Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Non Beam Based AM-24.07.2020
Non Beam Based AM-24.07.2020
Non Beam Based AM-24.07.2020
ADDITIVE
MANUFACTURING:
DEFENSE APPLICATIONS
Dr. Adepu Kumar
Professor
Mechanical Engineering Department
NIT Warangal
Email ID: adepu_kumar7@nitw.ac.in
Contact no.9492783067
OVERVIEW
Introduction to Additive Manufacturing (AM)
Non Beam based Additive Manufacturing
Friction Stir Additive Manufacturing(FSAM)
Additive friction stir deposition
Ultrasonic additive Manufacturing
Wire Arc additive Manufacturing (WAAM)
Beam based Additive Manufacturing
Direct Energy Deposition process
Powder Bed Fusion Process
Hybrid manufacturing Process
2
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
MANUFACTURING PROCESSES
3
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
INTRODUCTION TO AM
Additive manufacturing is a manufacturing
process in which functional parts can be made
by adding materials without using special
tooling, jigs or fixtures.
4
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
STEPS IN AM
5
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
CNC VS. AM
Material
(plastic/wax/paper/cermics/composites/metals)
Speed
Complexity
Accuracy
Geometry
Programming
CNC-2.5D
AM-3.0D
6
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
TIME COMPRESSION
ENGINEERING/ CONCURRENT
ENGINEERING IN PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT
7
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
8
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering,
NITW 05/04/2024 9
Applications of AM
Direct Part Production
Prototyping Aerospace
Visual Aids & Presentation Models
Automotive & Motorsports
Fit, Function, and Assembly Medical
Models Avatars & Figurines
Tooling Furniture, Home, and Office
Metal Casting Accessories
Architectural Applications in Music
Medical Customer-created Products
Anatomical & Surgical Models Art & Jewelry
Custom Prosthetic Design Gifts, Trophies & Memorials
Virtual Surgical Planning & Marketing & Advertising
Personalized Surgical Instruments Museum Displays
Custom fabricated Implants Fashion & High-performance
Dental Products
10
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
DIRECT PART PRODUCTION
APPLICATIONS : AEROSPACE
11
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
NON BEAM BASED METAL
ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
Friction stir additive manufacturing
Additive Friction stir deposition
Ultrasonic additive Manufacturing
12
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Both friction stir additive manufacturing and additive
friction stir deposition are ‘intensive’ processes that
involve severe plastic deformation at high
temperatures.
14
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
COMPARISON TO OTHER
SOLID-STATE AM PROCESSES
16
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
COMPARISON TO FRICTION STIR
ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
Both friction stir additive manufacturing and
additive friction stir deposition are
‘intensive’ processes that involve severe
plastic deformation at high temperatures.
However, there are significant differences
between them.
One is a hybrid (both additive and
subtractive) sheet lamination process
involving welding that results in
microstructures with cyclic variations where
as the other is a purely additive process that
deposits a new track with each pass
17
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
PATHWAYS TO WIDESPREAD
IMPLEMENTATION OF METAL AM
For wide spread implementation metal AM
needs to possess a series of attributes ,such
as
affordability to customers
convenience and ease of use
energy efficiency
environmental friendliness
wide applicability to engineering materials
compatibility with mature technologies
reliability of part properties
18
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
FRICTION STIR ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
Non-consumable rotating tool with a custom
designed pin and shoulder is inserted into the
surfaces of sheets or plates to be joined and
traversed along the joint line.
Solid state process & No melting
Final thickness of the joint depends on
thickness of the sheets/plate and layers.
19
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
20
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
ADDITIVE FRICTION STIR DEPOSITION
21
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
RELATIONS TO FRICTION STIR
WELDING AND PROCESSING
22
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
COMARISION OF THREE PROCESSES
23
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
STRATEGIES OF ADDITIVE
FRICTION STIR DEPOSITION
24
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Tools with varying pin lengths
25
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
SIC DISTRIBUTION IN STIR ZONE
26
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
UNDERLYING MATERIALS SCIENCE
Additive friction stir deposition is a thermo
mechanical process.
Important processing parameters include
Rotation of the shoulder, shoulder normal
force, filler material feed rate R, layer
height ,and transverse speed.
These parameters control the heat flow and
material flow processes, which are fully
coupled.
For the deposited material, the heat
generation dissipation and transfer
mechanisms are similar to the stirred material
in friction stir welding or processing
27
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
RELATIONS TO FRICTION STIR
WELDING AND PROCESSING
Microstructure formation and applicability to non-
weldable alloys is same in both in friction stir
welding and processing, a shoulder with a
protruding pin is spun at a high rate and inserted
into the softened metal surface.
The shoulder then traverses the material to either
join two interfaces in friction stir welding or treat
the surface in friction stir processing.
However, in additive friction stir deposition, there
is no pin structure penetrating the base material.
The different geometric configurations lead to
different heat flow boundary conditions, and
therefore, different cooling rates.
28
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
RELATIONS TO FRICTION STIR
WELDING AND PROCESSING
In friction stir welding and processing, the stirred
material is surrounded and constrained by the material
in the thermo mechanically affected zone, into which
heat is transferred by thermal conduction.
In additive friction stir deposition, the deposited
material of the first track of each layer is in direct
contact with air on either side, and heat transfer
perpendicular to the tool traveling direction occurs by
convection and radiation rather than conduction.
Regarding heat generation, in friction stir welding or
processing it is generated at the shoulder-material and
pin-material interfaces, whereas in additive friction
stir deposition it is generated at the shoulder-material
and material-substrate (or new layer-previous layer)
interfaces
29
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
FEATURES AND
CAPABILITIES
(a) Images of a bend test for tantalum and niobium coatings deposited on a
copper substrate, which show strong mechanical bonding and no
delamination under bending.
33
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
FLEXIBILITY IN FEED MATERIAL
Beam-based processes have restrictions on feed material in terms
of powder composition, shape, and size.
35
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
A CHART OUTLINING THE BENEFITS OF
ADDITIVE FRICTION STIR DEPOSITIO
36
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
LIMITATIONS
38
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
FROM COMPUTER-AIDED DESIGN (CAD) TO
PART
In additive friction stir deposition, the deposition
path is guided by a G-code-based hatch pattern.
Since algorithms are available to automatically
convert the CAD file to G-code, it is
straightforward to go from CAD file to part as
long as the geometry is printable.
The printable geometry is limited by the in-plane
resolution and maximum over hang angle in
additive friction stir deposition. Given the layer-
by-layer nature of additive friction stir
deposition, parts may require additional post
processing to compensate for the stepwise
transition at the edge of each layer. This is highly
dependent on the feature size and part geometry
39
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
BUCKLING
A potential concern related to mechanical
instability is the printing of high-aspect-ratio
components, because the normal force from
the shoulder may cause buckling
40
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
TOOLING DEVELOPMENT
Shoulder life time is of utmost concern for
additive friction stir deposition, as the
machine's performance is tied to the tool's
ability to reliably stir material.
A balance must exist between the economic
viability and degradation rate of the shoulder.
The target shoulder proper ties include high
wear resistance, high fracture toughness, high
compressive yield strength at elevated
temperatures, high thermal fatigue strength,
creep resistance, chemical stability, and low
cost
41
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
ULTRASONIC ADDITIVE
MANUFACTURING
It is a hybrid sheet lamination process combining
ultrasonic metal seam welding and CNC milling
In UAM, the object is built up on a rigidly held base
plate bolted onto a heated platen, with temperatures
ranging from room temperature to approximately
200C.
Parts are built from bottom to top, and each layer is
composed of several metal foils laid side by side and
then trimmed using CNC milling
During UAM, a rotating sonotrode travels along the
length of a thin metal foil (typically 100–150 μm thick).
The foil is held closely in contact with the base plate
or previous layer by applying a normal force via the
rotating sonotrode
42
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
INTRODUCTION TO UAM/UC
The sonotrode oscillates transversely to the direction
of motion, at a constant 20 kHz frequency and user-
set oscillation amplitude.
After depositing a foil, another foil is deposited
adjacent to it. This procedure is repeated until a
complete layer is placed. The next layer is bonded
to the previously deposited layer using the same
procedure.
Typically four layers of deposited metal foils are
termed one level in UAM. After deposition of one
level, the CNC milling head shapes the deposited
foils/layers to their slice contour (the contour does
not need to be vertical, but can be a curved or
angled surface, based on the local part geometry)
43
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
FEATURES OF UAM
Creating complex features
Eliminates stair stepping effect
Good surface finish and accuracy by CNC Milling
44
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
45
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN UAM AND CNC
46
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
4. Ultrasonic consolidation
• Additive plus subtractive process.
• This is a bond then form process.
• Ultrasonic seam welding + CNC milling .
• Object is on plate rigidly held with bolt and
heated to 200 °C.
• High-frequency (typically 20,000 Hz) ultrasonic
vibrations are locally applied to metal foil
materials, held together under pressure, to
create a solid-state weld.
• Four layers = one level.
• CNC contour milling is then used to create the
required shape for the given layer.
• Weld at low temp (0.5 Tm).
• Low energy consumption for weld.
• Less residual stress.
47
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Fig. Schematic of ultrasonic consolidation[1]
48
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Dimensional accuracy and Surface Finish – Milling
52
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Metal foil thickness
• Foil thickness should be 150-200 .
• Bonds are easily formed between thin metal
foils.
53
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Oxide Formation
• Enhanced oxide formation at elevated
temperatures will prevent oxide removal to a
greater degree than the enhanced softening
that aids plastic deformation.
55
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
1. Internal features
63
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Structurally Embedded Electrical
System using UC
66
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
• Part strength optimization – Increasing LWD and minimizing
the defects(type-1 &3 minimized and type-2 eliminated).
67
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Microstructure of Ni 201
foils
68
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Microstructure of NI 201 foils
Ref.: Additive manufacturing
technologies(Ian Gibson, David
W. Rosen, Brent Strucker)
71
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
MICRO STRUCTURE AND
MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF UAM
Mechanical properties are anisotropic due to
defects
Plastic deformation increases the hardness
Decrease of ductility
Original microstructure is retained
72
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
ADVANTAGES AND
DISADVANTAGES OF UAM
Smoother Surface Finish
Low Energy Consumption
No Atmosphere Control
Wastage
73
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
UAM APPLICATIONS
Internal Features
Material Flexibility
Fiber Embedment
Smart Structures
74
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
WIRE ARC ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
(WAAM)
INTEGRATION WITH CAD AND CAAM
The development of wire arc additive
manufacturing (WAAM) is being driven by the
need for increased manufacturing efficiency
of engineering structures.
Its ability to produce very near net shape
preforms without the need for complex
tooling, moulds or dies offers potential for
significant cost and lead time reductions,
increased material efficiency, improved
component performance and reduction of
inventory and logistics costs by local, on-
demand manufacture.
75
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
First patented in 1920, WAAM is probably the oldest,
outwardly simplest, but least talked about of the range
of additive manufacturing (AM) process.
76
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
MAIN RESEARCH GROUPS IN WAAM
77
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
WIRE ARC ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
It works by melting metal wire using an electric arc as the
heat source.
79
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
CLASSIFICATION OF WAAM PROCES
WAAM Energy source Features
GTAW- GTAW Non-consumable electrode; Separate wire
based feed process; Typical deposition rate:
1-2kg/hour; Wire and torch rotation are
needed;
GMAW- GMAW Consumable wire electrode; Typical
based deposition rate 3-4kg/hour; Poor arc stability,
spatter
Cold metal Reciprocating consumable wire electrode;
transfer (CMT) Typical deposition rate: 2-3kg/hour; Low heat
input process with zero spatter, high process
tolerance
Tandem GMAW Two consumable wires electrodes; Typical
deposition: 6-8kg/hour; Easy mixing to
control composition for intermetallic
materials manufacturing
PAW- PAW Non-consumable electrode; Separate wire
based feed process; Typical deposition rate
2-4kg/hour;
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW Wire and torch
80 rotation are
05/04/2024
WAAM EQUIPMENT
Robotic and machine based system are two
types
Robotic based system includes in capable
manipulation systems and CAD/CAM
software.
Machine tool-based systems into which the
deposition equipment has been integrated
have additional potential to allow the
combination of AM and subtractive/cutting
(SM) processes in a layer-by-layer manner,
allowing features to be created and finish
machined
81
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
WAAM EQUIPMENT
82
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
THE COLD METAL TRANSFER WIRE ARC ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
(CMT-WAAM) SYSTEM.
83
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
COLD METAL TRANSFER (CMT)
MACHINE
84
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
MACRO SECTIONS OF (A) TI-6AL-4V, (B) AA4043, AND (C) IN718
WAAM WALLS
85
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
CORRELATION BETWEEN PROPERTIES
AND MATERIALS
86
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
QUALITY BASED FRAME WORK
87
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
PROCESS VARIABLES
Wire feed rate
Voltage supply
Argon flow rate
Weld speed
No of layers
88
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
METAL TRANSFER IN MULTI-
DIRECTIONAL GMAW-BASED WAAM
Free flight transfer can be further divided
into Spray, Globular and Repelled modes.
During Free Flight modes, the droplet
trajectory from the wire tip to the weld pool
is important.
In short arc transfer, a droplet forms on the
wire tip during the arcing phase, but
material transfers when the wire tip contacts
the base metal. Droplets transfer to the weld
pool is influenced by the gravitational force
less
89
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
FREE FLIGHT TRANSFER & SHORT ARC
TRANSFE
90
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
FABRICATION APPROACH FOR
DEPOSITION
91
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
3D model of the samples and Deposited near-net shape
92
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
93
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
BENEFITS OF WAAM
Production of large parts compared to powder
bed processes as robotic arm movement is free
to move
Wire is Less expensive compared to metal
powder
WAAM hardware is less expensive compared to
metal 3D Printers
It can deliver near net shape components,
minimizing the need for surface finishing
Good option for repair and maintenance
operations for specific components like
turbine blades, and also moulds and dies
94
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
LIMITATIONS OF WAAM
Heat management is some what difficult.
For materials like titanium the inert gas chamber is
required.
It limits the size of parts that can be produced with
this technology and installing such chamber will
increase the cost of the equipment.
Although a number of companies are developing
WAAM technology for the production of metal parts,
currently there is no commercially available system.
97
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
The traditional manufacturing methods of metal lattice
structure include investment casting, plastic processing
method and combination of extrusion and electro-
discharge machining, etc.
98
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Combination of extrusion and electro-
discharge machining is only used for the
manufacturing of pyramid lattice structure .
99
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Additive manufacturing (AM) can be used to
fabricate lattice structures of any complex form by
depositing the material layer by layer, and it has
become a new method of manufacturing lattice
structure developed in the recent years.
At present, the main methods for additive
manufacturing of lattice structures are Selective
laser melting (SLM) and Selective electron beam
melting (SEBM).
100
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Wire and arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) is an
additive manufacturing technology that uses arc
as a heating source and selects wire as additive
material to manufacture complex components
layer by layer
WAAM is suitable for the fabrication of lattice
structures of any metal, which overcomes the
shortcomings of high requirement for fluidity or
ductility of materials manufactured by traditional
methods and high absorbance of materials
manufactured by SLM.
WAAM is also suitable for the fabrication of lattice
structures of any complex form.
101
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Metallographic structure of the ER2319
aluminum alloy strut
103
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
4-D PRINTING
4D printing is the process through which a
3D printed object transforms itself into another structure
over the influence of external energy input as
temperature, light or other environmental stimuli.
4-dimensional printing (4D printing; also known as 4D
bioprinting, active origami, or shape-morphing systems)
uses the same techniques of 3D printing through
computer-programmed deposition of material in
successive layers to create a three-dimensional object.
105
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
ADVANTAGES OF 4D PRINTING
Size changing
The most obvious advantage of 4D printing is that
through computational folding, objects larger than
printers can be printed as only one part. Since the
4D printed objects can change shape, can shrink
and unfold, objects that are too large to fit a
printer can be compressed for 3D printing into
their secondary form
New materials= new properties
Another advantage of 4D Printing technology is
the usage of possible applied materials. 4D
printing has a vast potential to revolutionize the
world of materials as we know it today
106
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
APPLICATIONS OF 4D PRINTING
Self-repair piping system
Self-assembly furniture
Medical industry
Fashion
107
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
108
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
5D PRINTING
The name of this technology is quite
misleading, since 5D printing does not refers
to the addition of a fifth dimension of
printing.
5D printing refers to 3D printing using a 5-
axis 3D printer, instead of the 3 axis used in
conventional 3D printing. Five-axis additive
manufacturing essentially builds the object
from multiple directions, thus producing
stronger parts than regular 3D printing.
109
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
3D VS 5D PRINTING
110
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
111
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
INTRODUCTION TO HYBRID
MANUFACTURING
ADDITIVE
SUBSTRACTIVE
MANUFACTURING
MANUFACTURING
HYBRID MANUFACTURING
112
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
113
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
HYBRID MANUFACTURING
114
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
HYBRID MANUFACTURING
115
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
DIRECTED ENERGY DEPOSITION
Directed Energy Deposition is defined as “an additive manufacturing process in
which focused thermal energy is used to fuse materials by melting as they are
being deposited”.
Commercial technologies:
Direct Metal Deposition (DMD), Laser Engineering Net Shaping (LENS)
116
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
DIRECTED ENERGY DEPOSITION
It is an advanced additive manufacturing technology used
to repair and rebuild worn or damaged components, to
manufacture new components, and to apply wear- and
corrosion resistant coatings.
DMD produces fully dense, functional metal parts directly
from CAD data by depositing metal powders pixel-by-pixel
using laser melting and a patented closed-loop control
system to maintain dimensional accuracy and material
integrity.
With the feedback system, six-axis deposition, and
multiple material delivery capability it can coat, build,
and rebuild parts having very complex geometries
117
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
ELECTRON BEAM MELTING (EBM)
119
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
DIRECTED ENERGY DEPOSITION
120
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
121
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
122
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
123
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
ELECTRON BEAM MELTING (EBM)
Characteristic Electron beam melting Direcr Metal laser
sintering
Thermal source Electron beam laser
Atmosphere Vacuum Inert gas
Scanning Deflection coils Galvanometer
Energy absorption Conductivity limited Absorptive limited
Powder preheating Use electron beam Use infrared or
resistive heaters
Scan speeds Very fast, magnetically Limited by
driven galvanometer inertia
Energy costs Moderate high
Surface finish Moderate to poor Poor to moderate
Feature resolution Moderate Excellent
Materials Metals(conductors) Polymers, metals &
ceramics
Powder particle size Medium High
124
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Powder Bed Fusion- EBM(ARCAM)
125
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Powder Bed Fusion- EBM(ARCAM)
126
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
BENEFITS OF EBM
High productivity
Suitable for mass products
No residual internal stresses
Less supports are required for parts
Possibility to stack parts on top of each other
No gas contamination
Very fine microstructure
Good mechanical properties
127
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
DRAWBACKS OF EBM
Used for conductive materials only
Powder is sintered so tricky to remove
Long dead time between two production
(some times 8 hours for cooling)
Tricky to work with fine powder
Expensive maintenance cost
128
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
WORKING OF DED
Engineers download and edit the CAD file, adding
machining stock or hard-face surface geometry. The
updated solid CAD model is then sliced and tool paths,
identical to that used for CNC machining, are generated.
Information is downloaded to the overhead three-axis
gantry machine similar to a CNC setup with travel in the
X, Y and Z axes.
The process uses a variety of metal powders and metal
matrix composite materials, including conventional tool
steel alloys and special metals.
Cooling rates are fast, resulting in a very fine-grain
microstructure.
Hard faces are applied within an inert-atmosphere box,
filled with pure argon, that surrounds the work piece and
the machine nozzle.
129
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
DED SUPPORTS A WIDE RANGE OF METALS,
INCLUDING:
Titanium alloys
Stainless steel
Maraging steels
Tool steels
Aluminium alloys
Refractory metals (tantalum, tungsten,
niobium)
Super alloys (Inconel, Hastelloy)
Nickel Copper
Other speciality materials, composites and
functionally graded materials
130
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
BENEFITS OF DED
High printing speed: Typically, DED machines
have high material deposition rates. For
example, some DED processes can achieve a
speed of up to 11 kg of metal per hour.
Ideal for repairing parts:
133
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
APPLICATIONS OF DED
135
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
POWDER BED FUSION
Powder Bed Fusion is defined as “an additive manufacturing process in which
thermal energy selectively fuses regions of a powder bed”.
Commercial technologies: Selective Laser Sintering (SLS), Direct Metal Laser Sintering
(DMLS), Selective Laser Melting (SLM), Electron Beam Melting (EBM)
136
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Laser Material Interaction
137
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Laser Material Interaction
If sufficient energy is absorbed, then the vibration becomes so intense that the
molecular bonding is stretched so far that it is no longer capable of exhibiting
mechanical strength and the material is said to have melted.
On further heating, the bonding is further loosened owing to the strong molecular
vibrations and the material is said to have evaporated.
138
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Powder Fusion Mechanisms
139
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Solid-state sintering
• The driving force for solid-state sintering is the minimization of total free
energy, Es, of the powder particles.
• The mechanism for sintering is primarily diffusion between powder
particles.
141
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Chemically-induced Sintering
• Chemically-induced sintering involves the use of thermally-
activated chemical reactions between two types of powders
or between powders and atmospheric gases to form a by-
product which binds the powders together.
• This fusion mechanism is primarily utilized for ceramic
materials.
• Examples of reactions between powders and atmospheric
gases include:
• Laser processing of SiC in the presence of oxygen, whereby
SiO2 forms and binds together a composite of SiC and SiO2;
• Laser processing of ZrB2 in the presence of oxygen, whereby
ZrO2 forms and binds together a composite of ZrB2 and ZrO2;
and laser processing of Al in the presence of N2, whereby AlN
forms and binds together the Al and AlN particles.
142
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Chemically-induced Sintering
144
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
(a) separate particles,
(b) composite particles,
(c) coated particles, and
(d) Indistinct mixtures.
Dark régions represent the lower-
melting-temperature binder
material. Lighter regions represent
the high melting- temperature
structural material. For indistinct
mixtures, microstructural alloying
eliminates distinct binder and
structural regions
Fig. Liquid Phase Sintering variations used in powder bed fusion processing:
145
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Full Melting
146
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
3D (DMLS) PRINTED GAS
TURBINE BLADE
3D (DMLS) printed gas turbine blade
147
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Powder Bed Fusion
148
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
POWDER BED FUSION BENEFITS AND
DRAWBACKS
The PBF processing of amorphous polymers has been
successful
During part building, loose powder is a sufficient support
material for polymer PBF. This saves significant time during
part building and post-processing, and enables advanced
geometries that are difficult to post-process when supports
are necessary.
As a result, internal cooling channels and other complex
features that would be impossible to machine are possible
in polymer PBF
149
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Low cost – Comparatively low cost. Manufacturing
cost has come down in the recent past due to the
price drop in powder bed fusion machines cost.
No or minimum support – Mostly these do not
need the use of support structures as the powder
acts as an integrated support structure. But to get
more accuracy sometimes the bottom build plate
is used as the support.
Wide material choice – A large range of materials
including ceramics, glass, plastics, metals and
alloys can be used to make 3D objects
Powder recycling – Powder could be recycled in
some cases although to getter better parts some
time there is a need to preheat the powder which
might make the powder stick together
150
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
POWDER BED FUSION BENEFITS AND
DRAWBACKS
Accuracy and surface finish strongly influenced by
operating conditions and powder particle size
Finer particle sizes produce smoother, more
accurate parts but are difficult to spread and
handle.
Larger particle sizes facilitate easier powder
processing and delivery, but hurt surface finish,
minimum feature size and minimum layer
thickness.
With PBF processes, total part construction time
can take longer than other additive
manufacturing processes because of the preheat
and cool-down cycles involved
151
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Relatively slow and long print time – Powder preheating, vacuum generation,
cooling off period all adds to the build time making it one of the slowest in the
additive manufacturing
Post-processing – Printed parts need to be post-processed before usage adding
time and cost
Weak structural properties – Structural properties of these aren’t good compared
to other manufacturing processes due to the layer based manufacturing.
Surface texture – Since the parts are made fusing metal powder together, surface
quality depends on the grain size of the powder and would be very similar to
manufacturing processes like sand casting, die casting etc
Support build plate – Although technically it does not need supports, to avoid any
issues such as warping due to residual stress support may have to be provided.
Also, most of the printers use a build plate to build the parts .. hence needs post
removal and post-processing. This can be reduced by designing with that in mind.
Powder recycling – The powder is expensive but even more expensive is throwing
out residual partially melted or unused powder. To speed up the print process, the
powder is often preheated. This means that some powder is affected by the heat
despite not being in the final part.
Thermal distortion – Another problem, mainly for polymer parts, is thermal
distortion. This can cause shrinking and warping of fabricated parts.
High power usage – Uses a lot of energy to create parts
152
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
APPLICATIONS OF PBF
Medical
Aerospace industries
Manufacturing
Automotive
153
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
APPLICATION OF PBF
From an aerospace perspective, PBF
processes are finding much interest and use
for military and commercial aircraft.
Examples of this include the PBF
manufactured fuel nozzle on General
Electric’s GE9X engine, which is used on
Boeing 777 aircraft.
The GE9X is the largest turbo-fan engine
produced and the additively manufactured
nozzle is five times more durable than
previous versions.
The Boeing 777, with its two GE9X engines,
includes 300 additively manufactured parts
154
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
APPLICATIONS
155
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
156
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
NON BEAM BASED METAL
ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
Friction stir additive manufacturing
Additive Friction stir deposition
Ultrasonic additive Manufacturing
157
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Both friction stir additive manufacturing and
additive friction stir deposition are ‘intensive’
processes that involve severe plastic deformation
at high temperatures.
However, there are significant differences between
them. One is a hybrid (both additive and
subtractive) sheet lamination process involving
welding that results in microstructures
with cyclic variations.
whereas the other is a purely additive process that
deposits a new track with each pass. With each
individual layer undergoing the same type of severe
plastic deformation during deposition and reheating
afterwards, additive friction stir deposition can
lead to a much more homogeneous microstructure.
158
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
A COMPARISON OF DIFFERENT SOLID-STATE
AM PROCESSES
Process Process Friction stir Additive
Ultrasonic additive friction stir
additive manufacturing deposition
manufacturing
ASTM Sheet Sheet lamination NA
Classification lamination ( sheet thickness
( Sheet =1.5 mm)
thickness =0.1
mm)
Hybrid process Yes Yes No
Resolution Subtractive Subtractive Tool geometry
limiting factor process process
Temperature Relatively Low Relatively high Relatively high
Microstructure Similar to pre- Refined, equiaxed Refined,
processed in the stir zone equiaxed
only
159
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
COMPARISON TO OTHER
SOLID-STATE AM PROCESSES
161
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
COMPARISON TO FRICTION STIR
ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
Both friction stir additive manufacturing and
additive friction stir deposition are
‘intensive’ processes that involve severe
plastic deformation at high temperatures.
However, there are significant differences
between them.
One is a hybrid (both additive and
subtractive) sheet lamination process
involving welding that results in
microstructures with cyclic variations where
as the other is a purely additive process that
deposits a new track with each pass
162
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
PATHWAYS TO WIDESPREAD
IMPLEMENTATION OF METAL AM
For wide spread implementation metal AM
needs to possess a series of attributes ,such
as
affordability to customers
convenience and ease of use
energy efficiency
environmental friendliness
wide applicability to engineering materials
compatibility with mature technologies
reliability of part properties
163
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
RESEARCH DIRECTIONS IN AM
New product development (faster, cheaper, better, smarter)
Touch & Feel to Functional Testing
Enabler of Innovation
Bio- applications (Medical, Dental, Pharmaceutical, Biological etc.)
Newer materials development and characterization
Rapid Tooling & Rapid manufacturing
Geometric Modeling, data exchange and software issues
Process improvements (cost, accuracy, finish, size, strength etc.)
Development of newer processes, equipment and controls
Development of newer applications (aerospace, electronics etc.)
Process modeling and simulation issues
Scaling issues (micro- and nano- )
164
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Thank you
165
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
INTEGRATION OF CAM WITH
WAAM
To obtain the desired geometry, the CAM
software have to be able to,
(i) do a slicing during the additive process of
the part with a variable deposit height in
order to take into account variation of the
deposition process and
166
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024
Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) has the possibility to build
metallic
structures in 3D space.
WAAM system is based on welding process to deposit metallic
material and on a robot that moves the welding torch to add material
at a given position.
For large skeleton structures, it was chosen to deposit material point
by point. Welding process induces fluctuations.
To be fully scalable, two main features must be taken into account.
First, monitoring of the process is necessary. Local control on the
geometry of the deposition must be used to reach the nal shape.
167
Prof. Adepu Kumar - Department of Mechanical Engineering, NITW 05/04/2024