Constitution 2 - Roshni

You might also like

Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 23

Constitution Part II

LAMP Fellowship 2019-20


Fundamental
Rights
• What are fundamental rights?

• Why are they in the Constitution?

• How are these rights organised?


How are these rights organised?
▪ Rights to equality (Articles 14-18)
▪ Rights to freedom (Articles 19-22, freedom of religion – Art 25-28)
▪ Rights against exploitation (Articles 23-24)
▪ Cultural and Educational Rights (Articles 29-30)
▪ Right to constitutional remedies (Articles 32-35)
▪ Any others?
Who enjoys these rights?

▪ Citizens and non-citizens residing in India


▪ Enforceable against state and against individuals
▪ Individual vs. Group Rights
▪ Are these rights absolute?
Directive Principles of State Policy

▪ Why do directive principles find a place in the constitution?


▪ What is the difference between Fundamental Rights and Directive
Principles?
▪ Why did we not make them rights?
Fundamental Duties
▪ What are fundamental duties?
▪ When were they introduced?
▪ National Anthem!
Separation of Powers – Vertical and Horizontal
▪ India is a Parliamentary democracy. What does this mean?

❖ The Head of State is an elected President

❖ The Head of Government is an elected Prime Minister

▪ The Constitution specifies and separates the power and responsibilities of the
Legislature, the Executive and the Judiciary
Executive
▪ Who comprises the executive?

▪ How is the President elected?

▪ Does he have any special powers?


Parliament
▪ Who comprises the Parliament?
▪ How are Members elected?

❖ LS Members

❖ RS Members

▪ What are the roles of Parliament?


Judiciary
Supreme Court
▪ Court of record and can punish for its contempt
▪ Writ Jurisdiction – for enforcement of fundamental rights (Article 32);
▪ Appellate Jurisdiction – Where certificate of fitness granted by the
respective High Court. (Article 132/133/134)
▪ If certificate of fitness not granted – then, special leave to appeal under
Article 136
▪ Federal Disputes - Adjudicating centre-state, state-state or centre-state-state
disputes (Article 131);
▪ Advising the President (Article 143);
High Courts
▪ Court of record and can punish for its contempt (including contempt of
subordinate judiciary)
▪ Original Jurisdiction - Original Civil Jurisdiction of 5 High Courts (Delhi,
Bombay, Calcutta, Madras and Himachal Pradesh)
▪ Appellate Jurisdiction
▪ Writ jurisdiction under Article 226
▪ Supervisory jurisdiction (under Article 227)
Is the separation of powers watertight?
▪ Executive controls the lower House of Parliament
▪ Executive has ordinance making powers
▪ Office of Profit
▪ MPLADs/MLALADs
▪ Regulatory bodies
Vertical division of power
Supreme
The Union Parliament Union Govt.
Court

The States State


State Govt. High Courts
legislatures

Panchayat /
Local Subordinate
Urban
Local Bodies
Judiciary
Tiers of Government
▪ The Constitution initially specified two tiers of governments
▪ Two amendments (73rd & 74th) in 1992 recognised local governments
▪ The Seventh Schedule of the Constitution specifies domains of the
centre and the states
▪ 11th and 12th Schedules specify the areas that fall under the
jurisdiction of Local Governments
Legislative Powers
▪ How do centre and states share powers?
❖ Union List, State List, Concurrent List, Residuary subjects

▪ Concurrent List – if both Centre and state enact laws, who prevails?
▪ When can centre intervene in the state list?
❖ Rajya Sabha on matters of national interest – 3/4 th majority resolution

❖ National emergency

❖ Implementing international agreements

❖ If two or more states request


Emergency Powers
"I share the sentiments that such articles will never be called into operation and they
would remain a dead letter. “
Goods and Service Tax
▪ How did centre and states generate tax revenues before GST?
❖ Schedule 7
▪ Post GST, how do their powers change?
❖ Article 246A, 279A(3)
❖ Impact on revenue generation powers of centre and states?
▪ Powers of GST Council
❖ Tension with legislatures?
Independent Constitutional Bodies
▪ Finance Commission
▪ Election Commission of India
▪ Comptroller and Auditor General
▪ UPSC
▪ Attorney General
▪ Any newer bodies?
Summing up
▪ Limiting powers of the state
❖ Fundamental Rights
❖ Checks and balances across all three organs
❖ Federal structure
❖ Independent bodies like ECI, CAG, etc.
❖ Basic Structure!!

▪ Socio-economic reform
❖ Directive Principles of State Policy
❖ Fundamental Rights

▪ Holding the centre


❖ Emergency powers and
❖ Concurrent list overriding powers
Assignment
▪ Assignment 1: Give one example of how each of the three wings of the state
keep the other in check. (500 words)

▪ Assignment 2: Give three recent instances where there may have been a
Fundamental Rights violation through a legislative or executive action. (500
words)
Fin.

You might also like