Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Slides Unit 7 (Law of Evidence)
Slides Unit 7 (Law of Evidence)
TB: CHAPTER 12
WHAT IS THE LAW OF EVIDENCE?
ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
CREDIBILITY
1. Leading questions?
2. Cautionary rule? (evidence of single witness; young children)
sexual misconduct??
FORMS OF EVIDENCE
ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
INADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
INADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
(1) Character evidence: the purpose of this evidence is to show that the
accused has a tendency to act in a certain way. (usually inadmissible)
Exceptions
a) Sexual offences
b) Strong logical and relevant link
c) Actions of defamation
d) Accused gives evidence of his/her own good character, the State can now lead
evidence of his/her bad character
(Also allowed in trial on sentence = mitigating/aggravating circumstances)
FORMS OF EVIDENCE
INADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
Usually unreliable. Reason = the person who made the statement isn’t
under oath; statement can’t be tested
FORMS OF EVIDENCE
INADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
a) Nature;
b) Purpose; and
c) Reason why the evidence is not given by the person who made the
statement.
FORMS OF EVIDENCE
INADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
(3) Opinion evidence: only the observations of a witness are relevant. The
conclusions he/she draws from those observations are irrelevant.
Reason = it is the courts duty to draw conclusions from the facts before it.
INADMISSIBLE EVIDENCE
S v Soci
S v Mthembu
PRINCIPLES OF NATURAL JUSTICE
Be informed of charge
Reasonable opportunity to answer to the charges
Tribunal must listen to both sides
Nemo iudex in sua causa (no one should be a judge in his own case)