NATE CHOOSES A BUSINESS

AKASH AARON 23PBA218, MOHAMED UMAR KHADARI A 23PBA219,

ENTITY
INFANT LOGESH 23PBA251, JEEVA 23PBA254.
 Nate Jamison, the founder of City Moving, faces a pivotal decision in
expanding his successful moving business. As the company
experiences steady growth, Nate envisions transitioning his trusted
team members, Darius Colton and Terrance Taylor, into leadership
roles to spearhead individual moving crews.

 However, the critical dilemma lies in choosing the right business

entity for City Moving's expansion. Nate's fear of failure intensifies
amidst the challenges of understanding the implications of various
structures, from sole proprietorship to C Corporations, S Corporations,
partnerships, and Limited Liability Corporations (LLCs). Seeking
guidance, Nate turns to Uncle Rut, a lawyer, to navigate the complex
decision-making process.

 The current sole proprietorship structure poses risks, prompting

consideration of formalized entities. The case explores the
characteristics, benefits, and drawbacks of C Corporations, S
Corporations, partnerships, and LLCs.
About Case
NATE CHOOSES A BUSINESS
 The ultimate decision-making process involves a collaborative ENTITY
approach, incorporating input from key team members Colton and
Taylor, as they collectively shape the future trajectory of City Moving

2
 INTRODUCTION
1. Overview of Nate Jamison's Moving Business
 City Moving, founded by Nate Jamison, has been operating
successfully for a couple of years.
 Specializes in providing efficient and reliable moving
services in Washington, DC.
2. Importance of Choosing the Right Business Entity
 The choice of a suitable business entity is critical for the
future growth and sustainability of City Moving.
 Different entities have varied implications on taxation,
liability, and overall business structure.
3. Nate's Decision-Making Process
 Nate faces the challenge of deciding on the most
appropriate business entity for City Moving's expansion.
 Fear of failure and the desire for optimal growth drive his
decision-making process.

3
Character’s involved in the case....
The case introduces and discusses several characters involved in the decision-making process for City Moving's expansion:

1.Nate Jamison: The founder and owner of City Moving, Nate is the central character facing the decision
to expand the business. He exhibits leadership, a successful track record, and a vision for team growth.

2.Darius Colton: A key team member and protégé of Nate, Colton is part of the moving crew. He plays a
significant role in the company's operations and provides valuable input into the decision-making process.

3.Terrance Taylor: Another trusted team member, Taylor is part of the moving crew and, like Colton, is
poised to take on a leadership role in the potential expansion. He raises concerns about the decision-
making process.

4.Rutledge Ephraim Barnstable (Uncle Rut): A lawyer and uncle to Darius Colton, Uncle Rut is sought
for professional advice on the legal and business aspects of City Moving's expansion. He guides Nate in
understanding the implications of different business entities.

4
The Moving Crew

Introduction to Nate, Darius, and Terrance City Moving Company's Team Dynamics
• Nate Jamison, Darius Colton, and Terrance • The moving crew operates seamlessly, showcasing a
Taylor form the core team of City Moving. well-orchestrated dance in executing tasks.

• Strong work ethic and camaraderie have been • Nate envisions Darius and Terrance taking on
the pillars of their success. leadership roles to lead their own moving crews.

Nate's Vision for Employee Growth and Leadership

• Nate's plan involves empowering Darius and Terrance to run their own teams within City Moving.

• The goal is to build a business where each crew functions as its own business unit.
5
Expansion Plans
1.City Moving's Growth Trajectory

• The company has experienced steady growth, prompting the need for expansion.

• Nate envisions a future where City Moving becomes a nationwide moving company.

2.Transition from Crew Members to Crew Leaders

• Darius and Terrance are set to lead their own moving crews, taking on more responsibility.

• This transition is part of the strategic plan to scale up the business.

3.Need for a Defined Business Entity

• With the expansion plans, there arises a crucial need to define the business entity structure.

• Nate recognizes the importance of establishing a formalized structure for City Moving.

6
Slide 4: Nate's Dilemma
1. Nate's Fear of Failure

• Fear of failure is a driving force for Nate, pushing him to make informed decisions.

• The weight of choosing the right business entity adds to the complexity of the decision.

2. Challenges in Choosing a Business Structure

• The multitude of options, including C Corporation, S Corporation, LLC, poses challenges.

• Nate grapples with understanding the implications of each structure on taxation and liability.

3. Importance of Seeking Professional Advice

• Recognizing the complexity, Nate seeks advice from Uncle Rut, a lawyer, to navigate the decision.

• Professional guidance becomes crucial in making an informed and legally sound choice.

7
Uncle Rut's Introduction

1. Introduction to Rutledge Ephraim Barnstable

• Uncle Rut is introduced as a lawyer and advisor, offering guidance to Nate.

• His expertise becomes a valuable resource in navigating the legal aspects of business expansion.

2. Nate's Visit to Uncle Rut's Law Office

• Nate's decision to visit Uncle Rut's office signifies the seriousness of the decision-making process.

• Legal insights play a pivotal role in shaping City Moving's future structure.

3. Initial Discussion on City Moving's Expansion

• Uncle Rut engages in an initial discussion, understanding City Moving's current state and future plans.

• The groundwork for exploring different business entities begins during this conversation.

8
Current Business Structure
1. City Moving as a Sole Proprietorship

• Initially operated as a sole proprietorship, with Nate as the sole owner.

• Lack of formal registration and potential risks associated with this structure.

2. Informal Operations and Tax Implications

• Informal operations and undocumented registration may pose challenges.

• Tax implications and potential legal risks need consideration.

• Risks Associated with Sole Proprietorship

• Nate acknowledges the personal liability associated with a sole proprietorship.

• Risks include tax liability and potential legal consequences for business actions

9
C Corporation Overview

1. Definition and Characteristics of C Corporations

1. Uncle Rut introduces the concept of C Corporations as the most common type in the U.S.

2. Characteristics include unlimited investors and the ability to issue different classes of stock.

2. Benefits of a C Corporation for City Moving

1. Potential for unlimited growth and a splashy initial public offering (IPO).

2. Separate legal and taxable entity, providing protection to shareholders' personal assets.

3. Potential Drawbacks of Choosing a C Corporation

1. Procedural complexities, time-consuming setup, and potential high costs.

2. Double taxation concerns, where both the corporation and owner must pay income tax.

10
S Corporation Insights

1. Introduction to S Corporations

• Uncle Rut delves into S Corporations as a popular choice for certain businesses.

• Taxation structure and advantages, including the flow-through of income to shareholders.

2. Taxation Structure and Advantages

• Shareholders are taxed at the personal level based on their ownership percentage.

• Avoidance of double taxation, making it an attractive option for small businesses.

3. Limitations and Considerations for S Corporations

• Constraints on the number of shareholders and restrictions on stock classes.

• Non-U.S. citizens and other entities cannot be shareholders.

11
Partnership Details

1. Understanding Partnerships as an Option

• Uncle Rut introduces partnerships as a co-ownership structure.

• Similarities with S Corporations, with no double taxation.

2. Similarities to S Corporations

• Flow-through of income to individual partners.

• Conversion flexibility to C or S Corporation if needed.

3. Risks and Liability in a Partnership

• Personal liability for partners, similar to sole proprietorships.

• Potential legal risks associated with unlimited liability.

12
Limited Liability Corporation (LLC)
1. Features of an LLC

• Introduction to Limited Liability Corporations (LLCs) as a hybrid structure.

• Members instead of shareholders, offering flexibility and simplicity.

2. Tax Efficiency and Flexibility

• Pass-through taxation, similar to partnerships and S Corporations.

• No limitations on the number of members, providing operational flexibility.

3. Pros and Cons of Choosing an LLC

• Informal structure with fewer formalities.

• Protection of personal assets and potential limitations on employee stock options.

13
Decision-Making Process

1.Importance of Collective Decision-Making

• Emphasizing the significance of involving Colton and Taylor in the decision-making

process.

• Collective decisions ensure alignment with the overall vision for City Moving.

2.Involving Colton and Taylor in the Decision

• The decision impacts the entire team, and input from key members is essential.

• Ensuring a collaborative approach in determining the future business entity.

3.Factors to Consider in the Final Choice

• Highlighting key factors such as growth plans.

14
 S.W.O.T ANALYSIS OF CASE

Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats

Successful track record in Lack of formal business
moving business entity registration Expansion potential in the Legal and tax implications
moving industry of chosen entity
Strong and reliable moving Limited understanding of
crew tax implications
Transitioning team
Vision for team growth and Fear of failure and members into leadership Competitors in the moving
leadership indecision roles industry
Trusted team members in Potential issues in
Colton and Taylor employee accountability Future growth and Economic uncertainties
Nate's willingness to seek Lack of formalized nationwide expansion affecting the industry
professional advice ownership structure
Flexibility in choosing the Potential legal issues due to
right business entity informal operations

15
  In conclusion, the case of City Moving's expansion decision presents a
dynamic scenario where Nate Jamison, the founder, grapples with the
critical choice of the business entity for the company's growth.

 The SWOT analysis reveals the strengths of City Moving's successful

track record and a strong moving crew, but also exposes weaknesses such
as the lack of formal business entity registration and potential risks
associated with an informal structure.

 The opportunities lie in the potential for expansion and transitioning team
members into leadership roles, while threats include legal and tax
implications and competition in the industry. Nate's willingness to seek

Conclusion:
professional advice from Uncle Rut and involve key team members in the
decision-making process demonstrates a strategic approach.

 The ultimate choice of a business entity will play a pivotal role in shaping
the future trajectory of City Moving, impacting its growth, accountability,
and overall success in the dynamic moving industry.

16
17