Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LV Coordination (Updated)
LV Coordination (Updated)
LV Coordination (Updated)
IPSA-20
- FEB-02 - 22
LV – Release Coordination
1
ELCB/RCCB
MCCB
ACB
Extra-Low Voltage: < 50 V AC and < 120 V DC (Battery operated tools, lab devices, etc)
FAULT ISOLATION:
In LV system impact is Thermal only.
Possibility to select the Switchgear & Equipment with higher short time rating
a c c ordingly 1 or 3 sec.
In MV system considerable time delay is possible. More thermal impact and less stability
concern. Sophisticated protection in case industrial MV network.
Fault not cleared within critical clearing time may impact angular stability of
5 Generator.
Switch
Fuse
Disconnector
info@powerprojectsindia.com
ACB – Air Circuit Breaker. www.powerprojectsindia.com +91-9962188337
INTRODUCTION TO PROTECTION IN
LOW VOLTAGE (LV) SYSTEMS
PROTECTIVE DEVICES (PD) IN LV SYSTEM
FUSE:
Fuses work on the principle of heating effect of current. It consists of a piece of wire
called fuse wire made of a metal or an alloy of low melting point.
As the current increases beyond a limit, the wire in the electric fuse melts and breaks
off. The fuse is then said to have blown off.
OR
Rated Current: It means the current that can be carried safely for an indefinite
period without undue heating and melting the fuse wire.
8 Fusing Current: It means the value of current at which the fusing wire melts when
current passes through it even for a fraction of second
10
They are used to protect lower current circuits and have the following
specifications.
• Voltage – Volts ( Max 440 V)
A domestic MCB would normally have a 6kA fault level, whereas one used in an industrial
application may need a unit with a 10kA fault capability.
Protection Principle:
• For Overload protection, they have a Bi-metallic strip which causes the circuit to open.
• For Short circuit protection, it has an electromagnetic kind of thing.( Solenoid)
12
13
Notes:
protection device.
MCB may not be suitable for Over load Protection for Motor loads and it will have its own
16
Type B devices are mainly used in residential applications or light commercial applications
where connected loads are primarily lighting fixtures, domestic appliances with mainly resistive
elements.
The surge current levels (very low inrush loads ) in such cases are relatively low.
Applications: residential, commercial and industrial.
protection and control of the circuits against overloads and short-circuits.
Type B, C, and D are used for overcurrent protection of c a bles in a c cordance with IEC/EN
17 60898-1
This is used in a commercial or industrial type of applications where there could be chances of
higher values of short circuit currents in the circuit.
The connected loads are mainly inductive in nature (e.g. induction motors) or fluorescent
lighting (Conventional -Choke).
Applications include small transformers, lighting, pilot devices, control circuits, and coils. -
residential, commercial and industrial.
18
These MCBs are used in specialty industrial/commercial uses where current inrush can be very
high. Examples include transformers or X-ray machines, large winding motors etc.
D-curve devices are suitable for applications where high levels of inrush current are
expected. The high magnetic trip point prevents nuisance tripping in high inductive
applications such as motors, transformers, and power supplies.
19
The K and D curve breakers are both designed for motor applications where
ampacity rises quickly and momentarily during “start-up.”
Type K for the protecting motors and transformers and simultaneous overcurrent protection
20
of cables with overload tripping based on IEC/EN 60947-2
These type of MCBs are highly sensitive (Very Low Value) to short circuit and are used for the
protection of highly sensitive devices such as semiconductor devices.
Protection and control of the electronic circuits against weak and long duration overloads and
short-circuits.
Type Z for control circuits with high impedances, voltage converter circuits, and semi cable
protection and simultaneous overcurrent protection of cables with overload tripping based on
21
IEC/EN 60947-2.
Type S MCB:
A TPN MCB has switching and protection to all three phases of the circuit and
additionally Neutral is also part of the MCB as a separate pole.
A 4 pole MCB is similar to TPN but additionally, it also has a protective release for the neutral
22
pole , This MCB should be used in cases where there is a possibility of high neutral current flow
through the circuit as in cases of an unbalanced circuit.
where multiple sources are connected in a BUS , it is mandatory requirement to cut-off all
phases along with neutral . So 4P breaker is advisable to use and to avoid such unbalance
23
24
ELCB RCCB
25
It provides overcurrent and short circuit protection for circuits ranging from 6 Amps up to
1600A & 3200 Amps (ABB)
26
A mechanism which makes and breaks a contact through a toggle link mechanism having a
spring which can store tripping force,
An overcurrent trip device which reacts with overcurrent and short circuit current and trips
MCCB,
An Arc extinguishing device which extinguishes the arc generated upon current
interruption,
27 A moulded case in which these components are integrated and compactly contained.
28
29
31
Their characteristic inverse time-tripping under overload conditions is ideally suited for many
applications varying from residential to heavy industrial loads.
For higher level (short circuit) over-currents, instantaneous trip characteristics allow moulded
case circuit breaker to interrupt with no intentional delay.
The adjustable overload protection is from 70% to 100% of the nominal current and short
circuit setting from 5 to 10 times the rated current is possible.
The minor disadvantage of the release is that operating characteristics of the breaker
may vary depending on the ambient temperature.
32
Electronic Release :
Electronic or Static (Solid State) Release Moulded Case circuit breakers use power electronic
circuitry to provide overcurrent protection.
The Continuous adjustable overload protection from 60% to 100% of the nominal current
and short circuit setting from 2 to 10 times the rated current is possible.
This wide flexibility takes care of future increases in load capacity of installation and ensures
better planning at an optimum cost.
33
Microprocessor release :
Microproc essor release Moulded Case circuit breaker use mic roproc essors to
There is high Flexibility through multiple adjustments of protection settings, High repeat a c curacy,
and High reliability.
Time delays can be provided for Short Circuit Release better discrimination and co- ordination
using LCD display. System Diagnosis is possible as it stores the Trip history within the internal
memory.
34
A current limiting breaker exhibits a current limiting characteristic. That is it can reduce the peak
apparent fault current to a lesser value and isolate the fault in less than a half cycle time.
They cannot interrupt currents higher than their nameplate short circuit rating. Breaker frame
ratings of 150A and 250A tend to have the best current limiting characteristics.
Some 600A frame breakers can be current limiting, but not as current limiting as the smaller
frames.
Most breakers rated 800A and higher are not current limiting.
Some current limiting breakers were developed to obtain higher interrupting ratings than
previously available in older non-current limiting designs. The current limiting threshold is typically
Current limiting circuit breakers are used to protect loads close to supply source (substation).
Other application is cascading in order to get economic benefit of current limiting capability of
breaker in installation.
Fuses are also current limiter and cheaper. Current limiting circuit breakers ensure less thermal
stress on cables during short circuits.
36
Notes:
In a 50Hz system , to complete one cycle will take 20msec, when the fault occurred and fault
current is exponentially increasing ,the CL breaker (MCB /MCCB) will isolate the fault in 2msec. -
The maximum fault current is limited.
The fault is isolated before it reaches its perspective fault current which is widely called as
current limiting capability of the breakers.
Advantage of this Current Limiting breaker is the reduction of short circuit ratings of the down
stream outgoing feeders ( breakers , Cables ).
37
M anufa c turer will give a chart that will contains the data
of Breaker Ratings, Actual Fault Current limiting (RMS), Peak Current limiting, Let through
Energy.
38
Notes:
39
A circuit breaker in which the contacts open and close in the air at atmospheric pressure is
defined as an Air Circuit Breaker. The working of air circuit breakers is similar to miniature circuit
breakers.
Air Circuit Breaker is a switchgear device used to provide Overcurrent and Short Circuit
Protection for circuits ranging from 400 Amps to 3600A /10000 Amps.
Air Circuit breakers (ACBs) are available which can be Electrically Operated or Manually
Operated. This means electrically operated Air Circuit Breaker Can be Opened (switched OFF)
and Closed (Switched ON) using the external power supply.
40
The Electrically operated motor is used to operate the spring charging mechanism for closing and
opening the Circuit Breaker.
Air Circuit breakers (ACBs) are also available as Fixed Type and Withdrawable (Draw out) Type
formats.
A circuit breaker is a conventional type circuit breaker, and not a current limiting type breaker.
41
42
Icu is really the maximum perspective fault which a circuit breaker can clear (with the fault
current being expressed as rms for ac). but it may not be usable (in service) afterwards.
This is verified by testing in accordance with the standard and is applicable at a specific set of
electrical and environmental conditions. If these conditions change then it may be necessary
to de-rate the circuit breaker.
After clearing a fault the circuit breaker does not have to remain serviceable and could be
dangerous to operate.
This point is particularly important in circuit breakers when the Ics is lower than the Icu.
43
Test sequence III : O - t - C O ( open - 3mins- close open) as per IEC 60947
Ics is the maximum perspective fault current which the circuit breaker can clear and still remain
serviceable. The standard does allow some minor welding of the contacts to take place, so after
a large fault it would still be necessary to inspect the breaker.
When specified as a percentage of Ics, the standard IEC 60947 proposes ranges of 25%, 50%, 75%
and 100%.
For MV breakers Icu= Ics = Icw for 1 Sec or 3 Sec , That’s the reason behind MV breakers doesn't have
any such current ratings.
Icu is really the maximum perspective fault which a circuit breaker can clear (with the fault current
being expressed as rms for ac). This is verified by testing in accordance with the standard and is
applicable at a specific set of electrical and environmental conditions. If these conditions change
then it may be necessary to derate the circuit breaker. After clearing a fault the circuit breaker
does not have to remain serviceable and could be dangerous to operate. This point is particularly
45
important in circuit breakers when the Ics is lower than the Icu .
When we are using ETAP for LV circuit breaker which is current limiting type and operated in
2-3 msec will not given a correct co-ordination result.
When we modelled current limiting LV breakers in ETAP, we need model and validate it up to 3
msec but minimum available time in ETAP is 10-15 msec.
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
RELEASES
L – LONG ( OVERLOAD)
TMF – THERMAL MAGNETIC FIXED
S – SHORT (DEFINITE OVER TIME –
TMA – THERMAL MAGNETIC ADJUST BACK UP DOWNSTREAM PD)
MA – MAGNETIC ADJUST MF I - INSTANTANEOUS
RELEASES
54
THERMAL
MAGNETIC
57
58
58
59
60
60
61
62
(1.1/0.8) X FLA
SETTING CALCULATION LONG =
CURRENT SENSOR RATING
63
(1.1/0.8) X 296.5
=
800
= 0.5096
•NOTE 1: Few Releases not have “Multiples”
Pickup settings , Then settings will be 1.2 x FLA
only.
64
(1.3/0.8) X 1779
=
800
= 3.61
•NOTE 1: Few Releases not have “Multiples” Pickup settings ,
T6h5en Settings will be (1.3/0.8) x LRC only.
65
(0.1/0.8) X FLA
GROUND
CURRENT SENSOR RATING(NOTE 1)
=
(0.1/0.8) X 296.5
=
800
= 0.046 ( 0.2 MIN)
•NOTE 1: Few Releases not have “Multiples”
Pickup settings , T6h6en settings will be (0.1/0.8) x FLA only.
66
67
68