Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lfar Presentation BK Audit On 22nd March 24 (1) - S Chatterjee - 1711180576
Lfar Presentation BK Audit On 22nd March 24 (1) - S Chatterjee - 1711180576
MARCH, 2024
Represent by
CA. Sunirmal Chatterjee
(BSC. FCA)
S. Jaykishan
Partner
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
I Assets Particulars
1. Cash
(a) Does the system ensure that cash • Check Banks Policy for joint custody of cash
maintained is in effective joint chest and ATM.
custody of two or more officials,
as per the instructions of the • Verify the operations during your presence
controlling authorities of the whether joint custody is effective.
bank?
• Verify whether the cash vaults are opened /
closed / operated jointly by two officials and
comment (Comment on Key Register, if any)
LFAR (REVISED FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested
reply)
(b) Have the cash balances at the • Check Insurance Policy for Cash (including
branch/ATMs been checked at cash in hand, cash in ATM, cash in transit).
periodic intervals as per the Verify whether the limits fixed are
procedure prescribed by the adequately covered by the Policy.
controlling authorities of the
bank? • Check the date of the Policy for validity
during the FY. If the policy not available,
ask the branch to provide from H.O.
(c) Does the branch generally • Obtain Cash Retention Limit of the Branch.
maintain / carry cash
balances, which vary • Verify the Cash Ledger throughout the
significantly from the limits year and comment on the status of cash
fixed by the controlling retained by the branch.
authorities
of the bank? • Verify whether the instances of excess
cash balances are being reported to the
Controlling Office from time to time from
correspondence.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
2. Balances with Reserve Bank of India, State Bank of India, and other
banks (For branches with Treasury Operations)
(iv) Where the branch maintains an Not applicable to branches other than
account with RBI, the following Currency Chest Branches.
additional matter may be reported:
Entries originated prior to but
communicated/ recorded after the
year end in relation to currency
chest operations at the branch/other
link branches, involving deposits
into/withdrawals from the currency
chest attached to such branches
(Give details)
3. Money at Call and Short Notice
(a) Has the branch kept money-at-call and The Branch has not kept money-at-call and
short notice during the year? short notice during the year
(b) Has the year-end balance been
duly confirmed and reconciled?
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
For all accounts above the threshold, Comments of the branch auditor on
the transaction audit/account specific advances with significant adverse features.
details to be seen and commented on, A new word "Transaction Audit " has been
whereas below the threshold, the inserted, which in my opinion includes
process needs to be checked and checking of interest, valuation of
commented upon. Comments of the securities, Account specific details etc and
branch auditor on advances with branch has to furnish the details, which we
significant adverse features, which have to check.
might need the attention of the
management / Statutory Central
Auditors, should be appended to the
LFAR.
The critical comments based on the
review of the above and other test
check should be given in respective
paragraphs as given in LFAR given
below.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
Account No. Account Balance as at year end Balance as at year end 31 Total
Name 31st March 2024 st March 2024– Non-
Funded funded
(a) Total A B C=A+
(b) Total X Y Z=X+Y
Outstanding of
the branch
( c ) Percentage A as % of X B as % of Y C as % of
examined Z
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(i) In your opinion, has the branch To call for the fresh loan sanctioned and
generally complied with the renewed during the year. On receipt of the
procedures/instructions of the required details, examine whether.
controlling authorities of the bank
regarding loan applications, • The loan applications have been
preparation of proposals for grant/ obtained in the format designed by the
renewal of advances, enhancement of bank.
limits, etc., including adequate
appraisal documentation in respect • Whether in respect sanction of fresh
thereof. What, in your opinion, are loan or renewal of the account,
the major shortcomings in credit enhancement of the limit etc,
appraisal, etc. instruction of the controlling office has
been complied with.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(iii) Whether in the borrower accounts, To call for the circulars received from H.O
the applicable interest rate is for revision in the rate of interest and to
correctly fed into the system? check on sample basis from the system
whether revised interest has been applied.
The adverse cases to tabulate in Annexure.
(iv) Whether the interest rate is reviewed Obtain the guidelines and ensure whether
periodically as per the guidelines applicable to floating rate loans linked to
applicable to floating rate loans MCLR / EBLR
linked to MCLR / EBLR (External
Benchmark Rates) Lending Rate)?
(v) Have you come across cases of Ask from the branch the cases of frequent
frequent renewal / rollover of short- renewal / rollover of short-term loans.
term loans? If yes, give the details of
such accounts.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(vi) Whether correct and valid credit For the assessment of working capital limit of
rating, if available, of the credit borrowers, find out the policy of the bank where
facilities of bank’s borrowers from RBI credit rating is required before sanction of the
accredited Credit Rating Agencies has limit. In cases of renewal of working capital limit
been fed into the system? of the borrower, beside checking of validity of the
credit rating agency, also to call for downgrading
of credit rating from earlier assessment. In some
banks, for AAA+ category of credit rating of
borrowers, Stock Audit is exempted.
(c) Sanctioning / Disbursement
(i) In the cases examined by you, have Check of sample on the basis the following:
you come across instances of credit • Check whether delegation of power has
facilities having been sanctioned been exercised as per manual of
beyond the delegated instruction while sanctioning the credit
authority or limit fixed for the facilities.
branch. Are such cases promptly • Check the acceptance of Terms of Sanction
reported to higher authorities? by borrowers. It is very important to
obtain acknowledgement of the borrowers.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
( ii) Whether advances have been • Check the new cases of advances
disbursed without complying with the sanctioned/ renewals and find out
terms and conditions of the sanction? whether terms and conditions are
If so, give. fulfilled before disbursement, whether
details of such cases. appropriate documentations such as EM
of properties, pollution control
certificate, obtaining of guarantee etc
before sanction/ renewal of the limits. .
Report instances.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
( iii) Did the bank provide loans to Before commencement of Audit at the
companies for buy-back of branch, called for the information.
shares/securities?
D)
Documentation
In the cases examined by you, have
you come across instances of:
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(i) Is the procedure laid down by the • Check whether the branch has followed
controlling authorities of the bank, for operating instructions for monitoring of
periodic review of advances, including advances issued by H.O
periodic balance confirmation/ • Check adverse remarks of auditors /
acknowledgement of debts, followed inspectors are rectified /complied
by the branch? Provide analysis of the before renewal. The latest Financial
accounts overdue for review/renewal. Statements, Stock Statements,
What, in your opinion, are major Insurance Policies etc are available in
shortcomings in monitoring, etc. the file.
• Balance Confirmation /
a) between 3 to 6 months, and Acknowledgement of Debt is not time
b) over 6 months barred.
• Check prints from CBS regarding
noncompliance and verify.
• Date/Month on which the review was
done may be obtained.(If renewal is due
over 180 days, the A/C to be classified
as NPA.)
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(ii) • Are the stock/book debt Dates of submission of various periodic
statements and other periodic data like monthly stock statement,
operational data and financial Quarterly information system etc are
statements, etc., received mentioned in the Sanctioned letters.
regularly from the borrowers Stipulation of penalty for delay in
and duly scrutinized? Is suitable submission is also mentioned in the
action taken based on such sanctioned letter. Check for delay in
scrutiny in appropriate cases? submission of periodic data, whether
• Is the DP properly computed? system is automatically imposed penalty or
• Whether the latest manually fed in the system.
audited financial statements are For D.P calculation, check whether sundry
obtained for accounts credit balance, Debtors over 90 days etc,
reviewed / renewed during the as per terms of sanction, have been
year? considered.
( iii) • Whether there exists a system of Stock Audit is applicable for the borrowers
obtaining reports on stock audits availing working capital facilities Rs 5 crore
periodically? and above. Also, for Loan above Rs 250 Crore,
• If so, whether the branch has ASM is appointed. To collect the required
complied with such system? information from the branch and review
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
• Details of: Call for the list of the borrowers where stock audit
• cases where stock audit conducted in writing and find out whether all the reports
was required but was not conducted received by the branch. If not , report the cases in LFAR.
• where stock audit was conducted Also report the cases no action was taken for the
but no action was taken on adverse features adverse features reported in report and effect on the
accounts of the borrower.
( iv) Indicate the cases of advances to non- Call for the cases of loan to non- corporate entities with
corporate entities with limits beyond that is limits beyond that is set by the bank and whether
set by the bank where the branch has not branch has obtained audited financials of those non-
obtained the duly audited accounts of corporate borrowers. If not to report.
borrowers.
(In case, the branch is not the lead If the branch is not lead bank, then obtain
bank, copy of certificate/report the certificate from the branch.
should be obtained from lead bank
for review and record)
( vi Has the inspection or physical Call for the “Unit Visit Records”, which
) verification of securities charged to detailed the units visited by the branch
the bank been carried out by the officials.
branch as per the procedure laid down
by the controlling authorities of the
bank?
Whether there is a substantial Such cases to be reported .
deterioration in value of security
during financial year as per latest
valuation report in comparison with
earlier valuation report on record?
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(vii) In respect of advances examined by you, As per Para 4.2.9(a) of Master Circular issued by RBI,
have you come across cases of deficiencies, erosion in the value of security can be reckoned as
including in value of securities and significant when the realizable value of the security is
inspection thereof or any other adverse less than 50 per cent of the value assessed by the bank
features such as frequent/ unauthorized or accepted by RBI at the time of last inspection. Such
overdrawing beyond limits, inadequate NPAs may be straightaway classified under doubtful
insurance coverage, etc.? category.
(viii) Whether the branch has any red-flagged Collect the information about the Red Flagged account
account? If yes, whether any deviations in the branch, if any in writing and if so, check whether
were observed related to compliance of the red flag has been removed by the bank.
bank's policy related with Red Flag
Accounts?
(iii) • Whether the branch has reported Obtain in writing from the branch, the cases
accounts restructured or rephased restructured during the year. Ensure that the
during the year to Controlling branch has complied with resolution of
Authority of the bank? stressed assets as per RBI Circular on
• Whether the RBI Guidelines for Prudential Framework for Resolution of
restructuring on all such cases have Stressed Assets dated June 7, 2019
been followed.
• Whether the branch complies with the
regulatory stance for resolution of
stressed assets, including the
compliance with board approved
policies in this regard,
tracking/reporting of defaults for
resolution purposes. among others?
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(iii) • Whether the upgradation in non- Obtain the list of NPA Accounts upgraded
performing advances is in line with during the year
the norms of Reserve Bank of India • Compare the list of NPA accounts as at the
• Where the auditor disagrees with end of Previous Year and as at the end of
upgradation of accounts? If yes, Current Year Movement analysis &
give reasons thereof. completeness check
(iv) Have you come across cases where Obtain the list of such cases from the branch
the relevant Controlling Authority of in writing and give comment on study of
the bank has authorized legal action those cases.
for recovery of advances or recalling
of advances, but no such action was
taken by the branch? If so, give
details of such cases.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(v) Whether there are any accounts To obtain the list of accounts herein process
wherein the process under IBC is under IBC is mandated but not initiated by
mandated but not initiated by the the branch. In this connection, please go
branch? through the RBI Circular on Prudential
Whether there are any borrowers at Framework for Resolution of Stressed
the branch against whom the process Assets dated 7 th June, 2019.
of IBC is initiated by any of the
(vi) • Have appropriate claims for credit Check whether there are any claims pending
guarantee (ECGC and others), if any, with ECGC & others, any claims sent during
been duly lodged and settled? the year, or any payments received during
• Give details of claims rejected? (As the year. After verification of statements
prepared by the branch comment
per the given table)
accordingly.
• Whether the claim rejection is
appropriately considered while
determining the provisioning
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
Total A
Amounts representing
(i) Claims accepted/
settled
(ii) Claims rejected
Total B
Balance as at year end
(A-B)
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(vii) In respect of non-performing assets, If the valuation is more than 3 years old in
has the branch obtained valuation NPA A/C , then for the purpose of
reports from approved valuers for provision, the value should be considered
the immovables charged to the bank, as “Zero”. Consequently, due to that if the
once in three years, unless the security value is coming down below 10%
circumstances of the outstanding balance, then A/C
warrant a shorter duration? should be classified as Loss.
(viii In the cases examined by you, has the For the Prudential write off (PWO)or write
) branch complied with the Recovery off, call for the approval of the competent
Policy prescribed by the controlling authority. Of the Bank.
authorities of the bank with respect to
compromise/ settlement and write-off
cases? Details of the cases of
compromise/settlement and write-off
cases involving write-offs/waivers in
excess of Rs. 50.00 lakhs may be given.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(ix) Is the branch prompt in ensuring Obtain the details from the branch and age-
execution of decrees obtained for wise analysis of decrees obtained and
recovery from the defaulting pending execution.
borrowers? Give Age-wise analysis of
decrees obtained and pending
execution.
(x) Whether in the cases concluded the For appropriation of recoveries first against
recoveries have been properly principal or interest, we have to refer to the
appropriated against the principal / accounting policies of the bank. In absence
interest as per the policy of the bank? of any policy, obtain in writing the policy
followed by bank in this regard.
(xi) In cases where documents are held at In several banks, documents relating to loan
centralized processing centers / office, sanctioned are held centrally at Central
whether the auditor has received the Processing Centre (CPC). The branch auditors
relevant documents as asked by them should either call for the relevant documents
on test check basis and satisfied or visit CPC for examination of those
themselves. documents and issue comment, if any.
Report the exceptions if any
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(xii) List the major deficiencies in credit
review, monitoring and supervision.
(g) Non-Fund Based facilities
(i) List of borrowers with details of LCs
Invocation Party Beneficiary Amt/Rs Recovery
devolved or guarantees invoked during Date Name Name Date
the year.
6. Other Assets
(a) Suspense Accounts/Sundry Assets
(i) Does the system of the bank ensure Ask the branch in writing for providing the
expeditious clearance of items debited to age wise details of Suspense A/C. Audit trail
Suspense Account? Details of outstanding may be called for.
entries in excess of 90 days may be
obtained from the branch and the reasons
for delay in adjusting the entries may be
ascertained. Does your scrutiny of the
accounts under various sub-heads reveal
balances, which in your opinion are not
recoverable and would require a provision/
write-off? If so, give details.
(ii) Does your test check indicate any unusual
items in these accounts? If so, report their
nature and the amounts involved. Are there
any intangible items under this head e.g.
losses not provided / pending investigation?
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
II. LIABILITIES
(1) Deposits
(a) Does the bank have a system of In writing the branch should be asked to furnish
identification of dormant/ inoperative the list of dormant inoperative account with the
accounts and internal controls with regard date since the account is inoperative. Also the
to operations in such accounts? In the cases branch should provide the guidelines, if any, for
examined by you, have you come across the inoperative accounts.
instances where the guidelines laid down
in this regard have not been followed? If
yes, give details thereof.
(b) After the balance sheet date and till the Ask the branch in writing for proving GLB (General
date of audit, whether there have been any Ledger Balance) for the 1st week of April’24
unusual large movements (whether increase
or decrease) in the aggregate deposits held
at the year-end? If so, obtain the
clarifications from the branch and give your
comments thereon.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(a) Has the test checking of May refer the concurrent audit report for
interest/discount/ commission/ fees “Revenue leakages” detected by them and
etc. revealed excess/ short credit of ensure whether corrective action has been
taken. If not give MOC.
a material amount? If so, give details
thereof.
(b) Has the branch complied with the
Income Recognition norms prescribed
by R.B.I.? (The Auditor may refer to the
instructions of the controlling
authorities of the bank regarding
charging of interest on non-performing
assets).
(c) Has the test check of interest on
deposits revealed any
excess/short debit of material
amount? If so, give details thereof.
LFAR FOR BRANCH AUDIT (Questionnaire with suggested reply)
(e) Are there any divergent trends in major Please mention any important matter on
items of income and expenditure, in which you like to draw attention of the
comparison with corresponding Statutory Central Auditors.
previous year, which are not Please don’t mention on any aspect , MOC
satisfactorily explained by the branch. should be passed but as branch auditor, not
If so, the same may be reported. given relevant MOC.