Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ir Spad Cases 2022-23
Ir Spad Cases 2022-23
Analysis of
Indian Railway SPAD Cases
April 2022- March 2023
Ver 22.4.38
दूसरों की गलतियों से सीखो, अपने ऊपर प्रयोग
करके सीखने के लिए आपकी उम्र कम पड़
जाएगी।
-आचार्य चाणक्य
-
INDEX
CASE-01 CASE-02 CASE-03 CASE-04 CASE-05 CASE-06 CASE-07 CASE-08 CASE-09
KEY
START
DATE & TIME 08/04/2022 16:57 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
WR/RTM/SAT-PPD
R/PLPC 01 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
IBS
27 METER
UP MAIN LINE
Cause: Train was approaching Red signal at high speed. LP failed to control the train before IBS at
Red.
Conclusion: LP should start reducing speed after observing Yellow Aspect of signal. LP should control
Speed in such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is high, ALP should
DATE & TIME 13/04/2022 02:43 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
SECR/BSP/PND- KGS
D/NBRS 02 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
HOME (BHTK)/S-1
02:43
BHANWAR
TONK
395 METER
DN MAIN LINE
SPAD
200 METER
UP MAIN LINE
Cause: Train was approaching Red signal at high speed. LP failed to control the train before IBS at
Red.
Conclusion: LP should start reducing speed after observing Yellow Aspect of signal. LP should control
Speed in such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is high, ALP should
DATE & TIME 21/04/2022 17:28 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
WCR/JBP/RTGN-SAO
APLS BOXNHL 04 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
STARTER (S-29) & ADV. STARTER (S-35)
17:28 SAGONI
SPAD SPAD
INDEX
ADV. HOME
STARTER
STARTER
Cause:- LP failed to control BOXNHL train in Down gradient due to poor braking technique (cyclic braking).
Conclusion: LP should adopt proper braking technique while working BMBS rakes. CLIs should frequently counsel
crew about precautions to be taken while working BOXNHL & similar rakes provided with BMBS in
Down gradient as per JPO of Railway Board.
DATE & TIME 21/04/2022 08:18 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
WCR/BPL/VGLJ-BINA
00654 PARCEL 05 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
S-90 INT. HOME BINA
08:18 BINA
S-98 S-96
Cause:- Poor LRD of crew. Crew overlooked intermediate Home signal on RHS. Crew was working on this line
after long period.
Conclusion: Crew must keep their knowledge of LRD updated.
DATE & TIME 30/04/2022 19:54 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING AUTOMATIC
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
WR/MMCT/VLP-ADH
90987 EMU 06 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
S-27 ADH
22 METER
19:54 ANDHERI
PF-3
S-27 DN LOCAL LINE
SPAD
23:08
PARMALKAS
A
152 METER
DN MAIN LINE
SPAD
10:21
ISIVI
49 KMPH
110 METER
S-3 SPAD
INDEX
Cause:- LP presumed that Starter signal is Off as it was not scheduled halt of the train.
Conclusion: LP of DEMU/MEMU/EMU trains should call out and control speed of the train as per the aspect of
signal. LP should not presume aspect of signal.
DATE & TIME 04/05/2022 08:27 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
NCR/VGLB/JRO-LAR-DWA
JAB 09 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
STARTER (S-4) & ADV. STARTER (S-16)
SPAD SPAD
INDEX
ADV. HOME
STARTER
STARTER
Cause:- LP failed to control BOXNHL train in Down gradient due to poor braking technique (cyclic braking).
Conclusion: LP should adopt proper braking technique while working BMBS rakes. CLIs should frequently counsel
crew about precautions to be taken while working BOXNHL & similar rakes provided with BMBS in
Down gradient as per JPO of Railway Board.
DATE & TIME 07/05/2022 16:18 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING AUTOMATIC
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
DFC/EDFC/KJYN-BPUN
SOG GOODS 10 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
HOME SIGNAL KRJN
16:18
NEW
KHURJA JN
DN DFC LINE
UP DFC LINE
UP HOME SPAD
INDEX
Cause: Train was approaching Red signal at high speed. LP failed to control the train before signal at Red.
Conclusion: LP should start reducing speed after observing Yellow Aspect of signal. LP should control Speed in
such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is high, ALP should apply emergency
brakes in time to stop the train well before Red signal.
DATE & TIME 25/05/2022 08:56 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
ECR/DNR/BKP-DNR
Empty coaching/RNCC 11 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
STARTER ROA
08:56
RUSERA GHAT
DN MAIN LINE
GATORA
10:09
HOME STARTER
S-6
SPAD INDEX
Cause:- Crew was not alert while approaching Red signal. Crew got engaged in conversation on VHF.
Conclusion : Crew should not get engaged into conversation or any other work while approaching Red signal.
DATE & TIME 12/06/2022 11:30 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
WCR/JBP/TKYR-MJG
BOXNHL/E 13 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
S-19 STARTER TKYR
11:30
TIKARIYA
33 METER
DN MAIN LINE
Cause: LP involved in conversation on VHF while stopping the train and lost concentration.
Conclusion: Crew should not exchange alright or caution order on VHF.
DATE & TIME 27/06/2022 15:30 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
SR/TPJ/MV-ADT
AC LIGHT ENGINE 14 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
DN HOME ADT
15:30 ADUTURAI
HOME STARTER
SPAD
INDEX
Cause:- LP failed to assess brake power of LE.
Conclusion : Crew should conduct BFT/BPT and adopt proper braking technique to control the train.
DATE & TIME 05/07/2022 19:53 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
ECoR/KUR/BBS-KUR
18447 EXP 15 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
HOME S-1 KUR
The train started
after 1 min 43 sec
19:53 KHURDA ROAD and admitted on
route 4 by taking
of routing home
230 METER signal S-333 and
arrived on R/4
INDEX
Cause:- Lack of alertness of crew after passing Yellow signal and it was heavily raining. Incorrect calling out of
signal by crew.
Conclusion : Crew should exercise extreme caution after passing Yellow signal especially when visibility not
clear due to bad weather. LP should control the train in such a way that train stops well before
Red signal.
DATE & TIME 11/7/2022 15:34 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
NWR/JP/JP-BKI
14854 EXP 16 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
S-79 BKI STARTER
BANDIKUI 15:34
HOME
S-79 SPADINDEX
INDEX
Cause:- Lack of alertness of crew.
Conclusion : LP should start reducing speed after observing Yellow Aspect of signal. LP should control Speed in
such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is high, ALP should apply emergency
brakes in time to stop the train well before Red signal.
DATE & TIME 02/08/2022 09:39 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
WCR/BPL/BPL-BINA
COUPLED LE 18 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
S-15 STARTER DWG
DIWANGANJ
09:39
HOME
DN MIDDLE LINE
S-15 SPAD
14:37
BARGAWAN
199 METER
DN MAIN LINE
SPAD
MUNDERWA 15:26
73 METER
INDEX
Cause:- LP passed Yellow signal at excessive speed and failed to control train before Red signal.
Conclusion : LP should start reducing speed after observing Yellow Aspect of signal. LP should control Speed in
such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is high, ALP should apply emergency
brakes in time to stop the train well before Red signal.
DATE & TIME 17/08/2022 22:48 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
NCR/AGC/AGC-DLI
12156 21 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
S-3 RKM STARTER
RAJA KI MANDI
05:20
134 METER
DN LINE
Cause:- LP passed Yellow signal at excessive speed and failed to control train before Red signal.
Conclusion : LP should start reducing speed after observing Yellow Aspect of signal. LP should control Speed in
such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is high, ALP should apply emergency
brakes in time to stop the train well before Red signal.
DATE & TIME 03/09/2022 02:38 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
WCR/JBP/ET-JBP
A12731 DN PARCEL 22 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
SCKR HOME S-2
02:38 SALICHAUKA
29 METER
HOME
GATE SPAD
S-60
Cause: Poor braking technique by LP. ALP did not apply emergency brakes on time. INDEX
Conclusion : LP should control Speed in such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is not
reducing, ALP should apply emergency brakes in time to stop the train well before Red signal.
DATE & TIME 07/09/2022 18:58 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
DFC / EDFC /KJYN-BPUN
DN AMG 23 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
TDLN YARD STARTER
TDLN
18:58
SPAD
INDEX
STARTER
KARAUTA
12:01
30 METER
06:30
NEW
GANJKHWAJA
INDEX
Cause: Poor braking technique.
Conclusion: LP should start reducing speed after observing Yellow Aspect of signal. LP should control Speed in
such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is high, ALP should apply emergency
brakes in time to stop the train well before Red signal.
DATE & TIME 30/09/2022 18:36 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING AUTOMATIC
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
CR/BB/KLVA-TNA
EMU TK-18 26 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
TNA UP HOME (S-88)
THANE
18:36
INDEX
HOME SPAD L-3408
Cause: Late application of brakes by LP. S-88
Conclusion: LP should control Speed in such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is not
reducing, ALP should apply emergency brakes in time to stop the train well before Red signal.
DATE & TIME 03/10/2022 15:20 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
NWR/AII/AHO
MKIG/KIIP 27 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
STARTER (S-39)
ADARSH 15:20
NAGAR
25 METER
LINE 2 STARTER
HOME
S-39 S
PAD
INDEX
PANDHURN
A 03:17 DARIMETA
DN MAIN LINE
333 METER
SPAD
UP MAIN LINE
IBH HOME
INDEX
S-5
SPAD SPAD
INDEX
ADV. HOME
STARTER
STARTER
Cause: Late application of brakes by LP.
Conclusion: LP should control Speed in such a way that Train Stops well before Red Signal. If speed is not
reducing, ALP should apply emergency brakes in time to stop the train well before Red signal.
Proper braking technique should be adopted while working loaded train in gradient section.
DATE & TIME 21/10/2022 05:50 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
30
RLY/DIV/SEC WCR/JBP/OHAN-STA VISIBILITY CLEAR
TRAIN No. 15205 INVOLVED SIGNAL PF3 STARTER JABALPUR S-87
JABALPUR
05:50
2-3 KMPH
9.7 METER
SPAD
PF 3 STARTER
S-87
07:50 CARMELARAM
HOME
STARTER
6RA
SPAD
INDEX
Cause: Late application of brakes.
Conclusion : Crew should not presume aspect of the signal. Crew should call out signal aspect only after
confirming signal aspect independently.
DATE & TIME 17/01/2023 07:35 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
ECR/SEE/TGA-BCA
19038 33 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
IBH S-2
BACHWARA
Train run after 05 min 07:35 TEGHARA
without authority up-to
Bachwara station
SPAD
UP MAIN LINE
IB HOME
S-2 INDEX
SAWAI
19:50 MADHOPUR
KARWANDIA
05:53
171 METER
105 METER
DN LINE
SPAD
IBS UP LINE
S-2
INDEX
ITARSI
16:50
675 METER
Cause:- Poor LRD of crew. Crew overlooked intermediate Home signal on RHS. Crew was working on this INDEX
line
after long period.
Conclusion: Crew must keep their knowledge of LRD updated.
DATE & TIME 09/03/2023 19:27 CASE No SYSTEM OF WORKING ABSOLUTE
RLY/DIV/SEC
TRAIN No.
SR/TVC/TRTR-ERSD
19259 38 VISIBILITY
INVOLVED SIGNAL
CLEAR
ERS D CABIN UP HOME (45A)
ERS 19:27
D CABIN
39
RLY/DIV/SEC SWR/MYS/DAD-RNR VISIBILITY CLEAR
TRAIN No. TOWER WAGON INVOLVED SIGNAL DN LSS
DEVARAGUDDA 10:11
ROAD
INDEX
Cause:- TW Driver was not alert while approaching Red signal. TW Driver got engaged in conversation on VHF.
Conclusion : TW Driver should not get engaged into conversation or any other work while approaching Red
signal.
Learning Points
INDEX
Learning Points
while starting and stopping
INDEX
Learning Points
at RED signal
LP should control speed of the train while passing the Yellow signal in such a way that
train stops well before Danger signal.
While passing Yellow signal, ALP to hold RS valve and if speed is high, should apply
emergency brakes in time so that train stops well before RED signal
Complete attention on signal while starting/stopping the train.
Stopping the train at adequate distance from RED signal.
Not to presume any signal without confirmation.
पश्चिम रेलवे
संकलनकर्ता डिजाइन और संयोजन
श्री मिलिंद काले श्री बिनय कु मार श्रीवास्तव
(CLI/W.R/CCG) (LPP/W.R/BDTS)