Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Slide-09-Price Stability & Inflation
Slide-09-Price Stability & Inflation
Slide-09-Price Stability & Inflation
MODULE – A
Macroeconomic Objectives II:
Low & Stable Rate of Inflation
(Price Stability)
Prof. (Dr.) D N Panigrahi
PhD (Finance), MBA (Fin-FMS, DU), CFA & MS-Finance, CAIIB & DFS, M.Sc. (Physics)
INTRODUCTION
Price stability occurs when prices rise by only a small percentage and
there is an avoidance of fluctuations in the price level. A low and
stable inflation rate can bring a number of advantages.
This is why governments want their countries to experience price
stability. This objective is not always achieved.
Some countries experience a high inflation rate with their price level
rising by a significant percentage. Others experience large fluctuations
in their price level.
For example, their price level may have risen by 25% in one year,
40% in the next year and then 12% in the third year. At certain times,
some countries experience a fall in their price level.
What is Price Stability?
A low and stable inflation rate, of for instance 2%, is not generally
regarded as a problem for an economy. A low and steady rise in prices
may even encourage firms to produce more. Such a rate of inflation is
sometimes known as creeping inflation.
In contrast to a low rate of inflation is hyperinflation. Hyperinflation
is generally considered to be an inflation rate that exceeds 50% a
month, but the rate of inflation can go much higher.
Hyperinflation occurs when inflation gets out of control and
sometimes results in people resorting to barter, exchanging goods and
services for other goods and services rather than using money to buy
and sell products.
Degrees of Inflation
In a group, prepare:
• A wall chart showing your country’s inflation rate and another
two nearby countries’ (say, Pakistan and Bangladesh) inflation
rate over the last five years.
• Another wall chart showing your predictions for your country’s
inflation rate over the next six months.
Each month plot the actual rate against your prediction. (Note: a
number
of international organisations, including the IMF and World
Bank, central banks and media organisations make inflation rate
predictions).
Deflation and Disinflation
Fig. 20.3 shows the inflation rates of Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, the
Philippines and Thailand between 2016 and 2019.
In pairs, using Fig. 20.3, discuss:
1 What happened to the price level in Thailand between 2018 and
2019?
2 Which countries experienced disinflation between 2016 and 2017?
3 Is it possible to determine from the graph whether prices were
higher in the Philippines than in Japan in 2019? Explain your answer.
Then check whether your answers agree with the rest of the group.
Fig. 20.3: Percentage Change in Consumer Price Index
in Selected Countries, 2016–2019
Calculating the Inflation Rate
The inflation rate is the percentage change in the price level from one period to
another. The percentage change can be the change in average prices from one
month to the next month, or from one quarter to the next quarter of the year, or
from one year to the next year.
The two comparisons most used by economists are the annual average
method and the year-on-year method.
• The annual average method compares the average level of prices during a
twelve-month period, for example 2021 with the average level in the previous
twelve months, 2020.
• The year-on-year method is calculated as the percentage change in the price
level for a given month with that of the same month of the previous year. For
instance, if the price level rose from 120 in June 2021 to 126 in June 2022, the
inflation rate would be: (126 – 120)/120 × 100 = 6/120 x 100 = 5%.
ACTIVITY 20.3
Table 20.1 below shows the consumer price index for
Bangladesh from 2012–2018.
Using Table 20.1:
1 Calculate Bangladesh’s inflation rate for each year from
2013 to 2018.
2 In which year was the inflation rate highest?
3 In which year was the price level highest?
Compare your answers with another learner.
Table 20.1: Bangladesh Consumer Price Index, 2012–18
Year CPI
2012 118
2013 127
2014 136
2015 145
2016 153
2017 161
2018 170
Measuring Inflation and Deflation:
The Consumer Price Index
Explain that inflation and deflation are typically measured by
calculating a consumer price index (CPI), which measures the
change in prices of a basket of goods and services consumed by the
average household.
Measures of inflation (and deflation) are obtained by use of price
indices (indices is the plural of index). A price index is a measure of
average prices in one period relative to average prices in a reference
period called a base period. One of the most commonly used price
indices to measure inflation is the consumer price index (CPI).
A country’s price level indicates how much it costs to live in that
country. A rise in the price level means that the cost of living has
increased.
Measuring Inflation and Deflation:
The Consumer Price Index
The consumer price index (CPI) is a measure of the cost of living, or
the cost of goods and services purchased by the typical household in
an economy. It is constructed by a statistical service in each country,
which creates a hypothetical ‘basket’ containing thousands of goods
and services that are consumed by the typical household in the course
of a year.
The value of this basket is calculated for a particular year (called a
base year); this is done by multiplying price times quantity for each
good and service in the basket, and adding up to obtain the total value
of the basket.
The value of the same basket of goods and services is then calculated
for subsequent years.
Measuring Inflation and Deflation:
The Consumer Price Index
The result is a series of numbers that show the value of the same
basket of goods and services for different years.
The CPI is then constructed to show how the value of the basket
changes from year to year by comparing its value with the base year.
Once the consumer price index is constructed, inflation and deflation
can be expressed as a percentage change of the index from one year to
the other, which is simply a measure of the percentage change in the
value of the basket from one year to another.
Since the value of the basket changes from one period to another
because of changes in the prices of the goods in the basket, these
percentage changes reflect changes in the average price level.
Measuring Inflation and Deflation:
The Consumer Price Index
A rising price index indicates inflation; a falling price index indicates
deflation.
CPIs and rates of change in the price level are also calculated on a
monthly basis and a quarterly basis.
Summary: The consumer price index (CPI) is a measure of the cost
of living for the typical household, and compares the value of a basket
of goods and services in one year with the value of the same basket in
a base year.
Inflation (and deflation) are measured as a percentage change in the
value of the basket from one year to another.
A positive percentage change indicates inflation. A negative
percentage change indicates deflation.
Construction of Consumer Price Index (CPI)
In a group, assume that you have been given $200. You have to
spend all of this money. Decide what proportion you would
spend on food, on clothing, on entertainment and on other items
(miscellaneous).
On the basis of your decisions, attach weights to the four
categories.
Then, assuming that the price of food has risen by 10%, the price
of clothing has risen by 20%, the price of entertainment has
fallen by 5% and the price of other items has risen by 2.5%,
calculate the inflation rate you would experience.
Problems with the Consumer Price Index (CPI)
Explain that different income earners may experience a different rate of
inflation when their pattern of consumption is not accurately reflected by the
CPI.
Explain that inflation figures may not accurately reflect changes in
consumption patterns and the quality of the products purchased.
The CPI, we have seen, is based on a fixed basket of goods and services defined
for a particular year, meant to reflect purchases of consumer goods and services
by the typical household. The use of such a basket leads to some problems:
• Different rates of inflation for different income earners. The rate of inflation
calculated by use of the CPI reflects the change in average prices of goods and
services included in the basket. However, different consumers have different
consumption patterns depending on their income levels, and these may differ
from what is included in the basket. This means they face different rates of
inflation than what is calculated on the basis of the CPI basket.
Problems with the Consumer Price Index (CPI)
• Different rates of inflation depending on regional or cultural factors.
Exactly the same idea as above applies to consumer groups whose purchases
differ from the typical household’s consumption patterns, because of variations in
tastes due to cultural and regional factors.
• Changes in consumption patterns due to consumer substitutions when
relative prices change. Each good and service included in the basket is weighted
(multiplied by the number of units of the good or service purchased by the typical
household over a year). However, as some goods and services become cheaper or
more expensive over time, consumers make substitutions, buying more units of
the cheaper goods and less of the more expensive ones. This results in changing
weights (number of units consumed by the typical household), but because the
weights in the basket are fixed, the changes in consumption patterns cannot be
accounted for in the CPI. Therefore, the CPI gives a misleading impression of the
degree of inflation, usually overstating it.
Problems with the Consumer Price Index (CPI)
• Changes in consumption patterns due to increasing use of discount stores
and sales. In many countries, consumers increasingly make use of discount stores
and sales, thus buying some goods and services at lower prices than those used in
CPI calculations. This is another reason why the CPI tends to overstate inflation.
• Changes in consumption patterns due to introduction of new products. In
this case, too, a fixed basket of goods and services cannot account for new
products introduced into the market, as well as older products that become less
popular or are withdrawn (consider for example the replacement of videotapes by
DVDs).
• Changes in product quality. This is another problem related to the use of a
fixed basket of goods and services. The CPI cannot account for quality changes
over time.
Problems with the Consumer Price Index (CPI)
• International comparisons. The CPIs of different countries differ from each
other with respect to the types of goods and services included in the basket, the
weights used and methods of calculation. This limits the comparability of CPIs
and inflation rates from country to country. To address this problem, the European
Union (EU) has devised a Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP). The
HICP determines consistent and compatible rules that must be followed by EU
countries in order to calculate CPIs that are consistent with each other.
• Comparability over time. Virtually all countries around the world periodically
revise their CPI baskets and change the base year (usually about every ten years)
to try to deal with many of the problems noted above. In many countries the
weights of goods and services are changed as often as every year. This means that
whereas price index numbers are comparable over short periods of time, over
longer periods comparability is lessened because of cumulative changes in the
basket of goods and services.
The Core Rate of Inflation
Argentina’s inflation rate reached 47.6% in 2018, its highest rate since
1991, when the inflation rate was 84%.
The value of its currency, the peso, fell by 50% against the dollar and
the country’s output fell by 1%.
In August 2018, the country’s central bank raised the rate of interest to
60%, one of the highest interest rates in the world.
In a group, decide:
1 whether Argentina was more likely to have experienced cost-push or
demand-pull inflation in 2018
2 whether Argentinian consumers would have been likely to have
spent more or less in 2018.
ACTIVITY 20.7
If the price increases to £30 per shirt, you can only buy two shirts.
Your money, or your nominal income of £60 has not changed, yet the
purchasing power of the £60, or what this money can buy, has fallen
due to the increase in price.
‘Real income’ is the same as ‘purchasing power’; it refers to what
your money can buy: it decreases as prices rise, and increases as
prices fall.
Changes in real income, nominal (money) income and the general
price level are related to each other in the following way (roughly):
% change in real income (or purchasing power) = % change in
nominal income − % change in the price level (or the rate of
inflation)
Consequences of Inflation
• Holders of cash. As the price level increases, the real value or purchasing
power of any cash or liquid asset (cash like) held falls.
• Savers. People who save money may become worse off as a result of
inflation. In order to maintain/protect the real value (purchasing power) of
their savings, savers must receive a rate of interest that is at least equal to
the rate of inflation.
Suppose you deposit $1,000 in a bank account that pays you no interest. If
there is inflation, the real value of your savings will fall.
However, you may be able to protect the purchasing power of your savings.
Say the rate of inflation is 5% per year. If you receive interest on your
deposit at the rate of 5% per year, what you will lose through inflation will
be exactly matched by what you gain through interest income. In this case,
the real value (or purchasing power) of your savings remains unaffected.
Consequences of Inflation: Possible Costs
In general, savers who receive a rate of interest on their savings lower than
the rate of inflation suffer a fall in the real value (or purchasing power) of
their savings.
• Lenders (creditors). People (or financial institutions such as banks) who
lend money may be worse off due to inflation. Assume you lend your
friend €100 for one year (and you do not charge interest). If in the course of
the year there is an increase in the price level (inflation), the real value of
the €100 you will get back from your friend at the end of the year will have
fallen.
If you charged your friend a rate of interest equal to the rate of inflation,
then the real value of your loan to your friend will be exactly maintained.
In general, lending at a lower interest rate than the rate of inflation makes
the lender (creditor) worse off at the end of the loan period.
Potential Benefits of Inflation
Menu costs: Menu costs are costs incurred by firms when they have to
print new menus (in restaurants), catalogues, advertisements, price labels,
etc., due to changes in prices. The higher the rate of inflation, the more
often firms have to change their prices and therefore, the higher the menu
costs.
Money illusion: Money illusion refers to the idea that some people feel
better off when their nominal income increases, even though the price level
may increase at the same rate and possibly even faster. When this occurs,
people are under the illusion that they are better off whereas in fact they are
not: their real income or purchasing power has not changed at all, and may
even have decreased. If money illusion is widespread, it has negative
consequences because it leads consumers to make wrong spending
decisions.
Consequences of Inflation: Possible Costs
• Whether the inflation rate is the one that has been expected. Unanticipated
inflation, which occurs when the inflation rate was different from that expected,
can also create uncertainty and so can discourage some consumer expenditure and
investment. In contrast, if households, firms and the government have correctly
anticipated inflation, they can take measures to adapt to it and so avoid some of
its potentially harmful effects. For instance, firms may have adjusted their prices,
money interest rates may have been changed to maintain real interest rates and
the government may have adjusted tax brackets, raised pensions and public sector
wages in line with inflation.
• How the inflation rate compares with the rate of other countries. It is
possible for a country to have a relatively high rate of inflation, but if it is below
that of competing countries its products may become more internationally
competitive.
What is an Appropriate Rate of Inflation?
Most governments prefer a low and stable rate of inflation, not a zero
rate of inflation.
Why is a zero rate of inflation, meaning a constant price level, not
the preferred objective?
The reason is that a zero rate of inflation comes dangerously close to
deflation, which as we will see below can cause serious problems for
an economy.
There is no one particular rate of inflation that is ideal, but many
governments would like to see this in the range of about 2–3% per
year. Less than 2% might be considered as coming close to deflation;
more than 4% is seen as being too high.
Test Your Understanding 10.4
Why deflation occurs rarely in the real world: Deflation is not a common
phenomenon. Whereas it is often the case that the price of a particular good or
service may fall over time, it is rare to see the general price level of an economy
falling. There are several factors that account for this:
• Wages of workers do not ordinarily fall. This means it is difficult for firms to
lower the prices of their products, as this would cut into their profits, especially
since wages represent a large proportion of firms’ costs of production. There are
several reasons why wages do not fall easily (labour contracts, minimum wage
legislation, worker and union resistance to wage cuts, ideas of fairness, fears of
negative impacts on workers’ morale, etc.).
• Large oligopolistic firms may fear price wars. If one firm lowers its price,
then others may lower theirs more aggressively in an effort to capture market
shares, and then all the firms will be worse off. Therefore, firms avoid cutting
their prices.
Consequences and Causes of Deflation
• Firms want to avoid incurring menu costs resulting from price changes,
particularly if they believe that the lower prices will prevail only for short periods
of time. Therefore, they avoid lowering their prices.
Whereas deflation occurs rarely, it has appeared periodically, for example in
Britain and the United States in the late 19th century, in the United States during
the depression of the 1930s (1933–7), and in Japan from 1999 to 2006. In 2003
and again in 2008, there were serious concerns in Europe and the United States
that deflation might occur.
Deflation is generally feared more than inflation, because it may pose potentially
serious problems for an economy.
The negative consequences of deflation are discussed below.
Consequences of Deflation
Menu costs: Menu costs (the costs to firms of printing new menus,
catalogues, advertisements, price labels, etc.) are similar in the case of
deflation as in the case of inflation, as both simply involve changes in
prices.
Risk of a deflationary spiral with high and increasing cyclical
unemployment: A deflationary spiral involves a process where deflation
sets into motion a series of events that worsen the deflation.
Deflation discourages spending by consumers, because they postpone
making purchases as they expect that prices will continue to fall.
Deflation also discourages borrowing by both consumers and firms, for the
reason noted above: the real value of debt increases as the price level falls.
The result is that consumer and business spending falls, causing aggregate
demand to fall.
Consequences of Deflation
If the economy is already in recession, this will become deeper with falling
AD, unemployment increases further, incomes and prices fall further,
deflationary pressures increase further, spending and borrowing decrease
further, and so on in a downward spiral.
Risk of bankruptcies and a financial crisis: As we saw above, deflation
results in an increase in the real value of debt. If the economy is in
recession, and incomes are falling while the real value of debt is increasing,
the result will most likely be bankruptcies of firms and consumers who are
unable to pay back their debts. If such bankruptcies become widespread,
banks and financial institutions will be affected, and a large risk of a major
financial crisis arises.
The last two items, risks of a deflationary spiral and a financial crisis,
reveal the special and potentially serious dangers of deflation.
Causes of Deflation: Bad and Good Deflation
Mexico’s central bank aims for an inflation rate of 3%. Towards the
end of the second decade of the 21st century, Mexico’s inflation rate
fell. This was largely because of a slowdown in the rise of the price of
food and energy.
However, it was expected that the inflation rate might be higher in
2020 because of the increase in the national minimum wage in 2019
and the expected fall in the exchange rate.
Over the period shown, Chile’s central bank also had a 3% inflation
rate target while Brazil’s central bank target was 4.25%.
Table 20.4 shows the inflation rates in Chile, Brazil and Mexico
between 2013 and 2019.
Table 20.4: Inflation rates (% Change in CPI)
in Chile, Brazil and Mexico, 2013–19
Year Brazil Chile Mexico
2013 6.2 1.8 3.8
2014 6.3 4.7 4.0
2015 9.0 4.4 2.7
2016 8.7 3.8 2.8
2017 3.5 2.2 6.0
2018 3.7 2.3 4.9
2019 3.6 2.3 3.8
ACTIVITY 20.10
1 Explain why a slowdown in the rise of the price of food and energy
may reduce a country’s inflation rate.
2 Explain why the change in Mexico’s foreign exchange rate may
have caused inflation in 2019.
3 Using Table 20.4, explain why investment may have been higher in
Chile between 2017 and 2019 than in Brazil and in Mexico.
4 Using Table 20.4, compare how successful the countries’ central
banks were in meeting their inflation targets.
5 Ask another learner to assess your answers while you assess your
partner’s answers. Did you both make similar points? Did your
partner make additional points? Did you learn from each other?
Test Your Understanding 10.6