. 590 1310.13 1100.00 772976.70 649000.00 19.10
23 No. 1096 1424.06 7680.00 1560769.76 8417280.00 -81.46
24 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 2868 1253.17 800.00 3594091.56 2294400.00 56.65
25 Mtr. 10120 455.70 3449.00 4611684.00 34903880.00 -86.79
109
Quoted Supply
30 No. 140 45569.82 40000.00 6379774.80 5600000.00 13.92
with existing 11 KV Switchgears (Adopter Panel)
31 No. 140 1116.46 19326.00 156304.40 2705640.00 -94.22
3x185 sq. mm cable size (indoor)
32 G.I. pipe 50 mm dia Mtr. 420 308.55 396.00 129591.00 166320.00 -22.08
36 No. 4230 45.57 133.10 192761.10 563013.00 -65.76
37 No. 12690 113.92 199.65 1445644.80 2533558.50 -42.94
35 sq. mm size for energizing distribution kiosk/box
38 No. 4230 51.27 121.00 216872.10 511830.00 -57.63
42 Mtr. 28200 34.18 67.00 963876.00 1889400.00 -48.99
the distribution boxes/kiosks.
43 Mtr. 4230 35.32 40.00 149403.60 169200.00 -11.70
street light
48 No. 4098 2050.64 3500.00 8403522.72 14343000.00 -41.41
specification
51 ls 2049 626.59 250.00 1283882.91 512250.00 150.64
etc.
TOTAL 87644371.04 175431091.30
TOTAL (Cr.) 8.76 17.54
110
Quoted Supply Rate
PVVNL Tender Total Cost L1 Cost of Supply
by L1 Bidder M/s %
Sl. No. Item Unit Quantity Rate Bidder Items
No. 129201 141.27 178.47 18252225.27 23059093.73 -20.85
No. 42288 230.13 141.30 9731737.44 5975151.05 62.87
Kg 145365 55.82 56.00 8114274.30 8140440.00 -0.32
Kg 48455 55.82 56.00 2704758.10 2713480.00 -0.32
8 M.S. Angle
No. 29954 542.35 665.00 16245551.90 19919410.00 -18.44
9 cable, 3x185 sq. mm
mtr 111600 797.47 775.42 88997652.00 86537288.14 2.84
11 with existing VCB at 33/11 KV Sub-
No. 140 244937.78 255000.00 34291289.20 35700000.00 -3.95
station )
12 mm
Km. 74.6 230127.58 235655.93 17167517.47 17579932.54 -2.35
13 mm
Km. 73.5 118481.53 127425.42 8708392.46 9365768.64 -7.02
No. 742 112785.30 94745.76 83686692.60 70301355.93 19.04
No. 768 88861.15 89055.00 68245363.20 68394240.00 -0.22
No. 539 50126.80 47649.00 27018345.20 25682811.00 5.20
TOTAL 771351013.44 726606080.95
TOTAL (Cr.) 77.14 72.66
111
Activity wise comparison of L-1 Bidder Rate (Supply to Supply/Incidental to incidental/Installation to installation) T-82 (Moradabad)
Sl. No. Item Qty UoM As per L-1
As per DPR % Variation As per L-1 Bidder As per DPR % Variation As per L-1 Bidder As per DPR % Variation As per L-1 Bidder As per DPR % Variation
Bidder
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
1
742 Nos 167391 272599 -38.59 1691 18684 -90.95 23110 37927 -39.07 192191 329209 -41.62
63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
2
768 Nos 140670 250445 -43.83 1421 13556 -89.52 21327 24017 -11.20 163419 288018 -43.26
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV
3
539 Nos 99701 193809 -48.56 1007 13567 -92.58 19732 32067 -38.46 120441 239442 -49.70

4
1762 km 266316 354051 -24.78 3688 21578 -82.91 116304 126217 -7.85 386308 501846 -23.02

mm)

circuit

7 with 3x185 sq. mm. XLPE cable 11 Nos 489095 721650 -32.23 1420673 1160139 22.46 198151 134789 47.01 2107918 2016577 4.53
New 11 KV Feeder at
8
substation
140 Nos 394715 510386 -22.66 3987 17215 -76.84 66780 33870 97.17 465483 561471 -17.10

PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

10 (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm) on 71 km 393367 548821 -28.33 3973 38373 -89.65 112759 66108 70.57 510100 653302 -21.92
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

11 (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) on 70 km 275977 400782 -31.14 2789 28055 -90.06 110563 57279 93.03 389329 486116 -19.91
8.5 mtr PCC Pole

12
Building
42 Nos 0 0 0 753145 570905 31.92 753145 570905 31.92
2 L-1 Bidder Rate is Ex. 18% GST 112
Quoted Supply Rate As per DPR As per DPR As per DPR
Stock
by L1 Bidder M/s (Stock issue rate % (Stock issue rate % (Stock issue %
Sl. No. Item Issue Unit Quantity
NCC (T. no. 82) 20-21) difference 19-20) difference rate 18-19) difference
Item
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs. Long SI No. 3524 4443.06 4522.94 -1.77 4504.00 -1.35 4671.00 -4.88
4 SI No. 129201 141.27 182.00 -22.38 190.00 -25.65 384.00 -63.21
5 SI No. 42288 230.13 254.00 -9.40 251.00 -8.31 287.00 -19.82
6 SI No. 6515 567.34 872.78 -35.00 704.00 -19.41 552.00 2.78
7 SI Kg 145365 55.82 63.40 -11.96 73.59 -24.15 54.8 1.86
8 SI Kg 48455 55.82 66.78 -16.41 73.66 -24.22 54.8 1.86
10 SI No. 3876 738.72 625.00 18.20 618.00 19.53 744 -0.71
M.S. Channel
11 SI No. 29954 542.35 624.93 -13.21 618.00 -12.24 744 -27.10
M.S. Angle
12 SI Km. 51.6 625445.76 742000.00 -15.71 774000.00 -19.19 548000 14.13
messenger wire)
13 SI Mtr. 111600 797.47 992.00 -19.61 980.00 -18.63 725 10.00
cable, 3x185 sq. mm
15 SI No. 140 244937.78 340737.98 -28.12 290357.00 -15.64 353384 -30.69
station )
16 SI Km. 74.6 230127.58 256513.00 -10.29 258683.00 -11.04 224969 2.29
mm
17 SI Km. 73.5 118481.53 143597.00 -17.49 147192.00 -19.51 127687 -7.21
mm
18 SI No. 742 112785.30 133150.00 -15.29 145906.00 -22.70 136710 -17.50
20 SI No. 768 88861.15 107144.09 -17.06 105626.00 -15.87 104596 -15.04
21 SI No. 539 50126.80 57181.95 -12.34 58718.00 -14.63 56780 -11.72
113
Comparison of all Tenders at
a Glance
114
Comparison of L1 Bidder with Original DPR & DPR (Stock Issue Rate 19-20)
L-1 Package
Estimated Value (ex GST) Inc. 3% Estimated Value (ex GST) without
value %
Tender No. Name of the firm Conti., 1.5% T&P, 21% turnkey % Variation 3% Conti., 1.5% T&P, 21% turnkey
(Excluding Variation
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
GST) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
38.78 30.73
(As per original DPR Stock issue (-)31.37% (As per original DPR (-)13.42%
PVVNL-MM/MT/ M/s Sterling & rate 18-19) Stock issue rate 18-19)
ADB/77/18-19 Wilson Pvt. Ltd., 26.61

38.41 30.44
(Noida) West Mumbai (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)30.72% (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)12.58%
basis of Stock issue rate 19-20) basis of Stock issue rate 19-20)
37.71 29.88
(As per original DPR Stock issue (-)30.87 (As per original DPR Stock issue (-)12.97
PVVNL-MM/MT/ M/s Sterling & rate 18-19) rate 18-19)
ADB/78/18-19 Wilson Pvt. Ltd., 26.07

37.43 29.66
(Ghaziabad) West Mumbai (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)30.34 (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)12.10
245.96 194.93
PVVNL-MM/MT/ rate 18-19) rate 18-19)
M/s NCC Limited,
ADB/79/18-19 141.80
Hyderabad 243.21 192.75
(Bulandshahr) (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)41.69 (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)26.43
115
Comparison of L1 Bidder with Original DPR & DPR (Stock Issue Rate 19-20)
L-1 Package
Estimated Value (ex GST) Inc. 3% Estimated Value (ex GST) without
value
Tender No. Name of the firm Conti., 1.5% T&P, 21% turnkey % Variation 3% Conti., 1.5% T&P, 21% turnkey % Variation
(Excluding
(Rs. Cr.) (Rs. Cr.)
GST) (Rs. Cr.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
90.10 71.41
M/s NCC Limited,
ADB/80/18-19 57.90
Hyderabad 89.51 70.94
(Meerut) (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)35.31 (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)18.38
210.49 166.82
M/s NCC Limited,
ADB/81/18-19 119.68
Hyderabad 208.26 165.05
(Saharanpur) (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)42.53 (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)27.48
278.57 220.78
PVVNL-MM/MT/ADB/ rate 18-19) rate 18-19)
M/s NCC Limited,
82/18-19 155.09
Hyderabad 276.08 218.8
(Moradabad)
(Revised DPR prepared on the (-)43.82 (Revised DPR prepared on the (-)29.12
116
Tender No. 77 (Gautam Buddha Nagar Zone)
% Difference in lowest bidder package value
Sl.No Bidder Name Bid Rank Evaluated Package Value (Excluding GST) (Rs.)
w.r.t. other bidders
1 2 3 4 5
1 M/s Sterling And Wilson Private Limited. L1 266133869.61 —
3 M/s S.J.Transformers. L3 324720098.40 -18.04
5 M/s Feedback Energy Distribution Company Ltd. L5 384845796.20 -30.85
6 M/s Raj Shyama Constructions Pvt. Ltd. L6 668432279.70 -60.19
Tender No. 78 (Ghaziabad Zone)

1 2 3 4 5
1 M/s Sterling & Wilson Private Limited. L1 260711362.25 —
2 M/s Mayasheel Construction. L2 277525823.00 -6.06
4 M/s Gupta Power Infrastructure Limited. L4 297384416.60 -12.33
5 M/s RP Infrapower Private Limited. L5 307167826.10 -15.12
6 M/s Fabrico India Pvt. Ltd. L6 323621658.00 -19.44
7 M/s Vikran Engineering and Exim Pvt. Ltd. L7 325654376.80 -19.94
9 M/s Feedback Energy Distribution Company Ltd. L9 370348554.20 -29.60
117
Tender No. 79 (Bulandshahr Zone)
1 2 3 4 5
1 NCC LIMITED L1 1418093893 —
5 VINDHYA TELELINKS LIMITED L5 1786571737 -20.62
7 Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd. L7 2686425458 -47.21
Tender No. 80 (Meerut Zone)

1 2 3 4 5
1 NCC LIMITED L1 579075478 —
4 VIKRAN Engineering and Exim Pvt Ltd L4 758709556.4 -23.68
5 Transrail Lighting Limited L5 774331292.8 -25.22
6 VIBHOR VAIBHAV INFRA PRIVATE LIMITED L6 844419678.9 -31.42
7 Vishwanath Projects Limited L7 937720849.5 -38.25
8 Ircon International Limited L8 971861581.4 -40.42
9 Raj Shyama Constructions Pvt. Ltd. L9 1560069456 -62.88
118
Tender No. 81 (Saharanpur Zone)
1 2 3 4 5
1 NCC LIMITED L1 1196887261 —
6 Patel Engineering Ltd. L6 2132356177 -43.87
Tender No. 82 (Moradabad Zone)

1 2 3 4 5
1 NCC LIMITED L1 1550945115.71 —
4 VINDHYA TELELINKS LIMITED L4 2114522271.02 -26.65
5 Montecarlo Limited L5 2487485815.61 -37.65
6 Patel Engineering Ltd. L6 2770852959.84 -44.03
From the above tables it may be observed that quoted value of L-1 bidder is quite competitive in comparison to quoted value of
other participating bidders.
119
PVVNL ADB Tender-Zone wise Lot
Original DPR Cost (prepared on Resspo Rate 18-
DPR Cost (prepared on Resspo Rate 19-20)
19)
Teder No. Zone Districts included in lot
Including GST Excluding GST Including GST Excluding GST
Tender No. 80 Meerut Meerut & Baghpat 106.41 90.18 105.62 89.51
Tender No. 78 Ghaziabad Ghaziabad 44.52 37.73 44.17 37.43
Tender No. 79 Bulandshahar Bulandshahar & Hapur 290.4 246.10 286.99 243.21
Tender No. 77 Noida Gautam Buddh Nagar 45.78 38.80 45.32 38.41
Saharanpur, Muzzafarnagar,
Tender No. 81 Saharanpur 248.52 210.61 245.75 208.26
Shamli
Moradabad, Sambhal, JP Nagar,

Tender No. 82 Moradabad 328.87 278.70 325.77 276.08
Rampur & Bijnor
Total 1064.5 902.12 1053.62 892.90
120
Cost of L-1 Bidder in Tender No- 77,78,79,80,81 & 82
Estimated value (As per DPR) L1 Package value Name of L1 Bidder

Sl. No. Tendor No.
Ex. GST Incl. GST Ex. GST Incl. GST Rate (Rs.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
M/s Sterling & Wilson,

1 ADB T-77 (GB Nagar) 38.80 45.78 26.61 31.40
Mumbai
M/s Sterling & Wilson,

2 ADB T-78 (Ghaziabad) 37.73 44.52 26.07 30.76
Mumbai
3 ADB T-79 (Bulandshahr) 246.10 290.40 141.80 167.32 M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad
4 ADB T-80 (Meerut) 90.18 106.41 57.90 68.32 M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad
5 ADB T-81 (Saharanpur) 210.61 248.52 119.68 141.22 M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad
6 ADB T-82 (Moradabad) 278.70 328.87 155.09 183.01 M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad
TOTAL 902.12 1064.50 527.15 622.04
121
Comparison of lowest package value with M/s L&T quoted/calculated package value
M/s L&T have participated in tender no 79 & 81 and they are L-2 in both the tenders.Since M/s L&T are a firm of high repute, therefore quoted
rate of items by L&T in tender no 79 have been incorporated in price bid template of remaining 4 no's tenders .On the basis of assumption that M/s
L&T participated in these tenders also, In that case comparison of L-1 package value of M/s NCC,Sterling &Wilson with L-1 package value is
shown in the following table :-
L-1 Bidder Package Value M/s L&T quoted/calculated package value

% Variation of L-1
SL No. Tender No. Zone Districts included in lot package value w.r.t M/s
L&T package value
Quoted value Calculated value
Name of L-1 Bidder Value (Rs in Cr.)
(Rs in Cr.) (Rs in Cr.)
1 Tender No. 77 Noida Gautam Buddh Nagar M/s Sterling & Wilson, Mumbai 26.61 - 23.11 (+)15.14
2 Tender No. 78 Ghaziabad Ghaziabad M/s Sterling & Wilson, Mumbai 26.07 - 22.61 (+)15.30
3 Tender No. 79 Bulandshahar Bulandshahar & Hapur M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad 141.80 146.74 - (-)3.37
4 Tender No. 80 Meerut Meerut & Baghpat M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad 57.90 - 54.51 (+)6.22
Saharanpur, Muzzafarnagar,
5 Tender No. 81 Saharanpur M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad 119.68 128.97 - (-)7.20
Shamli
Moradabad, Sambhal, JP
6 Tender No. 82 Moradabad M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad 155.09 - 167.20 (-)7.24
Nagar, Rampur & Bijnor
122
Comparison of lowest package value with M/s L&T quoted/calculated package value
M/s L&T have participated in tender no 79 & 81 and they are L-2 in both the tenders.Since M/s L&T are a firm of high repute, therefore
quoted rate of items by L&T in tender no 79 & 81 have been incorporated in price bid template of remaining 4 no's tenders .On the basis of
assumption that M/s L&T participated in these tenders also, In that case comparison of L-1 package value of M/s NCC,Sterling &Wilson with
L-1 package value is shown in the following table :-
L-1 Bidder Package Value M/s L&T quoted/calculated package value

% Variation of L-1 %package
Variation of L-1
SL package value w.r.t w.r.t M/svalue
No. Tender No. Zone Districts included in lot M/s L&T package package valueL&T
value T no. 79 T
Value Quoted value Calculated value Calculated value no. 81
Name of L-1 Bidder (Rs in Cr.) (Rs in Cr.) with T no. 79 Rate with T no. 81 Rate
(Rs in Cr.) (Rs in Cr.)
1 Tender No. 77 Noida Gautam Buddh Nagar M/s Sterling & Wilson, -
26.61 23.11 23.78 (+)15.14 (+)11.9
Mumbai
2 Tender No. 78 Ghaziabad Ghaziabad M/s Sterling & Wilson, -

26.07 22.61 23.26 (+)15.30 (+)12.08
Mumbai
3 Tender No. 79 Bulandshahar Bulandshahar & Hapur M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad 141.80 146.74 - (-)3.37 (-)3.37
4 Tender No. 80 Meerut Meerut & Baghpat M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad 57.90 - 54.51 56.07 (+)6.22 (+)3.26
5 Tender No. 81 Saharanpur Saharanpur,

Muzzafarnagar, Shamli M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad 119.68 128.97 - (-)7.20 (-)7.20
6 Tender No. 82 Moradabad, Sambhal, JP

Moradabad Nagar, -
Rampur & Bijnor M/s NCC, Ltd., Hyderabad 155.09 167.20 172.04 (-)7.24 (-)9.85
123
Activity wise L1 Bidder Rate comparison with estimated rate of DPR (COST TO COST COMPARISON EXCLUDING 3%,1.5% & 21% IN DPR COST)
Sl. T. No. - 77 T. No. - 78 T. No. - 79 T. No. - 80 T. No. - 81 T. No. - 82
Estimate
No. Item Description UoM d per Quanti L1 per %age %age %age %age %age %age
Quanti L1 per Quant L1 per Quant L1 per Quanti L1 per Quant L1 per
unit rate ty Variatio Variati Variatio Variati Variati Variati
unit rate ty unit rate ity unit rate ity unit rate ty unit rate ity unit rate
n on n on on on
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
1 Nos 329209 120 260221 -20.96 118 260989 -20.72 752 200182 -39.19 267 221645 -32.67 636 196864 -40.20 742 192191 -41.62
63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
2 Nos 288018 120 198147 -31.20 111 198732 -31.00 745 170191 -40.91 253 188415 -34.58 595 167459 -41.86 768 163419 -43.26
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV
3 Nos 239442 60 149369 -37.62 66 149810 -37.43 440 125393 -47.63 144 138780 -42.04 440 123538 -48.41 539 120441 -49.70
11 KV Line on 8.5 m PCC
4 km 501846 271 476756 -5.00 250 479325 -4.49 1,730 401333 -20.03 639 443261 -11.67 1414 398702 -20.55 1,762 386308 -23.02
pole with rabbit conductor
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m
5 PCC pole with AB Cable km 845780 6 1076645 27.30 9 1084004 28.17 36 940218 11.17 13 1043668 23.40 36 925271 9.40 49 901900 6.64
(3*120 sq mm)
11 KV New UG Line with
6 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE cable km 6744793 6 4643138 -31.16 6 4655186 -30.98 35 3973510 -41.09 13 4340606 -35.65 34 3911844 -42.00 45 3836112 -43.12
double circuit
11 KV line at Railway
Crossing with 3x185 sq. mm.
7 Nos 2016577 2 1786613 -11.40 3 1788604 -11.30 10 2098436 4.06 4 2174239 7.82 11 1669693 -17.20 11 2070277 2.66
150 m
New 11 KV Feeder at
8 Nos 561471 20 561170 -0.05 21 562778 0.23 135 484989 -13.62 53 537144 -4.33 115 476335 -15.16 140 465483 -17.10
substation
3 phase 4 wire LT Line
9 ACSR Rabbit conductor on km 334325 20 343954 2.88 20 344969 3.18 138 276672 -17.24 50 305788 -8.54 118 274195 -17.99 514 266121 -20.40
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable
10 (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm) km 653302 11 642266 -1.69 10 642938 -1.59 67 530489 -18.80 26 586308 -10.25 57 525079 -19.63 71 510100 -21.92
on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable

11 (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) km 486116 10 506548 4.20 10 508043 4.51 68 404592 -16.77 29 449615 -7.51 59 401717 -17.36 70 389329 -19.91
on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole
Extension of substation
12 Nos 570905 6 806958 41.35 6 809340 41.76 38 785040 37.51 21 869807 52.36 37 769687 34.82 42 753145 31.92
control room building
124
Activity-wise break-up of costs under ADB Scheme
Sl. T. No. - 77 T. No. - 78 T. No. - 79 T. No. - 80 T. No. - 81 T. No. - 82
Item Description UoM Quanti L1 per Quanti L1 per Quanti L1 per Quanti L1 per Quanti L1 per Quanti L1 per
No. Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost
ty unit rate ty unit rate ty unit rate ty unit rate ty unit rate ty unit rate
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
1 Nos 120 260221 31226520 118 260989 30796702 752 200182 150537134 267 221645 59179215 636 196864 125205504 742 192191 142606011
63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV
2 Nos 120 198147 23777640 111 198732 22059252 745 170191 126792458 253 188415 47668995 595 167459 99638105 768 163418 125505623
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV
3 Nos 60 149369 8962140 66 149810 9887460 440 125393 55173034 144 138780 19984320 440 123538 54356720 539 120440 64917634

4 km 271 476756 129200876 250 479325 119831250 1,730 401332 694306036 639 443261 283243779 1414 398702 563764628 1,762 386307 680674330

5 pole with AB Cable (3*120 sq km 6 1076645 6459870 9 1084004 9756036 36 940218 33847864 13 1043668 13567684 36 925271 33309756 49 905580 44373457
mm)
6 Sq. mm. XLPE cable double km 6 4643138 27858828 6 4655186 27931116 35 3973510 139072851 13 4340606 56427878 34 3911844 133002696 45 3836112 172625058
circuit
7 with 3x185 sq. mm. XLPE cable Nos 2 1786613 3573226 3 1788604 5365812 10 2182373 21823733 4 2174239 8696956 11 1669693 18366623 11 2107918 23187101
New 11 KV Feeder at
8 Nos 20 561170 11223400 21 562778 11818338 135 484989 65473521 53 537144 28468632 115 476335 54778525 140 465482 65167571
substation
9 Rabbit conductor on 8.5 mtr km 20 343954 6879080 20 344969 6899380 138 276672 38180759 50 305788 15289400 118 274195 32355010 514 266120 136786154
PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable
10 (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm) on km 11 642266 7064926 10 642938 6429380 67 530488 35542743 26 586308 15244008 57 525079 29929503 71 510099 36217067
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable
11 (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) on km 10 506548 5065480 10 508043 5080430 68 404591 27512230 29 449615 13038835 59 401717 23701303 70 389328 27253024
8.5 mtr PCC Pole
Extension of substation control
12 Nos 6 806958 4841748 6 809340 4856040 38 785040 29831523 21 869807 18265947 37 769687 28478419 42 753144 31632082
room building
TOTAL AMOUNT (Rs.) 266133734 260711196 1418093893 579075649 1196886792 1550945116
TOTAL AMOUNT (Cr.) 26.61 26.07 141.81 57.91 119.69 155.09
125
Activity-wise comparison of L-1 bidders of T No. - 77 (Sterling wilson) & T No. - 80 (NCC)
Sl. T. No. - 77 T. No. - 80
Item Description UoM %age Variation
L1 Bidder Sterling L1 Bidder NCC
No. Quantity Quantity w.r.t Sterling
Wilson per unit rate per unit rate
wilsonT No 77
100 KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer

1 Nos 120 260221 267 221645 (-)14.82
S/S
2 63 KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer Nos 120 198147 253 188415 (-)4.91
25KVA, 11/0.433 KV Distribution Transformer

3 Nos 60 149369 144 138780 (-)7.08
S/S
11 KV Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with rabbit
4 km 271 476756 639 443261 (-)7.02
conductor
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with AB
5 km 6 1076645 13 1043668 (-)3.06
Cable (3*120 sq mm)
11 KV New UG Line with 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE
6 km 6 4643138 13 4340606 (-)6.51
cable double circuit
11 KV line at Railway Crossing with 3x185 sq.

7 Nos 2 1786613 4 2174239 (+)21.69
mm. XLPE cable double circuit 150 m
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation Nos 20 561170 53 537144 (-)4.28
3 phase 4 wire LT Line ACSR Rabbit conductor

9 km 20 343954 50 305788 (-)11.09
on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole
LT Line ABC Cable (3*95+1*70+1*16 sq mm)

10 km 11 642266 26 586308 (-)8.71
on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole

11 km 10 506548 29 449615 (-)11.23
on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole
12 Extension of substation control room building Nos 6 806958 21 869807 (+)7.78
126
Activity-wise comparison of L-1 bidders of T No. - 77 (Sterling wilson) & T No. - 82 (NCC)
Sl. T. No. - 77 T. No. - 82
Item Description UoM L1 Bidder Sterling %age Variation

L1 Bidder NCC
No. Quantity Wilson per unit Quantity w.r.t Sterling
per unit rate
rate wilsonT No 77

1 Nos 120 260221 742 192191 (-)26.14
Transformer S/S
2 Nos 120 198147 768 163419 (-)17.52
Transformer
3 Nos 60 149369 539 120441 (-)19.36
Transformer S/S
11 KV Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with rabbit
4 km 271 476756 1,762 386308 (-)18.97
conductor
11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with AB
5 km 6 1076645 49 901900 (-)16.23
Cable (3*120 sq mm)
11 KV New UG Line with 3x185 Sq. mm.
6 km 6 4643138 45 3836112 (-)17.38
11 KV line at Railway Crossing with 3x185

7 Nos 2 1786613 11 2070277 (+)15.87
sq. mm. XLPE cable double circuit 150 m
8 New 11 KV Feeder at substation Nos 20 561170 140 465483 (-)17.05
3 phase 4 wire LT Line ACSR Rabbit

9 km 20 343954 514 266121 (-)22.62

10 km 11 642266 71 510100 (-)20.57
on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole

11 km 10 506548 70 389329 (-)23.14
on 8.5 mtr PCC Pole
12 Extension of substation control room building Nos 6 806958 42 753145 (-)6.66
127
Comparison of Supply Rates quoted by L-1 Bidders
Quoted Supply Quoted Supply
Quoted Supply Quoted Supply Rate Quoted Supply Rate Quoted Supply Rate
Stock Rate by L1 Bidder Rate by L1 Bidder
Sl. Rate by L1 Bidder by L1 Bidder M/s by L1 Bidder M/s by L1 Bidder M/s NCC
Item Issue Unit M/s Sterling M/s Sterling
No. M/s NCC (T. no. 79) NCC (T. no. 80) NCC (T. no. 81) (T. no. 82)
Item Wilson. (T. no. 77) Wilson.(T. no. 78)
Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 8.5 Mtr. Long PCC Pole SI No. 2977.48 2986.27 2493.73 2763.00 2444.96 2392.42
2 PCC Pole 9 Mtrs . Long SI No. 4678.90 4692.71 4631.22 5131.29 4540.64 4443.06
3 Stone Pad (300x300x75 mm) RES No. 85.07 85.32 65.31 72.36 64.03 62.66
5 SI No. 200.39 200.98 147.25 163.15 144.37 141.27
was hers
6 SI No. 164.61 165.09 239.87 265.77 235.18 230.13
fittings
7 SI No. 214.70 215.34 591.37 655.23 579.81 567.34
fittings
8 Aluminium jointing s leeves No. 81.65 81.90 47.50 52.63 46.57 45.57
9 PG Clamps for ACSR Rabbit/Weas el RES No. 40.83 40.95 47.50 52.63 46.57 45.57
10 RES No. 1412.32 1416.58 1092.49 1210.46 1071.13 1048.27
mm dia. GI s tranded wire complete as per technical
work.
11 RES No. 572.40 574.12 418.00 463.13 409.82 401.20
12 11 kV SMC Danger board with clamp with N&B RES No. 190.52 191.09 118.75 131.57 116.43 113.92
13 SMC Number Plate with clamp, bolts & nuts No. 190.52 191.09 118.75 131.57 116.43 113.92
14 G.I Barbed wire RES Kg 83.20 83.45 62.94 69.73 61.71 60.38
15 Aluminium binding wire-6 SWG RES Kg 316.26 317.21 261.25 289.46 256.14 250.63
16 No. 1025.12 1028.21 832.19 922.05 815.92 798.38
17 SI Kg 76.42 76.65 58.19 64.47 57.05 55.82
s pan - )
18 SI Kg 76.42 76.65 58.19 64.47 57.05 55.82
s pan )
19 Turn Buckle (8 nos / km of guarding) No. 163.30 163.79 162.69 180.25 159.50 156.08
20 Eye Bolt (8 nos / km of guarding) No. 68.04 68.25 65.31 72.36 64.03 62.66
21 GI Binding Wire 16 SWG (1 Kg / km of guarding) Kg 76.42 76.65 65.31 72.36 64.03 62.66
22 Single s upport 13 Mtr. STP (SP-72) SI No. 22830.80 22900.56 23749.84 26314.30 23285.35 22784.91
23 11KV ' V' type Cros s arm 100x50x6 mm, M.S. Channel SI No. 1179.38 1182.97 770.01 853.15 754.95 738.72
24 X-Arm holding Clamp (Back Clamp) with bolts & nuts RES No. 137.12 137.53 145.79 161.54 142.94 139.87
25 GI. guarding Angle Iron 75x75x6 mm 3010 mm long No. 1812.64 1818.15 1447.02 1603.27 1418.72 1388.23
26 `F' Bracket RES No. 307.94 308.87 157.37 174.37 154.30 150.98
27 Turn buckle No. 163.30 163.79 162.69 180.25 159.50 156.08
28 G.I. Wire 6 SWG along the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 76.42 76.65 58.19 64.47 57.05 55.82
29 G.I. Wire No. 8 SWG acros s the s pan (For 50 Mtr. line) SI Kg. 76.42 76.65 58.19 64.47 57.05 55.82
30 G.I. Wire No. 16 SWG for binding Kg. 76.42 76.65 65.31 72.36 64.03 62.66
31 Set 409.30 410.55 356.25 394.71 349.28 341.77
Performed
32 Red Oxide paint RES Ltrs 128.29 128.67 89.06 98.68 87.32 85.44
33 Aluminium Paint RES Ltrs 283.58 284.42 190.00 210.51 186.28 182.28
34 11KV `V' type Cros s arm 65x65x6 mm, M.S. Angle SI No. 1304.86 1308.82 565.32 626.36 554.27 542.35
35 No. 1682.32 1687.43 1445.47 1601.55 1417.20 1386.74
nuts & bolts .
128
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
36 GI Channel 100x50x6 - 1300 mm No. 980.83 983.81 658.56 729.67 645.68 631.80
37 clamp
No. 1720.98 1726.21 1797.91 1992.04 1762.75 1724.86
38 È' Bracket RES No. 136.43 136.85 151.33 167.67 148.37 145.18
39 11 KV 3x120 s q. mm AB Cable (with bare mes s enger wire) SI Km. 739285.80 741500.38 651933.06 722327.44 639182.78 625445.76
40 HT Sus pens ion Clamp No. 217.73 218.39 207.81 230.25 203.75 199.37
41 Channel 125x65x6mm (500 mm long) with back clamp No. 625.55 627.45 443.74 491.66 435.06 425.71
42 Bracing angle 65x65x6,450 mm No. 213.66 214.31 167.37 185.44 164.09 160.57
43 Pole Clamps Pair 228.62 229.31 201.35 223.09 197.41 193.17
Pole Clamps Pair 134.52 149.04 131.89 129.05
No. 1893.49 1899.16 1365.62 1513.07 1338.91 1310.13
45 Mid Span Jointing Sleeves (120 s q. mm) No. 285.78 286.64 118.75 131.57 116.43 113.92
46 Straight through jointing kit (all s ize) No. 5904.42 5922.11 894.18 990.73 876.69 857.85
47 Alluminium jointing s leeves No. 81.65 81.90 47.50 52.63 46.57 45.57
48 GI Nut and Bolts (all Sizes for HT ABC line) Kg. 122.79 123.16 89.06 98.68 87.32 85.44
49 11 KV 3 core Al / XLPE Ins ulated cable, 3x185 s q. mm SI Mtr. 1031.70 1034.79 831.24 921.00 814.99 797.47
No. 2409.28 2416.49 1484.36 1644.64 1455.33 1424.06
51 G.I. Pipe 6" dia Mtr. 1858.50 1864.18 1306.24 1447.29 1280.69 1253.17
Mtr. 752.32 754.62 475.00 526.29 465.71 455.70
53 Cable Route Marker No. 478.75 480.21 475.00 526.29 465.71 455.70
54 S.T.P. IS 410 SP-55 11 Mtr. long. SI No. 15268.94 15316.38 14249.90 15788.58 13971.21 13670.95
55 nuts & bolts .
RES No. 2365.63 2372.82 1705.30 1889.43 1671.95 1636.02

56 fittings
SI No. 214.70 215.34 591.37 655.23 579.81 567.34
57 P.G. Clamp for Dog/Raccoon RES No. 108.87 109.20 47.50 52.63 46.57 45.57
58 GI Channel 125x65x2028 mm long No. 2072.40 2078.70 1546.09 1713.03 1515.85 1483.27
59 Holding clamps for channel with N&B RES Set 401.45 402.66 134.52 149.04 131.89 129.05
60 11 kV Lightning Arres tor No. 526.90 528.45 374.06 414.45 366.74 358.86
61 GI Strip 25x3 mm for earthing Mtr. 84.37 84.63 41.56 46.05 40.75 39.87
62 MVA (Compatible with exis ting VCB at 33/11 KV Sub- SI No. 337582.85 338579.42 255310.76 282878.69 250317.48 244937.78
s tation )
No. 47261.60 47401.12 47499.68 52628.59 46570.69 45569.82
No. 2049.58 2055.72 1163.74 1289.40 1140.98 1116.46
65 11KV Polymer Dis c Ins ulator T&C type 45 KN with fittings SI No. 164.61 165.09 239.87 265.77 235.18 230.13
66 & nuts
RES No. 449.01 450.37 134.52 149.04 131.89 129.05
67 11 KV TPMO RES No. 6804.21 6824.74 7124.95 7894.29 6985.60 6835.47

68 11 kV Fus e Set RES No. 3266.02 3275.87 2849.98 3157.72 2794.24 2734.19
RES No. 572.40 574.12 418.00 463.13 409.82 401.20
70 Mtr.
129
G.I. pipe 50 mm dia 438.05 439.39 321.61 356.34 315.32 308.55
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
71 LT Clamp with N & B for PCC Pole with Neutral RES No. 120.43 120.80 48.18 53.39 47.24 46.22
72 LT Shakle Ins ulator 100x115 mm RES No. 38.65 38.76 14.25 15.79 13.97 13.67
73 Bolts and nuts for s hackle ins ulators RES Kg. 122.79 123.16 89.06 98.68 87.32 85.44
74 Loop Guard complete, 3-Phas e RES No. 13.75 13.79 59.37 65.79 58.21 56.96
75 Earth wire clamp Kg. 133.74 134.15 478.56 530.23 469.20 459.12
76 Dead End (Ins ulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 285.78 286.64 219.69 243.41 215.39 210.76
77 Sus pens ion (Ins ulated) clamps with I-Hook No. 272.17 272.99 130.62 144.73 128.07 125.32
78 No. 108.87 109.20 47.50 52.63 46.57 45.57
79 No. 89.82 90.09 118.75 131.57 116.43 113.92
35 s q. mm s ize for energizing dis tribution kios k/box
80 No. 89.82 90.09 53.44 59.21 52.39 51.27
s uitable for s treet light connection
81 Mid s pan jointing s leeves (95 s q. mm) No. 285.78 286.64 47.50 52.63 46.57 45.57
82 including all clamps & material required for mounting No. 1156.72 1160.21 819.37 907.84 803.34 786.08
84 On/Off s with for s treet light connections No. 1367.85 1372.03 486.87 539.44 477.35 467.09
85 Mtr. 43.84 43.97 35.62 39.47 34.93 34.18
the dis tribution boxes /kios ks .
86 Mtr. 80.63 80.87 36.81 40.79 36.09 35.32
s treet light
87 Mid s pan jointing s leeves (50 s q. mm) No. 285.78 286.64 47.50 52.63 46.57 45.57
89 11/0.44 kV 100 KVA Trans former (Four Star Rating, Level-II) SI No. 147651.29 148096.77 117561.70 130255.77 115262.47 112785.30
90 GI Channel 100x50x6, 2028 mm (for Dropper Fus e s et) No. 1530.09 1534.74 1027.35 1138.28 1007.26 985.61
91 GI Angle 75x75x6 mm, 2028 mm long with clamp for T/F bas e No. 1916.81 1922.63 1018.82 1128.83 998.90 977.43
92 GI Channel 125x65x6, 1300 mm (Tee-off) No. 1328.46 1332.50 891.97 988.29 874.53 855.73
93 Clamp with nuts & bolts for 1300 mm long MS Channel RES No. 200.72 201.33 134.52 149.04 131.89 129.05
94 RES No. 30006.55 30097.09 9998.68 11078.32 9803.13 9592.45
100 KVA Trans former
95 No. 3233.77 3243.52 2137.49 2368.29 2095.68 2050.64
s pecification
96 LT PVC 3.5 x150/70 s qmm Cable RES Mtr. 545.65 547.28 415.62 460.50 407.49 398.74
97 ACSR Weas el conductor for jumpering SI Mtr. 25.49 25.57 20.31 22.50 19.91 19.48
98 Al. crimping lugs 150 s q.mm. No. 27.36 27.44 17.99 19.93 17.64 17.26
100 ls 683.92 686.02 653.12 723.64 640.35 626.59
etc.
102 RES No. 25828.77 25906.70 7243.70 8025.86 7102.03 6949.40
63 KVA Trans former
103 LT PVC 3.5 x70/35 s qmm Cable RES Mtr. 241.61 242.33 415.62 460.50 407.49 398.74
106 RES No. 11676.02 11711.25 4645.47 5147.08 4554.61 4456.73
25 KVA Trans former
130
Terms & conditions
1. Time for commencement and completion:- (Page no. 208 of SBD)

• Commencement within 15 days form the Effective date as specified in contract agreement.
• Time for Completion shall be 18 months from Effective date.
2. Performance Security :- (Page no. 209 of SBD)
• Within 28 days of award successful bidder shall furnish performance security 10% value of contract value in the form of BG and remain
operative to
cover defect liability period.
3. Defect Liability Period:- (Page no. 214 of SBD)
• 365 days from the date of operational acceptance.
• 5 years for Distribution Transformer.
4. Variation in contract Price & BOQ quantity Variation:- (Page no. 214 of SBD)
• Variation in Contract Value - ±15%
• Quantity Variation - ±30%
5. Payment Terms :- (Page no. 225 of SBD) & Amendment vide letter no 3563 dt: 17.08.2019
 In case of Advance Payment :- 10% of total Ex-works shall be paid as advance on deposit of BG (Advance Payment Security).
No interest shall be charged on advance payment.
 Payment on Goods :-
1. 50% after Supply.
2. 30% after Erection.
3. 10% after Operational acceptance.
131
 In case Advance Payment option not opted :-
1. 60% after Supply
2. 30% after Erection
3. 10% after Operational acceptance
 Payment against incidental (Fright & Insurance):-
1. 100% payment after receipt of material at site.
 Payment against Civil work:-
1. 100% payment after operational acceptance.
 Payment against installation :-

1. 60% payment after erection of material.
2. 30% after Completion.
3. 10% after Operational acceptance.
 Delay in payment :- (Page no. 228 of SBD)
1. Beyond 45 days, interest as per term deposit rate of SBI shall be paid to the firm.
6. In case of Low Bid Price :-
 The bidder to produce detailed Price analysis for any or all items.
 After examining :-
1. Accept the bid
2. Accept the bid but performance security be increased but not more than 20%
3. Reject the bid and consider for L-2 bidder.
7. Completion Time Guarantee :- (Liquidated damages) (Page no. 213 of SBD)
1. Penalty of 0.5% per work of contract Price or part thereof.
2. Max. 10% of Contract Price.
132
40. Abnormally Low Bids
40.1. An abnormally low bid is one where the bid price, in combination with other elements of the bid,
appears to be so low that it raises concerns as to the capability of the Bidder to perform the contract for the
offered bid price.
40.2. When the offered bid price appears to be abnormally low, the Employer shall undertake a three-step
review process as follows:
a) identify abnormally low costs and unit rates by comparing them with the engineer’s estimates, other
substantially responsive bids, or recently awarded similar contracts;
b) clarify and analyze the bidder’s resource inputs and pricing, including overheads, contingencies and profit
margins; and
c) decide whether to accept or reject the bid.
40.3. With regard to ITB 40.2 (b) above, the Employer will seek a written explanation from the bidder of the
reasons for the offered bid price, including a detailed analysis of costs and unit prices, by reference to the
scope, proposed methodology, schedule, and allocation of risks and responsibilities. This may also include
information regarding the economy of the manufacturing process; the services to be provided, or the
construction method to be used; the technical solutions to be adopted; and any exceptionally favorable
conditions available to the bidder for the works, equipment or services proposed.
133
40.4. After examining the explanation given and the detailed price analyses presented by the bidder, the
Employer may:
a) accept the bid, if the evidence provided satisfactorily accounts for the low bid price and costs, in which
case the bid is not considered abnormally low;
b) accept the bid, but require that the amount of the performance security be increased at the expense of the
bidder to a level sufficient to protect the Employer against financial loss. The amount of the performance
security shall generally be not more than 20% of the contract price; or
c) reject the bid if the evidence provided does not satisfactorily account for the low bid price, and make a
similar determination for the next ranked bid, if required.
41. Employer’s Right to Accept Any Bid, and to Reject Any or All Bids
41.1. The Employer reserves the right to accept or reject any Bid, and to annul the bidding process and reject
all Bids at any time prior to contract award, without thereby incurring any liability to Bidders. In case of
annulment, all Bids submitted and specifically, bid securities, shall be promptly returned to the Bidders.
42. Notice of Intention for Award of Contract

42.1. If Standstill provisions apply as specified in the BDS, the standstill period shall be defined in the BDS to
specify the duration subsequent to notification of intention for award of contract
(before making the actual contract award) within which any unsuccessful bidder can challenge the proposed
award.
134
Thank You
135

ADB PPT New

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

You might also like

ADB PPT New

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

ADB PPT New

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Uttar Pradesh Power Distribution

1 Meerut 33 73 43 123.1 37.9 85.2 14162

GB Nagar 11 41 20 87.10 27.10 60.00 9973 45.78 38.78

Techno Evaluated Package

% Difference in lowest bidder

M/s Feedback Energy Distribution

6 M/s Raj Shyama Constructions Pvt. Ltd. L6 668432279.70 -60.19

Price Bid Comparison L-1 bidder with L-2 bidder

Package Estimated Value as Estimated Value as per

11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with AB Cable (3*120

3 phase 4 wire LT Line ACSR Rabbit conductor on 8.5 mtr

LT Line ABC Cable (3*50+1*35+1*16 sq mm) on 8.5 mtr

L-1 Package Value is Rs. 26.61 Cr.

L-1 Package Value is (–)31.38 % Lower w.r.t. Cost of DPR.

DPR Amount L-1 Bidder % Variation w.r.t.

1 Cost of supply of items whose SIR available 13.50 14.74 9.19

(ii) 5 out of the 6 bidders have quoted below PVVNLs estimate.

(a) Interest free mobilization advance to be given to the TKC;

(b) Interest is to be paid in case of delay of payment to TKCs beyond 45 days.

Techno Evaluated Package

2 M/s Mayasheel Construction. L2 277525823.00 -6.06

3 M/s Jakson Limited. L3 288399135.20 -9.60

5 M/s RP Infrapower Private Limited. L5 307167826.10 -15.12

6 M/s Fabrico India Pvt. Ltd. L6 323621658.00 -19.44

7 M/s Vikran Engineering and Exim Pvt. Ltd. L7 325654376.80 -19.94

8 M/s Tata Projects Limited. L8 342121993.50 -23.80

Price Bid Comparison L-1 bidder with L-2 bidder

Package Estimated Value as Estimated Value as per

11 KV New Line on 8.5 m PCC pole with AB Cable

11 KV New UG Line with 3x185 Sq. mm. XLPE cable

3 phase 4 wire LT Line ACSR Rabbit conductor on 8.5

DPR Amount L-1 Bidder % Variation w.r.t.

1 Cost of supply of items whose SIR available 13.18 14.45 (+)9.64

(ii) All the bidders have quoted below PVVNL estimate.

(a) Interest free mobilization advance to be given to the TKC;

(b) Interest is to be paid in case of delay of payment to TKCs beyond 45 days .

Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)

G.I. W ire No. 6 SW G (330 Kg / km of guarding -

Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)

Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)

LT Ins ulation Piercing Connectors of 120-50 s q.

Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)

Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)

LT Line ABC Cable

Techno Evaluated Package

2 LARSEN AND TOUBRO LIMITED L2 1467476968 -3.37

3 Ashoka Buildcon Ltd L3 1674742331 -15.32

5 VINDHYA TELELINKS LIMITED L5 1786571737 -20.62

6 Montecarlo Limited L6 2138611017 -33.69

7 Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd. L7 2686425458 -47.21

Price Bid Comparison L-1 bidder with L-2 bidder

Package Estimated Value as Estimated Value as per

DPR Amount L-1 Bidder % Variation w.r.t.

1 Cost of supply of items whose SIR available 85.74 75.01 (-)12.51

(a) Interest free mobilization advance to be given to the TKC;

(b) Interest is to be paid in case of delay of payment to TKCs beyond 45 days.

Quoted Supply Rate

Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.) Rate (Rs.)

LT Line ABC Cable (350+135+1*16 sq mm) on 8.5 mtr